Пікірлер
@christopherbowden4870
@christopherbowden4870 2 күн бұрын
Interesting name I got to check it out
@nathalie468
@nathalie468 19 күн бұрын
this book was literally painful to read for me because it was so sad and so intense 😭
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 19 күн бұрын
I'm still recommending it to people who are looking for a book that will make them feel something. It sticks with you when you're done too
@DulKyoujiAnime
@DulKyoujiAnime 29 күн бұрын
Since this video recording is dated, do you still find yourself in a reading slump atm? I think i heard about this book sometime ago but i already had a full palette of books. I think i still want to try this out.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 29 күн бұрын
I am not in a reading slump anymore! It did take a while, though. I had a lot of personal life stress that made it so I couldn't really focus on fictional worlds and by not reading for joy it made the personal life stress harder to manage but I'm reading a LOT now. I went from 1-4 books in a month to 1-3 in a week. I finished 13 books last month. (Several audiobooks) I definitely think the love this book has is not unwarranted, the sheer number of people who recommend it it feels like it has to be up there but it just didn't fit what I needed from it when I read it. I hope you enjoy lit when you get around to it! I might give it another whirl in a year or so so I can forget what happened and see if a different head space makes a better experience
@DulKyoujiAnime
@DulKyoujiAnime 23 күн бұрын
@SammiShane oh okay. Well good luck with that and glad to see you reading. Hope someday that I can digest literature at a pace like yours but I'm enjoying the ride. 👍🏿
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 23 күн бұрын
Enjoying the ride is what it's all about!!
@MrRosebeing
@MrRosebeing Ай бұрын
In fairness, you're not wrong. I've always favoured telekinesis personally.
@DulKyoujiAnime
@DulKyoujiAnime Ай бұрын
This is an interesting topic. I tend to find times when reading that there are details added to the setting that take away from the main theme (and character action) that's currently happening. I think when done smartly it adds with what's happening (thematically) like in The Great Gatsby (for example). Thanks for the discussion.
@mckennaraulston6173
@mckennaraulston6173 2 ай бұрын
I recommend Once A Monster by Robert It's a retelling about the Minotaur
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 2 ай бұрын
Adding it to my list! Thank you!
@anastasiamalinska5118
@anastasiamalinska5118 2 ай бұрын
Can’t wait to read your book ❤
@Rue245
@Rue245 2 ай бұрын
Did you ever get the acknowledgements ? I’m listening to this in 2024 and that section would definitely explain most of your feelings. 😊
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 2 ай бұрын
I definitely may have picked up a copy at the store and read the acknowledgements then put the book back on the shelf. It definitely feels more like it's a fictionalized memoir more than an independent fictional story. Nothing wrong with that I just consider the writing of memoirs and fiction novels very differently
@A350Airways
@A350Airways 3 ай бұрын
And I was, like, finally, a book where the star football player isn't a quarterback! That, even though I read a few books where the star football player didn't completely suck academically before...
@tiamorton1927
@tiamorton1927 3 ай бұрын
Very well said and much needed conversation! Thank you for using your platform for good ❤ Free Palestine, Congo, Sudan, and all oppressed people across the globe
@idk-dz
@idk-dz 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for talking about this! A lot of booktubers refused to talk about P.alestine on their channel earlier this year because they 'only' talk about books, but then they release reading vlogs about The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes and keep talking about how sad it is that these fictional kids are dying and keep talking about the politics in the book.
@usernotfound13
@usernotfound13 3 ай бұрын
Well they’re still talking about a book though aren’t they? I don’t understand the obsession with wanting to force random KZbinrs to talk about their opinions on global world events on a public forum. If people don’t want to talk about something horrific going on in the world on their KZbin channel meant for other things then there is nothing wrong with that. Lots of people watch these videos for the content they are used to which in this case is books, not to hear more of the same stuff they can hear in the news and on dedicated KZbin channels that cover it.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 3 ай бұрын
I'm talking about it because I think it's important. Some things are bigger than one person's peace on their platform, especially when a lot of the people who are making videos and entertaining the masses are helping keep the general public's attention off of the terrible things their governments are funding. I genuinely don't think you should have to force someone to speak up about it or to care, I want people who watch my videos to know that I do care and have been caring this whole time. I've been supporting fundraisers, I've been going to protests, I've been reaching out to my representatives and literally begging for ANYTHING. I've been doing what little I have in my power in real life to try and force something to change. But I also have this small platform and I'm not going to pretend to be something I'm not on it because "youtubers don't have to talk about politics". It's not politics. It's people's lives. And people's lives shouldn't be political... but here we are.
@dropofsun92
@dropofsun92 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for making this video!
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for watching and commenting!
@havelahmclat
@havelahmclat 3 ай бұрын
You have freedom to be honest and speak that matters💛
@tehreemsyeda5025
@tehreemsyeda5025 3 ай бұрын
Free palestine!
@jameskellam2980
@jameskellam2980 5 ай бұрын
This is one of the best notebook videos I have ever watched. Great job!
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 5 ай бұрын
Thank you so much!! 💓 💓
@sarahchristinesbookshelf
@sarahchristinesbookshelf 5 ай бұрын
I finished this last night. I don’t think I would want to know the day I die i feel like I would get too in my head. But it did make me feel a lot and made me want to do more with my life
@Don_C06
@Don_C06 6 ай бұрын
This was a fun video
@yeshechoden
@yeshechoden 6 ай бұрын
YOU ARE MY CHILD. Cinema Studies in a Journalism building, gym = smoothies, the dorm horrors, bars bars bars bars bars, and sports? What are those? Where? I went to Indiana/Bloomington, and I can tell you this video is UNIVERSAL.
@julshearts
@julshearts 6 ай бұрын
YES! I love Abbie Emmons and I got 100 dos and the best Christmas ever in December! I reread them both this past week, and I love the way you went about critiquing it! You did a great job, and I’m def subscribing!
@karenarose13
@karenarose13 7 ай бұрын
I think the only major difference between the worldbuilding between the two books was specifically the timing, when Persephone in a touch of darkness goes to hades’ office the first time after discovering her mark, she “interrupted him before he was going to bed” which it was like afternoon for her, so I assumed he was on a different “time zone” bc of his inhabiting the underworld
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 7 ай бұрын
I definitely felt that, but I don't think I attributed it to a time zone type of situation consciously while I was reading.
@karenarose13
@karenarose13 7 ай бұрын
I read a touch of darkness first and i still had the same reactions! I will say I felt more connected to Persephone bc i read her book first, but the experience was exactly the same for me
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 7 ай бұрын
That's wild! I definitely would have thought that the order of reading them would have made a bigger impact on the individual experience of the story.
@jessicatell4159
@jessicatell4159 7 ай бұрын
I honestly didn't hate the adaptation of ALTA. It wasn't the same as the animation and the writing could have been way better and hope it improves with the next two seasons. But overall I think changing some of the show made it fresh and not exactly the same. I think the overall storyline could have been written better, I think the acting could have been better but the overall picture was ALTA. (To clarify I have been a fan of ALTA since the beginning)
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 7 ай бұрын
I know that there are people who are enjoying it... in my head, I know... and honestly, I'm glad that there are fans who are enjoying it, even when I can't. I think it goes along with the fact that I can't really engage with movies or TV without accidentally putting on my college-education-hat that makes it so difficult for me to just try to enjoy the show when I know that they didn't take the bare minimum steps to make sure that it was as good as it could be. I'm intrigued by the fact that they're giving more screen time to the fire nation, I've seen clips of the funeral scene for Lu Ten that really drew me in but I'm just concerned about the navigation of the other core elements of the story from a narrative perspective. I genuinely can't remember the last movie or TV show that I watched and just experienced as a viewer without having film-school-critiques at the end of it (against my will more often than not). I can't turn that off and the cartoon is doing so many things well that even when I DO have those critiques (and I have many...) it's outweighed by the attention to detail and intention behind the choices even if they aren't carried out in the most effective way.
@stgr6669
@stgr6669 8 ай бұрын
Often there are side characters who are more interesting for me than the main characters are. I'm glad you mentioned that this happens to others too. Every character is the protagonist of his or her own story, obviously, but every character can also be the protagonist for a reader, even if the author hadn't planned it that way. So, I think it's important that your side characters don't disappear without notice. This can leave some readers very disappointed.
@stgr6669
@stgr6669 8 ай бұрын
I think it's important to keep in mind that people first and foremost live their lives and don't think that much about the political system they live in. Unless you or your parents experienced dramatic changes, the politcal system in your country is "absolutely normal". You live in a western democracy, your readers probably too, but if your story does not take place in such a society, you can't watch things through the eyes of a person from today's USA or France or Germany.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 7 ай бұрын
The hard part is navigating keeping your reader in the know and not over explaining to your characters in the world.
@classictechr
@classictechr 8 ай бұрын
Your analysis was very detailed and helped me decide to both listen & read this intriguing book.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 8 ай бұрын
Amazing! I desperately want so many more people to read this book! Tell me what you think about it when you're done 🙂
@havelahmclat
@havelahmclat 8 ай бұрын
Nice job on the insight review.
@korifraziermorgan
@korifraziermorgan 8 ай бұрын
She did great!!! Thanks for the hookup, @havelah!
@Mudaax
@Mudaax 8 ай бұрын
Honestly this book sounds really bad 😭
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 8 ай бұрын
It certainly takes a LOT to get into. The reason I was drawn to it was because I like the idea of a school in a world with magic systems. And a lot of the summaries out there don't point out the whole Main-Character-is-the-fantasy-version-of-a-white-supremacist-at-the-beginning... So I definitely felt like that was an important thing to point out. I certainly have no intention of mimicking the parts of this story that are hugely off putting but those are still inspiring in a way to make sure that I'm NOT doing those things in my own book.
@andrewleyton6689
@andrewleyton6689 9 ай бұрын
I like this explanation some infamous people have caused people to assume They are bad, but this video is really supportive is remembering to split reality from fiction they have to be their own selves, but also flaws. when I did some variants of my avatar I used different things I like but also aspects I might not have used or that I would fully stick with the previous one like more of a part of me is on them instead of all of it.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 9 ай бұрын
I think a self insert is kinda like seasoning. You don't want to use TOO much otherwise it'll be overpowering and the only thing you notice, but if you use the right amount, it makes a well rounded final product. And everyone should know at least a handful of people that they can pull influence from that don't have to be just their one personal self, there's plenty to mix together.
@andrewleyton6689
@andrewleyton6689 9 ай бұрын
true that @@SammiShane
@LanesGrandma
@LanesGrandma 9 ай бұрын
Thank you, I hope to grab this book sometime soon!
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 9 ай бұрын
I hope you like it when you do!
@Asiannaffrierson
@Asiannaffrierson 9 ай бұрын
Hey its a great experience I won camp Nanowrimo as a newbie last year 2023🎉
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 9 ай бұрын
So shockingly rewarding! Hit me with a gamified goal and I'm THRIVING I guess 😅
@cherylm.5106
@cherylm.5106 9 ай бұрын
"Interesting...interesting...interesting...I don't want to say interesting again." 😆Well, I'm very INTERESTED in reading this book after hearing your review. Thank you!
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 9 ай бұрын
Well I'm glad I'm not the only one interested! If you pick it up you should definitely come back and let me know what you think of it
@jacireich1297
@jacireich1297 10 ай бұрын
Love the idea. I make these to put in snowglobe at the end of year all the books I read in that year. My suggestion is to use double sided foam tape. No cutting huge foam board or deal with glue
@SammiShane
@SammiShane 10 ай бұрын
Oooh! I didn't realize there's a such thing as foam tape! Once I run out of foam board that'll be my next method for sure. Unless i can come up with something to use the foam board for before I run out of the ones I've already made
@13sthename
@13sthename 10 ай бұрын
🫶
@CocoButterKisses-c8l
@CocoButterKisses-c8l 11 ай бұрын
I had the same reaction!!! Love this video ❤
@TheDarkAgez
@TheDarkAgez Жыл бұрын
I too felt like the beginning was a little too slow, but once I got into it, I was IN! And I was very aware how much Jessica George is in this book. Even the little things like her naming Maddie's character Jess, the dad's first name is George, her best friend's real last name is Wright, etc. It is very much Jessica's story which isn't bad, but I can feel it.
@kiwifruitkl
@kiwifruitkl Жыл бұрын
Wait... what? Tessa is home-schooled like Abbie Emmons? I have a copy of The Otherworld, and the main character Orca Monroe is homeschooled (presumably by her father) and has never left her lighthouse home-island, referring it to "our world" and the mainland as "the other world". I feel like a lot of authors share a lot of aspects and characteristics with their own main characters, especially if the author comes from an immigrant family and wants to share an immigrant story. That kind of story is usually based on the author's life and personal experiences, and is often very autobiographical. A lot of Overseas Vietnamese authors seem to have grown up during or after the Vietnam war, and they found themselves in a western nation by birth or early immigration; and the stories they write strongly reflect that fact. I feel like writing from personal experience is so much easier because you can go off your memories and emotions, whereas writing from someone else's POV can be much harder to get all the nuances correct. You have to do a lot more research because you are not that person. And if that other person doesn't express himself/herself in English, then you, the author, has to do the translation work as well.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
I completely agree that authors should share aspects of themselves with their characters, I actually made a video about self inserts right after this one because I was intrigued with the degree to which an author should put themselves in the characters. I think that every character in a story should have at least a little bit of the author in it because that's where your source materials come from, but I also think that your main character shouldn't just be YOU (or an idealized version of you). I also read The Otherworld and think that character has MUCH less to do with Abbie than Tessa does. Tessa has the same interests, the same education style background, and a very similar voice-- which I think is highlighted in Abbie doing the audiobook for 100dos and having a cast for The Otherworld. I would say with full confidence that Orca only has homeschooling in common with Abbie (from what she's put out on the internet about herself) and even then, a VERY different form of it. I definitely think Abbie has grown a lot in her leading character development from her first two books. I think that every main character---unless you're writing a memoir---should be NOT yourself. So while the character has some aspects of you- the writer, it should be someone else's POV. I think it creates more interesting, unique characters, and gives more opportunity for development in a way that perhaps the writer hasn't personally had the same motivations to grow in. And my opinion isn't the ~word of god for writing~, it's just where I stand as a reader/writer.
@kiwifruitkl
@kiwifruitkl Жыл бұрын
This girl looks biracial/multiracial cuz in some poses, she looks black and in other poses, she looks white. She just looks like a big mix.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
...thank you?
@robertsutton362
@robertsutton362 Жыл бұрын
I found this novel deeply relatable and ALSO wanted to quit reading it multiple times. My engagement ended after a 5+ year relationship and I did not respond to it well at the time. I did my share of self-destructive behavior. Three years out from that breakup, this book triggered a flurry of toxic emotions. As someone who loves to laugh and joke as a defense mechanism, I found myself chuckling along with the humor but also revisiting a dark period of my life. Very mixed on this one.
@angelaholmes8888
@angelaholmes8888 Жыл бұрын
Will be reading this for fall season 🍁
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
Definitely has the EXACT right vibes
@SC-rf2ro
@SC-rf2ro Жыл бұрын
I don’t understand the hype surrounding this book. It’s awful😢 I wasted an entire month trying to get through this, I finally decided to DNF. It was extremely uninteresting, and boring. Extremely boring This book was terrible
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
Totally fair. I don't think that every book is for every person. There are A LOT of books I've read that are super popular that just do not give me anything to work with. I think this one has to do a lot with feeling connected to the character in some way. Like I've moved across the country a couple times now and I relate to the distance that she has from others because I feel like I run into the same problems but from a different background. If you can't relate to her and want to see her succeed then that's honestly great for you. Its a very real life centric story and some people like their fiction to be BIGGER than real life, I often prefer books with bigger plots/characters/worlds as well. If you're reading for fun you shouldn't have to work for it so sometimes you have to DNF a book.
@sped_up_songs411
@sped_up_songs411 Жыл бұрын
Great review thank you!
@daolin2607
@daolin2607 Жыл бұрын
I'm so excited for my year in Iowa.
@Theghostinyoubedroom
@Theghostinyoubedroom Жыл бұрын
Thank you so much. I was looking at this book and nobody gave a good review of it but you did amazing. Thank you, now i have something to go off of if i want to buy it.😁
@sanghitadey8475
@sanghitadey8475 Жыл бұрын
I loved your advice. So, if i write the story in linear way and then shuffle them , will it work??
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
I can't say it will work perfectly 100% of the time, but I do think shuffling can provide some unique insights into your characters/world/arc. I wouldn't mix scenes up at random but if there are some scenes that could tie together well, or juxtapose nicely, who's to say that they don't belong next to each other? It'd be an interesting exercise anyway, even if it's not the final product.
@ven41618
@ven41618 Жыл бұрын
So sorry about covid. DOn't know why I am here but youth is exuberant.
@momo_genX
@momo_genX Жыл бұрын
I feel like I naturally corrected this by having myself in the work a great deal, but writing different traits spread over a lot of different characters
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
I think thats exactly how you should fix it. You have to write what you know but you don't ONLY know you right? So why not mix and shuffle your traits with others' and see what that makes in the long run.
@SilentTrip
@SilentTrip Жыл бұрын
Thank you the video was helpful
@SorryIcantIhavebookclub
@SorryIcantIhavebookclub Жыл бұрын
Started mine too, last week!
@malakm8143
@malakm8143 Жыл бұрын
Hey I loved your video! Does it also the same thing for writing a comic book? Or a manga?
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
You know, I'm not actually sure! I've never been a good artist so I never really thought about the process behind writing a comic book or a manga. I'd imagine the drafting process would be similar, structurally you would have the visual aspects written out and dialogue separate but I don't know how strict it would be, the way that screenplays are very reliant on their structure/formatting... Very interesting question!
@malakm8143
@malakm8143 Жыл бұрын
@@SammiShane Yes, I also though the same and I want to write it and draw it actually because it is in my mind moving, I can't write a novel, soo I'd try to write it the same way and wait if you have any other thoughts!
@aaronying4989
@aaronying4989 Жыл бұрын
This was so interesting and I really enjoyed watching it! I can relate. I can never just go to the computer and start typing. I also don’t want to think at the computer. So I too keep notebooks and take a lot of notes and journal by hand. I find by the time I flesh out and develop the ideas by hand, the typing is much easier and I can just enjoy the writing then. I found the hard work is done more in these little notebooks.
@SammiShane
@SammiShane Жыл бұрын
I am a big hand-written-process person. It's really refreshing to figure out that part of the process! Like yes, I can just start writing, it just has to be on paper because there is none of the "blank document paralysis" that I get when I'm on the computer. You get the joy of the process and the tangible notebook to look back on as you continue through the process 😍