[2017 SBS 가요대전] 트와이스(TWICE), 소녀들의 당차고 발랄한 매력 어필(a charming stage) 'Heart Shaker'

[@TruMuslima]

But Nayeon being in the Centre for the chorus is perfect. She brings so much energy and happiness with her vocals and smile. How come people never talk about her. I'm not a once but Nayeon Jihyo Jeongyun and Tzyu always stand out with their vocals to me, and Nayeon and Jihyo with their energy and big smiles.

[@smolchaengster7335]

Chaeriana Grande.. I mean Chaeyoung 😙😙 Wow Jihyo looks so glamorous, they all do as usual but God is a standout beaut here 😍😍

[@minari8518]

NaJeongMoSaJiMiDaChaeTzu slayyyyy

[@basicbiscuit4625]

The most noticeable things that show that it's live are that the rappers are saying their lines differently from all of their other performances and Jihyo' voice also sounds a lot thinner

[@chidera1113]

I think is their first live singing of heartshaker. They’ve improved so much 💕

[@uva8884]

They sang "heart Shaker" for the first time live on December 15 on kpop tv.

[@chidera1113]

@@uva8884 I meant live as in not using pre-recorded vocals.

[@uva8884]

@@chidera1113 In that case I go back and repeat that it was December 15 for "kpop tv" if you mean not using pre-recorded voices

[@neoreulboyeojwo1496]

They lipped this one tho

[@chidera1113]

@@neoreulboyeojwo1496 The cue sheet leaked and showed they didn’t lipsync so you are wrong.

[@bangtwicevelvetforever4096]

*SBS @ ORGANIZER ALREADY STATE THAT TWICE DONT HAVE LIPSYNC . THEY SANG 100% LIVE* *only you haters keep bashing them lipsync because YOU CANNOT ACCEPT THE FACT THAT TWICE IMPROVED* *NaYeon chorus part was obvious , her voice almost crack*

[@jyrv]

Jihyo looks stunning 😍 Good job girls!!! Rest well

[@cheesekimbap8100]

Jihyo's and Nayeon's vocal got me *shookt*

[@g1n45]

PHILIPPINE ONCE mas jihyo❤

[@chizzygirl18]

NAYEON, DAHYUN, MOMO & JEONYEON!!! My 4 twice bias queens!!!! F-I-G-H-T-I-N-G!!!! ❤ ♡

[@eleahjaizel6521]

Nayeon Jihyo And Mina :)

[@seeya3285]

Tzuyu says「You’re my heart shaker shaker 」😍💓 It’s so cute 💞💓💗💖💘

[@edrianpena5675]

Nayeon & Jihyo slays their part and all of them slays

[@Leihdi]

Jihyo is such a GODDESS. Love her in black long hair, no bangs. THIS is how you should’ve styling Jihyo all along jypent!! Don’t waste that beauty. Real visual for me. Pretty ever since a baby.💘👸🏻

[@nolnoru]

jihyo healty af

[@NovitaSari-cr6py]

i think she's beautiful too with bangs

[@dancelover300Msp]

She looks beautiful with bangs too tho

[@alikyondai5791]

She get prettier as time goes on. Her efforts for losing weight was no joke!! I hope it doesn't effect her health.

[@g1n45]

LADY yes so prety❤❤

[@regretregret956]

Tzuyu and Jihyo killin this stage!

[@kookitzuyu5348]

when I see you Tzuyu My Heart shaker💓

[@regretregret956]

Tzuyu is the best visual ever! Not only that, but she also excelled really well in her vocals for this comeback! She is sooooo precious! 💜💜💜

[@haylinarnett6529]

Regret Regret and she's so humble too

[@sylviali6248]

Black Hair Tzuyu! So pretty my angel ♡♡♡

[@nguyetanhdoris8313]

Dahyun,Tzuyu,Mina💕💕💕💕

[@cozyfire13]

I'm so proud of Nayeon for hitting every high note in her lines I was really nervous for her since it was live but she came through and really did it 💞

[@shikalukidot2990]

nah, its not live sadly

[@chaengpopper]

Shikaluki Dot. Its live, go on the mr removed video or smth bcs it is. Even the way tzuyu sing “you are my heart shaker shaker” is different with the original

[@snorribanix]

i think its live 2:41 notice that jihyo's voice cracks a bit

[@BBlubbyy]

Shikaluki Dot lol a person to immediately put down Twice... am I surprised? No

[@kolykachan7551]

Shikaluki Dot it’s pure live

[@patv8028]

When exo and bts comes the screams are so high pitch and for TWICE all I hear is deep voices of once fanboys😂 ONCES FIGHTING! you did well with fanchants💞🍭

[@Moonlight_14632]

😂Even BTS were shookt

[@anamkar]

Tzuyu's black hair is a blessing.

[@xstantalentstantwicex5277]

1:14 , NAYEON obviously singing live lmao haters listen carefully . Her voice almost broke . Hate with acceptable reasons , TWICE PERFECTIONS STARTS NOW

[@thaongan5544]

I want to fancam of tzuyu now

[@lunc.9972]

It's 100%live I'm crying 😘😍 3:19 Minari way too cute 😋

[@shikalukidot2990]

are you deaf?

[@empresstitania]

yes.100% live.

[@empresstitania]

You can hear their breathing and especially at Jeongyeon's part..We clearly can hear her loud voice.

[@zyteng3417]

Whether are they open 100% or not,I can’t sure. But i can ensure that they really open the microphone ,so if you feel that they’re lipsyncy.....Maybe your hears are broken

[@kimmiehwg]

Tzuyu's black hair is such a goddess!!!

[@frs4w208]

For those who are wondering - Heart shaker was live, you can still hear their voices despite the loud AR and backtrack vocals. And they sounded stable when singing Heart Shaker too. Likey wasn't sung live though, but it isn't a big deal cause many artists lip synced that night (e.g RV Peek-A-Boo was live but Red Flavor wasn't).

[@choutzairinwasowski4911]

Tzuyu my love !! My angel u jst slayed the performance 😭😭 I’m so proud!!!

[@rizkaoktari2017]

Jihyo so so pretty❤

[@oncetwice7321]

100% live :) proud ONCE here.

[@hahagames7490]

Is this live?

[@oncetwice7321]

Haha Games yes :)

[@nao2680]

Tzuyu is really improving in vocal 😍 because in inteview she mean that she didn't learn singing she just want to dance, but then leader jihyo teach her 😄

[@sattaphongstan603]

Death Hunter jihyo is such a kind leader

[@trezella8748]

Which interview

[@aangkorra]

This stage is lipsynced

[@jooseph_dub]

@@aangkorra 2 vocals sorry

[@aangkorra]

@@jooseph_dub Hm?

[@chaeyoungsstrawberry2941]

Chaeyoung is slaying. Her outfit 😍😍😍 OMG she is so beautiful and cutest girl i know

[@immycayubit1727]

Tzuyu Omygaaaad!!

[@reiwonyo]

AHHHH THE FLOWER ON SANA’S HAIR MAKES HER LOOK LOVELIER

[@nielku418]

Why is jihyo so pretty, I can't take my eyes off her

[@patriciodiaz819]

Momo ❤

[@MonicaHolly143]

lets all give silence for those Tzuyu stan that their dream black haired tzuyu is back again

[@thaongan5544]

Tzuyu new hair - BLACK HAIR, so beautiful 😍😍

[@tiffany2674]

Lee Kay yessssss

[@モーフィアス]

Whoa, that switch up from black to silver was awesome. TWICE look amazing in both looks! 🖤🩶

[@pfpft7370]

Dahyun is so pretty😍

[@RobertoWagner-bi6qi]

BB BAEKBAEK One of the prettiest 😍

[@mielle3470]

Ikr~

[@dubudahyun4918]

our dahyun is slay

[@kimsana3028]

Yeah

[@abygailpili7920]

Ikr ❤

[@Imjustccurs]

Jihyo,Dahyun & Nayeon biases❤️ plus Momo haha

[@twicexonceisheart1508]

Tzuyu with black hair is 💖💞

[@muhammadridwan7792]

jihyo and nayeon so beautiful

[@UchihaDZoro-se9pc]

Real best GG of 2017

[@nanacoffee6921]

Tzuyu's black hair😍

[@angielove8026]

Tzuyu with BLACK HAIR!! Awww she so pretty T_T

[@deniseroquefranco5298]

Nayeon is getting better and better in live performances👏

[@efemsiel]

0:21 literally shookt! Nice concept there.

[@sanadahyun8703]

Sana and Jihyo 's so beautiful,Dahyun and tzuyu 's cute ❤

[@hodanmahamed3774]

dahyun so cute

[@pajama3182]

Nayeon looks beautiful as always.. just realized that Nayeon hair should be like this, with bangs and a wavy hair anyway u look beautiful in any way #GoddessNayeon

[@bigbangarmy6802]

Omg, black hair Tzuyu is real goddes ❤️👍💓😍

[@madeleineauchocolat2726]

Jihyo is so beautiful OMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

[@cbtv861]

Chaeyoung so pretty 😍😍😍

[@emmac5242]

Trisha Sing I love her long hair!!

[@sh6kgu]

CHAEYOUNG WITH PONYTAIL SO BEAUTIFUL ❤❤❤

[@bubblysoapy_]

When their voices became more and more stable. 😍 They all slayed it! No need to do an MR Removed video since their voices are crystal clear. I'm so proud of these girls. 😍

[@najeongmosahyomidachaetzu7557]

Honestly nayeon slayed the stage but all of them are slaying

[@wannaonejeojang863]

Nabongs Love Trueeee

[@najeongmosahyomidachaetzu7557]

MD AC yes, because she is the face of the group

[@najwadiibah]

*T Z U Y U* 🔥

[@dearalissa3006]

Tzuyu and Sana slayyyy. Their outfit, hair and everything else are on pointtt

[@keavy21]

Goshh Nayeon she’s so beautiful ❤️❤️

[@sanashy9024]

I can now hear the fanboys chant! Yeaahh! Go guys! Happy Twicemas!

[@kimsana3028]

SANA LIKEY LIKEY yeah😭I'm crying

[@twiceislife5429]

TZUYU with BLACK HAIR soo BEAUTIFUL😍😍😍💘💘

[@Tim_Uni]

Jeongyeon so pretty and perfect, my bias 😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@sxmiebear8]

Tzuyu's voice mature😭😍

[@chidera1113]

Jeongyeon was killing it 🔥

[@dianaambrosio7034]

Chidera right she looks so gorgeous & her voice 🤤

[@chimiga07]

Finally found a comment about her! She's doing great! Btw...Hope she dye her hair black as well! 😊

[@nayeemakhan5323]

Tzuyu with black hair is giving me life! *My QUEENS slayyyyed!* 👑They *all* looked *sooo gorgeous* *GODDESS LEVEL VISUALS* 😍❤ *K-Onces jjang!* 👏 #TWICEsaranghae🍭 #NoTWICENoLife ❤

[@ohnaminami]

I live for Tzuyu's *you're my heart shaker, shaker*

[@tsuschiesama7898]

Uhm just gonna ask, do you still live for Tzuyu's "you're my heart shaker,shaker"?

[@Bonnie-xi6ov]

👏👏TWICE👏👏TZUYU 👍👍

[@kuby3454]

THIS LIVE IS OOOOHMYGODDD

[@minshookyshole4081]

Jihyo and tzuyu look so beautiful with black hair i swear

[@twicetwice211]

Tzuyu With black hair!❤😱💕👑

[@chaukim7110]

Nayeon sing very good.I❤️TWICE

[@aidannatividad7467]

It’s almost no prerecord in the background i only hear their real voices, all ONCES feel it too right? This is L I V E i repeat L I V E move on thrices our girls is Improving 🤬👋🏻

[@septianmulyadi128]

Tzuyu with black hair is perfect.

[@jinbts3213]

Damn jeongyeon ❤️❤️😍❤️😍❤️

[@onlyjade5209]

Jihyo's part after the chorus is what I really love! 😍

[@nana-vv3ln]

It will be better if you showed more TWICE, instead of the audience .-.)

[@vutruong7984]

Nayoen so cute

[@oncetwice7321]

K-once thank you very much. The fanchants gives me a goosebumps :) amazing

[@saph8802]

jihyo is so pretty and sana having a doll figure 😭💓

[@yomiraortega4123]

Nayeon 😘😘

[@heyitsme3689]

*twice pre-records for a music show* People: *twice sings live* People: I strongly believe this is pre-recorded! ??

[@tzuyuvislife7774]

Tzuyu beginning kill me😍💘

[@ktzuyu6592]

Ohh.....nice a tzukook shipper

[@twicebtsexoandblackpink6106]

Tzuyu Jungkook Lover wow ur profile pic is so cute and nice edited 😍😘

[@anabrigita24]

Tzuyu Jungkook Lover yeah. ❤

[@emmac5242]

I love your username #tzukook

[@emmac5242]

Acelina she didn’t even mention tzukook so you shouldn’t judge someone based on their name😂😅

[@yanaqhairunnisa]

Jihyo is thin and so prettyyy..🌺 her style now made her look stunning..

[@himarktuan]

was the first part prerecorded? with the whole posing with the black outfits? bc when i was watching this live i was sO SHOOK when they suddenly appeared with white outfits like i was so confused i thought i missed some neat trick but it seems like the black outfit part was prerecorded lmao both outfits were absolutely gorgeous tbh

[@channy2481]

mark tuan i think beacuse of the color of light it was so black so its so easy make their outfits black, i just think😂

[@moronicfrog9090]

mark tuan they pre recorder the first part early yesterday and just overlapped it during the live

[@kokorot6179]

WTFFFFF HOW DID THEY DO THAT!!!! IM LOSINGGG MY MINDDDDD

[@bbcreampapapalipstickeuuma631]

Got7 wut de fuk why so insecure? 😂 lol

[@NotAnotherVlog]

If you notice even the outfits are different not just the color. So I'm pretty sure it was pre-recorded. Regardless, it was a clever and creative thing to do, it really surprised me at first :)

[@waniehassan5791]

tzuyu dress is super simple because she's too much, beautiful💅

[@sarasa9146]

OMG they so beautiful 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@nathandrake6749]

heartshaker indeed tzuyu era....look at her visual..mind blown

[@shinepaingoo3697]

Tzuyu You are my heaet shaker

[@kemzmama]

jihyo so pretty, visual

[@hjrytpozx5836]

My bias Tzuyu 😍😘😗😙😚

[@hangdanh5559]

Guandi Me too

[@yaboredboii]

okayyy who’s here in 2021?? that intro transition is still chef’s kisses!

[@ianliang0220]

AMAZING!!!TWICE 사랑해요

[@TokyoHearts505]

Jihyo is so beautiful oml

[@fs87ss44444444]

Tzuyu💖Tzuyu💖Tzuyu💖

[@enjelele]

omg nayeon’s first outfit (the black one) WHY THEY CHANGED IT:((( but it’s okay.. SHE ALWAYS LOOKS GOOD❤️❤️✨

[@SetMeFree9]

You're my Heart Shaker Shaker🎶🎶💕

[@anxietea3561]

Once * Army WHY DO ISEE YOU EVERYWHERE AND WHY DOES YOUR COMMENTS GET SO MANY LIKES

[@nizamhakim3029]

Once * Army Again and again your comment always on the top

[@crackzonesubs8856]

Once * Army 😅

[@NguyenThao-dr4yh]

❤️

[@lcc.aurora344]

Once * Army 我

[@TT-qf8zs]

jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘jihyo 😍💘

[@betty6449]

Tzuyu 💕💕

[@rameshlama6128]

Why no one is taking about Chaeyoung!!??? I mean she also slayed this performance and her beauty is no joke😍😍😍😶

[@idolstrash1452]

SON CHAEYOUNG YOU'RE MY HEART SHAKER