22 July Supreme Court Hearing on NEET UG 2024 | Impact analysis of Physics Question on NEET UG Ranks

NEET UG case in #supremecourtofindia took an interesting turn when a petition came up challenging the marks awarded to students who wrote option 2 or option 4 for Physics question on Atoms.
Honourable Chief Justice of India was miffed at #nta for arbitrary decision making on awarding marks. He referred this question to director of IIT Delhi for his opinion and sought his suggestion before 12 Noon on 23rd July 2024.
This video explains the different probable scenarios on this question and their impact on marks and ranks for #neetug2024 This video is for information purpose and in intended to help in better understanding for students.
To see earlier video wherein Mr. Rakesh Jain raised this question and suggested NTA to declare question null and void, please click
• Impact of 23rd June Re...

[@Neet_Navigator]

There is an inadvertent error in table shown in the video. Please read the column 4 content as below: Attempted Answer Scenario 3 Question Null & void Option 1 --------------- Marks Increase by 5 Option 2 --------------- Marks reduction by 4 Option 3 --------------- Marks Increase by 5 Option 4 --------------- Marks reduction by 4 No Attempt --------------- No change in Marks Net Effect --------------- Change in Ranks Impact till AIR 25k --------------- High

[@thenativefrequencies]

If 2 nd option is wrong than 1 st option is also wrong becauss radioactive elements are not electrically neutral.Please share this point as much as possible because many have not observed it.

[@anilpatil8600]

For example number of protons and electron is 98 in californium so how is not electrically neutral ??

[@dpsingh5113]

Paper leak/ Re-Neet compaign was a drama in the hope of an extra chance😅😅😅

[@geopoliticalnewsstrategies1853]

5th drop 648 marks rank 30K UP GENERAL, kya karun ab sir.....?😥😥😥😥

[@zainaakram1039]

Sir nta ke brwsher me pahle hi likha tha k yadi 2 answer hai kisi question ke to dono ko marks diye jayngy jisne quetion attempt kiya hi usi ko marks milenge phir us ladki ne kyun attempt nahi kiya question

[@aishanikchatterjee7714]

Best would be to make that question null and void. Everyone should get zero and hence marked out of 716.

[@Ncertstudy.]

@@aishanikchatterjee7714 tb or v problem hoga.....jisa 716 pelhi aya jo wo question leave Kiya....wo v ab new 61 me jur jye gaaa😂😂😂😂

[@NarrityamR]

​@Ncertstudy.😂😂

[@Suryanshdr]

Koi ek option hoga

[@journeyoflife7862]

भाई सहाब नीट मे Q 19 के दो उत्तर पुरानी और नयी NCERT बुक के अनुसार थे । अगर पुरानी NCERT मान्य नही है तो लगभग 35 प्रश्न पुरानी NCERT से आये है तो 35 प्रश्न नयी NCERT में नही है तो ये 35 प्रश्न भी अमान्य है

[@Hellobro85]

Bro,there is a difference between new edition(in 2019) and new ncert with reduced syllabus.

[@thenativefrequencies]

If 2 nd option is wrong than 1 st option is also wrong becauss radioactive elements are not electrically neutral.Please share this point as much as possible because many have not observed it.

[@Ncertstudy.]

@@journeyoflife7862 purani ncert means..,. edition before last edition 2019 se pelhi wala......2024 ncert me chapter deleted h... syllabus me nhi.....to 2023 ke ncert padh lo.....😂😂😂😂

[@rajeshsoni1578]

इनसे ये पूछो की पेपेर में 200प्रश्न क्यो देते है करने तो 180 ही है जिस बच्चे ने प्रश्न छोड़े क्या वो पूरा पेपर करके आया है क्या अगर नही तो डाउट था इसिलए छोड़े ना ऐसे तो हमने ही 4प्रश्न छोड़ दिया डाउट के कारण घर पर किया तो पता चला हो जाते 1प्रश्न तो पूरा करने के बाद भी मार्किंग नही कर पाए सिरदर्द के कारण बाद में पता चला तो ये पॉइंट पेर गलत डिस्कस है

[@anupamgupta8497]

Thanks sir for your valuable opinion 😅

[@rajeevanand111]

So your stand is - dont order for re-Neet. Very well. I would like to ask you few questions. As NTA itself said that question was leaked on 5th morning(though Patna fir says otherwise) and on that basis questions can be solved not in 45 minutes but even in 20 minutes with multiple solvers. So now, we have timing between 9:00-1:30(approx 4 hours) accepted by NTA itself that question papers were leaked. Thus, 1. How can you be so sure that solvers haven't passed to others secretly either to make money or favour their friends or relatives? 2. Even with just 20 or 30 questions passed to someone who obtained 400 marks can easily get above 650 bracket. So we dont have to call only 200 questions leakage a leak. 3. NTA officials including education minister denied any leakage despite being proved by Patna police and have countless irregularities whether its question paper being transported in open e-rickshaw or grace marks awarded to random candidates without having any clarity on their procedures(that is also not possible in offline exam). Also they didn't allow all students who genuinely lost their time but only those who approached to the court. And that's why they revoked it even before any instructions by Supreme Court's vacation bench. And lastly, 4. When the entire system is clearly appears corrupt and govt is against students then if the court wont favor Re-Neet then don't you think next time these gangs will go to eny extent and students will never trust any examination.

[@s.k.3744]

2 Option no. Mese agar koi ek option click karte hai to use hi mark diya jata hai. Ye mudda janbuzkr uthaaya. Un logon ka kya jinhone paper leak karaaya, 9,10April ko form bhare hai. Agar NTA is question ke mark kate to 9,10 April ko bhare sabhi form unhe cancel karne hoge. Grace marks kise diye the wo konse center se the clear kyu nahi bata raha NTA. All OMR RECHECK HONE CHAHIYE tabhi result clear aayega. Ye sirf logo ko ghuma rahe hai

[@prakashdate8015]

Main problems are paper leak one registration window open grace marks centre settings OMR filling after exam these are diverted to centre wise result and one question of arom

[@prakashdate8015]

NTA SC CENTRAL GOVERNMENT diverting Paper leak one question is not big issue it not affects AIR much

[@17.omaaryanpatil97]

Scenario 3 me printing mistake ho gayi hai 🙏🏻🙏🏻2& 3 marks uper niche ho gaye hai

[@Neet_Navigator]

Thanks for highlighting the error 🙏 The corrected column has been published as comment now.

[@17.omaaryanpatil97]

Please analyse scenario 3 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@meshwa2955]

It would have been better, if the papersetter would have been interrogated for the right answer in question.

[@ansulanver]

How can that be right ? Two answers to one question..?!! One must definitely avoid....

[@rajeshsoni1578]

किसी भी पेपेर में अगर कोई प्रश्न kanfusion वाला होता है तो ये उस बच्चे के iq पेर निर्भर करता है ना अगर गलत हो गया तो no कट जायगे आख़िर ये भी विचार करना चाहिए इस परीक्षा से एक डॉक्टर का निर्माण होता है जो आगे जाकर सर्जरी में तुरंत निर्णय लेने पड़ते है मरीज की जान का सवाल है इसलीए ये गलत है cji ने बड़े मुद्दे छोड़कर इस बिना मतलब के point पेर गौर किया कैसे डॉक्टर बनाने में लगे है सब के सब मेरे को अच्छी प्रकार से ध्यान है 6साल पहले जब मेरी भांजी के aplastic अनीमिया हुआ तब इस भारत मे गिनती के डॉक्टर मिले थे और वहा पर भी 4 महीने की वेटिंग थी तो cji से निवेदन है कि इस परीक्षा में सत्य का साथ देवे ये सीधी स्वास्थ्य से जुड़ी है

[@choprashreya9833]

Well said

[@Aimhigh_dreambig]

If the cji has asked for assistance frim iit it indicates he does not want ReNeet otherwise there was no quesrion of asking IIT

[@srimeenakshitextilessrimee5475]

Coloum 1 is correct no change mark sheet

[@soumitra01965]

Children are breaking down mentally day by day

[@Ramdeenchoudhary-pl8ob]

इस क्वेश्चन को ही रद्द कर देना चाहिए था मार्किंग 715 में से करनी थी NTA को

[@user-oe7zn7um7r]

Maine 710 no ka paper kiya tha result may 586 no day diya hai omr seat say 31 bubbles he gayab kar diya hai nta nay omr scam hue hai sir hamare sath

[@user-oe7zn7um7r]

Reneet all students

[@MEHEDIHASAN-tf6qi]

Kitna Aya Hain marks tumhara?

[@dr.mukeshkumarvarma8993]

*ये कलयुग है साहब...* *यहाँ लोग दूसरे की तकलीफ़ को* *कर्मों की सज़ा मानते हैं...* *ईश्वर सर्वशक्तिमान है और कानून अंधा नहीं है,नीट परीक्षा दोबारा होना चाहिए, जय भारत..!!*

[@s.k.3744]

Koi jarurat nahi ye sab karne ki baki chije chupane ke liye chal raha hai NTA ka drama

[@manirabegam9357]

Re neet for all

[@amitkumarvermaofficial]

Re Neet only

[@sonalisawai8369]

Sir what happened to those of who didn't attempt the question unki rank kam hogi ya bade gi please tell

[@thenativefrequencies]

If 2 nd option is wrong than 1 st option is also wrong becauss radioactive elements are not electrically neutral.Please share this point as much as possible because many have not observed it.

[@Ncertstudy.]

@@thenativefrequencies isliye to iit Delhi ko mila h...,wo sb observe kr lega

[@thenativefrequencies]

@@Ncertstudy. Let's hope

[@Neet_Navigator]

If there is a change of status quo, then all students will get a revised rank.

[@anilpatil8600]

​​@@thenativefrequenciesfor example number of protons and electron is 98 in californium so how is not electrically neutral ????

[@rajpurailiyas629]

નવા NCRt ને sahi manna chahiye

[@sunilgirbava9298]

No re neet please

[@NarrityamR]

Re NEET to hona hi hai

[@laxmishreshthi6883]

Nahi karenge ooo

[@realeducation9012]

Delete hona chahiye

[@laxmishreshthi6883]

Re neet hi solution he

[@RahulSharma-fj8jo]

Agar question ko delete krna hota to IIT delhi se uska answer nhi pucha jaata