I think she was just nervous, like I sing a lot too and when I'm nervous, I can't breath so well, so the notes get shorter and more shakey and I feel like thats kinda what happend here too, at least it seems that way to me <3

Yes, very thin and trembly, not enough breath support. She was probably very nervous

@@einfachnursilvi9382 I am the same way as a fellow Soprano..but still ..I've always loved her..

I wish I can hit those high notes so clearly like hers but I’m frankly not a trained opera singer.

Opino igual. Las artistas de teatro tienen una voz mucho más fuerte y aunque son excelentes, no transmiten esa dulzura e ingenuidad que Christine se supone que tiene.

With good reason

Emmy is actually my favorite Christine. I can tell she sounded nervous in the screen test and was a little shakey. Her voice was much better in the actual movie. Remember Sarah brightman was in her 30s during phantom Emmy was only 17 here!

@@ericac88 And she performed like a 17 year old. Her acting greatly improved later, but that does nothing to save the movie.

@@ericac88 And Sarah Brightman was 26 when she performed in the Phantom.

​@@RebekkaJensenJust the actors who play Christine Daae on stage like Broadway or West End.

Agreed completely! I didn’t even realize she was so young!

The character is supposed to be nervous anyway at the beginning.

No kidding! Such a better singer than Emma Watson.

I think Anne Hathaway would be an amazing Belle, but Emmy is second in my book.

That's what I'm saying!!! I can't believe they took her into consideration and STILL chose Emma.

@@melissajohnson8050 I love Anne, but she was way too old for the role

100! Would have been such a better choice.

Yes plus she was like 16, the other actresses are normally 25 or something, once I saw someone comparing her with Sierra, and it's clear that Sierra is an amazing singer but she was like 29 when she played the 25th anniversary and her profession was musical theater while Emmy was a teenager and was in cinema

@@maggieaishalee3829 Emmy was 18 in this film but still , it’s very impressive .

Compare the two what?? She is 16 and everyone who played this character was 35. Anyone can be a great anything at the age of 35.

@@felixthecat2786 many people like to compare every actress with Sierra Boggess

@@maggieaishalee3829 I don’t know what age has to do with this. Age doesn’t equal skill level. Emmy was perfect for the role WHEN SHE WAS CAST. And that’s apparent because she was cast. I don’t understand how I made this post talking about the difference of singing for screen vs. stage. And it still turned into a skill conversation.

It sounds like it’s been edited up a half step which makes her voice sound higher. This ends on a B natural and the original key/key in the movie ends on a B flat. On Broadway they eventually moved it to a C but I’ve never heard this key used before. The key change and the voice quality difference makes it seem pitched up.

@@RileyKmusicsurprisingly, this is Rossums natural singing voice. She wasn’t edited in this tape.

@@animationflow1055 Do you have a source? This video sounds pitched to avoid copyright, and when you edit it down so the song is in the right key she sounds like she did in the movie.

🤡

Something's wrong with you.

i dont get it their voices sound so good sure theyre not professional ive seen the actual play and it was obviously better but the movie and the songs are GREAT especially since gerard butler wasnt even familiar with singing he tired his best and he did well , i guess i can see why you wouldnt like his voice , i do , but Emmy did incredibly well and as for the movie. id like to hear some of your reasonings as to why its so bad , sure has its flaws , but i enjoyed it a LOT thats why i also watched the play too.

Get out

Why are you so rude and mad?😆 This movie is a masterpiece!!!!!