Gwyneth's is the best.

Gwyneth Paltrow is my favorite. The sparks that fly between her and Jeremy Northam always intrigued me. And you can feel the sting of his rebuke to her spirit. They were a well-matched pair.

I think if i could put 2020 Knightly with 2009 Emma...I'd have my perfect version of this scene. 👒

I have always held Jeremy Northam’s Knightley in my heart as the best. He does speak to her a little more fatherly but he does emphasize in the film that he considers himself much older than she. The new Emma with Johnny Flynn just gave me a whole new perspective. He is fascinating to watch and his interpretation is completely different.

Both Bingley sisters behave this way every day and no one slaps them on the wrist.

my Elizabeth Bennet was composed through this encounter

Typical Austen in a nutshell. The poor should attract compassion rather than contempt? How about the right to respect between human beings! That disregard for equality, or the blithe attempt to make entertainment of pompous, artificial mannerisms, is what Austen either missed entirely or happily made money out of. She knew nothing about the really poor and the need for decency. Give me Gaskell every time.

Sadly her behaviour in this fictional depiction is very prevalent in real life today a lot of people could do with the same dressing down just because it can be said should it.

Every clip I see of the 2020 version underlines what utter drivel it was.

2009 version is the best

Eu li esse livro... Há eras atrás. Fará falta o Jô... ❤

Eu tenho o anime de Paradise Kiss... ❤

Eu queria o mangá de Hana Yori Dango... 🥰❤

Adoro você, Valéria! Te acompanho desde a revista Neo Tokyo, que eu colecionava todos os fascículos... ❤

I am for the Beckinsale version. Both look and sound very noble, like a lady and a gentleman. The others look cheap and clumsy. The last one seems a parody.

Quando eu penso em detetive que não quer se envolver no mistério por conta de preguiça só penso em Hyouka. Esse anime é muuito bom.

Muito obrigado por me apresentar essa obra. Tenho que ler um dia.

Shoujocast sempre maravilhoso! Ah, Valéria, como eu queria Hagio Moto aqui no Brasil, mas numa edição igual a da Fantagraphics Books XD Obrigada por todas as informações. Achei super interessante esse mangá todo colorido da Yumi Tamura, vou procurar!

Essa coisa do laço me lembrou uma cena da minissérie Chiquinha Gonzaga, onde a protagonista já bem mais velha andava pela rua usando laços de fita no cabelo e a personagem da Suzana Vieira arrancava o laço e fazia piada com isso, como se fosse mesmo algo muito juvenil e puro.

Aliás, sobre detetive, te recomendo Yukoku no Moriarty, mangá e anime. É uma besteira, mas diverte ao colocar o vilão como centro da narrativa

Eu conheci essa obra através do J-Drama que é ótimo, por sinal. E corri para o mangá em scan. Gosto como ele é sério e psicológico, mas tem seus momentos de humor com o jeito cínico do Totonou. Gosto como a autora humaniza as situações complexas da obra, e para mim, não fica pedante ou clichê.

I prefer the 2009 and the 1996 versions of him. In the 2020 film he feels too young for a man that is 38. John Lee Miller may also look younger but for me he is a better fit than the newest version of my favorite austen men. In 2020 he surely shows more emotions but for me that doesn't fit. I love Anya taylor joy. She is a perfect Emma. But her Mr. Knightly isn't. John Lee Miller fits the type of serous man with a heart of gold, what's made him a great Edmund Bertram too. And in the version of 1996 he had the right age and hit the right balance between gentleman and sensible human being. But I guess my view of all this versions depends from the time I watched them. I was a teen when I saw the 1996 version and loved Mr knightly instandly. (He also is one good character in a book I struggle with. I don't like Emma that much. I prefer Anne Elliot or Mansfield park.) So it's hard to understand why this to me soft version of him in 2020 is better or as good.

How many movies are there with so many variations, enough to compare them? Emma must be one of the few. For my money I preferred the Mark Strong/Kate Beckinsale, though Johnny Flynn comes a strong second. Gwinneth Paltrow makes me puke. All the men looked like they were enjoying clomping about in their big leather boots.

Johnny Lee Miller and Romola Garai take the cake for me. While I adore Anya Taylor Joy, I felt she was overacting in this scene.

1996

Mark and Kate

i have seen every adaption and my favorite by far and large will forever be the 2009 BBC production. UGH the actors play out the scenes exactly how you would imagine them, its like reading the book! Romola Garai is the best Emma hands down; she IS Emma in that production. I don't know how to describe it, other than she was perfect. Emma is my favorite Jane Austen book and Mr. Knightley is my favorite leading man of hers. personally, I think the handsomest is Johnny Flynn hehe, but there is something to be said on how Jonny Lee Miller portrays Mr. Knightley. All of the adaptions have their own charm but 2009 you have my heart!!! :)

Mark Strong and Kate Beckinsale. He manages to get the age difference without it being creepy. She is thoughtless but capable of remorse. The timing is perfect: just as he turns away she turns back ready to admit her mistake, but it's too late.

👏👏👏

this elizabeth looks too modern and too argumentative. not impressed

2020 is just so perfect

Now I’m even a bigger fan of the 2009 version!

Eu me condenei quando resolvi ler o mangá antes de ver o anime porque devo ter sentido o que as japonesas sentiram e não consigo engolir aquela releitura haha Tenho preocupações com o filme, mas quero só julgar quando ver haha

Acho interessante ser do Mappa que é um dos maiores estúdios atuais. Espero que seja uma boa adaptação, nunca vi a obra original mas estou muito interessada em conhecer o mangá depois de assistir a esse seu vídeo. Parabéns pelo trabalho sempre impecável em falar de shoujo com autoridade :)

Adorei seus comentários! Fiquei mais animada para continuar o mangá e curiosa sobre a animação.

Achei o trailer lindo apesar do CGI!

Quem acha o traço da Chiho Saito feio realmente prova que não existe uma verdade universal ne? Pra mim é um dos traços shoujos mais lindos

Cara se baratearam a produção do anime colocando cgi, acho difícil ter um segundo filme. Pelo menos, fico feliz que tem algo saindo

1996 version with Kate Beckinsale and Mark Strong is the best. Prunella Scales played Miss Bates. In this video, TWO 1996 Emmas were shown. This one and the Gwyneth Paltrow version.

The 2020 Knightley was very good, but the Emma actress is too wooden and petulant. I feel the 2009 version better as she was very understated. I also have a soft spot for Johnny Lee Miller. However, the 1996 version was very good because Emma feels genuinely dressed down and I loved the Knightley scold there.

My favorite Emma has always been the Kate Beckinsale. The 2020 version, which I haven't seen other than this clip, won't be one I watch... primarily becaus Knightly looks to be practically equal in age to Emma. One reply has disliked the 'paternalistic' attitude of Knightly. Well, he held her in his arms when he was 16 and she an infant. A bit of 'I am older and wiser than you' can be forgiven, I think.

Johnny Lee Miller and Romola Garai did such a fantastic job

Seria legal voltar com esse quadro (quando desse tempo) é muito difícil achar informações das autoras de shoujo em português. Adoro seus vídeos

I'm in need of your prayers and support. Please keep me in your thoughts as I navigate my health journey.

Interesting to see all the different performances, I think Sophie Thompson (1996 version) is an excellent actress and for me it’s the best performance. You can feel Miss Bates’s discomfort.

Interesting how Strong is still the complete gentleman, he's holding her arm, puts the step down, and hands her in even as he's taking her to task. Much as I love Northam's portrayal, my favorite, his putting a harsh hand on her to turn her round doesn't feel appropriate either to his feeling for her or her dignity in the view of the drivers.

I loved the Kate Beckinsale one! It was perfect from dialogue delivery to acting! All other scenes feel so ethics not right in them but that 1996 one is perfect! Feels natural

"A Riyoko sempre escala os mesmos atores." Eu te amo, valéria. Dkskzks man pior que eu amo onii-sama ee... ia ser tão feliz se lançasse aqui