Jinnah was perhaps justifiably proud in having achieved Pakistan without bloodshed. However, one must ask, did this have more to do with the force of his argument and not the broad-mindedness or even indifference of his opponents?

Good lord... Threw in the towel at 9 minutes. Not my kinda thing, I guess...

Robinson Margaret Garcia Elizabeth Perez Robert

Hernandez Anna Allen Ronald Wilson Gary

Oh yes, the same dean who is being investigated for Anti-semitic vile comments and got caught so apologised half heartedly to keep his job! Religion surely stinks when led by people like him! Sure kids, you will definitely learn religion from the bigot! What is wrong with parents sending their children to learn from racists?

THIS IS true thought. We cannot create change without serious reflection and study, without including a wide-angle vision of human and historico-social processes. Without teachers and thinkers such as this man, left vs right has degenerated into an incoherent free-for-all of people just beating up on each other. Which is what the control system truly knows how to do.

Leftist audio strikes again!

😂😂 and Narmada brought a revolution and literally lifted Gujarat out of poverty and now BJP never lost power always elected from 2003 to till date and so is Madhya Pradesh from 2003 even today they won reelection again😂😂….So called this intellectual actually tried to destroy India (using tribal population) and make it remain poor but at last india won this communist war and capitalism won

I´m Gilberto, from São Paulo, Brazil

these are the two most boring leftists on stage together.😂

Wow, such important work that is crushed out in the closing comments. That someone's pension - to uphold a money based economy, itself devoid of relation to the land except the murderous extraction being discussed, cannot be brought into question! Yikes, this is academia at its worst - talking radicalism and abolition without sacrifice and hard work. Our generation will not even be thinking about pensions, those days are long gone! But the penetrative insight, the utterly revealing moment - yeah, that's real bad but hands off my pension! There is a glaring blind spot within this dialogue, that local agriarianism is about self provisioning. All the high seated, high titled folks are gonna have to come down to the fields and put there hands in the soil, care for the children and spin the yarn - that's your pension, and it is literally the only way out of this mess. We will only protect the land by occupying it, living off of it. The adherence to laws us naive and deluded. You will not find solidarity with peasants, subsistence Farmers, pastoralist and indigenous people unless you yourself are one. If you remain in the cash economy, no matter you high protestations, you are one and the same enemy of the people you purport to defend. Find your farm, find your land and retire with dignity among a community that will look after you not for money but for love.

i have a critique of melinda cooper

WHAT A GIFT❤there’s such wisdom right out of the gate.

Thanks to Ti R², I found this video on youtube with way better sound quality 1 year ago better sound quality here: BRACS7JFXFg

I think something to add would be the reason hemp was banned was because of US asking the Nepali government to do so for money

This is fascinating

What a fantastic conversation! The ethical issues you are raising are so essentials and you are giving us the tools to start thinking about them and about how to better help other animals.

I'm so, so impressed by this nuanced and persuasive argument. Illuminating and brilliant indeed!

😃 𝕡𝕣𝕠𝕞𝕠𝕤𝕞

Thank you for sharing this!

What is graeber wearing 😂

Discussion starts at 5:30

Fabulous Discussion from Giants 😊

Absolutely tremendous from Two Giant trees in the forest, It was sad to learn one of the Giant Trees has fallen.☹️

Too bad sound no good really. 😕

Horrible quality.

Fire the sound man.

Very interesting to learn of Urban Planning , highway design, to protect the properties! Since the 60's

there's 8 bit (bzzzzpitpitpipitpit) interference signal as David Graeber explains common problems faced by common people, inside a collapsing system.

What the HECK is he talking about? This is a whole bunch of nothing

users vs.abusers; buyers vs. sellers; capitalism vs. labor; also feminism and environmentalism

White suprem@cists (Pro-American/Pro-Free Markets) keep trying to discourage me from Socialism. They claim that the economic (price) calculation problem is fataI to Socialism. Please tell me how to argue back against them! thanks!

From Michael Hudson. “Killing the Host.” "A society’s analytic concepts determine the kind of reality it creates. That is why parasites start by taking control of their host’s brain. Neoliberal enzymes aim to sedate the industrial host into believing that the financial sector is part of the real economy, not external to it and extractive. That is the first myth." 100% agreed! The financial world is not only outside of the economy but outside of deductive reasoning. What reasonable sense is there in believing in the creation of the monetary unit apart from ANY economic activity. The belief that anyone can create units apart from something real that they represent (not themselves!) is hard to get people to understand as a misrepresentation of the function of and purpose for the existence of what we call money. But the unit cannot be a tool to report on and/or keep track of economic activity and then claim to be part of the economic activity at the same time! So, in the world of what we call the economy, all the products and services along with their transaction between folk are tracked/credited/accounted/recorded with accounting units that are also thought to be products all by themselves. The populace has not challenged the illiterate notion that it needs unit creators to conjure up these units - Poof! - with the flick of a pen or the stroke of a key on the keyboard!?? What kind of thinking is THAT!? I mean, really, how can an accounting unit also be a product? Why is it that we all think that abstract units of economic measure have to already be in existence as the property of the unit creators before the populace can interact and keep track with the units they then have to rent from the unit creators!? Then, as if this illiteracy is not enough, we add insult to our own stupidity as we go along with adding in the "cost" of the existence and use of these units to every single transaction along the "value chain" of the real goods and services and wonder why the whole freakin economy is unstable! This is Monetary Illiteracy NOT economic crisis! No magical entity or power exists such that the Abstract AcCounting Units can be created - Poof! - 'all by themselves' attached to nothing and considered property before they are eventually used/attached/assigned to annotate something of genuine value. How is it that anyone would think that "property" can be created in this fashion and that one can "own" the unit of acCount and legitimately charge for its existence and use. (How many inches or liters or gallons or miles or kilometers do you own!?) The habituation of this kind of thinking is manifest in both the banker fraud of "creating" units of acCount that go onto the books in their own records as both genuine entities of real "value" that are also their own property and "owed" back to themselves! And along with this insanity we throw in additional temporal based fees (interest) for the existence of the units so created until such time as they are "paid back"; and these fees are marching along and compounding (by addition to every transaction along the ‘value chain’) until the very next iteration of this same process starts all over again! But this is NOT the whole of the problem, because the populace is still stuck with the illegitimate thinking that "the government" (as though it is actually something separate from the populace itself) has this mystical original power to create - Poof! - the unit of acCount by some sort of magical power that entitles government to claim the same kind of asinine 'property rights' over its declared/established currency (that stupid illiterate establishment clause in the Constitution) such that it can both delegate the "creation" process to banks while also retaining some "ownership" claim over the units which it has already declared to be the form in which taxes must be paid! (David Graeber documents the long history of this lunacy in his book Debt: The First 5000 Years) And just like that - Poof! - the populace thinks that abstract acCounting units are things unto themselves that are claimed as property by a government (seemingly separate from the populace) that has exclusive power to both create and collect this "property" as a means to sustain itself as though government is something altogether separate from the populace! And when the focus has shifted in this process from the real contributions (that 'the government' just like any other member of the populace can/could easily acCount for with units of acCount that come into being in book keeping fashion) that a populace can require of itself to sustain itself to this asinine thinking about units of acCount as entities unto themselves that can somehow magically substitute for those real contributions, then the populace has given itself over to abandonment of its own power to any who will take up this power and use it for its own purposes. And ALL of this is based on the illegitimate thinking that an abstract unit of acCount can be, simply on the basis of declaratory assertion by illiterate and mostly illegitimate "leaders", both an abstract economic measure of value and a genuine commodity at one and the same time!! If we are going to help our kids we are not going to pass on the illiteracy of the ages to them! mrcenter.info/Doc/ConferencePapers/2020/MRC%202020%20A%20systems%20approach%20to%20money_4122020%20rev2_17.01.2021.pdf

Karl marx was nothing more than a racist

David Harvey is right on the Button , very well explained.

53:00 "capital is about continuous flow!" Yeah right, look at the world now, capital is obstructing its own flow yet it's stronger than ever. Harvey had his ears plugged by Marxist dogmatism to anything Graeber said. He represents the same condescending arrogance Marx was also guilty of when he had the nerve to ignore the actual proletariat of his time. They were breaking machines because they've experienced on their own flesh what machines and the obsession with work and production do to people and their relationships, but to leftist pundits that's just heresy and infantilism. Just keep talking on behalf of an imaginary, theoretical proletariat, Harvey!

David got DRIP in this vid fr

Mike Pompeo brags publicly" we lie,we steal,we cheat." But we all know they also Bomb, Sanction, kill, Assassinate, torture, coup and actually think they are the good guys. How can a country like that possibly change? When evil believes it's good there's not much chance of change.

Cities are garbage. That's why everyone's moving out of them. The powers-that-be jam us all together into small spaces and then say we are overpopulated. LOL. No, the problem is population density not numbers.

Can someone explain to me how these two eminent thinkers were not provided with proper microphones? In New York City, in 2012. A lost opportunity, and David Graeber has since died. Unbelievable. Breaks my heart, frankly.

thanks for the informative talks! Critical reappraisal of the Yugoslav experiment are generally lacking, but are important for academics and activists alike.

I wish all socialists would study more in the whole world , and more seriously what kind of socialism will be by itself more easily transitionned or go to , with minimum class struggles , and max progress in csiences and technologies , into moneyless and with private property turned into use-valued property by instituting new foundations , that would not resemble state-capitalism at all ! I think it will be an Open social political Global University starting all over the world , with a Universal Status , replacing money and a universal crypto not bankable, not alianable from each and not speculative , just cumulated social hourly activities of each member and summued up with her or his Universal Salary at age of 16 , somme 850 dollars in 2020 added to his cumulated hourly activity , representing also her or his social part or social daily income right !

um

brilliant and crucial talk, excellent discussion, awkward q&a

Found a better quality version: vimeo.com/41997338

i'm saving this video for David's outfit. period costumes should be a thing for anthropology professors the way that oversized button-downs, khakis, and white sneakers are for mathematics professors.

One way to notify a city of injustice is to publish on the so-called sovereign's monopoly currency. #EndGlobalApartheid

6:28 ;) kzbin.info/www/bejne/eGbdpGx_fMdrd7M

Great work ,

1:23. This is the first time I've heard another person speak objectively about the goals and success of Osama Bin Laden. It's important to recognize the greatest weakness of our country; the freedom to act on our fear. Americans justified every atrocity, including the one's yet unknown. The terror instilled by drone strikes is like living 9/12 every day for 20 years.