18 NEW PALETTES RANKED FROM WORST TO BEST! *Spring & Summer 2024 Palettes Ranked*

[@glaminatrixcosmetics8136]

Number one?! We’re absolutely honoured. Thank you so much Patty. That means the world! ❤

[@PattyAlonso]

Loooooveeeeeee Barely Basics!

[@glaminatrixcosmetics8136]

@@PattyAlonso we are so glad 🥺❤️

[@jessicarauch1525]

I love it how you bounced back after your maternity leave and kept the channel the same! Congrats on that ! As a mom of 2 I know it’s tough. So many influencers slowly disappear or change to a mommy channel. I’m so happy you have kept true to your audience!!❤❤

[@kristentrep5038]

I totally agree! She’s still a makeup lover, and understands her audience! I understand how some folks can get caught up in being a new mommy.. (lots of us have children, so we get it) but we are here for the makeup and reviews!

[@WildeBookGarden]

I love the description of stepping out of the box but not out of your comfort zone - I think that's a great way of making playing with makeup more approachable!

[@klinzer1]

No apology necessary for not doing dedicated videos for some palettes as you are a new mommy. You’re doing so great and you look beautiful and happy. Thank you for your great reviews!

[@rebeccawainwright4515]

The Fantasy Cosmetica palette is incredible! Your eye look reminds me so much of Mothership X too

[@bevyoung2009]

Patty your makeup looks gorgeous 😍

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

Thank you for the honesty❤ It gets so exhausting listening to people say everything is amazing and great. It isn't possible. This was a breath of fresh air!

[@kathleenmoul3630]

Great video, Palettes are my most favorite beauty purchase, so I LOVE this type of review.

[@PattyAlonso]

Yay! Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it! ❤️

[@PriscillaLange]

“Scam in a quad” 💀

[@melindamorarie1251]

I just got barely basic in the mail last week and it’s STUNNING ❤❤❤

[@kristentrep5038]

I’m such a fan of indie sparkles and shimmers! I wear a ton of multichromes, and let me just say.., I get compliments daily on whatever I’ve got on my eyes!

[@kerriwright4593]

The look you're wearing is so so so beautiful 😍 whatever it is, i needs it.

[@asiyadua9590]

Need a tutorial on today's eye look! Amazing as always:)

[@5464916]

Patty, wow the adept cosmetics Amy Loves palette - are you kidding me?? Why haven’t I heard about it before and I need it on my eyes now. What a gorgeous color story and wow the shimmers are out of this world. I haven’t seen a palette like that like ever. Just mine with your discount code. Thank you!!❤

[@Amber86queenbee]

Love how many indie brands you review so we can see all the sparkly immaculate shimmer formulas. I hope you consider reviewing Ensley Reign such as the cold moon palette in the future as they have quickly become a key player for the indie beauty community.

[@EliseMarquamJahns]

I so love your wonderful enthusiasm! Thank you for sharing your favorites in such detail. Several years ago I tried a Sigma palette and was really disappointed with the formula, so I was glad to hear you say that you've felt they've improved the formula. The Sigma palette I've been so tempted to try is the collaboration with Angela Bright since I love the color story, but I've hesitated because of my concern about the formula. I'd be so grateful if you could let me know if you'd consider the Angela Bright palette one of the Sigma palettes with an improved formula. Thanks so much!

[@Observette]

Yes, what is going on with Pat Mcgrath!?? 😭 Awesome ranking Patty! 🎉

[@alexismorgan4809]

What about Natasha Denona's Golden palette?

[@bedazzledbuddhist]

Congrats on the new baby! In case you didn’t see it, I made a video all about every PMG eyeshadow and used your channel to help me research it. Thank you! Fingers crossed MSXII comes out soon.

[@Mikeyblazer2]

Hello.xx, you are literally awesome ❤❤❤😍♥️ You are my favorite makeup 💄 artist literally ❤❤🥰 I ♥️ you Patty Alonso ♥️ Take care ❤❤

[@5464916]

When Patty looks up close and says “Do it” - I listen lol

[@angelb0621]

I love that adept pallet, but I have so many eyeshadows…ugh 😂

[@bevyoung2009]

I like blue, I bought the ND mini in blues.

[@kerriwright4593]

With all of the new foundations being released, can you do another foundation ranking for this year?

[@lalainarandria8217]

Obsessed with your makeup❤

[@EnvyBlu]

I want the Sigma and the Amy Loves palettes so badly 😩 I hope they’re available for awhile.

[@Jaegeler762]

I know the problem with the crying eye. Damn house dust allergy. Thank you for your Videos 🙂

[@jeanninet.5010]

Thank goodness for the indy brands and their colorful palettes. Browns and neutrals are so overdone.

[@randomly_generated_]

Where is the mothership? What is actually happening with PMG??

[@kristenmckinney6706]

I know!! The mothership usually releases in July but we didn’t get one!

[@randomly_generated_]

​​@@kristenmckinney6706 I know! I think they're deleting comments about the mothership on insta as well. I saw loads of comments earlier in the summer but I don't see them anymore. Something must have gone really wrong with production, or there is major disagreement about the direction in which to take PMG. Patty, we need to the gossip! What is the rumour on the grapevine??

[@Observette]

What is happening!? It’s like whoever’s in charge just gave up on the brand! 😮

[@omegasobsessions]

@@ObservetteI think it is a board rather than a person so there’s the problem. A big circle jerk by dudes who don’t know squat about makeup but know lots about profit margins.

[@bevyoung2009]

Hello beautiful Patty 😍

[@Svp83]

The moonshroom palette let me down too ! I thought I was trippin. Lol formula was meh . I’ll never buy another one again from lunar beauty .

[@xxdesiire]

I was sorry that the pat quad was last and you were so disappointed with it because l was thinking of purchasing it.

[@lavayuki]

I wonder if we will ever get anything good from Pat again, all her recent releases have been rubbish. The last good thing she released was probably her last mothership but even that was not as good as the other ones. So far the ND I need a warm palette is my favourite one, followed by mini rose and then the new Lisa Eldridge fawn palette

[@AngelaHathaway-lt9hr]

This color story looks so much like Blend Bunny’s All Done Up, I can’t help but think it’s a copy. I wouldn’t say “dupe” because it’s so much more expensive.

[@Brandi_the_Baker]

Which palette?

[@sarahboden2018]

You ranking a pmg, low must be pretty bad formula considering pmg is one of your favorite brands

[@WendsSc]

❤ algorithm

[@ioanam257]

❤

[@antoinettezepeda433]

👍

[@bevyoung2009]

15 no

[@steph_the_franco]

Unearthly Cosmetics custumer service sucks. They don't reply to their customers.

[@bevyoung2009]

18 is terrible.

[@mayumin8347]

You don't look likw basic lover😅😅

[@bevyoung2009]

16 yuck