A new language policy for India - J. Sai Deepak

J. Sai Deepak talks to us on a new language policy foor the country. Listen in and share your thoughts in the comments section.
ALSO CHECK OUT:
"LAW FOR THE NON-LAWYER" listen to J. Sai Deepak's talk at his alma matter, IIT Kharagpur.
Link: • Law for the Non-Lawyer...
Don't miss out on the exciting Q&A session of the talk
Link: • J. Sai Deepak and an e...
Visit our channel to discover more videos and don't forget to subscribe!
You can also follow us on:
samvaadEvents
samvaadiitkgp

[@indodefencetalks8163]

"Japanese use only Japanese language for communication.They use a translator when required.Don't make english a medium to judge someone's intelligence". -Bhuvan Bam

[@romankumar5977]

who is bhuvan bam? an illiterate clown? don't quote these jesters and take them seriously.

[@amitverma223]

@@romankumar5977 its not about quoting someone it's about the fact he shared about japan don't you know japan is more technologically advanced in all terms as compared to any other country and also they prefer native language for acquiring knowledge and applying it into there lives. And about calling bhuvan bam illiterate, do you even know him? Calling someone illiterate without knowing them is job of illiterate.

[@romankumar5977]

@@amitverma223 yes i know that but what i wanted to point out is , youths should focus on intellectually robust people not these comedians and KZbinrs who know nothing.

[@mbangroo]

@@romankumar5977 disagree. point here is about the statement , not the person. focus on the message, not the messenger.

[@romankumar5977]

@@mbangroo people like you follow sonam kapoor and swara bhaskar to know indian Constitution. go on then.

[@pragasanarchary2980]

Parents should demand/raise their children to speak english only in out of state interaction

[@sliderBro]

When I was in school, I had to read Shakespeare. WTF! While I can understand that English could be considered the language of business and modern sciences in a globalized world, why in the world are we reading Shakespeare instead of our own literature in our schools?

[@renjiddavid]

Hope u have learned Shakespeaer in "English Class" not in your regional language class :)

[@sumankpm]

Deepak, Not sure how to approach you.... I have few things to bring to your notice..... In Andhra and Tamilnadu.... Every day abuse for Hindus and their gods are common ... However, worst things are 1. Building temples and claiming them as churches with a cross symbol 2. You might be aware of "kaamakshi vilakku" .... not sure what it is called in telugu or english.... Christian's started having cross symbol on this lamp .... 3. In shivaji nahar, Bangalore.... I saw a church which has "dvaja sthambam" pillar which we have in front of our temples 4. Also in Bangalore.... in few Christian dominated areas .... they started writing on the walls "Om yaesuvae namaha" How are we going to tackle this..... ?????

[@harishkiran3663]

Come to Kerala, all of them are all over here.

[@indodefencetalks8163]

Start placing jesus idols within temple complex and tell everyone that what you will get inside a church we have in the temple also.

[@thedarrrklllord]

Isnt it good that indian christians have hinduised their religion instead of us having abrahamised our religion... Thats what veer savarkar demanded ... What more u want ...

[@harishkiran3663]

@@thedarrrklllord It is, but there is always a threat of digestion. Just like Christmas, Santa etc were also assimilated by abrahamics, no trace of original systems left. Always be careful to not end up in museums like Mayans.

[@harishkiran3663]

@@indodefencetalks8163 Perfect, also should do an Upa Pratishta of Allah.

[@harishkiran3663]

Even Ayurveda is taught in English now!!!

[@Sarcasticsanskar]

@Stratus in local languages also enough literature is present for ayurveda

[@chandrandec31]

And it should be. And these English texts I'm sure has Sanskrit words.

[@Sarcasticsanskar]

@Stratus bhai matlab kooch bhi...

[@Sarcasticsanskar]

@Stratus yaar kya hai yeh.. koi bhi south se hai toh madrasi kar ke bol raha hai.. theek toh ho... ??

[@Sarcasticsanskar]

@Stratus stop behaving like a racist.. have some class, zaroori nahi koi south se hai toh Hindi bol nahi paega ya Tamil hi bolega.. thoda apne bil mein se nikal aur duniya dekh.. saare North walon ko bihari ya bhaiya ya koi generalization nahi karke bolte... Fir kyun faaltu mein chauda ho raha hai... Padha likha hai toh bartav bhi vaisa hi kar.. rahi baat J Sai Deepak ki... Woh AP se belong karta hai.. madrassi nahi

[@HarshitSharma-wr3pf]

Let's rejuvenate sanskrit and make it the language of intersected conversation of people of different state 🙏

[@kamathvishal5]

Let's learn it ourselves first , i am already begining the journey .

[@yashg2283]

@@kamathvishal5 How are you learning Sanskrit?

[@shashikumarreddy1857]

Nahi, hum ko to sirf logon ka statue kada karna asaan h

[@HarshitSharma-wr3pf]

@@shashikumarreddy1857 that statue is one of the most visited tourist attraction ,bhai

[@omthakkar7801]

For that you need to initiate, by admitting yourself or your kids in Sanskrit medium pathsalas & Gurukuls, thrn only it will happen. Infact, I myself initiated and took admission into Sanskrit medium. Now it's your turn!

[@shankarcg786]

English speaking is considered intellectual whereas vernacular or native language is considered dull. But wisdom has no language for eg in olden days Sanskrit or Pali or Tamil has utilised in astronomy, Vedic mathematics, vastushastra (ancient structural engineering), natyashashtra, ayurveda etc. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Bharat 🇮🇳

[@harishpatil18]

Excellent points, Sanskrit must be a link language for Bharata.

[@generalruckus]

No, it should be assamese or tulu.

[@sidhantdhyani9567]

There cannot be a single centralized language.......as it will not Help the Other Regional Language such as Assamese , tamil , Telugu etc.

[@dwightschrute5979]

No, must be malyalam

[@aek12]

We must have one language of national conversation which is not understood by the whole world. So that we can protect ourselves from what is going on in the world. It can be Hindi or Sanskrit. Please don't impose your language as national, as it will only create conflict. Please have a common sense and a open heart. The point of language is unity, When are united we are strong.

[@skt-os8eo5hv5e]

Dead Language 😂

[@youneverknow5555]

1.I understand Learning and mastering the mother tongue helps us connect more with our history, civilization, literature. 2. I would say mother Tongue + English be main medium in academics. I see the over dominance of English in most schools. Instead of eliminating English completely we can take steps to make a child to have a mastery in both his/her language and English before he/she completes schooling. 3. I think removing English will be disastrous. I'm Tamil. Suppose I would like to communicate with a Gujarati, English is a good binding language. Already people are lacking certain basic English skills . if the new policy does away with English, then I fear if that would be a threat to Indian unity in some levels and a weapon for separatists. 4. Without English knowledge, it would be a real hard thing to go through past to recent research papers. Translating them is time consuming process. With the entire globe we may get disconnected. CONCLUSION: let English have the place it has right now and let us push our mother tongues to have equal places.

[@akshaysawant3012]

@Porus You have made a very valid point.

[@abhyudaysinghparmar6055]

I'm from Madhya Pradesh I'm quite fluent in English but I didn't learn it in school in fact most of us learn English beacuse of wide amount of availability of English content. Btw I think gov should introduce inter state student exchange

[@abhyudaysinghparmar6055]

@stillwater 82 yes except in south everywhere hindi works very fine be it punjab, maharashtra, bengal even in so much isolated north east n ladakh. I think if 1.4 billion hv to choose one common language to communicate why not one of the language of the land.

[@abhyudaysinghparmar6055]

@stillwater 82 I nvr said imposition is da way as time will pass Indians surely will realize it would have been much better if we hv choosen a Indians lang

[@abhyudaysinghparmar6055]

@stillwater 82 good to hear that

[@sumankpm]

Valuable info deepak .... but already the damage is done....

[@rationalmanav3085]

Yes by d stupid nehru government.

[@rationalmanav3085]

@Stratus how???🙄🙄🙄

[@rationalmanav3085]

@Stratus what r u speaking say directly🙄🙄🙄. I m not understanding

[@rationalmanav3085]

@Stratus in that period prakrit or sanskrit was a common language between south nd north. Nd there was a mutual sharing of both languages and culture. Like worship of Shiva,vishnu,shakti,kaali,kartikeyan comes from dravidian culture nd similarly indra,surya,saraswati,brahma r indo-aryan traditions. Nd also there r many dravidian elements in indo-aryan languages nd vice versa for dravidian languages. But from d past 70 years nehruvian ideology inspired with western bootlicking,communism nd low esteem on our rich culture which resulted in d radicalisation of Hindus also due to lack of their knowledge on their own holy scriptures. Also more division being happening bcoz of d pseudo-liberalism,communist nd leftist ideology.

[@rationalmanav3085]

@Stratus I am not a andhbhakht of BJP though I do support BJP as it is only one of d nationalist party compared to shitty Congress nd other parties. Even. BJP has too much faults nd some ultra right wingers r too hindu fanatics that is ruining d image of BJP nd Hinduism. Our countries main problems r not muslims but with d pseudo-liberalism,communist and congress type leftist ideology. Even extreme right wing is also a threat which is making d Hindus kind of more fanatic hindu.

[@chethands3862]

Every state should make English as medium of instruction like AP, English and mother tongue will unite every Indian.

[@thaache]

அன்புத் தமிழர்களே!!, நீங்கள் கட்டாயம் படிக்கவேண்டியது:- நீங்கள் இடும் கருத்துக்களை முடிந்தவரை தயவுசெய்து தமிழில் #தமிழ் எழுத்துக்களில் மட்டுமே இடுங்கள்... இது ஒரு தாழ்மையான வேண்டுகோள்... . ஏனெனில், [கூகுள், பேசுபுக்கு, யூட்டியூப், துவிட்டர், இலிங்டின், இன்சுடாகிராம், ஆமேசான் போன்றவை நிறைந்த] *இணைய ஞாலத்தினுள்*, தமிழானது, எந்த அளவிற்கு நம்மால் நாள்தோறும் *புழங்கப்படுகிறதோ*, அந்த அளவிற்கு தமிழின் முதன்மையையும் இன்றியமையாமையையும் உணர்ந்து, அரசுகளும் பன்னாட்டு நிறுவனத்தார்களும் தங்களது சேவைகளை தமிழில் அளிக்க முன்வருவர்.. . காரணம், இன்று அனைத்து முடிவுகளும் '#பெருந்தரவு'கள், #செயற்கை_நுண்ணறிவு மற்றும் #புள்ளியியல்_கணக்குகள் ஆகியவற்றின் அடிப்படையிலேயே எடுக்கப்படுகின்றது, என்பதைத் தெளிவாக அறிந்துகொள்ளுங்கள்... நாமெல்லாம் தொடர்ந்து இணையம் வாயிலாக எழுதிடும் இடுகைகளானவை, பெருநிறுவனங்களுக்கும் அரசுகளுக்கும், நம் மொத்த மக்களின் விருப்புவெறுப்புகளையும் நம் எண்ணப்போக்குகளையும் கணிக்கப் பயன்படும் பெருந்தரவுகளாக அமைந்துவிடுகின்றன என்பதைப் புரிந்துகொள்ளுங்கள்.. . மலையாளிகளும் வங்காளிகளும் பஞ்சாபிகளும் இந்தப்புரிதலோடு தமது பெரும்பாலான இடுகைகளை தத்தங்கள் மொழிகளின் எழுத்துக்களிலே இடுகின்றனர்.. . விழித்திடுங்கள் தமிழர்களே!!.. . [..அதற்காக, பிறமொழிகளை வெறுக்கவேண்டும் என்பதல்ல இதன் பொருள்..] . மற்றொரு வேண்டுகோள்: உங்கள் வட்டார வழக்கிற்கும் முதன்மை அளியுங்கள்.. . யாராவது இதைப்பார்த்து தமிழில் எழுதத் துவங்கிட மாட்டார்களா, என்ற ஓர் ஏக்கம் தான்.. . பார்க்க:- ௧) www.internetworldstats.com/stats7.htm ௨) www.adweek.com/digital/facebooks-top-ten-languages-and-who-is-using-them/amp/ ௩) en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_used_on_the_Internet ௪) www.oneskyapp.com/blog/top-10-languages-with-most-users-on-facebook/ ௫) speakt.com/top-10-languages-used-internet/ . திறன்பேசில் எழுதிட:- ஆன்டிராய்ட்:- ௧) play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.inputmethod.hindi ௨) play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mak.tamil ௩) play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.murasu.sellinam . ஆப்பிள் ஐபோன்/ஐபேடு/மேக்:- ௪) tinyurl.com/yxjh9krc ௫) tinyurl.com/yycn4n9w . கணினியில் எழுதிட:- உலாவி வாயிலாக:- ௧) chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/google-input-tools/mclkkofklkfljcocdinagocijmpgbhab ௨) wk.w3tamil.com/tamil99/index.html . மைக்ரோசாப்ட் வின்டோசு:- ௩) download.cnet.com/eKalappai/3000-2279_4-75939302.html . லினக்சு:- ௪) www.arulraj.net/2011/01/type-tamil-in-ubuntu.html ௫) askubuntu.com/questions/129407/how-do-i-turn-on-phonetic-typing-for-tamil . குரல்வழி எழுதிட:- tinyurl.com/y6d7wd6r , என்பதில் வரும் செயலிகளை முயற்சித்துப்பாருங்கள். குறிப்பாக "கூகுள் சீபோர்ட்: play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.inputmethod.latin " தனை முயற்சித்துப் பாருங்கள். . இதில் உடன்பாடு கொண்டவர்கள் ஒரு "விருப்பத்தையோ" 👍 உங்கள் கருத்தையோ பதிலாக இட்டு, இச்செய்தியை (பிற தளங்களிலும் உள்ள) உங்களுக்குத் தெரிந்தவர்களிடமும் நண்பர்களிடமும் தவறாமல் *பகிர்ந்திடுங்கள்*. பகிர்ந்துகொள்வதற்கான இணைப்பு => thaache.blogspot.com/2020/09/blog-post.html . நன்றி. தாசெ, நாகர்கோவில்--------

[@sravanvedala7811]

Clarity and speed in the speech are the two solid advantages for this guy.

[@ananthaswath5543]

Sir, and right packaging.

[@hellodhani]

You said it right. But conveniently mute yourself regarding the hindi imposition on non Hindi speakers. Let yourself comprehensive towards what you tell. Thank you.

[@naiyayika]

Sanskrit must be taught. English can be taught as a language and the mother tongue in the form of club activities. Trilingual capabilities will link India with an ancient language and English professionally and mother tongue for our pride.

[@adarshactivity]

Joker

[@Aaauum]

how do you translate lacks of journals and technical papers in medicine, engineering, biology, physics and so on to all the native languages.....you need to create lacks of equal-ant terms for all the words to all the native language.. do you think its practical.....even to create words in single language from English. That being said its practical to create all in to Sanskrit which will unite all the Indian states.. by appointing retired profs and scientist, technical experts in all the fields...but not any sooner....definitely its possible to make medium of instruction in one language across in india...

[@ashoks5317]

J.Saideepak always short and crisp.

[@chandrandec31]

But in this case inadequate unfortunately. No solution he just gives an opinion without going into the difficulties of implementing it in current melting pot that is India.

[@Indian-lq8ue]

Sanskrit has very immense knowledge documented in it. India should make it's national language as Sanskrit. Instead of spending crores of rupees for Hindi prachara samithi, should spend on teaching every Indian our old culture rich Sanskrit. Britishers intentionally kept Indian's away from Sanskrit to steal our knowledge keep us away from knowledge. Example every formula like, value of PI, pythogorus theoram, Newton's law of motion documented in Sanskrit in the form of Sholkas in very ancient times itself. But Britishers stole them from Sanskrit and projecting it as they invented it.

[@KannapiranArjunan-vm2rq]

The problem is all tom, Dick and harry on.education and language policy...Mother tongue AND English languages enough... don't worry citizens know what is good for them .

[@ytadltspv]

this is a questionable perspective. 1. whatever technical knowledge each region has, no one has documented it and its not uniform - and this cant be an excuse to make sanskrit the national lang saying all available texts are in that lang. most of the texts are gone and whats left is what white and non-white scholars transliterated. since its proven that western technology has accomplished more, better to learn english and learn that or those texts in local languages. then theres the issue of transacting with the outside world - english is easier and alredy in use - why reinvent the wheel 2. this learned man should fight to get education back to state list from concurrent and drive policies to respect states and federalism. 3. hindi-guys are riding roughshod on the south with no one able to do anything. State govts are also more guilty coz they have no moral level to stand up to the center and ensure importance for state language. all central govt jobs exams are in hindi or english and north indians aim to grab all the central govt jobs all over the country while the southern state people suffer. all state govts should ensure exams are in respective langs also and 90% salaried central govt jobs should go to locals. 4. ridiculous amounts allotted to sanskrit should stop or all langs should get equal amounts so state lang univ. can open , give more jobs to state-lang-medium educated people. local language and english should be prominent with 3rd lang being any foreign language - we have to prepare to be global citizens - or hindi if people choose it, they will learn hindi anyway if they have to migrate or transact and more importantly, if theres enough opps. in every state , people wont even need to migrate.

[@Thepatriotpodcast24]

Apart from commansense n general observation even scientific Researchs show that acquiring education in foreign language requires several times extra efforts than that in native language. Today the harsh reality is that our students who studied in English medium schools neither have the proficiency in hindi or mother tongue nor can they speak english fluently n articulately (hardly go beyond hi hhru in eng)thanks to Nehru😂 Our Education system seriously need urgent overhaul....if the current dispensation can't revist n revise the system n remove the systemic flaws then who? But for executive n legislature to take steps in this direction ,pressure has to come from comman masses represented by intellectuals like jsd.....

[@brainymandar6]

Thank, you didn't bat for Hindi. मराठी and other regional languages are far far evolved. English should be number 1 for people, mother tongue should be number 2 and depending on the interest French /Spanish /German could be third or any other Indian language as per the choice and interest.

[@यवधेशसांचीहरसंस्कृत]

हमें गुरुकुल व्यवस्था चाहिए। तीन भाषा समीकरण सर्वश्रेष्ठ है। हिन्दी व मातृभाषा दोनों को होना चाहिए। विदेशी एक कोई भी भाषा सीखाती जा सकती हैं।

[@rajivjha123]

agree English should not for sure but one issue . People keep changing the states , through this mechanism people of 1 state will need to settle their own state due to children's education . Why people had issue with Sanskitized language understood by 90 % + removal of urdu from it ? This language sounds sister language of any Indian language . so, mothertongue + this language . check language spoken by Modi yesterday regarding the virus - It's very different than Bollywood + so called Hindi AND the scripts is devnagiri .

[@srikarsrivatsadahagam3859]

We are a country which is Hindu majority,all Indians must learn languages which have roots in Sanatan Dharma only. This refers to any language that is used in India, any means any.

[@geethar3573]

I don't agree with u. English based language is most convenient for all practical purposes. In fact it should effectively implemented in villages. Mother tongues r best within four walls. A majority of the Indian and nris as have benefitted from this language. In fact, it has been their rice bowl. Whenever I visit some place in Tamil Nadu I will feel my life squeezed out trying to communicate with the hotel (lodge) staff coz they know only one language. I feel discouraged to visit Tamil Nadu again. Back here I will relate my night mare experiences with ten others. Consequently, this will speak on tamilnad tourism.

[@Nitinbharatpur]

100% agree with technical education also should be imposed in local language..

[@vyseerx]

English is a language and it is not a sign of intelligence. No where in the world ( except India) it is considered as intelligence. The truth is those opposing English are unable to learn one more language. As simple as that. Telugus do not want to learn Tamil, Tamils vice versa, and the list goes on. Any language can be spoken very fluently if one knows few thousand words. If one can memorize few thousand words of any language that becomes a skill, if it is English, it is even bigger skill. The economic opportunities that abound with English are unlimited. India at the current status can not and will not be able offer Technical education in local langugaes. Imagine Anatomy being translated to Telugu/ Tamil. Extensor carpi radialis longus- the name of tendon which is on the lateral (radial side) and it is attached to carpal bones, and it has a long belly. All the function is implied in the name of the tendon. Now we are struggling to call Train / cell phone in our own local languages. How do we build vocabulary for these complicated stuff in Medicine /Engineering? Now if we do, one who does the education in Telugu, can not function in Chennai, even though he is born and raised in Tirupathi few hours from Chennai. If one is so restricted to one geographical area, who want to pursue that kind of education? The argument that students of Medicine and Engineerinng in English medium are trained to serve the people of USA and UK is baseless. 80% of these stay in India, and they are perfectly fine, speaking the local languages and English aplomb, no issues at all. The argument that we need to preserve our languages - is same as preserving Ayurveda, try do that when your father has heart attack, and try giving some Ashwagantha or natrum moore.

[@nerf2752]

I think accepting gov. to teach people properly is idiotic. they so bad at it. every middle-class and upper-class person should hire their own tutors to teach and the poor class should use school because they can't afford it anyway. gov should only manage exams

[@sumitdutta7043]

I think the following criteria should be used in language case: Divide into regions, e.g. North Region consisting of language Hindi Punjabi Ladakh region lang.. East Region consisting of language Odia, Bengali, etc North East languages. West Region consisting Gujarati and Marathi, and lang. of Goa (I don't know what it is) South Region consisting of Telgu Tamil Malayalam and Kannada Now do the following change in education system. Two language is to be selected for studing, both the language must be from different region. Frow Class 1 to 8 these 2 lang. are compulsary. Introduce English and Sanskrit as language in class 3 and teach it upto class 10 Mode of Sanskrit( Devnagri Script) since in that only earlier scriptures were written. At class 9 choose one lang. out of the 2 (which were taught upto class 8) In class 11 choose any two among the remaining 3 lang. or in place of english one can choose computer language (python C++ JAVA C etc.) But with english one can't choose computer lang. Other option in class 11 12 don't teach language at all. If somebody wants to suggest something they are invited....

[@sumitdutta7043]

Replacement of English is not possible atleast for few centuries it is impossible (as far as I know) There is nothing wrong in studying english (science and maths) should be taught in english only (modern science) but that doesn't mean you shouldn't know the terms in your native language, word meaning must be in all the language that you are studying. Maths should be taught in area specific language upto class 3 after that in english Similarly upto class 8 Science should be taught in area specific language after than in english. Regarding social science also same as science i.e. after class 8 either in english or sanskrit(if possible) in social science also geography must be in english throughout. Student must be able to translate the sentences grammatically correct into all the languages he/she was taught into. Taking into account what you said about sanskrit We must use some common script for writing otherwise it will impossible to implement it so let the expert choose any common script. I think the priority should be given to the languge in which most of the vedas are written. Hate of Tamil Nadu and Kerala are man made based on that Aryan Invasion crap (automatically communists are responsible) which is a total nonsense. First nullification of such thinking is necessary. Already languages are given thejr proper position and respect as per above rule. None is taking their language away infact sanskrit is introduced later (i.e. in class 3) in the ladder. If any modifications required do suggest.

[@sumitdutta7043]

@ರಾಹುಲ Rahul First of all sanskrit was actually taught a long time ago so it will take time again to reestablish it (atleast 25 years) Again reduce the slot of english don't eliminate the whole language. As I have mentioned in the rules english teaching will start at later stage (i.e. class 3) In order to eliminate any language 1st reduce its importance at the global level then think further. Language will survive if above rules are applied thoroughly. Now sanskrit is mother of language Yaa its true no doubt in that. But still with time its importance reduces and new languages are born. Howsoever great one language may be it is ultimately the impure form of sanskrit. But still new languages form and no one can stop it from forming up. Sanskrit itself got changed many a times. Pre Vedic sanskrit may be considered as the pure form of sanskrit. After that comes the Panini's Sanskrit. And the current modern sanskrit. Scriptures were either in very old sanskrit (especially vedas) which is very very very difficult to understand even now. Commentaries of Sâyanachâya are used to understand that. Even the chanting of vedic mantras are different from that of vedic period. Now a days chanting is no doubt great but it is different from those times. Now there are some problems with sanskrit: One word can have many meanings and many words can imply to same thing. Meanings depend on different factors. Thats why sometimes it is very difficult to understand shlokas/mantras without a proper teacher. UPANISHADS' mantras were understood differently by Shankaracharya, Ramanujachary and Madhvacharya (unfortunately all three came at different times otherwise the problem would have sorted out by debates) Becouse of that Advaita, Vishishtadvaita and Dvaits philosophies of vedanta came. Now if the probleb of many meaning nd similar type if sorted out with the help of modern sanskrit then its good. Slowly shift to sanskrit in common platform talks. Now no more further clarification by my side... Lets see what will happen in future.

[@Jagadiswar]

We want equal status for all 22 language.stop Hindi imperialism

[@alberttanner408]

English Sanskrit Mother Tongue

[@srinivasaraom393]

Thank you for the straight and honest talk. I could have written the previous sentence better had it been in my mother tongue, despite studying in English medium.

[@aswanisharma50]

your home minister wants to impose Hindi on entire nation and insists that people of different languages should choose Hindi instead of English while his own hindi is poor.

[@kaushikbanerjeekb724]

Why do you need to speak in English

[@rsr201]

I agree completely with Mr. Sai but I would like to make an important addition- imparting education in various Indian languages in their respective states WITHOUT making Sanskrit mandatory at least till secondary School would be disastrous. India is an ancient civilization and its linguistic diversity, though something that makes us proud, is unfortunately the reason why people from one part of India may not feel well connected to people from other parts of the country because there is no sense of commonness except for the fact that English is something that can be understood by all. Although I believe a foreign language should not be the reason for our unity, I think doing away with English as an instructional medium in education WITHOUT making students learn Sanskrit, which is the actual cause of our unity, we may be further widening the divide, and not bridging it. If Sanskrit is made mandatory at least till class 10, what you say can be actually realised without any negative effects.

[@rsr201]

@ರಾಹುಲ Rahul of course Sanskrit would play the role of a link language and not a common language. And I don't mean to say Sanskrit should be taught at the cost of regional languages, but should be taught ALONG WITH regional languages as a tool to make young Indians aware of their common civilizational roots.

[@nagarajk7863]

@Stratus You guys better learn Tamil

[@rationalmanav3085]

@Stratus 1st sanskritize hindi not dis disguised urdu in d name of hindi.

[@madhumahadev2083]

@Stratus . Hogi dabakond malko bevarsi

[@rationalmanav3085]

@@madhumahadev2083 dont pay attention he is a leftist troller.

[@HitheshKumarplus]

Woah Super point

[@Jagadiswar]

In India English is the only linking language among other languages

[@lopa4899]

While it is good to promote the language of the state, it would give rise to many problems. For example, a person studying in Gujarati medium transfers to Tamil Nadu where Tamil is the medium taught, then it would give lots of problems for that person to adjust. Also, I agree languages like Tamil should be promoted and wouldn't like it to be lost like Sanskrit has.

[@youraveragegachatuber]

Totally agree with Mr. Sai Deepak. This is exactly the reason why many Indian native & even officially recognized languages are dying. Most of the European countries do not have English as medium of instructions, they give priority to their mother tongue. English can be learnt as a language and need not be the language for instruction or medium for teaching. There are external exams for English such as Cambridge which can be taken up separately and schools can facilitate these exams.

[@sugatasenmazumdar7704]

What hypothesis? Didn't get it

[@chinmayalat7989]

Totally agree. The revival of Bharatiya languages is absolutely necessary. Will also bring a revival of the pluralistic bharatiya sanskriti. As I understand that a language is a creation of culture and not vice versa, similarly if each and every language is revived the organic nature of the Indic culture/s will also revive and the silly conflict created by the monocled political minded abrahmics will also be countered effectively.

[@shoaibahmed2122]

Hypocrisy level ,when he said we need to speak our Vernacular language and he speaks consecutively in English language..this is your Mr intellectual..

[@dmcindianfan5374]

Exactly bro if i start asking him what do you say in your mother tongue transport names jaise car bike or motorcycle train truck tractor bus Activa ya scooty bulldozer Jeep scooter aeroplane helicopter ambulance fire brigade or jitne bhi electronic items hai jaise AC TV cooler heater bulb tubelight freezer refrigerator washing machine mixer grinder blender microwave oven or daily usable items like laptop computer camera mobile jaise chizo ko or public places jaise banks railway station bus stand hospital or jitne bhi stationery items hai jaise pen pencil rubber ya eraser sharpener etc etc Or fishes name jaise shark 🦈 whale 🐋🐳 octopus 🐙🦑 dolphin 🐬 He won't be able to tell this also category wise list is too long this was just 4 to 5 categories 😂😅

[@kalpanasingh7929]

Had we used are own languages in work field we would have been far ahead of the time, though it's never too late.

[@alberttanner408]

India is a continent

[@ThatRitikPatel]

Bohut achi Video hai agar hindi me hoti to share karke dusro ko bhi dikhata..

[@dineshamboji8850]

Beautiful thought

[@kaushikbanerjeekb724]

Bogus

[@VijayRana78]

बहुत अच्छा सर। मैं अपने सारे ग्रुप में भेजूंगा।

[@hata1349]

Class

[@kaushikbanerjeekb724]

Join Rajneeti sir,

[@omkarreddy7836]

absolutely loved the thought here.........i want your opinion on sanskrith,every temple and every priest uses sanskrith slokas irrespective of their local languages,so if a priest is able to understand and use it,why not try it as a lingua prima,taking the place of english.and use person's own mother tongue as secondary language in our education system....adv:-it will impart a collective feeling at national level with preserving one's own indigenous identity......(just a thought,feel free to debate and express your ideas)

[@চলচ্চিত্রকথা]

ya it can be used as a link bhasha

[@AdityaKadamMechanical]

If we pledge to maximize speaking in native languages. International value of the native language will increase & people knowing the native language, his international value will increase. Just like stock market😃❤️

[@unknownAnsunknown]

Jai shree ram ❤️

[@saileshbabut9696]

Of course We can't deny English to communicate with other parts of the world. But learning should be in Mother tongue, and English should be learnt as another language only but not the medium of learning

[@jnagarajan3489]

You are wrong. Those who study in their mother tongue cannot go to other states for employment. Our unity will be destroyed. Regionalism has already grown . Karnataka wants only Kannadigas, Maharashtra wants only Marathis, Haryana wants only Haryanvis, but , where will an Indian go ?. English and mother tongue should be compulsory upto IVth standard ,and, after IVth standard, medium of instruction should be English throughout India. Otherwise, India will break up. HInduism and English are the two pillars of Indian society. If one is broken, India will collapse as one nation. Don't forget what happened in Maharashtra where U.P. wallahs and Biharis were asked to leave Mumbai. The day is not far off when we will see similar situation in other states.

[@MayankSharma333]

mother tongue should be spoken. However we NEED one language that is known by everyone... Government needs to promote one language that is devoid of state politics and English is the natural winner.

[@dipankardas1760]

Tyre, tube, tube insert, rim, spokes, valve, valve pin, valve cap. Translate this in any local language of your choice if you can. This is only cycle wheel, more to come, lol.

[@hman8100]

Lamhuage emphasis is alright, but not necessarily for clothing.

[@dhiyaneshsivakumaran9201]

Alongside of encouraging regional state languages we should invade English and Urdu impregnated Hindi with Samskritam and Bharat's native languages like Tamil, Bengoli etc and other age old languages. We should make sure that finally the mere grammar and basic vocabulary of English and Muhal bred Urdu Hindi remains just as a slave to serve us Indians.

[@RameshSingh-kc8yg]

Great views on language policy. As we need native language as communication skill in whole country.

[@sumandasgupta6179]

indian scholars must write in Indian local languages ...else for higher education you will not get good books in those local languages

[@srikanchimahan1674]

I feel and take pride claiming that you are a great orator, a fountain head of knowledge.Let Periyavaa bless you with a lot of knowledge .....

[@renjiddavid]

One need to "learn and understand what he studies" ..For that the professors need to explain them in mother tounge . I have done my education in Malayalam. now also I think in Malayalam when I work but I use English to communicate. People going and settling in other country is their choice, We (INDIA) should give more attractions to people to stay back. Unemployment caused not becuase of Educational system, It is the failure of Govt .. especially this Govt. We are not a poisiton of Job inflation. We dont have job oppertunities. That Govt should fix it . Each family should promote their mother tounge which will gradually improve the usage of local languages.

[@chandrandec31]

Cannot agree completely, not practical. It is not so simple as you say. You said about bridge course for those who want to out of the confines of his state. But what about those who already out of the state? Who will teach them their mother tongue properly forget about being language of instruction? What if they want to go back to their home state or another state with different language? Don't you think here also we need a bridge course to learn mother tongue (I'm not talking about spoken language at home, and there are those who don't even know to speak in their mother tongue and have adopted another tongue, friend tongue, teacher tongue, hehe) or a bridge course to learn the language of the new state he is migrating to? Already we have too much pride in the mother that India is on the verge of disintegration. Just talk about oldest language and see the fight that erupts. There has to be a different language policy not just mother tongue, English, Hindi etc. Multiple choices should be available.

[@naman_solanki]

This is the point I have read today. (Book - Gandhi for 21st century and my views on Education)

[@unrefusableoffer4412]

The reason i took English was because of the discrimination against my mother tongue.

[@pranavkarthik845]

The new education policy have brought this idea. sadly im not the beneficiary 😔😔

[@activeantzclub6150]

The language issue is the "urgent need" to be considered by the govt of India. Every language of this country has its own rich tradition and history. Starting from Kashmir to Kanyakumari and Katch to 7 sister's of NorthEast. According to me the 1) people of this country first get rid of their blind love towards English language. Yes English is required not at the cost of our native languages. 2) Start loving each language of this great land and place your mother tongue in your heart. 3) Teach your kids its mother tongue. Speak to your kid in your mother tongue. 4) Let your kid learn English also, with mindset of "My mother tongue I should never forget" 5) Please Please have pride in this great land history, language, culture. 6) The proud citizens of this country has the highest responsibility to save the languges which took birth in this land.

[@rameshiyer1]

I couldn't resist wading into this language policy argument, as I have for long believed that India is far too culturally and linguistically diverse to adopt any one of its native languages as a 'national' language. In fact, many in Northern parts of India feel that Hindi should be the de facto 'rashtra bhasha' which I strongly disagree with, despite being proficient and fluent in Hindi. India is indeed a very unique country, with perhaps more cultural & linguistic diversity than the whole of Europe. So, just as Europe will never have one common language because of the pride every country in Europe takes in its own native language, India will never have any one language as its 'national' language. Anybody who tries to impose Hindi on the entire country will be disrespecting n belittling the importance of every other regional language. In this regard, I find Article 351 of India's Constitution to be maliciously inserted, urging Hindi to be promoted pan-India gradually to become the 'national' language. So, I disagree with J Sai Deepak that one should be educated in one's own mother tongue, to be able to grasp the concepts better. The fact is, there are books on higher education only in English n a few in Hindi, but negligible in vernacular languages in India. I don't see how one can become an engineer or a doctor by referring to only vernacular texts. Besides, it's beneficial for Indians to learn in English, as those who aspire to go abroad for higher / specialized education will invariably have to do so in English. In fact, it will be very tough for a doctor who's educated in, say Gujarati, to practice in another State where his/her patients don't know Gujarati at all. So, while it's all very well to become torchbearers for native languages in India, realistically, thanks to our colonial past, English will remain our link language and the preferred medium of (higher) education. Perhaps Sanskrit should've been adopted as our link language soon after 1947, as most Indian languages are derived from Sanskrit, which is also believed to be one of the most suitable languages for computing.

[@vimalac8437]

Okay, agree with you,but are you ready to send your children to a Telugu medium school, don't be a hypocrite.

[@RameshTim]

Very good points, but how do you communicate with the fellow Indians who speak other language than your mother tongue?

[@krishnanair9390]

That said, I still believe that students (as a student myself, and as a Sanskrit Lover) should still have English Literature as a subject, and that children should do reading from multiple languages, Indian and non-Indian

[@lookoi9363]

All social sciences can switch over immediately. For science subjects, bett er think deeply before jumping

[@vishaln402]

It should be early before extinction of blocal and minority language so make early and implement strictly as soon as possible

[@omkarreddy7836]

had the constitution been respcted ,this state wouldnt have arisen now,all is to be blamed on 1965 lok sabha to indefinitely stall the lingua prima bill

[@vishnukvv]

It is a common sense to go for all studies...in native language....because we take atleast 10 yrs to learn english to come to a useful state in affairs for a limited use..we can easily acquire almost all studies in native language .....we can acquire thesame with english subtitles lately if required later for a particular subject...because we are not using every study in the later part of life professional/personal use....#narendramodi #BJP4India #BJP4India #KTRTRS

[@amanrooprai1763]

How would you react to the fact that India faced serious secession threats on linguistic lines post independence. There have been similar separatist thoughts experienced around the world.

[@ranjithsuccess]

There is lot of evidence, both Empirical and scientific to prove that education in mother tongue is far superior to that in any foreign language. I have done a very though research on this and also am willing to share the same on any suitable platform.

[@usc4405]

JSai please start your own channel

[@dikshita4666]

Wow sir.. Please be more available.. Kindly spread your knowledge.. Being a good speaker you can awaken our youth... I am your follower and almost share same views as yours.

[@babluyadav3860]

Market era Market destroy all things

[@krishnaprasadkittu]

This is the reason why we are not in a position to command anything on a gobal scale.

[@devrajsinghania6480]

noting each line for upsc mains..

[@AB-jw3mz]

we live in a global village and the language spoken is English. India is the largest English speaking nation in the world. even the French who are rabidly anti English have realized the importance of speaking English. no one thinks that the mother tongue is not important. But doing away with English means a big economic hit for the Indian people.

[@naiyayika]

That's what he says too.

[@buddhadevkonai5390]

Koti koti pronam 🙏

[@jasminekamalabhai]

Mr sai deepak is right.

[@sbos79]

Point to ponder over .

[@KneelBeforeBlue]

The thing is even when English is taught as a third language, it's not taught properly. People can speak it but what they speak is grammatically incorrect.

[@mtarkes]

90% CBSE and 50% ICSE students who learn english as first language speak grammatically wrong English. Very few of the so called English medium school alumni are actually better off than those who studied in local language schools.

[@sueel21284]

Tq n Well said sir.

[@KrishnaKumar-rc7tg]

He talks sense

[@harshbehl4]

Jai Shri Ram

[@cosmiceye2067]

How naive were the founders of India ? Why would anyone think that forming one country with hundreds of languages with rich literature and unique characters would be a good idea ? Did they really expect that we would all get along amd compromise on our native languages for their post modern ideas ? That there would be no impediment to communication and no inability for cohesion ?

[@ambar1969]

Saiji, it has been my feeling that there is Mother Tongue & Mother Dialect. I consider Sanskrit to be our Mother Tongue and the regional languages to be our Mother Dialect. BOTH MUST BE MADE COMPULSORY LEARNING

[@naiyayika]

I second you. 😀

[@LDSharma-hx9zi]

Should Bharat adopt a single national language like China and other nations? If yes, then which language should it be? Since Sanskrit is the language of next Gen AI as per NASA etc., should we also adopt this a s a national language since all language spoken in our Nation today have connection with Sanskrit? We have tried long enough to make all speak Hindi, but some States have never agreed to it and have played politics over it to divide the Nation. What are your thoughts on this K. Sai Deepak?

[@saiyemiftekhar9993]

Ironically, this video is in English. :P

[@mihir469]

I disagree

[@naiyayika]

Insane liberandus will. 😁