Man if they ever do a new Star Trek series that would be set during Kirk's time or even during Picard's time this would make a great episode as like when they brought the Enterprise D back as I read people commenting how she deserved better the same should be with this Enterprise as she also deserves better a WHOLE LOT BETTER.

Beautiful. Just, Beautiful. Happy Star Trek Day. LLAP 🖖

BRAVO!

This is criminally underviewed. This makes me want to re-remaster TOS just to slip an Ares into the background here and there.

“Ohnohowcouldthisbe?” 🙃 4:05

Wishful thinking, first ENTERPRISE was destroyed completely 😢so get over it😳🤔🧐😵‍💫🤨🤥

Just found your video. I commend you for the effort put into it, but, um, you spelled a word wrong in early on-screen text -- it's "border", not "boarder", when referring to a boundary. Also, I have to ask about Demora Sulu. You told us what happened to Captain Harriman after the maiden voyage, but not what happened to the B's original pilot.

Brilliant work, but I have a question. If the primary hull was such a wreck, wouldn't it have been more efficient to separate the damaged saucer section and place a whole new saucer onto the secondary hull?

Don't you think people will mistaken it for Miranda class?

Hello. Sir, could you please advise me on how to configure the Asi master of the Ac13xx series with Asi slave interfaces such as Emergencystop or Ac2410, Ac2412 Do I need to use any software or do the configuration directly on the Asi master keyboard? Thanks

So awesome!!!

Hey voice actors try to not sound like you’re reading a (poorly written) script? I like the design but the mid-warp “extendo bridge” and tractor beam pulling a flipping nacelle forward? A) why? B) just why? C) you guys know Star Trek, I’ve seen many of your videos you can all emote while speaking about anything except apparently while reading a script and you KNOW the universe. You know the rules of the universe and while lately all of those rules have been tossed in the trash but bad reboot and Klutzman you guys should still attempt to abide the rules of the universe you’ve literally spent thousands and thousands of hours talking about. You guys are DORKS just like me. I’m proud that I’m a dorky nerd when it comes to Star Trek, transformers, sci-fi and comics, books and whatever else. So you’d know that ships in ST can’t just disconnect a nacelle mid warp and magic hand wave it to a different position and have it work. You know people droning on about “parts per cubic centimeter” make extremely boring background noise at best no one cares about that and it wouldn’t be mentioned out loud unless it’s in a report after the relevant info is sifted out. Christ, I’m sorry for that rant I actually debated about deleting this but whatever. In all honesty I know you all can do better than this so if you can take the sharpness of my rant and look for the constructive critiques I’ve sorta laid out and redid this I’m positive you’d have something here that would be a ton of fun. Basically: do a Captain’s log voice over with the other dialogue from the science or whoever being a soft almost inaudible where you know what’s being said if you really listen but not actually being heard, you follow? Second have the center nacelle already being attached in some way to the separating saucer if you want it to go with. If you notice TOS & TMP era federation ships had very little to no moving mechanisms on the outside of the ship during warp and almost the same out of warp because ship components were connected to other components to make the ship go. To be in warp you need the nacelles (engines) connected to the warp core, the warp core supplies the juice to engines to create the warp field and it’s connected but power conduits which are generally a sort of ridged tube. If you can just slide it forward then how would it work? The power conduits would literally be severed and the warp bubble would become unstable to say the least and the most likely out come of that would be either the bubble collapsing causing the ship to drop out of warp or the ship would be torn apart. The next thing is the navigational defector dish, and unlike what we saw in TNG where they use it as a big gun, it’s literally used to deflect things out of the path of the ship so you don’t get a “last Jedi” moment every time you enter warp. There’s no dish on the saucer section. This one is a more minor quibble because the Miranda class and a few other ships didn’t have any obvious dish so we can hand wave that one. Idk, I’m sorry for the bluntness and I really do think you can do more with this but I just think you can give it a tiny bit of more thought.

Epic

So cool.

Density is measured in grams per CUBIC centimeter; not grams per SQUARE centimeter.

It's looks amazing, but at the same it's amazingly pointless 🙂 Why not have that third nacelle permanently attached to the saucer section?

you have improved so damn much since i started watching your videos, i am so proud to see you coming so far.

I like it. I just think there are three main issues with this idea. 1: An inactive computer automatically leading to the abortion of the self-destruct sequence? Seems wrong. That would make it enemies far too easy to stop a self-destruction, just by turning the computer off. 2: A backup computer controlling the ship like that? And not only managing to control, but actually succeeding in securing the vessel again? A ship with such a computer wouldn't need a crew at all. Besides, if the main computer was done for (main computer being int he saucer, cauer blown up) would mean the backup would have to be able to bypass the routes of the defunct superior computer iteration, slowing down the whole progress. If at all, that crippled should would've made a safer landing, instead of a total crashlanding. 3: For a ship that seared through the atmosphere, burning for hundreds of kilometers, and then was left for dead of a decade, the damage is far too minimal. Other than that, I totally buy it.

A saucer separation at warp, with late 23rd century tech, strikes me as a risky maneuver. Having a transplantable nacelle attach to the saucer before separation must add to the complexity, even if it isn't activated until after separation. I would imagine this would have been a pretty heavy engineering project. The idea of a "tactical separation" suggests that this was a precursor to the Prometheus class maybe a hundred years later. Cool design from our Trekyards friends, and nice visual execution!

Awesome video love it

The sound of this seems like it doesn't make any sense at all

Okay, that was an *amazing* saucer separation. The moving nacelle to allow the saucer to stay at warp without the stardrive section is something I've never even imagined, but it works so well.

Most impressive! I did not see that third nacelle moving forward coming. You have to give us the battle now!

Great, but not of fan of the AI voices, live actors would be better.

Nice

But stiff on the human models, but great work nonetheless. The idea of having a nacelle transfer to the saucer is great, and the animation for that fits the TMP-style, but this would be such a risky thing even in sublight. So much can go wrong.

Very nice! (Loved that I could hear the hull creaking sounds from from the 1980 movie Raise The Titanic during the separation sequence. Nice touch with that!) 🖖

This is AWESOME!!!! I am happy to cry for this!!!! Keep going!!!!

Does that third nacelle have a self-contained warp core?

Oh my word...those 3d models of Stuart and Sam as Adml. Foley and Capt. Cockings was a bit uncanny but cool. Great bridge design and interesting idea with the saucer sep.

I was under the impression that saucer sep at warp was extremely risky. I refer to season 1 episode 1 of Star Trek TNG. Saucer sep was inadvisable at any warp speed and there is absolutely no margin for error.

Why would you have a MOVING third nacelle? The ship would have to have two warp cores, one in the saucer section as well as one in the secondary hull. Why wouldn't you just build the third nacelle into the saucer section to begin with. Much less to go wrong.

So this vessel has 2 warp cores?

First off, your video was done very well, and the saucer separation sequence was interesting. The problem I have with it, in a practical sense, way too many moving parts. It would more practical for that third nacelle to already be in position on the saucer. Any and all moving parts is a potential failure point, one would think that by the 23rd Century Starfleet would have a total understanding of the K.I.S.S. method of doing things (Keep It Simple Stupid). Being that I am sure you were going for the wow factor in your video, you hit it out of the park.

That whole moving the nacelle to the saucer was really clunky looking let alone doing while at warp. I would suggest arms that raise the nacelle and rotate setting it in place on the saucer. The other idea is have neck and spline with the naceller on the secondary hull detach with saucer.

I love the video it is amazing and the love it shows the original Enterprise is awe inspiring. However, the ship saving itself defeat the purpose of the self destruct protocols to prevent the ship from falling into enemy hands by destroying it. I know that the main computer went off line ,and the back up computer came online and executed the engineering and piloting steps and maneuvers , to save the enterprise from crashing on the Genesis planet. However, don’t you think that Starfleet would have taken this possibility into consideration and placed a fail safe into the computer system to prevent the enterprise from being saved by the secondary computer system? Also in the original series episode “ let this be your battlefield” it was established that no power in the universe can stop a federation starship from carrying out its Self-destruct order. ”I’m just asking not to be critical or negative but to see if you had taken this account when you put your story together and if so what is the explanation ? Great job great job!🖖🏿

Thee Admiral sounds a little board with the whole situation. 😂😂😂 The saucer separation sequence was pretty cool ! 😎👍

I take it, there are CIVILIANS on this Starship? As that would be the only significant reason, aside from severe battle damage to the ship overall, to perform such a drastic maneuver.

If the next scene is we have engage the borg. I am going to scream and cry

Cool

Excellent!

What did you make this in?

Cool saucer separation sequence.

Scotty did too good a job of sabotaging the Excelsior. The transwaep drive never worked again.

I know youve probably used existing CGI models, but Excelsior was still an NX registration at that time!

The look on Admiral Morrow's face would be priceless if anyone saw him getting so irate because Admiral Kirk and his crew not only disobeyed his direct orders not to return to Genesis to get Spock back but also stole the battered Enterprise and sabotaged the Excelsior from following her. The look on Captain Styes' face was priceless when the Excelsior's engines conked out. A surprise that Styles didn't yell his head off in front of the crew on the bridge.

To Gene, Majel,Leonard,DeForest,Nichelle,James, Grace Lee,William, George and Walter..thank you

"There are always possibilities." - Spock

Very well done.

Great job.