A Muslim Lady was Raped by her Father-in-Law. Fatwa given that She was Haraam for her husband.

A Muslim Lady was Raped by her Father-in-Law. Fatwa given that She was Haraam for her husband. - Dr Zakir Naik
MIWPQA-18
Questioner: Assalamu Alaikum! My name is Shahid Khan and I’m a student. Ah.. first of all I’d like to congratulate Dr. Zakir Naik because not only the Muslims but everyone here is actually proud of you. So basically my question is recently in the Indian news channel there was a case like the daughter in law was raped by her father in law and it was a Muslim. So basically the Maulvis gave it like that she has to marry her father in law. And her husband is no more her husband. Do you have your say on that?
Dr. Naik: The brother again has picked up a very important issue of the media and people may be aware that a few months back there was girl by the name of Imrana, she was raped by her father in law and the Fatwa was given by the majority of the Indian scholar Aulmas and one Darul Uloom gave the Fatwa that because she was raped by the father in law she cannot go back to her husband she is haraam for her husband. Now the moment the media finds something which is interesting & that can malign Islam they pick it up and they blow it out of proportion as though there is nothing else in Islam but this issue.
So the Indian press what they did, most of the channels carried this news that the Aulmaas, the Shuyookhs, the Maulanas of Islam they say a girl, she’s raped by the father in law, she’s a victim but what does Islam say instead of supporting her now Islam is telling that she cannot go back to her husband, she’s Haraam for her husband. And they used this news and they blew it out of proportion even till this day today. Again, I always say that if you don’t know how to answer the media the people should be trained. And later on after a few weeks there were some other Muslim scholars they said no, no, no, she’s not Haraam for her husband she can go to her husband. Whoever has given Fatwa that she is Haraam for her husband is wrong. We are fighting like cats & dogs in front of the non Muslims. We are washing our dirty linen in public.
The joke is that both the groups of scholars are quoting the same verse of the Qur’an to give their Fatwa. The group of scholars which says that she is haraam for the husband.
They’re quoting a verse from the Qur’an Surah Nisa ch. No. 4 verse no. 22 which says that
“you cannot do Nikah with the woman who your father has done Nikah with”.
Now in Arabic nikah has got 2 meanings one meaning is marriage & the other meaning is sexual intercourse. And you ask any Arab who’s well verse with Arabic, he’ll tell you yes. Nikah has got 2 meanings one is marriage & other is sexual intercourse.
Now this first group of scholars which are in majority belonging to a group of Darul Uloom they take the meaning of Nikah as sexual inter course. So if you take the Nikah as sexual inter course the verse of the Qur’an says that you cannot have sexual intercourse with your sister, you cannot have sexual intercourse with your paternal aunty, with your maternal aunty, and you cannot have sexual intercourse with that woman who has had sexual intercourse with your father. So based on this they say that father did sexual intercourse with the woman now that woman cannot do sexual intercourse with the son therefore the husband becomes haraam...
#Muslim #Lady #Raped #FatherInLaw #Media #Promote #Fatwa #Haram #Husband #Zakir #Naik #Zakirnaik #Drzakirnaik #Dr #Drzakirchannel #Allah #Allaah #God #Muslim #Islam #Islaam #Comparative #Religion #Comparativereligion #Atheism #Atheist #Christianity #Christian #Hinduism #Hindu #Buddhism #Buddhist #Judaism #Jew #Sikhism #Sikh #Jainism #Jain #Lecture #Question #Answer #QuestionsandAnswer #Logic #Reason #Science #Misconception #Misunderstanding #PeaceTV #Dawah #Muhammad #Mohammed #Hadeeth #Hadith #Saheeh #Sahih #Man #Woman #Human #Humanity #Problem #Solution #Rights #Media #War #Peace #Similarities #Debate #Lecture #Quran #Quraan #AlQuran #AlQuraan #Bible #Veda #Gita #Geeta #Baghwat #Upanishad #Purana #Terrorism #Terrorist #Universal #Brotherhood #Word #Purpose #Life #Jihad #Jihaad #Jesus #Christ #Jesuschrist #Church #Mosque #Masjid #Perspective #Ask #AskDrZakir #Seeking #Knowledge #Education #NonMuslim #Fundamentalist #Fundamentalism #Symposium #Dialogue #Salaah #Salah #Shariah #Scripture #Ahmed #Deedat #AhmedDeedat #Daee #Missionary #pewdiepie #asmr #music #markiplier #old town road #pewdiepie vs t series #billie eilish #fortnite #Concept #West #Family #Global #Ramadhaan #Ramadan #Tauheed #Tawheed #Monotheism #Zakaat #Zakat #Zakah #Hajj #Saum #Fasting #Makkah #Mecca #Madinah #India #Malaysia #Ummah #Unity #Importance #Date #Isamophobia #Understand #Deen #Fardh #Fard #Haraam #Haram #Sunnah #Mustahab #Waajib #Wajib #Compulsory #Prohibited #Encouraged #Permissible #Permitted #Prohibited #Sin #Sinful #Heaven #Hell #Hellfire #Jannah #Jahannum #Paradise

[@bingola45]

How DARE these MEN take it upon themselves to decide on this unfortunate woman's future private life? How DARE they!

[@kejuuonemanarmy9358]

Go and. Give your wife right 🥺👍

[@justiceseeker3213]

Extremism bro, just like in Afganistan Bamiyan Buddha is forbidden in Islam and the muslim when to blast bom smash into pieces the historical significant statue protentially bring tourism industry.Muslim are fanatics.

[@IshaaqNewton]

The father in law is the criminal according to Al Quran. The wife has the full right to be with her husband.

[@snk5745]

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_in_Islam#:~:text=Terminology,to%20the%20contract%20of%20marriage.

[@snk5745]

This means Nikah means sexual intercourse or marriage This is very clear but noone wants to answer

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@@snk5745 Wikipedia is not a valid source, Nikah in this context of Sura 4:22 means marriage. There is no doubt about that.

[@boredom2022]

But she probably is best to not be with him... Move away and start life fresh somewhere else

[@عبدالقادرعبدالرحمنعبدالله]

@@boredom2022 very true

[@aliciaali8299]

Father in law should be jailed for atleast 30 yrs. that’s the law says....

[@imrankabir6116]

There is only one punishment for rape in Islam, that's beheading.

[@karamalqussiri6533]

He should be killed, look at America most rapists that are jailed after they are released they rape again, same with theirs they steal again after they are released, that is why Islam cuts the hands of the rapists

[@misscurious9289]

Death Penalty is The only Punishment for Rapist . .. .

[@ugh2668]

@@misscurious9289 Yup, rapists destroy the life of their victims, so their best punishment is death

[@francscoloitongbam8656]

In Islam you can rape Muhammad rape his son wife and all muslim say he is messenger of Allah. Muhammad even rape 7 years old girl when he is 54 years old he even fuck his mom friend which was 15 years old. It's ok Islam allow it even allah offer 72 virgin look at the moral of allah god or dalal I am confused.

[@erTalhaKhan]

He is one of the most logical and smart preacher.

[@vinayakchindarkar7326]

Good joke 👏👏👏👏

[@ashikalfaz9581]

@@vinayakchindarkar7326 burned?! Apply burnol rss chaddi

[@iffathashmi1336]

Exactly

[@vinayakchindarkar7326]

@@ashikalfaz9581 keep burnol for 2024 in stock. Baap ka kurta chote bhai ka paijama 😂😂😂

[@vinayakchindarkar7326]

@Sam 007 what abt ajmer dargha??? Short term memory loss 😄

[@IshaaqNewton]

Media is so gross... Especially Indian Media

[@mpc6912]

Why blame the media if Muslim scholars are divided over the issue

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@@mpc6912 They're not, the media just focuses on and gives the ignorant folks the platform. Whereas anyone who can learn to think, read and reason has to conclude the same as Dr Zakir on this issue.

[@recitationtohear]

@@ArdoBlueMoon kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXiqe6GaosR1j6c

[@Drago-sf2wi]

@@mpc6912 why watching Dr zaik Nair ?if you hate him?!

[@dontreplyaccountnotinuse3324]

@@mpc6912 unfortunately, I have to agree with you 😢 most of the people from countries like India, Pakistan etc are totally illiterate. Whether it be religion, politics, or any such field

[@safiulmoin3620]

The explanation seemed a bit vague even though he did mention his answer But what I found a bit odd was that he was too busy blaming the media(rightfully so) rather than the those maulanas who gave the fatwa I think he should have atleast condemned the maulanas

[@sahilkhan9818]

He already condemed them by giving an idiom as an example that these molanas were fighting like a cat and dog.

[@JC-nx5xx]

@@sahilkhan9818 Irony is , M Bullshit Zakir naik didn't give the answer only. When sexual addict Prophet Mohammed itself had married a step son's wife because she was beautiful then what can Quran says ...It cleary proves Quran is a word of aphrodisiac Mohammad and not from any God .

[@safiyaomer7878]

Look at likes and dislikes ! there are people who have more sense Than the hypocrites who are trying to maline ignoring truth and facts

[@syenas4100]

@@JC-nx5xx zayd is a slave tho but treated well like a family. He is not a stepson nor adopted.

[@roberthannah7983]

@@sahilkhan9818 I disagree, in this case one side was right and the other was wrong. The media was right to publicize it. It was not the media making a mockery of Islam, it was the scholars issuing the first fatwah who made a mockery of Islam to anyone with common sense.

[@ameliahamkai8103]

STone the F in law. The woman can remain with her husband

[@zebakhan39]

That would have happened in places like Saudi, Kuwait and so forth

[@mohdig9]

@D Saiseya hurr durrr, stfu no one is punished for a sin they commited while being forced.

[@chanovia5912]

@D Saiseya Where did u get that information?

[@aadilchohan877]

D Saiseya give me a proof that women are also punished for rape in Islam? Is zina rape? Oh yeh I forgot you take knowledge from the islamophobes who have never actually read the Quran in Arabic or know anything about the sharia law. 🤭🤭

[@njpravin]

My only question, in the same logic, isn't the father in-law also haram for her mother in law? 🤔

[@triptisingh9992]

Pravin Jagadish logic has no space in Islam

[@crackaby7075]

@@triptisingh9992 Frankly, Logic is the thing that MAKES Islam because we are supposed to go deep into the reason for every commandment of Islam other wise we would just be following a set of rules with a brainwashed hollow understanding.

[@shabrajsir2199]

Father in law is criminal, he is haram for everyone.

[@muspatel487]

@@triptisingh9992 have you ever learn islam learn then buk....

[@ebadurrehman5919]

+Pravin jagadish the father-in law and daughter-in law relationship is prohibited in islam. But there are some wrong molvis who give wrong fatwas for everything seriously they didn't know anything. And our indian media they were busy with doing interviews with molvis (bloody) liars.

[@pradeepbajaj7513]

I tried very hard to understand the answer, can someone explain it, please.

[@moonlight8848]

No she is not haram for the husband as the woman was raped and wasn't involved in voluntary intercourse with the father-in-law. In Qur'an it states that you cannot do "nikkah" with the lady your father has done. Now Arabic is a diverse language and a word can have several different meanings based on the context. Nikkah may mean either marriage or sexual intercourse. But in this particular situation marriage is meant.Since he didn't marry her,the girl ain't haram for her husband and the father in law is to be punished according to the sharia law.Hope this helps☺️

[@Goldenrose137]

Tazrin Rashid thank u so much Allah bless u I understand now

[@LR-kj8ec]

the father in law is sick in the mind

[@halalified8903]

I invite all my brothers and sisters to come and listen the peaceful holy quran

[@anjumanislam9375]

@@vijendrapokhriyal6630 whats wrong?

[@TrusttheY]

Vijendra Pokhriyal something funny? The only thing funny is your name! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Also learn how to spell.

[@dhirajdbb]

@@TrusttheY peaceful quran is funny

[@TrusttheY]

Dhiraj Singh your name is funny. Again you also need to learn how to spell....

[@isaiskander3774]

@NEW LIFE ...Krishna was muslim

[@BabyGz100]

Rape is not sexual intercourse? Care to pronounce that statement to a group of rape victims? This is one of the worst things you have said.. your world knowledge is weak

[@PictureThisNewMedia]

Sexual intercourse is when two humans agree mutually to engage in it. Yes rape envolves intercourse but there is nothing really "sexual" about it.

[@BabyGz100]

@@PictureThisNewMedia look up definition of sex, my first point.. pain is for some people sexually arousing, that makes it sexual

[@ahmadshahid1635]

@@BabyGz100 u hv poor knowledge.

[@BabyGz100]

@@ahmadshahid1635 that's the best argument I have ever heard! You must have a PhD degree? Go be a sheep and follow your master Zakir, kthanksbye

[@yourabotomegalulthisgametr1770]

That’s not what he meant. They are not the same in the context of punishment and with what the Quran says.

[@diaz6636]

This man needs an award 🥇

[@jyotsnamohanty9060]

Wow. What a justice. Without any fault the lady is haram for her husband.

[@saniyakhan1474]

Wo haram nhi h apne husband k liye... Uske Paas choices h....raper k death k baad wo apne husband k sath rahe ya use chd de... Yrr samjh toh lo phle acche se.. Kuch mulnana jinko knowledge nhi thi uss ldki ko galt advice kiye..but quran m aesa nhi h

[@naureen5279]

I don't understand. My english is not so good. Whats does it means, what he said. Is she now haram for her husband or Not I didnt understand. Can someone explain what bis answer was

[@dapurmamagangpanda6235]

2:04 the answer. It is not that difficult to comprehend this.

[@TrusttheY]

She is innocent, it's the father-in-law who should be punished/accounted for. The embarrassment and the shame on the family. The whispers of the devil.....

[@sickid41]

What was the answer

[@SNH987]

Husband and wife are islamically legal and father in law is rapist,that's what Zakir Naik said

[@sayeedabano7652]

MashaAllah what a beautiful answer. May Allah swt bless and protect Dr. Zakir naik and take more work of islam from him.

[@satishs8481]

He never answered the question

[@maamarfaroukbenbada454]

4:28 use the brain that Allah gave you its not that complicated

[@christophermallett8166]

@@maamarfaroukbenbada454 actually he never answered the question. Arguing semantics about what a word means does not arrive at any conclusion regarding the treatment of the poor girl who was raped. Use YOUR brain!

[@hinnakhalid7622]

@ Mr Mallet, he explicitly explained that nikkah clearly means marriage and not rape/just sexual intercourse hence implying that the girl could go back to her husband. He clearly proved the scholars who proposed the contrary wrong.

[@hinnakhalid7622]

Also all the marriage counselors out there know that marriage/nikkah don’t just mean sexual intercourse as some nut cases may assume. Sex is just a 10 percent of a healthy married life according to Dr. Phil

[@christophermallett8166]

@@hinnakhalid7622 do you even know what the word "semantics" means?!? The question was not about the meaning of the word, it was about the treatment of the girl. What girl would WANT to go back to her husband after his own father had raped her?! Arguing semantics over the meaning of a word does NOT answer the proposed question!! Moron. Why does he have to "imply" the answer? Rather than GIVE an answer. I'd think about that if I were you.

[@shaziyasiddiqui5341]

Thank you Dr zakir nayak....I heard this case when I was in 12th I think....till then upto now I wanna know the reason why there was fatwa like this ....as one of my dii...told me about this..and she was a non Muslim...I feel so ashamed and cannot understand what to say...at that time I don't have so much access to internet and also I forgot the name of the victim ....but these days I don't know why this question always came into my mind... especially during Ramadan till now....and finally got relief.... Alhumdullilah....

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@Diamond S Under Islam, the rapist is to be executed. But as they live under the law of India, that will be followed.

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@Diamond S That's a question you need to ask him and not random people on YT.

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

@Diamond S Good question, I'm not sure as to who the baby's legal father would be. However, I do no there is no blame on the wife whatsoever. I suggest you pose that question to the scholars.

[@Mr1985123]

Aurat ki Koi Jaat ya Dharm Nahi Hota....

[@roberthannah7983]

@@ArdoBlueMoon But under Islam, you need 4 male witnesses, which are never available so the rapist always goes free. That is why you need a secular law against rape.

[@smarterlogic1281]

now I know to follow Islam first I have to sell my brain....n logic

[@hchcchchcllhclh5341]

U have already sold it.

[@Righteousanger1001]

Islam is not the problem, and also not a man made religion; no man made justice system in the world can deliver true justice to victims who are in these situations. In the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him), those who were found to commit sexual assault were actually given capital punishment. If you believe there is a higher power, you can say that it is ultimately that higher power that delivers true justice because humans cannot, regardless of what punishment (or lack thereof) humans carry out-- Islam teaches us to believe in that higher power, Who is also the best of healers, and with Whom lies ultimate recompense (since you don't see justice/ full compensation/ forgiveness for all in this world itself).

[@hinnakhalid7622]

You cannot sell what you don’t have 😂

[@psenji]

@@Righteousanger1001 Sir how many Islamic kings who ruled India have raped innocent women and still called themselves as rulers who followed Islamic teachings? Why didn't the Islamic mullahs in India not call for hanging those kings following the example set by the holy prophet? Can you answer ? Thanks.

[@itchyexorcist]

@@Righteousanger1001 yeah yeah.. and will u please explain how a sexual assault is being proved in accordance to your law.

[@poiusone]

Small zikr which can take you to jannah 1.It was narrated that Abu Umaamah said: “The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever recites Ayatul Kursi immediately after each prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and his entering Paradise except death.” (An Nasa'i and Ibn Hibban). 2. Abu Hurairah reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said: He who says, ‘Subhan-Allahi wa bihamdihi‘ (Glory and praise be to Allah) one hundred times a day, his sins will be obliterated even if they are equal to the extent of the foam of the sea. (Al-Bukhari and Muslim). 3. . Abu Hurairah narrated that the Prophet said:“There are two statements that are light on the tongue, heavy on the scales, and beloved to the Most Merciful: Subahana Allahi wa bihamdihi, Subhana Allahi Al-`Azeem (Glory and praise be to Allah, Glorified is Allah, the Most Great.)” (Al-Bukhari) 4.share this comment as much as possible, anybody who do this because of you, you will also get reward for it, you may call it the halal compound effect or ripple effect.

[@Mohammadkashifkhan2093]

Why are people so stupid, they keep on saying that He never answered the question, please listen to the question properly. The guy never asked what has to be done to the Father-in-Law, also that comes under the Govt. jurisdiction.

[@motibilli]

These are paid trolls with fake muslim names. They are out to get Dr. Zakir

[@iloveyouallah8800]

Question, If someone is going to do sin within few seconds and suddenly he stops himself and think Almighty ALLAH (SWT) is watching me so will he/she gets Gonna

[@suaimkhalil6964]

They will get good deeds

[@iloveyouallah8800]

Suaim Khalil InshALLAH!

[@jahangirmallick1732]

Allah will give him/her great reward

[@techonist]

No. When you have stop yourself from doing bad you will get rewarded by good deeds. You will get gunnaah after making a sin.

[@ronnyquatre6305]

As a Muslim, I've never thought about this situation or heard about it( father-in-law raping a girl)... I didn't know the law about it and I find it very interesting 🤔🙄

[@triptisingh9992]

I guess no other book is as misinterpreted as Quran. Every so called Islamic scholar interpret it in their on way

[@bineetshukla]

Did he answered what should be done to father in law

[@triptisingh9992]

bineet shukla no he didn’t answered.he just played tactfully that how nikaah has been misinterpreted as sexual intercourse instead of marriage in this case and declared wife as haraam for the husband.the so called scholars should take the education of Quran first and then teach

[@songs1739]

@@triptisingh9992 try to watch again the video and try to understand what's really his point😌

[@fitnessabdul6811]

@@triptisingh9992 The Punishment for Rape is beheading.

[@shabrajsir2199]

Father in law should be punished as Criminal, it's simple.

[@توحيدالاسلام-ر7ض]

جزاك الله خير 👍👍

[@abuudi2025]

Masha allah i love you dr zakir naik ❣❣🙏🏿🙏🏿😍😍🤩😘

[@mohammedharoon1335]

Very beneficial InshaALLAH

[@servantofthecreator3997]

Why are we skirting around the fact that the woman was raped? A crime was commited against her and no one is addressing the fact that this man needs to be held accountable. Was she still married to his son? Had the marriage been consumated? Were children involved? The Holy Prophet, (s.a.w.), would have brought this creep to justice if the woman had complained to him (s.a.w.). The man needs to answer for his crime of rape!

[@tanvchem9444]

He thought people has brain so they will clearly understand that father is guilty here. That's why he didnt concluded by decision.

[@armaannoor9968]

Unfortunately people have no brain

[@workinprogressbutconflicted]

Dr Naik is a wise man

[@naimurhasanrwd]

Allah guide us to the straight path.

[@bdnewsfatima5909]

Remember God, God will protect you! (Tirmizi: -2516)

[@আব্দুল্লাহআব্দুল্লাহ-স৫ঘ]

You are right

[@bdnewsfatima5909]

বাংলাদেশ লাভার আপনি কি বাংলাদেশের

[@abidhasan7768]

@@bdnewsfatima5909 when we give reference from hadith, please don't use the word "god".Instead of it use almighty or other. But it would be much better if you use "Allah"

[@recitationtohear]

@@abidhasan7768 kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXiqe6GaosR1j6c

[@recitationtohear]

@@bdnewsfatima5909 kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXiqe6GaosR1j6c

[@pirmuhammadkhan5923]

Please don't mention the name of the woman so openly.

[@zainabkhursheed3354]

Please give subtitles.

[@uhhvd]

But he didn't condemn rape by a single word!!!

[@zebakhan39]

He did but was super long winded, Islam does not condone rape

[@uhhvd]

@@zebakhan39 in which part of video he condemned rape????

[@GodPilledZen]

@@uhhvd it is self evident. We can't even have sex out of marriage yet you think we are allowed to rape? Where is your brain?

[@uhhvd]

@@GodPilledZen what your allowed and what not is not important but what are these people are doing is more important!!!!

[@barnythepreacher4559]

Does anyone actually understand what this chap is talking about?

[@rider4745]

Coz ur too dumb enough

[@salafisaudi9905]

He didn't answer the question.. Or other word he was stucked.. What to say.. Where is the answer.. Means her father in law did right as per Quran or Islam

[@mohdrozaidimatlazim8953]

@@salafisaudi9905 what a dumb comment

[@rider4745]

@unkown user yup soon ill be getting And then ill mock u with my newer brain skills (Warning " Never peek in the religious matters )

[@hillydilly474]

Yes. Rape does not dissolve a marriage contract No matter who committed the crime.

[@vibratooctave1805]

Previous he said 13 years girl could marry to a 100 old man 😆

[@shruthis2134]

😅👌

[@huzaifarasheed7181]

who said ?

[@sidratulmuntaha6351]

Marriage is giving them respect and protecting their social status unlike those chicks who just become high class whores just to make there ends meet. That's the different between treating them like a human and a tissue paper.

[@MirzaSe]

Who are you to tell her she can't?

[@hakoonamatata7133]

@TLM Abul Kalam - Marrying 55years old man was her biggest accident... This is completely social injustice... With all due respect, if something is illogical even in Quran that needs to be corrected... Some of the things for all religion if that doesn't hold good now that needs to be corrected logically in favour of humanity..

[@davecooper6540]

What scares me is the fact that the majority of the Indian scholars ruled that the girl had to marry the father in law. WTH!!!! I’m a Muslim but what type of scholarly wisdom is that? Seriously.

[@assiduous2011]

Not one mention of the punishment that the rapist deserved. Smdh

Muhammad: A summary to understand the man behind the "Religion of Peace". Stoned women for adultery. (Muslim 4206) "I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" (Muslim 1:33) Permitted stealing from unbelievers. (Bukhari 44:668, Ibn Ishaq 764) Permitted lying. (Sahih Muslim 6303, Bukhari 49:857) Owned and traded slaves. (Sahih Muslim 3901) Beheaded 800 Jewish men and boys. (Abu Dawud 4390) Murdered those who insulted him. (Bukhari 56:369, 4:241) "If then anyone transgresses the prohibition against you, Transgress ye likewise against him" (Quran 2:194) Jihad in the way of Allah elevates one's position in Paradise by a hundred fold. (Muslim 4645) Married 13 wives and kept sex slaves. (Bukhari 5:268, Quran 33:50) Raped a 9-year-old child. (Sahih Muslim 3309, Bukhari 58:236) Ordered the murder of women. (Ibn Ishaq 819, 995) "O you who believe! Fight those of the unbelievers who are near to you and let them find in you hardness." (Quran 9:123) Ordered 65 military campaigns and raids in his last 10 years. (Ibn Ishaq ) Killed captives taken in battle. (Ibn Ishaq 451) Encouraged his men to rape enslaved women. (Abu Dawood 2150, Quran 4:24) Demanded captured slaves and a fifth of all other loot taken in war. (Quran 8:41) Was never tortured, but tortured others. (Muslim 4131, Ibn Ishaq 436, 595, 734, 764) "And fight them until there is no more persecution and religion is only for Allah" (Quran 8:39) Blessed the brutal murder of a half-blind man (al-Tabari 1440) Ordered a slave to build the very pulpit from which he preached Islam. (Bukhari 47:743) "Belief in Allah and Jihad in His cause" (Muslim 1:149) Demanded the protection of armed bodyguards, even in a house of worship (Quran 4:102) Advocated crucifying others. (Quran 5:33, Muslim 16:4131) Had others give their lives for him. (Sahih Muslim 4413) Said that women are deficient in the head (Stupid) Sahih al-Bukhari 2658 Died from poisoning by a woman. Sunan Abu Dawud 4498, Sunan Abu Dawud 4449, Sunan Ibn Majah 1622, Ibn Ishaq, p. 516, Ibn Sa’d, Volume 2, pp. 251-252 If the prophet Mohamed would be accused of rape, murder and hate speech today in a court of law, would he be found guilty or innocent? What is your verdict?

[@assiduous2011]

2niner71 Except your exhibits are all lies and made up. It doesn’t even answer my question. Nice try troll.

[@fathimohamed4734]

Assalualeikum doctor i have aquestion to ask although it's out of the topic. my question is you have said in one of your lectures that if you are not praying(swalah)it doesn't mean you are a non_ muslim but another sheikh said that a person who is not praying is non-muslim considering in Qu'ran chapter 74 verse 40-42 . I'm a muslim learning the religion please doctor Naik i'm in a confuse so make it clear for me.جزاك لله

[@shirazahmad7144]

I love you dr zakir Saab GOD gave you long life

[@blessingdawn6660]

A good explanation....as Muslim al Qur'an is truly the guidian and clue in life time....

[@FaizanAminMir]

agr meei lyf b milai zakir naik ko ,i m ok with it. may God keep zakir naik evergreen always

[@amitskumar]

Bastered didn't told what will happen to that innocent girl and that basterd father in law. He quickly escape from the actual subject.

[@raj8172]

Very precise answer by sir naik

[@vaibhavbaranwal3558]

Totally diverted the question in second part of answer.... So many time he do this...

[@ibrahimsyed1033]

“Diverted?” He literally gave the answer to people like u who say he diverts the answers 😂🤦‍♂️

[@sachinj1302]

true

[@sachinj1302]

in on video he was telling that 13 yr old girl can marry to 103 year old man 😃😃😃

[@jcc4041]

Zakir Naik did not answer the question. He downplayed the crime. The issue got swept under the rug.

[@ROBIN_HOOD_111]

i really like him , he shows the true face of islam

[@allahisthebestprotector2455]

Assalamualikum Dr. Jakir naik Sir can i talk with you please i am from Bangladesh 😥😥😥😥

[@abdulgaffarabdulgaffar8533]

same problem

[@abdulgaffarabdulgaffar8533]

if got his number please send

[@thebigshot7348]

@@abdulgaffarabdulgaffar8533 i got this no. but this is international no.+60 11-2695 3895 so I'm not able to message

[@Oceaniac]

They’re all too worried about whether the husband can keep his wife or not rather than worrying about the wife herself -.- Girl got RAPED and they more worried about whether her marriage is nullified or not. Her feelings and mental and emotional state clearly doesn’t even matter to these people.

[@zakariahasaan2847]

Brother, i see what you are doing and as far as I can tell its laudable and I am not saying you are wrong.however, there’s problem to be judged that is not clear ,,,, The father in_ law’s crime is crystal clear Daughter being victim is clear But What is not clear is weather the marriage is still to be held . Hope I cleared that out . Thanks in advance

[@masoodjamily]

I’m sorry I am Muslim and answer that he just gave about a girl getting raped by her father-in-law did not after my curiosity at all as a matter fact what he’s telling me he said yes if a woman gets raped by the father-in-law she is now obligated to be with him and not be with a husband that’s bullshit...

[@kausarshaikh9891]

He clearly said that father in law committed a crime of rape and according to Shari'ah the outcome of this crime is stoned to death in public/100 lashes in public. Secondly, the victim faces no consequences of the action and she's free to abortion as well.

[@sarakhushi23]

The reply is not clear, what should be done and no pain and voice for woman?

[@kausarshaikh9891]

He clearly mentioned that it was rape and according to Shari'ah the penalty for rape is stoned to death in public/100 lashes in public.

[@sanjayramadhinchauhan4569]

Worst man ever seen ! Making fool in front of them

[@mohsinarfat749]

Greatly explained😊

[@Safiyyrh]

Narrated Abu Jamra: I was an interpreter between the people and Ibn `Abbas. Once Ibn `Abbas said that a delegation of the tribe of `Abdul Qais came to the Prophet (ﷺ) who asked them, "Who are the people (i.e. you)? (Or) who are the delegates?" They replied, "We are from the tribe of Rabi`a." Then the Prophet (ﷺ) said to them, "Welcome, O people (or said, "O delegation (of `Abdul Qais).") Neither will you have disgrace nor will you regret." They said, "We have come to you from a distant place and there is the tribe of the infidels of Mudar intervening between you and us and we cannot come to you except in the sacred month. So please order us to do something good (religious deeds) and that we may also inform our people whom we have left behind (at home) and that we may enter Paradise (by acting on them.)" The Prophet ordered them to do four things, and forbade them from four things. He ordered them to believe in Allah Alone, the Honorable the Majestic and said to them, "Do you know what is meant by believing in Allah Alone?" They replied, "Allah and His Apostle know better." Thereupon the Prophet (ﷺ) said, "(That means to testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is His Apostle, to offer prayers perfectly, to pay Zakat, to observe fasts during the month of Ramadan, (and) to pay Al-Khumus (one fifth of the booty to be given in Allah's cause)." Then he forbade them four things, namely Ad-Dubba.' Hantam, Muzaffat (and) An-Naqir or Muqaiyar (These were the names of pots in which alcoholic drinks used to be prepared). The Prophet (ﷺ) further said, "Memorize them (these instructions) and tell them to the people whom you have left behind." Sahih al-Bukhari 87

[@Lawrence305]

Superb answer

[@ASLAMKHAN-rq9ry]

Mujhe Muslim Se Bahar Na Karen Allah Duaa Kijiyen Dr. Zakir Naik Sahab

[@stanleyhood4343]

So what happened to Daddy Dearest? Isn't he a rapist?

[@rakhee_aisha]

Mashaa Allah Very wise Dr Zakir Naik V Well explained Thank you

[@simplyclear]

He is one of the best scholar of comparative study of world religions who talks only what is there in the scriptures and never adds his own masala emotion and bullshit gyan like sadguru.... No butter and cheese no beating around the bush straight to the point...Dot... that is Dr.Naik

[@farazkhan21fierce]

Superb excellent reply Dr. Zakir 😎 i am proud of u 👍

[@tariqkhan351]

JazakAllah khairan kaseran

[@abuzaransari.4823]

Best answer

[@deepshikhaverma5838]

Im stunned. I didn't see him talking about how gross injustice it is with the woman.

[@AhmedAli-fg7gj]

Dr Zakir Naik Is The Best

[@abrahamt1813]

Irrelevant answer...

[@kausarshaikh9891]

To everyone who thinks he didn't answer the question: The person asked his say/opinion on the matter which Mr. Naik gave from every aspect. To break it down further in simpler terms: 1) The woman was "raped" hence the father in law according to Shari'ah to be charged with rape. Which according to Shari'ah is stoned to death in public /100 lashes in public. Source : en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_in_Islamic_law 2) The difference of opinion between maulvis was unwanted since surah Nisa Ayat 22-23 mentions Nikah between Father's bride and son i.e. step mothers is unlawful and incestuous which is straightforward and logical. Source : en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/An-Nisa#:~:text=And%20if%20you%20fear%20that,that%20your%20right%20hands%20possess. 4:22-23 Incest 3) The response of the media and the response to the media - Maulvis are definitely not trained spokespeople to speak in the media who can misquote them easily. So Mr. Naik's point is pretty valid that they should be trained in this field as well since the media without any doubt is out there to find flaws in Islam. It was just a humble attempt to clarify any doubts that anyone had regarding his speech.

[@samsamba2472]

What do you think gave the father-in-law the impression that sleeping with your daughter-in-law is not a big deal, worse punishment will be marrying her?

[@safiabegum2801]

Maa shaa Allah very good answer for him and all of us

[@whisperingwhiskerss4877]

That father in Law should be hanged. She was raped, she did not willingly commit this act. Alhamdulilah for Islam ❤️

[@TheGerrard000]

All the great scholars were tested in their lives. Every one of them had problems with the people in power. Some were jailed. Some were tortured. Some were publicly humiliated. And years in the future we still say these scholars names. They are still respected across the centuries and we still benefit from them. Those people that were in power are long long forgotten and if mentioned they are not mentioned fondly. The entire subcontinent is a mess. There are so many uneducated people, lack of basic manners is shocking, bida is rife and the idol worshipers are running rampant. What do they do to a good man who only wanted to help people for the sake of Allah? A man that could’ve easily have been The Emir of the subcontinent based on his knowledge in a bygone time? Allah takes him away from them all... whatever is happening in that region now is a punishment. Corruption, poverty, racism, injustice - the list is endless. Stop making sujood in front of graves! Fix yourselves before it’s too late. Listen to this man before it’s too late.

[@gudbrid8702]

Mashaa ALLAH amazing excellent Dr zakir sirji excellent correct thanks a lot 👍🏻🙏🙏🙏👍🏻👌👍🏻👌👌👌may Almighty ALLAH bless always n protect you always wishes you all the best of luck keep going 👍🏻👌👍🏻👍🏻👌👌👌👌👌❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️n bless the one who bring this video for as good job thanks all the best 👍🏻👌👍🏻👌❤️👍🏻👌

Look at the prophet and you will understand this behavior more clearly. Muhammad: A summary to understand the man behind the "Religion of Peace". Stoned women for adultery. (Muslim 4206) "I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, and that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah" (Muslim 1:33) Permitted stealing from unbelievers. (Bukhari 44:668, Ibn Ishaq 764) Permitted lying. (Sahih Muslim 6303, Bukhari 49:857) Owned and traded slaves. (Sahih Muslim 3901) Beheaded 800 Jewish men and boys. (Abu Dawud 4390) Murdered those who insulted him. (Bukhari 56:369, 4:241) "If then anyone transgresses the prohibition against you, Transgress ye likewise against him" (Quran 2:194) Jihad in the way of Allah elevates one's position in Paradise by a hundred fold. (Muslim 4645) Married 13 wives and kept sex slaves. (Bukhari 5:268, Quran 33:50) Raped a 9-year-old child. (Sahih Muslim 3309, Bukhari 58:236) Ordered the murder of women. (Ibn Ishaq 819, 995) "O you who believe! Fight those of the unbelievers who are near to you and let them find in you hardness." (Quran 9:123) Ordered 65 military campaigns and raids in his last 10 years. (Ibn Ishaq ) Killed captives taken in battle. (Ibn Ishaq 451) Encouraged his men to rape enslaved women. (Abu Dawood 2150, Quran 4:24) Demanded captured slaves and a fifth of all other loot taken in war. (Quran 8:41) Was never tortured, but tortured others. (Muslim 4131, Ibn Ishaq 436, 595, 734, 764) "And fight them until there is no more persecution and religion is only for Allah" (Quran 8:39) Blessed the brutal murder of a half-blind man (al-Tabari 1440) Ordered a slave to build the very pulpit from which he preached Islam. (Bukhari 47:743) "Belief in Allah and Jihad in His cause" (Muslim 1:149) Demanded the protection of armed bodyguards, even in a house of worship (Quran 4:102) Advocated crucifying others. (Quran 5:33, Muslim 16:4131) Had others give their lives for him. (Sahih Muslim 4413) Said that women are deficient in the head (Stupid) Sahih al-Bukhari 2658 Died from poisoning by a woman. Sunan Abu Dawud 4498, Sunan Abu Dawud 4449, Sunan Ibn Majah 1622, Ibn Ishaq, p. 516, Ibn Sa’d, Volume 2, pp. 251-252 If the prophet Mohamed would be accused of rape, murder and hate speech today in a court of law, would he be found guilty or innocent? What is your verdict?

[@princesslelaka1844]

Eh he actually never answered the question

[@hemangtaunk4911]

Ryt

[@ShannonGuay]

@عُمر اِبن حُسَين and you think you're so smart!!🤔🤔

[@maureencopeland1008]

Yes he said the woman was a victim of rape by the father. SO the woman could go back to her husband

[@nosayy]

He did. He explained the ruling did not apply here in this case. She was raped. A victim. So yes she can be with her husband.

[@commonman8872]

Well he also stole 193 crore rupees from the zakat fundings he got and bought properties in Mumbai!!!!! He is a fucking cheat!!!!!

[@NirmohiHindu]

No word of condemnation for the rapist. Is this what a preacher of Islam is? God save the earth and humanity. I wonder how the likes are generated for this video . When the comments show the real response.

[@TheNickt1]

you haven't answered the question. What should happen to the father. He raped his daughter in law after all

[@hamentpandit6950]

I was searching for funny videos KZbin showed me his channel🤣

[@viv4060]

All the World's leftover hopeless beings, perverts and criminals follow this goat!

[@Noorfatima-xi1un]

Masha Allah.. May Allah ta'ala grant us beneficial knowledge. May Allah bless you with happiness, success, and good health. Aameen Ya rabb

[@jannatkhan4706]

Sir the peace tv app should be more updated.. I love you for the sake of Allah ❤️.

[@Mpostana]

As expected, the whole discussion was what to do with the woman❗️. What does the quran say about the perpetrator?.

[@darumer123]

Stoned to death

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

The Quran doesn't specifically say the punishment, but the Hadith of Muhammad pbuh say that he should be put to death. However, as the crime happened in India, the law of the land applies.

[@bombagent6774]

it's halal according to dr zakir naik's answer

[@zakismz]

The punishment for rape in Islam is the same as the punishment forzina (adultery or fornication), which is stoning if the perpetrator is married, and one hundred lashes and banishment for one year if he is not married.

[@ArdoBlueMoon]

We are going to ignore the trolls who didn't even watch the video, who think they're so smart.

[@noorsaheb7328]

May Allah give you long life in this world to answer those who malign Islam and clear the misconceptions of common men about Islam.. Aameen.....

[@gmsmhporae-learning2643]

Really appreciating sir.. We must be well read to counter the cunning enemies of Islam..

[@billsamuls7620]

HE TALKS A LOT OF BOLLOCKS

[@drnsdevi]

Wow so the victim never got justice not even a validation from this guy.

[@maryammustafa6128]

He was not asked to tell the punishment of the rapist... He simply answered his questions without wasting time... This is a seminar and so many people come there to clear there doubts and they have clear their doubts without wasting time and without distracting from the point... And the only punishment of rapist according to Islam is to cut their heads in front of public so that no one thinks of repeating this sin....

[@Meetabasit]

One of the most offensive question by Hindus.

[@naleemibraheem9926]

Y ongalku purinjika mudiyadha?

[@navedahmed2109]

Why is it offensive? We, as Muslims, shouldn't be afraid of criticism. We should welcome it and try to clear it by the help of Allah

[@kirans1]

it was asked by a muslim sirji

[@naleemibraheem9926]

@Way of Islam awaru solrarau "oru hinduwidam irundhu winawappatta oru periya attack aana question idhu" endu solraru

[@ambreensalman7305]

Woman has been raped and not had consented sex so she stays with her husband and father in law should be duly punished for his crime. Thank you for the answer

[@muskanshah6141]

Dr. Zakir naik may Allah give u health and long life aaameeen.

[@tastebuds4419]

Muskan shah. Sister may ra channel subcribe kar dain gi plz

[@mushfiquemahdiahmed2048]

Assalamualaikum. I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩. I have question that what is the opinion of islam to marring a raped girl. If you give me the answer it will be helpful for me.

[@syedsajidakhtar8186]

Nice explanation.....

[@subm2455]

Punish the father in law , leave the girl alone stop taking her name. now if the husband dosen't want her back then leave the husband too. Instead of debating who sould the women go back to we should discuss what should be the punishment to the father in law and also how to make the process less painful for the lady.

[@gustgoris8009]

Can somebody help me, I didn't understand him, What hapened with the woman now???

[@thebigshot7348]

the fatwa which says she can't live with man is wrong because which verse of surah al nisha is said the meaning of nikaah is marriage.so she live with man and father in law is punishable

[@angelalong6619]

It seems to be the Father n Law's sin not the women. Rape is violence against the victim. Crazy question. I think the Dr answered it well. I wouldve been too stuned to answer this one.

[@ikbalhossain9758]

Awsome hikmah.Respect from Bangladesh

[@beautyneedsnonametoberecog82]

#be practical in life be logical in life like Dr zakir naik

[@beautyneedsnonametoberecog82]

Islam is all about faith but logical in the sense to represent ur Deen , faith, religion

[@tazeenkhan7774]

Guys why when I m clicking on this channel and it shows this channel is no longer available Any one plz tell me

[@faizanalam1244]

Indian authorities has banned this channel in india u can use vpn

[@azar-ibn-abd-alkaiyoom]

Go to Settings - General - Location, change country to Malaysia

[@SIGSEGV1337]

@@faizanalam1244 You can also use TOR

[@suaimkhalil6964]

Go to the settings and change your location to anywhere in the world except India

[@jewelsgleaming401]

This is the most logical answer to an Islamic question I’ve ever seen.

[@NRFP]

why can not go back to husband. he does not gave answer

[@hearthacker5565]

Ohh my God how much i love him.. He is absolute gem

[@suyog70]

Zakir is a donkey braying.. the real reason is that the sexual intercourse between FIL and the wife was non-consensual and not binding.. hence the wife can still stay married to her husband..

[@roberthannah7983]

Why do you love somebody like Naik who is banned in several countries for hate speech and extremism?

[@Samudra1419]

Damn, how the heck that women dint get justice even on this level too

[@kamaldeenabdullah3424]

Bec it's India. If this was KSA, this person be dead on the same day, executed.

[@abusultan3375]

Good job Sir Love And Respect From Pakistan.

[@rajabhai_muktijoddha_7148]

What a Brilliant answer MashAllah!