$300 Nexgrill vs. $1080 Weber: Which is the Best Propane Grill?

[@richardstern9288]

Went through several cheaper grills, including a Nexgrill. The weak points were the burners, which start to degrade quickly and usually fall apart within 2 to 3 years. Cooking consistency becomes a problem right away. Bought a Weber Spirit 200 three years ago, and it cooks as well today as it did the first day I assembled it, and we grill with it far more often than any other grill we've owned (a couple of times a week, on average). It did need new heat tents this year, but that's expected and they are pretty inexpensive to replace. Igniter is still on the original battery, and grill always lights on the first push. A great product. Also, replaced the original grates with GrillGrates, which added tremendously to food flavor and juiciness. Great combo. Plan to use this setup for many years to come.

[@scrappycoco5423]

Well said. I owned a Nexgrill and it was a good value buy. After year four I replaced the burners. I’ve recently purchased my first Weber and their is really no comparison. No disrespect to Nexgrill apples and oranges.

[@hizzlemobizzle]

Major difference. You can buy a Weber when you enter college and still be using it when you are in the old folks home.

[@billwilliams9897]

I have a legit question. I have only had one gas grill, and its 2 years old and about done. Mine is just a $200 Walmart grill, I think charbroil. In its defense it has cooked at least 10 lbs of chicken a week. Sometimes 20lbs a day. I grill leg quarters for livestock guardian dogs. So I buy 50 lbs of chicken at a time. And I eat it too. So this grill earned its keep. But I am a little confused as to why the burners burn up if they as well as the tents are stainless steel?

[@richardstern9288]

@@billwilliams9897 Stainless is "stain-LESS"; it is not impervious to discoloration and rust. There are many different grades of stainless steel. Steel is basically iron + a small amount of carbon. Stainless steel is made by adding additional elements, primarily chromium, along with small amounts of silicon, manganese, and others. The amount of these other elements (which are generally much more expensive than iron and carbon) determine the grade of stainless steel. There are other issues as well. Generally speaking, the more stainless a steel is made, the harder it is, and the more difficult it is to machine and form into shapes. It becomes brittle as it gets harder and more impervious to rust. So it's a metalurgiacal balancing act. Higher quality stainless parts cost more to make. You can be certain: Budget grills use lower quality stainless parts.

[@billwilliams9897]

@@richardstern9288 thank you

[@mackintire]

I have a weber Genesis II E-Series, one model below the S - Series. I've also had 3-4 previous grills at the $300-$350 range, typically those grills burners have dissolved by year #4, and the entire grill is 100% junked by year #5. Some of those grills had decreased performance by year #3. I'm on year #2 with the weber E-Series. By what I am seeing I expect this grill will work beyond 7 years. The first component to go will be the flavor enhancers/flame guards and those are deliberately sold as replaceable components. I've repaired some of these grills in the past. If you call the manufacture they will replace parts under warranty. The manufactures are quite nice about it, but the hardware that bolts most of these grills together is junk, and none of the $300-$350 models will survive beyond 5 years if you move them or use them like I do (2-3 times a week, all year round). Lastly Grills from weber and napoleon are basically almost completely repairable with every part being available for replacement. My final comments are this. If you grill infrequently, clean and cover your grill there are $300-$350 grills out there that are worth it. Some like the nextgrill are excellent at direct grilling, and only ok at indirect grilling. The weber and napoleon models over $600 are built to last and be repaired. Weber and napolean have less expensive models and those give up some of the higher quality stainless steel components for lower quality stainless steel. Those cook better (direct and indirect) than less expensive other brands, but for most people they just aren't worth the money. If you are looking at those more expensive models understand you are not looking at a 5 year product and like most other expensive tools/appliances you'll have a little bit of TLC and maintenance if you want to keep them operating. Assuming you do, the value grows as time goes on. 5 years of a reliable grill that never develops annoying issues or falls apart and can handle any practical or even impractical cooking tasks starts to become a more tangible trait as time progresses. I've baked a pizza and made a cake on my weber grill. I wouldn't endorse trying that on many of the other models, as the hot spots and indirect heat control isn't up to the task. In short...need a grill for burgers and you only grill on occasions, yeah the $300-$350 grill is for you. Want to do it all, and are willing to invest...there's a market for that as well.

[@XiaoZong322]

Appreciate the insight

[@waynegilchrist1596]

Looks like, according to your estimates of each grill's longevity and considering the prices, a body could have 3 of the nexgrills @ $300 ea. and average of 3 years serviceability for an outlay of $900 as opposed to only 7 years of the Weber at $1080. The math says the nexgrill prorates out at approximately $100 per year and the Weber rates at approximately $154 per year. I am not a fan of propane grills myself as I prefer my big, "Kamado" But it's not cheap so it's a whole nother ball game. If you do a lot of grilling and smoking and you like being able to take control of the cooking temperature, then it's an outdoor chef's dream.

[@simonfacciani8522]

Atleast me and you can agree on spending the money on a yeti cooler !

[@adrianlouviere7650]

I have many years of grill experience both direct and indirect with propane and charcoal. I agree with much of what this fellow has said. I would like to add, If you like the convenience of a quick cook or direct grilling, propane would be your best fit. There is a lot to be said for the convenience of a new grill every two to three years. Many retailers offer free assembly with the sale. I tend to lean more toward indirect grilling and smoking which requires more time and lends itself well to charcoal and or wood fire. Weber kettle is hard to beat. Good luck

[@CloudSportracer]

I think the situation is a ymmv type situation here. I have a $300 Brinkmann 4 burner with sear burner and outside burner that I've had for the past ten years. It looks aged , the bottom plate is a little rusty, and I just bought replacement internal hardware as the current hardware looks quite rough but it's been ten years. I've mainly had it covered in a decent fabric cover but it sits on the deck. It has sat in weeks of rain during those times that I'm lazy. I did paint the screws with grill paint when I put it together to avoid rust which proves to be a good thing as it still looks pretty good given its age. At this point, I'm not convinced an expensive model would get more value if you only take care of your stuff. Think outside the box to maintain it and it should take care of you.

[@zebbie09]

You should revisit this review in five years.... The Weber will still be running like a champ. The NexGrill will be on its last leg, if not in the trash.

[@hleand210]

Agree. My 10years old Weber Genesis E-330 still going strong and I pretty much did zero maintenance.

[@boogey-gunman]

Just buy 2 more nexgrills still cheaper, stop justifying your big expense

[@theunkownwhy2820]

@@boogey-gunman Thinking the exact same thing

[@asadb1990]

@@boogey-gunman yeah for me a comparable weber to my nex grill at costco cost 4-5x as much as the nexgrill. if you take care of them both will last. i have had $40 portable grills that are still alive and kicking after years of abuse. they just need to be cleaned regularly.

[@zebbie09]

@@boogey-gunman I have a Genesis, not the Summit. But Weber also has a Spirit, which is just $200-$300 more. That would have been a better model to compare.

[@I-LOVE-EARTH]

You can cook burgers and hot dogs on a used $50 gas grill, please do another test this time with steaks and searing them, I think you may vote differently.

[@pauldailey3941]

Performance is measured in consistency. 15+ years with a stainless Weber and still doing perfectly every time. No comparison.

[@rolandaliti8079]

Sorry buddy, what part exactly of the weber grills differs in the built material here compared to the nexgrill? Your buying into a brand, simple as that. As much as it hurts to hear. Same that I did with a Broil King. Regret it massively, ye its still going after 7 years, but why would the nex not?

[@slickdeals]

Nexgrill 4-Burner Grill (MSRP $300) - bit.ly/Nexgrill-4-Burner-Gas-Grill Weber Genesis S-335 (MSRP $1,080) - bit.ly/Weber-Genesis-S-335 0:00 Introduction 1:12 Meet Justin(s) 1:29 Setup 3:16 Price 3:46 Features 6:34 Performance 8:35 Which Won? 9:28 Conclusion

[@Drew-di6nt]

Cooked on the Nexgrill and it does the job. Taste from a propane grill it’s all the same basically stove cooking but it’s how the meat is seasoned. What’s going to happen to both is a grease mess underneath the grills it’s easy to clean but it’s gonna take some time. Not sure why you need “smart” functions on a grill but I’m from Texas I cook and I’m done when it comes to grilling. I prefer charcoal before propane but if you want to be outside and don’t like waiting for white hot charcoals the Nexgrillwill get it done at a much cheaper price. Don’t be fooled by the “bells and whistles” when it comes to grilling. You need fire, grates and good meat. The bigger the grill the more to clean.

[@zebbie09]

One other thing to consider is that Weber has different price points. You should have compared to the Spirit or Genesis.

[@lewr3738]

I have a 20 year old Weber genesis. It looks great since it’s been under my gazebo since I bought. Its still on its original ignition, grates and flavorizer bars. Just this summer I replaced the burners after 20 years-a simple 30 dollars fix.

[@AM-kg5kb]

My buddy teased me 2 yrs ago for spending so much on my Weber when he got his Nexgrill… fast forward 2 yrs later and he tossed is bbq as it was rusting & falling apart. And yes, he bought a Weber 2 weeks ago after popping over to look at mine again.

[@dano727]

I've had my Weber for more than 20 years. I've only had to replace the flavorizer bars and grill grate. Try finding replacement parts for the cheaper grills in 20 years or even 10 years. The cheaper grills are just disposable, wasteful grills... much like almost everything these days...

[@hizzlemobizzle]

Exactly right.

[@davidchen4538]

I think the purpose of buying an expansive grill is to hope it will last longer. If you bring in any 2 new or almost new grills from any of those big stores they should be working fine. A weber cost around 1k gives 10 years warranty and a nexgrill only gives 1 year. Weber can last 10-15 years and if you are willing to change some parts it might last 30-40years. a nexgrill maybe last 4-7 years?? I would definitely go for Weber to save money in the long term. Also, Weber spirit 210 only cost around $550 with the same warranty and quility

[@jimmylarge1148]

I had a Weber handed down from my grandma that she used for as long as I could remember. I got it and used it for another 8 years. Still worked great but the cart finally rusted apart. I’d guess it was at least 20 years old. No parts replaced ever.

[@markeissler]

The parts on the Nexgrill are also replaceable. I just gave away my Weber Genesis, like the one shown, and enjoyed the iGrill feature for sure. The gas indicator (by weight) and the sensor which appears in iGrill are also convenient but not all that accurate. The button to switch on the led ring lights around the knobs broke within 2 years, but it's not like they were actually useful in any way. I previously owned a Kirkland bbq which was manufactured by Nexgrill. That thing was a behemoth. In the rough (costantly damp) conditions of the Pacific NW the burners on that thing didn't last very long (I'd say every two years they needed replacement). We bbq several times per week all year round. For sure, the Nexgrill is more likely a disposable grill but then in some way they all are unless you are one of those people that grills 3 times per year and makes a big deal about it. You can't deny the value in the Nexgrill.

[@davidneuzil9356]

Thank you for trying to do a fair comparrison. When I saw the one guy trying to flip cheese burgers with a set of tongs I knew then that this was not a serious comparrison however well intentioned. Doing Burgers and hot dogs for comparrison is like boiling water in a $5 pot compared to boiling water in a $100 pot. For backyard burger and dog cooks, any grill (I mean any grill) will work. Thanks again for the effort.

[@Xaplelul]

Go get em Dave. A real man like you knows his grilling and isn't afraid to say it.

[@rblancarte]

SPOT ON. I skipped to the end to see the results and I saw hot dogs and hamburgers and I was like WTF?!!?! That isn't how you test a grill. Do steaks, do things that if you get wrong, you know. NOTE - I have owned both of these grills, I really liked my Nexgrill. But it is nothing compared to my Weber, NIGHT and DAY. The Nexgrill was hard to get consistent results on. Steaks? One was perfect the other needed more time and they would vary in cook time, despite usually having consistent meat (size, shape, quality). Weber nails it just about the same times each time. And I can do things like slow long cook roasts on the weber which I would never try with the nexgrill. Yeah, this comparison was a dud.

[@MrAndysalgado]

😂🤡

[@chefmesser420]

Not necessarily I like a nice char on my burger u need heat for that. Not all grills are hot enough.

[@c.ramiez4505]

Just bought the Nexgrill Stainless Steel model. You can build it in about 45 minutes if you’re mechanically inclined. I can see how it might be difficult if you’ve never built anything before. Home Depot usually has them prebuilt if you’re nervous to take on the task of building it. While it is a little cheaper built then the Webber, I’ve had a Nexgrill 2 burner stainless steel model for years and its still holding up. Just take care of it by cleaning it every time and covering it after use.

[@8475143117]

I just completed assembling the Nexgrill 4-Burner grill and found it very EASY and fun. I will agree that the assembly instructions offer very few words but pretty much ONLY pictures that were very usable for me as I am mechanically inclined. I agree that it is cheaply made with sheet stainless steel but I guess it will do for now... I haven't yet grilled on it as I just finished assembling it...

[@fnafchannelquinn3486]

My nexgrill has been kicking ass going on 6 years. I never cover or store it and it still looks new. I used a $20 rebuild kit 3 years ago to replace the burners, igniter, and fire covers. It will not matter how much you spend if you are a shit owner.

[@tdyrkacz]

my weber is 13 years old and it looks and functions like the day i bought it. I went through a number of 200-500 grills before the weber and most lasted about 3 years. This is a no brainer. Get the Weber.

[@jackedwards7420]

My nexgrill is 6 yrs old and still going strong, I have turned it into griddle with a q230 grill top griddle

[@jackchristensen7725]

I just bought this exact Weber grill at Home Depot for $580 on sale from $1,080. What a deal…. It will be delivered & set up for free Friday! I feel like I got an awesome deal for a long lasting great quality Weber grill 👍🏻

[@hardon4life]

What weber model?

[@bradw.5991]

Your review was lagging on the mechanical features of both grills like the spider shields that the Weber has around the burner tubes, or size of the air gap between the back of the grill lid and the base (the Weber is about a half an inch were the Nexgrill is almost two inches). Also the Weber has a drip shield on the back of the grill lid so when it rains, the rain water doesn't roll back into the grill and overflow the drip pan. How did the grills perform when its windy outside? (maybe you should have set up a couple of fans to test). These are the kind of things that are to be Reviewed when comparing products. Having two separate car manufactures with the vehicles moving at the same speed reaching the same destination at the same time doesn't 'Compare/Review' the two cars!

[@slickdeals]

All good points! We shot over 2 hours of footage and decided not to include the more technical nitty gritty for the sake of time.

[@glenschecter97]

One thing I have to mention. I own the Webber Summit series and I love it! Also, Weber has the best customer service center you can get. They are fantastic! I had a small problem and they took care of it beautiful. I can not say enough good things about the company! It is worth the extra money!

[@jackdawson3276]

Yes! You pay more for the superior made in USA build quality and outstanding customer service and support. The cheap grills are only truely good for one or two seasons. If you are tenant on a budget, then get a Weber Spirit grill. That line is made in China but still are better quality than the cheap brands.

[@rolandaliti8079]

This is not true..

[@firesquad31]

17 year old genesis, only thing that has been replaced is the ignition battery. The flavorizer bars are getting small holes but not too bad for the age. Grill atleast once a week.

[@paulsycamore3012]

Would be very helpful to know how were the flareups from grease drippings. That's one of the most important aspects of grilling and can determine the difference between a perfectly grilled piece of meat, and one that gets charred from flareups greatly diminishing the grilling attempt.

[@slickdeals]

I asked the guys about consistency in cooking and neither grill had an issue. That could change over time if you don't consistently clean the grills, and I would actually be a bit more concerned with it on this particular Weber model because of the proximity of the burners on the right side to create that searing station, along with the extra internal pieces (the Weber has flavorizer bars as well as heat deflectors while the Nexgrill only has the deflectors).

[@timothyFL]

Flare ups arr from not cleaning not the brand I have $150 grill no flare ups and nice grill no problems I clean them and take care I live in Florida rain every day no rust on both

[@tisithecount4198]

I’m three years into my nexgrill. It rocks but I have had to replace parts at the end of year 3. I don’t move it around and keep it clean. Great value. I will still move up to a Weber next because not all parts are replaceable

[@vociferon-heraldofthewinte7763]

My last Weber performed perfectly for 24 years. I just replaced it last year, with another Weber, not because of problems but to get more bells and whistles.

[@FritoJ]

“626 square inches ends up being about 23 burgers” Sir, you clearly have not seen my burgers.

[@slickdeals]

Hahaha SAME. That's the estimate Home Depot gives on these grills

[@gslife1]

I owned the nexgrill and had it for 1 year. My neighbor sold his house and gifted me his 4 year old Weber genesis grill. I never knew how expensive the genesis were. Long story short the Weber cooks amazing and I never get flare ups like the nexgrill. Weber cooks evenly. I sold my Nexgrill even though it looked newer and shinier. Biggest thing I noticed is the Webber burner design, burners are much lower and better covered to prevent any flare ups.

[@jp7489]

I have a nexgrill still burning had it for about 3 years no issue's yet..

[@pjerosumavabich3074]

I used to go through cheep grills, one was actually a nextgrill, every two years. I have had my Weber for 4 years and it’s holding up great. I will never buy another cheap grill again. This Weber will likely hold up >10 years.

[@Rcarr3]

This is a great video, but I would say the Weber is still worth it. While I had a nexgrill and thought it was great… I was buying a new grill every 3-4 years. I keep my grill covered and cleaned but a Weber just lasts longer. So that’s another point to consider. You’re paying $800 more but also getting better features and longevity.

[@kmorris6107]

You are an expert builder .. 2 grills in 4 hours .. most people take much longer

[@Brian-tu7jn]

My Nexgrill just fell apart after 7 years (burners replaced for free under the 5yr warranty right before it expired). The lid is pristine, but the burner box completely rusted out dropping the back of the burners, so here I am at the same decision point i was at 7 years ago. I could see paying triple for a Weber if it lasted 3-4 times as long and had a better overall cook, but otherwise i keep coming back to the comments others have made- i could buy a new nexgrill every 5 years and still come out ahead financially (I actually enjoy putting them together so that's not a factor). We often entertain so really need the bigger surface or i'd be tempted to get the midgrade weber as a compromise, and we grill nearly year round. Ultimately i'd love to be able to justify a Weber because i think they're built better, but spending $1000 on a grill just seems impossible to justify. Also thought I'd add i never use the side burner when grilling, but always get a grill with burner because it's exceedingly handy when the power goes out!

[@alvd8511]

First of all you cannot compare 2 products that are at a completely different price points. It’s like comparing Honda Accord to a BMW M5. Both are great cars and will take you from A to B. Based on what I read, Weber is one of the top notch grilles for performance and durability. It all comes Dow to what you can afford.

[@dirtycommtroop]

The cheaper grills will last you a lot longer if you clean and cover them. Its the lack of maintenance and exposure to the elements year round that really takes a toll on it. You should ask yourself how often you are going to grill and are you going to clean and cover it. I bought a grill like this for my cabin but it stays covered and will only see use once or twice every 2 weeks at the most.

[@peterwillems2422]

Even with covers, the cheaper grills only last a few years. The quality comes in the extras. Weber grills (most if not all) have cast aluminum burn boxes and stainless steel burners. These are the two most fail points of cheaper grills. Also another point of better grills is the sturdiness of the cabinet/stand. The nexgrill has an open back, that if not covered, is open to rain getting inside the cabinet.

[@thehexman1]

You can buy the cheaper grill but in 5 years you have to replace it. The Weber if you take care of it will last a very long time. My Weber Genesis E-310 has been going strong for close to 15 years.

[@Slicey007]

My 2011 Weber Genesis still looks and cooks like brand new - there is no substitute - plus the sear burner let's me hit 700 degrees when I'm doing steaks. Not sure about the newer ones and the quality but there is definitely something behind the name that holds true about the quality and reason so many people hang on to them.

[@miked9594]

Sorry but the Weber Genesis II from 1994 ran until last year because I brought up to the Andes NY and left it out in the cold. It’s a beast? I feel like the cheaper line of grills work great at first and will work for 3 years but then break down and you need to buy another. So while you’re saving cash at first in the end you’re going to spend more in the long run.

[@smokedya420]

You are paying extra for the reliablity of weber. I had a char broil $300 and it only lasted 2 seasons and i cleaned n covered it after every cook. I upgraded to weber and have not regretted it since.

[@searex2268]

Really/ what went wrong, i used a cheap 200 grill from sam club taht lasted me since 2012 until now , 9 years, still running but rust the bottom , i just used it yesterday, it's fine but im throwing it out and bought nexgrill for 250 shipped :)

[@smokedya420]

@@searex2268 the porcelain grates started to rust. The drip pan was rusty too it. The drip pan was really small. It still lit up and ran but I didn't like rust on my grates. I gave grill away to neighbor on nextdoor app

[@searex2268]

@@smokedya420 tbh, rusting is part of nature doesnt matter if u cover or not, oxidation & moisture will get it even for stainless steel, best way to prevent it is to completely cover brand new grill with grease and heat it up so the grease (shortening) to bond w/ the metal surface ) and create an non stick surface, . I didnt do that so my grill is rot out on bottom, but my grate are extremely shiny, the trick is dont clean off the grease & fat from the grate after using. i love my grates i think i gonna keep them ( not stainless steel, just regular cast iron) and keep as spare part

[@jimrusch22]

After going through grill after grill, I’ve found the Weber grill withstands the test of time. I still can get parts for my 2008 Weber Genesis E series. After all these years of heavy use it still looks and works like new.

[@jrobdickson8498]

That’s the thing about Webers- you can get parts for them-

[@dustinsauter2832]

Can't say I agree with this video at all. I've owned a Nextgrill and a few Webers (recently picked up a Genesis SPX-435 which is amazing) and it's not even close. The Nextgrills are not only cheaply made, they have a giant design flaw in that the burners and flavor bars are WAYYYYYY to close to the grate which causes constant flare ups, full on grease fires and hot/cold spots. And as others have pointed out, the cheap construction means that they rot out super quick....if you get 3 years out of one of these things without a burner rotting or part of the firebox rotting, you will be lucky. And Nextgrill has crappy support and it's difficult to find parts which pretty much makes these things disposable. Weber is totally opposite. Fantastic support, plenary of parts, great aftermarket/3rd party parts and a solid community of people that love to grill. And the results are so much better than the Nextgrill. This thing can get to around 700 degrees quick with little variance across the grill, holds heat well and even if there is an occasional flare up, the thing isn't catching on fire. Don't waste your time with Nextgrill. If you are on a budget, then just get a lower model Weber and it will still run circles around anything Nextgrill puts out.

[@dannydee9919]

As a homeowner, One item that is on my "don't skimp out" list is a propane grill. Its weber or nothing. Better quality food and longevity. Yes the initial cost is higher but you are very likely that you will never buy another grill in your lifetime. My parents bought their genesis grill in 1995 and still getting used to this day. Original parts in all. I bought mine in 2013, if i had to do it all over again, i would of bought a weber summit.

[@matetheking]

I think you have to consider cost of ownership over longterm. I haven't bought a new grille yet, but I am done buying garbage that starts to fall apart and rusts after 4 or 5 years. 10 year warranty and better quality materials encourage me to consider getting a weber.

[@Iknowonlywhatimtaught]

Than you for the review. When you don't make enough to throw out $1,000+ for a grill, you h.ave to do what you got to do. I just paid $139.00 and free shipping on my Nexgrill 6 burner. Best grill I ever had. For this price it will let me grill as I save for a better grill if I choose. Which I probably will upgrade in a few years. That's the plan anyway. A car is a car but there are better cars.

[@sjvader2003]

I’ve had my Weber Spirit for 15 years, I am now just replacing the burn tubes

[@gaptastic]

I've had a weber grill for over ten years. I highly recommend them

[@Hoster987]

Durability is a key....used multiple weber last 20 plus years...some lasted 10 plus Yeats without issues especially rusting of base plate while others rusted qucikly...and I religiously clean and protect them with covers...sometimes weber will send you free replacement parts even after warranty expires

[@gzngahr]

I cannot speak to the quality of Nexgrill, but I have a Weber Genesis E330 that I bought in August 2012. I just today got a new set of burners warrantied because they rusted through just shy of their 10 year warranty. I opted to purchase new flavorizer bars and heat deflectors at this same time to fully revitalize my grill for about $115. The only other maintenance I have had to do is the occasional cleaning and replacing of the AA battery. There is a little bit of rust around where the castor wheels attach to the frame, I plan to wire brush and Rustoleum those as well.

[@rickbrio9485]

I’ve had both, Weber and Nexgrill. Weber had a lot of issues with flame control and consistency. Nexgrill out lasted it and I ended up sticking with it. Had it for 7 years and no issues. I think it comes down to how you care for your items and environment you live in. Save your 800 bucks, get a Nexgrill! Made in America doesn’t mean anything anymore, if Ford is assembled in Mexico now. Life is universal. Just look for quality products materials and take care of your stuff.

[@SL-vs7fs]

Weber grills are solid, and will last a long time. If you live in a high wind area, you will appreciate that the Weber barely budges when the wind is knocking about. I wouldn’t pay for a new one, but I would buy a used one for $300 easily.

[@RonOrud]

I know of 25 yo Weber’s. (Non stainless) that are in great condition. I would love to see how the Next holds up in that time.

[@deanndasilva8467]

We have a Weber Genesis. It is over 15 years old and still looks really good. Due to it age, the Fuel Crossover tube broke. Luckily, Weber still carries the part, so it can be replaced. The part only cost $20. I am happy Weber still carries the part since so many companies these days stop carrying parts after 10 years, so you are forced to buy a new appliiance. Unfortunately, customer service was complex. We ordered the part and paid for overnight shipping. The part never arrived. We called and learned that the part was out of stock. Fine, I understand. However, it would have been nice to know that when we ordered it. We re-ordered and again requested overnight shipping. Again, the same issue happened even though they had checked stock this time. Ordered again. Same issue. Now, after 2 months, and having to call them four times, we hope to have our part delivered in two days. I understand there is a supply chain issue, but customer service should have been able to check stock or at least notify us that the part was not coming. Having to call four times and trying to get through to a person was a waste of time. I feel like Weber is a brand that will last, and perhaps that justifies the expense, but since it is three times more expensive, the Nextgrill may be a good option. When this grill fails, I will likely get a Nextgrill instead of coughing up over $1,200 for another grill.

[@hizzlemobizzle]

To save money I recommend looking for a used Weber. Clean it up add new burners and you are good to go with a far superior grill.

[@frankastuto3211]

My Weber just turned 20 years old!! It’s killing me to buy another, but it’s time. Let’s see one of those cheapo brands do that!

[@larrysmac]

I'm replacing my Spirit with a Spirit II only because it endured 15 Michigan winters uncovered.

[@Rico_Hexican]

You guys should follow up with a 2 year update and a 10 year update. My guess, the Nexgrill will be out by the curb at 2 years and the Weber will still be cooking in 10 years, if you can't afford to spend $1000 on a grill, look at the Weber spirit line, which can be had for around $500. Not sure why they put a $1000 grill against a $300 one? If $500 is out of the budget, pick up a used Weber off craigslist, will still outlast this Nexgrill.

[@kirkthebeerslinger]

That's what I did...I had a virtually new Nexgrill and a free but virtually new Charbroil...I bought a used Weber plus a few parts and sold the other two grills and had money left over...WIN!

[@KWatson1984]

We have 2 NexGrill at work and they work, but we have to replace them every couple of years because the burners get holes in them and the hinges break. I have a Weber Spirit that lasted 9 years out in the weather before the parts rusted to the point I stopped using it. I just bought a 10 yr old Weber Genesis that looks like new and will last many more years. My father's 24 year old Weber Genesis is semi-sheltered and is still going strong.

[@markdetoma9062]

I have the nexgrill and it last about 3 years I’m on my 2nd one the burners and flame diffusers do rust out and cause uneven flames distribution after 3 years but that being said I’d rather spend just about $200 and get 6-7 years instead of $100 and get 5 years

[@jimmylarge1148]

I had a Weber that lasted over 20 years with zero parts replaced. I replaced it with a nexgrill and hated it. Very uneven heat and crapped out after two years. Junk.

[@lucky13farms99]

We've had a Weber Genesis for 12 years now. Gonna cook on it tonight. Still doing fine. Cost 800 bucks back then. These 3-400 dollar grills will not last. Oh, had 3 sets of burners in it so far. First 2 were replaced under the 10 year warranty for free.

[@thereelchad]

Because of the smart phone and the wheels? You give it to the Webber??

[@jenkins9104]

I purchased my Weber in 2001. I’ve replaced the flavour bars, and the cart rotted out 4 years ago. I called and Weber sent full replacement parts. This is an expensive BBQ but in my mind worth every penny.

[@80goal]

Actually in Canada, the price difference is 5 times for large grills 750 sq in: $350 under promo vs $1700. No way I can justify the price difference and I'll feel guilty if I buy the expensive one. I bought cheap one with zero maintenance and lasted 9 years. If I buy an expensive one, I'll feel the obligation of doing regular maintenance. But with a cheap one that can last 5-10 years with zero maintenance, with fraction of price 1/5, I can't go wrong in my opinion. We grill only from April to November

[@josephsalak3430]

Look at the grills 3 yrs later! I've owned 3 weber got 20 yrs out of each one. Keep your low priced grills

[@vinny6685]

We’ll said

[@vinny6685]

Well

[@RobertA-jw4pe]

23 yrs with my Weber and they just sent me my new fire box and a few more replacement parts all that were under warranty Weber is the only grill I would ever buy

[@JimTheis32]

I have a Weber Genesis…. I’ve owned and thrown away too many cheap grills. I’m very happy with my Weber and I expect it to last.

[@agfa663]

It does NOT have phone connectivity. One have to buy the i-grill-3 separately for that. It only has the built-in cradle for the i-grill 3.

[@djcordes4352]

I can tell you why you want the weber genesis. I’ve had mine for 14 years and it looks brand new. And not touch the burners or the flavor bars at all. The entire bottom below the burners pulls out so you can clean all the drippings Preventing flareups. Plus the Weber cooks chicken absolutely perfect and when it’s on medium it’s exactly 400° which is the exact medium temperature. Extra money spent in the long run will be well worth it.

[@METRIKxv1]

Yeah I'm getting a Weber now. I kept getting those cheap generic home Depot grills but they only last like 2 years and they feel like tin cans 😂

[@daveh8405]

I’ve owned both. The next grill lasted 3 years. Everything on the inside rusted, burners, covers over the burners and the catch tray under the burners. I’ve had my Weber for 3 years now and it looks almost new. A good cleaning and it would look new. If he would have shown a side by side comparison of the parts used inside the grill one could see why there is a price difference. Also one is made in America one in China. I will let you figure out which is which. Weber hands down is the best. Same money by the time you replace that next grill in the next year few years.

[@tomdavis3038]

You could get 3 brand new grills that would last a decade. That’s how some people think. Bear in mind that’s not my view. People love buying and throwing away. Consumerism run amok Cheers

[@renereyes3311]

cheap grills are for cheap lightweight amateurs. If. You're serious about grilling and don't want to be embarrassed at your next cookout, get a well made grill.

[@davidkreitzer6712]

I assembled grills for my job at a big box store and you did a terrible comparison video. ANY grill can cook burgers and dogs. One key factor in the longevity of a grill is ease of cleaning and availability of parts - you mentioned neither. The Weber design makes cleaning the firebox a breeze and has been around a long time - parts will be available for years, but sure, go ahead and buy the cheap grill. You’ll find yourself buying another new grill in 2-3 years when it rusts out on you. Your review was a big waste of time.

[@armandboisvenue2987]

The problem with this review is he should do it after 3 years of use. The Nexgrill will be trash and the Weber will still be working like new. You get what you pay for with grills. I just bought a new Weber and gave my old Weber to my son. It is over ten years old. Had to replace the burners and it's good for another 5 years +.

[@joeb.5564]

I have that nexgrill, bought it almost 2 years ago, 2 winters and 2nd summer started and the drip tray is completely rotted, the burners are rusted and holes have to be rust scraped often and the grills are pretty shot also, not to mention the heat plates are junk, and I bbq homemade burgers every week all year.. I'll definitely be looking for weber or similar that will work for 10yrs without rotting out. JMO 👍

[@freddyoner]

You can justify it when you realize that next grill will only last you two years if it gets left out in the elements. Also, Weber has $200-$800 that will still outlast that next grill. I bought a Weber in 2006 that still performs like the first day. I don’t put the grill cover on it. It gets rained and snowed on. I had to replace the flame starter and the thermometer once. Before I bought my Weber I was buying grills on the $200-$300 range every other year. You cannot compare grills based the burgers or eve features that much. What matters most is built quality and how long they last in your backyard. If I had kept buying my regular next grill I would have spent $1500 in 10 years. I only spent $750 on my 4 burner grill with a side cook top.

[@johnnyclarik1]

I own a Nexgrill and have had no issues. At least, not yet. This is a review which should probably be repeated after a year and even after five years so as to compare how they have held up.

[@come_on_now]

When you put a burger between some bread, umm, who's counting grill marks? In my opinion, the more grill marks, mmm, the better... more char for your burger is better

[@dianabriggs7052]

What size orifice to convert to natural gas from LP?

[@paulhegreness4865]

Here’s the deal with Weber we use ours weekly. We bought it in 1998 with minimal repairs.

[@cecilmckeithan5088]

That’s what I don’t like about grills these days. They put the burners higher up and they get really hot and it’s harder to cook at lower temps. I prefer lava rock grills due to the fact the rock disperses the heat so much better. A bonus to this is the rocks carry the heat and I have used that to cut off grill and finish cooking just with the reserved heat. Most things I cook I like a slow and low cook and these newer grills like to cook way hotter than the older grills. You have to cut off 2/3 of your burners in order to keep heat down and they are harder to maintain one temp.

[@jimdent351]

Nexgrill will last 3 years and the Weber will last 10, easily. Also, the Nexgrill will show signs of rust the first time it gets wet, and you will have to baby sit those steaks or it will burn. Trust me!

[@jaybartgis5148]

Who cares. Just buy a new one every 3 years and save money 😂

[@jimdent351]

@@jaybartgis5148 The cheap grills are prone to flair ups. If you like burnt food then knock yourself out!

[@Drew-di6nt]

@@jimdent351 flare ups come with grease dripping so that happens with even charcoal grills also not cleaning your grill can cause it no matter the price.

[@jimdent351]

@@Drew-di6nt I understand that but I've just seen those cheaper ones not cook nearly as well, and any one I've ever cooked on was not trust worthy enough to walk away from and do other things inside the house.

[@fidothepetmonkey]

I bought a cheap grill like 8 years ago with my house and it’s still fine.. I don’t know what you’re doing to your grills that kills them so quick lol.

[@syung8549]

Hate to be negative, but this review is not very helpful. Almost any propane grill can grill burgers and stuff like that, whether they're $100 or $1000. You don't pay $1,000 to cook a burger patty. What sets grills apart is heat retention, even indirect heat (most grills like this can't even get meat hot enough through indirect heat becase the heat just vents right out do to poor lid design), and even heat throughout the cooking surface. You didn't cover any of these issues.

[@slickdeals]

Thanks for the feedback. We'll make sure we do better next time. - Austin

[@johnnybwrlr983]

There is definitely a problem with this review. It was the other reviews like this one, why I bought a Nexgrill, exactly like the one in your video and was sorry I ever bought it. Now I have a Weber Genisis II S-335 like the one in your video and I am positive I made the best decision possible. In fact, I will go so far as to say, the Weber Genisis II S-335 is worth at least 3 times the price of the Nexgrill and maybe even more! While no high end grilling system, Weber puts a lot of thought into the build. They line the hood, use a cast aluminum body, 304 stainless burners and a cabinet design that prevents water collection on the metal. The Nexgrill I own, wore out in 3 years. And in that time, I replaced burners once, flavor bars twice, ignition system onve, and grates once. Then the stainless body of the grill fell apart. The problem with the Nexgrill, is that the stainless steel is not 304 stainless, but some inferior grade that deterioates rapidly. This is especially true with the burners. My 3 year old nexgrill was in such miserable condition that I put it on the curb with a free note, and the scrap collectors took it for its metal. I have had a Weber grill in the past, and it has been my experience and many other peoples experiences that show the Weber grill to last 10-20 years. So, in fact, there is value in the difference in build quality. Don't make the bad choice to buy the Nexgrill based on short sided reviews like this one. Save your money and buy a grill that will hold up better. If you want a better built, quality grill, then be prepared to shell out $4,000 or more. As others put it, under about $800, you are buying junk. $1000-$2000 is a quality grill. $2000-$4000 is a premium grill and $4000-$14000 is considered a luxary, (professional quality), grill. In the quality grill area, Most important is the body of the cooking area. Cast aluminum makes for a better grill. 304 stainless burners, flavor bars and grates are ideal. Smart design, like a hood liner is important. Burner heat shields are important to prevent flare-ups. Weber has these things, Nexgrill does not!

[@camnguyen3953]

For the Weber, they have an app that show you step by step. I have build a hand full to see that it is so easy to build.

[@jzero32]

ou can also simply go to you tube where normal people give their impressions on how to's and their actual experiences and likes and DIS likes .

[@cdragon88]

Ez choice, bbq master? Buy the more expensive grill--itll last longer and youll learn to cook on it effectively. Occasional bbq person? Buy the cheap grill--you can always replace it with another cheap grill.

[@franciszajauskas35]

I got an OG Weber Genesis back in 1998 Guess what 24 years later it's still works The only thing I had to replace was the igniter one time just bought the Genesis 2 3:35 and love it to death had the same exact one you reviewed with the sear burn and I would say beyond the shadow of a doubt give it 5 years the Nexus will rot to hell fall apart and you will not have any consistent temperatures like the Weber does by far the Weber wins my heart 5 million percent compared to a Nexus cheap quality cheap grill you pay for what you get and I will pay bar none for the Weber I consider this a biased review because of the fact of what Nexus is yet cheap but you get what you pay for....

[@csApollo11]

Love the part with Justins

[@dsb227]

Great video, thanks for the information! I'll take one of those burgers!

[@eoland]

I just threw a Nexgrill away after five years. I replaced the flavor bars, grill grates and burners after three years. The box of the Nexgrill very cheaply made and fell apart after five years. In my opinion I would rather pay more and be able to replace parts for 15 years and still have a working grill. Weber is a better value if you want it to last longer.

[@spoon8890]

Theres no comparison, you get what you pay for. If you want a meh grill thats going to fall apart in a few years, get the Nexgrill. If you want a quality lasting grill get the Webber.

[@nigel900]

There ain’t no damn grill worth $1,000+ dollars anyway. Buy that, and 3 or 4 years from now looks and works no better than a cheap $200 Wal-Mart model…

[@amwood7076]

The not Justin's "narrators"hair is killing me. I've seen comb overs but comb forward is hilarious. I'm laughing as I type. Hair club for men. Still laughing out loud.

[@CP-pb3pj]

I love my 2 burner Weber Spirit 2. Free 10 year parts warranty. I don’t have experience with Nexgrill.

[@takishabaker7520]

I have a Weber Spirit E-210 It's hard to get it to ignite for some reason. You have to turn the propane on very very slow. I don't think its worth the price i paid.

[@SpikeRazorshards]

Loved this guy in The Hangover.

[@ericwilliams626]

You get old enough to understand that with some products you buy, BRAND is everything. There is a reason. Ever heard of someone complaining about a Weber? Yes, there is always someone complaining their pot of gold didn't come in a pot made of gold, but seriously, think about it. Brand matters with grills.

[@louisgiuliana7929]

You’re missing the point ..in a few years that nextel to grill is going to rot out.. the constant heating and cooling will destroy the inferior frame cover, etc. of that unit. With the Weber eventually all grills, will need burners replaced.. and with the Weber. It’s well worth to rebuild it . Meaning replacing the parts that we’re out but the unit itself will last a long time.

[@whenpiratesattack]

"Pretty much just as good" translates as a coping for the cost of the Weber. Great video but not the same conclusion I came to for grills. :)

[@SortaDopeIGuess]

Common Sense - do you like to goto Home Depot every few years to get rid of and replace your rusted out cheap grill whose burners are only half of their effeciency? At the end of the day, the inconvenience and time does NOT equal the initial savings. You pay for what you get and weber's are known on forums to last a long time.

[@poppaschlong2000]

I have a summit 670 I bought new in 2012 and it still looks and works like the day I bought it. Cheap grills rot out very quick up here in canada with our winters. I would have owned likely 3 cheap grills over the se 12 years

[@lamboseeker238]

I have the Weber. I bought it after the nexgrill died. Go Weber. 3/16 aluminum body, stainless top, stainless grate, after market parts everywhere. Save your money get the Weber.

[@danielanderson635]

My Weber Genesis 330 is 10 years old. Just replaced the old steel flavor bars and heat deflectors with 1.2mm 303 stainless which should last forever for 35 bucks. The original SS burners still work like new as well as the ignition system and not a spec of rust. I had a Nexgrill that the bottom rusted out after 2 years. But hey, at least the burners still worked. Lol.... Nexgrill is no comparison. Sure you can fire up any brand new grill and get similar results. But in 10 years that Nexgrill will be in a landfill with 8years of garbage piled on it. The Weber will still be cooking like the day you bought it with minimal maintenance. You get what you pay for.

[@RR-qf9re]

One thing that you can’t test is longevity…cheaper grills are thin material metal material and warp really easy during high heat. Plus corrosion is a big issue with cheaper grills.

[@slickdeals]

Nexgrills on average have a higher heat output, too, which would likely contribute to decay of the materials. That's another thing to keep in mind when comparing the brands.

[@1pollock405]

You can look up videos of people restoring 30-year-old weber gas grills by sticking $50 worth of parts in them and they run like new. This is because Weber uses cast aluminum fire boxes in their grills which do not rust. On the other hand you can look at videos of people showing their 3 to 4-year-old cheap grills and the whole firebox is rotted out on them.

[@kirkthebeerslinger]

I skimmed some comments - maybe someone else mentioned it-the BTU's on the Weber...always wondered about that until I bought one...I will never use another BBQ. Weber Genesis heats up HOT, fast and cooks evenly...all with less BTU...The heavy lid and cookbox are key to this efficiency...they retain and redirect heat much better than the thinly made models...you may be able to buy three new Nexgrill BBq for the price of one Weber-but tbh...you are better off buying a used Weber in good condition that may only need a little cleaning for the same money as a new Nexgrill and you will have made the better investment...and if a $1200 grill doesn't affect your lifestyle any different than a $300 grill...just get a new Weber...you truly won't regret it...my meats come out juicier and more evenly cooked on a used 14yr old Weber Genesis with new stainless flavorizer bars and new stainless grates than on a new Nexgrill or Charbroil Infrared...I used to be skeptical...but hands down better outdoor cooking investment IMHO

[@jackedwards7420]

Well.... you also compared the cheap base model nexgrill to a top of the line Weber! Mine is the $650 upper range nexgrill and is more compatible with the Weber!! Comparing apples to oranges!!

[@slickdeals]

At the time we recorded the video, the two we chose were the most comparable options for each brand - both grills were the most affordable options with 4 burners. If anything, I'd say we were biased towards weber because it's not *technically* considered a 4 burner but a 3 burner with a special searing station.

[@byronholt3993]

Take this into consideration, I’ve had the same Weber Genesis gas grill for the last *24* YEARS. Original Cast Iron grates but the gas burner is about to need replaced. You get what you pay for on the long haul. Buy quality and you’ll never regret it.

[@byronholt3993]

I have replaced the flavorizer bars about every 5 years.

[@gerrylundergaard60]

The 24 year mark was before they were made in China.

[@sttm1283]

you cant compare them over just one session. i myself also feel like the weber being 8x more expensive. but its not that. you have to consider the quality of the parts etc. im sure they both do similar whilst cooking. but how long will the nex grill last. we all know webers, if yhou take care of them, they will last a looooooong time. in the end its all about yourself, how much are you willing to pay for a gas grill. i would definatley buy the nex grill. id rather buy a new one after a few years and save me a buck or three. although i own a weber spirit. but with owning that for 2 years now, id say id rather pay less for a not so known brand and rather swap it out often than paying what weber wants.