@@krowlyy Hahahaha 😂😂

@@Guest.7289_2 Yes, my low chest notes are actually too weak for that stuff, but I wanted to do it to give myself a challenge. I already raised the song by one semitone to make it more manageable. But thanks for the compliment at 2:01 🙏🏻🎶

@@Mayur15993 Thank you very much! 🙏🏻❤️ My lowest chest note on any day is a very weak and breathy F2. That’s just what you get as a Tenor…

@@jmbmusic1 me to... But someday i can sing a breathy E2

also at 1:53 this is a growl (unvoiced fricative exhale). It's too soft to be subs or chest-fry.

@@lumi5164 I‘ve been listening to Geoff Castellucci and dozens of other bass singers for the past few years and I can 100% guarantee to you that all the notes in this video are named correctly. Some of them have even been confirmed by Geoff in comments or in other ways. And I will always be able to differentiate a subharmonic from a chest note (at least when it comes to Geoff’s subs and chest notes). And growl is so vastly different that it would be very easy to identify that.

As someone with a very similar range to Geoff, I can confirm comparing my G1 (with subs) to Geoff's here, as well as to both the G1 I've heard in person as well as classical performance G1s, that my subharmonic sounds nearly identical to Geoff's G1 (after a little voicing) as well as is a lot more click-y (?) than a real chested G1. Also the growl note I pointed out he confirmed to be as such. if you are comparing to how notes are labeled in the various videos online to write these, those are also typically inaccurate. If not, then I would suggest checking again as well.

I can also tell from how easy he is singing subharmonics in that low 2nd octave as well as high first that the corresponding fundamentals there are already low for Geoff. After all, his range is definitely more aligned with a baritone given the power he gets higher up compared to the sound of his low notes (something else he has also confirmed).

@@lumi5164 Alright, let’s go over all the notes in this video… G1 from Misty Mountains: This one is easily chest. Compare it to his G1 Subharmonic note earlier in the song and you‘ll hear a HUGE difference. Overtones are completely different, the weight of the note is much heavier and it sounds exactly like all his other G1 chest notes that he’s been singing the past few years. G1‘s from ACA Disney: This one is recorded long before Geoff even knew about subharmonics, and growl would sound way different (more air, less overtones) F#1 Kidnap the Sandy Claws: Confirmed to be subharmonic by Geoff on his Q&A F#1 in Country Roads: not sure if he confirmed it, but it’s a very obvious Subharmonic note. F1 in Daddy sang bass: He confirmed that LIVE he sang a growl note (which is also very obvious from the recordings of it) AND there are actually several F1 growl notes throughout the song in the background bass line. Now compare those to the F1 at the end of the song. It’s a very different sound. The growl notes have a lot of air in it and other than that just a pure bass frequency. I will admit that the Subharmonic F1 at the end sounds different to a lot of Geoff‘s newer subs but that‘s just due to it being one of his earliest recorded low subharmonics. He sings it more quietly which results in a rounder and less overtone-rich sound. Still, you can hear the very distinctive Subharmonic sound at the end of the note cause it’s held just a fraction longer than the other notes of the chord. A growl or chest note would never sound like that. I hope I was able to clear this situation up and that you can hear all the things that I explained here. I can’t explain all of this more detailed in a KZbin comment so I will stop here. If you still hear the notes as other techniques, I‘m sorry. All of this is confirmed by multiple sources and good friends that are also basses who know Geoff’s voice thoroughly. But if want to keep debating, feel free to join the Bass Singing Nation Discord server (link in description) and let these people there explain it to you further. I am done with this conversation. Have a nice day and keep enjoying bass singers!

@@tizwigtfc6566 When you sing a comfortable middle to low range chest note and add some relaxation or tension to it a note exactly an OCTAVE below will appear. That is a first sub. If you now find the sweet spot WITHIN that subharmonic note, add the right tension or relaxation, a note exactly a FIFTH below the first subharmonic will appear. Now THAT is a second sub. It‘s HIGHLY unlikely that you are accidentally singing second subs as they are way more difficult to hit than first subs. Hope this helps.

@@jmbmusic1 helps a lot actually

@@randyjsing Thanks man! I really appreciate it!

@@emilyrln hehe

@@zntnx Thank you very much my man!!

@@gellertgrindelwald7171 Thank you very much!!

@@TaigaMoriBass Haha, thanks Taiga!! It‘s truly an honor to share the screen with Marwan. He‘s amazing!

Vielen Dank Michael!! 🙏🏻🎶

@@nathanielmori1865 Thank you very much, but there’s actually no Subharmonic note in here… All the really low stuff that you‘re hearing is ingressive phonation.

@@stevendeslauriers1369 Thanks!! I am unfortunately not blessed with a naturally low voice, so using subs, seconds subs or other techniques for everything below F2 is a must for me. Sometimes I even use subs up to G2 or G#2 cause they are qualitatively better than my low chest notes.

@@rtsbass7829 Thanks broski!!

@@SethMichel-wd2ln Thank you very much dude 🎶🙏🏻

@@tarantula6669 Vielen Dank!!! :)

@@ColtonRMagby Thank you!! And thanks for the English version of your comment haha

@@jmbmusic1 Only a certain percentage of people can read and understand Arabic, so I accounted for that.

@@manavsharma869 Good good good! Giving me the watch time 📈😅 Thanks bro! 🎶🙏🏻

@@paulschmidt2508 They‘re everywhere 😳👽

@@FernyBass EXACTLY THAT MARWAN!!! 😂😂

@@bradyschoch7562 Thanks a ton Brady!! 🎶🙏🏻❤️

@@ChristopherCosbyMusicOnline Thank you so much Chris! Huge shoutout to my friend Michael for showing me this wonderful tag!

@@journeyday Thanks buddy! Really appreciate it! ❤️🎶

@@davidrock5887 I hope we are able to meet your expectations!

@@genesisPiano Thank you!

Thank you!!

Damn that's low even for males!

Thank you! I never marched in any group. I live in Germany and didn’t even know about DCI until like seven months ago. I really wanna hear and see this stuff live at some point…

Was it chest or subs

@@Guest.7289_2 sub

​@@amogns_the_real nice

Nice

@@jakemf1 Thank you!

Yeah, I‘m not sure how much sense that would make hahaha But there are a lot of other ones planned for the future so stay tuned!

Thank you!! It’s definitely interesting to see and hear how subs work for different voice types…

Thanks! Go for it!

Hahah, well… It’s all about the practice. (And don’t forget that these are just the best takes out of MANY attempts, so don’t think that my subharmonics always sound like this)

@@jmbmusic1 im pretty sure I can hit 1st sub but i need to work on range lowest right now I can go is either a F1 or a E1

​@@jmbmusic1After further me listening to bass music instead of me doing a 1st sub it sounds like a chest fry

What? An F1 is a piano key…

Thank you!!

Well… That high note at the end is an A5 for you sir haha

Haha, let‘s blow your mind even more… There‘s technically an infinite amount of sequels. And I managed to sing down to the 4th subharmonic before. I recommend watching David Larson‘s videos about 1st and 2nd subs as well as Bass2Yang‘s videos on subharmonics to get more foundational knowledge about the topic.

I've watched a video of people creating subharmonics with subharmonics with bobby bass and david and they managed to make a C0 5th subharmonic somehow Ok so david sung a G#2 chest and Bobby sung a G2 chest and that made a C0 5th subharmonic somehow

Hey, thanks man!! Haven‘t heard from you in a while. It’s nice to see a comment from you again!

@@jmbmusic1 ya I’ve been a bit inactive on here lately, but I still like seeing what’s going on in the bass singing community! Glad to see that you and others are continuing to keep it alive and growing! It’s good to hear from you again too! 🙏

Thank you!!! It’s really cool that it works out this well… I will do a lot more hornline stuff in the future!

Hahahaha!

Thank you very much for the encouraging words! Make sure to check out my newer content as well since most things have improved quite significantly ever since releasing this video.

@jmbmusic1 For sure I will and always supporting talent where is it 😊

What part exactly of Crown 2018?

​​@@jmbmusic1 Honestly, The tuning hit (which is the end of the show or Epiphanies, Fanfare and Chorales by Ron Nelson) is a good section. Also, there's the amazing low brass version of Blow it up, start over.... Then again there is the opener with symphony number 8 by Bruckner. I don't know there's a lot of fun spots but my favorite part is the tuning hit which is also the closer!

@@J-Strength1 Alright. I‘ll have a listen to these. Maybe I can do one of them at some point. Thanks for the suggestions!

I‘ll add that to my to-do list! But there’s already a lot on there so we‘ll have to see when I can get to it…

@@jmbmusic1 there's just too much good stuff to source from, indeed

Hahaha, that’s pretty accurate!

Thank you very much!!

Thanks I guess? 😄

Vielen Dank! Das freut mich wirklich sehr!