This is saddening although not surprising. Korea is a very xenophobic and homophobic country. Jolin's performance is beyond their comprehension. Their lack of simply enjoying Jolin's performance from the standpoint of professional appreciation says a lot about them as artists as well as individuals.
@FelopohPower8 жыл бұрын
I totally agree with you. Their faces said everything. It is a real shame and pity to see these idols (who are supposed to love and respect any kind of type of art) look at her performance so pissed for something they believe is atrocious. Jolin tsai (in my humble opinion) is one of the most respectful artists througout the asian continent and (why not) the globe. Her style and respectful view of the world (meaning that she does not discriminate between a woman or a man, neither their sexual preferences) has made her the woman she is today!! I'm really upset, and for a moment I'd got the stupid idea of the idols I like to meet her, and the great featuring that they would have been able to create, until I saw this. The only one who deserves my full admiration and respect now is Jolin Tsai.
@MrSmac92428 жыл бұрын
+Felopoh figueroa I think Chow Yun Fat's enjoyment and appreciation of Psy's performance is a good example, if not the complete opposite end of the spectrum, of a true artist supporting and appreciating his fellow artists despite his personal tastes. The U.S. Grammy Awards may be a better example wherein music artists of all heritages, ages, music genres, and political beliefs get together and celebrate each others talents and music and all you need to do look is look out in the audience or into the wings of the stage and you will see people grooving out to whatever artist happens to be performing at the time. I didn't think about this earlier but what is even more disappointing about Got7's reaction is that they are a JYP group. He of all people should be mentoring his groups in the diversity of the world outside of Korea. Back in the day when Jinyoung was gaining success his music and more so his performances were considered scandalous and provocative by Koreans both in and out of Korea but he persevered. He was frequently the object of criticism by the Korean press and public. His music and style was considered anti-Korean by some and it was blamed on him being influenced from when he lived in the U.S. Quite the contrary, it was Jinyoung's exposure to other cultures and other styles of music that made him who he is today. So for him not to pass those experiences and artistry on to his young artists is shameful.
@LDLK8 жыл бұрын
+MrSmac9242 What are you even know about them. Rap Monster (Pink hair with glasses) is very friendly to lgbt, he even said he loved and recommended mackelmore song about homophobia and Recently him and the kid there who sometimes didn't watch the performance (Jungkook) made a cover of song about homosexual love Troye Sivan's fools. They're listening and watching attentively, most these idols usually learning from another performances too thats why they dont give much reaction. Also, that kid Jungkook is a minor. Give him a break.
@genisveil8 жыл бұрын
+篠田麗 This plus there are a lot of idols who are gay and not out and idols who're around lgbt staff in their company I doubt they care at all. idols tend to study a lot at award shows as well like you said.
@MrSmac92428 жыл бұрын
+篠田麗 Thank you for pointing out Rap Monster's and Jungkook's support of LGBT issues. I suspect that because of Mark's and Jackson's origins they too would probably be friendlier to the LGBT community. But anytime one is in a group of people and are of the minority opinion they tend to follow the majority consensus even if it is not their opinion or belief. And in Korea where they are about everything but individualism it would even more difficult for them to express their differing views within their groups whether implicitly or explicitly. The LGBT issue aside. as artists and professional artists at that their lack of enthusiasm for Jolin's performance is shameful.
I think only Jackson & Mark know what she is singing
@wiseprize17977 жыл бұрын
Style_talker_ stalker I believe so too
@hsiaobaby7 жыл бұрын
Style_talker_ stalker mi
@bwangutang4 жыл бұрын
I’ve noticed that with idols, a lot of them don’t clap at the end of a performance. It’s courtesy to do so even if you don’t like it (this is just what I am accustomed to for classical music concerts). Idk about Korean culture, but that’s literally the least they could do for a fellow artist and a respectable one at that...
jungkook should clap even if he was not enjoy it , he should show respect ( and i really like bts and him but still... and sorry for my English ;)
@peace29233 жыл бұрын
@SIR ALEX Even if he doesn't like still she is in Music Industry for more than 20 years isn't it a little disrespectful? I know some members did still! And this is not about hating them!😐! And if you support them no matter what in saying let's both stay quiet as there is no point of fighting! You will support them.😪
@eeew12176 жыл бұрын
她真的不喘耶 跳完马上讲话 也太酷了吧😱
@cweibo4938 жыл бұрын
现如今华语乐坛 女歌手 能跳能唱的 好像也只有蔡依林了吧...
@quicku53066 жыл бұрын
c weibo 沒辦法 華語樂壇只幫抒情歌當回事 超怪的...跟其他國家比起來超怪
@user-bc9vx6ki3n4 жыл бұрын
@@quicku5306 觀眾喜好 JOLIN算少數能紅的唱跳歌手了
@uala08017 жыл бұрын
完全是舞台經歷的深厚功底~蔡依林超棒!!
@keerma73288 жыл бұрын
jhope being the only normal one
@dprsky8 жыл бұрын
Actually... How can you not turn up even a little with that lit ass song... like HOW? V was lowkey turning up too, btw. And Jacksoon too...
@keerma73288 жыл бұрын
what i meant was hobi's reaction was normal comparing to the other memebrs
LMAO they were probably so stunned. Jolin Tsai always slays. let's try not to judge people by one reaction.
@jhc66087 жыл бұрын
請問有注意到子瑜嗎? 我想子瑜應該很嗨吧 (可惜沒錄到)
@katekate17026 жыл бұрын
这全开麦啊,边唱边跳太厉害了,这现场太牛了
@medela19958 жыл бұрын
tae... close ur mouth! i know she is amzing :D
@notamillionaire14308 жыл бұрын
it looks like jungkook is trying to resist looking at the stage lol
@Juju_958 жыл бұрын
+not a millionaire probably getting distracting by fabulous dancers, i think he wanted to focus on jolin
@vl_rs8 жыл бұрын
+not a millionaire Don't think so tbh... He didn't even clap at the end... :( it really seems like he didn't like it imo. Sad, she is a great artist...
@vl_rs8 жыл бұрын
+not a millionaire Don't think so tbh... He didn't even clap at the end... :( it really seems like he didn't like it imo. Sad, she is a great artist...
@lolita96438 жыл бұрын
+Vi Ru (V!Ck'Y) well he watch from another cam
@vl_rs8 жыл бұрын
+lolita9643 yeah. he could've, but the fact that he didn't clapped was obvious.
@syakeera19958 жыл бұрын
I think all the artist think jolin performance is amazing that night bcos u can see all the artist kept their attention to her performance..maybe they did not know how to react bcos of the dancers..hihi...anyway, jolin slayed that night :D
lol so many comments saying they r disappointed, whether its cause of got7's reaction or bts's.. tbh i can understand tho, its their first time seeing the performance, just seeing them all concentrated on the performance had me super happy, and tbh we can't talk bout whether they turned their head to the front cause they were looking away or looking at the screen.. and judging someone by if they clap or not? to me, they looked like they were thinking bout something, and they were staring (whether its screen or the stage), so u never know whats going on in their heads. wow I wrote a long paragraph... but in short, theres nothing to be disappointed about. they r audience just like all the rest of the fans there, and im sure if u take a random reaction video of a fan audience out there, u'll more or less get the same reaction. All we know is, jolin was ranked 2nd on naver after her performance on MAMA, so I think that sums up how she did in general and her performance's impact on korean ppl
@user-ne5ux4wt1g5 жыл бұрын
I like your perspective! Thank you.
@bernicel5748 жыл бұрын
希望哥看得好投入^^
@wateverlyf8 жыл бұрын
Idk about others but markson looked very interested in her perf, esp mark!
I have been Jolin's fan for almost 10 years and I have just become bts's fan for few months. Honestly, I was disappointed to see that most of them showed no reaction for the performance (which I thought was awesome.) I know that they don't understand Mandarin, but still I feel sad...
@RaintoSatoru8 жыл бұрын
+yuri 同感!! 讓我覺得他們很傲慢
@kalvinyeh77528 жыл бұрын
Yes! I'm a huge fan of Jolin, BTS and GOT7 A little disappointed tbh
@sakurash08 жыл бұрын
maybe they don't know who is Jolin Tsai 😣
@NanamiYukiyo8 жыл бұрын
Well you also have to remember that Jolin performed closer to the end of the show and it was like a 7 hour show. They were probably tired
@niitchi7 жыл бұрын
Jolin's performance got them fucking shock. What a legend.
@user-tc7jq7jk4o8 жыл бұрын
感覺厚比和有謙很喜歡的樣子 😂
@JeffreyMais10138 жыл бұрын
後排右三載副歌hook的時候還跟著做了動作XDDDD Jolin FTW!!!
@keerma73288 жыл бұрын
是BTS的V
@marktuanproperty35697 жыл бұрын
Jungkook be like JK: this is too sexy for me but I have to look also JK: no no I shouldn't look
@elesien20858 жыл бұрын
我是個army可是我看完這影片後真的覺得。。挺生氣的。。
@sherrynctzen8 жыл бұрын
????
@Yyxx88 жыл бұрын
为什么??
@user-dm5fc2yz2x8 жыл бұрын
+JiaYi Loo 田正国一直不知道在看哪也不做个反应鼓掌什么的
@Yyxx88 жыл бұрын
+Amy 122 他应该不知道要给什么反应吧😮
@user-qq1xl3ih3y8 жыл бұрын
田看這場的態度我真的不喜歡😒
@jennyann90988 жыл бұрын
Oh gosh her vocal though!!! Amazinggg!!!
@ren24848 жыл бұрын
J-Hope's neck dance😂😂
@vecnapeter72338 жыл бұрын
They can not understand the power of a QUEEN DIVA , Jolin Tsai shines brighter than a supernova
jackson so cool and bambam checking out the girls RV AT 2:27
@pendragon3038 жыл бұрын
3:35 Jb : hey what time doe... Jackson: shush brother the queen has arrived Jb: holy shit do I look , nah amma faint bro.
@mw04037 жыл бұрын
GOT7的成员都很投入去看哦,还跟着节奏摇😆 不过,BTS的柾国好像不在状态呀
@spaceship99618 жыл бұрын
it seems that Mark &Jackson were introducing Jolin to GOT7's other member^V^ JB&YG already enjoy the song. and BTS's member V likes the song,too.
@user-ti4vk1pq3q8 жыл бұрын
我看了五遍👍👍👍
@tomybtsmylittleuniverse74468 жыл бұрын
看過之後 想到的話 我一天都看一次 或許是因為自己是台灣人 所以特別在乎吧😂😂😂
@user-se3vq4li4c7 жыл бұрын
aw yugyeom was clapping at times during the performance and did a thumbs up at 2:22, and youngjae smiled and was bopping a little at around 2:11
@i.jchang74788 жыл бұрын
No on recorded BigBang's reaction??
@jodielin64538 жыл бұрын
want watch +1
@bellet80298 жыл бұрын
bigbang was in backstage that time
@wanchi10245 жыл бұрын
现场的音质 蔡依林绝对实力压倒啊 全开麦 没有对嘴 唱跳的实力真的是功底的完美体现
@amenawhyte20808 жыл бұрын
Why are people saying they're not reacting when most of got7 are bopping along
@sariesy8 жыл бұрын
not much of a reaction because they're probably not used to seeing men (the backup dancers) sexulized the way women are maybe?
@yessirok20857 жыл бұрын
现场好棒,有跳,飙高音,实力啊
@Staryc02168 жыл бұрын
他們感覺真的很想跳 跟著動 可是礙於感覺會被講甚麼 所以不敢 韓國人也真的是很憋= =
@junnnting17478 жыл бұрын
他們聽不懂啊XD
@florencechan11848 жыл бұрын
I think it's more cultural . They dun groove or scream crazy, but it doesn't mean they are bored. They all bow as respect.
@zhaviaunicornpuffs50977 жыл бұрын
The way they reacted to my queen
@user-qk1gi9yz6v8 жыл бұрын
BTS的 J Hope 在2:18~2:30手跟著打節拍😃
@Latitude6318 жыл бұрын
Forget their reactions for a moment. Did anybody else see the director little jump at 2:22 that was hilarious.
@gae4kkura7344 жыл бұрын
I understand they really don't look like there enjoying the music but plss don't think that there agenced her and what she stands for. all of the artists sitting there are really humble and opend minded about culture, lgbt right's, and race, they are all good people and would never disrespect or downgrade anyone. Jackson (guy with the White hair sitting to the left) is like one of the kindest people on earth he cares a lot for people and would always stick up for them no matter who you are or were you come from Namjoon (Guy with the pink hair and glasses) he is the leader of his group and he's one of the best out there he once said he wanted to live in a world were everyone would be treated the same no matter were you come from or who you are and he never misses a chance to correct his members/fans on respecting others and respecting themselves same as Jackson . So plss don't think badly of these guy's
@puzzzzzz8 жыл бұрын
BamBam so cute 😘😘😘😘
@mailtochung5 жыл бұрын
This recording is better than the official one!
@gislainea.49607 жыл бұрын
Jungkook ficou a performance inteira olhando pro nada e no final nem bateu palma. Que nojinho do bias
so many ppl are over analyzing the situation. you can't expect them to look over excited. it's not like it's an artist they are familiar with. besides, if I'm a performing artist that has to sit there for so long after schedules n flight I would be bored n tired too. they can't be cheerful 24/7. I mean we can't do it ourselves so why should we expect them to be so just because they are artist. have you clap n cheer for every speech, event n performance? I know I don't. by that standard I would be the rudest person on earth.
@SMAnthonyW6 жыл бұрын
You don’t clap for your seniors when they give a presentation or performance in school? That’s considered rude, regardless of the culture or circumstances.
@hihithehippo8 жыл бұрын
Ailee walked pad them like a queen!
@TheKuroArisu8 жыл бұрын
Yeahh, I see J-Hope moving a bit, and it looks like V wants to too, but had to compose himself. Quite sad.
Hobi and V can't resist that rhythm lol also Jackson
@lolopopmuax8 жыл бұрын
did anybody saw V with his mouth wide open at the beginning? he was so surprise haha
@abegailuyaan71668 жыл бұрын
Honestly though this was my favourite performance. I was kind of disappointed in the artists I was looking forward to
@urmomascasa8 жыл бұрын
Lol Ailee's diva strut at the end
@winnieguo11257 жыл бұрын
Jolin is really awesome! Some ppl or youngsters may not know her well or like her style but hey, how many Chinese female Singers can Go with her this awesome style and vibe nowadays?! Not many I guess...it really ain't easy
@bangbangwilliams37638 жыл бұрын
oh to the comments why they didn't kpop artist's didn't react to this song,maybe the artists didn't like the song has anyone thought about that for a change. hoiiii
suga probably lowkey checking out the masculine backup dancers in the black pants.
@Hana-li8zf8 жыл бұрын
you can see taehyung going "oooh" "aaah" lol
@vanilaice18207 жыл бұрын
It's pretty normal having this reaction cause most of them don't understand the meaning of this song, not to mention knowing Jolin. And also, these boys are barely minor, they still need to experience what proper social manner is.