2. Taraweeh: Umar's Innovation | Night 2 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445

Night 2 | Topic: Taraweeh - Holy Ramadan 2024/1445
London, U.K.
2. Taraweeh: Umar's Innovation | Night 2 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445
Taraweeh - Ammar Nakshawani - Ramadan 2024
Ammar Nakshawani reply to Zakir Naik
#AmmarNakshawani #Ramadan2024 #Taraweeh
--------------------------
Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!
www.sayedammar.com

[@brunopropheta]

I was asking myself about Tarawih last night, since I'm a revert I always look for answers on both sides Sunni and Shia, but honestly I prefer Shia theology and jurisprudence in general, hence why I'm a follower of the Ahlul Bayt

[@abbas-bg3dd]

Mashallah.. May allah guide you further in your life like this ❤

[@abdulelkobaitry3402]

You either are choosing the easier way or your a liar or your misguided so go do some studying

[@99knight]

@@abdulelkobaitry3402 School of Ahlulbayt is pure

[@abdulelkobaitry3402]

Your whole claim of the prophet never done it when we bring up over 100 things that shias do today, for example find me one source from your books or our books where the prophet saw said " ya ali" or "ya hussien". Even if its not in making dua to them its the way where your saying " ya allah for the sake of ali" like this liar claims. Show me the proof that this was ever done by the the prophet saw or by any of the ahlul bayt, from sunnu or shia books please. You see the difference between what we do has kept generations of people practicing a sunnah of the prophet and what you do which has turned generations into thinking your making dua to ali. And nakashwani cant refute this because he made a video trying to teach shias the meaning of it, clearly showing that its a big misconception with their people.

[@abdulelkobaitry3402]

And check my other comments for more my brother

[@Maryam-sh1oh]

I am a revert Muslim many years now , actually I am a Shia because I read the books of Hadiths of Sunni mostly so I ve got my answers why to follow Shia ! I am a happy Muslim and fully satisfied of my practices ! Blessed Ramadan to everyone ! ❤

[@zaroso766_official]

Mashalah. Hope that you may be granted paredise.

[@sullyqureshi676]

Hitting yourself is Bidah, praying on stone is Bidah and combining Salah without reason is Bidah. They are worse Bidah than Taraweeh.

[@certificated]

Welcome to the perfect family

[@hammadhussain4422]

​@@sullyqureshi676 "Praying on stone " and " combining Salah without reason" is a well documented Sunnah even according to sunni sources . hitting yourself can be bidah if you take it as a part of Deen instead of cultural practice. Some cultural practices are not against religion therefore can be practiced . You can mourn for your loved ones according to your culture.

[@shaheensssss]

@@sullyqureshi676you make it sound like a bidah competition. You have to accept the facts of this lecture. It’s made me think.

[@SyedRizvii]

This is a great format. We've been missing this type of rebuttal from Shia Western scholars and Alhamdulillah Sayed has taken up this initiative. JazakAllah Khair

[@mostafahusain7724]

Am I the only one that wants all the lectures of ramathan to be out right now so that I can watch them all right now?

[@RFD313]

Wait untill the month is over and play them all on a playlist 😏🤓

[@Mohdzn]

I agree with u, but it’s too much knowledge to obtain all at once.

[@gettingfaster801]

hes got tonnes of other videos and most revolve around this topic go through channel

[@JacK__90]

Yes you may be the only one..

[@gettingfaster801]

@@JacK__90 abit of cognitive dissonance? cant handle the truth?

[@mfbx6tk3]

Fantastic. Barik Allahu feek. This is not an attempt to convert anyone, like a missionary. This series is only for the people to open their minds. As was the sunnah of RasoolAllah ﷺ

[@YaaALI313]

Your lectures gives me strenght on the path thank you i feel very lonely in my countrie as a shia

[@liahnatashahalihassan8033]

me too.. where do your from ? i just learn through youtube and sources from google. u r not lonely brother/sister.

[@Bruno-jt3um]

Same here , where are u from dear?

[@S.O.A.M.C-]

May Allah be with you !

[@SameerHaiderAbbas]

where are you from. All of you?

[@tawabturkmani1838]

​@liahnatashahalih Allah is with you and Nabi SAWW and his family cheering you for being on the right path. As true followers of Nabi SAWW were all less in numbers but stronger in imaan and logic and on the haqq. May Allah bless you, protect you and always guide you 😊assan8033

[@FalconsHighAbove]

This is a great lecture. It is time that people open their eyes to truth. Thank you Dr Ammar for the great work during this holiest month of all.

[@Carmen-ex3nr]

Thank you for clarifying this subject. I am a convert and I didn't know this.

[@iMan-610]

Prophet a.s himself prayed Nawafil prayers during Nights of Ramadan.

[@Islam_will_prevail]

subhanallah

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@rezasadventures1352]

Well don't rest just yet search about shia and sunni sect and confirm the truth yourself don't let anybody prevent you from researching and getting knowledge

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

@@rezasadventures1352 yeah I did and found Halala in Shia 😅😂😂

[@theinformant101]

I was born in Sunni household, i identify myself as just Muslim. I totally agree with brother Sayed Ammar in this matter.

[@iMan-610]

He is manipulating. Prophet a.s himself prayed Nawafil Night prayer during Ramadan. Umar only made it to be prayed on Congregation.

[@batoolsleiman8519]

@@iMan-610That’s the point.. praying nawafil in congregation is a bid’ah. It angered the prophet (pbuh&hf). Why is it preached as an obligatory prayer in the month of Ramadan? Why not use your time to focus on aamal that were recommended by the Prophet (pbuh&hf) and actually benefit you?

[@doctor8417]

The people who r saying nawafil can't b prayed in jammat r wrong here bcz prophet saw did lead d prayers for 3 days.... But after tat he( saw ) stopped...he(saw) feared Allah tala can make these night prayers farz.... About umar (ra) he only made it easy for those who doesn't knw reading of quran... Any act of prophet (saw) even it is done once it's sunnah... There r several examples regarding this type of practice were prophet (saw) done act only one never again but still those practices considered as sunnah...... In this case both Shia and Sunni brother r rt If u pray there is sawab If u don't no harm.... It's not bidah.... Who ever say it's bidah... Simply he doesn't knw d definition of bidah.... Unfortunately Allah knows best.....

[@MOkera786]

​@doctor8417 dude umar himself said its a bida'a 😂 Arent u listening at all? Or u jst came to comment ?

[@adgame0625]

​@@MOkera786 the prophet still did it 😊

[@Madenia_Bedford]

Proof given and shown…. Great lecture Sayyed Ammar

[@iMan-610]

Prophet a.s himself prayed Nawafil prayer during Nights of Ramadan

[@iMan-610]

Shias have even changed the Shahada & Adhan.

[@batoolsleiman8519]

@@iMan-610I’m guessing you didn’t watch the video lol. Do you know what nawafil means?

[@MustaphaMuazu-el6fc]

After all the proofs you are still blabbing, your heart is blind

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@skanthaadsigns]

I am a revert Muslim via Hidayah, Guided, although in a Sunni nation but inam Guided to ah Lulbyat/Shia, Jaafari, Ismaili & Zaydi wisdom

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@norahbenbrik314]

He should do how cross in g the arms came into Salah… these things are what made me convert from being a Sunni to Shia.

[@glitch_abbossii1889]

salam, we don't cross our arms in salah but we put our arms strait down. kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZurinSjfp2mg8U&ab_channel=ImamHusseinTV3 this video should give you an idea

[@SubTheHan]

subhanallah. the world needs this.

[@CricEditzOP]

This lecture is a slap on the face of those people who say shia do bid'at

[@mohammedalivakil7434]

Sayed Ammar's profound knowledge with documentary evidence of Tarawi being an innovation is an eye opener for all whi seeks to know the truth

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@3ahmad1zeino3]

this man is the goat of shia lecturing... the discussion is finished.

[@davidayoubi1967]

One of the most evil things about this Tarawhe is this: It puts people, families, communities on the spot for being Judged by each other as to who attends this ritual and who does not. It puts a harsh burden on those working people who have to go to work the next day. It shoves the religion down people's throat, therefore creating a loss of interest in the religion. That is exactly what Omar ibn Khatab was trying to do. To make each and every Muslim dislike this extra burden. Also, this was a way to figure to out who are the Shia's in the community and to weed them out and persecute them and eventually kill them. Omar had created a spy state through Tarawhe and all of the successor excluding Imam Alis A. S. used this tool to control the masses. They also used the pulpit in the same manner by either bribing or forcing the clergyman to spread falsehood which suited their power grab.

[@iMan-610]

Taraweeh is not obligatory prayer. Prophey a.s himself prayed Night prayer during Ramadan. Umar only made it to be prayed in congregation

[@kawtharkasole4127]

​@@iMan-610 Why would he do that

[@70newlife]

​@@kawtharkasole4127Umar himself never prayed Taraveeh. He instructed people to get behind an imam and pray Tahajudd in jama because they were wasting time sitting and talking or having multiple jamat in same masjid. He himself went and prayed.

[@Moonzzie]

@@kawtharkasole4127because the prophet (pbuh) did aswell. its a sunnah

[@Moonzzie]

evil???? harsh burden??? loss of religion??? ITS OPTIONAL. YOU CAN PRAY AT HOME. STOP SPREADING LIES. subhanallah calling a sunnah prayer a 'ritual'.

[@Farhadmusic29]

Salaam alaikum brothers & sisters, Excellent lectures by Doctor Nakshawani... thank you for sharing from the source... directly from the hadiths. Beautiful... may Allah guide and protect us to the right path. 🤲

[@Dalida143]

اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد الطيبين الطاهرين المعصومين

[@RUNESCAPER123]

The fact Omar (LA) said that taraweeh is a good innovation/bid'ah is ridiculous. Also the fact that he denied the Prophet SAWA from writing his final will and saying "this man is delirious, the quran is enough for us", what about him running away from numerous battles like a coward? oh, what about when he slapped his sister for accepting Islam? the list just goes on and on. What an absolute coward.

[@omarazmery]

Don’t worry about Omar worry about who was first shia 😂😂Lol

[@SAMoussavi]

@@omarazmeryyeah it was your mom, shame on her

[@HassanNazir-uy6do]

Go and do your research mate​@@omarazmery

[@jameso8711]

1) Tarawih in jama’ah is bid’ah, not the prayer in and of itself. 2) For the Sunni world, they are following Umar because they view him as a mujtahid. It is no different than following Sayed Al-Sistani in a ruling that he has derived, which may not be explicitly stated in the corpus works. If we look at our own practices, there is no doubt that certain aspects that we practice weren’t practiced by the Ahlulbayt (as). For instance, majalis to commemorate the 20th day of Imam Hussain, or the 30th day. Or even the Mawlid, the Ahlulbayt were happy and celebratory on the Mawlid, but did they gather in mosques and distribute sweets and recite poetry of happiness? No. It is a bid’ah, but it’s not wrong because there is no harm in it. You are simply gathering in a halal and honourable way to remember them. Tarawih has more benefits than harm. If we’re saying it’s bid’ah based on principle, then we have to stop our own bid’ah. If we are saying it’s bid’ah to have a jab at Umar, then what’s the point? You’re not going to change anyone’s mind. For Sunnis, Umar is a mujtahid who made a ruling. If he is wrong, Allah will reward him and if he is right, Allah will reward him - and the people who follow the fatwa will also not be punished. That’s how Taqlid works for both schools of thought.

[@rkcapo74]

@@omarazmerydon’t comment emotional comment with reasonable Hadith and proves.

[@larabasma823]

Brilliant analysis of resources. Jazakallah sayed Ammar. To the keyboard warriors: pls watch the lecture, and listen to it with eyes and ears open, welcoming the knowledge, then type in your comments. There is a whole section in the lecture dedicated to (you) defenders of Umar

[@paimei26]

go back to being someones mistress for 10mins in iran

[@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim]

Sayed Ammar Nakshawani cannot be resisted!

[@whysthat123]

Too logical. May Allah bless him. And you. Ramadan Mubarak

[@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim]

@@whysthat123 Thank you bro. Allah bless you and your family. Ramadaan Mubarak!

[@iMan-610]

His lies soon will be exposed Inshallah. Umar didnt inovate Taraweeh prayer. Prophet a.s himself prayed Night prayers during Ramadan.

[@Mombi786]

​@@iMan-610if watch the video, he agrees the prophet prayed night prayers but it was by himself. There is a big difference here and he explains the hadith where the prophet tells his companions to pray to Allah in private. If the prophet felt this prayer needed to be prayed in congregation, he would have done it. However he didn't, and Umar did by innovating this prayer hence it's bidah as not done by the prophet in congregation.

[@Warlock786]

@@iMan-610 Dude are you blind or jsut stupid ? Did you not see the video ?

[@user-pr8ov5yc4n]

You are awesome we (Shia)are proud of having a scholar like you ….May Allah(SWT) and RasoolAllah with his Ahlulbath (AS) protect you ….Ameen

[@Mohdzn]

Thank u sayedna, I kiss ur hand. May Allah lengthen ur life and grant all ur hajat in this holy month of ramazan

[@dilaverali05]

Mashallah Dr. Ammar, May Allah swt bless you with abundance of happiness and prosperity. Alhamdulillah I benefited a lot from your lecture.

[@Sarah.M5]

May ALLAH protect you and bless you you‘re doing such an important work 🤲🏼

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@AK002-sp5ho]

Jami` at-Tirmidhi 806 Abu Dharr narrated: "We fasted with the Prophet, so he did not pray (the night prayer) with us until seven (nights) of the month remained. Then he (pbuh) led us in prayer until a third of the night had gone, then he did not lead us in prayer on the sixth. Then he led us in prayer on the fifth until half of the night had gone. We said to him: 'O Messenger of Allah! Wouldn't you lead us in prayer for the remainder of the night?' He said: 'Indeed, whoever stands (praying) with the Imam until he finished, then it is recorded for him that he prayed the whole night.; Then he did not lead us in prayer until three (nights) of the month remained. Then he led us in prayer on the third and he called his family and his women to pray with us until we feared missing the Falah" I (Jubair bin Nufair) said to him: "What is the Falah" He said: "The Suhur." Please explain this hadith

[@gettingfaster801]

prayed what? Qada?

[@UmalkhairAsghar]

Oh man what a epic point to point lecture 😮 just mind blowing 🤯 the way you are delivering lecture with profs is just a classy thing . May Allah reward you ameen always a fan ❤

[@theniwasguided8360]

SUUNi scholars hide these things from their people bcz they earn a lot of money through this prayer, called Taraweeeeh.

[@jameso8711]

1) Tarawih in jama’ah is bid’ah, not the prayer in and of itself. 2) For the Sunni world, they are following Umar because they view him as a mujtahid. It is no different than following Sayed Al-Sistani in a ruling that he has derived, which may not be explicitly stated in the corpus works. If we look at our own practices, there is no doubt that certain aspects that we practice weren’t practiced by the Ahlulbayt (as). For instance, majalis to commemorate the 20th day of Imam Hussain, or the 30th day. Or even the Mawlid, the Ahlulbayt were happy and celebratory on the Mawlid, but did they gather in mosques and distribute sweets and recite poetry of happiness? No. It is a bid’ah, but it’s not wrong because there is no harm in it. You are simply gathering in a halal and honourable way to remember them. Tarawih has more benefits than harm. If we’re saying it’s bid’ah based on principle, then we have to stop our own bid’ah. If we are saying it’s bid’ah to have a jab at Umar, then what’s the point? You’re not going to change anyone’s mind. For Sunnis, Umar is a mujtahid who made a ruling. If he is wrong, Allah will reward him and if he is right, Allah will reward him - and the people who follow the fatwa will also not be punished. That’s how Taqlid works for both schools of thought.

[@theniwasguided8360]

@@jameso8711 Tarawee itself is Bidaa.... Mujtahid deduce rulings from Quran and Hadiths

[@alizaboom]

@@jameso8711 tarawih is bidah because the Prophet quite literally said not to do it lol. You don’t need to run in circles with this one sir. The two examples u gave about Shi’ism are derived from practices that were established by the ahlulbayt, there’s no comparison to tarawih.

[@iMan-610]

Prophet a.s himself prayed Nawafil Night prayer during Ramadan. Umar only made it to be prayed on Congregation. ​@@alizaboom

[@muhibbualii4580]

​@@jameso8711As salaam aleikum warahmatullah wabarakatu, habeebi you've a respectful way of seeing why the masses follow Umar on this. The analogy of taqlid and the example of Umar are way different because Umar did an open innovation that he's proud of. The maraajii on the other hand deduce texts based on a number of reasons i.e hadeeths from Ahlulbayt ,Qur'an,etc.....imam Ali's reaction to taraweeeh being the soul of rasulallah should be enough proof to refute taraweeeh.

[@nasreenkhader1910]

Alhamdullilah. What a lecture. An eye opener for me.

[@fpsFAMOUS]

Alhamdulillah., they've been exposed! 🤲 The evil ones wanted to take FULL control of Islam and change it like other faiths they've been able to change.

[@Sam-yu4yy]

Short and sharp lectures , great idea for Ramadan , thank you to the team for coming up with them and Syed Amar

[@kalamuddin4253]

Am a sunni , sunni scholars they lied before saying if u dont do Tara wih your fasting will not be valid , now they say its not true ,before they said it to push people into it

[@user-zo3jj7sv7b]

Omg I cant believe they say that 😑

[@theslicer22]

Lol where did you hear this haha not true

[@batoolsleiman8519]

Mashallah, every point presented with visual evidence that cannot be disputed. May the hearts of the true believers be enlightened and open to the truth.

[@butulzehrabz4233]

That Smile, when youve Proofs ❤

[@nilofarsayed2516]

Thank you Dr. Ammar Nakshawani for this great lecture! ❤

[@taqoastudio557]

I've been listening to syed since 15 years, Always treat to listen him.

[@Zhraalmusawi]

Such a great lecture!! May Allah bless you Sayed 🙏🏽

[@SameerHaiderAbbas]

You are unbeatable. Thank you Syed Amaar 😊

[@salmanjaffri2539]

Speakers Corners peeps mobilizing right now lol.

[@zehrabhanji4247]

Salaams n Duas from kenya. What a wonderful lecture. May Allah SWA keep u under his protection always. 🤲 Ameen

[@shakirakamula8221]

Thanks for putting up this as I requested it was much needed

[@aliasad7346]

Love from Pakistan ammar shia islam ❤

[@abdelqadir5227]

The comments for sure will be insuls or changing the topic or myths against shias. As always. It hurts when the truth is from their own very books, oh it hurts so bad. He will be called liar for reading from an authentic book

[@toninaaliyah5451]

I love that you’re doing this like kamal al hiederi ( sorry for misspelling). Ramadan karim to all my brothers and sisters ❤!

[@No-qwewe]

Thanks❤

[@AMIRVAFA]

Very clear proof!!! I chose the Shia theology. It makes so much more sense. Ya Ali❤

[@salifuabdulmumin6485]

Dr. Ammar, thank you for the educative and passionate presentation. The objective minded people do understand. We are grateful. God bless you.

[@shiashameem3545]

I thank Allah for letting me know the holy family (pput) they're our best examples of how to be a good servant of God

[@AliAkbar_313]

I love how the comment section is open and there is no sunni in sight

[@aminahussain6915]

Bless you brother Ammar for this lecture!!!

[@theupperroom1]

Allahuma sallay aala Muhammad wa aal-e-Muhammad Wa Ajal Farajahum Wa Lan’al Adhom

[@sakinakassam2434]

The sunnis also say that we delay our fast and going against what rasululah (saw) said hasten to break you fast and don't delay....can you address this next time..please

[@AH-zf5on]

yes i need this too

[@Trime_467]

For the algorithm + Best series we needed

[@firdosRS]

Masha Allah Sayed. Great lecture 👌

[@weebob2803]

MashaAllah Sayid very well explained. May Allah swt bless you. JazakAllah khair.

[@ksvlogs5995]

Last night I have questions about tarawha but you clearly answered me which question were in mind thanks...

[@nusratfatima4258]

Amazing

[@syedadeelali786]

Amazing work ❤

[@habibanathani3747]

But despite of refering all sunni book of hadees They will up with not discussing but attacking the shia

[@iMan-610]

This liar already read the hadith when people were praying Nawafil Night prayer during Ramadan. Umar only made it to be prayed on Congregation

[@crocified]

​@@iMan-610when the Prophet pbuh refrained people from praying nawafil in congregation? Who was umar to prioritise his commands when the Prophet pbuh commanded something and do you prioritise the Infallible prophet pbuh or a fallible convert? A man who has knowledge of everything or the man who half of the time of his life remained a mushrik and gave rulings and sermons contradicting to the quran?

[@AH-zf5on]

​@iMan-610 Not liar. He told what Night prayer is. He said no Jamah.

[@saqh.4439]

Very clear Sayed ❤

[@xoxomanutdfan]

Amazing lecture!

[@AH-zf5on]

The last two minutes were hard. May Allah swt help them immediately Ya Allah Ya Rab😢

[@omersuliman_]

proud follower of ahlul bayt 🩵

[@syedakiran223]

Jazakallah

[@amazing.2079]

Great keep it up

[@awababdullah3963]

Thank u Sayed ❤

[@whysthat123]

Jazakum Allah khairan teacher. Ramadan Mubarak.

[@dinam1349]

May allah bless you alhamdulillah for being shia🤲🏼

[@mahnaz5217]

he really said to the sunnies: in your face, mic drop !

[@runeline9463]

Subscribed to the channel appreciate this lectures Sayed Jazakallah Khair from Australia

[@peterlorenzen2000]

Ahsant Sayed.

[@AbdullahMTarek]

Amazing episode Sayedna ❤

[@liahnatashahalihassan8033]

assalamualaikum sayed .Salam Ramdhan to you and your family.

[@Showtimedaguy]

Wa Alaikum Salaam Rahmantulahi wa Barakatu 💚

[@aliishahh]

Alhamdulillah

[@Dogru__Yol]

ALLAH. Razi olsun

[@MrPanda.23]

Proud to be shia. Alhamdolilah, I’m very fortunate I was born in a shia household.

[@alnabba]

Very interesting 👌

[@sim-ej3xn]

I did not know this. I just followed what my father and his father used to do.

[@Dailyversion]

Learn your religion rather inheriting- Imam Ali (as)

[@azataliking8302]

Exposing Sunni beliefs. Great work Ammar God bless you

[@designerpacks3065]

i love this guy we need more multi language sayeds

[@ice2kewl112]

I'm a Muslim. I read the Quran and pray Salatul Layl as extra worship particularly in Ramadhan. May Allah save us from innovation in religion. "...Will you not use reason?" 7.169. I would go on to further saying that engaging in religious innovation is shirk! See 6.121. Some questions for Nakshawani/Shia: You believe that Jummah and Eid prayers are only obligatory during the time of an infallible. Why then do you pray these as well as the prayer for rain (which isn't obligatory) in congregation? Is that not contradicting your position of 'only obligatory prayers in congregation?' Secondly, what is the grading of the Shia hadith you presented? I think at a minimum, only hadith classed as 'authentic' by the rijali standard should be presented. If you disagree, please explain why?

[@AH-zf5on]

That means thats a Wajib if possible Some people cant pray Salah Jumuah and it has no Qadha. Eid prayer thr same.

[@ice2kewl112]

​@@AH-zf5on Actually, the Shia believe that Jummah and Eid prayers are only obligatory when there is an infallible imam present. That is, jummah can only take place behind a 'just leader'. This is why, in my imambargah, we would pray Jummah as a sunnah in congregation, then pray Zuhr individually, then pray Asr in congregation. There are even some extreme Shia that say Jummah is forbidden during the absence of an infallible, because only they can be a just leader, and everyone else is unjust. The issue with this take though, is Allah requires two just witnesses for a divorce as per Surah At-Talaq. So, I wonder how the extreme group would go about seeking a divorce when they believe there is no just people present!

[@ahditah8102]

Thank you for this work you are doing. I really Need it ❤

[@husseinbandali991]

An excellent lecture by sheikh Ammar.This was very well put and clear.I am just wondering ,couldnt this argument also apply to all the sunnat acts of worship we do as part of the muharram ritual as they never existed at the prophets time.

[@masaratimoe24]

All the Sunnis that are ignorant usually love commenting under all the Shia pages on every platform, when evidence is shown from their own books there’s nothing to make up from their side now…Smh…Shia have proof and evidence on everything of why they do it or don’t do it and the Quran and Sunni/Shia hadith always back it up.

[@najumabanoo2006]

Thnku soo much for such a knowledgeable lectures ❤❤❤

[@winstonbachan9661]

You are a wise man stick to your Schools of Thoughts! It's beautiful! If all Muslims be like Shia, O how wonderful Islam will be! ☮️

[@workout-7050]

InshaAllah one day sunni will realize how many lies molvi has told them.

[@mohamedrawji9691]

May Allah bless you. Amen

[@Aaron-188]

24:37 ‘Excellent Bidah’ wow

[@davidayoubi1967]

wonderful talk, thank you, May Allah S.W.T. bless you in this holy moth. would you please include this in one of your lectures in the next few days? Sura Fatha, first 3 verses. We the Shia believe the Prophet P.B.H. was infallible. This verse is very confusing. إِنَّا فَتَحْنَا لَكَ فَتْحًۭا مُّبِينًۭا ١ لِّيَغْفِرَ لَكَ ٱللَّهُ مَا تَقَدَّمَ مِن ذَنۢبِكَ وَمَا تَأَخَّرَ وَيُتِمَّ نِعْمَتَهُۥ عَلَيْكَ وَيَهْدِيَكَ صِرَٰطًۭا مُّسْتَقِيمًۭا ٢

[@abdelqadir5227]

the word ghafara is not limited to forgiveness but does mean protection here. Allah has protected RasouluLah SAWW from past and future sins

[@user-jy8uf8nw1q]

MashAllah very well explained Syed

[@ukke83]

The things you said are known to most sunnis. We also use this as evidence to refute the salafis their concept of bida. This is not why we differ with shia. Dont put all sunnis under the same brush.

[@shovonarafatrahmankhan4418]

What an amazing lecture!

[@mariyasam2411]

God bless you Sayed Ammar. This is needed for people to open their minds to these things.

[@sabika33]

AOA. Please tell me where can I donate??

[@Syed.Sher1]

Imam Hussein Tv or TheZahraTrust

[@AH-zf5on]

29:45-30:15 on point!

[@roni_aust1594]

Yes the prophet did not come out. But when he did he said. I was afraid that it would become complusory for you. So that's why he did not lead that prayer.

[@asadabbas8844]

What is your point?

[@rcmysm9123]

The point is we follow the prophet pbuh, those who do this prayer in congregation follow the one who admitted he innovated it. Alhamdulillah!

[@jameso8711]

@@rcmysm9123 1) Tarawih in jama’ah is bid’ah, not the prayer in and of itself. 2) For the Sunni world, they are following Umar because they view him as a mujtahid. It is no different than following Sayed Al-Sistani in a ruling that he has derived, which may not be explicitly stated in the corpus works. If we look at our own practices, there is no doubt that certain aspects that we practice weren’t practiced by the Ahlulbayt (as). For instance, majalis to commemorate the 20th day of Imam Hussain, or the 30th day. Or even the Mawlid, the Ahlulbayt were happy and celebratory on the Mawlid, but did they gather in mosques and distribute sweets and recite poetry of happiness? No. It is a bid’ah, but it’s not wrong because there is no harm in it. You are simply gathering in a halal and honourable way to remember them. Tarawih has more benefits than harm. If we’re saying it’s bid’ah based on principle, then we have to stop our own bid’ah. If we are saying it’s bid’ah to have a jab at Umar, then what’s the point? You’re not going to change anyone’s mind. For Sunnis, Umar is a mujtahid who made a ruling. If he is wrong, Allah will reward him and if he is right, Allah will reward him - and the people who follow the fatwa will also not be punished. That’s how Taqlid works for both schools of thought.

[@SparringHighlights]

@@jameso8711 The Hadith about the night prayers in Ramadan clearly states it is better for the believers to pray at home. Also, to NOT congregate them. This is the sunnah of the prophet. Taraweeh is clearly sunnah of Umar which goes against the prophets wishes. The Prophet did not say “but after I die you can pray them in congregation.”

[@kazimsyed7367]

Why would prophet stop his ummah from optional prayers. You can do optional prayers but u can't do it by jammat(in congregation). Quran and the prophet came us to teach how to please Allah. If prophet didn't practice Tarabeh. Than it's anti-Sunnah.

[@certificated]

Fantastic analysis