335: Examining Anas ibn Malik's status as Prophet's companion | Our Prophet

This episode is from Chapter 14 of Our Prophet -- the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s) by Sayed Mohammed Baqer Qazwini.
View the complete Chapter 14 (Conquering Khaybar) here:
• Chapter 14: Conquering...
Links to previous Chapters:
Chapter 1 (Prelude):
• Chapter 1: Prelude | O...
Chapter 2 (Birth to Revelation):
• Chapter 2: Birth to Re...
Chapter 3 (The Mission Begins):
• Chapter 3: The Mission...
Chapter 4 (Struggles in Mecca):
• Chapter 4: Struggles i...
Chapter 5 (Road to Medina):
• Chapter 5: Road To Med...
Chapter 6 (Foundations of Islamic State):
• Chapter 6: Foundations...
Chapter 7 (Badr & Uhud):
• Chapter 7: Badr & Uhud...
Chapter 8 (His Other Wives):
• Chapter 8: His Other W...
Chapter 9 (His Family (Ahlul Bayt)
• Chapter 9: His Family ...
Chapter 10 (His Character)
• Chapter 10: His Charac...
Chapter 11 (Battle of Ahzab)
• Chapter 11: Battle of ...
Chapter 12 (Years of Relative Peace)
• Chapter 12: Years of R...
Chapter 13 (Hudaibiyyah & Beyond)
• Chapter 13: Hudaibiyya...
Things You'll Learn In This Episode of Our Prophet:
00:00 - Why the Shia are critical of Anas ibn Malik
01:11 - Imam Ali's dua on Anas ibn Malik and its result
02:21 - Anas's status as a hadith narrator, as mentioned by Imam Sadiq
02:56 - Hadith al-Tayr and Anas's jealousy towards Imam Ali
Join us in creating the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s). Dedicate episodes in the memory of your loved ones by visiting thaqlain.org/ourprophet.
Visit app.thaqlain.org and download the first "Knowledge App" from the School of Ahlulbayt.
#ProphetMuhammad #PropheticBiography #OurProphet
=============================================
► HELP US REACH 100K SUBSCRIBERS:
/ @thaqlain
► JOIN US AS KZbin MEMBER:
/ @thaqlain
► BECOME OUR PATRON:
thaqlain.org/support
► CONNECT ON WHATSAPP:
wa.link/hfcf0g
► FOLLOW US:
Facebook: / thaqlain
Instagram: / thaqlainmedia

[@Thaqlain]

Are you dependent on KZbin and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Subhanallah Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad Labbaik ya Ali a s Ya Allah on the day of judgement please mark our foreheads with the seal of love towards our prophet sawws and his righteous successor and his pious progeny a.s. In shaa Allah aameen

[@hasanurus]

Jazakallah khairan. May Allah bless you for your efforts 🥰

[@fuadyunus2433]

As the lecturer mentioned: If he became "old & also forgot," then how could his narrations & reports of traditions be accepted as AUTHENTIC (?)

[@fromdarkness2lght587]

By who ?

[@tufailmir6372]

اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد وعجل فرجهم ياكريم نسألكم الدعاء

[@BlkArabian]

4:36 was such a wholesome commentary from the Sheikh ❤😊

[@dark1hand2]

3:08 the story that that speaker has mention it was Aisha who kept refusing Amir Al Mumineen from entering . According to (Shia narrations).

[@Thaqlain]

That is another incident. But yes, Ayesha had similar animosity.

[@dark1hand2]

@@Thaqlain Can you please give reference to that other incident thank you.

[@Thaqlain]

It happened at the time of the Prophet's demise when the Prophet requested to see his brother. We have covered it in #HisLastWords of the Holy Prophet.

[@dark1hand2]

@@Thaqlain Thank you for clarification sorry for my misunderstanding.

[@fatinsabrina8]

🫶🏾🌹🔥🔥

[@dhruvsangari2370]

I completely believe that Anas was jealous of Hzt Ali but this hadith about Anas having the guts to prevent the Imam from entering his own home and the Imam leaving without a word despite his aa’la akhlaq Mashallah, is clearly either incomplete or a mixture of two different rivayaat… Allahu aalim

[@Thaqlain]

It was Holy Prophet's home. Imam Ali desired to meet him at his place.

[@baraslim]

Who is Imraatun?

[@dark1hand2]

It can only be Aisha because she is the one along with Abu huraira and Anas ibn Malik's who report a lot of hadith in the Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jamaah school of thought (Sunni Islam)

[@baraslim]

@@dark1hand2 Ok Thanks

[@gamerworld5863]

​@@dark1hand2 Abdullah Ibn Abbas also narrated alot of hadiths along with Jabir and Abu Said Al Khudri

[@dark1hand2]

​@@gamerworld5863 The question was who is imraatun ? I was answering who the scholar in the video above at 2:00 is referring too regarding imraatun when the scholar in the video says according Imam Sadiq three would fabricate lies against the prophet Muhammad (peace and blessing be upon him and his family) 1.Abu huraira 2. Anas ibn Malik's 3. Imraatun( Aisha) because she is only women that has reported a lot of hadith along side the other two.

[@AnasMir-uj9ym]

Rawaafidh creating their own stories

[@Thaqlain]

If that's the case then Rawafidh should be allowed to say things mentioned in Sunni are their own stories and then Christians should be allowed to say that things mentioned in Quran is 'own stories'?

[@AnasMir-uj9ym]

@@Thaqlain oh idiot rafzi,now u will tell me about the status of Hazrat Anas bin Malik? Prophet made a dua for his dunya and akhirah and he used to say Prophet's every dua for me got accepted now I'm waiting for that dua to be accepted which Prophet made for my akhirah.When ibn ziyad,the cursed tried to disrespect Husain ibn Ali(AS),it was Anas bin Malik who said"Husain resembled the Prophet the most". Also it was Anas who used to say"None resembled the Prophet more than Hasan".And that Hadith e tuayar of Hazrat Ali,it was Anas who narrated this,if he wouldn't have narrated that,how could u fools have known about this fazeelat of Imam Ali. U people are simply Shame for Muslim Ummah, trying ur best to disrespect noble companions.

[@gamerworld5863]

Was Abdullah Ibn Abbas also a fabricator?

[@Thaqlain]

We have never mentioned so :)

[@simbillamachiyya]

So, this incidents can change the history? قال امام علي ابن ابي طالب رضي الله عنه من قال انا خير من ابي بكر و عمر فعليه جلدة مفترية )(مصدر ابن عساكر)

[@Thaqlain]

So suddenly one supposed narration by a historian takes precedence on all other narrations by the Prophet and Imam Ali?

[@simbillamachiyya]

@@Thaqlain Where he quoted the saying of Ali ra? He invented this saying? What's his purpose of inventing this saying? More over did Ali ra wage war against the three Khulafaa? Why he waged war against Muawiyya Ibni Abu Sufiyyani, and ramain silent to wage war against Abubakar ra Umar ra Uthmani ra? Where he declared openly about his status to require his Post?

[@Thaqlain]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqmnY2CXaNudq5Ifeature=shared This should answer most of your concerns.

[@ibnnader8373]

Your claim that anas ibn malik tried to close the door to prevent ali from entering is a lie. Let’s see the actual narration: al-Suddi narrates from Anas b. Malik: Birds were given as gifts to the Messenger of Allah. So, he distributed them and left a bird. Then he said, “O Allah, bring to me the most beloved to You of Your creation to eat with me from this bird. So, ‘Ali b. Abi Talib came and entered and ate with him from that bird. Tarikh madinah dimashq, vol 42 page 254 Where did anas ibn malik tried to prevent ali to enter? You just made that up. And if anas ibn malik hated ali ibn abi talib, why did he even narrate this hadith? And you mentioned in ur video that jafar as sadiq said that 3 people used to lie about the Prophet ﷺ; abu huraira, anas ibn malik and a woman. If that is the case, why are u guys accepting this hadith, narrated by a liar? And about the hadith that ali ibn abi talib alaih salam made dua against anas ibn malik because of not testifying the hadith of ghadeer, lets examine that: Amirah ibn Sa’d reports: I clearly remember ‘Ali standing on the pulpit and asking the Companions of Rasulullah sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallam on oath. Among them were Abu Sa’id, Abu Hurairah, and Anas ibn Malik who were sitting around the pulpit while ‘Ali was on the pulpit. Around the pulpit were twelve men, among them were the above individuals. ‘Ali announced, “I ask you in the name of Allah, did you hear Rasulullah sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallam saying, ‘Whoever’s friend I am, ‘Ali is his friend?’” All of them stood up and replied positively on oath besides one man who kept on sitting. ‘Ali asked him, “What prevented you from standing?” He replied, “O Amir al Mu’minin, I have grown old and I forgot.” ‘Ali supplicated, “O Allah, if he is lying, afflict him with a befitting trial.” The narrator says: He did not pass away until we saw a white mark between his eyes (on his forehead), which the turban could not conceal. Hilyat al Auliya, vol. 5 pg. 26, 27] First of all the hadith doesnt even mention the name of the one who sat. And second of all the hadith is weak because of Amirah ibn Sa’d. He is majhul (unkown). Yahya ibn qattan said about him “He was not relied upon.” [Mizan al I’tidal, vol. 5 pg. 358]. Second narration: Simak ibn ‘Abid ibn al Walid al ‘Absi narrated to us saying: I entered the presence of ‘Abdur Rahman ibn Abi Layla who narrated to me that he saw ‘Ali in al Rahbah saying, “I ask in the name of Allah a person who heard Rasulullah sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallam and saw him on the Day of Ghadir Khum to stand up; only one who saw him should stand.” Twelve men stood up and testified, “We certainly saw him and heard him saying after taking his (‘Ali) hand, ‘O Allah, befriend the one who befriend him, show animosity to the one who hates him, assist the one who assists him, and forsake the one who forsakes him.’” Three men did not stand up. He cursed them and his curse afflicted them. [Musnad Ahmed, vol. 2 pg. 270, 271, Hadith: 964] The report doesnt say anything about anas ibn malik. The hadith is also weak, because of Walid ibn ‘Uqbah and Simak ibn ‘Ubaid being majhul (unkown) [Mizan al I’tidal, vol. 7 pg. 135]. There is also a third narration, the narration of ibn qutayba. But Ibn Qutaybah himself states that this story is baseless and has no credibility whatsoever. Ibn Qutaybah only related the incident to point out that it was a forgery. [Kitab al Ma’arif, pg. 194-195] In fact there is a narration in mujam as saghir of at-tabarani that Sayyidina Anas ibn Malik radiyallahu ‘anhu was one of those who stood up confirming that Rasulullah sallallahu ‘alayhi wasallam did, in fact, say, “Whomsoever considers me his Mawla; ‘Ali is his Mawla.” [Al Mu’jam al Saghir, vol. 1 pg. 119, Hadith: 175] Keep lying bro.

[@Thaqlain]

JazakAllah for sharing. But not every merit of Ahlulbayt or demerit of those who opposed Ahlulbayt is mentioned in Sunni books. Many times, even Sunni narrators like Imam Nasai faced persecution for narrating the merits of Ahlulbayt. The narrations mentioned by Sayed are present in the books of the School of Ahlulbayt by the Ahlulbayt 🙂

[@ibnnader8373]

@@Thaqlain he clearly said in the video that these ahadith are mentioned in sunni books. At 4:00 he said this hadith, i.e hadith of tayr where anas ibn malik is preventing ali from entering is saheeh in sunni books. But if you look at sunni books it doesnt mention at all that anas ibn malik prevented ali from entering. It just mentions the prophet peace be upon him made dua and then ali entered. No mention of preventing ali at all. So he is clearly lying.

[@Thaqlain]

lib.eshia.ir/70601/5/69 Al-Maghazali is a Sunni historian/muhaddith who has shared this narration in his book. This should answer your concern :) The last thing a scholar from the School of Ahlulbayt will want is to lie to prove a merit of Ahlulbayt or to share our concern about a particular companion. As for Anas, he even cited narrations that belittle the Prophet (s). One of them is shared here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJ_doWp_qcynqqs

[@ibnnader8373]

@@Thaqlain just because a sunni historian has a particular narration or hadith in his book, it doesnt mean it is authentic. Have you looked at the isnad of the narration? Is it saheeh?

[@Thaqlain]

The same narration is found within the School of Ahlulbayt. Along with other narrations mentioned by Sayed. So it overall makes the character of Anas ibn Malik controversial. And there was no other aim of this episode.

[@mohomar786]

what a load of lies

[@Thaqlain]

Load of information new for you 🙂

[@Loyalsurly]

yeah bro go ahead and take from the enemies of the ahlulbayt instead of taking from them. Prophet left us the book of allah and his family to hold onto to never go astray.

[@mk-fv5ut]

Hate hate hate

[@Thaqlain]

So exposing a fabricator is hate?