3 Idiots vs Nanban | What is a Machine? Scene Reaction | Aamir Khan vs Vijay | PESHFlix

Here is my reaction and review to '3 idiots' and 'Nanban' What is a machine Funny Comedy Scene.
'3 idiots' is a Bollywood comedy drama film starring Aamir Khan and directed by Rajkumar Hirani. 'Nanban' is a Tamil comedy drama film starring Thalapathy Vijay and directed by Shankar.
3 idiots Movie Scene: Aamir Khan What is a machine?
Nanban Movie Scene: Vijay What is a machine?
'3 Idiots' (2009) Hindi Full Movie
'Nanban' (2012) Tamil Full Movie
Subscribe to PESH Entertainment: / peshentertainment​
Twitter: / peshflix
Instagram: / peshflix
#3Idiots #Nanban #AamirKhan #Vijay

[@tamizh-247]

Vijay face reaction, screenplays, music is always perfect in Nanban...

[@bikramkeshari1381]

Copy always taunt and bad Amir Khan is more better than Vijay

[@maharaja9805]

Poda punda thalapathy act better than amir

[@INDIAN-pg9xr]

@@bikramkeshari1381 😂😂are you kidding me??

[@jayapoovarasu613]

@@bikramkeshari1381 Our Thalapathy Vijay got international award for mersal 2017 . THE ONLY INDIAN ACTOR TO GET THAT AWARD . NOW SAY WHO IS BEST

[@SuperEntertainment5]

@@jayapoovarasu613 t Vera level karuthu🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 indias no 1 actor is aamir khan

[@vigneshvidi]

No reaction in Amir Khan's face....Thalapathi always great....his innocence in this scene awesome...!!

[@Parmatmaaek]

Amir khan is best. Our bolywood is bst

[@faahkiun2198]

Vicky VIDI shut up you copy cats tamilians our aamir is best

[@faahkiun2198]

Thalapati😂😂😂😂😂

[@sathyasai6880]

Goldy interovert no way .... Thalapathy Vijay bro always ultimate so mooditu poda

[@sathyasai6880]

Atahar Chaudhary Nope .... Tamizhan da .... mind ur language stupid ... see reaction then will u do ....

[@manjuaneeshroy9413]

When I reed comments I can most people say vijay was better.....tats y I love vijay♥♥♥♥

[@paobalaji368]

Because most of the comments here are from vijay fans and in their head....stardom dominates over sensibility.

[@aravinthanrasalin9240]

Vijay best

[@gladlingladlin6455]

TheMd Moosa . if u don't know vijay how can u compare and say who is best

[@Rishikumar-go2bg]

Because in comment box most of the people from south

[@abhijeetdangi866]

@@paobalaji368 what a comment ❤️

[@mugilansubraiyan4961]

Both of them did a wonderful job but I personally felt that Vijay at his best..

[@roshanichavan2784]

I am from north and I really like Mahesh babu and Vijay.

[@unkonw3253]

U must watch Vijay last 7 moves

[@Sabkabaaphoonbsdk]

One is overactor and the other one is underactor.

[@beybladelegends6726]

@@Sabkabaaphoonbsdk stupid naai

[@Sabkabaaphoonbsdk]

@@beybladelegends6726 what stupid?

[@reshma8610]

Vijay not only an entertainer but also a good actor,human being too... I like vijay more than amir.... Loves you lot...😍😘

[@shaifuddinbhuiyanmunna1261]

U r a chutiya fan of vijay

[@chandankumar-mi4kf]

Hmm

[@rajeevkachakkat1414]

💕✨

[@nishwanth5664]

I am thalapathy fan.if you too like this comment

[@suriyaprakash8914]

Thalapathy daaaa

[@mohammedkailendar8765]

தமிழன்

[@m.sabari6052]

Thalapathy great and vv good

[@dhayafarii4046]

me too

[@lijofedrick8877]

@@dhayafarii4046 I AM TAMILAN

[@enfielder2590]

Thalapathy's innocence is lovable😍😍😍😍

[@the_varunrvel]

Not as good as Aamir's dorky one in 3 Idiots. It was more real than the cinematic innocence

[@the_varunrvel]

@@pandeykrishscss3820 You homophobic or what?

[@SJ-ey5mu]

@@the_varunrvel amir khan is waste actor comparing to vijay

[@the_varunrvel]

@@SJ-ey5mu You're a blind Thalapathy fan. Fans like you are worse than Vijay where Vijay is totally awesome

[@Sabkabaaphoonbsdk]

@@SJ-ey5mu Vijay overactor

[@sansumwibra1662]

I am from Assam n I am big big fan for Vijay i love Vijay so much n always

[@sumithrashamith1990]

Ed Alla sample.... Yenga thalapathy nale semma gethu...... Thalapathy da

[@manikandant7921]

Vijay was the perfect because of his expression while he explain the definition of Machine

[@harikrishnankanakath2121]

Yes. His eye brows coming up when he tells the long definition of machine🥰❤

[@newkerala9850]

amir is good ,and vijay was v v good

[@ritusinghparihar9653]

Right

[@joythiprakash4153]

Vijay was very good 💕💕💕

[@thepaperninja3123]

Dude im tamilan ameer was way better

[@hafisphamsa9253]

Good joke

[@rashedsaroarrashed9247]

joke of the million years.. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@mohansudhe3275]

maximum tamil version much much better.... mersalaitten...😚

[@516naishageorgezoologysf5]

mohan sudhe every thamil version not better... Like chandramukhi It's malayalam version(manichitra thazhu) is super and perfect... In malayalam Shobhana, Mohanlal, Suresh Gopi is perfect awesome actors than thamil...

[@PeterParker-so6yk]

Yes

[@priyahnj1293]

Yes thalapathi awesome

[@abhi-nl3jz]

@@516naishageorgezoologysf5 i dont know any malayalam actor thet actor not in india list dont consider thet actors

[@516naishageorgezoologysf5]

Abi nash what do you mean??

[@jackpotter1221]

Vijay Anna is always best actor 🤗🤗

[@michealeaj5678]

@@Suriya_offl no no Vijay is best

[@bikramkeshari1381]

But Vijay copied that from The perfectionist Mega star Amir Khan

[@user-hf9ik5sz6p]

@@bikramkeshari1381 even it's a remake. Vijay too did well

[@the_varunrvel]

@@bikramkeshari1381 Wrong. Even though 3 Idiots is far better than Nanban, it was Shankar who copied it. Vijay was acting good but Aamir was living it better

[@kishoreKumar-gq4gl]

It is very difficult to satisfy audiences..when a mass hero doing a remake movie.... but only thalapathy vijay can satisfy it...& aamir Khan is good actor ... But vijay is always perfect actor 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎

[@suryaganesh7733]

In 2012 Vijay was not a mass hero

[@r.asmultiverse5846]

When the film released in 2003 named *Thirumalai* , people accepted he is a massive hero.

[@btsfan4rmpakistan914]

basically I am Muslim from Pakistan but I like Vijay more than amir khan Vijay is awesome

[@therirashmi989]

Asma Ahmed thank you for your valuable comment

[@CiaoGhost98]

Asma Ahmed good😂😂😂

[@maheshkumar2912]

Thank you for supporting from Pakistan.. For vijay

[@bamangmenia114]

wow armies are everywhere from kpop to non kpop to not at all kpop related videos

[@akashdiehardfanoftaekwondo6278]

Thanks bro

[@chintusai3121]

3idiots is epic like thuppaki no one can replace Aamir khan no one can replace vijay in thuppaki this is fact

[@sheikhasad4125]

Nanban (English: Friend) is a 2012 Indian Tamil coming-of-age comedy film directed by Shankar.[4] It is a remake of Rajkumar Hirani's 3 Idiots (2009),[5] which itself was adapted from the novel Five Point Someone - What not to do at IIT! by Chetan Bhagat.[6] The film features an ensemble cast that includes Vijay, Jiiva, Srikanth, Ileana D'Cruz, Sathyan and Sathyaraj.

[@comedynightsbachao8622]

sheikh asad whatever you say but amir khan expressions were way better.and only idea was taken from 5point someone but direction script writing and screen play dialogue writing all credit goes to rajkumar Hirani .

[@595saiteja8]

Chintu Sai mahesh babu zindabad

[@user-ky9mj3gv7n]

Chintu Sai .... you're wrong a grown up kindergarten kid can replace vijay in 3idiots....... instead of acting like idiot he acted like kid in the nanban movie

[@ssravan4847]

MAHESH BABU ZINDABAD ..... SPYDER

[@deepandeepan8656]

See vijay's hands reaction

[@snglvl]

I admire Aamir khan for his many acting works. I really love the way he portrayed in 3idiots. But, The way Vijay did was natural. Let me say why. We grew up watching and idolising vijay or ajith in our college days. I have seen nerds who are also cool dudes were very much like vijay's character in this scene. They do great in studies and hang out with us all the time. We wont know when they put work on their studies. Aamir khan is a master. He gives some wisdom to his character how to speak with a professor. But Vijay displays a normal college goer who didn't know the consequences when facing a faculty who is very much capable of ruining his life. I think Aamir is a bit too humble here for a college student.

[@the_varunrvel]

Thats what Aamir's character is. He's supposed to be a dork. Vijay didnt display anything special. Just his usuals. You're right. Vijay portrayed a normal college guy but Aamir lived a dorky genius he was written to be

[@rsaravanan2887]

Vijay tells the dialog in single take but aamir Kahn face just outer

[@bikramkeshari1381]

Amir Khan is only One perfectionist If Vijay is the actor for his only Father who is a Director by Amir Khan has talents

[@sreedathsomisetty3020]

😂😂😂

[@rufiyafathima1846]

@@bikramkeshari1381 evryone is talented don't discourage anybody

[@SuperEntertainment5]

Vijay 10th dropout he takes more than 20 takes aamir khan single take

[@westfieldcom3839]

@@bikramkeshari1381 @ Aamir father is also director but still both are great

[@bharathy8234]

Vijay have an expression face, but amir khan doesn't seen like that even though the dialogue delivery is good.

[@ramprasad7673]

Vijay done this scene in a single shot...My favourite hero ❤

[@shivduttpurohit1370]

that's why he is looking like not into the character and people here are comparing him with aamir khan

[@vinodvenugopal4891]

Ram Prasad Yaa vijay' s acting is superb

[@prabhaprakash5129]

No comparison with Aamir Khan

[@akhilpremkumar7557]

Thalapathy mass

[@gamingworldadil972]

Vijay is not good acting

[@RangeshV]

vj rocks ,,bcoz its a single take....

[@thesouloflifemelodies0208]

Amir has no that much reaction in his face and other actors also less only ...vijay has given perfect action and others also

[@hindihainhum5734]

Muthamizh Karuppiah I think same about vijay because I can't understand Tamil. If you understand Hindi you might not comment on Aamir's acting or expression.

[@manikandan_ip]

@@hindihainhum5734 expressions are different from language.

[@dicaprio5350]

Direction makes the difference,Shankar is a better director than Raj Kumar Hirani

[@beyblade7246]

Why you Tamil people try to defend yourselfes rather than accepting the truth Nanban is good but cannot touch the original aamir acting was real and no over reaction like Vijay and one fellow is taking shankar is better than original director raj kumar. These Vijay fans always tell he did better acting than the original even about Mahesh Babus okkadu please change and accept the truth

[@arjunp5397]

@@dicaprio5350 Wtf

[@devendrasaisri9373]

My vote goes to illayatalapati vijay anna and east or west illayatalapati vijay anna is best and my favourite hero is VIJAY Anna and vijay Anna is best actor in kollywood and his acting is extraordinary and his smile is so cute and his dance is superb and fabulous and he is a kind hearted person and I am a die hard fan of action hero vijay Anna and vijay Anna is good in stunts and fights and he is a person who had number of fans in Tamilnadu and Andhra Pradesh

[@riswanarahim4347]

Amir bhai mass nnaa vijay macha kolamass thaan. love u thalaiva😍😙

[@sivabakkiyavathibabu5708]

Are you hindi

[@joyboy1482]

I am a vijay fan but the both vijay and amir khan had done well but in thebcase of the teacher and students i liked nanban

[@MCA_PreethiP]

Absolutely I think our thalapathy vijay.

[@SudhaKumari-ws1lx]

Vijay is very good actor. Even his eyebrows act if you observe carefully. Proud to be vijays fan.

[@Karthik-mw8kn]

I'm Tamil guy but I love Aamir Khan's original version more . Aamir khan's acting looks so natural . He is the best .

[@tharan6982]

Puriyara maari 🐢🐢🐢 sollittu poda

[@tharan6982]

Aamai

[@shakkthikannan270]

Agreed

[@hawwa5225]

Both of them were acted good in their own way

[@kevinangel234]

Thalapathi expression is superb

[@bikramkeshari1381]

Amir khan Acting is superior than Vijay

[@bikramkeshari1381]

Amir khan is great his acting is invisible

[@ahmadkamal5982]

Aamir khan is better

[@rufsanarufsana172]

y to comment,everyone know Vijay is gonna rock the universe,vijay fans like here

[@sujith_r_nadar_tn75]

No doubts...vj's natural acting best..... 😍

[@kiruthikaparamaguru7834]

AMIR KHAN IS GOOD..BUT *VIJAY* IS AN EXCELLENT PERFORMER

[@lifesymphony2024]

Look at the title of the movie. 3 idiots ( in hindi) and Nanban (means friend in tamil). Which is more positive?

[@gatisgroskaufmanis6760]

Sharmella Krishnasamy Mam I know only hindi not tamil or telgu

[@angeloperez3954]

3 idiots of course

[@shwetha3937]

Sharmella Krishnasamy nanban!!

[@onedirectioner5889]

Sharmella Krishnasamy nanban

[@mothisundar8901]

nanban

[@kcflix1265]

You can't compare them both are amazing

[@sumpihano3036]

Lol.. he can..., He can, it's his opinion. And for your kind information, directors should not copy movie, whether it's bollywood, Hollywood or tollywood, they should create thier own idea.

[@Mr.manja5]

3 idiot is best

[@mcslater_5281]

​​@@sumpihano3036 It's Not Copy There Is A Term Called REMAKE and IT Is Legal In Indian Cinema...You Know the Difference Properly .😂 and Moreover Now-a Days Bollywood Copy Majority Of Their Movies from South Cinema..Which Makes Sh*t on Your Comment😂

[@sumpihano3036]

@@mcslater_5281 well! I know the differences between Copy and Remake!! Amir khan never mention it as a remake!!! It is clearly copied!

[@mythiliponnusamy811]

always vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay vijay anna is best...

[@dineshpedia8987]

R u tami me too

[@tdeenadd1410]

thalapathi

[@knowtheunknown9323]

@@Suriya_offl salman fan spotted😂

[@parvathipa5819]

VIJAY...😍❤🔥

[@LakshmiLakshmi-yl3fd]

Always vijay

[@sweetychandra4433]

Both were good in their own way but Aamir's smile before being asked the definition was definitely a charm to watch.

[@saketsaurav3820]

Won't compare. Both are great actors. Being a hindi speaker, I haven't seen much of Vijay's work. We acknowledge Aamir as a perfectionist as he can do even dull scenes effortlessly making it enjoyable and intriguing. I have seen a few dubbed movies of Vijay and he is an excellent actor; specially when he does an angry hero. His action doesn't look forced and he has a great timing too. As far as this scene is concerned, the script wins. Both the actors are equally good in enacting it. In terms of rest of the cast and environment, 3 idiots seems to have an edge, like when we compare Omi and Sathyan. Otherwise it depends on which scene you watch first. The first watch scene will always look better than the second.

[@mittu1238]

Obviously it's Vijay 💓 look at him man his expression..kinda both are good..But it Vijay for me

[@Sujidhan]

😍Thalapathy Vijay is always Great.......

[@renugalashmanan9155]

Ilayathalapathy VIJAY IS THE BEST

[@veerasandy5466]

thalapthy always mass

[@the_varunrvel]

thats why Aamir's version is better. It's more about class than mass

[@arockiamsamy6427]

Thalapathy is nice

[@simsonmathews4364]

NANBAN is Good Remake of 3idiots........ it's the content Matter ......3 idiots gave good lesson to the North Indian parents about students Passion.......same Here Nanban gave good Lesson to Tamil parents about students Passion...... original or Remake they conveyed their message for What they are made for......Hats of both the film from a student......👏👏👏

[@ashwinshankar6223]

simson mathews gud message

[@renugalashmanan9155]

simson mathews nanban was the original one 3 idiots was the remake of nanban

[@faxthestar3120]

No bro 3 idiots 2009 n nanban 2012...shankar said that he tried hard to find every character..3 idiots is the original..but nanban or 3 idiots both are the best n i love thalapathy acting..im too thalapathy's die hard fan..

[@the_varunrvel]

@@renugalashmanan9155 double check your facts

[@nanthininanthini6405]

தளபதி விஜய் அண்ணா என்றுமே மாஸ் 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@vrunda_narayanan1829]

I m from Kerala... Both Vijay sir and Amir sir both done perfectly..but while coming to whole movie Nanban scores more I think..... Even though Hindi movie is the original one..... 💕

[@VSRSRANJITH]

Thalapathy vj's Dialogue delivery was good...

[@engineergokul1837]

thalapathy rockz. love you thalaivaaaaaaaa

[@krish5554]

Thalapathy Gokul k ha h best commedy i have ever heard in my life

[@JCJERIN]

Wow my #Thalapathy is always great

[@sridharnarasimhan1706]

Thalapathy Vijay 💥💥💥💥 better than original version

[@monumeeshka3577]

Aamir ji's effort is tremendous to transform him into his character in each and every movie. He is the best 👍👍👍

[@maxxmaxx5524]

Amir without any doubt...his innocence and simplicity in this scene is amazing.

[@abishekn7042]

East Or West Thapalathy Is Always Best

[@prakashPrakash-po9ej]

THALAPATHY than😍😍😍😍😍

[@gayathris3604]

Vijay got a International actor award for mersal movie He is first Indian actor to get the award Not other Bollywood actors

[@kishoreKumar-gq4gl]

Namalam vijay fana....so we should not underestimate others..they will realise vijays performance.

[@Bharat22158]

One common difference is that chatur's speech is still more popular than Tamil version chatur's character is irreplaceable

[@dadfilmsinternational]

thalapathy always good actor. Thanks to thala fan also

[@pavanprecious5346]

SORRY ...but outta blue @watever shitty crap name that is !!!.. so r u symbolyfying that vijay is a great actor thanks to thala fans???... dude LMFAO!!

[@arundharanipathy714]

Pavan precious thala fans replied previous about this scene so I replied thanks to thala fanz

[@pavanprecious5346]

oh!! i see . BUT may i ask who u r arun ?? and why are replying for 984088...guy?? UNless it is one of your fake accounts i presume!!XD lol

[@arundharanipathy714]

Pavan precious no my friend am doing short films so only that's given ful detail ya

[@CiaoGhost98]

9840886461 dadfilmsinternational Ha ha...his acting is funny😂😂😂...ha ha..thalapatty piece of.shit

[@TheTsuyang]

Vijay Looks Young More Suitable

[@ashutoshkarna2133]

Aukaat hai vijay ki ? Samosa bechne wale usse achcha dikhte hain

[@philomenaledger]

are you insulting people selling samosas???? or u r trying to say aamir looks like the guy selling pizza??

[@roshanichavan2784]

ye kya pagalpan hai. aamir khan ho ya Vijay ye dono India ke greatest actor hai. unka is tarah se insult mat Karo.

[@the_varunrvel]

Aamir looks like an actual dork which his character is supposed to be. He's called Perfectionist for a reason bruh

[@Dulanjalimadushikapeiris]

Vijay..he is awesome.😍...

[@mohammednuayum1803]

Aamir khan is perfectionist and he nailed this scene while Vijay just delivered the same dialogue

[@vallalmurugan4001]

Amir told in two more take but Vijay told in single take but both dialogue was same only but that dialogue was the definition of book so no one copied

[@yogeeswarikr7898]

Your channel is awesome bro....thank you for reacting to our films

[@ilakiyaarumugam5858]

Vijay is amazing

[@shafaurrehman8051]

3 idiot superb movie 😍😍😍

[@romanempire3977]

Vijay is best actor in the world and he is greatest person

[@vinvenforever6889]

Thalapathy 😍 expression super 🥰😍😍

[@azhaganvenkatesan1653]

Vijay Is looks like college student and his expression good,but Aamir is also good

[@benstienantony8876]

Thalaivaaaa ur really great🙅🙅

[@vishnuprasath8531]

Thalapathy is better than amir khan

[@manikachakraborty1697]

In this case the idea of the defination of the machine has first come from Aamir Khan in the movie of 3 idiots. Vijay has taken the idea from the movie and has executed it in a better way. So I think the credit should go to Aamir Khan for the thought of this scene otherwise individuals will like the actor whose movie they have seen regularly.

[@pratheekurmila]

Vijay acted very well, we can clearly see his acting. I couldn't see Aamir Khan acting, it was so natural, I could only see Ranchoddas Chanchad in that situation :)

[@imhsar1]

Amir has that inherent naughtiness in him that Vijay lacks.. So Amirs zipping unzipping is more believable

[@sahayavivek4978]

Vijay best actor

[@k.malleeswaran7179]

Vijay Anna mass

[@hdmoviescenes6265]

Thalapathiiii always good actor and I'm Biggest Fan of thalapathiiii 😎😎😎😎😎 thalapathiiii always great

[@eyuvashreeu6050]

vijay☺

[@sanjaybond007]

Shankar as improvised a lot to perfection. Vijay was so expressive. Every other actors did well. Amir is a legend acting was amazing but u cant compare both becoz obviously shankar will not take the photocopy of 3idiots he as proved it. If somebody films it in telugu r someother language they may improvise further.

[@rockermoll1875]

Aamir in a realistic reaction in a simple way of delivering dialogues. I go with the fact.

[@meshachthevathason2718]

Vijay all the way

[@joraj00]

both are legend.but I love vijay more than ameer

[@gsharmasvali]

The improvisation of my Tamil cinema is the inclusion of the things that we generally get to see in our day to day lives "V.V.Good"

[@aryansinghrana1990]

Hypocrite

[@gsharmasvali]

@@aryansinghrana1990 Judgemental

[@poornimagesh4759]

I love Vijay

[@gk.pers_Gk4n]

Cute expression thalapathy best performance

[@user-ug9dr8iv6g]

As a vijay fan amir khan performance better than vijay

[@aadityasuresh3768]

vijay is better

[@AnishAnish-zp1fe]

Vijay action s awesome 😘 wt a cute expression

[@rukmanimurali5772]

Thalaphathy😍😍

[@mahendragaikwad9205]

One and only superstar vijay

[@tamilmagan9771]

Vijay is face reactions is funny and thinking and his always a silent porcen and ofcourse a good human and good rolmodel good leader ,Amir doing first shoot so it's not for big but Vijay Nanban movie is 2copy so it was verry hard but Vijay doing very well .I'm (thala) fan.

[@vinodhvijayvfcvijay6073]

The vijay give super expression of the scene

[@ehtgrj1575]

Thalapathy rocks...☆☆☆☆☆

[@d1n35h7]

super 😎😎✌️

[@Keshgandi]

amir ji you are unique

[@the_varunrvel]

Nanban is a movie but 3 Idiots is an emotion.

[@haneul484]

vijay. 😘😘😘😘

[@hariprasath5458]

Vj Anna is super

[@dr.lavanphysio8689]

Action and reaction always thalapathi only best 😍

[@chandrubarathi4103]

Hindi so boring tamil super vj

[@harrivarman4303]

@@Suriya_offl hindi boring af

[@dolandtunk8147]

@@harrivarman4303 seriously?

[@harrivarman4303]

@@dolandtunk8147 yeah I'm serious

[@deneeshg9188]

Vijay action is 😇🔥🔥