Terrible

THIS… (Just) PUT ME, in the “Best” MOOD!!! (MISS, IT). ;) <3 HE (‘Certainly’ DOES!) He’s, NO… “BORE!?!”

"This is the time to be, more than a name or a face in the crowd ya know this is the time, this is the time of my life" ❤

David still has to properly record a cover of _All Right Now_ just like he played it here.

The single best thing I ever saw on this show.

David went to American Idol to support his brother, Andrew's dream, and the producers heard him singing and told him to try out too!!! And he WON!!!

데이빗쿡 그리워서 옴❤

I miss that day, the moment

This is still the greatest cover ever

How did this song not chart?? AWESOME writing, and vocals!!! God Bless You!!

still watching this...

LOVE David Cook! Saw him live when he came to my city and he’s phenomenal- puts on a great show, super funny and interactive with the crowd while having the most powerful voice! He is so underrated!!

Could play checkers or chess on that sweater vest

Best performance on American Idol

I knew David cook was going to win with this performance! It was great.

Holy smokeshow 🔥🔥🔥🔥 this song did not get the recognition that it deserves. Way, way better than Always Be My Baby IMHO.

Flawless ❤

Hard to remember but American Idol used to produce bona fide celebrities.

Gives me chills. Loved it.

Sorry Simon, but dude's still got charisma and it's 2023. And that wink at 1:29! ❤🥵

Somebody should pls give us an HD version

that show has changed so much,

Nicole was so rude to the lead singer during her critique . She even made fun of the way he stands up there . I think he’s pretty amazing ❤

🎶🎶😮😮❤❤😊😊

Going to see him in concert soon and I cannot wait!!!!

Chris daughtry and david cook was my favorite artist out there😊😊😊😊

Heartthrob city, best ever!!!

Love the wife, “Oh, STP, STP!” She knows! 💙 #STP4Life

the sexiest performance in Idol history

He’s from my town

Holds up! He isn't given enough credit for this arrangement and the famous arrangement of Always Be My Baby.

When I was at. A music store in Tulsa David cooks brother was in there He told me about the tour it was a great truly a great experience

Still watching this in 2023

I miss those times......

Loving this cover in 2023!!! Fan for life!!!!

This was my second favorite performance by him that season. My favorite was “Always Be my Baby”! He deserved to win!!

He was my favourite this whole season! I still love him! So happy he won!

2009 could be the toughest..

I love David ❤️

I remember hearing this and wanting to kill him the only other good cover of Eleanor Rigby is done by godhead and there's two of them

2022 Brazil

This literally just felt like his own concert. Dude's effortless on stage

Paula was wasssssteeeddd in this episode lmao

I love his version. David is such a cool and yet confident guy.

Only his answer was true - idol

After last nite, I had to revisit every David Cook Idol moment. 💙💙

I remember on his season, I worked evenings in a busy hospital, and I saw his Eleanor Rigby/Beatles week competition, in a patient room, and I said, oh he’s gonna win 🏆 that was awesome

I knew when he got going he was going to be in the finals. I also knew when he did his rendition of Billie Jean, the game was over. What talent!

Reminded of this gem yet again from Tulsa!

Simon always being brutally honest