5 Backpacking Quilt LIES You Shouldn't Believe

👇 GEAR FROM THE VIDEO 👇
EE Enigma Quilt: geni.us/enigmadown
Xtherm Sleeping Pad: geni.us/xtherm
EE Hood: geni.us/EEhoodlum
-- OTHER RELEVANT VIDEOS --
Beginners Guide to Quilts: • What is a Backpacking ...
Benefits of Quilts: • WHY YOU SHOULD USE A Q...
Staying Warm Using a Quilt: • How-To SLEEP WARM WITH...
Quilt Buyers Guide: • Backpacking QUILT BUYE...
EE Enigma Review: • Enlightened Equipment ...
Are backpacking quilts better than sleeping bags? I have heard a lot of misinformation and misunderstanding about quilts and it is time to set the record straight! In this video, I bust 5 common myths about backpacking quilts so you can make the choice on whether a quilt or a sleeping bag is best for you in order to be comfortable in the backcountry.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐ MY FAVORITE GEAR ⭐
Garmin InReach Mini: geni.us/inreach
Decathlon Down Jacket - geni.us/Trek100DownJacketM
Trekology 2.0 Pillow: geni.us/TrekologyPillow
REI Flash 55 Pack: geni.us/Flash55
Enlightened Equipment Enigma Quilt: geni.us/enigmadown
Garmin Fenix Watch: geni.us/FenixWatch
Lanshan 1 Pro Tent: geni.us/Lanshan1Pro
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONNECT WITH ME!
Website: justinoutdoors.com
Facebook: / justinoutdoors
Instagram: / justinoutdoors
------------------------------------------------------------------------
This video description includes affiliate links. Affiliate links help support the channel at no extra cost to you!

[@JustinOutdoors]

Let me know WHY you prefer a sleeping bag or quilt!

[@stonefaceexpeditions854]

I only use envelope style sleeping bags, like my kelty galactic 30. I feel Closter phobic in bag with tight foot boxes, got to be able to move my feet around. good thing about the kelty bag is it has a draw string around the neck also.

[@neilhughes3529]

I think there is a simple way to settle this - ask yourself how many Arctic expeditions use quilts? The logic to me is clear - when it’s REALLY cold a bag that completely envelopes you ( including your head) is just bound to be warmer than a quilt and beanie in sub -10C conditions (not withstanding the weight penalty of a small bit of compressed insulation under you). For the sake of maybe 300 grammes penalty it’s a no brainier to me. If you are in warmer conditions then knock yourself out with your quilt, but when it’s really cold (or even a bit chilly) I’ll be snuggled into my cosy bag and hood, chuckling at you 👍😀

[@JustinOutdoors]

@@neilhughes3529 For an arctic expedition, I'd 100% use a sleeping bag. When not on an artic expedition though, I do prefer a quilt.

[@garrycollins3415]

@@JustinOutdoors I agree. For most of the U.S. a quilt is great. I have a 20 and a zero degree and backpack in the mountains all winter. Been to 10F/-12C a number of times and slept warm. Also, it is easier to regulate temp within a quilt, almost subconsciously sticking a knee out just like in a bed.

[@SimplyLesa]

I love my quilt even car camping!

[@donmartin9567]

Interesting but I'm an old mummy bag guy. My current setup is a mummy bag with an uberlight underneath. I stuff my pillow into the hood of the bag so that it is always right there for me, in the position I want it in. I do toss and turn a fair amount at night but my bag turns with me, I don't turn in my bag. Also, yes, insulation is what keeps you warm and when you sleep "on" it, you are compressing it but your body isn't flat so where your body doesn't press against the mattress there is still space for insulation. Plus, if the bag has heat reflectivity of any kind, that continues to work. But, whatever works best for each person, as long as you are getting out!

[@ashleykbarks]

As a side sleeper who turns and kicks or flails, quilts are my thing. Sleeping bags are too restrictive. I don't mind wearing something on my head. Even if my face gets too cold, I usually have my head inside the quilt with the rest of my body and limbs. I basically cocoon myself in a partial fetal position sometimes, and a sleeping bag doesn't let me do that. 🤷‍♀️

[@thepfleidi]

Oh boy. I think I just learned why I’m often getting drafts when using my quilt. Thanks for the tip with the pad straps! I’ll give that a try the next time I’m using one.

[@whiteavalanche8347]

Everybody loves a quilt until they get stuck for days in a windy blizzard. Enjoy those drafts 🥶 ☠️

[@johnsonsama]

Justout Indoors, killing it, as usual.

[@MaryannHazel]

OMG! I just figured out that I've been using my straps wrong. I toss and turn a lot at night, and I'm constantly pulling the quilt back down to close the gap. I had the straps going under the pad instead of wrapping around the pad. I also realize that one of my staps had some stitching come off so it is way too long. Now I'll sleep warmer. Yay! Thanks so much for yet another great informational video! PS...I LOVE my EE Revelation quilt!

[@JustinOutdoors]

Glad I could help!

[@229Reaper]

nothing can't beat the feeling to get really wrapped in a sleeping bag,quilts isn't for me at all.

[@Everydaybackpacker]

Great video and info! I just got a Western Mountaineering Astralite top quilt and I am super excited to try it out! Thanks for sharing.

[@HalfInsaneOutdoorGuy]

Dudes. I swapped out my sleeping bag for a quilt 3 years ago and not a single regret except that I didn't do it sooner!

[@jaytabac6525]

my main reason for NOT going to a quilt below -10 is the lack of the cocoon effect of having a sleeping bag with the hood sinched up. for 3 season, i agree that a quilt does look more comfy.

[@martindonaldson5433]

I use both, for this exact reason. Quilts above freezing, for weight and comfort. Bags below freezing, because they're warmer. 👍

[@jantomaszrogala4230]

that was very kind of you Justin, that at the end you have acknowledged that some people may just prefer the sleeping bag :) I do. When the temperatures go down to 32F and below I will always choose sleeping bag. Myth#2 is a fact for me, however I put attachments from my quilt on the straps I will always get a bit of draft, when I toss around and I dont like it. When it's freezing, why should I have beanie, hood, straps and quilt, so many different items, cumbersome, when I can have all this in one - sleeping bag. Hood in sleeping bag I can tight so only my nose is sticking out, no beanie required, with quilt and hood, still wont work, I had to put extra towel over my face. Yes, when it's warm like high 30s and up I take my quilt, what you have said is true, less constraining, comfortable. And just for the record here in Europe they put temperature limit (lower comfort) on both sleeping bags and quilts, so it's all the same. and to save on weight it's better to think 950 fill power rather than no zipper, hood and back. Of course this is just mine opinion, but isn't this film just yours ;)

[@4drcanyonracer]

A lot of people already carry a beanie and a buff with them for use in the morning and evening so it's free weight in that case. It's true though. You can get a UL 950 fill hoodless bag that's close to the weight of many quilts. The Zpacks Classic is one of them. I heard something genius recently on this topic. The guy said in warmer weather, say high 30s and above, he used only ultralight quilts like the EE ones. Simple and light. He left the straps at home and just clipped the ends together if needed. Drafts weren't much of a concern at those temps. Under the mid 30's, the guy said he used a Feathered Friend's Tanager zipperless sleeping bag because when it's cold, you won't need the zipper to vent and it's plenty easy still to slip into it. No worries of drafts in the cold temps and the simplest of simple designs. Kind of sounds like the best of both worlds as long as you're ok spending the cash for two setups!

[@jantomaszrogala4230]

@@4drcanyonracer interesting, I need to check it out

[@JustinOutdoors]

Whatever keeps you comfy for sure! In the Canadian Rockies here, it is below freezing at night year-round and I use a quilt except for when it is really cold in the winter!

[@jantomaszrogala4230]

@@4drcanyonracer hey I checked Tanager 20 CFL Sleeping Bag and it looks really good, specs very similar to my Cumulus xlite 400 20.3 oz with the hood

[@DaveOffGrid]

Great points! Your last myth busting video on quilts v. bags convinced me to go with a quilt! I finally got my UGQ quilt a few weeks back and testing it out soon. I also got mine with the tension control down the sides to help keep the quilt more underneath me. Great tip on pad strap placement!

[@aaronfuentes5919]

Got mine from ee few months ago. Only done some cold weather testing so far, but super happy with the quilt life. I don't even use the pad straps, the neck buttons work great.

[@reddragon7356]

I really appreciate your videos, you do all the hard work and share the benefits of your personal findings with us. Take care and happy hiking neighbor.

[@backyardfern1923]

these videos bring me so much joy!

[@willsmith7475]

the parts of the video where you show the quilt in use are really helpful to understand what they are all about. Thanks

[@ianrudd7442]

Some very good points made here. I will definitely research this more. Thanks.

[@iPhoneeditor]

Drinking game: take a shot every time he says "backcountry". Actually, don't do that you'll probably hospitalize yourself. Great tips man! Have a sub par synthetic mummy bag that I'm looking to replace and I'm definitely considering quilts. They seem superb for side sleepers too!

[@JustinOutdoors]

It's 904 times. I counted :p

[@tracygenereux959]

I'm a big quilt fan as well! They are more versatile and comfortable. I didn't actually know the tip about the pad straps, I will test it out next weekend!

[@buckmaster3594]

...... I think you might have that backwards, a sleeping bag can be turned into a quilt, but a quilt cannot be turned into a sleeping bag, although with the maxi pad tie downs and snaps around your neck, also you can buy an extra hood so it resembles a ......sleeping bag !!

[@tracygenereux959]

@@buckmaster3594 What I meant by versatile is I can use my quilt on the ground, but it's also very confortable in a hammock. I can travel with it (takes little space in my bag), I can combine it with another quilt or sleeping bag (it draps over easily), and when it's warm I can use it like a blanket which is nice :)

[@barondavis5692]

Boy, am l glad I watched this. I have been using the pad straps incorrectly for years and negotiating drafts. Now I know. Thanks 🙏

[@sheilastevens7956]

Very informative! Thank you!

[@hmbee1110]

I really appreciate the way you do your videos and actually demonstrate what you're talking about. I'm a visual learner and that helps me immensely to better understand what you (or anyone) is talking about. I also learned a lot about quilts through this. I will be investing in one down the line. Thanks for the great video!

[@JuanRamirez-jm9bp]

Thanks for this great vidéo! Using a quilt is the further step for me!

[@alextheis1123]

Great info, very helpful. Thx.

[@neemancallender9092]

I must have a hood around my head to keep warm I dont want to sleep directly on a pad When I turn in my sleep, I want the insulation to move with me

[@alexanderfriis1]

The tip about putting the straps on the side was the winner here for me. Even in instructionvideos from the company itself they show it wrong Cuz it makes a huge difference. Thank so much I was close to ditching my quilt thank god i found this!

[@theoutdoordogandhikinggirl]

Very helpfull. I am at the point that I need a new sleep system and I am very much thinking about going for a quilt.

[@sagehiker]

Well done. I will give a quilt a try for this summer or warmer fall and spring weather. I will also add a sheer liner to go with it as I cannot stand bare skin against sleeping pad fabric. And I OC about keeping my pads clean but funk happens. Also I am not hot to go in Wyoming winter in a quilt as I have too many $$ in zero to sub zero bags and it is unlikely I wear the beasts out; and they work. My 3 season stuff is near ending in life, so I am more open to options.

[@jtellier0]

I'm thinking of getting a quilt to lighten my pack weight, but my 15° bag has served me well for over 12 yrs. I use it as a sleeping for very cold weather, and I turn it over on me like a quilt for warmer weather (~30° and up).

[@MeetMeOutside]

Been there done that. If you have a good quality sleeping bag with continuous baffles, you can simply fluff and adjust the down so that it’s on top of you, not compressed under you, Cheers

[@alexl8328]

Totally agree with this. I prefer a quality bag over a quilt.

[@wad6216]

the zip keeps the down from going up running on the bag length and every bag i have seen on the seam at the other side it separates front and back down. So you can do what you say

[@oskariponkala1508]

The point about comfort and limit ratings is false. Enlightened equipment (the quilt you have there) always lists limit ratings for their quilts.

[@thek3743]

Warning: drafts are real and they are a problem when it's cold. I tried both sleeping bags and quilts. Even if you do everything correctly like Justin (straps, neck) there are cold drafts when you move. And it's quite logical as there is no seal between pad and quilt at the upper body/shoulder area.

[@WoutervanTiel]

Both: quilt in summer and warm weather fall and spring and my Moonstone bag for sure in winter.

[@BackcountryPilgrim]

Quilting for life! Somehow that didnt sound as badass as I thought it would...

[@SERESurfer]

Great info! New sub👍

[@bryanhryciw]

my UGQ bandit should be shipping soon. can't wait to try it out in Banff or Jasper at some higher altitudes

[@RapidGW]

Great tip on pad straps toward the outside of the pad rather than under you. It does work much better 😎👍🏼

[@4drcanyonracer]

My question on that is, for max warmth, bags and quilts are usually designed and sized to not leave a bunch of air voids inside. I wonder if it would be colder the way he's shown it. It does look like it would reduce or eliminate drafts though.

[@RapidGW]

@@4drcanyonracer And that is a fair point. I have tried both and find the edge of the pad works best for me. I think everyone has to figure out what works for how they sleep 👍🏼

[@4drcanyonracer]

@@RapidGW in using the straps that way, do you think you still need a wide quilt like most people recommend or go for a regular width? With it strapped that way, it seems like you wouldn't need as wide of a quilt. I sure wish I tested that method before I returned my reg width one. For EE, a reg is 54" and the wide one is 58". I'm using a 25" wide tapered sleeping pad.

[@RapidGW]

@@4drcanyonracer So I have a regular width UGQ Bandit which at 55" is about the same width as your EE. I use a 25" Nemo Tensor (no taper). I originally bought my UGQ when I was packing with hammocks exclusively. Been using tents mostly for the last 3 years since majority of my stuff is above tree line these days. Personally I'm happy with the regular width, but I don't know that you will notice 2" on each side with the wide. Might be able to pull it further around the pad to take up any slack. Play around and see what works best for you 😎

[@4drcanyonracer]

@@RapidGW Good info. I already returned the reg/reg Revelation and am wanting to order an Enigma or Conundrum. Just trying to decide on which one and which width. I tested out the reg/reg Revelation at home quite a bit and was getting drafts flipping from one side to the other and with the straps in different places. It just seemed too narrow and without the side elastics some brands have, that was an issue. The only method I didn't try was how Justin did it in this video! Ooops. No worries though, I can order a new one.

[@CBne1997]

Added an EE Enigma 10 degree this year. My Nemo Disco 15 was pretty good for tossing and turning due to the spoon shape, but it was also 48 ounces verses 26 ounces for the quilt.

[@tiffanyliu7015]

I have a Nemo Riff 15 and and am considering a quilt. How have you liked your quilt so far? any draft problems? Do you like it more than your Nemo bag?

[@tobiasherzfeld6673]

Really great info on the pad straps! Just bought my first Quilt and was wondering how to use the straps properly, but now I know how! Really like your videos, but maybe a tip for the presentation: Reduce the talking speed by 10% and show the little clips (photos) a little longer, so all the information can sink in more easily. Just seems a little rushed. Just meant for constructive criticism and keep on the great work!

[@stephenbouchard8075]

Great video Justin. I’m still undecided on either going with another sleeping bag or quilt. But I’m leaning towards a quilt

[@ck9973]

Interesting video. But enlightened equipment even recommends sleeping bags for colder weather. I don’t have experience in cold weather though.

[@JustinOutdoors]

I've used quilts down to -20C without problems. I think EE is just playing it safe with that recommendation as people aren't as familiar with quilts and the consequences of not using it properly in cold weather are much greater.

[@kayasper6081]

There is such a flow of info published about this subject, but finally I really understand the difference in "feel" thanks to your video: excellent! During my kayak trips sometimes I don't put up my tent and sleep in the open air. Wouldn't a sleeping bag protect better from crawling bugs?

[@JustinOutdoors]

You got me there! A sleeping bag probably would protect better against crawling bugs.

[@Juansoto20233]

I have a 20°F quilt and I can't argue with the weight savings- at 24 oz, it disappears in my bag. Even if there are drafts, a pound or more of weight savings is worth it. My knees thank me. I've found the key to making the weight savings worth the perceived draft disadvantage of a quilt is to make use of the clothing items I would have brought anyway on a cold weather trip- a beanie, thermals, puffy, etc. Those are the items that I wear while hiking or while in camp- none of them are exclusively for sleeping.

[@JustinOutdoors]

The weight savings is nice. The temperature flexibility and ability to toss and turn are even better for me!

[@4drcanyonracer]

Not sure if you know, but you can get bags like the Zpacks Classic in 20 degree that's only 19.3 oz. No drafts and ultralight. Quilts are still cool but just sayin!

[@MeetMeOutside]

@@4drcanyonracer Also, my 10 degree Western Mountaineering Versatile has a “ true” comfort rating of 10 degrees Fahrenheit,and is under 2 lbs just sayin ! Love it !

[@4drcanyonracer]

@@MeetMeOutside That looks like an awesome bag but it should be for almost $600! Damn. For a true no fuss sub 20 degree setup, that looks perfect though.

[@MeetMeOutside]

@@4drcanyonracer Its sweet !

[@Jonsoh811]

After having used both (correctly) I think it depends on what kind of sleeper you are. I'm a side/belly sleeper, I toss and turn and love to snuggle my cover around me. To have enough fabric/material to do this, I need a wider version. Making it the same size as a zipped open sleeping bag. Making the entire weight saving the hood... but I want a head cover, so not having a hood is a con for me. Why have a separate hood when you can have it on the bag? Allowing for more temperature control. Quilts are (more easily) draftier when used incorrectly or if it isn't wide enough for your sleeping style. Doesn't Quilts can have the same insulation value, true, so the warmth is the same. As long as the quilt fits you. isn'tIfootbox isn't there or often can be opened. As someone with very very warm feet, that's a big plus. I used to have sleeping bags that could do the same (its just 30 grams of extra zipper) but nowadays most sleeping bags don't have that anymore.

[@filmic1]

I have a Thermarest NeoAir X-LT 'small' reduced price. (I have a TR Pro Lite+ reg also.) I'm only 5'8" and ordered the MEC Talon 0ºC Quilt. Watching all you experts waxing positive on the quilt. Quite curious now how this will work for spring. I sleep very warm. Thanks, J.O.

[@buckmaster3594]

It is wise to take notes of what the Big Dogs use at base camp " Everest ". ...and I can guarantee it will not be a quilt.

[@JustinOutdoors]

They also use 12lb expedition tents and bring oxygen... ;)

[@dj-kq4fz]

Thanks!

[@fergusrb]

I just got a top quit synthetic to 40 degrees. I used it on my bed and was not cold but not hot either. I hear people how hot they got right away with a top or bottom quilt. I thought my heating blanket was on the way out so I put the top quilt on the top of the bed. Crawling into bed it was so warm an ahhh moment. About 2:00 am I thought I was being cooked it was so hot. What I learned is the installation only traps your body heat. I guess I am a cold sleeper and don't generate a lot of heat but the heating blanket did. How warm a quilt or sleeping bag gets depends on how much heat you put out and how much of that heat is kept in the quilt.

[@beatbasher]

I'm going to wait until the warmer months before trying a quilt, so if it doesn't work for me I won't have to part with quite as much money.

[@jimrice4699]

Justin, you might look into and test Katabatic Gear quilts for additional perspective on closure systems. Katabatic is a premium manufacturer of quilts (better than EE in several respects - including temperature ratings). Katabatic's closure system operates differently from the one you show and IMO is far superior and operates differently. The ability to "roll" and to get a good seal without drafts is superior with Katabatic's closure system compared to the traditional system used by EE, MLD, etc. (the type you show in the video). I agree that down quilts CAN be more comfortable than down sleeping bags, largely due to the ability to "roll" inside the sleeping bag without everything twisting up. There is also some advantage in ventilation, but the first step in better ventilation is getting a down bag rather than synthetic - they are simply more comfortable as long as the user can safely manage the risk of accumulating moisture inside the insulation. However, IMO a quilt is better only if the user does not mind "fiddling" with things. I advise new backpackers / campers NOT to get a quilt unless they have a personality that enable them to embrace "fiddly" stuff. Example, my good buddy runs a construction business. He definitely would NOT be happy dealing with a fiddly quilt. He watched a bunch of videos extolling the virtues of quilts and was leaning in that direction. Because I knew he would be unhappy "fiddling' with a quilt, I advised him to get a Western Mountaineering sleeping bag and he is very happy with it. For perspective, I've been trying to get him to at least buy a good down bag for over 20 - perhaps 30 years. He can sleep on a rock with a grass matt for warmth and there have been times when I could mistake his sleeping gear for those things. He's probably like a marine that way. Once he finally got the good down bag he was sold (I let him use one of mine a few times and that helped inform him). In addition, many very experienced users (and myself) prefer regular sleeping bags over quilts when temperatures are much below freezing - I'd draw the line at about 20 degrees. Listen to Ryan Jordan on BPL.

[@outbackwack368]

Subbed! I have never tried a quilt but have been reading a lot about them over the last year. I am ALWAYS uncomfortable in a sleeping bag because I'm a side/stomach sleeper and generally sleep poorly no matter where I am. I'm about to venture into bikepacking and will need to buy new, more packable gear for that. The BA Fly Creek bikepacking tent will be the shelter but I'm not sure about the pad or quilt yet. I'm not "planning" on camping below freezing if I can help it. Any thoughts on a super packable quilt and pad? Thanks and stay healthy!

[@JustinOutdoors]

A 950 CUIN down fill quilt and the xlite (or uberlite) pad would be your best bet! Expensive though.

[@BackpackingwithBuckley]

Nicely done dude!! I can't return to a sleeping bag. I thrash like I'm in a mosh pit!

[@JustinOutdoors]

You and me both!

[@BackcountryPilgrim]

You say that like it's a bad thing... :)

[@DarrenYee]

Thanks Justin, I don't do a lot of winter camping but hope to go out soon. Question, If my sleeping pad isn't warm enough and I want to add a reflectix as an additional layer off of the snow is it better to have it under my sleeping pad or on top closer to your body? I have seen both and have heard reflectix is more effective closer to your body in reflecting heat. What are your thoughts, Thank You

[@JustinOutdoors]

The thing to keep in mind with reflectix is that it will help with radiative heat loss, so you need some air on the side that is being reflected. For this reason, I'd probably put it under my sleeping pad and hope there are some air gaps around the pattern of the sleeping pad. If it was on top, it would just be sandwiched between you and the sleeping pad and not be very useful. You'd probably get further by bringing a cheap foam pad to put on top of or under your sleeping pad.

[@CanoehoundAdventures]

Great info Justin... is the same type of Quilt that someone would use in a hammock?.. Dennis, Canoehound Adventures

[@JustinOutdoors]

Same type! Maybe a bit wider for ground sleeping :)

[@nickwheelan1082]

Hey Justin, fellow Calgarian here. I ordered a synthetic Enigma and I'm stoked on the product. Wondering how you pack your quilt. I have a Balatoro 65 and I haven't quite figured out how to pack it efficiently. Advice?

[@lpoulin78]

great question! I want to know as well!

[@JustinOutdoors]

I either put it in a 10L stuff sack and then put it at the bottom of my back or I just stuff it in the bottom loose with a pack liner (nyoflume or contractor bag).

[@dennislavelle6909]

Hey Justin, Will a quilt work if your not using a traditional pad but instead using a foam pad?

[@OutdoorTherapy2020]

I can't wait to get my quilt...I don't know if I want to Thermarest Vesper -6c or a custom made from UGQ

[@Presshandstandgirl]

If you live in Europe check out cumulus quilts

[@Heikki_Finland]

I wonder when someone comes up with a system where the quilt is zippered to the pad from the edges, forming a hybrid to please everybody. Getting rid of the nasty air gap. Quilts seem a suspicious trend to me, as blankets belong to history and sleeping bags took their place later as more advanced sleeping system. This kind of shallow trend pattern sometimes appear in other items too.

[@mikevargas809]

brilliant

[@4drcanyonracer]

Great vid! I need some help Justin! I'm about the same size as you so this should be an easy answer. I ordered then returned a Revelation reg/reg because I thought it was too narrow. I use a 25" wide tapered sleeping pad and am 100% side sleeper. I'm thinking about ordering an Enigma but don't know if I should go with the regular 54" width or the wide 58". Too keep the drafts down I had the ends of it clipped together as tight as they could go but it would open up gaps just like you showed when rolling over. I never tried the straps in the "correct" position you showed, with the clips right at the edges of the pad. This seems like it would leave a lot of unoccupied air space inside and make it cold. Is that the case and would you still recommend the 58" wide that you have for someone our size and with a 25" pad? Thanks a ton for your help!

[@4drcanyonracer]

Side note, if I can't get comfortable with this, I'm going to order a Conundrum. After the Revelation draft concerns, I started looking at a fully spec'd out Katabatic, Warbonnet or UGQ with edge tensioning, draft collar, etc but by the time you add up the weight of those extra features and the cords to eliminate drafts, the weight is about the same as a 950 fill Conundrum, and with the bag, I wouldn't have to deal with two straps, four clips, two buttons AND an edge tension cord!

[@JustinOutdoors]

Hey! I actually have two Enigmas now - one 58IN and one 54IN. I find that they both work great for me on 25IN pads but that due to the extra material, the 58IN eliminates some of that dead airspace you mentioned when the pad straps are on the edge. The 58IN runs down to the quilt and then out to the sides whereas the 54IN gets tipi'd more.

[@4drcanyonracer]

@@JustinOutdoors Nice. Thanks for elaborating a bit on how the 58" fills the space and thus would be a bit warmer. You haven't tried the Conundrum right? I'm looking at their sizing too. I appreciate your feedback based on real experience!

[@summerlarson1171]

Do quilts work just as well with a sleeping pad that’s not full length? I’d love to save some weight with a quilt but I don’t want to have to invest in another pad too. Thanks Justin! Happy trials 💜

[@JustinOutdoors]

You'd still want to put something under your feet like your backpack.

[@beardedfrogoutdoors]

Too many caveats to quilts- booties, hoods, insulated mattress a must (straps), get wet easy in cold weather from condensation-need to air dry them out daily(if the weather is good)

[@andrewbstevens]

I have used a quilt exclusively for the last six years. I don't understand how you say they need to be aired out daily (wet?). Maybe if you pulled it over your head and were breathing into it at night, but that's not the case. Have slept warm and comfy down to 14f on my early winter section hikes on the AT. I don't use booties, just my wool socks that I would be using in a sleeping bag also. No way I could go back to sleeping bag at this point. But every person is different. Hike your own hike.

[@rahabh09]

Handy tips! What pants are you wearing here?

[@mattheishman170]

Best way to counter act drafts with a quilt....use a sleeping bag

[@JustinOutdoors]

But then how do you counter act getting all tangled up in a sleeping bag when tossing and turning and the extra weight?!

[@mattheishman170]

@@JustinOutdoors. I don't toss and turn. I'll have no problem carry a extra few ozs.

[@neilhughes3529]

@@JustinOutdoors I have a Thermarest Questar 0 degree bag. It has pad straps underneath to hold the bag on the pad and what they call WARM (with additional room for movement) fit. I can wriggle around all night in it and not worry about slipping off the pad and you don’t have to fret about drafts from a quilt (which I have always done when I used one). For me the Questar is the best of both worlds. I don’t know why other manufacturers don’t copy the design - it’s awesome!

[@MeetMeOutside]

@@JustinOutdoors Personally my sleeping bag has a wonderful wide shoulder area, has a “ true “ comfort rating of 10 degrees Fahrenheit,and is under 2 lbs. Done deal. Cheers

[@andrewbstevens]

Love my quilt. Can't go back to a sleeping bag. Have so much more freedom (active sleeper) with movement in the quilt and sleep so much better. Plus I love not carrying the extra few ounces. Few ounces here and a few ounces there add up to a lot of pounds everywhere.

[@Hikebike365]

Thanks Justin! I have 2 questions How is being strapped to your pad less claustrophobic than being in a bag?? Do you use a sheet or anything on top of the pad?

[@JustinOutdoors]

In a quilt, it drapes over you like a blanket and allows you to toss and turn easily. It's a lot tougher to toss and turn in a sleeping bag - especially with a hood. I usually am wearing base layers and don't use a sheet.

[@Hikebike365]

@@JustinOutdoors thanks! I get that part about tossing and turning. Is it not claustrophobic though? I'm not generally claustrophobic, I've cave dived, did a lot of SCUBA and don't mind tight spaces but for some reason when I zipper tight into a bag for Max warmth, I get a little spooked about having to get out in a hurry if I wanted.... Is being strapped to the pad similar??

[@barondavis5692]

ski kite bike When I used a sleeping bag, it wasn’t wide enough to put a small pillow between my knees. Sleeping on my side meant pulling my legs up while the bag is wrapped around them. I don’t have any of those problems with a quilt. Hope this helps.

[@justincase7661]

I'm inexperienced with quilts. Are quilts an alternative to a SBag? Or vicaversa? What is a US military quilted Poncho Liner? Is this a quilt? Hope you can enlighten me Justin?? Bonsoir :)

[@JustinOutdoors]

Quilts are another type of top sleep insulation, like a sleeping bag!

[@TheRealSteveEllis]

Horses for courses, quilts have their place but not a replacement for sleeping pads imho

[@linux_admin2501]

I grew up sleeping in tents and backpacking. However, now that I am older and gained weight during this pandemic, I am not sure which one to go with. sleeping bag or quilt. I weigh about 300 pounds and I recently tried the Marmot Sawtooth Extra Wide Long. I felt too constricted in it and overall prefer something like a square sleeping bag. I do toss and turn a lot during sleep and generally sleep on my side and stomach. I am getting back into tent camping and considering the quilt. Any advice?

[@JustinOutdoors]

Most people are much more used to sleeping bags, but I love a quilt. Like with anything, it will take a bit to dial in and get used to though.

[@linux_admin2501]

@@JustinOutdoors Thank you for the reply Justin.

[@DirtRiderLife]

Hoping you'll review a Zenbivy quilt before I buy one!

[@JustinOutdoors]

I have one but haven't been super impressed. After several times of use, I find it annoying to set up and not any warmer or more comfortable than my standard quilt. The biggest thing going for it is probably the hood on the sheet.

[@DirtRiderLife]

@@JustinOutdoors Wow! that's surprising considering the rave reviews elsewhere, I'm also attracted by the hood thinking that would provide additional warm. I do very much value your opinion particularly considering your location, I was thinking the 25F light bed (when its back in stock) for 3 seasons but now I have a seed of doubt. Fully understand you not want to go against the flow posting a negative review though. Regarding set up, is it possible to leave it hooked up and just slip the whole setup onto the pad maybe that would make it simpler to use

[@JustinOutdoors]

@@DirtRiderLife The insulation the zenbivy uses is super warm. It's rating is definitely accurate. The problems I encountered were when leaving it hooked up - it would get all tangled. The solution from Zenbivy is to unhook the quilt from the sheet after using it and then hooking it all back up when setting it up (this was way more work than I wanted). I've ended up in a catch 22 with setup. Leave it hooked and maybe spend 10 minutes untangling it or spend 10 minutes hooking it up and unhooking it.

[@erikdahl3171]

Great video. I prefer a quilt for a few reasons. One, down compacts on the bottom anyway, so your warmth is really about your sleeping pad. Second, I do like to side sleep and role over, much easier with a quilt vs a sleeping bag. Third if it is warmer, the quilt lets you open it up easily and adjust your level of comfort. Really, the other nice thing is with the straps it stays in place on the sleeping pad. I tend to roll of the sleeping pad with a sleeping bag. Overall, personal preference, but the quilt works best for me for sure. I also do a mix of overlanding or hiking. Quilt is great both in my rooftop tent, in my larger ground tent or in my back packing set up.

[@Fellmandave1]

Great effort Justin. Still not convinced. Still have to lie on the nasty nylon of the pad and no cosy hood. Will have to try one reluctantly instead of being a bigot.

[@JustinOutdoors]

Quilts are not for everyone! My girlfriend is in the same boat and finds a sleeping bag to be a nice cozy cocoon and loves the hood - but she is also is not active at all when sleeping and is never too warm. Let me know your thoughts when you try a quilt!

[@blessedarmadillo8257]

The straps do not "eliminate" the side drafts, they mitigate the side drafts. The truth is if you are a side sleeper and turn throughout the night you are going to pull on the side of the quilt and will create drafts. The degree to which this interrupts your sleep will probably determine whether you will be comfortable with a quilt or not. Personally I'd rather carry a few extra ounces with a sleeping bag, not have to worry about waking up and get a good night's sleep. Better sleep + a few extra ounces makes for better hiking the next day. But to each their own.

[@JustinOutdoors]

With hundreds of nights out using quilts and sleeping bags, I never get drafts when I set up my quilt properly.

[@MathiasSmedberg]

I toss and turn with my sleepingbag so that the down falls down on the sides and I get cold. I have to find a sleepingbag with channels from "feet to head" (as I se many quilts have) or try a quilt. The fabric on the sleepingbag may eliminate some draft but it doesn´t insulate :(

[@AggyGoesOutdoors]

Every time I see somone sleeping in a quilt , they're also sleeping in their puffy jacket with their hood up, apparently the underside of a puffy jacket has magical insulation powers that the underside of a sleeping bag doesn't. Sadly I still remain unconvinced despite a really nice video... I'm waiting for the world's military forces to ditch sleeping bags for quilts....

[@JustinOutdoors]

I almost never sleep in my puffy when using a quilt. Usually it's just base layers!

[@djdonkeyslap]

Quilt or bag, just a matter of personal preference. I can guarantee one thing, you won't find quilt sleepers at a K2 base camp.

[@JustinOutdoors]

100% agree that comfort is personal preference. All the power to you if you adhere to K2 basecamp gear approaches when 3-season backpacking.

[@djdonkeyslap]

Yup. Considering your vid is in winter, hence my K2 comment. And thanks for heads up at 6:35 on the hood. If only someone could invent a quilt/bag with an attached hood. @@JustinOutdoors

[@OstryHeniu]

Which sit pad you are currently using?

[@JustinOutdoors]

I usually use the Thermarest z-seat!

[@christopherclements5909]

I think I'm just holding onto old ways honestly. I don't really have a good argument to why I use a bag, just always have lol

[@JustinOutdoors]

Whatever works and keeps you comfortable!

[@GromtKromkakejern]

The placement of that draft collar looks really annoying, will it not just get in your face when you are trying to sleep?

[@JustinOutdoors]

It's not! It rests loosely around the upper shoulder area.

[@johnnyappleseed6960]

Personally, I would never buy a quilt that was too small for my body type and/or sleeping habits just to save weight.

[@mootrail9487]

Dig your channel, but this video is full of holes. I think we should focus on the myths that quilters believe without one ounce of scientific proof and are just flat out untrue. As someone who recently switched to a 30° baffled Quilt from a 40° sewn through bag for 30-40° nights, a sleeping bag has a quilt beat everywhere except for flopping around comfort. The Number myth is that the extra material on the bottom side of the sleeping gets compressed, doesn't keep you warmer and is extra useless weight and cost. Even compressed, the bag is adding R value regardless how small and as you turn or move, it instantly starts to decompress. Not only are drafts stopped, but it just as importantly minimizes air voids around your body which is less heat loss to heat empty air. That's why tucking the edges of the quilt under you is recommend vs wrapping the quilt around the edges of your pad. Creating bigger pockets of air may be comfortable but it is not thermally efficient. Without a doubt, you need to buy a more expensive and heavier pad with a higher R rating for a quilt. And along with a down hoody, it makes quilting neither lighter or cheaper and a whole lot fussier. Sure both may be equally warm on a overly hot and pricey xTherm, but that's not a test. So I will issue you a simple challenge. Go out on a 30° night with a 30° quilt (no standardization for quilt ratings yet, only bags and pads, FYI) and 1.7 R Z-lite. Or I'd accept 2.3 R Uberlite on a 25° night. Do the same with a 30° bag and let us know your results. You might be cursing your mummy bag, but you'll be a whole lot warmer. Then you can do the "5 lies about sleeping bags that YouTubing quilters tell".

[@Rampampulin]

That is absolutely true. I had the same experience. Qulits above freezing, bags below. Thats just common sense in the community, even Skurka, a much more experienced guy than Justin, recommends bags below freezing.

[@FredOutdoors]

One the the best comments about this topic! I tried quilt once and hated how fussy to use it. Putting in straps was extra work. And even with the straps, there were still tiny holes letting drafts happen in a cold night. And the purpose of getting a quilt to save weight is absolutely pointless if you need to bring extra hood and warm clothes to keep you warm.

[@eddydewilde4958]

So you save 100 grams with a quilt only to have to buy a hood for cold weather. Good luck with the fad. Sleeping bag for me

[@asher8272]

Katabatic gear.

[@muskadobbit]

Theory at 4:30 might be true if we were flat on the bottom. Don’t know about you but I’m not...

[@luc1ferblack]

See to me quilts are a massive ripoff. If you look at a standard single down duvet they are cheaper and larger and you dont need straps because they are big enough to cover the sides. somebody should make a down selk suit. perfect soluution

[@gregsparks]

Your head is still exposed and you can's sit up, period.

[@johnnyappleseed6960]

Quilts vs. Sleeping Bags? Stupidest First World argument ever!

[@Corcioch]

I dunno, I like your videos alot Justin but, well buying the hood you cut off for a quilt is a bit ridiculous . . . .and There is no way, bearing in mind the laws of physics and conduction, that the outer material, the insulation even though compressed under me, and the inner material of my sleeping bag is not affording me some insulation/ thermal break, even when I am lying on it. To say that it offers no insulation is simply false. Sure it may not be much, but it is still more than a quilt with an open back offers. Also, as you move around at night, areas of the underside of your bag will become un-compressed and will insulate more. If I lie flat on my back a large area is compressed and insulating less, if I roll onto my side, a smaller area is now compressed and I am getting more insulation.

[@JustinOutdoors]

Thanks for the reply Cormac! I 100% agree that compressed sleeping bag insulation provides some insulation, but I do thing it is too little to reliably rely on for keeping you warm when planning a trip. With dense foam insulation, you increase the r-value by about 1 per inch of insulation thickness. Even with synthetic insulation, I'm compressing the insulation down to fractions of an inch when laying on it and, as a result, probably adding 0.1 to 0.2 to the r-value between me and the ground. That amount of r-value increase isn't enough to change the type of sleeping pad I bring. I agree that with a quilt, you rely on the sleeping pad more if you're a side sleeper compared to if you're in a sleeping bag. A sleeping bag is likely more efficient in the short-term when using a sleeping pad that resists convective heat loss well for the reasons you laid out (I'm not a thermodynamics expert though).

[@4drcanyonracer]

For sure man. I'm a side sleeper and am only compressing at most 1/3 the area of the bottom of my bag. The other 2/3 are lofted and formed around me providing quite a bit of insulation. I also use a 3.9 R value pad. Still looking at getting a quilt for the warmer weather though. They really shine there, especially if you get a 950 fill. They weigh almost nothing.

[@bishnes]

These are just 5 reasons why quilts arent VASTLY inferior to a sleeping bag, just inferior. Using a quilt is one step backwards. Its a reason why no serious expedition use quilts. And watching someone put on a down hood is the biggest meme ive seen. That is a part of a sleeping bag, which you basically "cut" off and buy separately?

[@JustinOutdoors]

I don't think the majority of people are going on many expeditions every year ;)

[@MeetMeOutside]

I agree, I’ve done the overquilt thing in winter, it just sucks. Back to my Western Mountaineering bag ! I did enjoy the quilts in my hammock, and occasionally in the summer will use a light quilt, on the ground,or in my tents.

[@ChopperChad]

So 5 month self supported hike of the PCT is not an expedition? A quilt seems to be a well-liked option for many of those people.

[@bradorndorff7408]

Quilts are a over hyped ripoff, cost is not justified. Zipper is the most costly thing that a seamster does yet quilts cost more. 🤔

[@JustinOutdoors]

Quilts cost less when comparing equally performing products...