Buy Legacy of Lunatic Kingdom for the full version!

Mr science Guy astronomer a disagree with you strongly in that you could use science with the moon when there's a full moon it definitely an absolutely scientifically and otherwise is proven that it rises the ocean level 1,000 percent true address the universe does care what is what you make it so you can't rely on astrology to guide you you got to rely on the parents are the country you live in there's a lot of Truth to astrology so if the moon has that effect on us Saturn has and Uranus and Mars they're definitely felt. Just like the moon you can't discount the energy will we all feel it as a collective moreover, it doesn't dictate our choices were born with three choice and you scientists and astronomers cannot predict that there is a God and you cannot deny it and you think ghosts just a figment of imagination and you're wrong there too so I think you just should stick to astronomy and don't tell us your opinion especially when it's not based on all stocks like the moon having an effect on the water level and people because we've made out of water and their behavior when a full moon is apparent.😊 Thank you for your time and attention

Is the woman making the question the ski athlete Lindsey Vonn?

It’s like they’re trying to promote astrology as a sort of religion or secrete society that bases their entire life and personality on the time,date, and location they were born. I say secrete society even tho they aren’t hiding because they choose who to accept based on the 3 afformentioned specifications above. It’s the epitome of judging a book without its cover , but even worse because they feel as if they actually have read said book because they know when and where it was published 😂 .its all placebo stimulation fuels by the human desire to belong to something. The weak seek out groups of likeminded individuals. The weakest pretend to be likeminded just to fit in.

I believe in chinese astrology , its approved for me , 100% works . This is an ancient knowledge from 5000 yrs ago . maybe an alien knowledge that conducts us to live better . According to this astrological table , incompatible people must avoid each other to live peacefully . We can use this at office , university and home . Only compatible people must have contact to each other . This is a great and useful ancient knowledge . With deploying it in societies we can decrease crime and divorce significantly . Scientists like this guy are absoloute ordinary people who studied and read some papers at university or college not more , they cant think beyond the uni books . Their minds are locked and frozen by so called scientific papers😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

The flaw of Neils logic is that Astrology is in its own multiverse as most things are ... this is why water and oil don't mix ... it doesnt make oil valid and water a fraud ...

So if you are famous you can just talk shit about the things you dont know

This explanation is bogus. Run your own chart and see and read for yourself

What about the fact that we are made of the same material

He has to no power to debunk the management of god which is astrology Please recollect him...he is a human not a god

Every tarot reader and spiritual beliefs

Remember we know very little about life

Why are the fish losers though, seems a bit of a coincidence 🤔

Did you also know that when all the plants allign in a strait line something REALLY bad happens? I dont know what it is but oh man its bad. A disaster of cosmic proportions!

I dont know anything about the subjects spoken about. But anyway i will try make a argument. Lets say sirius is at x degree during the morning. And 2eather or not you see this star or not it determens weather the river will rise or not. It doesnt mean this star is the causeing factor of what they noticed on earth. Its just a sign for how it was percived for them. Also you may only know one thing. No amount of thinking will prove it is reality. Only experiance/testing will prove weather its real or not. Here we do not really know. And can never know if this situation is correct or not

damn , I really wish he knew what he was talking about. Its more powerful and actually convinces me when people really know about a subject, THEN disprove it. damn Neil " I was rooting for you!"

Not sure how Neil disproved something that a peer reviewed paper has provided evidence of. Quantitative sociologist David Voas examined the census data for more than 20 million individuals in England and Wales to see if star signs corresponded to marriage arrangements. He found no correlation, but he ignored his own findings. Table 1 of his data reveals that the order in which Sun signs are most likely to be married is the same for both males and females. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bH60e4p-h56IibMsi=iDz1pJjzt_mk_hgv&t=92

I don't see how scientific knowledge and human happiness are compatible

This guy must meet K.N Rao Sir … this guy Tyson will just pull up a blanket and sell away all his degrees and sleep till someone wakes him up and give him a Donut or a piece of cake. This guy will even forget to smile once he meets KN Rao sir. 😂❤

The thing is that the alignment of planets does influence some people's behaviors but not in the way scientists currently try to reason with. There isn't a causal relationship but a belief relationship. The one who believes that there is a connection between planets and their life will be influenced by the event of planetary movement. It's not causal because it's not a force that the scientific community believes in, belief. Scientific community does not believe in belief, and yet its real. They are more concerned with atoms and molecules and gravity, which is true also, but fail to regard belief as a force. Yes, it's a paradoxical theory that by believing in something, it becomes true, but its real, so, yea.

What he said has no bearing on how mythology explained peoples understanding of reality. Why would you ask him anything about metaphysics? I watch him for astronomy, the latest on dark energy and recently one they did on dark matter, and it was really good. This guy knows nothing about metaphysics. Don't go to the dentist to get brain surgery. Neil has contempt for astrology.

He doesn’t disprove the theory that the stars have effect on us. He merely explains that people in ancient times where more connected to their spiritual body than we are today. The earth revolves around the sun and the sun around some galaxie. Just as we revolve around the earth and the earth is the only aspect of universe we as humans interact with on a daily basis. So to say that the constellations will look differently from another point of view is irrelevant hence we are talking about the effect the “stars/planets” have on people, on earth.

Simplistic view you have zero spirituality

Women love to use this nonsense because they lack accountability and it's easier to put in on astrology.

he should just say IDK because tbh our environment has an effect like it or not and we don't have any PROOF that it's not a possible influence on people.

Also you can spend hours looking at the stars and still get a long nights sleep… that’s how the solstice works… … Neil needs to go camping touch grass and take the celebrity crown off for a sec

Makes sense except what he’s describing isn’t astrology …

Much needed

To astrologers, may I know what is the science behind astrology? Just curious

How about the one who created the life path numbers lol who thinks that when u collect your numbers of birth dates.. Like if your life path number is 1 you're creative woahoo! I really want someone to prove for me what the benefit for that and how could if my birthday is 12/5/2000=10, 1+0=1 define that I'm creative and flexible and easy and think out of box!? I may believe in anything else but how could those numbers define my whole personality? :/

Berserk timestamp: 02:35

I could a sworn it was a proven fact how the moon does cause human behavior of the least .. also most terrible crimes are noticed to be committed under a full moon as well but if I’m wrong I’m wrong .. i definitely can’t go against my guy Tyson

I mean the universe does care for us…. Food and oxygen? Like yea Science but also mystery.

I'm a natural skeptic, but also with an open mind. Personally, I do believe that much of the nay-saying against astrology comes from the fact that most people who claim to be 'experts' are not. They are either snake oil salesmen or good-intentioned people who REALLY want to believe and thus fall into causation = correlation beliefs. ..."the stars/planets predicted that some specific type of catastrophe will happen on day X, and LOOK! there was a bomb that went off somewhere, so that 'proves' that astrology 'works'. This is, indeed, BS. On the other hand, I'm also of the persuasion that if it IS a pretty well-known scientific fact that our moon has, at a minimum, an effect on our physical environment in tidal cycles, I also don't think that it's too far-fetched to admit that the moon, (and possibly other planets), may have some effect on humans as well. There have been times when I've felt unusually anxious, or angry, or even calm and peaceful, ...in other words NOT myself, and wondered what the F is going on, and later learned there was a full moon at that time. Also, I had heard the what I considered for a long time a 'wive's tale' of ER rooms and police calls ramped up during fool moons, and always took this with grain of salt, until my sister who is a very no-nonsense and an RN specializing in neurological trauma (i.e. brain injuries and the like) mentioned that she'd better get some rest because it's close to a fool moon and her work load always goes up. Before letting her go, I asked her to pause for a moment to verify that, as a trauma nurse, ...that the full moon thing is real. In so many words she said, yes. She doesn't understand how it works, but that yes, the few days around full moons do generally mean an pretty predictable increase in patients admitted with serious, in her case, brain injuries. ...Usually from either accidents caused by other people, or stupid behavior of the patients themselves. Aside from astrology, but on the subject of the esoteric in general, in my younger days, I used to dabble in Tarot cards. I'd never read for anyone else, as I didn't feel I was expert enough, but would 'out of fun', do readings for myself, with a seed of doubt and recognition that I may 'see' only what I want to see, or even the opposite, being reading too much into my own personal fears. That was until one day, I had a pretty important and life changing question and did a one card draw. ..that's where you simply shuffle the cards and draw one card. ........ I drew the same card 21 times in a row, shuffling every time in between every draw. After the first few times of getting the same card, I shuffled several times, and still got the same card. I repeated, asking the same question, and still.... EVERY TIME, got the same card, every time. 21 times. I likely could have gone even longer, but that's when I said 'okay, I get it', and stopped. Then to test if the cards themselves might have been sticky or if there was something else going on, I then asked some other random questions, and then I did not get the same card. I looked up the statistics of getting the same card 21 times in a row out of 72 card deck, and it came back as pretty much impossible. After years of being alive, I have also figured out that I pick up on other people's emotions and anxiety. Even before I thought this was a thing that could happen, I remember sitting in a college class one day, feeling fine, but suddenly out of nowhere, feeling massive panic, and an urge to run out of the room. I was fighting with myself, wondering where the hell this came from and wondering ... should I follow my 'gut' and run out of the room or not, when a student on the other side of the classroom stood up and ...ran out of the room. He came back after several minutes, with a waft of the worst kind of diarrhea still clinging to himself and his clothing. If you are still reading, you may be asking yourself why I went to the trouble of writing this lengthy post. It is because I have MAD respect for science, and those who devote their lives and careers to science. Even knowing that science is not always perfect (and bless good scientists for knowing this as well - it's always improving), I would bet my life on the expertise of a scientist over knuckle-dragging doubters in social media or comment sections any day. That being said... much like if a person from today traveled back in time to even about 500 years ago, and said that one can create light by flipping a switch on a wall, or that people can immediately communicate with nearly anyone on the planet with a small device in their pocket, ... they likely would have been burned at the stake. We have satellites, we have radio frequencies, ...we send info in ways that are beyond my numskull understanding, but it works somehow. ...And it's all based on physics. One thing I think that even the mos ingenious scientists forget, is that Humans are .... still made up of the stuff of physics. Our entire molecular structure is made up of the entire history of, not just this planet, but other planets and stars ---even and especially those that are now long gone, and 'dead'. We are beautiful and unique, and SO BLESSED to be on this planet. But what many people forget, is that we are still animals, and tied to and rely on the minerals and even in the case of fossil fuels, the death of other animals that came before us. Birds rely on magnetic or other frequencies of the earth to know where to migrate to, that us weeee humans of the earth are not tuned into. It's not magic or witchcraft. They feel the pull of the earth, and act in accordance to their survival needs. In sum, dismissing that there is absolutely nothing to any of the 'witchy' practices such as astrology or resonant energy of distant planets (yes, even the dead ones) is a bit lazy, or at least disingenuous.

Your intelligence is very limited to take into account all the co-relations of millions of combinations of the planets and stars . You are a fool to limit your observation based on a few observations which human intelligence can perceive , not human I would say your limited knowledge could gather

Actually if you're reading this, go and check your Vedic Sun sign and see if that connects more with your outer personality.

5th October is Virgo, NDT's birthday and Sun sign, according to Vedic astrology. Not Libra as the false, Western chart implies - make of that what you will.

It's incredible what people still believe in.

Yea all the people saying it’s fake are the same people who has never Tom time out there day to do research on it or anything spiritual or supernatural. Find out before lying to yourself and other. Astrology is real and much more than that is real but these people will never know. I have literally witness so many supernatural things that led me to believe astrology. It’s not just oh I’m a Virgo and that’s it nooo it’s much deeper. They don’t want to believe it so they won’t find out the truth.

Neil is one of the dumbest people.. I can’t respect a man who has a degree studying something he ha sbever been to. As far as any of us are concerned. All these giant gas balls are fictitious. Ya know? Like, has he ever talked about thenobserver effect? I’m super curious. Cause I think it should be widely spread that sending a message all those light years away and how long it takes us to receive something is actually….when we observe the whatever. Not light years. Not millions blah blah. It is that moment. There’s nothing out there cause no one is there for there to be something. Simple. But complicated cause it’s quantum physics. We still haven’t even passed the van alien radiation belt, go look it up. NASA don’t know hot safely. Yet we did it back then in the 70s 60s whatever? With more primitive technology and Apollo 13 dudes had zero health issues? My dudes. Logic needs an iOS update. Does a tree fall in the woods and no one is here to listen, does it make a sound? The answer is no. Debate settled. If no one conscious is there to observing the space doesn’t technically exist. It’s just info 1 and 0s. Truth is stranger than fiction. But finally I’d like to hear how he feels about his fictions ideas of space and how he above all feels about destroying the Hawaii mountain all to make his big number get bigger. How does he sleep at night?

no, we learned that living crystals align our chakras not to mention crystals have electrical frequency

The planetary configurations effect solar actvity. Solar activity effects us.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Astrology is an interesting topic because it's an observation of correlation. The association of certain archetypes with times of year and other planetary cycles is just fascinating. To dismiss it outright is hubris. The ancient people weren't dumb, they simply didn't have a hindsight of all the information, data, and knowledge we managed to achieve and record in our archives today. If you presented ancient astrologists with modern astronomy they would be only more certain of many of their ideas. Then again, Neil isn't particularly known for being humble or intelligent.

I disagree. Neil just needs to learn the science!!! Ask Fauci!

"The opinion of 10,000 men is of no value if none of them knows anything about the subject." - Marcus Aurelius

It was actually 3 & half minutes he just kindly waited for his turn to speak for a little bit

Its like playing with cheat codes or playing by the rules - nothing wrong with either Just dont complain when you are losing or havent completed a level or task !! On time or years later

Neil Degrasse Tyson is a great example of humans lack of humility. But I appreciate his perspective.

I know what confuses people even me is that if we do our chart it seems so accurate. Sure there's a lot of psychology involved with confirmation bias and core beliefs and they say we all could relate to any sign or much of it. But have you tried to read someone elses different than yours to know ? Or just compare yourself to another human. Could we all have the exact same personalities? ..🤢 sure wr all have the same feelings and traits but not all to the same degrees. Many people just really do seem to be as their stars say mostly. Astrology aside.. we are all star stuff. We are all one and all connected. To say science hasnt proved something can be ridiculous itself as its saying nobody knows more than science. But science isnt some entity of its own its lots of people using a another incomplete system. We always find out more. Even the chat gpt ai bot agrees the principles of hermetic philosophy can actually be truth and that science just yet doesnt know... because WE DONT TRY TO PROVE WHAT WE DONT WANT TO. It all costs money and the purse is restricted isnt it. So every institution is controlled and limited. Some scientists may agree with astrology 🤷🏼 same as some sort of believe in some of the bible somehow even if SYMBOLICAL. Everything is symbols on this planet and magic ✨ be-LIE-f systems.. ( physics in action ) brand names and logos etc.. .we imagine a thing in our minds.. we then manifest it physically.. Science proves mind over matter with the placebo effect. LIES can HEAL.. the TRUTH can destroy again.. though also funnily enough it doesnt always.. so then science knows more about belief than religous people.. truly ironic paradoxes.. explained in hermetics also. Hermetic says ALL IS MIND.. the universe is mental. This is profound.. as I said even Ai chat bot was able to reason with me if i asked it to just speculate and stop mentioning " but science doesnt support this ". 😅. Then it says SURE ! yes it is reasonable and science may not yet know enough... Your perspective is very interesting etc it even explains why its reasonable comparing it with what we know in physics. Also its already been aired lately that we have new information on laws of physics ...this is because of all the UFO UAP business...new crafts they make.