What if the Hobbits Never Came to the Shire?
13:49
Пікірлер
@deepmines
@deepmines 22 сағат бұрын
a day in the life of mordor
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 20 сағат бұрын
@deepmines i'm cooking something along the lines 😉
@deepmines
@deepmines Күн бұрын
what if the two tree did not dye
@deepmines
@deepmines Күн бұрын
and what if morgoth won from the valar
@deepmines
@deepmines Күн бұрын
what if isengard did not lose
@weldonwilson
@weldonwilson 2 күн бұрын
Without the Hobbits, Galadriel would never have been tested by Frodo offering her the ring and might not have been allowed to go West over the seas. The Ents would not have been roused and destroyed the Isengard orcs and Saruman's power base at Orthanc, resulting in the destruction of Rohan. Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli would not have had a reason to go to the edge of Fangorn where they met Gandalf. They would probably have gone straight to Gondor with Boromir and not taken the Paths of the Dead so the Corsairs would have destroyed much of Gondor's coastal population. Would Gandalf have even gone to Rohan and freed King Theoden from the control of Saruman?
@deepmines
@deepmines 2 күн бұрын
can you do a video what if the hobbits never came to the shire
@deepmines
@deepmines 2 күн бұрын
ty for a great video
@stephensmith4025
@stephensmith4025 3 күн бұрын
“Come back to the forest Wizaddy… Celebrimbor is gone for the week!”
@fitnessteacher1845
@fitnessteacher1845 2 күн бұрын
Celeborn
@kathryncainmadsen5850
@kathryncainmadsen5850 2 күн бұрын
We shouldn’t forget he’s a Maia and can shapeshift… Fun.
@propellerhead428
@propellerhead428 3 күн бұрын
The Dragon is flying backwards?
@SteveDave211
@SteveDave211 3 күн бұрын
No like Disney with Star Wars LOTR was messed up with those crappy Hobbits movies like Universal with Fantastic beast so yes they should stop yet don't act like it was perfect before.
@jeremiahr7585
@jeremiahr7585 4 күн бұрын
Good video. The producers of Rings of Power disrespected Tolkien and thought they could do better than him by severely changing characters, events, and ideas.
@jeffmarshalek8859
@jeffmarshalek8859 4 күн бұрын
Have to wonder how much Amazon pays these people for the promotion or if they are simply delusional.
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 3 күн бұрын
@jeffmarshalek8859 I've actually done 2 videos which discusses both sides of the argument.
@SubjectDelta20
@SubjectDelta20 4 күн бұрын
Nice video! 👍 There's no such thing as too many LoTR lore videos
@MrAgustos
@MrAgustos 5 күн бұрын
meh some people should keep their whining about this to themselves. Writers and actors do their best to continue some of the storyline as Tolken is not with us anymore. If you dont like it dont act like yiur opinion needs to be heard as does not. I was happy to watch some new art even adjacent tobthe Canon. I enjoyed the Rings of power myself and comend the writers and actors for trying. The vitrol put out ia horrible and not needed. If you dont like it dont watch it. Go whine elsewhere in private.
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 5 күн бұрын
@@MrAgustos I've played devils advocate for both sides on this channel
@Mengcharsway
@Mengcharsway 4 күн бұрын
Nah, this series deserves to be lambasted; it's awful. Open up your brain and consume the regurgitated corporate sludge-at least they tried.
@mgh7634
@mgh7634 5 күн бұрын
"There is still hope for Amazon" Whatever you say consoomer. If you believe that cope I've got some hot crypto to sell you.
@brooksdemontluzin4598
@brooksdemontluzin4598 5 күн бұрын
Imagine a video game like this, you play as one of the regular soldiers and just get to experience every siege or battle. And it’s setup like a nightmare experience. You have to find a way to survive.
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 5 күн бұрын
@brooksdemontluzin4598 it's all fun and games until the army of the dead show up, or you hear the horns of the mûmakul
@victoriakidd-cromis1124
@victoriakidd-cromis1124 5 күн бұрын
Why is she handing him such a huge section of hair? It is much more than three strands.
@humanusarmainvictus6752
@humanusarmainvictus6752 4 күн бұрын
Probably AI made clip
@TadashiKitsune
@TadashiKitsune 6 күн бұрын
a
@RambleT26
@RambleT26 7 күн бұрын
Really? Still doing the RoP bashing thing? You guys can’t just focus on your own content? Ffs. I really like these videos but unsubscribing, find a new pedestal.
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 7 күн бұрын
@@RambleT26 It was a video from a common viewpoint. I can also make another one for why Amazon should continue ROP..
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 7 күн бұрын
@RambleT26 Personally, I loved S2, however all I'm doing in this video is stating some truths which might oppose Tolkien's works. Hope i can win your sub back by making a video which supports the argument for why they should keep going!
@jeremiahr7585
@jeremiahr7585 4 күн бұрын
You can’t appease everyone. I commend you on this video
@etpc2023
@etpc2023 7 күн бұрын
‘It is said that the skill of the Dwarves is in their hands rather than in their tongues,’ she said; ‘yet that is not true of Gimli. For none have ever made to me a request so bold and yet so courteous” the greatness of Gimli further demonstrated. Out of characters from the book done dirty by the movies he was the second worst. Denathor got smeared much worse
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 8 күн бұрын
THIS IS THE SECOND LAST PART!
@DaahkGaming
@DaahkGaming 8 күн бұрын
...I love this. Thank you.
@papabird4425
@papabird4425 8 күн бұрын
I heard the gift was GTA6
@robertcurtis-c1h
@robertcurtis-c1h 9 күн бұрын
sorry if you have read Tolkin then you would know Tulkas and any Valar would not intervene because the war of the ring was a middle earth made and had never been near the land of the Valar,the Valar went to war in the first age of middle earth to bring Morgth back to valair and to retreive the Silmarillion that Feanor made from the first light
@jurgenolivieira1878
@jurgenolivieira1878 9 күн бұрын
Excellent watch, thank you!
@jurgenolivieira1878
@jurgenolivieira1878 9 күн бұрын
One important thing maybe... is that the Hobbits actually failed tom destroy the ring. Frodo could not do it, but was by shear accident that it was destroyed with Gollum holding it. Perhaps that was always the only way (as it perhaps was always Gollum role to do so). The fellowship did ensure the ring was inside the mountain, the only place where it could be "unmade".
@jurgenolivieira1878
@jurgenolivieira1878 9 күн бұрын
I like the idea of Tulkas getting the ring... that is a very interesting concept!
@jurgenolivieira1878
@jurgenolivieira1878 9 күн бұрын
Lol, Tulkas destroyed a continent when he fought against Melkor... he latterly changed the face of Arda. I don't think Sauron would be any match for him at the state he was in even with the ring. It's like throwing an Ant Eater in an ant farm. He would be danger for weak beings like humans or Hobbits for accidental harm. By his presence alone.
@Jakblade
@Jakblade 9 күн бұрын
🙏
@inadisguise9824
@inadisguise9824 9 күн бұрын
After death their souls are able to transend to a place where they can be with Eru Ilvatar. Thats the gift, were elves are imortality tied to earth and will never be with him.
@DeathBySparkles
@DeathBySparkles 9 күн бұрын
Submission is required for love.
@YanquoiZaza
@YanquoiZaza 9 күн бұрын
Someone finally called out that piece of garbage place. The valar aren’t cool
@CognitiveDissonance2.0
@CognitiveDissonance2.0 9 күн бұрын
The Pelennor Fields would be known as the Pelennor Forest ever after.
@YanquoiZaza
@YanquoiZaza 9 күн бұрын
I love this video
@roymarkwell4210
@roymarkwell4210 10 күн бұрын
Hails Morgoth and Sauron Dark Lords You are Rulers Darkness v Light Elves Dwarves Men bad ok
@inadisguise9824
@inadisguise9824 10 күн бұрын
If they had joined, by the lore, Eru Iluvatar would most likely have stepped in right away. Most likely would have destroyed the universe, wiping the slate clean and maybe, hopefully started creation all over again. Which makes for a very bad story. We would be robbed of the masterpiece which is J.R.R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings and all of the rest of the lore of Middleearth.
@teslabulls1238
@teslabulls1238 10 күн бұрын
Arwen is way more powerful than Eowyn. Not even close.
@meyshiaangela9968
@meyshiaangela9968 9 күн бұрын
Physical strength, yes Eowyn will not stand with Arwen. But inner strength, comparable.
@teslabulls1238
@teslabulls1238 9 күн бұрын
@@meyshiaangela9968 I would argue that any child of Elrond would have a great amount of inner strength.
@pr1ncecharming306
@pr1ncecharming306 10 күн бұрын
I suspect this Chanel is AI
@UndisputedLoon
@UndisputedLoon 10 күн бұрын
@@pr1ncecharming306 even if that’s the case, I’m grateful for Boromir content
@Jakblade
@Jakblade 10 күн бұрын
Really loving this channel so far! Have a feeling I’m gonna really like this channel when it’s time to unwind from my day. Thanks for sharing! I love the art and music. And from what I’ve seen so far, your perspective is very refreshing.🙏
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 10 күн бұрын
@Jakblade Thank you kindly! I personally find it so relaxing to listen to lore content after a long day or before bed whilst learning some insightful facts about the legendarium. So glad I can deliver that 🙌🏽
@Jakblade
@Jakblade 10 күн бұрын
Who doesn’t love Glorfindel?! 😌
@UndisputedLoon
@UndisputedLoon 10 күн бұрын
If Boromir had survived, it would’ve been the happiest possible ending for LotR. Would’ve loved to see him give Denethor a thorough chewing out after returning to Gondor with Aragorn, for everyone and especially Faramir’s sake. It’s a shame how Faramir had to endure such tragedy since he loved both of them despite Denethor’s coldness. Boromir also has the single greatest redeeming act in the history of redeeming acts. It’s a necessary development and ending for his kind of character, and Tolkien knew this. I would say even the greatest heroes of his story only get a bittersweet ending at best. Righteous and bittersweet. Those who weren’t taken by the battles surely took some of those battles home they’ll likely never escape one way or another, such as Frodo and his departure to the undying lands. Boromir surviving would’ve made LotR too fairy tale, as much as I love his character. Boromir’s sacrifice shows the grit and rawness of Middle Earth. He’s such a real, dynamic character. It’s hard to say I’d want it any other way than Tolkien’s way
@SickMindeBarBie
@SickMindeBarBie 10 күн бұрын
the storyline and arc in a theater adaptation could be great
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 10 күн бұрын
@SickMindeBarBie not sure if the Amazon team could nail it, it'd need to be super dark in my opinion
@SickMindeBarBie
@SickMindeBarBie 10 күн бұрын
@@EnchantedBasement Fuck no rings of power was garbage. However the trilogy is a very hard act to follow. Fall of gondolin + Beren&Luthien have a lot of potential for cinematic adaptation. The battle of gondolin (and beauty of gondolin) would be very hard to depict in a way that would do it justice imo.
@YanquoiZaza
@YanquoiZaza 10 күн бұрын
Can we just say the valar kind of suck
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 10 күн бұрын
@@YanquoiZaza Anyone in particular or or just based on negligence to intervene?
@YanquoiZaza
@YanquoiZaza 10 күн бұрын
@ everyone of them except ulmo and aule. I would take the rest powers and make them be regulars bro
@tooslow4065
@tooslow4065 9 күн бұрын
@@EnchantedBasement sauron was a problem for the valar. they didnt act, like they should have.
@kathryncainmadsen5850
@kathryncainmadsen5850 11 күн бұрын
Cirdan?
@EnchantedBasement
@EnchantedBasement 11 күн бұрын
@@kathryncainmadsen5850 Yes! Cirdan was absolutely an advisor in the white council 🙂 I could only imagine the wisdom displayed that wasn't captured in the films