5 reasons for global crisis in political Islam: Shekhar Gupta in

[@ThePrintIndia]

High quality and fair journalism needs good people to pay just a little for it. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@abuamirsyed3048]

Sorry to say SG you opinion is out of the context issue is not muslim politics. Issue is is this acceptable to redicule others religion in the name of freedom. Muslims all over the world owe Prophet Muhammad PBUH their everything. No muslim no metter how liberal he is cannot see someone redicule our Prophet PBUH. You have seen this in salman rushdi case and everytime when people try to hurt our religion. And than advocate liberalism and even esteem jurnalist like you unable to understand the root cause. Love for our Porphet PBUH is uncomprehensive to non muslims to try to avoide that. You understand holocaust very easily but you are not will to accept our prospective. We understand that it is only to provoke muslim to label them. But there are many people who does not understand the intensions. It will alway happen in past and continue to happen in future whenever somebody try to redicule Prophet PBUH such reactions are certainity. And in otherway it is good for islam also you will notice more people start noticing islam and trying to understand it and this is winning for islam. Hope i made my point clear

[@vickyvicky2734]

@Albert Einstein why are saying this brother he is one of us,whose " ancestors wear salwar on swords", leave him..

[@aryaman.agnihotri]

Ohh need money for journalism or to fund anti india activities

[@tusharmallick4413]

Just watch it carefullykzbin.info/www/bejne/qpC0oaxmor2abrs

[@rohittaro9121]

@@abuamirsyed3048 are you trying to justify killing in the name of religion is your religion so fragil that it can't even tolerate a little ridicule

[@AtulKumar-me5vd]

"The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is the brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only" - Ambedkar

[@warpdrive9229]

What Ambedkar said about Islam is something that you won't even hear from a RSS dude.

[@ImranKhan-ey6ws]

Ambedkar is not a saint or a prophet. Who gives a shit.

[@syedali4488]

usne aaaisa kuch nahi bola hai

[@chandrakantshanbhag3058]

@@syedali4488 Read Dr Ambedkar's book THOUGHTS ON PAKISTAN

[@PJ-cm8ix]

He also called Hinduism a pagan religion that is stooped in slavery and against human rights

[@SurajRawat-db6ts]

All Muslims have to sit down and decide, whether they want to be liberal or conservative, if they want others to be liberal they need be liberal first. and if they want to be conservative they've to respect other's values. they just cannot swing wherever they think is their personal interest.

[@huzaifa6126]

Yes 2 billion people sitting down and deciding. There are 72 factions within islam. Some are liberal some are really conservative. It also depends where you come from and where you're brought up.

[@amanbishnoi130]

@Suraj Rawat true

[@sudhanshusrivastava1969]

to be liberal in Islam the have to first denounce their holy book which itself is full of hate speech and bigoted views which is impossible so to say Muslims can be liberal is oxymoron, few countries are accommodative due economic reasons , first Muslims need to amend their 7th century era book to stay peacefully in multi cultural multi faith societies.

[@huzaifa6126]

@Ashwini Desai of course there is extremists and extremism. Did I say otherwise? Read before you start commenting.

[@huzaifa6126]

@@sudhanshusrivastava1969 where did you get that from your RSS class? Have you read it? I don't think you have so what are you basing you opinion on? I know, your own bigoted views.

[@nirajsalunkhe2158]

Sikhs, Buddhists, sindhis are more minor co mmunities than the Muslims ! But They are respected in all countries. It's all about our civilised behaviour and mindsets

[@tomomiki2923]

Usually there is a hatred mindset for the magor minority group in every country. In old times in my country there were hindu and Buddhist only. And as Buddhist were the largest minority group Hindus targeted the Buddhist, the Buddhist population declined but the Muslim population started to grow very rapidly but after the British came, a new thing began and it was hindu Muslim. And when they left a new thing began it was India Pakistan. And in 1971 we got rid of this and we became bangladeshi.

[@Riuytfhjklf4634]

Sindhis is no religion, it's an ethnicity. 85 percent sindhis are Muslims, 15 percent are hindus.

[@amanjha5916]

@@tomomiki2923 most of what you said makes less sense than a drunkard, Look for the reasons of decline among the Buddhists followers first.....and I hope you will come to know how naive you were. No hate intended, Just look up your facts(NOT FROM ANY SOCIAL MEDIA) before you make any major statements.

[@tomomiki2923]

@@amanjha5916 it is all about my country not about India. 😑

[@adj33]

@@tomomiki2923 Buddhist declined in the sub continent due to Adi Shankara, he went around debating Buddhists leaders all over the Indian subcontinent. Back then when you lose a debate you had to convert to the winners view. This is called renaissance of Hinduism by Adi Shankara. He started Advait Vedanta philosophy which is widely practised today by the ones who truly understand Dharma.

[@VIVEK-ru4rg]

"Rakhi is symbol of misogyny and Burqa is choice of clothes." Islamo- liberal for you.

[@shrikantbkaware]

@Muha Mmad liberals are the only tribe to have somewhat sympathy towards Muslims now you idiot fuck, soch ke gali de

[@striker1088]

Im afraid you talking about UCC, in that csae Bhagwa will also be banned, duh😂

[@Hashashin_420]

@Free Speech I think he is saying so because all the major invasions of Muslim countries in modern times were under liberals and liberals usually try to disrupt the dynamics in Muslim countries and often receive funding from foreign countries (not an alt-right conspiracy but a serious thing) and hence the negative image. Plus a Muslim would value a practicing Christian more than a non-practicing atheist or something given that he isn't anti-Islam of something.

[@killDJuice]

No one ever said tat 😂😂😂 maybe u got that on you whatsapp group 😂😂😂😂 with a imge

[@rahulsharma8940]

@@striker1088 Bhagwa is colour idiot not an attire and attires are not banned under ucc

[@mubasshirahmed673]

He has pointed towards the hypocrisy amongst the Muslim nations without calling them hypocrite. Such a shrewd analysis in such a polite way makes me watch The Print. I appreciate it. Thank you SG.

[@shashanksri5993]

he has this ability to identify patterns and present them in a non judgmental way. It is up to us to make judgments

[@darshilmashru8479]

@@wahidsebpo8908 How many Muslim democracies are there anyway? Name them, and India would be friends with them (except Pakistan, because it isn't a democracy).

[@plasmaboy4513]

You know that people like you are minority in your community?

[@mubasshirahmed673]

@@shashanksri5993 Of course not. You are an outsider. Most of us feel the religious as well as the political leadership has become hollow, but we do like to follow our religion without making any compromises.

[@RanjitNayak]

Another way of looking at it is that he is baised and a hyprocite himself. I think he is pretty direct while criticising Modi and the BJP, so why this beating around the bush with muslims?

[@rajgarg1413]

Keep your head safe Because of issues you are raising

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

watch kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

[@MrHotheadalex]

Ohh pleaseee..... He didn't even had guts to use the word "radical islamic terrorism" once in such a long video... He didn't even addressed him as "terrorist" once, kept saying this boy of 18 years.... And in a democratic nation even after saying something in such sympathetic tone you still live scared or recieve death threats that we have a huge huge problem at hand that needs to be addressed

[@MrHotheadalex]

@Neurogamer ur forgetting about murder of kamlesh Tiwari

[@MrHotheadalex]

@@aniurs yup even failed to say words like "terrorist" "terrorism" "fundamentalisms" "extremism" "radical islamic terrorist" nothing none in such a long video.... Just kept making excuses for terrorists

[@MrHotheadalex]

@Mohib Quadri How many total lynching have happened.... The data that was put up by hate tracker was taken off after 2019 elections, mentioning that data was incorrect..... And tell me if and when a lynching takes place how many hindus come out to support it..... The deafening silence on slaughtering of French teacher from the entire muslim world and then protest against french president even here in India shows who is the real bigot here..... Stop making excuses for terrorism

[@kamalbhatt2502]

India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh are the three different countries made from the same civilization, but divided by religion. It shows how religion may shift the goals and directions of a country.

[@blacksheep6174]

Not same civilization, maybe inda bengladest but punjabi balti pashtons have nothing to do with south or north indian

[@blacksheep6174]

We dont share culture with u

[@kamalbhatt2502]

@@blacksheep6174 You forgot to mention your favorite place 'Kashmir'. Although here in India we are not bothered about your radicalized opinions.

[@vishnu4234]

@@blacksheep6174 Ofcourse, you have forgotten about your ancestry. How they were ki||ed, pressured to convert. Were r@ped and imposed Jizya for non muslims.

[@hkumar7340]

Currently, one will have to say, it is the religious division that seems prominent. If at all these three nations shared some civilizational ties and practices, those have become weak and unimportant. Maybe, India and Bangladesh have some cultural and literary/artistic commonalities, but Pakistan seems far more a part of the Middle East than of the Indian subcontinent.

[@pepesilvia813]

Irony died when these Islam countries talk about secularism 🤣🤣🤣

[@shalinitiwariscorner5210]

Albania, Mali, Kosovo, Kazakhstan, Nigeria, Morocco, Azerbaijan etc are Muslim-majority yet secular and modern countries. Secularism has many enemies, not only Islamic fundamentalism. Hindutva or Bhagwa Wahaabism is also a constraint for secularism .

[@KishoreKumar-cs6dd]

@@shalinitiwariscorner5210 i dont know where u find bhagwa wahabbismmm......

[@KishoreKumar-cs6dd]

@@shalinitiwariscorner5210 kosovo 🤪🤪 i think you'll simply type what comes to your mind

[@KishoreKumar-cs6dd]

@@shalinitiwariscorner5210 nigeria unable to beat terrorism in own land buying pak jf 17 to bomb own people.. I think you are a mindless creature....👹👹👿😈👽 typing bullshits that comes to your mind😈...

[@serioussamik]

@@shalinitiwariscorner5210 Restrain from typing opinions without visiting the countries you mention, atleast once your lifetime or at least do proper research before commenting things bordering on absurd! That way you will not make up imaginary monsters (Bhagwa Wahabbism lol🤣) and cover up the real ones (Beheaders of European girls in Morocco, 2015 Mali blast perpetrators, Boko Haram in Nigeria, Kosovo militants/insurgents etc).

[@sarkarinaukar.790]

I can't believe what I am listening... National interest on Islam... You have earned my respect Sg...

[@janeswan1124]

SG stepping on circumcised bananas 😁

[@Renusri12]

He is trying to project himself as secular

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

watch kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

@Hunt Slither he probably did a lot of charity to balance out his karma , just enough to not get killed by saying something slightly politically incorrect😂😂😛

[@Renusri12]

@Aryan Sharma we don't go by theatrics .....we look at consistency and intensity

[@vickyb7802]

In France, French laws and freedom should reign Supreme. Just like in Islamic countries , their law is Supreme.

[@bancrftiwunchuria4221]

Yes , there should be limitation on freedom of speech.Just see the hypocrisy of Western countries just like Uk, who suspended jerram for antisemitism. There should be freedom of speech but not at the cost of hurting other religious sentiments.

[@PJ-cm8ix]

@@bancrftiwunchuria4221 I mean denying the Holocaust is different from drawing caricatures of the prophet Muhammad,denying the Holocaust is denying history

[@coppersulphate4967]

tht is where the exact issue is..their laws let this happen....they got to change the law...

[@sonitabh]

@@bancrftiwunchuria4221 Ye zara tweet kardo sentence Rana Ayyub, Umar khalid ke liye bhi. Unhe bhi gyan do.

[@Rayan42069]

Says bhakt who can't tolerate pk

[@rajeshdaviyal4602]

Democracies will always have more problems because you can talk about them. - R. Daviyal

[@daxpatel2530]

Just like persons in a single family "can" have "lifelong disagreements", so does the rest of the world !

[@saurabhmawle8813]

Well said

[@shashu990]

😂😂😂vro

[@kalpeshkumarpatel380]

That's deep.

[@mohitvyas97]

Fuck man. Insane quote, you have my respect.

[@deboo117]

"If you are emotionally attached to your tribe, religion or political leaning to the point that truth and justice become secondary considerations, your education and exposure is useless. If you cannot reason beyond petty sentiments, you are a liability.“ - Dr Chuba Okadigbo

[@sabhji9780]

Who is Dr. Chuba.? What is he emotionally disposed to? If matter is to be decided according to human conscience, then understand human conscience is different from one to another. So for one it may be rational while for other it may not be. So in order to manifest right understanding of living one must adhere to the correct ascetic order. And that ascetic order must be quested.

[@RamKrishna-hf6dd]

@@sabhji9780 all of your gyaan is awesome. Your community though selectively applies all that gyaan

[@RamKrishna-hf6dd]

@@sabhji9780 and don't impose your Shari'a ideals upon unwilling people

[@sabhji9780]

@@RamKrishna-hf6dd, yours too

[@MunnaBhai-tn2hg]

That is true of India which is fast transiting from democracy to theocracy.

[@rajeshdaviyal4602]

This is French Revolution 2.0, France may win or lose but I hope the world learns from it like the 1st one.

[@soumenhalder4831]

Yes

[@amanshroff3624]

Couldn't agree more

[@dudedebonair]

@poorva sharma Bhakt Spotted...Bigot

[@dudedebonair]

@killer miller Every Bhakt is a Supporter of Radical Fascist Hindutva Rsss Ideology..🙏🏻💀😅😅😅

[@dudedebonair]

@soham panda yes Bhakts Prefer Mob Lynchings by Cow Vigilantes.. Raping & Harassing & Bullying Women Online.. Drinking Gaumutra & Eating Gobar Cakes Taking Down Advertisement promoting Communal Harmony ...😅😂😂😂😂😂

[@adithyachintalapati6851]

Guptaji was doing so many gymnastics with words and was so careful in this episode that it almost felt like he was so scared of getting beheaded himself !!

[@abhiarya8550]

🤣🤣let's not point out the main thing that....... we don't allow dissent to our own muslim brethren than how should I left you alive on critising upon me

[@gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129]

I wish long life FOR SG

[@suriyaprakash8663]

🤣🤣🤣

[@niharenduchakraborty8710]

Mr.Gupta is afraid to discuss the main thing

[@Nimish204]

Not without reason. Just ask Samuel Paty.

[@edmundburke9477]

*The only problem with Islamic fundamentalism is the fundamentals of Islam! ~Sam Harris*

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

[@drvibhorsharma6607]

On the dot

[@roshanserrao854]

@@satyajeetsingh5383 nice link bro

[@kireshpanchesh4503]

@Aqib Ali This is very stupid, how can one interpret wrongly, eg: “Therefore cut off their heads, and strike off all the ends of the fingers. This shall they suffer because they have opposed Allah and His Prophet, and whosoever shall oppose Allah and His Prophet, verily Allah will be severe in punishing them” (8.13). How can such words be misinterpreted.

[@kireshpanchesh4503]

Muslims must understand that the prophet might have deceived them, how can one be sure that he received the word of god? There was no one with him on the mountain. He might just have added these statements in the quran to induce fear and get more followers.

[@Meaningful_Nature]

I've not expected such a clear massage on Islam from U, I'm a Nationalist. Brilliant Effort you have done to summarize it all in 23 minutes👌👍

[@vickyb7802]

salute to u brother

[@Meaningful_Nature]

@@vickyb7802 I've left Islam

[@vickyb7802]

@@Meaningful_Nature dude, I didn't even read ur name earlier..also I have nothing against Islam

[@saktiprasadswain6546]

@@Meaningful_Nature that's a twist,u know what that guy saluted u

[@not4yman]

Murtad 🤢🤮

[@archisman4165]

The idea of Ummah fails the Chinese test.

@friendly advice very true, jo paisa deta hai, oyi bhagawan

[@ashishsachdeva1800]

Does that also mean that solution of Islamism problem is ultimately the China solution?

[@vipulkrishnasingh5652]

U r missing the point globalisation of revenge takes place in liberal democracies like usa France not in closed country like china

[@Vrtpnwr]

@New start XyzEven with all that context, its still a Human rights violation. How do you justify that? Politically motivated or not, Muslims/Humans are being locked up in camps.

[@rabiyasyne621]

Ashish Sachdeva, do you mean going to the Middle East and other Muslim countries to solve Islamism ? Did you think before you made this comment?

[@loveorperish8418]

Kya Christians or Hindus k koi sentiments hurt nahi hote ? Wajib ul Qatal keh kr Jihadi Muslmaan Uneh kbi b maar skte hain..

[@neerajkumar-ts6om]

no don't know about Christian but for hindu yes it happens even more than islam. 2 day back in punjab no violence reported. asked police to lodge a FIR.

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

[@soumyadipdey6531]

Tu pagal hai kya ??? Wajib ul qatal ??? Tu modern world mein rehta hai koi 7th century mein nahi...sala education ka soch economy ka soch....sala agaya arabic jhar ne...

[@sourav7162]

@@soumyadipdey6531 ucc will resolve the most of community issues. We should focus more on employment and economy.

[@VikashKumar-jv4kt]

Sentiment admi ke hote hain. In secular jamat ko hindu to admi bhi nhi lgte. To hindu ke sentiment to chhod hi do jaan ka bhi koi keemat nhi hota.... Ye apni hi buddhi khud kha chuke communist hain.

[@114asp]

Reading comments is fun too. Some Muslim friends are ignoring reality and defending their faith in comment section:( lol

[@subhradas1644]

Because everything is written on Quaranvirus

[@mohdazamk91]

Commenting someone who is still far far behind in every aspect of life found people defending something which is presented inaccurately is funnier. The Crisis is really in Hinduism where a Mahant is making speeches like terrorist while the public Apploud, Iraq Syria despite facing terrorist never elect terrorist and you know who have elected terrorist here. So calm down before commenting nonsense.

[@TR-ur9zp]

@@mohdazamk91 okay when u don't have democracy how can you elect?!

[@bibin4641]

@@mohdazamk91 elect ?? 😂 First you need a proper democracy..

[@imranim6834]

Idk why sikhism isn't blamed for killing of Indira Gandhi

[@moinulhaque4665]

As an ex Muslim atheist I don't understand why good indian Liberal progressive people practices proper criticism of Hindutva but not Islamism, Islamic fascism shouldn’t be taken lightly. In a lot of sense Islamofascism is a lot stronger than other form of religious fascism.

[@common-sense99]

Only a diamond can cut diamond. 200 invasions needed to conquer india. Hindus who turned to buddhists betrayed india and sided with muslims.only then muslims could conquer india (present day afghan,pak and northern part of india).mighty British also used one indian king against other for 100 years and with help of indians only could conquer india

[@rahuljoshi5394]

Poland is laughing 😂 😆 😝 on the other europeans countries...

[@amritpanda7947]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 damn

[@saurabhmishra2363]

@friendly advice link de bhai is video ka like krni h

[@s.tay1804]

Link bhai

[@birendrathakur222]

@@saurabhmishra2363 twitter.com/rashtrawadi21/status/1322383286836948992?s=08

[@birendrathakur222]

@@s.tay1804 twitter.com/rashtrawadi21/status/1322383286836948992?s=08

[@staymotivated5743]

The only reason the print is speaking about this topic is because French ruling politician's has removed the mask of the Islamic leftist

[@saurabhmishra7913]

Noo

[@user-zy8vk2ip8o]

Yes, they don't have guts on their own to call out these jihadis for last so many decades.

[@NonSecular]

@Warpdroid well said

[@saurabhmishra2363]

@@saurabhmishra7913 why tf are so many saurabh mishras here?

[@user-fw1hj3vv2k]

Yes so in India it doesn't seem that you are 'bhakt' or speaking in favour of ruling party. You could give 100s of examples of India but you choose to give international example to maintain your unbiased nature. He could have given example of Kashmir in india but everyone avoids that.

[@anubhavpraharaj5782]

No need to talk about France, see our neighbours and know. 😂😂😂

[@sahilsalim4169]

XD right

[@abdulmoiz5987]

Same as we see hooligans of RSS defaming Hinduism in India

[@sachupradeep7009]

@@abdulmoiz5987 comparing RSS to Followers of a pedophile death cult is the problem u piece of shit

[@anubhavpraharaj5782]

@@abdulmoiz5987 Jaali Na 😂😂😂 Teri Jaali Na

[@abdulmoiz5987]

@@anubhavpraharaj5782 boy this is what yu think. Yu know even our prophet was ridiculed. So if I'm ridiculed for the sake of my religion,it's not a big deal. Moreover,the RSS racist ideology needs to be addressed rather than pointing at others.☺️

[@samyakhp4353]

Basically, shekarji just said that Muslims are not loyal to their Nationality, their loyalty is only towards Islam! (This is exactly why muslim regiment was removed from Indian Army decades ago).

[@sleepyeinstein]

Can you tell me when it was formed and removed? ..As of my knowledge there was no muslim regiment so far in India army history. Check the facts bro

[@Sh3llyxfan]

You are spreading fake news andh Bhakhat

[@samyakhp4353]

@@sleepyeinstein "As of your knowledge" that's the point to be noted. Just because you don't know something, doesn't mean it isn't there. You could have atleast done some web surfing, and you would got the answer right there. I don't understand how you get this confidence inspite of being wrong.

[@warhead160]

@@samyakhp4353 Why don't you provide the source of what you have stated. Here's what I found. www.google.com/amp/s/www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2020/oct/15/army-veterans-write-to-president-kovindseeking-action-over-fake-muslim-regiment-social-media-post-2210760.amp Even I can say that the moon is a giant rasgulla in the sky but I will still need to provide proof. Now the Indian army of today is the successor of the British Indian Army, most of which were based on caste/ethnic lines. Upon independence some Regiments like the Baloch Regiments were transferred to Pakistan and many still retain their old names to this day. ssbcrackexams.com/indian-army-regiments-motto-and-war-cry/ Have a look and see if you can find anything that refers to a Muslim regiment. You just fell hook, line and sinker for an old Pakistani propaganda doing the rounds whenever the anniversary of the 1965 war comes around thelogicalindian.com/amp/fact-check/muslim-regiment-indian-army-fact-check-india-pakistan-war-1965-war-against-pakistan-24315 Speaking of which Abdul Hamid who was awarded the Param Vir Chakra belonged to which regiment btw. Now present your sources to refute mine. Otherwise you can dispense with your bruhahaa

[@captainnemo8072]

Nothing new, Ambedkar said the same thing during partition.

[@TheBakor]

May Allah give strength to Muslims to quit Islam

[@islampath2success41]

apposite will happen

[@TheBakor]

@shabir dar Allah has given me the strength to see thought Islam.

[@mohammedalishaikh3950]

MAY BRAHMA GIVE YOU ENOUGH SENSE NOT TO BELIEVE IN MYTHOLOGICAL BULLSHIT.

[@TheBakor]

@@mohammedalishaikh3950btw Brahma does not give power nor strength. Only Allah does it. hence don't believe in Muhammad or Islam

[@yuvrajsawant6828]

@@TheBakor Yes they think our culture is mythology and they believe that Muhammad had really seen Gabriel 😂😂😂

[@chan-yeol4262]

Muslim in minority - We Want Secularism , constitution Muslim in Majority - We Want sharia , Quran...

[@amansaxena6798]

True words

[@sahilalisaiyed5924]

Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, have Hindu population and they can practice their religion freely if you didn't know

[@aweshsaiyed1212]

Shut your mouth 😂

[@dericchris8150]

Extremists in every religion are the biggest traitors to their own community......they just free themselves and enslave people for political and business dramas..

[@aweshsaiyed1212]

@@dericchris8150 Absolutely Correct .

[@dipayandas3568]

If you expect others to denounce Hindu extremism, If you expect others to denounce Buddhist extremism , then we too have expectations that you denounce Muslim extremism. Tolerance and Secularism does not give a free pass to any religion

[@ananth224]

Did you ever think that “Hindu extremism” and “bhuddist extremism “ (which have no doctrinal sanction) could just be a reaction to Muslim extremism which has doctrinal sanction

[@dipayandas3568]

@@ananth224 To me extremism means violence in the name of religion ... what is one's belief is up to the individual

[@pseudonym9215]

I think there is no debate, extremism has no place in modern society.

[@krateproductions4872]

@@ananth224 Have you read the Quran? In which Chapter does it say to kill innocent people? I could go on talking about “doctrinal sanction” in Christianity, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, etc but I don’t... Read any religious book of any religion then talk about it

[@ananth224]

@@krateproductions4872 yup I have read Qur'an....there is less filth in it ....the real mines of filth are hadith.....I agree that the old testament was also equally filthy,it seems as if Q was a copy of that.. .but Christians have reformed and you can have a reasonable conversation with them( the don't behead you if you question Jesus) ..... please show "doctrinal sanction" in Gita !!!

[@riffaahmed5551]

Very aptly put by veteran journalist Shekhar Gupta. Most of the points he mentioned has to be taken serious note of. Objective and crisp in his approach, his work and outlook has never failed to impress us since a long time.

[@nasirahamed944]

This has something to do with Education gap difference with Muslim youths. When we distance ourselves with Scientific and literature activity and believe only on God(which maybe good to a certain point but we forget that we need to put effort as well for something to happen like to get good marks we need faith as well as to study) this is bound to happen and middle East countries or turkey doesn't want to build Educational institutions where excellence can prevail. Somewhere down the line we(Muslims) have become stagnant as a society in terms of seeking knowledge (science and literature) and started relying more on God(blind faith without effort) Middle East nations have money but not the will power to change the society.

[@vinamrasinghai2339]

It is not also that easy. It is not about God, it about Muhammed and Islam. Arab Civilization was destroyed by Muhammed and replaced by Islam and Arab Conquests. That was successful but that history has little value. Also, the rise of Muhammed seen as rising of a Prophet rather than that as the making of a King. For Arabs Muhammed is hero, for non-Arabs it created an identity crisis. Also, Muslim Mullahs and Mulavis hide Muslims about Islam like there are more than 30+ different Qurans, present Nafs Quran written between 1921-24 AD, Muhammed is the last prophet not even mentioned in any Quran or Hadiths, about Muʿtazila, etc. Lack of Questioning culture and right to do propaganda or taquiya keeps Muslims away from facts. Muslim historically relied on Jizya and loot.

[@0609Bhuwan]

Well said indeed... wish there are many more like you... The real issue with Islam for the non Muslim world is not about less educated devout followers... It is the brutal violence that seems to be the way of showing dissent and that these methods seem to be gaining legitimacy in the larger community instead of being addressed by the leaders .. Baghdadi and Osama could even be called lunatics & terrorists but likes of Mahatir & Erdogan justifying beheading of innocent does not help the muslim cause at all

[@nasirahamed944]

@@vinamrasinghai2339 Don't you think so all great Empire relied on tax (Jizya) even the Great Ashoka Kingdom relied on tax system and about loot kindly check British or any other European power had colonization all around the world for your kind information which looted wealth of the nation. Highlighting only Islam or Muslim did is a wrong perception on how you see it. Kindly look at the abbasiyad Caliphate which had many significant advancement in the field of science and technology. Ibn al-Haythm invented the first camera and was able to form an explanation of how the eye sees. Doctor and philosopher Avicenna wrote the Canon of Medicine, which helped physicians diagnose dangerous diseases such as cancer. You can Google this page of national geographic not by Muslim author but by people of West .. www.nationalgeographic.com/history/magazine/2016/11-12/muslim-medicine-scientific-discovery-islam/ There may be many versions of Qur'an but most Muslims follow only the authentic one only. When the love of scientific knowledge declined we became stagnant and backward.

[@nasirahamed944]

@@0609Bhuwan Politicians want people with blind faith and not with facts. Turkey economy is in decline but people are busy with religion.

[@satishchandraGK]

@@nasirahamed944 Turkey is a real disaster. It was considered as an European/western democracy but right now is a sad story

[@KEMPIREK]

I don't want to sound racist.. but 1 religion has problems everywhere.. Either the fundamentals of the religion itself is wrong or the understanding of preachers reading the holy book from back to front have got it everything the wrong.. Unfortunately even the highly educated also getting into the religion card played by politics..

[@elborrador333]

Islam isn't a race and you're not being racist when you criticize an ideology.

[@gabbar51ngh]

Islam isn't a Race but violent ideology

[@imranim6834]

@Abhilash J yes And varaha avatar is real🐗

[@michaelruatfelaralte84]

Thats not racism, Islam is not a race

[@AdilKhan-kr8om]

@Abhilash J it's a religion. Almost all religions are stories for one another. I could say similar stuff about Hinduism as well

[@prasadpawar7027]

Islamic countries appeasing China: I did business.

[@nitish523]

You have to appease China, it's the main power and source of Cheap goods and labour which we as a consumer society are relying heavily for our needs.

[@darthludicrous99]

“I was a businessman... doing business.”

[@amanjha5916]

@@nitish523 Exactly you didn't get to be a bitch while demanding a pedestal to commemorate your chastity. That is either you condemn them all for *hurting* your sentiments or you just don't spread terrorism.

[@sachinreddybappa1273]

Mr.xi is new allha & china is new jannat for 72 hoors 😂😂😂😂.

[@nitish523]

@@amanjha5916 Spread everything...all types of BULLSHIT. I have to be a bitch, otherwise how can i badmouth. At least get the meaning of bith right. Moron. Take everything to the gallows. There's no wrong in Chastity, you create your own rules and stay within that boundaries. Call all the names that you like, coz those are the titles which doesn't mean a thing, they are just words. Brag about everything and follow your own.

[@preciouspaws1400]

The only Muslims living in Peace are in 'Graves'.

[@harishaneef26]

Yes away from idiots and bigots like you. Rest of us are having to deal with morons like you on a daily basis 🤣

[@harishaneef26]

@Nick 🖕🖕

[@harishaneef26]

@@casperghost0secondsago594 Bro , the problem is deep only for those who indulge in perpetual wars in the middle east , support and fund violent organizations, conduct assassinations etc. The entire west is crying of Islamic extremists in their countries but can't take responsibility for the wars that led to mass immigration from troubled countries. Ignorant people like you speak about how deep it is but don't really think that deep. This monster of Islamic terrorism is your own creation . Blame Islam all you want but we all know ISIS alqaeda and the likes did not emerge until the 20th century.

[@Ben-nt4fq]

🤣🤣😂

[@vipuljawalekar6058]

@@casperghost0secondsago594 They are in complete denial mode

[@lucy-uo6bt]

Was Modi govt correct in terminating *Rohingaya* refugees to India ? After watching this i think so..

[@amanshroff3624]

There are still many Rohingyas spread all over India..

[@xyzabc162]

India should have distanced itself from France issue

[@prasannar6847]

@@xyzabc162 why??

[@tejasdeepsingh456]

@@xyzabc162 Why?

[@amanshroff3624]

@@xyzabc162 india is a victim of islamic politics, Hindus spoke of this but we're tagged as islamophobic now when the world has woken up how do you expect us to be shut. Just look at these islamic leader's hipocracy, how they've ignored china. Also read the MEA's statement properly it's clearly mentioned "terrorism".

[@Anupam0121]

Really appreciate the fact that Shekhar Gupta has actually (without any fear) pointed out the real picture of islamic world in depiction in a very articulated manner... thank you for being so open and neutral. 👍🙏

[@Sachinmkammar]

He didn't even scratch the surface and that's fear!

[@arindamkumar7725]

God Bless the Modi Government for implementing CAA.

[@AbdullahAlMamun-to9zh]

😂modi is killer

[@muttineni03]

is it implemented yet? I don't think so, last I saw there were riots by peacefuls and then nothing after that

[@bharatnotindia.6296]

God Bless Modi jihaadiyon ki gaand maarne ke liye

[@harishreejoshi3195]

9:15 Dr Swamy said the same thing very bluntly in a Vice video Burning India and it created a huge backlash

[@sarangpatil8775]

Hai can you provide link to that video.

[@harishreejoshi3195]

@@sarangpatil8775 search vice burning india on KZbin

[@sudhirjadab2654]

One can clearly see how scary he is. He is struggling to explain because he knows his one mistake will cost a lot (including his life). That's level of fear they created.

[@MunnaBhai-tn2hg]

That is not fear, that is respect to others sentiments. That is good thing.

[@rudalibellator1739]

@@MunnaBhai-tn2hg such respect is surreptitiously missing while depicting goddess Kali and smashing brahmanical patriarchy..

[@amongyou6419]

He is speaking the truth as a muslim a I am convinced

[@plasmaboy4513]

@Pratyush Kishore chutiya h wo kuch nahi karega, abhi I am satisfied bol ke gaya h, usi molanao ki chatega ja ke. Ha bjp aur hinduo ko gali dilwa lo, khusi khusi aa jayega

[@saifrahman5643]

@Abhishek Debnath Of course, there is no place for nationalism in Islam. But that doesn't mean Muslims hate their motherland. Prosperity of your country = Prosperity of Islam.

[@nagaprathyush]

@@saifrahman5643 - not a very convincing argument... because Islam > everything else(personal, nation etc) for some...

[@infobomb466]

@@saifrahman5643 hey, indoctrinated shit! What a fuck point! I am Muslim,just for name sake. Islam is a problem. It's a shit full of bigotry and age old rotten ideas. Islam is in crisis and will remain in crisis.

[@infobomb466]

@@nagaprathyush It's true. Islam is a disease. It kills creativity, enthusiasm and life outs of an individual. It is choking while surrounded by Muslims.

[@ayushkumarrai1117]

If tens of crores of Muslims across the world feel they are victims of mass Islamophobia, their Holy Prophet shown deliberate disrespect, it is a sense of crisis and siege. The description says it all! This is courageous SG.

[@anilnair14999]

It’s a good analysis, but on two issues I feel differently. 1. You conveniently brush aside the most important reason for the violence propagated by radical Islamists - the religion sanctions it - The religion believes that all non believers are to be be appropriately dealt with !!! 2. You say all religions are political. Honestly, I don’t see Hinduism qualifies as a political religion at all ...

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

Hinduism is political too. For example it dictates rulers how to make laws and how to govern their realm.

[@kb30gpu]

Hinduism is very vast. Politics is a small part of it. The problem with Islam is that there is an overwhelming indulgence of politics in it.

[@maryamkidwai2543]

The religion of Islam does not sanction it. Learn before you speak. Look at Indian politics hear Modi and Yogi and Mohan Bhagwat speeches. Hindutva is political Hinduism.

[@dineshgupta-ir9zi]

@@rajashashankgutta4334 No it doesn't. People are free to write whatever they deem fit. Others equally free to contradict him. The rulers decide what is appropriate for them. They are free to follow what they think is right for them. Nothing is mandated by relegion. There is no single authority. There are no commandments, no Sharia, no book, prophet, God to follow. There is no compulsion.

[@furqanshariff]

@@dineshgupta-ir9zi that is becoz hinduism lost its scholarly zeal during bhakti

[@harishs6048]

This was more like why Muslims are fighting among themselves not going against their countries, abiding by a Caliphate and Ummah. Did not expect this. This concept of Ummah has created security threat in many countries including India made it's citizens disloyal and also led to the partition of India.

[@prathamgupta840]

@New start Xyz My friend one thing you gone wrong is that the Indian muslims do not follow sufism as most of them believe in Hadees and gajwa e hind . When maulana and owasisi like people come on TV they clearly accept that they follow Hadees teachings.....

[@MunnaBhai-tn2hg]

It is always two way street. Holding only one party responsible is foolish and doens't solve problems.

[@ritikanubhav]

Owaisi comments on macron but not on uighurs of china ,this is hypocrisy

[@IditriPictures]

Not just owaisi See the deafning silence by anurag kashyap, taapsee pannu, swara bhaskar, anubhav sinha n all Even quint, wire, portals r not publishing the news with unbiased view. Search abt Kamlesh tiwari - India's charlie hebdo. Nobody batter an eye

[@georgeabraham5672]

Christianity would have been in the same mess today had it not been for the reformation movement of 16th century. Hope Islam recovers from the crisis as it is the second largest religion with more than a billion followers.

[@amitkc20001]

Wrong hope buddy. Christian force pegans to convert to Christianity which in due time over taken by Islam. Almost all North African countries gone. Christians are loosing battle in Europe as they focus in wring places with rice bag conversion.

[@parth6115]

George you keralites Mocking Gujarat for 2002 but after that violence Muslims here living peacefully, otherwise we had seen many communal violence before 2002

[@georgeabraham5672]

@@parth6115 so you saying there is no violence in Gujarat arter 2002? All peaceful? The Tanishq incident says otherwise

[@georgeabraham5672]

@Angelo Wilson it's only a small minority group in Islam who is creating all this problem

[@parth6115]

@@georgeabraham5672 fake news spread especially by NDTV to fool pseudo seculars like you... Tanishq store manager already cleared there was no such incident.Gujarat Home minister also condemned this fake news and will take action against ndtv

[@thromboplastin446]

The weirdest thing is when this guy blames Hindutva, a lot of guys hail him as the true journalistic lord, whereas all I see is Muslims here trying to tell him that he is a fake journalist. Lol, proves the point of the video.

[@Priya-cm3tr]

Hindu is not even a religion term but cultural/geographical word, and anyways we criticize and reform it. It is sadly the umbrella term for everything discovered in Indian civilization and its history/discoveries/Vedic knowledge (Vedas = Knowledge) are not even studied, researched or taught in school because it has been termed as "religious" which is stupid. Which culture doesn't explore its own history/achievements? We are the most self-defeating nation. ALSO hypocritical since ACTUAL religious books like the Quran and Bible are allowed to be taught in madrassas or catholic schools but the actual scientific books are not even explored? WHY should we - as the only oldest living civilization -not teach about our own history? And how can we treat Ramayan and Mahabharata as Mythology whenwe have archaeological evidence? At least if not the history they are legends which made a crucial impact on South Asian culture. You don't have to be religious to know about them. We in our culture are known to worship people from our own community and Krishna and ram are shown as enlightened being just like Budha or Mahaveer were. They are also the biggest and oldest literature in the world - nothing about heaven and hell but a freaking STORY. Another thing we boast about is classical Indian music, yoga, meditation and Ayurveda but we aren't taught about Vedas and Sapt-rishis? WHY is the whole of our civilizational knowledge is being shunned as being religious just because someone said so? It's clearly not. Faith is personal, let us decide what is useful or not by reading, researching and exploring rather than being oblivious about it.

[@AnkurRoy-bi9yz]

Please stay safe sir. I love your work, but there are some crazy people out there.

[@ThePrintIndia]

Thank you very much for writing in... sg

[@bongfish1369]

Mr. Shekhar Gupta - my sincere appreciation. I wish Indian pseudo (left) liberal journalists learn something from you and stop misleading people. I wish you more courage and shall expect more and more of this kind of honest journalism.

[@VIVEK-ru4rg]

Islam needs reformers.Period. And it also needs to accept change and faults in it.😬

[@markteck278]

Muslim extremist are believers that being stuck with 7 century mentality

[@sohailstone]

May Allah bless you all & your family at all times , Amen ✌🏼

[@sohailstone]

@Ethan 0007 Thanks for the stark reminder though 👍🏼 Quran & Life of Prophet Muhammad. That’s more than anything I can ask for 🙏🏼

[@amitmeena7711]

We are human first before hindu muslim Cristian

[@sohailstone]

@@amitmeena7711 Absolutely well said , we all are kids of Adam 🙌🏼

[@pradipghose2125]

Why did you not mention that Gandhi supported the Khilafat movement bringing about Muslim relihion bigotry.

[@scooby5478]

Muslims fought only for themselves. Gandhi and Nehru are the biggest culprit of India... Ambedkar and Sardar patel was correct when they asked for complete population exchange...after all divide was on the basis of religion.....then why major chunk of that community were allowed to stay here . Don't blame me for doing any politics here ... This is the legitimate question which youth of majority community is asking. Hindus have always been backstabbed by insiders

[@malaashok173]

Because they are scared they will be tagged non secular and non liberal😂😂

[@arm789]

This guy is big pimp

[@sanathanadharmama]

He will not mention cos he is from print...he always does wrong print

[@tuhinsubhrabhattacharya5311]

No one from the so called mainstream media regardless of their idiological inclinations ever speaks about the Moplah massacre and Gandhi's disgusting comments and stance on it.

[@ItsSaurabhRaut]

Absolutely freedom of speech is an indicator of a healthy society.

[@Mardonagod]

Saddely we can't have that right.

[@balpreetsingh6834]

We can't even have that in India 😔

[@loading3138]

Bro freedom of speech tab tak sahi hai jab tak ke woh kisi ko offend na karre Chakka,kala,gay,lesbian,hijra,trans ye sab bhi freedom of speech hua tab matlab kal hoke sab ek dusre ko gali dene lag jayo freedom of speech hogy

[@Mardonagod]

@@loading3138 We speak like this because we are taught like this People of French have their way of life but I still can't agree with killing someone for speaking.

[@loading3138]

@@Mardonagod bro I am not justifying killing I am telling that what france have done is need to be stopped

[@therightgame3]

Why does the jurisdiction of Ummah end at China's borders? I haven't seen any protests amongst Muslim communities in India for the genocide happening of Muslims in China..

[@shivamPal-my7nr]

And Indian communist

[@user-zy8vk2ip8o]

But China is doing the right thing, na? They would get beheaded if they gave them as much space as India has.

[@therightgame3]

@@user-zy8vk2ip8o you are part of the problem.

[@user-zy8vk2ip8o]

@@therightgame3 you bring pointless arguments and comparisons with China.. how does that have anything to do with beheading a school teacher in France? You are definitely not part of the solution!

[@culeforever5408]

Bcoz they get money from China ... They dont really care abbout uiughurs un China..

[@akhiljames3435]

It is the test of a good religion whether you can joke about it. - Chesterton

[@rabiyasyne621]

@ Then he must have been an atheist. No one must joke about peoples' religion.

[@akhiljames3435]

@@rabiyasyne621 Far from it, Chesterton was a staunch Christian. God is more humorous than humans because he created people who fart, animals like hippopotamus so I don't see why we cannot joke about him or religions that talk about God. Humour is a gift from God that should be celebrated instead of suppressed.

[@rabiyasyne621]

@@akhiljames3435 I once asked an old chap in his 80s [ I knew him to be a Christian] about God. The chap said 'God? Noah and the Ark? Where did Noah get get all that food for those two elephants?' Ha hahaha.

[@suchender801]

@@rabiyasyne621 If god can’t be the most magnanimous being, he doesn’t deserve the veneration of his people.

[@nib69]

Buddhism is the best.He will not say anything.He will leave it to your karma.

[@SreekanthJ]

Here in Kerala, they are planning to make a movie on Khilafat movement projecting it as a war against British for Indian Independence..😉

[@puneetmishra4726]

Would there be a sequence on Moppila riots?

[@sundareshkrishna6457]

Lol…..

[@sukanyagupta1533]

that is what they taught us😂😂

[@rockongrx20]

Why does this ummah not give citizenship to south asian muslims??? Any idea?? They are one after all.

[@NaveenYadav-il5bw]

Where will they live ?!on moon!FYI it's an metaphor nothing like that exists.

[@scooby5478]

They are expanding in the name of crisis.... It is a well thought plan to conquer Europe.

[@relaxeveryonetakedeepbreat732]

@@scooby5478 yes

[@pseudonym9215]

Ummah is not a political or national identity, it's means brother in faith, like we all are brothers and sisters in humanity. Edit : Also because middle eastern countries doesn't represent islamic values, they pick and choose.

[@manga1970]

I support France and from today I’ll start using one French product in my life. Starting from French kiss to my gf

[@rajanaravind2069]

Me too .... to start with FK is a right choice

[@sachupradeep7009]

I also support France but i am pretty sure u don't have a gf 😂

[@rajanaravind2069]

@@sachupradeep7009 You seems to be jealous lol

[@sachupradeep7009]

@@rajanaravind2069 just a joke mate 😂 jaihind

[@rajanaravind2069]

@@sachupradeep7009 Yes I know

[@stratosphere969]

Thats y in CAA there was wxclusion of muslim refugees.

[@darshankhandelwal7290]

Nrc bro

[@adityagandhi2073]

@@darshankhandelwal7290 NRC doesn't exist. Just like god's of books and statues.

[@Rayan42069]

Bhakts rock

[@gayatri555]

Exactly

[@p7ytzxq]

Gosh the height of intolerance..... that boy literally beheaded a teacher because he was trying to teach his students freedom of speech, a basic human right using a cartoon.

[@anivib]

It's time we all start calling a spade a spade without fear

[@anivib]

Brothers. Nobody can reform Islam other than Muslims themselves. Every religion is flawed, every religion has their fanaticals zealots, but it starts when we don't indulge in being an apologetic & whataboutery. That just shrouds the naked truth in our own mind rather than becoming a convincing counter argument. Please focus your energy in not countering my opinions but on reforming extremist & exclusionary tendencies of your religion. The world & Allah will thank you if you stop defending violence in the name of Allah.

[@saket2980]

This community is deadly against all other religious organizations

[@abhikharde]

Sir, u only spoke abt political islam n not abt radical islam. Dissappointing. 👎

[@prachetmakwana6011]

I doubt that needs any explanation - atleast in today's world

[@papayaman9567]

He loves his life and doesn't want to be beheaded.. I thought that is obvious 🤔

[@knightofgodserventofholymo7500]

No left person can say that

[@premprasad3511]

That helps him to be politically correct !

That is what has been affecting the Non-Muslims since 14 centuries! Jihadism!

[@ananth224]

It’s great that awareness among young Hindus is growing everyday.......once atleast 50% becomes aware of what has been suffered by their ancestors,in the name of Islam since 712AD .....this nuisance of Islamic bullying will end.

[@ajaxaj8470]

Muslims are Muslims first and Indian next. Period.

[@vibhanshuvaibhav335]

😂

[@mukundaprabala5486]

The indian muslims never consider themselves, they think they are of Arab descent and are doing a favor to india by staying in India.

[@vkchaitanya2003]

@@mukundaprabala5486 lol

[@daxpatel2530]

There is no "OATH of total Allegiance" just because you are resident in a country. Incredibly all r "BORN" individually n grow into adults, yet no-one can choose where he/she is born. (country, family etc etc at birth). Kismet n Karma in practice!

[@pradippatil5832]

Where is intolerant and secularist gang ?? Hindu o ko gyan dene ate hai lekin ab kya hua??

[@satishrawani3166]

@Andrew David and where are they🙄🙄

[@rishabhraj8233]

@Andrew David Yes but if pms of countries are not progressive then where will find such muslims they are probably 1 % progressive muslims and the reason is they do not take quran in literal sense. I had the same thinking as you but after knowing the faults it made me worry for what is going on in . Also we have seen national muslim leaders who have done gr8 things for our nation but the sad reality is most muslims of today want to follow the medieval texts of 7th century word by word in 21st century and that is why things are not going well.

[@Jw08560]

It was a peaceful beheading, stop your hatred😌

[@yujirohanma5332]

Liberal Religious radicalists k khilaaf hote hai chahe koi bhi religion ho, Emmanuel Macron liberal hai🤣

[@sunnydrall1940]

@Andrew David See there cannot be reform in Islam😂. People are not wrong yes but my naive friend tell me one thing if u do not speak against the crime u are an accomplice as per every civil law . Doesnt that count here we saw no protest against the terrorist who beheaded and killed the innocent ppl. There is no secularism when u are arrsted in islamic countries for any comment or even worshipping other religion. Problem is The verses of the quran which says kill kaafirs . If they can remove them then yes reform can be done . I m sure they will listen to a liberal like u and progressive muslim will do the reform. Good luck👍

[@clashoflands]

Today sg has outdone himself

[@nitish523]

@rahul k That's the Khasiyat of Mr Shekhar Gupta. He's clever at the same time knows from where the wind blows.

[@sunithsubramanian2449]

Neither Islam nor any other religion will Survive this era, Let us wait for that

[@specture9529]

Khilaphat's time has gone Muslims all around the world needs to understand this !

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

for d past 1400 yrs they hv not understood. root of d problem lies somwhr else kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

[@kashmir1892]

Easy boy ! 70-80 years on backfoot is nothing compared to the 1400 years on front foot , we enjoy what you say about us , we enjoy to see the hatred that is in your hearts , for it fuels us to do what we will do

[@Anushrut1]

@@kashmir1892 Your bad time has only started. The demographic change in Kashmir is underway and soon it'll be a Hindu majority land. The rise of Hindutva and nationalism in the west will be deadly for Islam. Islam ki kabr khudegi, Bharat ki zameen par.

[@kashmir1892]

@@Anushrut1 tumhari tammana sun kar boht khushi huwi , tum jo chahtay ho woh hosakta hai ya nahi bhi hosakta hai lekin me jo kehnay ja raha hu woh ho chuka hai Sirf tumhari agar baat krain i mean hindus ki Toh Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh Indonesia Malaysia, ye sab Hindu terriroties thy ye tum se gaye, Christians ki agar baat karain Yemen egypt algeria syria iraq moroco tunisia , Turkey , Bosnia Azerbaijan Ye sab gaya Tum 1.4 billion ho aur abi Kashmir jiski population 8 million hai handle nahi kr pa rahay , tammana aur iraday achi cheez hai lekin practical reality bi koi cheez hai

[@kashmir1892]

@@Anushrut1 Hindutva can do nothing , you can lynch some muslims inside India , but there r around 200 million muslims there , if you jus try to fight indian muslims on a big level you will have millions of suicid bom-ers everywhere which will be more than enough to collapse the Indian state,

[@abdullahsamad9586]

Very interesting analysis and eye opener without any prejudice Thanks you sir

[@dharmgyan4493]

kamlesh tiwari ??????????????????????????????????????????/

[@muzicaldoctorz0901]

You can agree or disagree with the views of Kamlesh Tiwari. But if you are a human first you have to admit he didn't deserved to die.

[@nageshthakur4103]

@अमन ऋषि because they belong to media.

[@nageshthakur4103]

@अमन ऋषि bhai mae to yae bolna chahta tha ki The Print ko Kamlesh tiwari kae upr bhi report bnanai chahiye thi

[@nageshthakur4103]

@अमन ऋषि aur rhi baat yogi ji ya Modi ji ki to agr vo kuch bhi krege Hindu kae liye to leftist media(including print) unpr kuud pdegi ki bhai yae to secular nhi hae , ense democracy to khtra hae

[@rohitgiri0]

@rohan singh make it Hindu lives matter.

[@sandeepchavanke9325]

जहां पर मुस्लिम पापुलेशन ज्यादा हो जाती है वहां पर वह किसी और को रहने नहीं देंगे। हमारे कश्मीर का ही ले लो।

[@Heyaaand]

indonesia, arab, hyderabad, iraq, ka hi haal dekhlo ,manaki forcefull coversions islam mai mana hai firbhi kuch chutiye karthe hai

[@jebilchacko6740]

One of the best analysis of the situation I have ever seen.You are among the very few journalists in India who remain neutral.Hats off Sir.❤

[@pmam4241]

Dear SG, I wait for your video everyday eagerly. I do not listen when our prime minister give sppech to the nation but I listen to you. I love your close to honesty speech and your understanding of so many issues. From an ex-muslim Bangladeshi!

[@mikasa8238]

Isn't atheism prohibited there? I saw something like that in DW documentary.

[@pmam4241]

@@mikasa8238 it is. We are minority and has to face a lot of persecution and torture

[@mikasa8238]

@@pmam4241 have you come out to your parents?

[@tejasdeepsingh456]

I am glad that he's rising above party lines to finally talk about this issue.

[@angtasp3640]

Heeey! I think Gupta is quite unbias in his opinions,not related to a party.

[@tejasdeepsingh456]

@@angtasp3640 nah he ain't

[@angtasp3640]

@@tejasdeepsingh456 🤔 mehh,just can't digest that.

[@tejasdeepsingh456]

@@angtasp3640 The only reliable source for news now-a-days are Printed Newspapers (The Indian Express & The Hindu are both Anti Establishment yet extremely good. The New Indian Express is different from Indian Express but is still really good) followed by The Tribune which is kinda mixed but still pretty good and Family Owned Newspapers like Deccan Herald fall at the last (or maybe it's a different one I may have forgotten the name)

[@angtasp3640]

@@tejasdeepsingh456 what about digital media???

[@anmol5041]

So we all agree on the fact that Shekhar Gupta sir is the best journalist in the country right now (and most unbiased too).

[@BABURAO-tt4jo]

You forgot to tell about the most important reason for crisis in Islam- ~"ISLAM".

[@adnanali-xi5sv]

oh look that's so enlightening, how come I as a Muslim never came across one 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@tenzinnorbu134]

Mashalla

[@dangerzone8570]

@jiri lol 2 billion Muslims read quran and hadiths and also practice their faith actually Islam is not in crisis its muslims who are in crisis Islam is second most followed religion and also fastest growing religion

[@aishahale5504]

@@dangerzone8570 your daughters and wives are pregnant at the same time, nice way to become the fastest-growing religion.

[@ArghyadeepPal]

Respect for SG Sir increased after this episode. This topic needed a frank discussion..

[@Sirajkhan789]

Agreed

[@surajupadhyay9322]

Again barking at wrong tree. Problems are fundamentals not fundamentalists...

[@omarjanjua3020]

yes Hinduism fundamentals are crystal clear,

[@SuperTechno2012]

@@omarjanjua3020 Yes when was the last time a Hindu beheaded someone over a religious cartoon? Please tell me?

[@omarjanjua3020]

@Dhrishtdhyumn when was the last time someone was lynched or burned for slaughtering a cow? also I do not make fun of a religion / belief system so Pisslam is disrespect, hope your fundamentals are in place

[@omarjanjua3020]

@Dhrishtdhyumn whatever but man beef burgers are the best, you should try it sometimes, also your new masters are the largest eaters of your "gai mata"

[@kevinhu4345]

This is the real wise Indian! Respect from China cn!

[@In1221kc]

Unbiased truth narrated like a family elder..Thats what I like about Mr Gupta..

[@MRINDIA-pd6rz]

Why attendance of fellow Muslim brothers in the comment section is very low....quite understandable.

[@puneet7768]

@shabir dar Way too many Hindus have been lynched too. Recently Rahul Rajput, Nikita Tomar, Ankit Saxena and many other Hindu girls. Just google Mewat, a Muslims majority place in Haryana has become a hell hole for Dalits because of Muslims! Pretty much every Muslim majority land is a fascist land!

[@Basanttailang]

You have not said that if Muslim are in majority no minority survives it is wiped out only Muslim remains.

[@marioman581]

@@ribrafi5771 they only work their they are not citizens.

[@ADARSHSINGH-iq3lu]

Corona : i am the biggest pandemic Islam : behold me lala

[@SP-oc7dm]

And you make light of the CAA. Which is not only just but necessary, to save the minorities in the Muslim majority countries around India

[@ramananvenkataraman4594]

These Lutyens mafia does not know where to hide, they are for the first time using "political islam" and "islamic terrorism".

[@welingkartr416]

@@ramananvenkataraman4594 They are scared shitless- can't even call a spade a spade. Why hide under the skirt of "political Islam"? These are the same group of journalists who have been throwing muck at the BJP and Modi for years and claim there's vendetta against them. If that were so how come you guys continue to operate? But these guys cannot dare say a word against Islam even when they know the truth..... High quality and fair journalism? The Print it seems is given to making outlandish claims.

[@JU-bz1kn]

I dont have any problem with CAA other than its implementation by BJP. We already have seen the implementation of GST, Demonetisation, Article 370 and Lockdown by this govt. All these are good policies to the ears but most horrible implementation by government. If its implemented in a good way, its OK. But if we see NRC its clearly against Islam. Actually we should not have NRC at all. instead we should improve our immigration policies to bring in the oppressed minority without pointing out religion. Mentioning religion in the Law itself is not right as per the equal dignity of religions provided in our Constitutions. I think even without NRC with the current system itself we can achieve what NRC is intending to achieve. All solutions can be achieved by sensible discussions between people in both positions. I don't know why, but any suggestion against the CAA and NRC are pointed as anti-National. I guess Govt. want to show off their anti-muslim sentiment for vote bank politics. What can one say.

[@pappupass6979]

Hard realization for all western countries. Trump had the right policies all along not granting refuge to Syrians. All of Europe and Canada accepted thousands of refugees there should be lot of nervous citizens in those countries.

[@SK-yo5nl]

We should have a law that prohibits any protest carried out in support of non-democratic and religiously established nations!

[@satyajeetsingh5383]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eaTPYZqujNOssNU

[@Morpheus2020]

Thats the dream Can only comes into reality if our political party stop appeasement of minority and value true secularism

[@howardsmith3218]

Imagine this applying to both Hindu and Muslims as well as all the religions. India doesn't have that many literates who would understand constitution and the role of blasphemy in freedom of speech

[@Morpheus2020]

@@howardsmith3218 india literacy rate in 2020 is about 80% which is equal to 850 million people , in 2019 general election 700 million voted to elect their MPs. So don't you worry about the Indian literacy. And btw at this day and age of internet when there are 700+ 4g smartphone user in India ,anyone can see a topic about anything

[@humanbeing361]

Kill the polytheists ~Quran *9:5 -And when the sacred months have passed, then kill the polytheists wherever you find them and capture them and besiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish prayer, and give zakah, let them [go] on their way. Indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.*

[@khozemasaify2281]

Brilliant analysis and eye opener.

[@hardeepsikand8463]

Why not ummah worrying for uighars ?

[@ArghyadeepPal]

Fear of Xi

[@PJ-cm8ix]

Because without xi no money only pee😂😂

[@ArghyadeepPal]

@@PJ-cm8ix Once you anger Xinnie the Jinpooh, then you are done for😂😂

[@sreekr]

The Chinese will ignore their worries and give them stuff to worry more.

[@anandkhond5474]

Xi g maar denga bhai ek ek ki.😂😂

[@PrathameshMone]

This is why Savarkar was so opposed to supporting Khilaphat movement as he was foresighted enough to understand the dangers of supporting such a movement. Because what we are supporting is allegiance to some powers outside of India.

[@vishnu4234]

Uniform Civil Code, ASAP.

[@aggressive9999]

Haan

[@aggressive9999]

@@aayushroy0609 uCC mein kya samasya hai

[@vishnu4234]

@@aayushroy0609 People willing to get country in flames, should not be part of nation. Kick them out.

[@ADARSHSINGH-iq3lu]

Though i didn't understand much english But i feel this man Is sympathizing islam.

[@adityagandhi2073]

Half truth, Still did not talk about alliance of left and pseudo-secularism with radial Islam in democracy and their hatred against genuine reform.

[@daxpatel2530]

U.K?

[@adityagandhi2073]

What U.K.

[@vivekgusain660]

Family Man, that series is superb in terms of realistic depiction and relatability.

[@pawanchauhan043]

I can't believe SG exposed Islam.....you really have guts.....You will always have my respect sir.

[@adnanchikani7374]

I want to expose it further (with ideas for change) but I don't think they'll understand. We need a "renaissance" to put it mildly.

[@pawanchauhan043]

@@adnanchikani7374 change can only happen from within and i believe good people like you (and i m sure thr must be many like u) can actually bring it.

[@pawanchauhan043]

@nidhi mimani i know that, but plz give credit where it's due.

[@ramananvenkataraman4594]

These siculars feel they have nowhere to hide and hence these "honest analysis" This is also some kind of Takhiya

[@Harigram]

Liberal Indians that Minorities should not be asked to wear their patriotism on their sleeve. Your analysis says rightly that for some, religion is more important than nationality. How to handle in such situations ?

[@skmuzammilzeeshan6173]

Good one SG.👍🏻Keep up the good work. You raised a very important question in the end which has been hovering in my mind from the beginning, i:e where were Erdogan and Imran khan or any other so called self-proclaimed protectors of Islamic ummah when thousands of Uighur Muslims are being targeted, tortured and killed in Concentraion camps of China...

[@vinamrasinghai2339]

Chinese PM called Islam is an Illness, what was the reaction nothing. Chinese also published Muhammed cartoons, what is the reaction nothing? You can only protest in a secular and liberal democracy. It is easy to fight and protest in a democracy, not in dictatorship countries.

[@rupayanb]

"Angry reactions" "protests" huh? Not terrorism ? What is this Shekhar uncle?

[@emilyganguly8150]

He loves telling the truth. But he loves his life too😂😂

[@pavankumarvakulabharanam6717]

@@emilyganguly8150 🤣🤣

[@shivamkavitkar2052]

@@emilyganguly8150 most underrated reply

[@WheelOfThought]

The idea of 1.liberation of expression 2. Emancipation of women 3. Lesser permeability with the change of time and socio-economic world 4. Democracy doesn't inherit in Islam.

[@sohailstone]

😂 as if all women are roaming safe in India, my friend we are at the cusp of being the rape capital of the world ! Do you know Modiji & RSS wants to delete the word democracy ?? I really wish BJP rule India for another 100 yrs. only then people will realize how good governance can be

[@nikhiljha5251]

@@sohailstone bro why are you bringing Modi RSS into this, criticize them all you want but don't start this what aboutism. ISLAM NEEDS A REFORM ASAP

[@sohailstone]

@@nikhiljha5251 When you saw Hathra rape case , do you say Hinduism needs reforms ? It’s not the religion , it’s the people who are at fault ✌🏼 May Allah bless you & your family and guide you at all times . Amen 🙌🏼

[@abhiramkaushik3312]

@@sohailstone do believe it or not it's always changing. Democracy is not existence in muslim majority countries with maybe one exception . That tells you alot about Islam am afraid. Don't tell India and Hindus to be. We choose to be a secular democratic Country with Hindu majority even with sizable minority. Show me a secular democratic Country with muslim majority.

[@sohailstone]

@@abhiramkaushik3312what is your definition of democracy ? Is Queen Elizabeth elected head of people ? How long had democracy been in existence , Btw I’m completely with democracy, it gives opportunity even for a taxi driver or movie stars to rule a nation. So it’s great , US fighting for black rights is sign of successful model. 😄 😂 you need to know a little more about Islam if you really want to stand for an argument. A lil bit of hear n there is not sufficient, it actually exposes your ignorance .

[@dARKf3n1Xx]

That is so fucking accurate. More Muslims should see this and learn how they are seen Globally.

[@agnishwarmukherjee1101]

This is a brilliantly put forward video. This, I feel cuts the clutter more than anything else. Thank you for clearly stating the facts as they are

[@KunalKumar-np4ig]

Not 5 reasons. Just 1. Quran. Read it. And you will know. Edit: Counter arguments are welcome, abuses are not. Thank you

[@selenophile410]

@Ashwini Desai not really bro

[@KunalKumar-np4ig]

@@selenophile410 I wouldn't use the same language as Ashwini as I don't want to offend my muslim brothers and sisters but unfortunately what he has said is true. I have read it and that book IS problematic.

[@bilalhayat1]

@Ashwini Desai have a look at ur cans, they all are filled with dirt.

[@bilalhayat1]

Did u read it ?

[@rahuljoshi5394]

quran.com/ Please read it... @I.B.

[@kedarnathshenoy5791]

It is a pity that even when they are stepping into their introspective, sunset years, some people find it difficult to be truthful to themselves. He is beating around the bush, "globalization of revenge", et al., refusing to see the elephant in the room. “The ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people but the silence over that by the good people.” - Dr Martin Luther. Probably the "good" above should be in quotes.