Пікірлер
@larskarlsson6197
@larskarlsson6197 5 сағат бұрын
Please send me the checklist
@maxamedxuseen1740
@maxamedxuseen1740 13 сағат бұрын
Why you speak fast. Slow down, so that your audience could understand what you are teaching.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 сағат бұрын
Hi, thanks for the feedback. You are literally the first to mention this! This 'high information density' is a very conscious decision. I've had many comments of viewers who really appreciate that. According to research, talking fast is an advantage on youtube, Apparently the majority of viewers do not want to waste any time getting their information. What you could do is play the video at half of trhee-quarter speed. I had one viewer that was soo happy with no BS high speed approach, he said that he normally played clips at double speed but he had to slow mine down to normal speed :-D Best regards, Hans
@ioannismanousakas3040
@ioannismanousakas3040 16 сағат бұрын
Send me the checklist! Thanks!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 сағат бұрын
Link is in the description! Check out the course I'm making as well, this is not free and meant for professionals: www.hans-rosenberg.com/product_development_course Best regards, Hans
@ekkotron
@ekkotron Күн бұрын
send me the checklist `:-)
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 сағат бұрын
Link is in the description! Check out the course I'm making as well, this is not free and meant for professionals: www.hans-rosenberg.com/product_development_course Best regards, Hans
@fabrizioajola2085
@fabrizioajola2085 2 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
Link is in the description! Best regards, Hans
@JoEmbedded
@JoEmbedded 2 күн бұрын
Hello Hans, very interesting! Yes, I would like to receive a link to your checklist book! Which VNA are you using? Can you recomend a not-so-expensive VNA for home-use? I am trying to add a slotted GPS antenna to a cat tracker, but the learning slope is long and high ;-) Thanks a lot, best regards, Jo
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
HI, I use the nanovna V2 plus 5, that is the most expensive 4.4ghz model they have. For rough matching, I think the 60usd vna's should be ok I think, i never tested one. Link to the book is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@neodiy
@neodiy 2 күн бұрын
Apologize for my rookie question..when apply DC at the output of the amplifier ...why it is not damaging it although now it has two current opposing each other at input and output? Out of curiosity hope you can explain for me to understand
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
The amplifier gets its power through the output pin. Hope that clears it up?
@huraibyel-huraiby7462
@huraibyel-huraiby7462 3 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist 🙏
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
Link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@saptarshibiswas3487
@saptarshibiswas3487 3 күн бұрын
Please "send me the checklist", sir. This video is amazing!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
Haha, thanks a lot :-) Link is in the description. I'm currently making a 'not free' course which is completely in the same style as this video. I've just gotten a bit better at presenting since this was my first KZbin video. The free guide is a basis for this course, but it goes much much further. www.hans-rosenberg.com/product_development_course . It's only for professional designers though, they'll very easily earn the cost of the course back. For a private person it's a little expensive. Best regards, Hans
@gabrovche
@gabrovche 3 күн бұрын
If you want to achieve HiFi performance you have to design your circuit with RF rules in mind to. At the end - for every frequency from DC to GHz range you get a net of complex impedances that determine your performance (SNR). The real issue ist that those frequencies interact with each other due to non-linearities in the design and cause intermodulation. I have used e.g. exactly this effect to build an RF detector out of an audio opamp. Unless you and not intentionally seeking this effect you have to respect RF rules even if you design kW audio amp! Of course RF rules are not the only thing to respect to make this work - in order to get to the optimal design you have to have wholistic approach and consider everything - and, as always, at the end you get a compromise, because you cannot set all parameters at their most optimal range, but the trick is - the more you know and consider - the better you can steer this compromise to the goal you have set! In that respect Hans Rosenberg ist doing a really good job explaining all those details and giving vivid examples! Keep up the good work Hans - we are spreading the word!!!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
Fully agree, everything is a compromise, the trick is to weigh all the factors correctly so you get the best compromise, that can be very tricky at times. Especially with audio....
@emiljankes
@emiljankes 5 күн бұрын
Thank you for taking the time to make these videos! Cheers from Finland!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 4 күн бұрын
Glad you like them!
@williamwaters3717
@williamwaters3717 5 күн бұрын
Hans, Thanks you for the great information. If possible I would like to have a copy of your checklist.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 5 күн бұрын
thanks, link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@petrsuchomel9639
@petrsuchomel9639 5 күн бұрын
One interesting parameter to check would be return loss with different coupling capacitors. I wonder what you are actually seeing on 1GHz, the lower gain might be caused by worsening RL.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 5 күн бұрын
Based on past experience, I don't think the capacitors are the problem. The bandwidth of the amplifier is just not high enough.
@kompallivinaynaidu7236
@kompallivinaynaidu7236 6 күн бұрын
hello sir , is it possible do one video on power amplifier ?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 5 күн бұрын
Will try
@Cooper_013
@Cooper_013 6 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 5 күн бұрын
thanks, link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@redbeard9496
@redbeard9496 6 күн бұрын
Thanks for this great video, please send me the checklist :)
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 6 күн бұрын
you're welcome, link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@azback001
@azback001 6 күн бұрын
Please send me the checklist!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 6 күн бұрын
Link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@OutThere458
@OutThere458 7 күн бұрын
I am curious why you didn't use an LDO on the PCB. I would expect a good deal of noise added to the signal when powering from any switching supply, let alone a bench power supply. I don't know of an inexpensive way to measure noise figure (other than luck on eBay), but I wonder if your gain and compression measurements might even change if you repeated them using a lithium battery? Actually, if you have a variable attenuator, you could do a noise comparison (not measurement) by sticking this on a GPS receiver. See how high you can dial the attenuator before the receiver stops acquiring a cold fix. Then repeat, but using a battery as the power source.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 7 күн бұрын
I have a very good linear bench supply :-) I'm not sure what the transfer or supply noise to amplifier noise is. The bias resistor does take care of some isolation but some will definitely get through. If you want to supply it from an unspecified supply it would be great to add a low noise ldo. Do you know the LT3045?? That is an amazing device!
@andreasaltmann9397
@andreasaltmann9397 7 күн бұрын
I saw you on Robert Feranec's Channel. Incredible good Tutorials and easy to understand for me. Thank you so much! Also please send me the checklist. :-)
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 7 күн бұрын
Thanks a lot! Link is in the description. Also making a professional course at the moment (not free). Best regards, Hans Rosenberg
@big_whopper
@big_whopper 7 күн бұрын
Hi! Send me the checklist! I have one, but would love to see yours
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 7 күн бұрын
Link is in the description. Curious to know what you think about it. Best regards, Hans
@Soupie62
@Soupie62 8 күн бұрын
Nice theory, but I mostly use HF bands. 2 metre at the highest. At 2m, the tracks would need to twist like snakes to fit on a board.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 8 күн бұрын
indeed, 'lf' is not acceptable here, maybe you can do the same with a transformer at these frequencies?
@rogeronslow1498
@rogeronslow1498 9 күн бұрын
You need a proper vna.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 9 күн бұрын
I know, care to donate one ;-) I really would love to have a fieldfox all in one....... a bit expensive unfortunately ;-)
@chrisgj198
@chrisgj198 8 күн бұрын
@@HansRosenberg74 The Librevna is ok for many things. The developer is very helpful. There is an ecal for it too, the librecal. The whole setup is reasonably priced, at least when compared to some online electronics courses ;-) There is potential to improve the isolation on the Librevna (although it is ok for many things already), and being open-source, you would be free to do this.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 2 күн бұрын
I looked at the libre vna. However, the specs seemed to be very similair to my nanovna v2 plus 5 which is the best model currently. Improving it might make it better, allthough my biggest lack in the nanovna is dynamic range and I wonder if you can improve that because it is most likely linked to the dynamic range of the adc in there.
@dave_dennis
@dave_dennis 9 күн бұрын
This is so very useful for me. Thanks for posting this Hans. DE N5BOC.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 9 күн бұрын
You are welcome!
@fabriblu
@fabriblu 10 күн бұрын
Hi Hans, I tried to send you an email to your address but it return undeliverable. Did you change address ?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Hi, I did not change it. It is [email protected]. I had a problem a month ago, my mailbox was full. I configured my mailserver with very low storage space. I just tried to send myself an email and that was ok. I'll try to send an email with attachment, maybe it is full again? I set it to 'unlimited' but maybe it runs into the limit of my subscription?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Just tried it with 5Mb in attachments... no problem. I don't know what is wrong.....
@jbrown468
@jbrown468 10 күн бұрын
Great video!!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Thanks!!!!
@kreativa6190
@kreativa6190 10 күн бұрын
Greetings Mr Hans! I'm wondering if you are reviewing the PCBs of your subscribers? If so I would gladly send you my very second PCB in the hope to give me some advice. And i wanted to note that your videos can't get any better. Thanks for your work!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Unfortunately, I don't have the time for that. You could try the reddit printedcircuitboard thread: r/PrintedCircuitBoard . That thread is specifically for that goal and they have good experts there.
@kreativa6190
@kreativa6190 10 күн бұрын
@HansRosenber Totally understandable. Anyways, thanks for the quick response. 😄👍
@jonhoyles714
@jonhoyles714 10 күн бұрын
thanks thanks hans another interesting video ❤
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
You're welcome :-)
@dephnor
@dephnor 10 күн бұрын
Hello, I am an IT student interested in programming, electronics and all it's aspects. I am sure you hear this often, but this 15-minute video taught me more than any lecture/lesson from a teacher at my high school. I would like to express my gratitude for sharing your knowledge. Since you've linked the checklist in the description, I thought I'd at least leave a comment for the youtube algorithm and to thank you.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Thanks, the reason for making these videos is exactly what you state: You don't learn this stuff in school. Actually, I hardly learned electonics design at school, even though I did an electronics program. It's not very good. I learned most of it because I'm hooked on electronics since I was 8 years old :-)
@samulinyman
@samulinyman 10 күн бұрын
When calculating S21 and S43, did you also account for the extra losses from the SMA connectors on the PCB? How much are those losses in your setup?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
I did not account for those. It could very well be that those extra pieces of pcb track from the coupled lines towards the connectors and the connectors themselves account for the 0.1dB of loss I'm missing.
@samulinyman
@samulinyman 10 күн бұрын
@@HansRosenberg74 Thank you for the reply! I would be interested to learn more about your footprint. I've struggled to get losses of less than 0.5 dB in a connector when using edge-mounted coaxial connectors. The transition from the connector to a 50-ohm trace is tricky to get just right.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
If you want good performance, you have to use specialized connectors and ro4003. Here is an example of such a connector: www.belfuse.com/resources/assemblyinstructions/cinchconnectivitysolutions/johnson/ai-ccs-john-sma-high-frequency-end-launch-connectors-pc-mounting-instructions.pdf
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
This is not the best document, 10 years ago I worked on a radar system that needed very high specs, I used end launch connectors that were specified up to 26GHz. The layout was exactly outlined in the datasheet that came with the connector, including which type of rogers material to use and the thickness of the dielectric off course. I couldn't find it that easily, but a bit more searching should allow you to find it. These connectors are more expensive though. I think they may go up to 20usd.
@Hari-uy3rm
@Hari-uy3rm 10 күн бұрын
Thank you for the tutorial sir✌, can you make a tutorial on how to design wideband coupler?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Thanks, yeah, that would be interesting. I did study the theory for how to do that so it should not be that hard, however, getting a very high directivity at the same time (which I would really like to have) might be pretty challenging. Not much information present on how to do that. I think for a wideband design I'll also need better pcb material like ptfe or rogers.
@samjones1954
@samjones1954 10 күн бұрын
quick english lesson... it is not coopled... it is cupled. it means to join.. like a couple of people... not a coople of people
@Mr.Leeroy
@Mr.Leeroy 10 күн бұрын
it's a Netherland thing. And it's nothing compared to e.g. the way some Germans pronounce "kay-coo-late" instead of "calculate"
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Haha, thanks, you're not the first one to mention it, I had no idea :-)
@dave_dennis
@dave_dennis 9 күн бұрын
Hans your English is well enough that I didn’t not realize you were not a native speaker on the first 2 or 3 videos I watched.
@DH4YM
@DH4YM 11 күн бұрын
Thank you.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
You're welcome!
@TonySebastian-g3q
@TonySebastian-g3q 11 күн бұрын
Send me the check list please
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Link is in the description! Best regards, Hans
@s7arkchannel848
@s7arkchannel848 11 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Link is in the description! Best regards, Hans
@RicoElectrico
@RicoElectrico 11 күн бұрын
Nice "coopler" tutorial. Thanks Hans 😁
@lohikarhu734
@lohikarhu734 10 күн бұрын
Good old Dutch version... but, honestly, the English here is on the transmitted side of the coupler, only about 0.05 dB out the accented port 😺🇨🇦
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
:-D
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
I'm getting the feeling I pronounced something wrong..... on more than 1 occasion :-) As long as you guys get it, my engineering mind concludes that the main task of getting information transmitted from A to B was successful and there is no real problem :-D
@rfrisbee1
@rfrisbee1 7 күн бұрын
​@@HansRosenberg74Your english is infinitely better than my Dutch and perfectly understandable, compared to, say, some people from the north of the UK ;-). For DC to 10's to possibly the low 100's of MHz a similar device can be built with opamps. Ian Hickman provided the details in his "Analog Circuits Cookbook"
@TheTrueCBaer
@TheTrueCBaer 11 күн бұрын
I checked the geometry with the (free online) Sierra Circuits Impedance Calculator which claims to be a 2D Field solver. The numbers are very close. Without solder mask: C=0.0979, Zodd=45.21, Zeven=55.03 S11 to S14: -42.836 ∠ 110.64, -0.287 ∠ -89.07, -20.371 ∠ 1.04, -24.244 ∠ -179.7 With solder mask (parameters guessed): C=0.1000, Zodd=44.46, Zeven=54.34 S11 to S14: -34.881 ∠ 157.36, -0.291 ∠ -90.37, -20.191 ∠ 0.25, -24.58 ∠ -179.64
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Nice!
@norbertdapunt5092
@norbertdapunt5092 11 күн бұрын
Awesome.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@TheTrueCBaer
@TheTrueCBaer 11 күн бұрын
Sadly QUCS development is in such a sorry state. So much potential.
@xfxox
@xfxox 10 күн бұрын
Fortunately there is a well developing fork: Qucs-S
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
Oh, cool, did not know about that!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 10 күн бұрын
what is improved in that version?
@rjordans
@rjordans 10 күн бұрын
@@HansRosenberg74 it adds support for spice based simulation
@venom_ftw9316
@venom_ftw9316 11 күн бұрын
Thank you Mr Rosenberg
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 11 күн бұрын
You're welcome! :-)
@terjekristiansen0
@terjekristiansen0 11 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist please! And thank you
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 11 күн бұрын
You're welcome. Link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@commanderfun4790
@commanderfun4790 12 күн бұрын
How is input and output stability accounted for in this design?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 11 күн бұрын
That was really hard, those devices are unconditionally stable ;-) I think you may be able to get them to 'yell at you' if you annoy them enough, but you'd really have to do your best to achieve that.
@andreas5719
@andreas5719 15 күн бұрын
Could you send me the checklist Mr Rosenberg?
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 14 күн бұрын
Hi, yes, link is in the description. I'm also working on a professional course, this is not free and will be ready in 3 months hopefully. Link to that is in the document. Best regards, Hans.
@Wo0dY101
@Wo0dY101 15 күн бұрын
Hi, I'm a software developer getting into electronics and it's a ton of fun. I'm trying to build a 8 bit computer using sinple IC's for gates and transistors but i start getting strange "mistakes" in the logic and someone informed me that it might be that I need capacitors as I'm using too much power too quickly on certain parts. Can you make a video on nice rules of thumb to keep things powered? Maybe how to segment the sections in a way that keeps it simple. The wiring becomes a lot so any simplicity I gain is a win!
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 14 күн бұрын
Hi there, sounds like you're breadboarding? This is a real pain for getting good 'signal integrity'. For that you need a ground plane and good decoupling. If you're on a breadboard, use a star shaped supply (supply all ic's from one point) and make sure you have a 100nF cap very close to each ic to keep the supply of that single ic quiet. Best way would be to design a board, but that is not flexible off course.
@graemejury3184
@graemejury3184 15 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 15 күн бұрын
Link is in the description, best regards, Hans
@zenithparsec
@zenithparsec 15 күн бұрын
You should say you have to sign up to your community to get your "free" checklist. It might be a fantastic checklist. I don't know. The video was good. Don't like clickbait links which promise something, but then add another step. Can't trust them.
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 15 күн бұрын
sorry about that. The reason I gather emails is that I need a way to pay for these youtube videos. I intent to do that by selling courses. These courses are not free. In order to reach potential customers I need email adresses. Just to get an idea, I 'burn' 3000 euros a month doing this because of regular costs, so I need to generate some income from this in the future. Very scary, since setting something up like this (with a course) takes around a year. The checklist is really good, I've been sending it out for a few months now and the nicest responses I got were from other very experienced engineers who really liked it. The course I'm making is based on this document, but goes a lot further. It is going to take me 5 months to make I think. I can imagine your hesitation to leave your mail address. I also hate spam. You can always unsubscribe, your mail address will disappear from the platform I use and I don't think I can get that back. Hope this clarifies things a bit. Best regards, Hans
@kavinduratnayake
@kavinduratnayake 17 күн бұрын
Send me the checklist
@HansRosenberg74
@HansRosenberg74 17 күн бұрын
Link is in the description. Best regards, Hans
@kavinduratnayake
@kavinduratnayake 16 күн бұрын
Thanks Hans. I got it