5 theories that I scrapped

I've had a few theories throughout my years on SSO, and some of them have been scrapped with time - so I decided to make a video showcasing them and explaining why they didn't work out. Enjoy!

[@rotteddwelling]

I- these make sense tho

[@grob391]

I think your first theory makes sense. Has anyone noticed that weird map at the midsummer festival? It shows a little bit of Northern jorvik.

[@eleanornightwalker]

I was actually pretty conflicted on whether or not to include that theory in this video, because it hasn't really proven to be wrong, either, I just couldn't prove that it was right. And when I was editing this video I got even more conflicted because I found a book in Fripps chamber that said how the Kallters worship a "queen with a heart of ice" (aka the ice witch) and I immediately thought of Katjas redesign cause she looks like a Kallter 😶

[@unattt5739]

@@eleanornightwalker this is starting to make sense nowww! she might not be the ice witch (hopefully is) but i think shes definetely related to the kallters or has something to do with them. and hopefully soon we get to know more about it and maybe get to go into the kallters village in mystic valley, considering the kallters recently left the dino valley

[@breadcult-bj2wh]

I think Nic's fridge is a pandoric keystone but in disguise

[@catdnb6204]

There is also another theory connected to the North link. It is that the 4 hatches/ fridge doors around Jorvik are perfectly connected by tunnels dug out by GED in the shape of the 5 pointed star, and that there must be a 5th door: in the Northen Mountains.

[@eleanornightwalker]

I've heard about that! I don't really think it adds up though, because the sound that plays is connected to Dark Core.. The fridge doors were actually the reason i created this channel. I've always wanted to add something more to it, like some more information about what they're for and what role they play in the story. You have no idea how many hours I've spent staring at the door and trying to figure out what that other symbol means, without figuring out anything 🙈

[@violwarden5693]

@@eleanornightwalker Another theory about the fridge door is that Mr Sands family is trapped in them (when you slow down the soundtrack you can hear crying and banging noises) which to me seems a little-far fetched. But I really can't wait to something on SSO actually admitting the doors even EXIST.

[@stepha3523]

@@violwarden5693 hello evie >:D

[@keirabravewright5173]

See you guys in five years when this pops up in your recommended, and all of these theory's have been released 🥺 I'll miss you guys 😕😖

[@lixscat9419]

my theory: the dews farm isnt abandoned, or at least not completely. if you go there, there are still chickens in the coop, water in the well, there is an axe stuck in that log behind the farm, and the pile of wood seems untouched. Almost as if someone kept on filling it and adding to it, since there's no spider webs on it, and it's not scattered all over the place, as it'd probably would be at an abandoned farm. and the house behind the farm just... looks like a normal house, no spider webs, not dirty or whatever. Neither the farm or house are falling apart. edit: the farm could be a frequently visited place since it's along the way from jarlaheim to forgotten fields or whatever. Also, behind the farm, next to the house there is a "path" from the forgotten field that u can use to go to the farm and remain unseen, its perfect if you want to enter the house and leave, without any people seeing you. its so random 💀🤚

[@tishaprnucedteasha]

SSO has said that they wanna disconnect with the old game and make sso different or something like that

[@eleanornightwalker]

yeah, they are, but it's sad though :/ I mean yeah, the new game is great, but the old ones had some really good stuff as well and I wish they could've kept it 🙈 that's me though, I grew up with those games

[@SoManyColours]

Thats sad :( I think the history gives the game a lot more character.

[@sirenserenades]

Didn't the old games have a different owner than Star Stable Online? Was the game sold for the new team to be able to make it into a MMO game?

[@eleanornightwalker]

@@sirenserenades Yeah, the old games are created by Stabenfeldt and Hidden Entertainment, but I think some of the creators went on to SSO 🤔

[@SoManyColours]

@@eleanornightwalker I really want to know if some creators went on sso. For sure some of the music these days still gets made by Sergeant Tom those are the same people who made the music for star shine legacy! So thats nice

[@vee773]

Sometimes it annoys me when people are like oh Catherines a new character and I’m like NO ITS JUSTINS MUM AHHHH

[@potion5174]

ikr

[@potion5174]

like justin is the first character you meet so that means Catherine is not new at all

[@lilyberrygames7181]

Omg I knew it was her when she was first introduced

[@adriaedwardss]

linda did grow up tho, in the photo in linda’s apartment where she is young she looks the same as old linda

[@greettat3453]

We might get new storyquests even in 4 weeks maybe, because sso spoiled about Dark riders return in instagram, and Linda also said something about ”Dark times might be coming” so we are gonna find out pretty soon if the first theory is true. 🙂

[@stqrmin]

when you're so early that youtube is still broken 5 views 9 likes

[@lilahwinterleaf2800]

anyone remember how scared you felt when you heard and saw that ice cave involved with that first one? i know i was petrified when I was little 💀💀🤣

[@fabiancsernak1763]

I think the fridge is Elisabeth. Because Elisabeth is in the Sun Circle, and we know they can make portals randomly, and travel trough them. So what if Elisabeth didn't die in the Darco fight, before she exploded, she's transfered her soul in the fridge. 🤔🤔

[@morganjames3816]

The fridge had been around in the quests years before Elizabeth died, so that would be impossible chronologically. Amazing theory, though!

[@annalisagoldweb6850]

That couldn't work, the fridge existed long before elizabeth died, tho that could be a good theory!

[@njuhna]

Really good video, i like it!

[@mariannetrure9883]

Mystic Valley's name never made sense to me as the Norwegian server is named Mystic Valley, like the exact same name. So it may just be a place holder name to not give away anything from just the name.

[@eleanornightwalker]

The server is called Misty Valley :) I'm on it

[@mariannetrure9883]

Eleanor Nightwalker Ah, I apologise, I must have read something wrong somewhere.😅

[@Helene-jl6gx]

Eleanor Nightwalker I’m on Misty Valley too🤗

[@marblepie5104]

Honestly I think that maybe, since Nick is part of the AAE and all, they sometimes give him supplies, and considering we've met a lot of people who take part in AAE then there's a good chance one of them might be Pandorian (originally I thought Ydris but really we only ever see him with Mario which is only one AAE member) which would explain the fridge :PP

[@Sakura27900]

I mean.. Now at the new event katja is also playing around with ICE, I think she's definitely who we think she is

[@linneas.m.1576]

Could you make a theory about the kallters and why they left?

[@sprite6178]

the day that eleanor changes her outfit is the day that sso lowers the price of star coins permanently

[@Talis1717]

Star stable could have integrated the original soul rider story into the new updated game, its kinda sad to see them making such big changes. I never played the starshine legacy or the winter, autumn, spring, summer rider games or the old star stable but I have watched many videos and you can feel the nostalgia of the old star stable which is lacking in the updated version.

[@Quadrobist_-_-_...-_-.-0]

It seems so crazy how major the lore of SSO is. It began as a silly series of games to books, to a larger game. The roots of lore are still such a big mystery for us to uncover. And its all just a daft horse game for female minors!

[@random_hooman8297]

I saw a comment on how Elizabeth could be in the fridge and then someone asked why, what if Elizabeth knew she was going to die but didn’t want to accept it or something like that. She could of planned ahead and gave that fridge to him and then she went inside right before she died since sun circle have made portals randomly, but then people asked why a fridge, maybe she didn’t want to be noticed and it has the same particles as Fripp yes but what if she did plan ahead wouldn’t be the first time someone looked into the future. About the future maybe she knew her time would come to come back, btw I do believe someone looked into the future before I don’t remember. (Edit: I thought about it and what if she made her soul or spirt or something go into the fridge explaining why her body pretty much froze, another thing the future seeing they can make portals what if in the past she opened a portal by mistake and saw her dying in the future this is a very outstretched theory but it makes sense and pieces together in my brain idk)

[@aliciabruder1106]

Well, The soul riders did technically grow up as SSO is supposed to take place 2 years after SSL, so some of that may be true. I’m writing a Star Stable fanfic that will try to adapt the new and old back stories of the soul riders.

[@xoderota]

I honestly think Katja being the ice witch could work. Her introduction quest in sso was called the ice princess, right?

[@xoderota]

I can't edit the comment for whatever reason but I honestly really like the theory that the soulriders changed because they grew up, but I know it's not the case because they now have different backstories. But I can still think that, right?

[@shadoelixir]

Well I'm glad I know Catherine is a fridge 🤣

[@oliver5900]

Although I mostly know of the lore from sso, and not star academy and that, I kinda like to think that they are like parallel universes. Idk if it makes any difference or sense to anyone but me, but if they change the backstory for the newer soul riders, but they are still kind of the same, I like the idea and it makes the content and stuff from star academy feel less like it is just thrown away, and just in a parallel universe about the same characters and story with some differences. Idk of this made any kind of sense as I did not write it very understandable and just wanted to get it out there lol. Probably said the same thing like three times as well

[@nova3842]

The fridge theory was probably true someone is probably in there remember when the fridge ran?

[@zoesalthope9880]

Who laughed when she said Catherine in nic Stoneground’s fridge? 😂

[@cloudsistergaming]

Sorry for commenting an old video but I have a small thought about theory number 2: Katja is practically an ice witch but I don't think she is the ice witch from icendell. Nic Stoneground says the ice witch hasn't always been evil, and I don't think that holds true for Katja. She's not even from Jorvik, but gets there trough a portal in the early main quests. 🤍

[@eleanornightwalker]

I made an update to this theory, I un-scrapped it 😁

[@IcarusFluffle]

I didn't grow up with the older games, mainly beacuse I'm from Mexico and something from Sweden would not make it here, but I'm glad they changed the characters, they feel more human, they are actually builing their connections and relationships making them feel alive and not just NPC's with too much power (Tho I don't see how Lisa's backstory makes sense with her being such a country girl when she was in a rock band but what ever,) Tecnically, your theory about them growing up is true, there's a two year gap between Starshine Legacy/the Jorvik Calling books and Star Stable Online

[@zivabobnar1468]

I have a theory! Do you remember when you talked about codes and that maybe our beginner horses will die? Well maybe they will and the rune rider (I don’t know how to spell it) will simply be a substitute and we will ride it on. What do you say makes sense? (I used a google translator so there may be some errors inside)

[@eleanornightwalker]

I believe it was SSO Theory Time who talked about those codes 😅😅 my initial thought about those codes is that they don't have anything to do with future content, but rather that they're codes for when you take a dangerous fall, or when your horse's lifebar runs out (hence "dies"). I really like the idea of the Rune Runner being a substitute for our starter though, and I hope that the horse is going to be equally important

[@zivabobnar1468]

@@eleanornightwalker I went a little deeper. Maybe Rune Runner is free because the SSO didn’t want us to be sad about losing the Starer horse. Also, every Soul Rider has a special horse that has a similar body (strong body with shorter legs and special colors) not like Jorvik Warmblood. In the older version, however, they are even more similar. Linda also said “Dark times might be coming” and this will be possible when our Starter horse is killed. Something more about dreams at a summer festival. If you collect seven flowers playing cut scenes we can see how the horse saves us from the GED. Maybe it foretells the future. I hope I don’t bother you too much with this theory.

[@SnappyAdds]

Her videos are so underrated tbh

[@yeahshush1]

The Miscreants are actually a band called Browsing Collection! Go check them out

[@eleanornightwalker]

I thought they were based on a band called The Misfits? 0.0

[@yeahshush1]

Eleanor Nightwalker They are! But the band irl is one called Browsing Collection

[@williamloel]

I don’t know if The Miscreants are supposed to represent the ones who are singing in real life, or is going to be other characters in game. All I can say now is that Browsing Collection is the real life Miscreants.

[@angelandpippa9556]

Early squad Like the theory

[@naomieastpeak6760]

Them Eleanor you gave me inspiration to make a video on my channel about the fridge what if it is a portal to pandoria

[@georgemosdell2051]

I think the theory about Katja being the ice witch makes a little bit of sense. You mentioned her new outfit, which supposedly is related to the Kalters, there is evidence of this theory, as the symbol on Katja's new outfit is the same one that is on the Icengate? This also relates to Katja being related to the Kalters. You also pointed out that we already have witches in the game, and with this you showed a picture of the witch Pi. However with this information comes an argument. The witch Pi was originally a beautiful women, the wife to Mr. Claus in Cape West, located in Goldenhills Valley. When you first unlocked Golden, there was a quest where Mr. Claus told you about Pi, and how she was related to dark core. Since Pi got turned into a witch, she should know how to turn others into, or cure them, of being a witch? Maybe Katja didn't like being the Ice witch, and perhaps this is why she chose to be a dark rider? Maybe Pi turned Katja into a dark rider, and cured her of being the ice witch? This makes a little bit of sense.. doesn't it? Is it a coincidence that the supposed 'Ice witch portal' is identical to the portal dark core used whilst summoning Katja? Since Katja came from a mysterious place, did she come from the 'Ice witch portal'? Please let me know your thoughts!

[@eleanornightwalker]

I've already re-considered this theory... stay tuned 😉

[@spacebar1624]

Can you do a video on the Crater of Jor? I’d really like to know more about it!

[@shannonlaffin6335]

Hey I think every signal of those theories are unique but I can't put my finger on them all I wish there was a way for us to find out once and for all I seen Katja art work it is classic I don't get is why is Katja wearing? Can you do a theroy on Katja's clothes it doesn't make sense to me but the clothes Katja wearing in the picture is very realistic but what is she supposed to be native American? 🤔 I'm confused but exciting this is a very big twist can someone do a theroy video please?

[@eleanornightwalker]

I have mentioned it before how she looks similar to the Kallters, but I haven't gone too much into detail about it. I don't really have a fleshed out theory about it, but because of her clothes alone I have a feeling that she is connected to the Kallters. It's really hard to tell though, because we know so little about the new her. Like, what is that violin for?

[@shannonlaffin6335]

Good point I wish I can learn more about Katja

[@claracatlight]

Katjas new outfits, like some of the kalters. The ice witch are in Dinovalley. The kalters are in the Dinovalley...

[@maplemarblez]

It also makes no sense that in the middle of jorvik there is an abandoned snowy mountains lol

[@sprite6178]

finally a youtuber thats not like "horse die"

[@dinkyrat11]

Star Stable: Shoot she is onto us-

[@NoName-ml5rm]

About The katja icewitch thing they did say something about it at the rainbow festival soooooo...?

[@ania1825]

I think that the Nic's fridge is one of fridge doors ( that from north part)

[@silkyahc]

Actually Eleanor, Katja could be the ice witch. Besides, it could just be a nickname for Katja, and not her actual name abviously. Also, they could have named her a witch, just because she has magicl abilities.

[@haydenhawkhand5503]

OMG I LOVE YOU

[@sp4rr0w-quitting99]

#2 In the Star Stable books, Katja is ‘death’. This is why she dresses in white, because she is the opposite of life. See what I’m getting at? About her looking like one of the ice people.......I think that since Dino Valley has barely any life, she could’ve have some origins from there? Ily 😘

[@experiment626eventing]

What if the fridge is a power source for the icendale portals thingy and nic is the one who "created" it or "owns" it Ik this theory sucks

[@lapizblxu4066]

For the Miscreants: What if they were failed soul riders who would have taken our place if we hadn’t come to Jorvik? We can buy their masks from a shop, but we can’t buy other cannon items. I don’t exactly have proof of this but I feel like it’s a cool concept 🤷‍♀️

[@anyasharma813]

I luv u!!!

[@bleh.5258]

Yay! First!

[@user-jy2gr4cr4n]

actually the katja one kind of makes sense 👀 i mean yeah it's completely random but---

[@eleanornightwalker]

Oh yeah, I un-scrapped it 😅 there's a whole seperate video on that one

[@user-jy2gr4cr4n]

@@eleanornightwalker just watched it :) really good! honestly I could never think up those theories 😮

[@Jillian.luella]

I hate how they changed Lisa to be this western girl, she used to be punk and now they changed her 😔

[@00gmaja00]

i checked the fridge and it was empty

[@enyawijkakerman8942]

i really like the new soul riders but i liked lisa more when she was a punk girl and not a cowgirl, but i still think she listens to the miiscreants.....

[@aerdraiochta]

It is so funny how you pronounce katja 😂

[@eleanornightwalker]

Yeah :P I know how to pronounce it but got confused with the english context 🙈

[@moeroethler6633]

If you go to the "explire jorvik" page, the closed areas are kinda grayed out, but above valedale, theres an opening and mountains, but i thought the druid training paddock is more to the left. Is it Dino Valley? If it was, then why does it look green and theres no water or dinosuar drawing on the map?

[@BananasSuck]

I still find the updated soulriders real

[@claudiolarrosasm]

When they released the rescuing frip I think that is not a theory anymore

[@lucysummerhall4969]

What if the fridge Nic is always holding has something to do with those fridges in the ground?

[@n0zusaki]

Oh my god what if nicks fridge is the one that is missing from the fridgedoor theory?!?? Ik it doesnt evne have the same symbols on it but what is inside it?? Idk just a random thought lol.

[@Thenris1297]

I think "Sands Manor" will be the castle in Golden Hills. What do you think?

[@eleanornightwalker]

Hmm, it could be 🤔 although it's originally located in Pine Hill (which is further north), they do make a lot of changes nowadays. The road sign says Marchenghast Castle though 🤷‍♀️

[@Thenris1297]

@@eleanornightwalker yes I saw the road sign yesterday! 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@potion5174]

wait... that black girl on Lisa's band is shown in Fort Pinta...

[@abbiejongbaker4368]

wich programm do you use to record your sso? :)

[@eleanornightwalker]

I use the game bar that comes with windows 10 :)

[@abbiejongbaker4368]

@@eleanornightwalker Thank you

[@mrs.sweetbow5573]

First yeay

[@arabellaovari1715]

Step 1: Turn the subtatle on. Step to: Read it at 1:08 ,,Ketchup"🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@aaaaze]

That one dislike:

[@somebody4269]

i think thatthe soul riders LOCK better now

[@johanwillman8595]

Hi could you read the soul rider books?

[@eleanornightwalker]

I don't think so, reading a whole book aloud would be really hard :P also only the first one is out in english yet.. I could probably read them in swedish (I'm norwegian) but I'd rather wait in case I don't understand it that well 🙈

[@zo9612]

I got one complicated theory, but I don’t know if you want to hear it...

[@eleanornightwalker]

Go ahead, I love hearing other people's theories 😁😁

[@zo9612]

Okay, once I wrote a letter to SSO support why we don’t have the... umm prison island? I don’t know how to call that in English. And they say that we weren’t on this, but only in pandora. And I thought that’s impossible, because everything said that Anne is on this island. Than I found a weird, small island in Pandoria with PORTAL. So I think that Anne will be kidnapped again, or Anne Von Blyssen is still in Pandoria. Sorry for my English, but I’m from Poland so it’s hard to explain 🌸

[@lorettaahmed4384]

Oof

[@liaavv_4959]

1:34 where do you find this stuff?

[@eleanornightwalker]

I found that particular image on google, but I remember SSO posting it somewhere back in the day in 2018/2019. I think they may have removed it

[@dancingintherain6675]

I think one of the game masters posted it on instagram :)

[@fabiancsernak1763]

It was in the 2019 Christmas calendar.

[@ning_dungie]

No hate, but what kinda name is kAtChA

[@Frentoags]

Are you danish and have a TikTok account?

[@eleanornightwalker]

No and no I'm norwegian 😊😊

[@Frentoags]

Ok, cool! Your voice just sounded familiar to a tiktoker that i follow🙂

[@emilycoldlock9438]

She literally butchered Rhiannon’s and my name. Im not mad im just joking around

[@masajovanovic7120]

I'm so sorry if this sounds annoying but Katja is pronounced Katia or Katya and this just makes me cringe I'm so sorry

[@eleanornightwalker]

I know how it's pronounced in Swedish (I'm norwegian and we pronounce it the same), but I feel like it doesn't sound right when said in English xD Even when I try to say it the right way, it sounds so strange in an English context that I've just converted it 🙈 Edit: I try pronouncing it like cat-ya, but when I say it fast it just becomes catch-a

[@Jdudj373y]

It's actually cut-ya but well