Thanks for sharing the rules explanation this week. In the Georgia vs. Mississippi State game, this past weekend an opposing team coach made forceable contact with a participating player, in front of a game official. Why did the game official did not call a violation on the play for unsportsmanship conduct?

I was hoping there would be a broadcast review of the clock and discussion of rules on the last play of the OSU-ORE game. Does there need to be over 1 second on the clock to get the time out?

An excellent video and I am very happy with the quick action on the rules change. My opinion is that sports that permit breaking the rules of the game to give an advantage are deeply flawed and yes I am talking about basketball.

In the clip of the Alabama South Carolina game regarding the momentum rule, the player started to take a knee in the endzone before changing his mind, shouldn't the play have been blown dead immediately when he started to take a knee?

Why was the ORE-OSU play not enforced as a foul for Illegal Participation rather than a substitution infraction? The 12th player did participate actively in the play and was not trying to leave the field. Does the NCAA not consider this to be IP?

Funny you didn’t review the reversal of targeting call in the LSU game

Your overtime rules are idiotic. There should never be more than one overtime. Whoever gets the ball second should have to play for the win. Start the first possession at the 40 then second team to possess the ball has to play for the win

Play #4 - The linebacker appears to simulate a hard count before the D-Line shifts. Is this not disconcerting signals?

Regarding the OT play fumble and the entry onto the field. If it had been a TD and game continued, and ONLY the goal post in the opposite end of the Field was taken Down, the game would have continued with just the one functioning goal post, since we never use the Goal post in the opposite end of the field during OT - or????

@ncaaresources Would love an explanation for the waived off targeting in the Bama Vandy game that resulted in a player being injured for the remainder of the game.

You guys need to promote this channel more. Millions of fans of college athletics and this video only has 791 views despite being up for 13 hours. I have learned SO MUCH from these videos and I look forward to them every week! I would love to see more people benefit from all the work that goes into making them.

The NCAA's desire to drag out the full game longer and longer for commercials with the "2 minute timeout", and yet limit the length of something exciting like overtime is absurd. These videos are great none the less. They should play them at halftime at games.

Odd choice not to cover the targeting on Cal's QB.

Great videos. I especially appreciate the zero tolerance for brandishing a weapon.

No call doesn't mean legal.

This guy and his comrades ruined college football. The replay system is RUINING the sport! The games are constantly being stopped to look at completely insignificant plays! Fans pay their hard earned money to watch these games and you end up getting constant stoppages to pointless reviews and fake injuries! Terrible I’m selling my season tickets & cancelling cable if this isn’t fixed fast

Sure hope that the brutal hit by #45 Wake Forest is explained as to why it wasn't targeting next week. Sure looks like he launches himself and dislodges the QB's helmet.

Is there an explanation for the kick catch interference during the Notre Dame-Louisville game that wasn’t called?

2:49 For as much as some like to critique these videos as only pointing out correct plays, I'm glad to see the analysis of Play 2. Good on you for calling out the bad penalty and clarifying that this isn't what we want in the game.

Bold of the NCAA to not address the VT - Miami ending

A lot of UGA fans would love to hear the NCAA/SEC explanation for the side judge who was caught on video at the Alabama bench laughing and joking with the Bama quarterback.

RIP Dikembe Mutombo. I had watched his game several times during 90s and 2000s.

We gotta find the highlights with Mutombo and Alonzo Mourning on the court together. That's block city. RIP Dikembe

RIP Hoya Legend

Please please please spend some time on the final play of VT vs Miami from Friday night.

What the hell is that field goal rule @5:22 ? If the ball is higher than the uprights it can't be reviewed, why? That just means a crooked ref could rule that a 15 yard game winning field goal right down the middle is no good knowing that because it was higher than the uprights replay can't override him.

So for the first clip do you not have to hit the pylon with the ball just any part of the body to activate goal line extended?

Please stop with the horrible changes to the game. It is a great game. Stay out of the way. Why are you trying to take the setter out of the game? It became great without you. The double contact and the prolonged contact with the setters are horrible!! Let the game be great without you.

This was a great stroll down memory lane. Richard was definitely the face of the NCAA when you walked through the doors. I miss him. Thanks Yvonee and Kevin.

What about hand gestures made by the offensive lineman just to the left or right of the center? It seemed like this happened a lot in the USC @ Michigan game but not every instance was flagged for false start. So is there some movement by offensive linemen that is not considered a foul?

Would be great, if the CFO/NCAA broke the video into segments (as you can on KZbin) and named them each accordingly. And then, more importantly, that the relevant rules respectively sections of the MOFO for each segment is listed in the description of the video with the relevant time codes.

lmfao now the NCAA is censoring their own comment section because their ego is so fragile towards any type of criticism. grow a spine and stop being such a bad organization

Thank you for these videos; I always learn something!

Convenient that the NCAA choose plays that are pretty indisputable yet they do and say NOTHING about the terrible and egregiously missed calls. Show some actual transparency and not just rehashing penalties no one disagreed with. You have the opportunity to explain yourself yet you never do. Cowards.

I really dislike the action by the linebacker @6:26 His intent is masked by calling a defensive shift, but its obvious this is done to get a reaction from the offense. I think it needs to be addressed in the rules committee.

What if a player A shoves player B, with only their hands, on the front face of player B's shoulder pads and player B falls to the ground because they are not paying attention in front of them?

Would have appreciated breaking down some of the more questionable rulings this week (i.e. the NIU 4th down spot and the OKState "false start" against Arkansas)

I'd love to hear stats about other penalties too. How does the total number of penalties per game change from week to week or season to season?

4:28 Really appreciate this type of review. It's a little bit about rules but mostly about official mechanics which I find fascinating. More like this please!

The viewership would be much higher if there weren’t so many POINTLESS reviews. What other sport would allow this? Reviewing random tackles and plays that have no impact on the game. It’s absurd. Just switch to the NFL replay system it’s not hard.

The targeting rule has become such a joke. Stopping the game constantly to review a tackle. Ejecting players for hits that are far from dirty. The targeting ejection of Ohio State's Denzel Burke was awful. Stopped the game for 10 minutes for it too. Unwatchable.

Why are you still stopping the clock on first downs inside of two minutes?? The offense has three timeouts and a 2 minute timeout + the clock stops when they go out of bounds. It's so unfair to the defense. You've given the offense training wheels in 2 minute stations.

Would love an explanation of the no-call late hit when Quinn Ewers took a knee during Texas/Michigan game today

Good explanation of the no call during the NDSU and Colorado game

Glad you're doing this again this year!

Be curios to see if there’s discussion of a possible missed targeting call in the final drive of the Colorado win tonight…

With that last one it sounds like Steve is almost suggesting players to give the T sign deceptively on a return attempt to throw the kicking team off-guard.

Kyrie Irving does two layups back to back starting at 3:04 in below clip. Are both considered traveling? kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXjLkpJ9i7CWndUm04s

At @2:32 Black #11 does a swing step. Is it possible for a player to do the swing step move but terminate the ball while feet are in the air so that they can take two legal steps and finish. If it is possible, can you share footage of someone doing a legal swing step according to NCAA rules?

Why wasn’t Kentucky flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct in the bowl against Clemson for machine gun/pistol celebrations? While celebrating the kickoff return for touchdown #7 Barion Brown ‘reloaded’ and kept ‘firing.’ After his third td he makes the piston motion then sniffs his hands as if to inhale the gun smoke. The rule is explicit. Why were the infractions overlooked? Multiple times! Four instances, three by one player alone, that were crystal clear penalties!