4everfreebrony - Chant of Immortality (ft. Chi-Chi)

MERCH: 4everfreebrony...
--------------------------------
LINKS TO THE CHANT ALBUM:
Bandcamp: 4everfreebrony...
iTunes: / the-dreamers-door
Amazon: www.amazon.com...
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Google Play: play.google.co...
Also, check out my Patreon! / 4everfreebrony
--------------------------------
Follow me on Twitter now! / 4everfreebrony
Sheet Music created by Taleshic Matera!
• Chant of Immortality -...
--------------------------------
Amazing PMV! • [PMV] Chant of Immorta...
--------------------------------
#9 Community-voted pony song of 2013's Top 25! • Top 25 Pony Songs of 2...
#1 Community-voted pony song of November 2013! • Top 10 Pony Songs of N...
--------------------------------
Physical CD copies of "Small Horses and Other Stuff" are now available at Bandcamp!
Links to digital album:
Bandcamp: garrisonulrich...
Google Play: play.google.co...
iTunes: itunes.apple.c...
Xbox Music: music.xbox.com/...
Amazon: www.amazon.com/...
cdBaby: www.cdbaby.com/...
--------------------------------
Thanks to the Golden Muffin voting for voting this as the #1 fan created song of 2013!
--------------------------------
I'm well aware that becoming an alicorn does not make you immortal. It has hardly anything to do with it, really. I was pointing more toward the direction of Twilight gaining responsibility as ruler after Celestia. Without immortality, her time as ruler would be utterly short. I always imagined she would rule at a certain point, so she must become immortal at some point.
And who says she wouldn't be immortal after becoming an alicorn? It's highly possible, anyway. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but please don't go saying I'm wrong about my own lyrics. No hard feelings to anyone.
--------------------------------
Spotlight on EQD! www.equestriada...
--------------------------------
Here's something I don't think you see too often in the fandom. After a small chat with Chi-Chi, we decided to do a song, and we're both very satisfied with how it turned out. Hope you enjoy it!
Also, I can't thank RainSnowHail enough for mixing this song! Thank you SO MUCH, dude! You rock!
Oh, and you guys should totally subscribe to both of them. They're awesome.
Chi-Chi: / chisanaai
RainSnowHail: / rainsnowhail
--------------------------------
The EPIC artwork was done by DragonwolfRooke!
Link to art: dragonwolfrooke...
--------------------------------
Chords
Chorus:
F, G, Am, Em, F, F, G, Am, C, Em, F x2
Verse: F, G, Am, Em, F x2
F, G, G, Am, G
F, G, Am, Em, F
After 2nd and 3rd Chorus:
Am, Em, F
Lyrics:
(chorus)
Remembrance, part of every life
Num'rous regrets, the art of passing time
Not one forgets, spent nights of chasing days
Eternal rest, to witness being erased
To witness being erased
(v1)
It is seldom seen in this world of now
It is welcome, universe and out
It is seen, only from eyes of thine
Is it free? 'Tis only by invite
(repeat chorus)
Remembrance, part of every life
Num'rous regrets, the art of passing time
Not one forgets, spent nights of chasing days
Eternal rest, to witness being erased
To witness being erased
(v2)
It is ponderous, willing to know my fate
In its longest lingering while to wait
I can see, memory taken tolls
I'm not ready, ready to let them go
(repeat chorus)
Remembrance, part of every life
Num'rous regrets, the art of passing time
No one forgets, spent nights of chasing days
Eternal rest, to witness being erased
(repeat chorus)

[@4everfreebrony]

So, not like I care that much, but HA!! TOTALLY CALLED IT!!! IMMORTAL TWILIGHT IS CANON, HER FRIENDS ALL DIE, AND SAD TWILIGHT IS SAD, HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!! Have a nice day. ^^

[@Greeneflower]

hell yeah

[@yutahkotomi5156]

As someone in Camp Immortal Twilight, I love this becoming so true.

[@cephalopuppy8684]

i actually wondered about this back when blueblood was introduced. if the royals have family but are canonically ancient are the people they love dying one by one?

[@yutahkotomi5156]

@@cephalopuppy8684 Yes. That's the price of being immortal while others are not.

[@astralaegis]

Sadly you are correct. I'm happy you are, but it's still saddening to think about.

[@plazmikpond]

This song was ahead of its time... Really ahead of its time.

[@dynamicwarfare]

Indeed, it really was.

[@beachboysswiftie]

It predicted the finale. Twilight is gonna outlive her friends

[@farresalt4381]

@@beachboysswiftie Who said that!) **Maniacally pulls out a gun.** Megan said that Twilight won't outlive her friends - Twilight won't outlive her friends. Mua ha ha ha ha... - (c) one of my friends.. and I agree with him. ;-)

[@cobaltcomet9883]

@@farresalt4381 We all saw how obviously that was contradicted in the finale, however. As much as I would have liked to see them all grow old together and Twilight not to have outlived her friends (what a disheartening thought for her to have to go through), you would have to truly ignore the end of the finale to still be able to hold onto that notion. The staff could not have made it any more obvious apart from outright saying it. Megan's comment came long before the season finale was written, long before it was even a mere notion. But like everything, change is a constant.

[@farresalt4381]

@@cobaltcomet9883 well... Sure, finale is a thing. But! That's why headcanons is such a nice thing. And I still have one more for that finale, which can make Megan's words possible. It even combines (more or less) all the episodes of the series! And even some comics, books, and I found a way to play into most of the fandom material as well. So... Yeah. Even if finale is a thing, there's still a countless amount of universes, where everyone is happy. Specifically, about the amount of most of the people who liked/watched the finale of the series.

[@mattiaberti9160]

I see everyone is back here after the finale.

[@Rainbow__cookie]

yes but i did not watch it :p

[@SoulariceJackson]

it hurts; but im happy. why is that? life is strange. to witness being erased.

[@distancerunner6211]

Yep

[@meggamiauw4266]

Whyayayayyayayayata

[@warriorcatsmlp5447]

dangit, your right

[@Ec360Gaming]

Years after the show ended (and even longer since I left the community) I still find myself drawn back to this song every once in a while. Theres something hauntingly beautiful about it that resonates with me in a way that I don't think any other song does. I probably haven't seen an episode in 5 years, but this has stuck with me.

[@dominicbrothers]

it is for a lot of people. 4everfreebrony just hits different. his songwriting is amazing. I come back here regularly, after being out of the fandom likely as long as yourself.

[@MyNamesNotKim]

"It is ponderous, willing to know my fate. In its longest lingering while to wait. I can see, memory taken tolls.I'm not ready, ready to let them go" This gets me every time right in the feels Q_Q. In my head when I listen to this song I just imagine that Twilight is heartbroken after the last of her friends has passed away. Twilight is looking for a way to remove the pain she is feeling from this. She realizes that the only way to get rid of the pain that is agonizing her is to forget her memories with her friends since its her memories that are causing her this pain. Twilight refuses to forget her friends since life without these memories she holds dear would be a fate far worse. Best to have known friendship and lost then to never have friends at all.

[@artfulcord]

Found this comment at the exact moment the part played.

[@joshuadavenport-herbst2036]

Artfulcord same

[@whitestarHokie]

I'm starting to think this comment is blessed or something, cause I did the exact same thing.

[@CutTheVioletWire]

@@artfulcord same

[@comicallycorrect4042]

The set of crystal-y sounding chimes during the last set of choruses is the guaranteed point where, every single time I listen to this, I will at least tear up a bit and start feeling the chest pains of deeply rooted sympathetic sorrow.

[@phoenixfeather8511]

This really hits different when you're returning from years of being inactive in the fandom. It's one of those songs that makes my throat get all tight and painful, even when I dont actually cry. I made my first true friend through this show, and now we dont really talk anymore. I'm not ready to let her go, I'm not ready to leave that part of me behind. The world keeps spinning, though, even if I'm not ready for it to. Time will march on, with or without me. I must carry on with the memories of good times.

[@snowfox4704]

Time does not wait. It is both a Gift…and a Curse. I hope you are doing well.

[@Lex-nq3zx]

They say that a man who has everything must be the happiest in the world. But if said man had everything, what would be left for him to gain?

[@4everfreebrony]

I think that it's not in the gaining that we find true happiness, but in the giving. To the man who has everything, including all the time in the world, wouldn't there be infinite happiness in giving to others, in enriching their lives?

[@Lex-nq3zx]

4everfreebrony -OH GOD I WAS SPOTTED. *Dives into ocean*

[@enochholmes6140]

4everfreebrony That is really quite astute of you to note. However, with humanitarianism (correct me if that is not it) and it's... expansion?... growth? I lack the word... cannot misanthropy also root itself deeper in the same aspect?

[@ZizzyDizzyMC]

That means a lot 4everfreebrony.

[@grayblackhelm6468]

4everfreebrony But If one spends his entire life collecting- how can one know the joy of giving it back?

[@pcdeltalink036]

Given that what we see of how Twilight looks in the final episode compared to her friends this beautiful yet sad song is more fitting than ever.

[@Hawkbreath36]

I this shared to my non-brony friend on Facebook yesterday and he replied with this: "Wow that is just spectacular, very beautiful, and they are just spot on with each other" I talked to him today and said it was so amazing that he cried. He asked me if this song was really in Friendship is Magic. When I told him it was fan made his mind flew out in six directions.

[@TheAdamUlrich]

Who did he mean when he said "they are spot on with each other?" You do know that other than Chi-Chi's female voice, that is 4everfreebrony singing all the male vocal parts, one at a time, right? From Bass to High and Low Tenor and Falsetto, that is just one singer.... :)

[@4everfreebrony]

He actually meant that we have voices that blend well, as well as being precise with timing. I have four parts, whereas Chi-Chi has two, during the chorus.

[@Hawkbreath36]

What he said

[@62shredderdude]

:)

[@Doing_It_Again]

I love how I can hear every individual voice singing in harmony. Each individual is dead (to me). I never knew them, but I know they were great ponies and now they are gone - each subject to the same undeserved tragedy of inevitable death. It sent shivers down my spine hearing the little girl sing about the awareness of her own mortality before joining the choir as one of the individuals. And the image fits so well with the song. It sounds like they are singing "remember us" to Twilight. She holds the world in her hooves in the form of her memories amongst the dark void behind her because she and her memories are the only things that survive the consuming void of death. That's why the memories are in the form of a globe (to me). The remembrance she holds so heavily is the world to these ponies because the memories are the only thing that remains of their individuality after they are gone. After long enough, everything that made each of these ponies special / distinct will be gone, which is why the individuality in each of their voices give me a heavier sense of loss.

[@kissmysoup]

Well said. I couldn't agree more to this.

[@DaedricPony]

For those who would argue that immortality is a curse, I would ask you this: Is experiencing the death of a loved one any less painful for mortals? Does your own approaching death bring you comfort? We all suffer from grief. The question is whether or not you enjoy your existence regardless.

[@4everfreebrony]

For some, knowing that you will die some day actually is comforting. I guess it really depends on what you believe in.

[@MrAsmodeusH]

I find death comforting. Its guaranteed that one day I will die and that really calms me. Because life is full of suffering and death will be my release. I am waiting for that emptiness. But before that, I must fill myself with beauty, because while life is horrid it has another side. Thats why I am listening to this, thank you for making everything easier to withstand.

[@HaniiPuppy]

I find death, the cessation of existence, the destruction of all that I am and my capacity to simply be, on any level, a terrifying thought. And the idea that anyone would find comfort in that - even see it as some kind of ultimate goal, rather than something to be avoided like the plague (excuse the pun), is almost as horrific.

[@MrAsmodeusH]

HaniiPuppy Death is a part of life and it has been turned into this big mystery in the western world. Its natural and it shouldnt be feared and hidden. Death is what gives life meaning, that is why every moment is so beautiful. Its so fragile.

[@HaniiPuppy]

Asmodeus H But you could use the same argument to say that evil dictators, serial murderers, rapists, etc. are good things to.

[@wingsonthebus]

rip to all our headcanons about how this wasn’t actually gonna happen

[@lohdhshs]

It was so hard to see how they had all aged so much except her.

[@Wendek.]

What's weird is that a member of the MLP team also said that "Twilight won't outlive her friends" recently, yet it seems the Finale showed exactly that.

[@Emanon389]

@@Wendek. Maybe she's going to step down early. Not sure, but that may be possible.

[@belmontzar]

@@Emanon389 or there is a darker variety. Where she dies with them.

[@Rose_Harmonic]

@@Wendek. They could have simply been wrong, maybe deliberately. Telling an audience, 'hey, those ones will die and that one will live on alone' is very off-color for the storytellers and the corporation. Regardless, whoever's interpretation of future fictional events counts as canon doesn't matter as much as how we choose to imagine them.

[@Newage416]

I see Twilight a few hundred years into the future, and she is visiting the graves of her friends. As the song progresses, I see Twilight flash back to the day before each of the Mane 6 died. Pinkie would have a heart attack, Fluttershy would die in her sleep, Rainbow would be involved in an accident, Rarity's would be work related, and Applejack would die mysteriously while staying in Twilight's castle. But that's just me

[@ponyempiresunite9702]

But the real mystery is who dunnit!

[@daelen.cclark]

I doubt they’d die like that, but I can see something similar on Twilights part.

[@sunstreaker913]

@@daelen.cclark well, eating too much sweets can make plague build up on your heart and arteries near the heart will eventually lead to a heart attack, and flying or driving too fast can eventually cause you to crash which some crashes are fatal, and some people die in their sleep either because of poisoning or a sudden stroke, and before the safety rules and stuff were set in, companies made their workers die on the job, like someone got grinded up in a gear while trying to fix the gear and the triangle waist factory fire where hundreds of women who worked there died of smoke inhalation, etc. So, it's a high possibility that Pinkie Died of a heart attack because she ate unhealthy foods, Rarity could have gotten hit in the head with a 2nd sewing machine that was on a high shelf that broke and cause the 2nd sewing machine to fall and hit her head and caused to have a broken skull that eventually led to her death, and Applejack could have died of Cyanide poisoning since apple seeds contain cyanide, Rainbow dash could have flown then experienced a sudden wing fracture that could have caused her to lose control which she flew and crashed into a mountain and died, and Fluttershy could have died of a sudden stroke.

[@ClearSummerSkies]

Never been a brony, but man does this song slap. Still coming back to it after discovering it years ago.

[@LWolf12]

Only one word can really describe this song. Powerful.

[@nicke9012]

Spyro:indeed.

[@jussysheart]

“See you on the other side.” “Oh twilight, no. There is no other side. This is it.”

[@Joaftheloaf]

I feel terrible for not listening to this song more in depth sooner, but let me tell you, never EVER has a brony song put tears in my eye. This song broke that. Thank you for making such an amazing song ;)

[@MRRusskij]

Not even Lullaby for a Princess?

[@TheMithridates]

Mr.Russkij Lullaby does not compare and there are several other, sadder versions of it or the event itself. It is a song about longing, want and shame. This, this is utter loss, remembrance and depending on view... hope. I fear the loss this song describes that may be coming but the important thing is to cherish and remember. No matter what happens, hope and remembrance.

[@ganondorfchampin]

Mr.Russkij Lullaby for a Princess was never that sad. A little said, yes, but it was just a really good song that got extremely popular. The only songs from the fandom which I think might be sadder than this one are "Blank Pages", which is about the loss of memory, and "Wish List", which is about self loathing.

[@MRRusskij]

ganondorfchampin I guess it depends on personal view. This song comes off as bittersweet to me rather then sad. Twilight has been granted the greatest gift her teacher could give her alongside her complete trust, and yet, it could mean Twilight might lose something very dear to her. And she simply contemplates all of this.

[@ganondorfchampin]

Mr.Russkij "Eternal rest, to witness being erased" The song is bittersweet, but the sad parts are very hard hitting, and the focus is clearly on the downer parts. Lullaby for a Princess isn't as hard hitting, first we know Luna is going to return eventually, and second, the theme has been done to death, for example "Home" by Jeff Burgess. Admittedly immortality has also been done to death, both for Celestia and Twilight (though I prefer Celestia death songs), but here the way it's delivered is particularly punchy IMO.

[@SirBevian]

Still listening to this masterpiece (this and the other chants). Depending on my mood, it can really hit hard.

[@justsomeponywithamustache8731]

Ever since this Twilicorn controversy started, no one ever seemed concerned that Cadance might lose Shining Armor forever. "True love" my Flank.

[@wsuppdoublesupp5553]

I have come again!!! After 4 years of my last comment, and 8 years at all!! I'm still living!! I have new family new wife, and probably new life!!! Thank you. This song is still in my heart❤

[@camthefemalefont9801]

"I can see, memory taken tolls. I'm not ready, ready to let them go." AAAAAAAAHHHHHHH WHY MUST YOU HIT ME RIGHT WHERE IT HURTS?? Memories are sometimes the worst gift mankind was given, and sometimes the best. My favorite memories are also the ones that make me the saddest. She was my best friend. Now, does she even remember me? I remember her. I would give almost anything to see her again. Maybe she's only a state away, but it feels like the entire universe stretches between us. Oh Hazel... will I ever see you again? I need to tell you something. Please don't make me leave it unsaid...

[@4everfreebrony]

Wow! That's an intense discussion on immortality! XD Alright, I think it's time I put my words in on the matter. So, Megan McCarthy - a writer for MLP:FiM - pointed out that Twilight will not outlive her friends, correct? If so, the way she worded it still leaves Twilight's fate open to several directions. On one side, she could be implying that Twilight is, simply put, not immortal. And being an Alicorn, she would only have the aspects of the three pony races, as opposed to an extended period of life. On a different side, she could be implying that - downer incoming - Twilight dies. That is to say, if she were to become immortal, she would be killed before she had a chance to live longer than her friends. She would die before her friends died. Putting death aside, remember that there's also a chance that Twilight could become the ruler one day, being put in charge after Celestia's rule. It wouldn't make any sense for her to not live a long time if she were to claim that position. Besides, maybe Megan will change her mind. :\ Anyway, I'm amazed to see all the feedback this song has received! And 50,000 views!?!? WHAT!?!?!? You guys are all awesome. Thank you for your support! p.s. - You guys are really going to like my next post. ;)

[@DMC4EVERUCCI]

We love you 4ever

[@thatguydownthestreat]

Of course, you could also interpret that since Friendship is a magic shared equally between others,that they become immortal, especially if you take into the account the usage and inherent connection of the elements of harmony. however over the top it may seam, it as far as I am aware, it hasn't been dis-proven :P

[@MrMasterSmasher]

Personally, I've never been a fan of the idea of Twilght being immortal, so I was relieved when Megan said she wasn't. This is because the idea of being immortal, to me, is absolutely terrifying. Seeing everyone and everything you hold dear break down and die around you, over and over, while you never change, never able to grow old with those you love... Such a fate is something that scares me almost more than anything, including death. With this in mind, the thought of such being the fate of a character I hold dear is something I most certainly am not a fan of. That having been said, this is still a GREAT song about death and loss in general, and it brings a tear to my eye. Great work on it, guy!

[@4everfreebrony]

Thank you for your opinion and the compliment! Yeah, I'm honestly a big fan of sad stories, so I wouldn't really mind watching her witness everything pass as she lives on. However, to live it is a different story, and I would not be in favor of it happening to anyone. Truly, unless one is completely heartless, it is a curse. Man, I swear, I must be really into the depressing side of the music scene, lol.

[@thatguydownthestreat]

4everfreebrony Guys, Immortality is not a curse to ALL I think it would be a blessing, while yes, i would feel bad about having to see my friends and loved ones die, I am sure I would EVENTUALLY get over it, and once I did, I would relish the chance to watch the world and universe unfold around me, see the progress society makes, guide and tempt said society into new and grander directions. Immortality is not a a curse. I do not know a word for it, but its in between, because it can be bad Or good. Also Celestia and Luna did it, and they seam fine

[@angelsister7635]

The moment that I saw Twilight had become an alicorn I told my friend that she would have to watch her friends and family die. Then I watched the finale episode and sat there and died on the inside as I realized she probably knew that too now and all she has left is Spike and the other princesses.

[@Princess_Luna2004]

Как же я обожаю старые брони-песни 2011-2015 годов. Это было время рассвета брони фендома. Это были наши лучшие времена

[@ForkGenesis]

Как один мудрый чел сказал: "Вы пилот своего времени". Никто не объявлял конец лучшим временам - значит, они и сегодня) Вон у Ponies at Dawn в субботу показ альбома был, 3000 пони собралось)

[@amoniousbt1110]

i cried.... thinking about twilight coming to terms with the fact that she will have to watch her friends die...and i cried thinking about the fact i will never see their world .. and im going to die and then i will be forgotten in time..and oh god now i'm crying again :'c

[@holtengibson8534]

send me the place of your tome stone it you have one

[@holtengibson8534]

send me the place of your tome stone if you have one

[@allenabbot4110]

what kinda shi

[@ponyempiresunite9702]

Oh well. That one's going to hell anyways. Life lesson- DON'T PUSH!

[@nathangamble125]

1. Some people turned MLP into a religion called Celestianism. It teaches that we go to Equestria after we die. Celestianism isn't even a joke (or at least isn't always a joke - there are some trolls, as there always are with weird cults and new religious movements), it's something some of them legitimately believe in. 2. Why would you want to see their world? It's got nice people/ponies, but Equestria is genuinely terrifying. It seems to get invaded at least once a year, plants and wild animals are constantly trying to kill you, and there's a suspiciously high number of orphanages.

[@thecensoredcrusader]

Hey, remember when Faust said that Twilight will grow old with all of her friends... haha funny. You have predicted the ending of the show, gg

[@captainobvious6779]

TheChinkCrusader We’ve been bamboozled boys!

[@FlameSwordedLink]

KZbin is broken. I can't like the song more than once.

[@Arthus850]

Could you ever? or are you joking?

[@jcoonie2]

Can you do that? Can you like a song twice?

[@FlameSwordedLink]

...Well, aside from making a glitch happen, then no. You cannot like a song twice. Sadly, might I add.

[@BioniclesaurKing4t2]

FlameSwordedLink Solution: Like it once in each of multiple accounts.

[@FlameSwordedLink]

But then you can`t like it an infinite amount of times!

[@mrx4022]

"I'm not ready to let them go." That hit me

[@elierickson298]

Anyone here after The Last Problem?

[@HauntedLotus777]

Poor twilight, she had to watch all her freinds slowly fade away from her life... everyone she knew will have passed and all she has is her memory's that are slowly fading away over the years... she will wait eternally for the relief of a death that will never pass... she will be stuck with this curse... everything she knew will fade and eventually it will only be her trying to remember their name's... poor twilight :(

[@nakysha6660]

Fun fact: my vocal jazz group did a cover of this for out band concert. One of my favourite songs

[@4everfreebrony]

Send a link if someone video'd it!

[@williamfreeman2025]

You recorded it, right?

[@tashazimmerman779]

Fun fact: I was in this Group 😂😂

[@TripleTapHK]

Send video or it's fake news lol

[@totallycarbon2106]

The ideal for me would not be immortality, rather it would be the option of indefinite youth. The ideal would be to stay young and fit for as long as you choose, and then once you have decided you have lived long enough and are fulfilled with your life, be it in 100, 1000 or 1 million years, you can then opt out of immortality and then age again like normal and die gracefully. This is one step above immortality as it removes the potential downside of being to live forever.

[@fleetwingpone966]

that's awesome

[@pyre1738]

@@fleetwingpone966 Let's make it 20% cooler

[@fleetwingpone966]

@@pyre1738 lol

[@pyre1738]

@@fleetwingpone966 kek

[@fleetwingpone966]

@@pyre1738 hhhhhhhhhh

[@ponivi]

Huh, it’s nearing a million views, you deserve it man

[@Raspopopo]

The finale makes this sadder.

[@theortheo2401]

I couldn't sleep, now I won't sleep. This song is too powerful and convey a huge message. Damn.

[@ispecs]

This hits different after watching the show from the very start to the very end...

[@ChichiAi]

Amg! its finally out :DDDD and it is AWESOME

[@reubensanimatingchannel]

I know

[@reubensanimatingchannel]

Ir’s cool 👍

[@175myles]

Goosebumps the size of mountains over here.

[@robloxrules44]

Be careful, RL stein will turn it into a book if you say that word

[@captainobvious6779]

Knowing this is canon after the finale is rough. With that being said, all hail Empress Twilight!

[@Kurorahk]

Years and years later, this song still makes me tear up. Probably more now that the show is over. A mark of an excellent song is when it can make you feel so emotional.

[@potatospy3306]

It seems more disturbing to me because instead of "rememberance", I hear "Remember us..."

[@ilovecats790]

Potato Spy I thought it was "remember us" ever since I first heard the song. I didn't notice it wasn't until you pointed it out.

[@grayblackhelm6468]

It seems intentional, as well. Brings the whole price up.

[@Firebolt193]

So true after the finale....

[@cinivin]

Same

[@brantcobb]

I've listened to, and have sung, this song so many times now. This song brings a tear to my eye, but not because of poor Twilight in particular. When I hear this song I don't think of Twilight, honestly, my thoughts go to the Bronies themselves. I'm reminded that, regardless of how great we are now, we will not last forever. Both the show and the fandom will begin to die away. Of course, the spark will remain, and the art will be just as fantastic, but I think of the friendships this community has brought me and how they to will be lost and eventually forgotten. I feel I may live to see the day Bronies outlive their own fandom. I'm sure you had your own intentions for writing this song, 4ever, but that's to story it speaks to me.

[@4everfreebrony]

Well, that's definitely a profound way of looking at it. I like your point of view. :)

[@Arthus850]

Even though you're not wrong. fandoms never truly die. They do have low points, almost to the point where people think they disappeared, but they will always be there. And even if they do go away, the impact it left on us will remain. I don't see myself abandoning friendship any time soon.

[@vonellisequintel7507]

I always saw this song as bitter sweet. The idea behind it. The memories are painful, but they bring such joy. I don’t think she ever forgot until the end of time where everything’s erased. She carries with her every though, until the end where she herself is watching everything pass.

[@migeruface]

After all these years I didn't know I wasn't subbed, and now that the show is over and I look back on the good moments, and the bad ones... all the conventions where ponies were everywhere in many forms. And most of all, hanging out with my friends and watching this show every week, who were there through all my moments, the good, the bad, and the inevitable. We will all carry on the torch of harmony in our hearts from here on out. Stay amazing everypony!

[@SteveyJ03]

Beautiful moving music exists aplenty, but songs like this are beyond rare. You can listen to new music for years and never come across a song that has the kind of cathartic effect that this one does. And what’s more incredible is that this album has numerous more songs that are all nearly (if not equally) as powerful as this one. I’ve never found any other artist who’s music can repeatedly bring tears to my eyes like yours Garrison. You’re an incredible musician to put it lightly.

[@PonyExMachina]

I will always kick myself for not discovering this song sooner. This is such a beautiful song and it brings me to tears of both Joy and Sadness. Thank you 4everfreebrony for creating such wonderful music

[@theortheo2401]

Welp, it's now confirmed. Hurts. This made me cry the frst time I listened to it. And today, Im crying again knowing this'll happen.

[@NovaFlare_griffgon]

*Notices Twi is holding the world in her hoof* SHE HAS ATTAINED ULTIMATE POWAH!!!!

[@SnowyDragoon]

There's all these people in deep conversation about immortality, then there's this guy. Freaking great

[@NovaFlare_griffgon]

Well there's always gotta be one person that spawns the stupid comments. I don't do it often but when I do, I try to be a complete dumbkoff about it. XD

[@Glowmoff]

This song just makes me remember how we list a good chunk of our musicians and content creators. It takes me back to when I actually watched the show and all my friends did too. Now they've all moved on to other counties and jobs. Makes me reminisce man.

[@michealtheevilhero2340]

Listening to this song literally made me cry rivers and didn't even realize it until it ended,It brought back so many memories it felt like my life was flashing before my very eyes,memories with friends i never got to say goodbye to.. memories of communities that helped me get through the hardest times of my life by far.. while I was late to the MLP community it really has a special place in my heart I will keep with me to the grave and whatever comes after it,Wish you all the best my brothers and sisters,Stay safe out there.

[@ShikamaruXT]

I now know, why The Immortal told Perry Rhodan, to be immortal is not everything in the universe. It's a curse. It's the greatest pain you can suffer.

[@ArtemisRedcrave]

*End of MLP G4.* Internally screaming all the time while listening to this song.

[@Ketirz]

Caught this randomly on related videos, and wasn't sure what to think at first; I'm not often into the more solemn stuff, but this grew on me quickly. The vocals are all really nice and the layers work together well, and the instrumentation is simple in a way that emphasizes the mood and vocals really well. I came in on a whim and found a really beautiful, moving performance. Good work!

[@l1nus0nl1neproductions9]

And here I was thinking that ”here on the moon” was 4everfreebrony No.1 hit on KZbin as well as Spotify but I stand corrected this song is aperently the number one hit on KZbin and now I understand why...it's mesmerizing

[@myriadmaestro572]

You know, for a song about immortality, this song sure says something poignant about death. The hard part isn't death itself, or even the knowledge that such a destination is inevitable. The hard part is letting go of it all.

[@kellyfrench]

It reminds me of the ending of The Good Place.

[@scratchy5640]

Even after all these years... Damn. This song didn't have to go so hard.😭

[@Acarcion]

You know, sometimes I go back to songs and wonder if they have the same impact on me that they did the first time I listened. Tears still glisten in my eyes listening to this, just like the first time. 4everfree your pieces always will have a tiny part of my heart, from times of joy to when it's time to see my friends pass to when I myself pass. Thank you.

[@werewolf873]

Personally, if the opportunity arose for immortality i would deny it. I don't want to live forever, i dont want to go mad with the thought of the years that have passed and the many many years yet to have passed.

[@neosaneo2]

i would only take it if it meant magic. and world-teleports.

[@werewolf873]

neosaneo2 "shrug" after eternity, even magic would lose it's appeal.

[@neosaneo2]

werewolf873 oh, come on! being able to breathe in space, going from planet to planet, looking at every nook and cranny; documenting aliens! THINK ABOUT IT! :D creating your own immortal familiar would be pretty cool too. :D

[@werewolf873]

neosaneo2 It's not worth it, all of those millennia, alone in the darkness of outer space. No friends, no family, just the endless years passing by. Its just not worth it.

[@neosaneo2]

werewolf873 there are other suns. :/

[@BpEmpire2001]

My god, this brings me nostalgic when i got into the fandom, those first weeks in it, where amazing, the music, the show, the fandom, the art, the people, forums, videos, etc, so many good memories

[@spottedstar1123]

first of all, this is one of my favorite brony songs ever!! second, joining the discussion of twilight being immortal or not, i point out something that someone said somewhere: just because she has the physical features of an alicorn, doesn't mean that she'll live forever. she *gained* those features that made her an alicorn, so technically her biological makeup hasn't changed. because of that, she isn't necessarily immortal.

[@gameboycolor47]

I hope she is. simply because megahn said she won't outlive her friends. so if she doesn't age well, there's only one way for her to not outlive her friends.

[@4everfreebrony]

There would be two ways, really. The second one is that they become immortal, as well.

[@gameboycolor47]

4everfreebrony good point. that or they go all 80's transformers on us

[@4everfreebrony]

Ha! Yup. :)

[@gameboycolor47]

4everfreebrony OH awesome song by the way. hits right in the heart.

[@silverblaze4445]

Duuuuuuuuuuuuude it's already been 10 years? I remember when this song dropped... Where has the time gone?

[@LORDOFDORKNESS42]

Holy crap, ten years old. AND still getting new versions, too. Congratulations.

[@jacobmiller2164]

I LOVE this guy's voice so much! His voice is...I wanna say smooth but I don't know if that's the word for it. His voice makes me happy but the song is so sad. Why are my emotions so confused!

[@mangofoalix]

I accidentally just refound a CD of the album this is on from his bandcamp. This brings back intense nostalgia of 2014 and before. God bless.

[@jimenafernandez5714]

10 años y todavía ronda en mi cabeza, que increíble. Y eso que yo ni siquiera era parte del fandom, pero si que hacia buen material los fans.

[@vulkris]

It really hurts my heart seeing these comments from years ago. I know that I’ll return to this song many years into the future, see this comment, and feel even more pain. We never realize how much time has passed until we think about all of the things that have changed in our lives. When this song released, I was 11 years old. I thought 16 was a speck on the horizon. But, I slowly became older and have forgotten how it felt to be young. Truly young. Innocent and carefree. This song about an immortal princess pony from the magical land of Equestria has made me think about my own past and brought that feeling of youth back to me.

[@SaveTheDragonsCorp]

So sad, yet such a stunning tribute to that immortality we all wish to gain. The curse that clouds humanity's reasoning. No one should be immortal; loneliness is a horror not even the most evil of beings deserve. Immortality with Twilight is only the more saddening...

[@mariadanilova5063]

Rare song about immortality that's not like "oh nnnno being immortal is soo horrible why am i immortalll", but just talks about others passing away and you being able to witness this. Really pleasant.

[@SlyphStorm]

Holy....I need to step my game up, this is so cool it's almost scary.

[@M3RKSYNDICATE]

SlyphStormARCHIVE Indeed.

[@snowdaybornagainbrony6832]

I'm never leaving this fandom, and I know that for every year that passes, this song will hurt more.

[@RedPineaplleStudio]

I just finished the show and came here, cause i think this to be one of the best and most beautiful songs to come from any fandom. And not only that, it's also remarkable how this song hit the mark on the same themes that would be touched upon by the series only years later! I really think this fandom is unlike any others, having the same liveliness and sentiments of love for its characters as something like Undertale comunity, but with years and whole eras of changes and development that make it feel *seasoned* and kinda bittersweet. I still haven't seen even a half of what this wonderful art cluster has to offer, with lots of cool stuff still being made. I see this new world come alive, and it's more open for me to explore than ever before!

[@ThePureSynergist]

Wow! I lost this song years ago and upon hearing those first beautiful vocal chords, I’m right back. What fortune.

[@wsuppdoublesupp5553]

I was here 4 years ago. I had all, family, wife, healthy. I was here. And now im here again, still here if be true. I will die, i lost family, my wife go out. Thats my died. This music will be foreve in my mind and heart. Thank you. Just crying.

[@wsuppdoublesupp5553]

I have come again!!! After 4 years of this comment, and 8 years at all!! I'm still living!! I have new family new wife, and probably new life!!! Thank you. This song is still in my heart❤

[@nerfpup3089]

This is so beautiful and depressing. Usually I'm not someone to obsess over a story idea so sad but I have to with this one

[@Eirreann]

Oh my goodness... this song... is beautiful... so beautiful...

[@RaidianaS]

Well... it’s been about 10 years, and I only remembered part of the tune to this song, but at least I finally found it.

[@SatyrToon]

You know the saddest part about all of it? She's immortal, meaning she will live infinite lifetimes, have an infinite number of new friends and she will eventually forget what any of them were like. After five years, I have trouble remembering my grandmother's face without a picture. Imagine how hard it would be after a thousand.

[@Kirithian_OW]

The fact that the show is ending makes this even sadder for me.

[@RainWasTaken]

I’m really happy I discovered this fandom.

[@4everfreebrony]

EEKUM BOKUM. Sorry, I just felt like putting that here.

[@ricoshield9954]

What??

[@euducationator]

Not sure if you'll see this, but I was wondering why you decided to put that here. I can see that it's a banjo kazooie reference, but I was wondering if there was a reason for it.

[@rydymsdeim4486]

This doesn't make any sense... But, as someone would say: What fun is there in making sense? It doesn't make any sense to write this, after 11 months, either... But... You know.

[@Zanator1]

2 years after you posted that comment the phrase became a widespread meme. You prophet, you.

[@tudoraragornofgreyscot8482]

@@Zanator1 Fucking psychics man, they’re getting bold.

[@SpiritzPlanet]

Yep--just as beautiful as I remember.

[@steelmatt6]

This is such a powerful song. I mean really beautifully powerful. Great job on everything! The music, voices, lyrics, all just amazing!

[@HallowNocturne]

Why does sadness sound so beautiful?

[@twilightsparkle2764]

This song ignite the sorrow and sadness in my heart, yet make my fire of hatred rising. They hurt us, making us bleed. It is they that break the promise. Nice work, 4ever.

[@ALinkIsHere]

This song..... This FREAKIN' song...... I am on the verge of tears right now.... So many feels.... Fantastic job on this. 'Tis a shame I never found this earlier.

[@emera1d944]

Who's still listening in 2024?

[@ramonasosna]

Hwree

[@MrSasunaru101]

Hi

[@yogiboy3185]

Hello There

[@TLoSpyro]

Привет

[@enthaloslarpenteur6196]

still here

[@Osoch]

Love the vocal production on this one and the overall sad/tragic feel of it

[@kellyfrench]

Congrats on 1 million views!

[@lordoffallsjb4620]

Now this is my favorite song ever

[@samfiles]

I listened to this on repeat for almost a month when it was first posted. Can remember studying in the library freshman year of college with this playing in the headphones. Then it was lost to me through the sands of time. Somehow this popped up on my feed just now (algorithm at it again), and the thumbnail caught my eye, I clicked this so fast and was taken right back to that moment of my life. Great song, great memories, thank you

[@Cloudtail33]

Whenever I hear this song, I don't know whether to cry, panic, or sit still in awe. It's beautiful.

[@Foreign501st]

That moment when you scroll through the comments and find your comment from 2 years ago... Edit: Now 4 years ago... Edit 2: Now 10 years.

[@anonymousrandomness1374]

Remembrance, the art of passing time...

[@echobounce2945]

*Num'rous regrets, the art of passing time

[@Foreign501st]

Echo's Tech Side True lol

[@anonymousrandomness1374]

Ironic, I'm reading my reply and I am not sure if it is accurate, yet it has 20 likes, odd

[@MayorLightning]

Remembrance, the art of passing time... Someone have to do it every year ;)

[@BrokenHeart-bz9og]

When I feel somber, this song makes me smile. I remember that everything is fleeting, most of all sadness. Bravo sir. Bravo.

[@orange_man_from]

Congrats on 1M views! Every view deserved for this masterpiece

[@Grundag]

Speaking as someone advanced in years ( Old Being Speak ) who once upon a dark time had to attend the funerals of 99% of his Friends, the line," Numerous Regrets, the Art of Passing Time" ...Could easily be the Cost of Passing Time. It speaks the Strongest to me. I spent years as the Canis Major in SL, in Oathbound Service to the Princesses Royal and the Empress of Roanoak. Best time I have ever spent online and the values of Friendship I learned there still live in my Heart. Thank you, Ponies of every Tribe and to the Writers of that Amazing Show. Thank you for this Chant. Portraying the Living Night Sky gave me the opportunity to pass this very message to all who would listen during the Years of Fabled Canterlot and Storied Roanoak. Some Days and Nights are never gone.

[@ArgSel]

Man, I wasn't in the community at the point this was made. It makes me sad for all the songs, memes, and stories I've missed out on until now. This song makes me think about mortality and the fact you can't turn back time to relive your "better" days. I think about all the things I used to do, the things I used to like, and the friends and people I've met over my years. So GG, thanks for making me think back to my old life. And thanks for the great song.

[@poqqery8950]

From the image, I always imagined this song as being about Twilight's turmoil - but also grudging acceptance - over the double-edged nature of immortality. Both a gift and a curse. Limitless opportunity - but can one accept that at the cost of inevitably losing it all, of knowing that, one day, it will all fade; that your loved ones prove no exception? Centuries pass, and all she has left is a spiralling but distant world of memories and the bittersweet companion of eternal time, cursed with denial to ever bear witness to being erased. How does one prevent the creep of madness? How does one avoid descent into insanity? Without the universal threat of time, how does one define the value of life? Is it ponderous, memories soon taking their tolls in the art of passing time?

[@fistrebellion]

Ok, how do you do it? How do you create some of the best songs I've ever heard? First Honesty, the Laughter, and now this. I can't describe to you the emotions this song makes me feel. Keep up this level of quality in your music. I can't get enough of it.

[@grayblackhelm6468]

Ecoyli Ellis For some people it’s built upon instinct, others through practice. Usually you can tell the difference.

[@AurelaCZ]

Yep, no doubt about it, this is a masterpiece, as are all of your other songs. Being a guy who thrives on melancholy and bittersweetness, this song has always resonated with me. When it came up in my playlist today, I had an epiphany: I realized I hadn't commented on any of your songs yet, despite loving all of them deeply for a long time. So, taking this opportunity, I decided to rectify that mistake and thank you not only for this one song, but for all of them. Emerald Eyes, all the other Chants, Pink Side of the Moon, Giggles & Gumdrops, Birdsong to name but a few; a meager example of your all-around excelence! Thank you for making such a wonderful music, it made me so much happier than I was before I started listening to you!

[@cakebomb3756]

I feel like I'm in some kind of church right now - like there's a service being held there.

[@AcidApplejack]

discover this masterpiece since this year and holy cow this is amazing