"Always" and "at least" NINETY-FIVE percent the same? Mind sharing your data with the class?

@@derekegidio2723 what kind of data would you need from me when there's millions of data out there in the internet conducted by more reputable people than me ? I didn't say 100% because there could never be 100% of anything. Matter fact why dont you do your own experiments and grab two people of the same star sign and find if they're similar or not rather than trying to be the antagonist on every single comment

Dude that is SOO false

@@tjay6969 you're probably a virgo or a Capricorn

@@mars9075 Not saying you're stupid or anything but dude EVERY SINGLE INDIVIDUAL is different. Your zodiac sign has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with your personality or behavior. It just doesn't. "People with the same star sign are always at least 95% alike" That statement is VERY incorrect and it can be DEMONSTRATED that it is incorrect. For example, take 10 Aries and put them together, most likely most of them will be different from each other. If you REALLY went out and tested this out you'd see that most people of the same sign are NOT the same. And the few that are the same are not alike because of a zodiac sign. It is a coincidence. Also, with 8 million people in the world, OF COURSE there are a lot of people ON THE PLANET who have similarities based on the numbers game in which a lot of those people just happen to be of the same sign. That's because of a large NUMBER. Not because of a star that connects them. Hell, ALL it would take is for 1 out of the 10 Aries to be different from the other 9 to show that this belief that "people with the same sign are always alike" is CLEARLY wrong.

The effect is one thing, but effect on what level ? If stars affect , than so is the topography of earth, the thing is how you prioritise the effect. If you are in budding that are gonna destroyed by earthquake, than does ithe stars makes sense, like everyone do have the somthing similar in their horoscope, no proof at all

@@anaconda4407 Everything has subjectivity. An example, mushrooms have a certain way they grow but are they aware of themselves? Whether they are or not they are still existing. The effect is really in our own awareness. Astrology helps some people orient to this world. Others orient through understanding science or other things. I guess the question you're proposing is to what level and the answer is subjectivity. Everyone "is" with a different understanding!

@OftheVine I don't think astrology orients people, but it does very well in disorienting people, and the tendency of astrology is not towards subjectivity, but it tends more towards objectivity, these are two points I want you to consider. Astrology's foundation is prediction, and prediction is not based on subjective technique, but it is quite objective, if there is a certain combination, the specific thing is more likely to happen, now this is purely objective. It is this nature of astrology that some astrologers call it similar to science. Now let's talk about what is the objective of astrology, is it gonna help someone in any way from coming out of the problem he or she is in, or save the person from the problem, I don't think so. It will rationalise the problem in the language of stars like it is your horoscope that made you get robbed on the street. Poor is poor because of its horoscope, so that blame goes back to a person only. In fact, in India astrology was used for 1000 years to justify the caste system, and it gave the intellectual backing for the exploitation. I read a wise man saying, that if you believe in astrology, it will come true to you, and if you don't, you can see it does not work on any level, it is just about our mindset. Everything affects the life of a person, from the sun to stars, and even galaxies, that is how the universe functions and we are alive on Earth. Every thread is important. But the question is how it affects us, is it Venus that gives money to a person? Then why do certain geographies have prominent poverty, so is it earth and resources? Then why are many Western countries rich without resources, so is intelligence and technology, or the balance of everything that brings prosperity? I have studied astrology for 3 years, and I have made predictions that amazed people. But gradually I felt hollow from inside, the arrogance that I understood the magical rule of the universe corrupted me, my brain became more foggy, and I was not grounded. Today I criticise astrology at all levels, no matter whether it is true or not, it is useless. Our body and brain have limitations, and sometimes it is better to respect limitations. That's remind of Socrates who said I know I am wise because I know, I know nothing.

@@anaconda4407 The way I look at astrology is it's a cosmic weather report just like wear your sun hat when it's sunny. I'm a teacher and when it's a full moon and throughout the moon cycle you can tell the students feel the changes. It's important to be objective and understand our subjective experience. And, like you said there are many factors. Hari Krishna

@OftheVine A teacher, that's a huge responsibility, you have control over the life and shape of the future of many students of yours and by that the whole nation and world. So good luck with that. You have a very positive perspective, but since you are a teacher I would just add that never discourage a critical mind, which by the way lot of teachers do. The many past human generations have lived their whole life based on fact which was a lie, like a flat earth, Thousands of civilisations died in ignorance, and those who rebelled challenged the existing understating , they were the ones who made breakthroughs in human life. This is what many elders do to exceptional children who don't follow the same chain of thought, as normal children, they superimpose their thoughts on them to kill critical thinking. About your whole comment, the one thing that really want me to respond to you is your last word Hare Krishna, why you said that ? What does it mean? It is subjective question , I know, that's why I am asking it, what these words means to you when you say it to other ?

Imported knowledge.

"Science" it is a pseudoscience alright 😂

So what is it exactly? He basically debunked what people think about astrology that is it affects & influences the life of people. And co-relation doesn't always mean causation.

@@vinodgurung2291 he didn't actually debunk anything; he doesn't understand anything about how astrology actually works and he misrepresented the origins of it which is shady. Astrology is not a hard science, it's better to consider it a soft science at most or an art. It's very interpretive and studies correlations- that's the whole point. Lots of scientific studies are just studying correlations because sometimes it is valuable