A DIFFERENT EYESHADOW FORMULA?? | Menagerie Sugar High Palette | First Impressions & Comparisons

[@leahmiranda8359]

Love the baby babbles ❣️ Love the look! I'd love to see another look using the green if you have time... 💚 Thank you Katie...

[@KatieMarie]

I know, I was ITCHING to use that green too 🤪

[@biogirl1381]

i loveeee the look you created and i hope to see more looks. this sold out on me as it always does so i signed up for notifications because there’s just something special about this one. 🐴

[@KatieMarie]

Oh bummer, sorry you missed it! But it’s definitely unique and worth picking up on a restock!

[@biogirl1381]

@@KatieMarie yesssss!!! i agree. 💚

[@scotzmnswife]

I think this look you created is gorgeous, & I wouldn’t mind seeing a multiple looks video with this very unique colorstory with the varying shimmer finishes. The comparison swatches with earlier palettes really show the improvement in their shimmer formula for sure! They appear much more vibrant & sparkly &/or foiled-looking. 🤩👍✨💖💖💖✨🐴✨

[@KatieMarie]

Thank you for the feedback! Yes, the shimmers have come such a long way and I’ve really been enjoying the ones from this palette!

[@bethbowling4817]

I would love a video with more looks with this palette!!! I haven't received mine yet 😊

[@KatieMarie]

Thank you for letting me know…I think I’ll start recording them, then! ☺️

[@LorraineParis1]

I love how a eyeshadow look comes together after liner lashes and fountain! It grounds it. Came out awesome!!💜🌈💜

[@KatieMarie]

Yes, agreed!

[@claudiajimenez661]

I love the look you created. I might have to buy this palette. It’s cute. 😍

[@journaldunefemmemoderne]

Hi Katie, of course you can do 3,4,5 looks ONE palette lol This eyelook is very unique, like it! xoxo from Belgium! Steph

[@KatieMarie]

Lol thank you - I’m going to start recording my looks and see if I can squeeze in a multiple looks video sometime next month ☺️

[@chrissymoss514]

If you possibly can, I'd love to see some other looks from this palette - it's so flipping good 👍 . Also, there's a green in there that needs to be used 😉😂 Who could "mind" Levy (Levi 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️) playing on the floor? His little baby sounds really made my day 😊😊 Oh yes ....... This look is awesome 😍 Love and light to you and your family 💗💗💫💗💗💫💗💗💫💗💗

[@KatieMarie]

I know, I was kinda sad not to use the green in the first look…But I’ll for sure feature it if I do a multiple looks video!

[@gillypiexo]

dude im Right there with you! More looks!

[@keishastroud9212]

Such a fun unique look! This colorstory for sure was something new for menagerie... loved the helpful tips

[@gillypiexo]

WOW KATIE!!! This look in the intro is So Freakin Amazing!!! daaaaaang 🔥 I would never know how to pair this with any color clothing (why my wardrobe is 90% black) so special props to You 👏 you look so summer-y & fun ♥ 😀

[@melodyrecchione]

I bought mine right at launch and it still hasn't shipped! But that's ok, I can be patient lol. This is my first purchase from the brand and I am excited! I love the look you created! It's unique in a good way. 🐴

[@rosiel2774]

I just got my shipping notification today.

[@KatieMarie]

I hope it ships soon - I was honestly surprised to get the palette so soon, since they said up to 3 weeks to ship. But these palettes are worth the wait 😍☺️

[@krystina8412]

same... i was thinking everybody online that got theirs must be on PR or something. i think i ordered mine like 5-10 minutes into launch & mine hasn't even shipped. I've bought lots from menagerie & i have all their palettes. i just wonder what their shipping process looks like, so i can better understand.

[@KatieMarie]

@@krystina8412 I purchased this palette as a customer, I’m not on menageries PR list ☺️

[@krystina8412]

@@KatieMarie yeah, I heard you mention that in the video! I appreciate you being transparent about that, although regardless, I know you'd give us an honest review! I'm trying to be patient over here (about my palette).., but struggling a bit, lol.

[@glamwithkimbeauty]

Mine still hasn't shipped but it's OK I had a few things in my order. Please deff do note looks with this palette ❤️

[@KatieMarie]

Thank you for the feedback! I’ve recorded a few looks already ☺️

[@LorraineParis1]

Love you child’s sounds in background. You crack me up saying the Joey shade. My son is Joey my husband Joseph and his father Joseph. We have many shades of Joey here.💜🌈💜🤗😂

[@KatieMarie]

Oh that’s so fun!

[@TheFolkyboy]

I’m still waiting for mine to get out to me, but I also ordered the Ultichrome shadows she launched with this collection, too. I could kick myself for not getting the new blush she dropped but I have so many shimmery blushes that I’m fine with missing out (for now). Thank you for your extensive review! I think initially the colors looked crazy when you first applied them, but once they warmed up to your skin I loved. Would appreciate anymore inspiration you could offer with this!

[@KatieMarie]

Sorry you’re still waiting, but I think they said the processing time is up to 3 weeks - I think I got on the website within a minute of the launch, lol, so maybe that’s why my order arrived so quickly.

[@TheFolkyboy]

@@KatieMarie I ordered at the beginning of the launch from my wishlist, too. I think because I picked up quite a bit they’re still getting it together. I am patient. I only get annoyed when it’s months out.

[@celestecelestial90]

What size are the pans? Are they like those large 36 mm? Are the mattes that sheer to buildable formula? I used the pastel pup palette today and love the look I created with it. Sorry if you already addressed those questions. I was doing my makeup while watching the video so I may have missed something. 🙂

[@KatieMarie]

I believe there is 18 grams of product total in the palette - whereas the square-pan palettes were 24 grams total. So it is a bit smaller. The flight club is also circular pans and only 18 grams of product total. I wouldn’t call these mattes sheer, but they’re nicely pigmented and buildable, if that makes sense. I’ve only used the palette twice currently but both times I was surprised/pleased at how easy the mattes were to work with - they aren’t like the older formula that you had to be SO CAREFUL when dipping in to only touch the pan. They are still very pigmented when I’m using it on my eyes, but I don’t have to worry about picking up too much and getting too much product on my eyelid to blend out. Hope that makes sense.

[@celestecelestial90]

@@KatieMarie thanks for the information and honesty. I’m still on the fence about it, but I’ll consider and see if I have dupes. 🙂

[@paulas2218]

I’d like to see the lightest shades in the palette-more pastel looks. But I don’t think that’s your thing. I’m hoping it comes back on the market, and I’m loving the pastels for spring.

[@KatieMarie]

I did a more pastel look with this palette this morning - if you have IG you can see the look in my stories. But I would also recommend that you check out Amy Loves Makeup on YT - she does a lot of softer/lighter looks in general with palettes and she just recently posted a video on the palette ☺️

[@Superfreaky1RU]

I haven't decided whether to get tnis or not. I know they're different, but the shimmers from this and Annetes palette are fairly close and I'm not using that one as much as I thought I would. I'm not really an orange or yellow wearer for most looks so that's 4 shades I may not use. But I love the rest of the shadows, especially the matte colors in it. I'm torn. Loved your look though. Definitely a tick in the pro buy category!

[@KatieMarie]

There are definitely pros and cons to this palette that I’m finding as I use it - it’s actually a lot easier to get pastel blues/purple/pink looks from it than I had anticipated, so that’s been a surprise. I hope to do a multiple looks video with jt soon and share some more thoughts on it. Maybe in another week or two ☺️

[@CINDYMDEMAMBRO]

Such small pans for such a high price but still pretty.

[@KatieMarie]

They are a bit smaller than menageries square pans in the past - I believe the old square pan palettes held a total of 24 grams of product and these new round pans hold 18 grams total

[@chrissymoss514]

Yay, I'm 1st 💃💃🤪🤪💃💃

[@KatieMarie]

Thank you so much Chrissy! So fast! ☺️☺️

[@thesoulfulbunny6067]

😍🐴

[@KatieMarie]

💚💚

[@cjaneg97]

🐴

[@KatieMarie]

💚💚💚

[@DeMinimusMs]

🐴

[@KatieMarie]

💚💚💚