A gruesome crime at a Kolkata hospital | Faye D'Souza

[@PraveenUpadhyay-u4o]

Thanks a lot for understanding our plights . Need more focus and attention on working conditions of doctors

[@NatashaSingh-xz3qs]

Unimaginable, how much pain and trauma she must have gone through. She deserves justice at all costs.

[@akshay_persona]

Victim parents recorded a statement to CBI! HER colleagues who themselves are doctors are involved in this heinous crime! Now the question is: whom to trust nowadays!

[@ami4764]

She did not deserve what happend to her at all! In fact women should be protected at all costs! The public and private sector of any institution needs to provide adequate security for all staff and all patients in any medical facility! I pray she gets justice! To her family may they also heal with time. Lots of love to them from South Africa 💜💜💜💜

[@Black149coffee]

The work hours we have as interns and residents are insanely inhumane. I have had 72 hours shifts without sleep, food and shower. When we demand a free hour at least to go home and eat something, the professors joke that we are called residents because the hospital is our residence. And this is a job where there is no room for error. At all. We don’t have the privilege to make a mistake in treating a patient and then say that we were sleep deprived and hungry for 3 days. We have to be as attentive and perfect on the night of day 3 as we were on the morning of day 1. And then comes the thanklessness. As if we are the ones being negligent. After more than 8 years of slogging our guts in rooms without fans in a hot weather, being on our feet all day long, never having a proper meal for days and just surviving on coffee and biscuits at times, and barely catching short Naps on broken govt hospital benches with nails jutting out, when we are attacked and assaulted and not respected at all, it just seems worthless. The patient load in govt colleges is ridiculous. No wonder we have to work long shifts because the work never seems to end. And the only solution is an increase in the number of seats and colleges and thereby doctors. The patient load is never going to reduce. We badly need more hands working. And with this kind of nonsense on top of all this, there will be a time when no one will want to become a doctor in this country. Either they’ll switch professions, or the country altogether.

[@vikramaditya47_]

Utmost respect for doctors. All your demands should be met.

[@supritiphani1282]

I really empathize with this

[@angielobo56]

You have given the correct picture of the situation. They forget that we are humans and need to replenish ourselves to serve with dedication, accountability, c precision, compassion and love to deliver quality care. When we are deprived of basic requirements of food and rest, how can a human function. We are still the stone Age in spite of all development everywhere. The our elected leaders are keeping themselves busy in doing research on how to amass wealth in the quickest time to sustain their next 100 generations, we will be always ignored. It's time for our people to rise up and stop the atrocities to humanity and more importantly to those who sacrifice their lives to serve others. God bless our land and our people for a better future for our children. 🙏

[@khaalis]

Senior doctors ridiculing our demands just shows how bad it is for us. It really seems worthless

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

Totally understand and believe you! I remember the resident in PGI who used to get us a frozen sample.While we worked on it and turned around to get more details on the patient, he would be snoring!!! Such sleep deprivation is not healthy at all!

[@dudette317]

She toiled so hard only to meet a brutal end. Policy makers should do better, safety should be ensured to doctors. The victim was on a 36 HOUR SHIFT, after so much dedication, what did she get in return? It is high time society raises voice for us doctors. Enough is enough.

[@maureensamson4863]

Thank you ! Yours is about the only news channel that hasn't discussed the details of the gruesome crime ... I wouldn't wish for any woman to face that humiliation , dead or alive ! Besides , all these sadistic perverts out there are enjoying themselves and could do the same to another victim . Working conditions are appalling for many humans from all strata of society... thanks for highlighting the plight of these doctors 😢😢

[@deepa466]

Instead of opening more AIIMS and medical colleges , Modi government has to concentrate on uplifting existing colleges and hospitals

[@bridiptabharali3433]

Yeah !then the state government should dissolve it's self and submit itself to center

[@Nathan-ql2wh]

The unavailability of room facilities is the main reason. A room with doors locked is much safer. Staying in a large seminar hall is not safe for anyone.

[@notflash11]

Somehow she found a way to neglect the atrocities of Mamta government in the investigation. Leaving politics aside, the doctors workload, safety and facilities should be seriously considered and addressed immediately

[@pizzac5931]

Biased journalist. Media is terrible. Even independent journalists will align to their political ideologies no matter how inhuman the crime is. Horrible behavior. She didn't say anything about Kolkata police forcing the girl's parents to burn the body within a day or two, hiding evidence, and the state govt allowing the hospital administration to carry out renovation in order to tamper with evidence. Even worse, the principal of RG Kar resigned and was appointed as the Principle of Calcutta National Medical College within 4 hours by the state government. Will she talk about this? No. Because it doesn't align with her political ideologies.

[@notflash11]

@@pizzac5931 That's the sad state of media today. They are woke only when it comes to BJP related issues

[@muditjain8784]

Useless governments both at the centre and the states

[@VyVoise]

Appreciate the work you are doing Faye! Very rightly pointed, this is not just an issue of resident doctors’ safety. On a grand scale, this is our collective failure in keeping services and people safe and equipped for nobody else but ourselves.

[@mainaksarkar6392]

Thanks. The "details" you did not go into clearly show it could NOT be perpetrated by one single person. And that side opens other heinous aspect which also is equally liable for these conditions. Another episode in this aspect please!

[@HKS286]

CM is busy protecting Sanjay Ghosh...

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

Plus working hours shd be logged in as in the USA. In fact if an overworked resident feels he cannot keep awake , he gets a cab to take him home for his safety. Doctors really need better working conditions in India. Go to any Govt hospital and see what it is like. They do night duties in deaddiction wards too! This doc was a life saver! And our laxity made us lose her. Vvv sad and numbing. There shd b a police station INSIDE ALL Govt hospitals

[@altafarsiwala9122]

It will take a minister's child to undergo this brutal trauma for the law to be implemented

[@91096]

Amazingly explained ♥️🙌🙌

[@kiara7749]

Very truly said, my daughter is also a dr and she tells me the pathetic condition they are all working and so much pressure,as u said not given proper breaks. This is really too much we must all fight as one. Otherwise why are v paying taxes from our hard earned money😮

[@vandanaraoyalamanchi9813]

We are paying taxes for Statues of Unity and Statues of Equality, and tourism, didn't you know? Misery ranks lower than enjoyment for this government.

[@MRC647]

There is no adequate safety or dedicated restrooms for doctors on emergency duties. I still remember directly drunk relatives of patients banging on doors of the big lab at odd hours asking for reports which they were not supposed to do and we used to sit inside locking the doors for our safety , processing samples in midnight. Used to be very stressful and scary. Corruption in government hospital is so common and male gaze of authorities is real. If you can't feel safe in your own working environment, what's the point

[@vandanaraoyalamanchi9813]

I feel for you. Hugs.

[@ralmeida522]

Will like to mention that the doctors in government & private practice in the State of Goa have joined the protest. Saturday all doctors went on Strike in solidarity to the movement for save working conditions & punishment for the accused

[@vilhenadsouza1788]

This is the fate of many women in our country, India. Fear and anxiety of every mother. Lord protect every girl child.

[@seemagayadin5199]

This is insane!!!!! Justice, justice, justice....

[@agnelocarvalho6417]

First of all stop 36 hours duty of doctor and nurses in india. No where in the world thre is 36 hours.

[@challenger539]

Whatever is worse is that the Police initially called it a suicide without any investigations!! The corpse was cremated as early as possible to hide evidence perhaps. The Principal blamed the victim shamelessly and now forced to resign but immediately got into another Med college - NMC(due to his close political connections with ruling TMC party) where the students made a grand welcome with shoes😂 It is perhaps due to this, that the state is trying to protect him. All the real culprits must be punished including the principal. The police commissioner shall be tried to the court of law on why he said it a suicide!!! Destruction of evidence is also a crime. Even Mamata Banerjee must be answerable as the health & family planning minister.

[@happinessgyms]

EVERY GIRL IN INDIA DESERVE SAFETY AND FREEDOM

[@mainaksarkar6392]

At least in one hospital I have seen that they are entitled for one day weekly off plus 19 days yearly leave according to their appointment letter.. But never nowhere they get any, repeat, any leave or off. There is no getting away from the fact that some kind of ragging mentality of the seniors is very much present in most of the places beside all the truths stated and commented.

[@AshishChauhan-bd5lv]

Junior doctors and residents are not managed well anywhere in India…. It’s all because management hires a senior consultant who speaks the language of administration and keeps treating junior doctors like clerks …. Look at their salaries …. Best is medical Council too doesn’t do anything …. Central and state both government give deaf ear , rather the doctors and hospitals in India are the soft targets … One of the Noblest of profession is going to the dogs and hello it’s in every corner of India… Kafeel Khan in UP was targeted for being a good doctor… We Doctors lack unity … Politicians and Society only believes in blaming and trying to establish alternative medicine which will have dire consequences May God bless the departed soul and give strength to the family to accept the same

[@vandanaraoyalamanchi9813]

About time they passed rules to prevent seniors taking up other jobs elsewhere, leaving juniors to grapple with the workload.

[@supritiphani1282]

If all the videos I saw on this you have conveyed the message well

[@nanda9536]

How can we have better health care when our priorities are wrong?

[@CajjieP4Peace]

Faye I appreciate the spirit of your journalism. Almost every youtuber and media org have posted titles such as 'sensational, horrific details revealed avout the rape" asif people should know all that. Terrible terrible media focus only to get more likes. I appreciate you for keeping the title just.'

[@abhijitguha494]

Everyone in the country deserves safety in whatever profession they are or even not working. Not only doctors. Every citizen deserves that.

[@abhijitguha494]

This heinous crime is being protested nationwide because the victim is a doctor. These crimes are being committed everyday on ordinary defenceless women across the nation. But no media space is ever given to these victims. This incident also tells us that media/civil society gets involved when a person who belongs to "us" is attacked. When it happens to "them" we just go about in our lives. We don't care.

[@shireensaira2395]

Very true

[@lorettarebelo5395]

Well spoken, heartwrenching story

[@mavispillay5976]

My sympathies to the family of the deceased.i prayer to God to give the family strength and comfort..😢😢.😢. It's sad to say that she was saving lives whilst these monsters are talking lives...I'm glad that the country is standing together to bring justice.... 🙏🙏🙏

[@ajayakumarkumar9082]

Ofcourse it's a fight for all of us.Hope you raise this kind of issues again?Or else who will raise this?

[@dr.rupshikhadutta2873]

U r absolutely correct 💯

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

There shd be a high security duty room for individual docs doing night duties. These residents in Govt hospitals are serving the country and its citizens in v poor working environment and conditions. It’s sad that senior docs do not insist and project their apathy!

[@heartofbuddha63]

Mamata Banerjee should resign.

[@asiskumardatta1859]

CM Mamta Banerjee should immediately resign .

[@KJ-db7pt]

Don't they have some sort of security guards sad to learn of crime in a hospital area

[@Geekchicc]

Forget about security guards we don't have lights, CCTV a lock on the door and sometimes not even the doctors room is available. There is no bed most of the time for us to rest after 30-36 hours of continuous duty.

[@elviesmascarenhas6059]

Trainees should get better facilities

[@pallavishirodker3990]

Why only in India interns are working 36hours this should change this physical and mental torture

[@nitishdas9991]

Dear Faye, please watch your personal BMI and get into tje correction mode on a war footing. I'll pray fot You. Thanks for this wise and accurate report. Best wishes !

[@deepalakshmi8401]

Every women needs safety

[@cbfenwick4211]

Well said

[@paranoah8550]

I understand the doctor's protests and of course they should have more safety. However, she wasn't attacked because she was a doctor, she was attacked because she was a woman. And we don't need to shy away from talking about women's safety. It effects half the people of this country directly and women are sick of living in fear of being assaulted and always being on guard

[@opsharma8458]

Shame on such cases. Women are unsure of their safety in India. No law, no security, no legality. No पुलिस, all agencies untrust worthy.

[@homely6616]

Madam. Please fight for the issue

[@JamesKumar-n4e]

Perhaps MCI in consultation with various govt and non govt agencies sets the standards for no. Of work hours, secure space for rest, surveillance , periodic inspection walks by seniors staff , this is serious if we need to come world quality standards in all facets of health care.

[@JamesKumar-n4e]

0:10 Is capital punishment way forward without appeal the solution and deterrent, as Nirbhaya and the 40 + year old case of 1980s of brutalising of Aruna Shanbag, that left her inanimate dead. She was cared so well by her colleagues though she was brain dead. Capital punishment with a large bench on fast track, without further appeals may become life beacons of hope for helpless hardworking staff, doctors and perhaps ensure safety as the deterrent is death within time specified by judiciary and Govt. 0:10

[@Pjrdjf]

This is not about doctors getting raped. It's s systemic problem of our society. Towards how it views and treats women. There are countless incidences in the recent past when sexual offenders were protected by the police and the government because of their political affiliation. Unless this is addressed, these incidents will keep happening. Selective outrage will not help here.

[@JeffsonNathan]

BJP is not expected to be helpful, but they may hound TMCs failures in this case. Hope this case increases the security for all female doctors in hospitals nationwide

[@starlitnews]

In the United States and other European countries, medical students have a breathing space for relaxation. This is in stark contrast to India, where medical students are worked to the point of exhaustion. In India, medical students are worked to the point of exhaustion.

[@halle0]

Excuse me.. this ain't problem of doctors alone..but every woman. Right? This ain't problem of just women in India but also men..real men who care about women in their families. Stop making it a doctor problem solely confining it to the women's profession. Ohh ok.. I understood.. a women maybe who's housewife, or fieldworker or less paid wage would be cared less for her soul and for her poor life,?! Gotcha

[@abrahamphilip6439]

Find out the reason why he assulted her, he who has been working in the hospital ,

[@baljitsandhu5995]

So sad 😭 for that 🙏💐 wehaguru mehar karan 🙏 wehaguru wehaguru wehaguru wehaguru wehaguru wehaguru ji 🙏😢😢😢😢😢

[@mad0987able]

It is also important to stop this constant hospital hopping by senior doctors . Many senior government doctors do private visits and surgeries in private hospitals during duty hours. When the patient family gets angry due to their absence ( because junior doctors often don't have patient related decision making authority), they attack the junior doctors present there instead of the senior doctors who are busy making money elsewhere..

[@haroldhart5702]

Faye, why is it that rape is on the rise in our country? Don't these men have mothers, sisters, aunties etc. Is there no respect and honour for women? Do they think that they can commit such a crime and get away with it ? As someone said, the heart of the problem is the problem of the heart.

[@yashagar4443]

Terrible

[@radiomed1097]

Only maa durga can save bengal

[@rahil5989]

No it's foolish to rely on god, if that would have been possible, no women would have been raped and subsequently killed in this country, where goddess are worshipped in the form of durga and kali.

[@masudurrohoman7617]

❤

[@zahidaParveen-m5p]

😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@EffieDavid-k6y]

Dear Mrs Faye pls tell us y did S.Roy cimmitted this crime on our innocent young Dr. Of 31years who was diligently doing her duties serving our people as doctor. Pls reply dear

[@renatefernandes9486]

👍

[@seshadriiyer3737]

All political people get bail so also in this case

[@nidhi5635j]

And sadly we all know how much budget was allocated to HEALTH this time. These were the very people doing duties day in & day out during the pandemic risking their own lives..but who cares, the public also has a short term memory as well as the governments. Shameful

[@mathewmonteiro8100]

There is no Word has rape as per The Hindu culture,so it's clear there will b no severe punishment

[@seshadriiyer3737]

Why modiji and shah not dismiss the mamta government why India alliance is silent

[@greywinter3870]

Men were supposed to protect women!!!!! But their fragile ego and heinous desires jisko pura karne ke liye apni insaaniyat bhi bhul jaate hain

[@apurbabiswas7790]

What about the conduct of TMC after the incident? Why are you not highlighting it in your video?

[@gopalsanyal6277]

Mamata better resign.

[@vandanaraoyalamanchi9813]

Dear Faye, I appreciate your efforts to balance truth with wrath of erring governments, while simultaneously invoking our conscience on something that happened to somebody else's child. Difficult task. But merely accepting that it is wrong, and using scathing words doesn't solve the issue. There is a large population, and there are many issues. This makes it easy to shift to the next issue, and this one goes into back burner. Dear girl, if you can ask for suggestions, we can all come up with some. I agree that some of our suggestions will not meet your approval, and often seem midieval. Nevertheless, if the majority agrees to it, we may have to adopt it and can twist the arms of government, even after elections. Perhaps it can be fine tuned by others. As things stand, governments seem short of workable solutions. Some can be tried, and if successful, made permanent. If not, discard the section. Haven't we changed something like 498A before attending to Juvenile crimes? Please come up with a video calling for suggestions to stop such crimes. Who knows we might hit the bull's eye.

[@mad0987able]

As you rightly ask, "where is the money going". Well at present, i think all the money is going into buying votes from vote banks and maintaining them. By EVERY party trying to stay in power.. during the Loksabha 2024 elections, in west Bengal alone, one could see both potholes and election postest at every 10 mtrs. Where does all that marketing budget come from??

[@Priya-ks8ut]

BJP is silent now. Modi busy touring 😂

[@mariapinheiropinheiro3443]

M

[@zahabiyajumboo922]

Faye,don't you think this gruesome rape and murder is politically motivated?

[@SultanaAnsari-w1l]

Aap India rahti hai thoda Hindi bhi bola karta taki India Wale Ko Bhasha samajh mein aaye

[@Abhi081220060]

why there is no video on 'nuns deserve safety from pastors' ?!

[@bharatmatakijai9601]

She won't get into that!!!! That's a no go zone for them😂😂

[@Abhi081220060]

@@bharatmatakijai9601 but we need to remind it so more people know. It is our right to ask questions in order to help make our society more informed so we can stay away from insects and able to protect ourselves

[@georgemathew1815]

There is also no video on 'female bhakthas deserve safety from swamis'

[@bharatmatakijai9601]

Not just the the poor nuns but they also prey on little kids of both sexes!! Not just in Bharat but all over the world!! So many cases coming before the Vatican and now even thr pope has apologized for the horrific crimes of his fellow clergy!!

[@Abhi081220060]

@@georgemathew1815 consume less rice bags so your brain can work more and then see news.

[@haniyunos-5612]

Well said

[@homely6616]

Madam. Please fight for the issue