230610 FULL aespa Governors Ball Music Festival NYC 【4K】

[@queenning28]

14:20 This ningning is going down in history. She is the hottest girl in the world and she KNOWS IT.

[@jlolxd]

experiencing this live was insane! despite giselle unfortunately being absent, the 3 of them slayed the stage. the live band elevated their already great performance sm!

[@sunsetlass8959]

what happen to giselle? the unfortunate event of having less members in kpop is when one of them is sick or unable to perform

[@juansuarez0126]

​@@sunsetlass8959that's exactly what happened to her, she's sick, that's why she couldn't perform with them.

[@Slidemoon]

I can’t get enough of how the band gets into it! They brought it to the next level indeed!

[@staychellin5905]

I truly understand when ppl started screaming as the band came to the stage!! lol i mean seeing aespa perform with a live band must be a dream come true 🤩

[@hittingthatdrum]

This band is so sick! Live bands just hit different. Does anyone know who they are? I have tried to search the names but I havent found any mention of them. I havent seen any article talking about them, which is really odd! Incredible stuff

[@-zunaid2124]

Ningning ate those lines❤

[@naviseu]

No wonder why people keep on trying to drag Aespa down, they're this good, members are full of aenergy

[@nikolasscheeks]

Because they’re an extremely popular and visible group. Kpop fans always need something to hate on. It fuels their endless misery. I don’t think there’s much hate now. But during the Girls era…wow. I’m a new My (though I’ve always liked Aespa’s music), and I was astounded at all the negativity surrounding that release. People saying they have no stage presence, the dance break was awkward, the choreo was lacking in energy…what a bunch of bullshit. I love Girls. The dance break is iconic.

[@ishathakor]

they're popular, they're pretty, their releases peak high on music charts, they have a lot of fans, they make a lot of money. they're all talented too which can't be said for all idols in the industry at this time. it's exactly the kind of group kpop fans love to hate on. plus, they didn't have the best stage presence in their first few comebacks so some people thought they deserved the relentless bullying.

[@theetaurus1832]

@@nikolasscheeksgirls is actually shit idky y’all think they’re exempt from criticisms or bad releases.

[@vnrs]

@@theetaurus1832 its your personal taste, bro, its not "actually". Girls is one of my fav aespa releases

[@pearsblikingone.jand9cb764]

@@theetaurus1832 I love that you're also here on an aespa video saying that

[@leonk2586]

Ningnings body roll is on 🔥 especially with this outfit

[@jeffadler3151]

Seriously, why I feel Ningning’s energy is getting stronger and a lot more passionate than before🤩

[@ævrilll]

i fr hope sm got them therapy after the abuse knetz and fans in general put them through during dct and savage era

[@danissegomez7953]

she has always from day 1

[@theetaurus1832]

since début she’s had it.

[@alanrodrigues2483]

Ningning proved herself once more as an all-rounder! What a voice, rap and stage presence... Always killing it!!

[@desinovitadahlan]

(2)

[@Jwa123]

And also winter! They are good at everything 😂

[@yoonie8912]

NINGNING IS SHINING 🌟

[@danissegomez7953]

​@@Jwa123 Winter is weak on stage presence

[@danissegomez7953]

As always.. Main slayer❤❤❤

[@mypearlb5208]

Ningning shifting from main vocalist to main rapper every now and then all throughout the performance! She was in-charge with majority of Giselle's lines in every song, so she had so many back to back parts wow

[@yoonie8912]

NINGNING ❤❤❤❤

[@danissegomez7953]

hevk even main dancer, she sometimes outdances Karina.. She is a beast

[@ginnybelle6300]

​@@danissegomez7953 here is the toxic solo stan of ningning. Ningning is all rounder. She's good at dancing but she's never outdanced karina. She's full of energy but so far she can't dancing as detail as karina dancing. So stop your moron! Stop downgrading other members!

[@ffbeexaid4509]

ace in the group for me

[@jonathangrant9811]

@@danissegomez7953she does not outdance Karina Ning can be sloppy with her execution sometimes

[@radish.]

Oh Ningning is going to EAT when she gets a solo debut, she has pure diva energy on stage - her charisma is off the scale

[@sharonsimba5257]

She is sooooo fun to watch. And I always love the outfits their stylish gives her!!!!!!!!!!

[@alishakhisa6427]

People praising Ningning, she really deserve it. Our main vocalist, maknae fighting❤

[@sachizz9923]

Mainslayer Ningning😍😍👌

[@mypearlb5208]

25:18 Ningning singing Giselle's "welcome to my world" line before her naevis outro 👏

[@justanormalhooman]

Ningning's live vocals are so consistently good and vibrant. And to think she's covering a lot of Giselle's rap lines as well. What a superstar

[@mypearlb5208]

Giselle parts that Ningning covered: Girls 6:49 Salty & Sweet 11:43 11:55 12:20 12:41 Life's Too Short 16:25 17:05 Welcome to My World 24:31 24:40 25:18 Hold on Tight 26:16 Next Level 28:48 29:41 30:51 31:10 31:41 Black Mamba 33:34 Spicy 36:56 37:49 38:53 39:32 And that's on being an ACE 💯

[@yoonie8912]

NINGNING ❤❤❤❤ ALL ROUNDER

[@ariabowls1117]

@@superduperordinary she did with her graduation song

[@whf5667]

​@@superduperordinary This person can't handle Ningning praise 😂 "aLL AEspA mEMbeR iS AlL RouNder" and then continue to discredit Ning. Don't call her Ningie, you troll don't deserve that privilege. And yes, she's an all rounder. Stay off Ningning's lane you miserable human.

[@heyheyhey2041]

@@superduperordinary just let ningmes praise ningning, can you? they even didn't bring other down or anything, so many people can call their idol ace/all rounder so let ningmes do it too. btw, ningning already produce her own song for her graduation

[@Shaahmd-on7lw]

@@superduperordinarywhy you being salty under all comment that praises ningning? we all know how good all the member are, but couldnt you let us gave all the mvp to ningning when she did shine in recents performances?

[@Savage94]

Ningning you are 1000000/10 honestly 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@sneak7066]

Ningning slay!

[@kr0210]

Ningning was so amazing all throughout but i really have to commend her during next level. She covered a lot of giselle’s parts in that song on top of her own, a lot of them were right after the other as well but she did so well in singing/rapping all of them. I’m also glad she got to showcase a lot of her talents, she’s truly a main slayer!

[@谭林-u7v]

she slays!

[@brit1317]

REAAAL

[@lulashepard3253]

I could hardly take my eyes off her, and the other two looked pretty amazing.

[@danissegomez7953]

now we know she can rap RAP❤ NOW THATS THE ACE❤❤❤

[@mypearlb5208]

You can always trust Ningning to hype up and interact with the crowd 👏

[@jvnabelle]

Ningning ate and left no crumbs! Slay girl

[@tpoprocks]

Love the dress code that matches their character Ning Ning - Red the diva girl Karina - Black the mysterious girl Winter - White as winter which suits her skin color so much

[@scxxx07]

Wonder what color will be gigi?

[@maheephoenix4398]

@@scxxx07green or blue maybe?

[@scxxx07]

@@maheephoenix4398 yess i can see blue on her

[@AznIntegra521]

My guess is black and blue if she was there.

[@danissegomez7953]

if Giselle will be there, her theme will be emo punk😅😂

[@sophtheloaf4393]

ningning devoured those high notes on hold me tight, she's main vocal and main slayer !

[@dindinjellies1044]

I like it when aespa live, cause ningning can enjoy herself on stage. look at her energy, SLAYNING really ate the whole performance

[@谭林-u7v]

yes!!!!

[@joeaaron1]

Exactly, I notice that as well.. she has more passion when it's live.. she enjoy it more

[@Moonwalkmj]

All of them enjoy it more when they can sing and rap live!

[@vaanshichauhan9868]

All of them enjoy live

[@songokuxkakarot]

@@Moonwalkmj we talk about ningning

[@azabache1525]

Ningning is all the good things in the world just listen her voice is pure gold is like heaven, she is amazing

[@summerxu9091]

Ning is very relaxed, nice performance!

[@danissegomez7953]

thats a Born performer right there

[@user-zc6zn8cs2g]

the scream for ningning OMG‼️🤍

[@danissegomez7953]

true she is really popular outside Korea😅 they know a true performer when they see one❤❤❤

[@loretta_3843]

I know, I'm in Australia and I've always been drawn to her but on Korean programs, she doesn't seem as appreciated ​@danissegomez7953

[@tobiasbacca6944]

NINGNING IS A FIRE😮😮❤❤

[@RiverFlower26]

Woahh Ningning powerful voice for Black Mamba!!! Awesome!! AESPA AENERGY really great omg love them so much :))

[@danissegomez7953]

she is lethal🔥🔥🔥 and its like nothing for her, vibrato and all❤❤❤ such a powerful voice❤

[@debritubose3363]

Next level ningning is really next level the way she did Giselle parts is just awesome true ace

[@afifahrahma4893]

NINGNING KILLING IT!! Aespa jjang!

[@GIRLBOSS-1111]

Ningning is amazing. Amazing energy, stage presence and vocals. Plus she looks so pretty wow. Also the band and arrangements slayedddd

[@katnip8228]

"Don't be sad, cause three out of four diamonds ain't bad!" In fact, they were brilliant! Hope Giselle gets better. Ningning was born to be on stage. Aespa really are 100% awesome!

[@queenning28]

37:50 Between fixing her messy hair and giving justice to Giselle's rap, Ningning chose the latter and I respect that so much.

[@danissegomez7953]

if you know Ning, Ning does not care of her hair is all over her face, she DELIVERS

[@jacobong2257]

ning ning vocal are so damn stable even though song after song!

[@winter_m401]

winter really shined 🤩💕especially in girls that high note and the dancing 🫠🫠🫠

[@Cinnamon_gorll]

The energy Ning2 displayed in Spicy is crazy!!!

[@Princessthatlovesyou]

Ningning always full with energy!! Really loves her stage presence.

[@edwardk8477]

Finally Ningning got so many lines and had a chance to RAP!!! She is an all-rounder ❤

[@alazz1406]

You can tell that being an icon of idols is ningning’s passion

[@danissegomez7953]

you can tell by her role models, like Beyonce, Doja Cat and she has diverse taste in music. Even she was young she already oozes imense presence

[@mimibley4737]

Ningning is a star, i wish they perform Savage for this performance and see who would do Giselle's iconic parts

[@savage_0217]

It will be suicide for them. Like i am thankful Ningning able to cover her parts well but Savage is such a difficult to take since there's a double beats in Giselle's rap same goes to Thirsty rap, lines and rnb adlibs which is why they didn't included in their setlist.

[@BTSsexyvempirejin]

​@@savage_0217giselle rap is not that hard lol look bts and blackpink rap line and compare lmao

[@desinovitadahlan]

aespa main vocal and main slayer, ningning~

[@hildadidot4651]

Ningning is on fire, her energy was so strong.

[@danissegomez7953]

thats why I prefer to watch her live than on their concert hyper line where they lip sync some songs😅 You can feel Ning's passion when its live

[@serenalee7459]

7:06 the powerful dance live winter showed on the stage was insane!!! Just look at that high kick!!! All about passion and profession!!!😮

[@Shaahmd-on7lw]

they all did super great but ningning really stood out through out this performances for me… She’s a MAIN SLAYER!! ALL ROUNDER!! btw this two part hit me so much 24:58 - 25:33 i mean the place that she deserved, as a main vocal… the way she sing her heart out with that hand gesture, i just can’t 🥺 wtmw definitely Ningning’s song!❤ Hold on tight too 😭 the way she hit everynote clearly while shifting from head to chest voice at ease omg?! Please give a lot of love to our super maknae 🤍

[@Password9141]

YES COULDN'T AGREE MORE!!!

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

​@@Password9141 if the comment bother u no need to write

[@Justeva030]

​@@layzhangismyhero4395you must really see the meaning her word(sorry for my bad english)

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

@@Justeva030 what is the meaning 🤔

[@Justeva030]

@@layzhangismyhero4395 she say "yes couldn't agree more" meaning she no doubt/agree for the coment except she just say "couldn't agree" different meaning

[@mypearlb5208]

NingRina hyperline Girls dance break will always be iconic 🔥

[@Password9141]

They're queens and leader in gen 4 for reasons.. as expected. and NingNing truly the pro Diva among Aespa.

[@HaNeul0805]

Ningning has a passive ability. The longer the performance is the higher her energy and stage presence becomes.

[@danissegomez7953]

I agree and her true performer energy will come out when you let her sing LIVE

[@XccZ9]

Ningning absolutely ate it! She is getting more and more amazing every time, so proud of her

[@hicater]

Thank you for the video! Winter's extended high note + dance break in Girls at 5:33 and 7:05 was mind-blowing. Her stage presence is really outstanding here. Other members did amazingly as well. Overall great live band performance!

[@kdkffk]

Ningning was awesome there l love her energy in this performance she has great stage presence ❤️ lots of love for her❤❤ she has again proved that she is a great perfomer 😊

[@danissegomez7953]

SM should treat Ning right😅 they found a true gem, no wonder they did not let her go and the only sole survivor of SMrookies. She was destined to be in aespa from the first time they saw her in China, training in SM was just formality. look at her pre debut stages in China, you will know what I mean, and she already oozes so much and overflowing stage presence at such a young age, she knows how to project in front of the camera what more with the training and experience? So to new fans, now you know why she is 🔥🔥🔥 always, performing and singing is her PASSION and it shows every single stage🔥🔥🔥❤

[@Max-my6rk]

Ningning vocal! Wow that's why rolling stone calls her vocal particularly shining

[@Cinnamon_gorll]

Girl Ning2 is an absolute unit! Shes going to devour her solo stages

[@messedgranger5955]

Omg ningning is killing it

[@sushi672]

Winter is absolutely incredible. SM undoubtedly hit the jackpot with her. Vocals, stage presence, dancing, visuals she’s got it all! What a superstar

[@queenning28]

If you still don't think Ningning is the best singer in Aespa after watching this, then you're simply delusional. America (and Japan) doesn't do dirty tricks like messing with her and Giselle's microphones and in-ears. That's why she always sounds amazing whenever she steps out of Korea. Well done Ning, our beloved main vocal and maknae. You have endured so much but come so far.

[@liljjj4972]

Our ningning really is a hardworking shinning star. I couldn’t take my eyes off her, she’s pure charisma and talent. And so natural too. She seemed to really enjoy herself

[@danissegomez7953]

if they even doubt, they are deaf and blind and purely biased to other members, bitter and does not accept a straoght fact😂

[@danissegomez7953]

​@@afeliz2642 Winter was too stiff there and zero stage presence, thats why she was hitting high notes but she was struggling and like her voice will rip apart. Karina on the other hand dont sing high notes. Ning hype the crowd, dance likeno tomorrow and its their first live ever with a huge crowd, she was a bit nervous and she was catching her breath, cuz Ning is their only salvation with the NO STAGE PRESENCE allegation. She saves the group.

[@danissegomez7953]

​​@@afeliz2642 😂 hitting same high notes than Ning sure but she is clearly struggling, I pity her vocal chord in the future😂 Then , who is the most talked member in the comment? Ning right? and this is international stage not Korea, sure Karina and Winter can have Korea but Ningning and Giselle has the best appeal among non Koreans. Just look at the comments, I am not biased dear I am just stating straight facts that has evidence😂 LOOK AT THE COMMENTS AGAIN if you disagree with my opinion😂 thanks

[@ym__0820]

WINTER KILLED IT!! SHES ON FIRE 🔥🔥

[@Emily_fanai]

Rapper Ningning is so damn hot plsss 😭😭🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@strawberry0419]

Can't take my eyes off of Ningning damn. She's such a diva. Salty & sweet is her song. my aespa girls truly killed it ❤

[@dolidoli4190]

I'm sad that giselle is not here but happy that Ningning slayed the rap parts and we got a chance to hear her rap. She is definitely an all rounder idol

[@danissegomez7953]

more than an all rounder. She is the PERFECT IDOL and she can be a solosit now, and I wont complain❤

[@joejoecorral]

Karina and Winter may be the "better" dancers, but NingNing's stage presence is undeniable. I feel like with performances in Korea, audiences don't care if idols are lip-syncing because it's all about the visual and performance. But American audiences don't necessarily need the performance to look or sound perfect. They want charisma and charm, and live vocals for sure. And I think NingNing provides that for the American audience.

[@gabrielzzz2492]

for real, shes such a secret weapon for aespa outside korea

[@joejoecorral]

@@gabrielzzz2492 That is a way more concise way of what I was trying to say haha. I agree! Giselle was great at Coachella too. She and NingNing really shined with the American audience. And obviously Giselle speaks fluent English which helps. I hope they can do more performances in America and become more comfortable performing, ad-libing, and engaging with the audience.

[@gabrielzzz2492]

@@joejoecorral i couldn't agree more 😁

[@queenning28]

Ningning is a far better dancer than Winter now. Her dancing has leveled up so much it's kinda crazy. She can have dance battles with Karina now. Her dance breaks in 'Girls' and 'Spicy' are FIRE.

[@gabrielzzz2492]

@@queenning28 dont let winter's fans find u lol

[@FF-zz6yc]

Ningning slayed. Her vocals really shined especially in hold on tight

[@teiarah]

Despite Gigi being absent, it's amazing that almost all of the songs they performed were actually played by live bands! It's even crazier because Main Vocalist Ningning did Gigi's rap parts! I don't regret having her as my bias, she never disappoints despite having such a pure voice that can hit killer high notes! Karina was amazing during her center dance break and of course, Ningning aswell but we cannot forget about our Minjeong, she truly is stunning with her visuals, vocals, and dance! This performance was surely amazing, more performances and achievements to come to Aespa! Hwaiting~!

[@yg_oh]

I hope next concert tour aespa with live band. Damn, that so good

[@danissegomez7953]

you know why it does not look empty???? cuz Ningning is there, her stage presence covers up for it

[@teiarah]

@@danissegomez7953 mhm, she has the best stage presence in aespa.

[@mypearlb5208]

25:58 Ningning's intro in Hold on Tight is superior! Her low register is the best.

[@danissegomez7953]

true she is flawless in low, middle and high registers and she does it flawlessly always. I never see her perform where she truly struggled with high notes cuz every high note she have done so far is like nothing for her. I bet she can do whistle note

[@yeahyeahyeah3724]

Ningninggg ❤

[@jops1004]

when winter moved her mic at 5:40, you just know that it's live... so proud of them

[@sophtheloaf4393]

would have died for their solo stages, ningning's song in particular would have been so good with this hype crowd

[@maytsaayayna2059]

Ningning so STABLE. She's a great performer. She awesome on her own part and note, did well on Gigi's. Black mamba, life's too short and especially hold on tight soo stable

[@Max-my6rk]

Hold on tight is not easy to sing live.. gosh Ningning nailed it..

[@vitol8227]

Gov ball should PROVE to SM that NingNing is their ace/ all rounder… the way she shifted from main vocal to main rapper to cover majority of Giselles parts, and even out danced the groups main dancer in a lot of this show..GIVE HER MORE OPPORTUNITIES TO SHINE!!! I was so glad I was there in person to see these girls kill it

[@vaanshichauhan9868]

Her rapping was okay and how she outdanced Karina idu. Sometimes people love exaggerating her skills. She has high energy but her executions are poor

[@unknownuser4747]

​@@vaanshichauhan9868 i guess the term should be outperformed more than outdance

[@nekrozma]

​@@unknownuser4747definitely, because I feel like sometimes ningning stans always exagerate on how she's now the best dancer and everything... No she's the best performer

[@imasaiko_]

Ya'll can't really praise a member without bringing down other 🙄

[@vitol8227]

@@imasaiko_ I was in no way bringing Karina down, she is ridiculously talented and such a strong performer and star. I made. a comparison how mingling is the strongest overall performer of the group and can hang with Karinas dance ability yet gets paid dust.....

[@notskieminatozaki7442]

Playlist 0:40 Intro 2:44 Girls 7:39 aenergy 11:35 Salty & Sweet 16:14 Life's Too Short 19:29 **Live Band** 22:26 Welcome to MY World 25:58 Hold on Tight 28:30 Next Level 32:22 Black Mamba 35:19 **Ment** 36:33 Spicy

[@MrNosebleeding]

😅

[@RO-vr9qx]

thxxxxxxxx

[@seijiiwaguro]

36:51 🆙Thank you🙏

[@kimrinabluu]

thankyouu

[@miep3764]

Ningning vocals are perfectly stable, plus her energy on stage is undeniable and Spicy! 🥵 Winter looks like a fairy princess - visual, angelic vocals and high notes! 🧚‍♀️ Karina is serving ACE like she always does, captivating anyone who grace their eyes on her! 😍 Giselle is smiling watching her Girls slay their performance, Æs let's pray for her speedy recovery! 🙏 This concert is a proof that they are in their element when they sing live 🔥

[@ryoujika]

NINGNING WENT CRAZY

[@whf5667]

Ningning praise in the consec is what i live for and its true, she's on fire ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[@brit1317]

Hats off to our girls for SLAYING this stage as 3! hoping giselle will get well soon. and just want to applaud NINGNING bcos she really ATE and left no crumbs I'm so proud of her

[@zoey4148]

NINGNING ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[@andersonmejia9811]

Couldn’t take my eyes from NINGNING 💕🥵🙈😍

[@desinovitadahlan]

Ningning is amazing performer

[@kamiliakaty9398]

Thank you so much now I can enjoy all the rap parts that Ningning covered 💗💗

[@fullsunvely]

I always love ningning highnote in black mamba 😭

[@_dionne]

This just proves that Giselle also contributes big to the group. She may be the least popular among them but that doesn't mean she isn't a prominent member. I mean Ningning really did a great job covering most of Giselle's parts but Giselle just gives off a different vibe with her lines that make them iconic. And the small talks and interactions weren't as natural without their English-speaking member. Hope she's well now and be present in their next stage.

[@Poop-pd9tg]

I low-key agree with the English speaking parts, but I think giselle won’t be participating in all US tours sadly

[@Poop-pd9tg]

Also the raps were good but doesn’t have that level of unique sass giselle has

[@_dionne]

@@Poop-pd9tg Didn't she said she'll be back soon? She'll probably be back before the tour starts..

[@songokuxkakarot]

No one ask lmao

[@danissegomez7953]

true but gigi has this sassy rap that is so cool. indeed main rapper❤. And Ning really can rap, now people will not say she cant rap😂 and thats the real ace there

[@wintereux]

NingNing vocal on hold on tight is powerful, she's amazing

[@danissegomez7953]

thats her real tone.POWERFUL AND WHOLE🔥🔥🔥🔥 reminds me of Taeyeon❤❤❤

[@pannybunny1510]

Wowwww ❤❤❤ Aespa is really amazing. Their stamina is incredible. NingNing was enjoying sm. Plus she was entertaining and sending energy not only to the audiences but her unnies too❤❤ And I think she really suits this kind of stage and performance. Love Aespa 💗 Thanks for sharing this amazing video.

[@danissegomez7953]

thats a BORN PERFORMER there..... idols can train for long period but if they dont have innate stage presence and talent in engaging the crowd then its useless

[@ralucagreen6555]

and thir Live voices are... OMG !! so stable .. This is for the haters !! Slaaaay Queeens !! Hope they get invited next year as well, so Giselle can attend as well. and the orchestra , love that they also enjoy the songs :)) .. OMG.. this sounds so good.. and also the dancers slaayed . Thank you for the video !

[@gadislavender403]

All-rounder ningning 🌼 Slay like always 🤍🤍🤍🤍

[@ichachoi1515]

Ningning .. Omg terharu banget anak2 udah sekeren ini .. AESPA JJANG!!!!!

[@retsak]

They nailed it. Karina one more time proving her dancing skills/stage presence, and her beauty? OMG

[@nikolasscheeks]

Amazed at how Winter makes singing look so easy. She never falters, never cracks. Pitch perfect, every time.

[@waswell8234]

RIGHT!!!!!

[@miep3764]

Right?! But to be fair all of the Aespa members sang perfectly. All their voices are almost CD quality in clarity it's insane 🤯

[@ibizamarquina793]

winter stans just be saying anything at this point it's so funny

[@heart8143]

Hold on tight performance she cracks. Watch and listen carefully.

[@thatKdramaDrip]

Winter was the most underwhelming person here. Your comment is ironically hilarious

[@chetbilks1998]

18:58 Underrated Karina ad-lib. Solid gold.

[@dinh_khai_]

it is not underrated, we all know its freaking good

[@louis-uv7ro]

Ningning Queen

[@ImNotSerious77]

aespa with live band was amazing 💜

[@elinebelle5128]

Thank you for sharing that performance with us 😍 and I love how they added electric guitar to the girls song it Made it sound More catchy and energetic but I have to say something was missing without Giselle

[@MB-nv8sw]

Winter 🥰

[@seaawithmee]

winter's stage presence really improved since their last comeback! all of them really slayed!

[@danissegomez7953]

nope, still not..

[@user-tb1lg6iq6n]

윈터 진짜 이갈았네... 보컬 그냥 음원이고 춤이 말도안되게 각이 잡혀있네 헤메코도 레전드고. 매번 레전드지만 이번 무대는 진짜 윈터의 독기 그 자체였다. 여태껏 이런 쌩라이브 무대는 춤 약간 마이너스하고 보컬 플러스하는 느낌이었는데 이번엔 둘다 그냥 플러스하고 나옴. 무대가 연속으로 있고 거의 매노래마다 고음 지르는파트 있는데 정말 너무 대단하다. 평생 윈터팬할께

[@danissegomez7953]

Ning is🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Password9141]

i love Karina is so fluent enough and confident convo in English

[@crystalcastle660]

Ningning my main slayer 💯🔥 her vocals,rap, dance, stage presence were amazing! Love her so much ❤️

[@clarp.3305]

Wow! They’re all very good. Ningning’s singing was very clear and stable. ❤

[@curhamzoa]

애리가 없어서 아쉽지만, 개쩌는 라이브에 밴드까지 정말 멋진 공연이였습니다. 애리 파트를 나눠서 부르는 진귀한 광경까지... 이쁘게 찍어서 올려주셔서 감사합니다!! 에스파도 MY도 화이팅~!!

[@Eunjiliiii]

Karina dancing so well .I can see how she dance complete and detail.Sboulder moves are just insane

[@Moonwalkmj]

Proof they all can sing, dance and rap in this group. Their stage presence was amazing too.

[@syazwina21]

Though Giselle was absent, aespa did well filling in her parts throughout these live performances, especially Ningning! Ningning's energy, stage presence & facial expressions in addition to her amazing live singing, rapping & dancing make her shine the brightest! I love the sound of the live band too! It gives a different atmosphere.