Пікірлер
@teamcopro652
@teamcopro652 17 сағат бұрын
Very interesting. Thanks! About UK joining, I totally agree with M. Zuleeg. Imo UK is better outside the EU (De Gaulle was right from the start) with trade agreements between the 2.
@JohnnyinMN
@JohnnyinMN Күн бұрын
It’s amazing how myopic the English people are. A complete country of idiots.
@ShikharRawat-ft6yd
@ShikharRawat-ft6yd Күн бұрын
Don't be fooled bjp getting 324 nda 370 pm modi come back
@larstenfaelt1859
@larstenfaelt1859 Күн бұрын
40:37 in. I think that UK citizen has a total different view about in own responsibility and personal committment in regards to common goals than here in Sweden. I have a summer house on the west coast of Sweden and naturally I have had a heat pump for about 15 years and got 3 layer isolation glassing in the whole house a couple of years ago...in my summer house!!! I have also installed a heat pump in the shed. Non of these are economically justafiable but totally justafiable in regards to my role in the system. Most of my neighbors have done the same without any programs from the state. It's not "we and them". We are the country and as citizen we need to understand our role!!! I am looking at Solar pannels dispite I don't have a EV and cosume quite a little but it is all about our mind-set.
@amirishelston5212
@amirishelston5212 Күн бұрын
Ah yes Neil Kinnock, still holding the record for the Labour leader who stayed further away from office than anybody before or since.
@Nehemiah_Scudder
@Nehemiah_Scudder Күн бұрын
Did you really call Britain a "stable democracy"? In the last election a party took 58% of the seats in Parliament with 43.6% of the votes cast, and the party with the third largest portion of the vote got the fourth largest representation in Parliament.
@AlexGys9
@AlexGys9 Күн бұрын
Dreaming should have been mentioned as one of the weaknesses: dreaming of becoming a leader in this, a global player in the other and world beating in whatever else. Although, tbh, that very dreaming also ensures the UK has excellent research and development capabilities. Unfortunately, dreamers are not doers. British industry is one of the least innovative of the OECD countries. The results of said research and development are not applied in Britain but exported.
@venmis137
@venmis137 Күн бұрын
True. Potential is there but it needs to be applied. I won't pretend to have any clue as to how to go about this, though I will say that a Labour government is at least more likely to TRY to push for something, for what that's worth.
@Conservator.
@Conservator. Күн бұрын
It’s poor education and the class system. How can any country prosper when it doesn’t get the full potential from its population?
@martynmeacham-hw2pi
@martynmeacham-hw2pi Күн бұрын
Kinnock the traitor who stabbed the miners in the back for a bag of Judas gold, and a cloak trimmed wth the skin of a dead animal!
@Conservator.
@Conservator. Күн бұрын
“Especially if we can become a leader in AI” How on earth should the UK achieve that? It’s a pipe dream and dreaming isn’t going to help anyone.
@venmis137
@venmis137 Күн бұрын
The UK was already at the forefront of the AI. But we let the Americans buy up all our startups (because the British State is weak) so we lost our early advantage.
@Britonbear
@Britonbear Күн бұрын
A stable democracy where 30% of the electorate can give a party a massive majority.
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet Күн бұрын
58:00ff 'the EU would be in no position to say no to them' Correct, you utter ignoramus from the EPC, 'the EU' would indeed not be in a position to say 'no' to the applicant little brexitannia for the simple reason that it's not 'the EU' that decides about membership, but the 27(+?) national parliaments and in some memberstates us, the electorate, via referenda (e.g. France, Ireland). Your utter ignorance about the decision making processes in the EU is beyond embarrassing for a so-called 'expert'. I suggest you read the acquis communautaire for a variety and educate yourself on the basics?! Other than that, daaahhhhlink, I named 3 excellent reasons for quite a number of us memberstates to veto the applicant UK / rumpUK / whatever will be left of her around 2070. As explained in a response to a co-commenter above/below. Greetings from civilization 🇪🇺 where lay(wo)men apparently know more about your field of expertise than you do 🤦‍♀️
@julianshepherd2038
@julianshepherd2038 Күн бұрын
At this point, I have stopped listening to Labour. You can't change on so many issues and retain my trust. I dread to think of another government that built its popularity on lying.
@old_seadog
@old_seadog 2 күн бұрын
1:06 _"It's against the law to publish any information based on how people have actually voted before 10 o'clock on Polling Day"_ Unless your name is Laura Toriesberg, then it's ok to let everyone know you've seen the postal votes on the day and what the vast majority of those voters have voted for. And don't complain to the beeb about it, it's NFI on their part.
@andrewrose7800
@andrewrose7800 2 күн бұрын
Regarding erosion of trust in British politics, surely Blair got there first.
@larstenfaelt1859
@larstenfaelt1859 2 күн бұрын
The reason Boris got so engaged in Ukraine is the same as with most leaders with domestic problems...they love to get involved in other contries conflicts (the theme of the movie "Wag the dog"). Boris didn't need to start a war...just in a populist way show it in rhetoric. According to the Kiel institute UK has contributed 0,3 % of GDP where as my country Sweden has contributed almost 0,7% (0,5+1,9) but much beaten by Baltic states and Denmark where Estonia has given almost 1,8 % (1,6+1,9) of GDP . I do agree that UK is great in given support however to say that they are leading...well...maybe in the rhetoric when Boris was PM (fueled by domestic problems with "party gate" etc. )
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 күн бұрын
53:40ff Jesus Christ, yet another 'expert' participant who has *ZERO* clue what the SM is about. Good woman, the SM is about trade and trade only, not about defence. *OF COURSE* the EU can and probably will cooperate with little brexitannia in defence when she finally - IMO long overdue* - will funnel and concentrate all members' military and defence, analogue to the trade in the SM, but this definitely will not mean the EU grants little brexitannia a kind of trade-in as in preferential access to the SM for the UK's cooperation, should this strange thought be lingering in the back of your head. And let's be clear: the UK as a random 3rd country will not be part of the decision making, but a 2nd tier partner. Greetings from civilization 🇪🇺 *guess what member for decades was one of the worst blocking factors for a more cohesive, stronger common EU defence. Spoiler1: name starts with U Spoiler2: name ends with K
@larstenfaelt1859
@larstenfaelt1859 2 күн бұрын
I think it's you who needs to be observant as the discussion was on a wider role for EU...not the single market.
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 күн бұрын
@@larstenfaelt1859 In the time stamped above, the lady explicitly refers to the SM in the context of defence cooperation.
@larstenfaelt1859
@larstenfaelt1859 Күн бұрын
@@EllieD.Violet Yes in the context that the SM could help out with military support as well...and that is fine. I just heard on the news that other EU members are buying military equipment from my country Sweden replace weapons sent to Ukraine. Thanks to the SM that is seemless and easy. If they bought it from UK or other counties outside EU it would be more difficult. I think this was the message from her. SM as such is just a term to describe the 4 freedomes (goods, serices people and capital) but has no context without the use of these freedoms. I have no clue what experience you have in the military but it is extremely international, also the trading part...so SM highly implify trade. I have a long history in trading and have a long history before Sweden entered EU in the 90-ties. I have worked in the defence industry and seen this first hand and the huge benefits. I have also been involved in industrial collaborations and seen how great benefit the SM is for all type of goods regardless in what areas but especially in the Military area with common standards and high visibilty of rules for goods that might be part of a larger re-exporting deals. Sooooooo relevant!!! What type of experience do you have in trade and especially in trade with goods that have extra regulations in regards to re-exporting etc?
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet Күн бұрын
@@larstenfaelt1859 Since I'm a forensic data analyst by profession naturally I have no experience in trade. One doesn't need to have experience, only a well functioning brain and a knack for logic. I don't get your need to explain the benefits of the SM to me, be it in military equipment or non-military goods. I know the benefits of the SM rather well. All I did was lecture the participants of this discussion about 2 facts: 1) the SM is the internal trade body of the EU and hence not connected to ANYTHING defence related as opposed to what that lady seemed to imply. She explicitly related to the EU extending her potential purchases to source from outside the SM, hence the UK. 2) I reminded her that naturally, given the classification of military equipment, the UK always only would be a 2nd tier participant, and that military cooperation in no effing way could be used by the UK for demanding any kind of trade-in for preferential access to the SM.
@larstenfaelt1859
@larstenfaelt1859 Күн бұрын
@@EllieD.Violet Yes. The problem with UK (where I have spent a couple of my working years) is that they believe that rhetoric and perception is more important to do things and be honest. Sadly they have this imperial excelionalist thinking believing they are "leading" everywhere.
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 күн бұрын
9:00ff 'We turn our back for a couple of years...' Mr Menon, if you're lucky it's only a couple of *decades* as in 40-50 years. If you're unlucky it will be much longer. Leaving was *your* decision. Re-admitting you is *OUR* decision. And *solely* ours. Greetings from civilization 🇪🇺
@julianshepherd2038
@julianshepherd2038 Күн бұрын
🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 more complex than that
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet Күн бұрын
@@julianshepherd2038 Feel free to elaborate, enlighten and correct me. Given the average low level of the 'expert' participants in the UKICE discussions, I kept it short and simple. 3 factors: 1) as of 2024, the UK fails to meet 50% of the accession criteria. She will need half a century to meet those missing 50%. 2) those of us EU27 members that profit from Brexit - e.g. euroclearing - will veto the UK. Nobody here 🇪🇺is stupid enough to hand back said profits in return for nothing. 3) we 🇨🇵 have referenda on applicants for EU membership and will veto little brexitannia for a minimum of half a century. Just for the fun of it and because we can 🤣. Greetings from civilization 🇪🇺
@BobQuigley
@BobQuigley 2 күн бұрын
The false separation "UK in a changing Europe" implies is at the heart of the cascading catastrophes gaining momentum in UK. The entire population is of European origin. French was the preferred language for centuries of the nobility. British linked royalty led much of Europe. Yet today the little island of 76 million does everything possible to distance itself from Europe. Comically many Brits consider themselves closer to America located 3,000 miles away than to Europe only 35 miles away by tunnel. America's companies are taking full advantage of this foolishness as it "invades" UK slowly consuming more business.
@Purple_flower09
@Purple_flower09 2 күн бұрын
The entire population is of European origin? No it isn't. Everyone in the UK knows that.
@YouTubemessedupmyhandle
@YouTubemessedupmyhandle 22 сағат бұрын
Europe can have a range of outlooks and historical context.
@dougtsax
@dougtsax 2 күн бұрын
What on earth is all this about? It needs some sort of introduction. And it's well out of date/time.
@TheUKinaChangingEurope
@TheUKinaChangingEurope 2 күн бұрын
Its a snippet from our podcast - which you can listen to here open.spotify.com/episode/6D4PJpoj8mSf2yxgMAmKWR
@linyarin
@linyarin 2 күн бұрын
So Laura Kunssberg announcing the postal votes the day before an election got a free pass?
@dw-yl3ln
@dw-yl3ln 2 күн бұрын
Even as someone who doesn’t like Kuennsberg, it’s not the same. A) it was a mayoral and not general, and b) all she said was ‘it’s going to be closer than you might think.’
@billtycoon3289
@billtycoon3289 2 күн бұрын
@@dw-yl3ln They were referring to the 2019 general election, where Kunssberg tweeted that the postal votes were looking grim for Labour, before the polls closed.
@mccoomer
@mccoomer 2 күн бұрын
@@billtycoon3289saying they look grim, according to her source(s), is not publishing the result.
@linyarin
@linyarin 2 күн бұрын
@@dw-yl3ln It was in the 2019 General Election where she was privileged to view the numbers of postal votes for each party and announced that the Tories seem to have a hugely commanding lead. Coming before people went to the ballot box it was totally unprofessional and illegal and yet nothing was done about it.
@johntipeti4597
@johntipeti4597 2 күн бұрын
biggest failure in world history = brexsh.t
@EllieD.Violet
@EllieD.Violet 2 күн бұрын
Not for us EU27 🇪🇺. We win - both economically and politically.
@fToo
@fToo 2 күн бұрын
so in the past when the exit poll leaked - who did it ?!
@Da1Dez
@Da1Dez 2 күн бұрын
Kinnock should've advised Jo Swinson before doing her 'candidate for prime minister' speech.
@andrewrose7800
@andrewrose7800 3 күн бұрын
His performance at the rally was ridiculous, he didn't seem to realise the electorate don't appreciate these American over the top celebrations. He is a failed politician.
@anthonyrybicki1000
@anthonyrybicki1000 3 күн бұрын
She may not last long in a Starmer cabinet if she wants to keep her principles.
@michaelmouse4024
@michaelmouse4024 3 күн бұрын
Johnson was/is a venal parasite
@neilbower9052
@neilbower9052 4 күн бұрын
it was the BREXSHITTING LIARS that really did that AND the same ones are STILL telling their BREXSHITTING LIEs today
@robertlamont9455
@robertlamont9455 4 күн бұрын
It is loss of faith in democracy in the UK which is destroying belief in politics, that disconnect between 'real' people and manipulators began a long time ago. If that is all Lisa has to offer by way of honesty, her 'significant role' will remain as a sidenote to British history...
@stuartnoyes2615
@stuartnoyes2615 4 күн бұрын
I think trust went for many after delaying brexit. Many lost trust when we were taken into a political union and lied about its true nature.
@neilbower9052
@neilbower9052 4 күн бұрын
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha whatever you say LITTLE ENGLANDER. you brexshitters LIED & LIED & LIED & LIED & LIED & LIED and the people you fooled are now giving you the finger
@BrianRussell-ku8jx
@BrianRussell-ku8jx 4 күн бұрын
What a load of bollocks
@davidmcinnes8290
@davidmcinnes8290 4 күн бұрын
I wouldn't trust Nandy as far as I could sh*t on her. Her hatred for the people of Scotland is well known never mind her being a vile brexiteer.
@hefinjones3385
@hefinjones3385 5 күн бұрын
She's a total waste of space.
@LarryEaton-zc3ck
@LarryEaton-zc3ck 5 күн бұрын
I accept that the tories have had there day but the thought of a Labour Party running the country with people on the shadow front bench does not give me any confidence that things are going to get better and the unions in the back ground pulling the strings
@qeitkas594
@qeitkas594 5 күн бұрын
Lisa Nandy is a Brexiteer and hence I find it hard to take her seriously on her complaint about the difficulties people in her constituency are going through, if Brexit has proven to slash 4% of growth for many years to come. Lisa Nandy is a Corbynista who puts her own believes above the wellbeing of her constituents. Not exactly what the UK needs right now.
@rickerbyct
@rickerbyct 5 күн бұрын
The EU wouldn’t want to touch this nasty toxic island with a barge pole again! That’s the biggest barrier to us rejoining
@JohnnyinMN
@JohnnyinMN 5 күн бұрын
Same woman who said they could cherry pick their way back in. Yeah. Sure. See you in 50 years.
@basda234
@basda234 6 күн бұрын
Surprised this got 200 views, judging the panel quality got about 200 more than I what expected. Well done!
@gilgamecha
@gilgamecha 6 күн бұрын
Always good to hear from her. If she was leading Labour instead of Starmer there would be a landslide.
@alanhat5252
@alanhat5252 6 күн бұрын
Well that was suitably vague. Warm words (lukewarm) & no action like the Torys they're supposedly replacing? I'll be going with the much more positive statements from the Green Party & pray "The Establishment" let them do what they promise.
@julianshepherd2038
@julianshepherd2038 6 күн бұрын
Labour eill have two years to prove themselves before the next Scottish General Election. Or the SNP will crush them. Again.
@rickerbyct
@rickerbyct 6 күн бұрын
I think most people now understand that a tax cut is likely to put tuppence happeney in their pockets but take billions out of the exchequer. Do people really want that extra few bob but to wait hours in A&E, wait years for a routine operation, spin the wheel of fortune everytime they try and catch a train or see their kids in classrooms with Acro-props?
@RF_Burns
@RF_Burns 7 күн бұрын
Britain needs to get its own house in order before trying to fix everyone else's.
@annenunney9907
@annenunney9907 7 күн бұрын
I truly dislike this awful woman is she having a laugh her party voted against a ceasefire in Gaza
7 күн бұрын
Babbling out her paragraphs of derp. "A horizon to work towards", "the prospect of diplomacy working", "the global south". What about sanctions, boycotts, blockades, prosecutions.
@tommynocash2419
@tommynocash2419 8 күн бұрын
Lord kinnock, what a joke
@tommynocash2419
@tommynocash2419 8 күн бұрын
Ramsay Mcdonald was less of a traitor than you
@markmerry1471
@markmerry1471 8 күн бұрын
There is no hope of that.
@timtranslates
@timtranslates 10 күн бұрын
I'm still baffled as to why people rejected AV in the referendum. I wasn't in the UK at the time, so I don't know what people were thinking.
@haydoncooper3744
@haydoncooper3744 11 күн бұрын
Another example of a Windbag spineless MP who has since feathered his own nest over the years.Mind you they were funny times.
@johnmccarron
@johnmccarron 11 күн бұрын
Unless the Tory get the boats fixed and Rewanda