This video clearly confirms how Lanzmann was manipulating his witnesses. He interrupts him when he sees that answers does not suit the narrative. Then, he asks questions over and over to receive answer that will be satysfying to him and corresponding to the overall concept of the documentary (like with the ownership of the field). The lady translating was omitting some pieces and you can see how she does not allow him to speak. They use an uneducated peasant to prove Lanzmann's point, whereas the witness is not understanding how he is being manipulated. Truth is that in combating antisemitism Lanzmann shown plenty of antipolonism.

Habe selbst sein Buch gelesen! Unglaublich, wie offen er über diese Zeit spricht und wie detailliert er alles beschreibt. Bin sehr dankbar dafür. Kann es nur empfehlen-> Sonderbehandlung

Pas de noms.Pas de legendes.. Why ?

😢😢

fenomenāla čekista tieksme piesiet latviešus visur un pie visām nacistu zvērībām! Tā māk tikai maskavijas nacistu pakalpiņi!

What I glean from this is that the Nazi's were more lax in their efforts to conceal the true purpose of the camps than is usally assumed.

Once again we see that Ukrainians are participants in the murder of Jews …so once again I ask “why is the United States defending and supporting an ally of nazi germany “?

Legendary

My DOB 18.07.1959. I feel the holocaust of Jewes during begining to ending the 2nd world war is the worst history of human in the world.

Oh those innocent children. How can people be so wicked.

Это разве вошло в фильм?

You say he escaped....HOW???!!

The Death Camp Belzec was the first of the Aktion Reinhart Camps the only purpose of these camps were to kill the Jews upon arrival.

Never forget.

Bu acıları çeken insanlar nasil olurda gazzede bebekleri, tonlarca ağırlıktaki bombalarla parcalar aklim almıyor.

Adı Naime olmalı tamam

Bizim babannemiz burada ölmüş olabilirmi Atatürk'ün cocuğunun annesi burada öldürülmüş benim anladığım bu

😢😢😢😭😭😭😥

Buenas noches,La verdad es que se me parte el alma, cada vez, que veo, las imágenes de sufrimiento, del pueblo.judío. Siempre he amado a Israel.Y en estos aciagos mom3ntos, dónde algunos poderes quieren tacharlos de genocidas,no acepto de ninguna manera, tal calificativo. Pienso realmente,que hay mucha ignorancia, que la gente no lee Pobres, deben conocer la historia. Te amo Israel, Dios siempre te acompañará.Beñdito seas Israel.

I pray, never again. I pray we always remember!

En español por favor yaaa😂

dommage de ne point avoir la traduction française

Nikdy se nesmí zapomenout👍

I saw Shoah in the mid 80s, when it was shown on PBS. Almost 30 years later, I read Into That Darkness. The two complement each other and there are points of "similarity". I have to disagree with some of the comments below, re the interviewer and his line of questioning; Sereny followed much the same technique in her book. First ask some "soft" questions to establish some sort of "rapport" with the "eyewitness" to unspeakable horrors. Then gradually bring up the tougher questions, that exposed much of the truth in all its bestiality. I recall a scene from Shoah in which a villager is interviewed - cannot recall exactly where, probably in Poland. The interviewee had a Jewish family as his neighbor. Starts talking relatively "well" about them. After a few minutes with increasingly searching questions, he is almost foaming at the mouth. Saying how much he hated his neighbors and wishes he had participated in a bigger way, in their "extermination".

Most people are only 1 step away from being able to commit crimes like this, all they need is the right level of propaganda to convince them. And if anyone thinks otherwise I envy their innocence.

Obrigado pelo vídeo 👏🙏

2:33, Hitler considered the Jews the ones responsible for the defeat of German's loss in WWI.

Film Critics: Gene Sickle & Roger Ebert both considered "Shoah" one of the important documentaries of film making.

Es ist so unfassbar traurig, daß darf niemals vergessen werden

Incredibly Terribly Sad... Never Again

I have watched lanzmans work several times, and allways one interview stands out, That of one of the ss men at treblinka, suchomel. Filmed from a hidden camera, suchomel seems at ease when he talks, the term, the banality of evil, is perfectly on display with suchomel. He looks and sounds like someone's white haired grandad, laughing, engaging in conversation with lanzman.... You would never suspect him.

Waiting for something they don’t know. Left their livelihoods, brought here in animal truck. Almost dead in train. Separated here After arriving . still waiting for something good. My Lord GOD.. So painful.

For you, the uneducated. The Jews told the world for centuries that they were God's chosen people and that they were a race. Unfortunately the Nazis believed them to be a race so tried to annihilate the race. The Jews are a religion and nothing more.

Of course the Ukrainians are totally innocent. Right??

Cry Babies! You are allowing it to happen in the Middel east today. Hamas are no different that the Nazis. You cry to justify your doing nothing.

Toutes ces photos d'auschwitz... Sont prises au camp d'extermination de birkenau..... Ce sont la plupart au début l'arrivée des juifs de Hongrie ( 500 000) exterminés. Nous les voyons dans le petit bois entre les 2 crematoriums avec chambres à gaz. Toutes ces femmes et enfants ont été gazés dès leur arrivée. Paix à leurs âmes. El mole rahamine ✡️

Ludzkość niszczy Ludzkość

Это сделал Запад,учит нас жизни...

А кто это делал?

💔💔

Possibile che con tutti i filmati le fotografie di chi ha ripreso tutte queste scene... Ci sono voluti 6 lunghissimi anni per liberare la gente...ed intanto sono morte quante persone???? Miglioni???? Nel contempo nessuno vedeva sentiva sapeva niente????SEI LUNGHISSIMI ANNI DI TEMPO.!(QUALCOSA NON TORNA!)QUANTA SOFFERENZA..........

Man's inhumanity to man is unbelievable, Yet such people live amongst us today, waiting for the moment to be on the safe end of the rifle

Waiting four or five days for your death as Treblinka wasn't too far away from Warsaw by train. Beyond tragic. No amount of reparations can atone for the suffering of tjese poor people. What else to say but God bless & keep their souls.

Very interesting material. I am puzzled by the fact that in the aerial photos from 1945 there is no connection leading from Umshlagplatz east, straight to the Gdanski Station. There are no tracks that would allow trains to turn east. The trains started from the Umshlagplatz area, went westwards, crossed Mlocińska Street and then Burakowska Street, they had to stop and the locomotive had to be connected at the end so that the train from the vicinity of Burakowska Street could go eastwards. This is the only logical solution. But of course, this is just my hypothesis and perhaps there were some tracks leading directly to the east earlier (the maps do not show it), and by 1945 they were closed down and that is why there is no trace of them on the aerial photo.

I found this video absolutely moving. I wasn't prepared for the Mahler or the victims reel (I found it on a search for "Raul Hilberg," to find clips of him talking) and I broke down crying. I see that you have many educational videos on this subject and other genocides such as the Middle Passage. Thank you for your work. I hope eventually many thousands see these videos.

A documentary about trees not being there...

Na mapce brakuje podobozów pracy na tzw. flugplatzu i przy ul. Lipowej oraz nie ma obozu przesiedleńczego na ul. Krochmalnej. Obóz koncentracyjny przy drodze na Chełm, we wsi Dziesiąta, powinien być określony jako KL Lublin "Majdanek", bowiem to getto szczątkowe na Majdanie Tatarskim miało potoczne określenie Majdanek.

Thank you for posting this in the format that you did, as it made it a far more powerful device than when one has to listen to the spoken word alone.

'promo sm' 🤔

Tous ces morts..... quelle horreur ! C'est juste insupportable !!!