I've seen every Galacti.... oh hell I couldn't watch this because I got BORED and wanted to start drinking again!
@Cerberous1020Күн бұрын
You obviously know nothing about actual technology. The empire weapon's are lasers. LASERS. Just focused light. Lmao. The basic shield of just a Borg drone wouldn't even get warm if the deathstar had a month to fire at it continuously. None of the weapon's from star wars would make a scratch on any of the ships from star trek. Where as phasers, disruptor and photon torpedoes, plus teleportation and replication technology and transwarp drives. Would make attacking the empire seem like an utter waste of energy. Ultimately, except from the population numbers greatly boosting the Borgs drone numbers by trillions, the Borg would ignore the empire as its entire civilisations technology is abysmally obsolete and would do nothing at all to advance the Borg. So this would be a pure horror show for the empire as they can only watch helplessly as the Borg assimilate the entire galaxy without any resistance whatsoever.
@DrownedInExileКүн бұрын
Borg win, no question. (Long post) The Empire might win, if through some World-Between-Worlds force-space-magic, they figured out the location of the Borg Unicomplex. And somehow tear through layers of corruption, bureaucracy, infighting etc, to launch a fast pre-emptive strike with the Death Star and the Rim Fleet. The superlaser is far too powerful for the Borg to adapt fast enough. But the retaliation would be swift and deadly. ISDs might be able to significantly damage or even destroy a few Borg Cubes... for a short time. Then it would be a complete slaughter. The Force wouldn't make any real difference. A handful of space wizards against dozens of Borg ships and possibly millions of drones beaming in? Would make the Clone Army look like a bunch of Boy Scouts! The Fleet's best bet would be to jump out as quick as possible. Any ship in danger of being captured, would have orders to self-destruct. As for the Borg. They would employ the same tactics as they did against the Federation, starting small-scale. Assimilating isolated outer worlds, pirates, smugglers, absorbing their inhabitants' biological and technological distinctiveness. Gathering intel on this "Galactic Empire". Normally the Empire wouldn't care, unless their core worlds were hit. But the Emperor would feel a chill in his bones, like nothing he's ever felt before. Fear normally strengthens the Dark Side, but not this time. He sends a fleet to the Rim, but it's too late. The Borg have already adapted to the weapons of this galaxy. It isn't a battle, it's a complete curb-stomp. Through assimilation, the Borg learn of Emperor Palpatine, Darth Vader, and the Death Star. There were some odd mentions of the former two having magic powers, but that was irrelevant to the Borg. Given the size of the Empire, the Borg brought a battle-group of 12 cubes for assimilation. They immediately set course for Corusant. The Death Star and the entire Imperial Fleet was waiting. The Borg immediately targeted the Death Star for assimilation. Planet-killing was irrelevant, but the underlying technology was something they could consume. 2 cubes were instantly destroyed, before the rest converged to point-blank range. They quickly disabled the Death Star, and began beaming tens of thousands of drones over. Blaster rifles, rockets, even thermal detonators only slowed the Borg briefly. They adapted and kept coming. Vader had more success, cutting down hundreds of drones before his sabre bounced off their adaptive shields. At least they had no defence against the Force. But no matter how many Borg Vader crushed, the essence of what they are remained. They regenerated and kept on coming! Eventually Vader was exhausted, his strength depleted. The lava of Mustafar was nothing compared to the ice-cold touch of Borg nanoprobes injected into his neck. The Borg didn't even bother with the Imperial fleet, single-mindedly focusing on assimilating the Death Star. Imperial weapons were by now, completely ineffective against the Borg. Some bold Captains even tried ramming the Borg, but they simply used their tractor beams to swat them away like flies. In less than an hour, initial-stage assimilation of the Death Star was complete. It broadcast out to the entire galaxy, via the galactic holonet: "I am Vader, of Borg. Resistance is futile. You will disarm all of your weapons, and stand by for assimilation. Your lives as you have known them, are over. From this time forward you will service... us." The Borg were fully aware of Vader's public image as a hero, so he was useful as a liaison. They promptly regrew his lost limbs and healed his scars, though out of efficiency not compassion. His lightsabre was intriguing, but the rarity of kybre crystals made it of little use to the Borg. So they kept his mask for his liaison role, but discarded his primitive flawed armour in favour of Borg cybernetics. It was all over from there. Palpatine fared batter with Force Lightning, but he was only delaying the inevitable. As compliant drones, Vader and Palpatine could no longer channel the Force. Even if it were possible, spending time and resources to cultivate this mysterious power in a few rare individuals, was an inefficient use of the Borg's resources. The Force was irrelevant. Gifted rare individuals were irrelevant. Wow I didn't expect this to turn into a short story! Well that's my take and I'm sticking to it. Borg victory, hands-down.
@geoffstonehouse6304Күн бұрын
I think the empire would win. The borg wouldn't be able to adapt to the death star if they keep getting destroyed in a single shot because they wouldn't be able to learn about it. And as long as they don't let their top minds who know the plans get assimilated the numbers game would win out too.
@brockstran2 күн бұрын
Ok this guy's analysis is wrong, point 1 Star Wars uses laser-based weapons laser-based weapons can't even affect deflector Shields let alone the main Shields. Point 2 Star Wars can only travel faster than lights speed in hyperspace corridors when they're in the corridors they can't fight. When they are outside of the corridors they are super slow, and the corridors are very limited they could on😊ly travel where there's a corridor. What Star Trek universe has warp speed and that could done warp time any direction. Star Wars will find themselves in surprise attacks with a warp in destroy then and warp out before they could even react. Poin 3 Star Wars are like battleships on the water all their weapons are on the top of it if you look underneath it maybe they're all you have one laser, all the Borg have to do with state under them, lol
@OfficerCain2 күн бұрын
the Borg are ALREADY, by the time of Next Generation, immune to ALL laser tech. they were by the time Earth went to the moon. other than the Deathstar, no laser could even pierce the shields of a probe. the Borg also can travel wayyy faster than any ship in the Empire. the Falcon, the fastest ship in the Star Wars universe travels at Warp 1.2 on the Warp scale. the Phoenix, the first warp capable ship from Earth traveled at Warp 1.5 when the Vulcans came to Earth... Hands down, the Borg would win. and it would be quick.
@OvisMilitaris2 күн бұрын
All this talk about the Borg not having the Force. The Borg would assimilate Force gifted people and gain access to Midi-chlorians. Not every Force gifted person is a Jedi or Sith, so they don't have to go after Vader level folks to get them, and its easier to boot. They'd eventually fill in the blanks themselves. Also individual drones might me weak minded, but the hive mind Collective as a whole would be terrifying.
@carlhardric86062 күн бұрын
Can you imagine a Borg Sith Lord?
@markpattenden72562 күн бұрын
Death Vader would choke the Borg queen to death. Fight over.
@safetybuddy2 күн бұрын
The Borg win hands-down, no doubt in my mind
@g-92223 күн бұрын
Picard wins every time, for one simple "but all powerful" reason....Q. Q has a affinity with Picard, therefore I'm guessing he would not let Picard lose, but this is Q we are talking about, so anything goes really.
@JinnWorld3 күн бұрын
Star Wars may win. Until the Borg assimilate Yoda on Dagobah. The Borg we are. Assimilated you will be. The Force we now have. Resistance, futile it is.
@Qubk03 күн бұрын
Is this video AI generated? Certainly feels like it
@TheRattlefinger4 күн бұрын
BSG had its moments, and I thoroughly enjoyed the first season, had a blast with the second, but stopped watching some time during the third when the main theme became "Who's Cylon today?". Interestingly my favorite moment was also in the third season (I think, my memories are hazy) when the Galactica jumped into the atmosphere of New Caprica, and launched the fighters during the fiery descent. Might give the whole series a second chance though after watching this video.
@majorsynthqed73744 күн бұрын
Sidious could use the Force to throw a fleet of cubes into a sun. No more cube. While the Borg can, and would, overwhelm the technology, use of the Force is an inane ability, not a technological one. The Force cannot be assimilated. It really depends on how powerful Sidious and Vader are.
@shengyi17014 күн бұрын
Vader to the borg queen - Don’t be too proud of this technological terror you’ve constructed. The ability to assimilate entire worlds is insignificant next to the power of the Force! Force chokes the Queen and it’s over. Vader scoffs at her lifeless body - “I find your lack of faith disturbing!” Yes - borg have transporters but they will underestimate the power of the Force.
@OfficerCain2 күн бұрын
the next queen will be chosen from a drone and they will keep coming. seriously, that is how the borg have survived sense before humans existed on earth...
@shengyi17012 күн бұрын
@ perhaps they should have the empire race the Xenomorphs or XX-121
@FedoReds884 күн бұрын
Borg haven't planet destroying weapons, they have entire solar system destroying weapons, as shown in Voyager
@OfficerCain2 күн бұрын
and in Star Trek Online (kinda cannon... some of it is, some isnt..) they have probes that assimilate whole planets.
@ajteer4 күн бұрын
An assimilated Storm Trooper might actually be able to hit it's target for once.
@wtfa29104 күн бұрын
I don't care how powerful your ship is if you see a borg cube you run don't look back don't look back
@commentsedited5 күн бұрын
Borg would go through G..E. like crap through a goose.
@tardiscommand18125 күн бұрын
I hope we’ll never get a movie cause they’ll bigger it up
@chriscasias2706 күн бұрын
That symbol at the beginning was that of the Republic not the Empire
@shawtylrg6 күн бұрын
Would love to see an animated depiction of this
@ModernSciFi6 күн бұрын
That’s not a bad idea
@JOHNN01.826 күн бұрын
The Borg would eventually drain the empire down until breaking point adapting assimilating the Empires numbers to their own
@blindscience17017 күн бұрын
It doesn't take that much to change and adapt to weapons fire or saber attacks. The force, would be detected, but the Borg, do to races with Mental type powers, like Betazids. A defense would be formed quickly. Droid factor, would be useless as well. They are walking computers and those can be hacked remotely or on contact. Borg Unimatrixs is like an Hydra. Cut off the head, another grows back aka transfers to another Unimatrix. The only way to stop them, that somewhat effect. Is to strike at them on their Nanites. Also, if the Borg, came to the galaxy far far away, The empire needs to out right destroy the beach head in which the Borg had taken and no doubt set up an Transwarp gate and an unimatrix. Failure, will doom the galaxy.
@Sigmatechnica7 күн бұрын
cross-franchise comparisons tend to be a bit daft, this being no exception. i think the only interesting point this brings out is what is the point of fighters in star wars at all? they don't have enough firepower to damage the large ships, the borg could ignore whole fleets of them. so could the larger starwars chips (based on the various films and series) so why have them at all, appart from the eye-candy space dogfights
@ModernSciFi6 күн бұрын
Interesting point. I wouldn’t call it daft since it’s a thought experiment. The fighters are only impactful when they fly inside the Death Star but in that case it was a game changer since the Starships couldn’t destroy it
@wwhite-hz4zv8 күн бұрын
Borg will crack the empire's primative shields, they figured out the Enterprise D's real quick, the beam drones onto the ships and turn the stormtroopers into drones. Darth Vader and Emperor will be surrounded by drones. Their lightsabers will stop cutting the drones because they will adapt. The Emperor and Darth will be forced to flee their ships. Also, when the Star Destroyers start shooting at the Borg cubes and Spheres, the Borg shields will adapt to their firepower.
@christopherherrle85899 күн бұрын
The borge relie heavily on adaptive shields for protection. Force crush or choke will bypass that shielding. Force lighting will be able to fry the mechanical parts while cooking the organic mater. Theres never been a measurement of the most powerful of lighting. And what about the light Saber. I bet it cuts them down quick.
@c.alucard635210 күн бұрын
The Borg definitely have planet destroying weapons. They do it all the time. Ffs they will make a sun go super nova and smoke a system. Tos enterprise phasers could glass a planet with a few shots at max power. The Borg are much further in the Future and much much more advanced. The Borg would use them as fuel. And with so much and so easy, they would take over most of the galaxy. Resistance would be futile.
@georgecoons687210 күн бұрын
the borg has species 8472 tech now. the borg would win easy.
@williamfleishman375010 күн бұрын
I know what would happen! I know who wins! Whoever gets this going is served process and a judge issues an injunction preventing the battle from happening. Then the case settles and there is no battle.
@maclanekeller830811 күн бұрын
Empire. Definitely.
@phantomvmfa12213 күн бұрын
Would it be possible to have a video on Starfleet vs the Galactic Empire?
@ModernSciFi12 күн бұрын
it would. The scenes of DS9's battles vs the dominion would be great for that.
@jeffpurnell86414 күн бұрын
Neither can shoot straight so it would go on forever. A draw.
@pingpang781714 күн бұрын
just transport everyone off the death star into outer space, then take the death star ez pz lemon squeezy
@toddkurzbard17 күн бұрын
"How did Palpatine come back after his apparent death in ROTJ?" Somehow, he returned.
@toddkurzbard17 күн бұрын
Much as I love Ol' Baldy, the win goes to Thrawn.
@toddkurzbard17 күн бұрын
Easy win for The Borg (the ORIGINAL Borg, NOT the pathetic iteration led by the Borg Queen that gets beaten by every opponent). Resistance is futile. The Empire will be assimilated.
@paulrichard847418 күн бұрын
It all boils down to how many Borg cubes can be destroyed by the Death Stars in under a minute. Before an army of Borg transport over and begin assimilating imperial soldiers minus force sensitive fighters.
@OfficerCain2 күн бұрын
once they assimilate one of the force sensitive fighters... Drones with Force powers!
@christopherort288918 күн бұрын
Borg
@atomgrounder85719 күн бұрын
You ruined the video with an AI narrator ---- "ADAM AH" see if you would have bought a 5 dollar microphone and narrated your copy and paste content you it is "AH DAM AH" watch the show, spell out the words, DO NOT RECOMMEND CHANNEL, DISLIKED. BYE BYE
@ModernSciFi6 күн бұрын
Yeah I was gonna try it myself or get a British guy, might try that in the future
@TheRattlefinger4 күн бұрын
What if he's not a fluent English speaker? Then he'd get downvoted by random mooks for his accent. Or by those who say (and they're right) that 5 dollar microphones are servicable for speaking with teammates in an online game, but otherwise produce quite bad quality audio.
@atomgrounder8574 күн бұрын
@ Whose fault is that? So you are his knight in shining armor, it is still a microphone and give the genuine person his earned stature. Quit kissing up to him
@atomgrounder8574 күн бұрын
and my next thought is, how about you buy him that microphone and teach him to speak fluent english. Are you just a worthless knight in armor that does nothing more than talk about his weakness and does nothing? yes you are take your no helping self to salvation army and get training
@TheRattlefinger3 күн бұрын
@@atomgrounder857Deep thoughts. Edgy even. Bye.
@kyorin652619 күн бұрын
It was definitely a moment when Tom Zarek had the council members executed. Any pretense that he was legit was gone instantly in a jaw-dropping moment!
@ModernSciFi6 күн бұрын
That was ruthless yeah loved it. Richard Hatch was such a great actor and so under appreciated. I am so happy they brought him back. He sadly passed away in 2017.
@Timberjac19 күн бұрын
The Borg are like an insidious dancer that can start metastasizing at any moment. A few Borg on various levels of Coruscant, who have not yet been eliminated, can bring down a planet as complex as that. The Empire has a disastrous problem, its weapons are standardized for manufacturing on an immense scale (which would accelerate the adaptation processes used by the Borg), not thinking about their adaptability to various situations that require the use of weapons and equipment to unknown situations, as happens with the Federation and even so they have to be thankful for not being the focus of Borg attention.
@BrianDrake-u2h19 күн бұрын
Not sure who to root for with this one.
@danyeo20 күн бұрын
If the Borg assimilated just one stormtrooper then ALL their targeting systems wouldn’t work LOL. ButThe Borg would be confused why the Empire would use lasers against them. But once they start assimilating a few Star Destroyers forget about it. Stormtroopers are useless, Borg can transport right into the center of any Empire ship and assimilate it. The Empire have never seen a virus like The Borg.
@invictus257821 күн бұрын
Picard stays cool headed under pressure unless the adversary is the Borg then he’ll lose his shit
@GOCAPSDMV21 күн бұрын
Excellent channel! So many Star Trek fans think that they would be able to use the force when the only way someone could use it as if they’re literally born with it. The Borg can’t just take over the death star because each one has Vader or Palpatine in it… too many people are underestimating the force. Really sad.
@OfficerCain2 күн бұрын
and you clearly do not understand Trek. Psykers are not a new thing in trek. even what you would call Force Powers are present.
@zulzuli360322 күн бұрын
In real life, Galactica are toast!
@ankursahu26922 күн бұрын
Big invest this technology reality please sir please