superyoshiom

Пікірлер

@opalskycanvas 20 күн бұрын

Homura wants Madoka to choose desire, to break the rules, and to care about herself more than than the needs of the rest of the world

@Eliz418 Ай бұрын

I honestly think the ending was perfect, not silly. Not all endings need to be happy. Besides, this makes perfect sense for Homura's character. You think after all that she has been through she would just accept Madoka's wish?

@コミヤツグミ 2 ай бұрын

ひょっとして今のまどかとほむらの力って同等だったりするのかしら神にも等しい存在と悪魔という違いはあるけど。

@短得嘿 3 ай бұрын

Worst good ending 😢

@pluswig 3 ай бұрын

what’s the song

@PTCLegacy777 4 ай бұрын

Madoka ALMOST goes god mode again!

@Andimooo 4 ай бұрын

the fact that madoka and homura are destined to be enemies now breaks my heart :( when that happens its going to be a sad day for the lesbian community

@Miyoshi-Rei 4 ай бұрын

0:38 I’m trying to understand this part because I’ve been thinking about it a lot (about why Homura hugged Madoka). Just feel like there’s something to it.

@Eliz418 Ай бұрын

Homura hugged her because she was trying to prevent Madoka from remembering her divinity

@Grenat 4 ай бұрын

okay if anyone comes here (well) after Walpurgisnatch Rising trailer, i just have an idea i thought about the first time i saw this scene and then i think gets stronger with the trailr and poster of PMMM:WR. get ready, it gets sad. i think this scene is a full display that we, the audience, need to come to the conclusion that the original personnality of Homura, the one that loved Madoka, is gone. leaving a personnality where she is obssesed with Madoka but more importantly, wth herself, her ideal world where Madoka is hers. seen by the final lines "you will become my enemy, but i don't care, because even then, i will continue to wis for a world in which you will be happy" but we and Homura aren't even sure if Madoka IS happy really this grandiose labirynth of Homura's desires, she doesn't seem very happy to not be in her new role, and she said she don't like when someone breaks rules just because they feel like it. but i think the most telling part is when Homura gives back OG Madoka the ribbon she gave to OG Homura, when Homura LOVED Madoka, it was her ultimate reminder, her ultimate symbol of love, and she give it back to a Madoka that will not love Homura anymore (i think) so Homura just, lost, she lost everything, her original self and Madoka, but this Homura is also dangerous, not only because of her powers, but because of her new personality, more focused on control then ever before. in conclusion, or a tl:dr ; Homura giving back the ribbon to Madoka is basically her last send off of everything she was in the original show/most of Rebellion, she is now just, the Devil, not even Homura

@shaneokeley825 5 ай бұрын

That's pretty much some people's reaction to the end of Attack on Titan

@CupOfConfetti 5 ай бұрын

Homura walked so that the Scarlett WItch can run

@balladofthegoddess 6 ай бұрын

I love how even the slightest bit of deja vu can unravel all of homura's work. Remember kids, there isnt a single universe where devil homura is stronger than ultimate madoka

@Stormtide 7 ай бұрын

I know the uploader of this video will never see this comment, and I absolutely do not mean to imply that I am invalidating their opinion by saying this, nor am I hating on them, but I really wish they hadn't said the ending was "silly." That implies (at least to me) that the negative opinion of the ending was emotionally charged, as opposed to logically understanding the reasoning behind it. Not all stories will have good endings, and while I think this one will eventually have a good ending, I for one was perfectly content with this movie's ending. Acceptance of a logical ending over a happy ending is an important ability to have. Homura was never going to be content with abandoning her duty as Madoka's protector and allowing herself to be saved by the Law of Cycles, not to mention the fact that she hates herself more than ever before, so she most definitely does not believe she deserves such a good fate. This is a movie about an individual. No one on an individual level is a perfect person, protagonists no less, they should not be put up on a pedestal as always perfect people who make perfect decisions. This movie is realistic about its characters, not idealistic. It's not afraid to hold back on the different aspects of Homura's personality and her values. How do you judge a person and their actions? "Good" and "bad" are such vague words. While we can strive to be better people, inevitably individuals will stray from that for whatever reason. Who are we to judge? We cannot assume they've had the same experiences as us. This movie's protagonist is not a "good" or "bad" individual. Just an individual. It's not a hero or villain story. That's for the viewer to decide, if at all. This is but a crude description of the motives behind this movie and its ending, there are much better and more thorough explanations out there by more well read people. I think understanding a movie and the story it's trying to tell do is key before formulating an opinion about it. With that said, I would never argue that this movie is perfect or the best of all time and everyone should love it or that everything it does is "right" and everyone who disagrees with it is "wrong" for feeling that way. That to me is not success of a movie. A movie that makes people discuss and debate, a movie with positive and negative opinions, that to me is a successful movie. After all, from that we can learn about each other and our values, about life and its values. I said I wish the uploader hadn't called the ending "silly" but that doesn't mean I wish they hadn't criticized it. I wish they had written a more descriptive and specific opinion that shows logical (and emotional!) reasoning, as opposed to one or the other. This would have shown much better understanding, reason and knowledge. Perhaps I would have offered my own opinion regardless, but nonetheless I would respect such an opinion much more.

@直子藤本-f3w 8 ай бұрын

このシーン個人ほむらとまどか二人友達同士百合切ない関係ね個人❤

@brittanyfindley9177 8 ай бұрын

Homura: way did you make me do this! I'm doing this for you're happiness Homura: think madoka you're become a concept you won't be remembered by everyone not even the people you love Homura: what will you have left after an eternity Madoka: you homura I still have you

@直子藤本-e8f 9 ай бұрын

このシーンほむらとまどかこの二人切ない百合

@AbelNightroad26 9 ай бұрын

La parte de Patricio y Bob Esponja estaba demás, pero creo que puedo eliminarla con un buen editor de video.

@藤本菜々美-u7v 9 ай бұрын

このシーン個人ほむらとまどか二人切ない百合好き大好き❤

@imthecoolestguyalive 11 ай бұрын

"I guess I do think it's kind of bad to break the rules because you feel like it." - This kinda shatters my heart into a million pieces. Homura has sacrificed so much for Madoka, and now has to live with the fact that one day, they will be enemies. And Madoka, clueless of it all, tells Homura to her face something that only reinforces this, even if it's meant to be an answer to her question. It's a vague enough answer, where it makes sense given the question, but at the same time pours and pound of salt into Homura's wounds. Poor girls.

@vitorhenriquefarias8916 Жыл бұрын

about the description they did continue the series with this movie and also it's funny how back when this movie first released people didn't like this ending till a few years later

@isauldron4337 Жыл бұрын

Because it's a huge cliffhanger?

@CorralSummer 8 ай бұрын

It was mixed. Some people hated it and some people liked it. I think over time it has gained more favor as more people have come to understand it.

@mtwall5933 Жыл бұрын

Homura thought she was remembering her godhood but really Madoka was opening up about her DeviantArt Werewolf OC she roleplays as

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

Did you look at the new trailer of the new Madoka Sequel film yesterday? Coming in 2024!

@TheGreyParse Жыл бұрын

It goes to show the sheer scale of how powerful Madoka is to start to unravel the illusionary world Homura created with nothing but a pondering thought. And even worse for Homura, is that she wouldn't even be nearly that powerful in the first place if she hadn't looped the timeline so many times over the course of the main series.

@bardfall9555 Жыл бұрын

Is a happy ending (for the reality that is as the existence of 'God' and 'Devil' solve the problem of entrophy) Is bitter sweet and ironic because kyuubi achieve his goals but was rewarded with eternal suffering Homura solve the main villian that keep causing suffering and managed to obtain a normal and fufilling life but now she is more than a mortal so is madoka (from here i suspect just like the first part of this movie who know the number of cycles homura have been living a normal and fufilling life with madoka) The nature of devil is indulgence in desire Perhaps shegot bored of repeating the normal and fufilling mortal life with madoka and want to let go of her control over madoka which result in her subconciously guiding madoka to recover.

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

More info about Walpurgisnacht Rising on Sep 10!

@akira_ariga Жыл бұрын

This scene just harks back to one of the timelines, with homura turning around the same way, madoka delivering an answer in a similar way, and I love that

@Carolzinha642 Жыл бұрын

Accepted this ending immediately.

@donaldtse6995 Жыл бұрын

the spongebob suddenly pop-out almost ruined the atmosphere of the video😂

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

There's gonna be sequel after Rebellion. The story continues in Walpurgisnacht Rising.

@Jli2-x9l Жыл бұрын

Pucci and emporio be like

@JabamiLain 2 жыл бұрын

I think Madoka, deep down, does remember. She just...chooses not to come out yet.

@literallyme6365 2 жыл бұрын

Being Homura is suffering

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

There's gonna be a sequel after Rebellion. The story continues in Walpurgisnacht Rising.

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

There's gonna be a sequel after Rebellion. The story continues in Walpurgisnacht Rising.

@rice2cu5881 2 жыл бұрын

This is actually my favorite scene from rebellion. Everything about it is so wonderfully done. The way the music builds into the big moment, the ribbon symbolism, the fact it's a parallel scene of the hallway scene in the main series, and the subtext behind what they say, it's all wonderful.

@reyannhansen2852 2 жыл бұрын

This scene shows that Homura now has the power to change the whole universe, but the one thing she CAN'T change is Madoka. Sad

@mesugakichama 2 жыл бұрын

Well... I think her power derives from her 😌

@10054 Жыл бұрын

@@mesugakichama It does, actually. Because her only wish was to be strong enough to protect her. She became strong because Madoka was strong.

@ahmadnurruddinzainori8648 2 жыл бұрын

See you guys after movie 4

@heroboygamebase2286 Жыл бұрын

There's gonna be sequel after Rebellion. The story continues in Walpurgisnacht Rising.

@ahmadnurruddinzainori8648 2 жыл бұрын

That ending with Patrick was unexpected lol

@lorebleh 2 жыл бұрын

the red thread symbolizes a lot, souls that are destined to be together forever, right? or... something like that... I don't know... I lived on gacha sorry and madoka has the red ribbons in her hair, right? at the end of the anime, she gives her tapes to homura, who was the only thing left of madoka's existence, surviving from the recreation of the world and the universe Which means they're meant to be together or something... and at the end of rebellion, homura returns madoka's ribbons what can symbolize that homura thinks she doesn't deserve madoka's love they don't deserve to be together because homura thinks what she did was wrong, worthy of a villain so she now acts like she's a villain and who doesn't deserve madoka's love.

@esthererica7406 2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I think that's quite obvious. The red thread is often called "red thread of fate" which means two people are destined soulmates and are connected to each other for lifetime. Homura giving back the ribbon could symbolize the cutting of the thread, thus separating her from Madoka. In the epilogue scene, there's also a ribbon tying the window where Madoka used to reach out to Homura before witching out. That also could symbolize Homura denies any hope/salvation or fate itself is preventing her from getting saved this time. I'm scared for Homura's fate now. Hopefully she doesn't die if Madoka is ever saved and brought back to life in the end.

@lorebleh 2 жыл бұрын

@@esthererica7406 everything I want is them to be happy. God, they are just teenagers, they didn't need to suffer what suffered.

@owenspice 3 жыл бұрын

ive found my calling

@alfonsovallejo2665 3 жыл бұрын

I fucking cried on this scene, you can feel Homura's pain on the guts.

@luisgalvan8963 3 жыл бұрын

1:30 Homura: "...then i suppose someday, you will become my enemy as well. But i don´t care, because even then, i will continue to wish for a world in which you will be happy..." Me: "OMG!!! Madokami vs DeviHomura. I would love see that" MADOKA REBELION SEQUEL has been announce for Fall 2021 Me: Whaaaaattt??!!!! the hype is rising!!!

@iratepirate3896 3 жыл бұрын

The first time I saw Rebellion I was torn over my feelings for it, but every rewatch improves it. What an utterly fantastic ending. The promise of an inevitable collapse to what Homura has built leaving things open ended, but her love fulfilled at least for the moment.

@josearmandovalenciayoga 2 жыл бұрын

Same here

@TheWickedWizardOfOz1 2 жыл бұрын

Fulfilled is one way to put it, but even she knows that it's a hollow joke. That just makes it all the more tragic. Her perfect little world is imperfect before it even begins.

@ms.pirate Жыл бұрын

But the series isn't over

@iratepirate3896 Жыл бұрын

@@ms.pirate And that's a good thing!

@brupts7297 Жыл бұрын

@@iratepirate3896 WAKEY WAKEY WE GOT A NEW TRAILER AHHHHHHHHH

@MuzzySkeleton 3 жыл бұрын

Being meguca is suffering

@Moe_jun 3 жыл бұрын

This is a sad ending for me... Eventually Madoka will remember everything, and not only her, the other girls too, and when that moment comes everything Homura wished for, this world, will dissapear. When they recover their memories Homura will be the villian..

@rox_do_ur_animations 3 жыл бұрын

notice how golden is the color of gods’ blood and red - is of humans’. by redoing Madoka’s hair and replacing the yellow ribbon with a red one, Homura shows how she doesn’t accept Kaname as a god. idk just found it kinda symbolic, maybe it’s not what the creators were going for

@nanatsu_kingvendedordepao7116 Ай бұрын

probably it was since since madoka magica has a lot of religious theme stuff