I loved this video! Although this evidence was unsupported, most of it makes sense. Although I did not see the connection between Demeter and macavity, and I think that jennyanydots and munkunstrap( due to the fact that Munkunstrap sang a song about jennyanydots), and rum rum tugger and bombulurina, ( due to the fact that they were dancing together in the Jellicle ball) should be together. Also, I see no reason that Jemima(my favorite) would be macavity’s daughter, although she is probably somewhat related to Demeter. If it was me, I would have put her in the ‘adoption zone’ Overall a fantastic video, and I highly appreciate the detailed reasoning. #catfans

I mostly agree with this tree however i feel like ms.Jellylorum is Gus's kid and not his mate,thats about all though Also Mist totally pulled those six cats out of a hat-

Just so you know the actor that played Gus couldn't dance as his joints were not good. So they hired the actor who played asparagus. And they are supposed to be the same person. I'm in a production of cats rn and I play Jemima, love this video!!

I really like your voice :DD You sing so well!

thank you so much for making this! it’s lovely to see someone else freak out about Cats like me! [even though this is from three years ago!]

9:11 I always thought that mistoffolees was part of the same tribe of magic cats that Macavity was part of

7:10 I think the age gap is a bit big and they’re actually father/daughter. The 3 cats singing are 3 generations of the same family.

2:51 what does this mean/gen

HAHAAAAAA IM NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO SAID THAT MACAVITY, MUNSKATRAP, AND TUGGER WHERE RELATED TO OLD DEUTERONOMY AND HOW SEMETER AND MACAVITY DATED, BUT I ACTUALLY DIDNT GUESS THAT JEMIMA WAS THERE CHILD Also, victoria being the child of bustipher and griddlebone is pretty neat

I think that you should watch Jacob Brent's commentary of cats. Your family tree is incorrect.

Senior and Junior. Hint, same name.

They have 2 sets of official artwork and graphic novels... They had plenty of detailed description in plenty of the novels... Why now did Rick choose to prioritize representation?.. After all of the artwork, graphic novels, and all the the character?.. Nobody freaked out when Hazel was Black... When you have established character over 20 years and 15+ books... Changing the physical look for a series under the alleged promise to be accurate and canonically correct is dubious ngl lol...

First! This video made me very nostalgic I miss going on vacation to theme parks ;-; AND I MISS YOU MA'AM

I'm pretty sure the cat you labeled Admetus is called George in the 1998 version as usually Plato IS Admetus and switches names in productions. Although I think having a cat named George is kinda dumb so maybe Admetus is better. 😭😭😭

I personally subscribe to the headcanon that Grizabella is Demeter and Bombalurina's mom tbh, which adds to, like whatever conflict Demeter clearly has regarding her.

I like to think Plato is a secret child of Macavity bc the actor playing him also plays Macavity in the '98 version. He's, like, the ringleader of the other orphan kittens. He knows who his dad is but not his mom and is very angsty and brooding about it.

Sorry to say this. Rum Tum Tugger paired up with Bombalurina, as husband and wife. Don’t paired up with different ages.

Thanks for putting in griddlebone!!!! See they initially were going to have her and growltigers number in the 1998 film but had to cut it for the budget and runtime. However since she’s mentioned as an assistant in macavity’s song I do believe she exists in that universe just on the sidelines, I feel that mention disputes the idea she’s purely fictional. Also in my opinion I see her as a mother/ either biological or adoptive to mungojerrie and rumpleteazer. They’d all be working under macavity, griddlebone probably lead them under that path. They also all are dramatic theatrical cats.

any tree that has misto and tugger as couple is correct. according to me and my non-authority

Wow, how have I not run across this before? I've loved Cats since I was a lil' tot watching the VHS tape of the 1998 performance, but it's only now I'm older that I've noticed the various relationship dynamics going on. Also, seriously, your voice is gorgeous. Your vibrato is so controlled and even! :'O I'm jealous.

Because like a good leader, Munk is humble and wise and puts the attention on the other Jellicles rather than on himself. Notice in the song Magical Mr. Mistoffollees, while Tugger DOES make sure that his Dad knows who is responsible for saving him from Macavity, we see Munkustrap acknowledging Misto, as well, when Munk is hugging his father and they bow to each other. Munkustrap sang the Old Gumby Cat's song....he sang Old Deuteronomy's song....he pays homage to the older and more experienced Jellicles in his clan. As Mufasa (another feline King) so wisely put it..."While others (i.e. Macavity) search for what they can TAKE, a TRUE king searches for what he can give." One of the only GOOD lines they added in the live action version of the Lion King. I DO agree with you that Cassandra is a beautiful queen....I think the reason why she didn't have leg warmers is because she has those beautiful, long legs and they didn't want anything to hide them when she was dancing.

I like the idea of Mistos mom is a fictional character That’s why Misto is magic

Rick doesnt even know the gravity of the words hes using. Racism is denying blacks or other victimised grps socio economic and political rights. And he is just an author who isnt in the field and calls for so called representation in film industry as if it will solve the whole racist problem in society. Its just entertainment and his plot is popular fiction not a social novel. I mean, he has Hazel, Leo, Carter, Piper, Frank and many others for representation. Saying that fans are racist for wanting an accurate appearance is an inadequate understanding of the term racist, and he may or may not be woke or he may or may not be influenced by disney but character appearance should have been a factor during the audition process and not just personality, which I feel that Leah can pull it off so can others who look like Annabeth. And if he says some black people imagined themselves as heroes thats just an individual aspiration, not because they wanna represent their community. I hated the movies for its plot (altho casting and bgm was better) and i expected pjotv to redeem the movies. Now this. I mean I still like his books but I dont want the border bw the book and adaptation to break. And I love making adaptations and Im depressed abt how my fav book couldnt get a proper adaptation. I mean, Rick himself! I admired that guy and suddenly---i prefer a white blonde annabeth and dark hair percy too. What do u ppl say? Shall we push for a refreshing of casting, like after all 5 seasons are over, shall we push more book accurate characters from HOO adaptations onwards? At least, among the 7, there will be a white girl along with a black girl, a native girl, then a dark haired boy along with a blonde guy, a Latino and asian guy...i rly want an accurate adaptation. I was disappointed with Rick changing the plot in Episode 5 too. Sure, to make an adaptation you can change somethings, but where did Hera's chair come from? Why is Hermes is Lotus Casino? Why should Hephaestus be there? Even the plot is somewhat going off rails. We need to do it better at least with HOO. No hate to the actress

How the heck do you have the exact same opinions as me

This woman almost broke her hand patting herself on the back about what a super, amazing, progressive, and ever so virtuous person she is. Everything she has to say is disgustingly boring, actually racist, and utter phony bullshit.

Unfortunately that poor child will have to pay and suffer and live through the hatred of others it’s inevitable. You cannot stop the hatred of the world anymore then you can stop natural forces like Gravity. You cannot change the world and others opinions That girl must bare a great weight responsibility pressure burden Consequences for the decisions that adults made I just hope that child understands and knows what she’s facing what she agreed to what she signed up for Because it’s just going to get worse and worse for her Their beef is not with the girl their beef is with Rick and Disney they are using the girl to get to him And they don’t care if it’s a child

i dont care what colour she is, from the first three episodes shes: not well characterised and not well acted. same goes for most of the others with the exception of dior goodjohn as clarisse who is atleast a good actress

Moar! CATS! Pleez?

I _need_ to be friends with you.

This was such an amazing vlog with top notch editing! Great job capturing the exact same feelings from the trip, best vlogger! It was epic singing with you and Zach in the back of the car singing Man or Muppet plus BTR!!! - THE Flower Girl

I love how Brian is just suffering from an aneurysm in the background 11:05

I'm so upset I wasn't able to be there myself, but I absolutely loved seeing this vlog and it made my heart so happy. I love you guys so much 💙

I am so so so glad that you were able to film so much of this precious weekend, and even more thankful that you stood next with me while I married THE Bustin :’) I love you so much this video was so well made and I agree with Anna, the transition using Zach’s piano playing was IMMACULATE ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ I LOVE YOU BEAUTIFUL WOMAN

10:10 He did not say that and i will not answer any questions until my lawyer gets back to me

I am so honored you used my piano playing during the table montage. Loved being there for Elijah’s big day! -Ring Bearer

Currently watching but I have to ask before I forget why you have a pizza coupon from 1988

Rose!! This was so well made and made me very emotional since you included a lot of major moments during the trip ;-; Also amazing touch including Zach playing the piano while filming certain shots!

I don't know how you crammed all of this into 15 minutes and still made it absolutely gorgeous you are the vlog queen now and forever, I can never compete!

having zach’s piano playing over the montage of the beautiful decorations was like such a nice touch omg

FIRST

Still revisit this now and then. Thank u rose. ❤

my mom has this game

imagine jk rowling making hermione black 🤣🤣🤣🤣

I AGREE 100%! Also your voice is very beautiful! Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer were ON POINT!

You have the same motivation to make videos I do

STOP. SINGING.

this video is actually so frustrating. its only munkustrap fighting macavity because munkustrap is the protector of the tribe. not rum tum tugger. and rum tum tugger literally brings up mistofelees as a solution to old dute being kidnapped.

"am I just hating on the actor?" YES. YES YOU ARE. because gus and asparagus are THE SAME CAT he wasn't really allowed individuality

in all other productions of cats, asparagus and gus are the SAME. its the same actor. they just didn't do it in 1998 because of jon mills' cameo. also, the naming of cats makes it VERY clear no 2 cats can have the same name.

ASPARAGUS AND GUS ARE LITERALLY THE SAME CAT. ITS THE 2ND LINE OF THE SONG