A sad farewell: a beautiful migration to a cold region.

After Ziba and her daughter took refuge in a mountain to be safe from her husband, they took refuge in a mountain with her daughter and are building a shelter to continue living there.

[@sarojadevi8693]

Hi viewers don't worry alot about Ziba. She is coming for filming. Just like a picnic. After filming they go back home.

[@annedavies2611]

Shouldn’t even be filming with a child in those conditions. Poor maryam

[@user-ql6oj7bh5n]

У этой женщины явно не все дома, зачем она перебралась в полатку,, ( ради заработка на камеру сидеть на ветру мучить ребёнка есть еду с песком))) Сценарий отпад...

[@user-ru7xf7rs3l]

На этот концерт не возможно смотреть!!!,Могу только сказать что. Упрямство - достоинство Ослов!!!

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

👍👍👍👍👍Tak toçno

[@L-km9ww]

Leaving rude comments is also the virtue of donkeys. Here, a woman is struggling to keep herself and her daughter safe and you and other viewers are leaving mean comments. Be kind

[@bigmag7802]

У этого оператора самый бестолковый сценарий. Просто идиотский. У дороги устроилась. Ну раза два переспит в палатке, вытерпит. А дольше ведь нет. А воду откуда возьмет? А в туалет голой задницей к дороге? На гору же не полезет. Да и вообще. ещё куча житейских и личных нюансов. Что-то она меня полностью разочаровала. Действительно непутёвая вместе с оператором.

[@marahardok3845]

😂😂😂😂

[@user-zl3sn1vl7u]

โง่สุดๆ

[@L-km9ww]

Use your brain. This is real life, not a show! She's near to the road so that if anything dangerous happens she can easily escape or someone can pick her up! Don't worry about how she uses the toilet or where her water comes from. Are YOU the person who's going to take her to the toilet or pay for her water? No, right? So BE KIND and STOP BEING SO CRUEL

[@rosajudithangel7926]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 de acuerdo 👍🏻

[@user-jt1qz4ne6q]

คนโง่มากๆ ทำไมเธอไปฟ้องศาลของเมืองเขาว่าความชั่วของๆสามีเธอมีอะไรบ้าง คุณหนี ก็จงหนีจนตายไปเลย นึกถึงลูกที่พูดไม่เป็นบ้างน่ะ อย่าเอาแต่สมองของตัวเองมาคิดทำไปจะพ้นหน้าสามี

[@user-mo7uj7bm3g]

Если Зиба уедет в город и снимет там жилье, то от ЮТУБа ей ничего капать не будет. Главное за что им платят, это стройка и драки

[@lara_lora_]

Совершенно верно.А ещё плохой уход за дочкой.Это неприемлемо.

[@ludmila360]

У Зибы сегодня, с мужем, романтический вечер))) костер, палатка.

[@gypsyrose2424]

And they cooked chicken & potato stew as well. 😂

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

😅😅😅😅💃💃👍

[@L-km9ww]

What a sick mind to think this is all fake, and laugh at her. Wow, let's try to be kind and show compassion, don't be a bully or a Karen

[@L-km9ww]

Without any proof that her husband came there, you cannot call her a liar or fake. Even when Ali filmed at the same time as her, anyone with eyes could see how strangely he behaved and how he mistreated her

[@user-nd5gq9pd8x]

Оператор мог привезти продукты . Думаю,что нужно быть добрее.😢

[@user-nj1zy8rm6w]

Интересно кто воду будет возить,там Мырза а тут , вода сама будет приходить к Зибе.Там пошла в магазин и купила,а тут курица сама пришла и сказала приготовь меня.Смешно.

[@marijakasperska5207]

Видимо пока сама вода к ней приходит и мясо примороженно 😊

[@user-mi5ez2zu5v]

Когда жила в своём доме постоянно где-то гуляла!а теперь хочет показать себя любящей и хозяйственной?бери машину и поезжай к родне в гости!ты же не можешь одна жить!тебе скучно!сейчас пару дней повыделываешься и опять гулять пойдёшь!или муж придумает сценарий,что он вас нашёл!🤣🤣🤣

[@marialenirsantos]

Cadê a pei deste pais..cadê a acolhida da família ...tem que dar um pau no marinheiro do marido dela...sem dizer que parede que ela está gravida..

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

😅😅😅😅👍

[@bluelagoon9990]

Think she's really fed up if Ali this time and wants to make sure he won't get to them for a good while

[@lara_lora_]

@@bluelagoon9990 Возможно муж ведёт съёмку.

[@tatyanalitvina6336]

Вместо того чтоб занятся ребенком, обследовать, научить говорить она бегает по горам, ты Зиба не видишь свою главную проблему,зачем подвегаешь ребенка опасности

[@user-zt3df7sy4v]

Она не живёт в этом месте Она живёт в доме А здесь просто сьемка

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

Qızın başı xarabdı.

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

Yazıq uşağın günahı nədi?. Soyuqda sağa sola🎉 sürükləyir,uşağı pula görə bu başı xarab qız. Polisə vermək lazımdı. Əzab verirlər uşağa. Birini saxlaya bilmir, hələ ikincisini zülmə salmağa hazırlaşır. Rzziyəə kimi kar qulaq edər Məryəmi də bu soyuqda.

[@user-xx9tp4wv3c]

Zιμπα δεν σε λειπαμε Δεν εχεις μιαλο δεν σκεφτεσαι το μορο Να πας στη μανα σου να εισαι ποιο καλα και οχοι να τρεχεις στα βουνα με ενα μορο εισαι τρελει δεν σε λειπαμε τα θελει ο κολο σου βλαμενη

[@lady4715]

Hoe kan ze een probleem zien ,als ze niet goed in der hoofd is net als haar zus met baby,wie doet nou je kind dit aan om zo te leven😮

[@user-pm1lc8us8v]

Что за глупый сюжет? Ведь ребенок может заболеть. Ещё она получит большой стресс. По- моему она из-за испуга итак не разговаривает. Зиба, так нельзя относиться к ребёнку. Ужас! Россия

[@tatyanalitvina6336]

Скорее всего Али всегда с палками на Зибу замахивается, может и по нарошку, а ребенок воспринимает по настоящемуу Марьям испуг, не один ребёнок спокойно не будет смотреть как унижают и бьют его мать

[@LeConifly]

Tambien creo que es emocional , para qué hablar si los padres gritan siempre , eso no le gusta , le teme y no habla . Es sicológico , tampoco le atrae la idea de crecer , teme ambos procesos , mejor seguir siendo guagua porque el mundo que le muestran es hostil .... Eso creo y me hace sentido .

[@LeConifly]

Continuación .... por eso es lactante , se alimenta de su madre , es más seguro .

[@marahardok3845]

Pior que Maryam está doente, com tosse gripada e está com o rostinho machucado e inchado. A Ziba é muito canastrona como atriz, acaba rindo nos piores momentos, até nos diverte, mas prejudicar um bebê não é engraçado :(

[@L-km9ww]

It's her life. If you can't bear to watch it, don't keep judging, go watch a different channel

[@user-un4hv4jq8w]

Не мучай ребенка иди жить к маме.

[@L-km9ww]

The mother is already taking on so much. Have compassion and understand Ziba wants to not burden her mother further

[@user-ns9el5nr1q]

Дура Зиба, на день на ребёнка куртку, из-за денег застудишь. Зибу надо вместе с оператором в психушку

[@emmafrick665]

ребенок выглядет уже как БОМЖ ,который живет только на улице ,а ведь она красивая девочка ,мама не нормальная , принимает не правильные решения, вся семья живет хорошо ,а один брат чуть ли не во дворце 👎👎👎

[@stanislavabagariova5722]

Ziba chce,aby ji všichni litovali. Chudák dítě 😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@user-rx8ko6li8c]

Почему к маме ? У неё с мужем свой дом есть , она там и живёт. На съёмки она приезжает, отработает и домой. Оператор ,её муж

[@user-me4ph9ii9i]

Ну вот как вам не стыдно, ради денег показывать такое отношение к детям. ведь ребенок постоянно болеет.Потому что раздетый и босиком.

[@maggiegibson7183]

How can they do this to kids for money. Whole family is using Viewers.

[@BABYGIRL19538]

The child is a her and the child doesn’t like wearing her shoes she takes them off Yeah ur right it’s stupid to leave her family you can see she afraid of her ex husband he’s crazy 🤪 but using KZbin for money so Maryam can eat . ❤Maryam not being abuse stop accusing the camera guy of it . Seek jesus.

[@marahardok3845]

@@BABYGIRL19538não se incomode por isso, é só filmagem para o KZbin. Procure os videos onde Ziba e Ali brigam, ela nunca consegue esconder que estão fingindo e da risada. Até aquela vez que ele roubou a Maryam e a esposa do Mirza a encontrou ela ri.

[@gypsyrose2424]

She won't stay their long😂 she'll run out of water & wood. Why would anybody in their right mind take a child to live beside a road ? Not a good storyline Bahar.

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

She now hiding very well that close to the highway. This script was not thought out very well. I wonder if Ziba or Ali wrote this script?

[@user-vu6ko2xw8j]

Она создала ещё хуже условия для ребёнка, чем были.Теперь точно могут дочь забрать и отдать отцу.Ей надо к матери идти.

[@user-ce3zr5bf6j]

본집에 있을때도 음식 잘 않 해먹든 사람이 여기선 요리열심하네요😅 닭은 어디서 큰냄비는 어제 없었는대 엄마집에서 가저왓나 요?😂

[@gypsyrose2424]

Agree 😂

[@user-gh9zn8jz7m]

Ali brought her chicken & a pot or she brought them this morning from her comfortable home where she lives with her so called addict abusive husband! 😅😂

[@tatyanalitvina6336]

Зиба если ты хочешь много подписчиков чтоб смотрели канал, для начала купи землю в красивом месте, начни строить дом, но не сама, а специально обученные люди, все должно быть красиво, а не как нибуть, обустроть дом, цветы, деревья, декоративная трава, и занятия с дочерью, а то что ты сидишь под трансформатором никому неинтересно

[@user-yq6qj1gc5t]

Все правильно.

[@MarinaM-vy9eh]

В доме когда жила не готовила,шастала по улицам,кому теперь готовит🤣Если в крови есть попрошайничество,его не очистишь.

[@lara_lora_]

Тому,кто её снимает.

[@gulsumkeskin4087]

Kameramana ce kendine ve çocuğa kameraman (bahar) yardım eder korkmayın bugün o et nerden geldi tabiki bahar getirdi

[@galinashemetova]

Не хочется смотреть этот спектакль, откуда она взяла новую кастрюлю, чашки новые, такая примермерная.Плохой аанал

[@user-ub1lm7vg7f]

Сюжет ужасный. Я отписалась😮

[@user-im2vf8nt9y]

Зибу никто не найдет! Обхохочешься! Невидимка ! Спектакль!

[@danasvobodova2439]

Snažím se. ale nemohu pochopit jejich způsob života. Sleduji to jako film .

[@marialuisadufourcandelaria2907]

Seguramente a pie de carretera no pasa nadie, y nadie la va a notar, mejor se hubiera ido afuera de la casa del marido y las cuñadas, para acabar pronto, no se si es tonta o se hace.con no volver a ver sus videos termino.

[@sova2077]

😂😂😂😂😂людишки ведутся,переживают,ой народ тупой

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

😅😅😅😅

[@valfr3241]

É pra acaba um negócio deste escondendo na beira da estrada 😂 gente para com isso volta pra casa ou vai morar com a mãe, senegrafista não tem lógica isso 😂

[@user-cl3fp5sc3i]

Ziba, operator, Ali you guys are not ashamed to put that little girl in that situation just for the film? For money? Shame on all of you

[@L-km9ww]

You don't know this is fake. No mother would willingly put her child in harm's way. Be nice, besides nothing is wrong with Maryam

[@letjoanin]

I agree. KZbin is easy money for them. They don't seem to care that they're traumatizing their daughter.

[@bluelagoon9990]

Well unless you live with them or know them personally you don't know they doing this "just for money" Some people actually have challenges y'know... Not everyone is born in America or Europe or any country with many resources and where women have lots of rights

[@sofiaobar9224]

I agree 80% of women in that country have no rights not equal to men but much better compared to other middle Eastern countries

[@user-vh8ty5jv9v]

Такая ерунда,ужас, смотреть не хочется,убежала,на дороге расположилась,ума совсем нет.

[@user-ht2ne7nr5p]

А рядом электровышка она ничего не излучает?

[@L-km9ww]

Be kind, try to see things from her perspective. If you want to leave, its fine

[@user-nj1zy8rm6w]

У нас говорят .Дурная голова ногам покоя не даёт .

[@L-km9ww]

And rude comments make you a bully

[@maryellenhanson9049]

That child is traumatized !

[@maggiegibson7183]

Suffer own kids for money God is Watching.

[@user-dv3my6rb8f]

Ничего не придумали еще, чтоб весь мир посмеялся???? Дешовое шок!!!!

[@altavanderwesthuizen1472]

THOSE OF YOU WHO CARE ABOUT MARYAM PLEASE REPORT THIS EMOSIONALY CHILD ABUSE TO KZbin!!!!!!! 😢😢😢😢😢

[@annedavies2611]

Agree. And sekinah needs reporting too. She’s done the same with her two kids. Both woman are pregnant. It’s child abuse. Maryam and mum could have stayed at Fatima’s …. I’m sure saiff would have supported his sister if her brute hubby started

[@L-km9ww]

There's no abuse. Learn the definitions of words before saying things that don't make sense. ABUSE IS WHEN YOU HURT A CHILD ON PURPOSE. This mother is doing the BEST she can to keep Maryam safe. If it really hurst you, go somewhere else and don't be a troll. KZbin has likely already seen this channel, they're not going to do anything. Anyone with sense knows that Ziba is doing her best

[@L-km9ww]

@@annedavies2611 No, several of Ziba's brothers like Ali and they will support him. They have their own problems, if they truly cared for Ziba, they can see her videos they would have already helped. If Ali rages like a madman in front of Fatima, Fatima will not encourage fighting, instead she will tell Ziba to go with him

[@jodeesmith1685]

You Tube won't go to Iran over a film to show what if. It is film people. There is a car there to leave after filming.

[@bluelagoon9990]

Is she beating the child? Yelling at her? I don't see her doing that. So how is it abuse? The conditions are rough, but Ziba is still caring for her Certainly even her mother Fatima must have had to face rough times but as long as she cared for her kids it was fine. Same here

[@user-xr4xj9pm5f]

Зибу не жалко, пусть мерзнет раз нет ума, а дочку жалко. Не могли придумать более реальный сценарий. Сейчас съемка закончится и уедет греться домой с оператором, не будет же она тут ночевать.

[@user-qi1wn5gj2w]

Сейчас муж приедет на ужин. Это же экзотика провести вечер на природе😅😄🤔

[@vidadisahmmmdov310]

Təpəsinə dəysin prirodası. Muçit edir uşağı.

[@user-ql6oj7bh5n]

Поесть еды с песком😂

[@L-km9ww]

You don't have any proof of that. Be kind

[@user-nd5gq9pd8x]

​@@user-ql6oj7bh5nлишь бы ты поела без песка. Надо быть добрее . Противно читать твои комментарии

[@user-ql6oj7bh5n]

@@user-nd5gq9pd8x а я их не для тебя писала, не читай сердабольная добрая тётя

[@nerminekti5590]

Ziba yolun kıyısındasın artık şehre daha sık gider gezersin sen gezmeyi seviyorsun ya neden Meryeme bu kadar eziyet ediyorsun seni geçtim aklından şüphe ediyorum

[@user-ub1lm7vg7f]

У Зибы не совсем впорядке с мозгами. Ребёнка у неё надо забрать! Это издевательство над ребёнком! Где власти Ирана???? Папа наркоман, мама тоже больная. Мания преследования. 😊

[@user-vh8ty5jv9v]

Издеваются над ребенком ради денег,изверги.

[@user-hw5fy5em6j]

戲劇越演越誇大了 😂看的很膩

[@svetlanavinnik6486]

Уже ночь,езжай в город или к маме спать ,серия уже подошла к концу

[@shirleybarker1163]

My heart goes out to the children they don’t deserve this type treatment even if this is a show.

[@annedavies2611]

Agree

[@carmenavalos8504]

Si es por sacar mas dinero y mas personas te equibocad porque lo q ases con tu hija es una brutalidad

[@user-cs6ds4yb6j]

Так и поверила зиба что ты сама там сидишь в кущах и ночью играй на публику тебе идет а мы посмотрим что дальше будешь сниматьпри такой огромной семье и негде остановиться стыдно зиба за твой поступок.жалко девочку что кругом носишь де попало.

[@annedavies2611]

Keeping the tent open so they can film is sick

[@user-sl1vl7uu3d]

Hasta que no pase algo a la niña es por culpa de la madre por terca 😡

[@user-pr9id8xw7p]

Meryemin pkolojisyle oynuyor ziba senayo filim cok kötü

[@annedavies2611]

I’ve reported it as child abuse. The mother had alternatives to stay in. She should have called the police on her abusive husband and gone to stay with her brother he would have protected them. Maryam looks poorly already. I’m so angry 😡

[@L-km9ww]

Haha, anyone can see there's no child abuse going on here. Anyone with a healthy mind knows this is just a mother with no other options fending for herself and her child. Clearly, the police in Iran would be more likely to blame Ziba and support Ali because he's a MAN. The brothers want to stay out of it because Ali is their cousin. Maryam is fine and best off with her mother. Don't troll or bully

[@jodeesmith1685]

You put the child in danger for doing that. The dad will get the child. While he is on drugs no one will watch the child. Way to go.

[@letjoanin]

I also reported them. They expose that child to all sorts of upsetting things, including her father beating her mother and pointing a gun at her. Maryam gets upset and cries. It's just plain wrong to traumatize a child to get viewers.

[@sandral.8693]

@@letjoanin💯childhood trauma stays with you and you carry it over to adult life,there are usually ethics involved when using children in a movie their psyche needs to be protected at all times 😢

[@L-km9ww]

@@letjoanin Clearly, this is their real life otherwise they wouldn't do so

[@MarinaM-vy9eh]

У дороги что бы муж быстрее нашел?

[@robertacress4945]

You sure are a brave lady Ziba..you have survivor skills but I hope at some point you will be closer to your family. ❤

[@selenabidois9373]

Gypsy Rose you are correct, so I would think Ali knows this location this seems to be the area that pops up on all the nomadic you tube channels, I am seriously doubting what I thought were their true life stories, there are areas around the mountains she left that have water, shade, shelter, No!! she wants to be by the roadside where theres no supply of water or firewood, Ridiculous!!!

[@gypsyrose2424]

Totally Agree...😊

[@florismarsilva4904]

Ziba deixe de ser orgulhosa, preze pelo bem de sua filha, vá morar perto de sua família, lá vocês estarão mais protegidas

[@user-ko1yu8qd4c]

Интересно, от кого защищаться🥺, всякую Ерунду придумали, то в горах, час здесь, просто сказка, кто поверить😊

[@anaisasmendi]

No xq acaba el suspenso, después se va a su casa dormir,es hinumano hay menor edad ella embarazada no puede

[@user-ur9ve6ex7c]

Маникюр хороший,видно в салоне побывала,что ты сидишь и ноешь,сама выбрала доя себя такую жизнь,придурошная

[@carmelrankin9362]

Poor Maryam sleeping on the cold ground😢😮😢 no blanket over her.😢❤

[@user-vi4jn5yn9s]

Бедный ребенок,мамашка ненормадьная подвергает ребенка таким испытаниям.Одна в горах,непогода,отсутствие элементарных условий для жизни,ей что экстрима не хватает,ладно сама мучается,а ребенок то за что страдает ?На самом деле надо ребенка у нее забрать пока она ее не угробила.

[@jodeesmith1685]

1 hour film of what if. It is a film. There is a car to take her home after filming. It is a picnic.

[@user-nd5gq9pd8x]

Рядом с родней жить и легче,и безопаснее,и счастливее от радости общения с ними .

[@user-yv8dr3lc7r]

Нечего страдать тебе мать сказала чтоб ты к ней пришла, а теперь из себя строишь жертву и ребенка мучаешь какого черта показываешь характер, иди к матери

[@user-bc1kg9cn7g]

Думаю, что Зиба должна построить свой дом рядом с мамой. Там ей легче будет жить, да и родня поможет ей отбиться от мужа. Жаль, если он заберет дочь.

[@evavesela7356]

Babička ji řekla ať zůstane u ní Ziba to nechtěla pomoc ji nabídl i Mírza, ale Ziba to taky nechtela, tady bude dáleko od rodiny a nikdo ji tu nepomůže. A to si chce postavit dům. Tam jak byla ji aspoň rodina pomohla Mirza jí dovezl vodu , dřevo co potřebovala ji vždy Mirza dovezl, kdo ji pomůže tady nikdo. A měla to i blízko do vesnice. Mohla tam chodit, tady nemá nikoho.

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

Ziba still lives with her husband Ali. This is all fake. They film these videos and after they films, she Ali and Maryam go home to their house in the city.

[@lara_lora_]

Зиба второго ребёнка ждет.Около дороги,около вышки,без воды,ветра.Ах,какое место выбрала Зиба со своим мужем. Любой контент.Уже кое что появилось из тряпок.Муж что ли довёз.

[@ludmila360]

​@@carolyndoolittle2970совершенно верно.

[@ivoneteteodoro2447]

Se fosse verdade ela moraria na vila. Se não quisesse morar com a mãe armava a barraca lá perto da família, eu queria vê o marido aparecer lá com tantos homens da família por perto. Pare com essa palhaçada, mulher ridícula. Essa criança é quem sofre pq vive nessa sujeira e passa por problemas psicológicos com essas cenas com armas e brigas.

[@ileanaescalante9193]

Hasta que Dios no lo quiera y le pase algo malo a la niña vas reaccionar ziba no seas orgulloso anda con tu madre quien más que la familia te cuide no seas terca

[@evavesela7356]

Uvidíte, že se Ziba ještě ráda vrátí ke své matce. Protože je těhotná a nezvládne si postavit dům sama.

[@user-rl7ek6gx7o]

Продукты закончатся, соберет свое барахло и опять к мамаке поедет 😂😂😂

[@cassiagoncalves6118]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@margaretharrison2560]

Yes 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@marahardok3845]

Comida o cinegrafista trás, o pior é a bebê ali neste lugar

[@marie-franceschouard5775]

Yesss 😂😂😂😂

[@user-je6ev5ms8g]

У зиби такой сценарий

[@bnt-alsoodih]

غريبة هذه المرأه

[@jeanneabiven6610]

Entre nous soi-dit ,elle fait m importe quoi !!!.Dans le vent et au bord d'une route !! Franchement un peu de bon sens quand même. Restez avec votre mère et pensez à votre fille..

[@user-ne8co4bz6z]

Это сценарий странный

[@user-cl3fp5sc3i]

Amazing, she even have a chicken to prepare 😂😂😂

[@franciscaromeroperalta3812]

Para de grabar y saca está madre y su hija de aquí creo que voy a denunciar este maltrato infa

[@user-ki4mi3gj3t]

Ella así lo quiere!!todo xdinero para el .marido

[@bluelagoon9990]

I think they don't have a choice

[@gypsyrose2424]

Tajmah & Mirza lived here with their kids & Saifullah & his wife & Arad, until Tajmah abused Saifullah's wife for wasting water. So she packed up Arad and told Saifullah they were leaving...Mirza did try to stop them. They moved high up the mountain's in a cave and she disappeared, either fell, runaway or murdered. Saifullah was left with tiny Baby Arad to raise on his own...❤

[@Appa94]

🐂 💩 story . The one who is suffering and getting affected by this BS is the little one . Shame on you as a mother putting your daughter whom you seem to care about … I doubt it now . Poor child e everyday a new drama … how she process it I really don’t know . Give the child stability … I just came to read the comments. Anyway I have unsubscribed long back .

[@user-nw2yb4ix9c]

Your totally correct!

[@lynntaylor4248]

They don’t stay here at night , she will go to her house 👍

[@maris.3200]

Yes, me as well. I unsubscrbe along time ago. Checking to see if there is any progress. No, still worse storyline. Cannot watch the neglect of Maryam.

[@annedavies2611]

@@lynntaylor4248not the point. Shouldn’t even be filming in these conditions

[@margaretharrison2560]

100% agree , it is truly disgusting

[@bhanson6540]

Where’s the nearest town? Where will you get water?

[@maiguablanco7037]

Ziba,deja el orgullo y vive con tu familia,tú madre y tus hermanos,te van a proteger del malvado Drogadicto,te equivocaste bien feo, pero pará Lante, con el apoyo de tu familia,sola no lo vas a lograr,es muy fuerte,piensa en el futuro de Marian,y x supuesto en el tuyo también

[@annedavies2611]

The child’s face has been hurt. This is abuse

[@user-im2vf8nt9y]

Это то место где жил Сайфуло только надо подняться выше в горы , пройти мимо железной вышки ! Там пещера свободная , это лучше чем жить возле дороги! Зиба включи голову?

[@maggiegibson7183]

Yes it's so sick playing on viewers for money And kids live in tent After camera shut of go home 😮😮😊

[@user-iz7gv7qb5l]

Пусть как хочет,так и живет.Это все из за денег, Чтоб люди пожалели ,и подписались.Противно смотреть,отписалась, вранье

[@user-ed7dn4tj3f]

me parese el colmo q esta señora salga d tu casa para llevar atu hija a un lugar peligroso y con muchas dificultades por caprichosas d no q dárse con la señora fatima está señora le gusta el sufrimiento y la niña esta pagando las consecuencias por favor q alguin recoja ala niña esto para nosotros los colombianos es maltrato infantil ala señora le falta carácter con ese drogadito denu celo con la policia. meda muchas tristeza con la bebé 😢😢😢😢

[@user-vu6ko2xw8j]

На улице холод,а ребенок без носков!

[@user-wc7bn5pe7k]

Она всю зиму ходила без носков и обуви, а сейчас весна тем более босиком будет бегать Это полезно закаляться, они же будут жить под открытым небом.😢

[@user-cs6ds4yb6j]

Когда съёмки на улице будете, а потом по квартирам.

[@annedavies2611]

Oh my goodness that poor child 😢

[@myrtle7043]

I saw Ziba's husband's blue truck in the road hiding behind the rocks as she was getting the firewood. His long ass is behind the camera and it is his brown jacket that is covering up his daughter as she sleeps

[@letjoanin]

Viewers don't seem to understand that all of this is a story. These people can't even act, and Ziba is often hiding a smile when she's fake crying. My problem is that they drag their child into this drama. She deserves better.

[@maris.3200]

I agree. Both are bad actors. Using their daughter for likes and views. Ziba is not sincere, does not listen to her mother. Just wanders around the city looking for her husband. She has no self respect.

[@rahaabdi1644]

I saw that too😂

[@orientwavecaesar103]

So, make it clear. What do you want to tell ?

[@myrtle7043]

@@orientwavecaesar103 what do you want to know?🙎

[@KristinaMay2109]

Oh Ziba...it really breaks my heart seeing you and your daughter in that situation😢

[@myrtle7043]

Her husband is behind this. His blue truck can be seen when she was getting the firewood and it's his brown jacket that was covering up his daughter as she sleeps. Ali is the one behind the camera 📸

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

This is all fake. She goes home with Ali after filming and their home in the city. Why would she leave and hid from Ali, and bring what was in her house and settle so close to the road for anyone especially Ali to see if she didn't want him to find her and Maryam? She and Ali didn't think when they wrote this script!!!!!!! How stupid to make camp so close to the road!!!!

[@L-km9ww]

@@myrtle7043 You don't know that's his blue truck. That is so stupid to think considering that ALMOST EVEYR NOMAD HAS A BLUE TRUCK. And ANYONE could have a brown jacket. It's like the viewers are trying to FORCE a lie to be the truth

[@L-km9ww]

@@carolyndoolittle2970 No one knows where they go when the camera is off. Unless the viewers have proof, constantly saying they go home looks really bad on every one of these viewers. Moreover, THAT'S NOT ALI'S HOUSE IN THE CITY. That's HIS SISTER'S HUSBAND'S house. Ziba was smart not to go deep into the desert. There are wolves and snakes and if she needed help, it would take her too long to get back to the road or civilization

[@user-xs9cn3ot5e]

Congratulations Ziba. Do you want to spend the winter here too?

[@MayraGarcia-rb2zy]

She’s giving more reasons to the father to take Mariam away by making terrible decisions for the baby girl. Not good move lady. GO TO THE Authorities to make a restrictions and go live with your mom. She can use some help as well. Think of Mariam

[@user-uf4qi4ss1b]

خطيه هذي طفله

[@gwendahughes6253]

They must think we are stupid to believe this she has her mobile phone there that will need to be charged she will need water and food the need to go to toilet

[@meymabautista8326]

So dumb 😂

[@VictoriaHinay]

GOD bless you always 🙏💖

[@RosavillaVillacorteza]

Ziba, you are torturing Maryam. Maryamis sick over her warm and let her wear Socks it is cold. Cameraman tell Ziba to Cover the child warm. My goodness it is cold.😢😢😢

[@jodeesmith1685]

If you are there to feel the temperature why aren't you helping her

[@bluelagoon9990]

Hahahah, very good response! They are wearing coats but that doesn't mean it's totally freezing! Instead of judging this mother we should encourage her. She's clearly trying hard to care for Maryam! ​@@jodeesmith1685

[@marahardok3845]

Ziba sua filha está doente e com o rosto machucado e inchado, cuide melhor dela, ela não poderia estar aí nesse tempo filmando com você, pense na saúde da sua filhinha!!!

[@SylviaVillarreal-hr5ip]

her hairless heads got to be FROZEN 🥶!! where's her hat?? Maryam keeps taking her hat off

[@olgaparra707]

Esto es una locura, un defensor de menores tiene que intervenir, por mas que sea la madre no puede obligar a vivir en esas condiciones a un niño 😮😮😮

[@user-ii9rm4qq9v]

Она не одного серьезного шага не сделала, чтобы хвалить . И стой умом будет рожать второго ребенка.

[@terriholley1298]

She’s not PREGNANT!!! A woman does not have a menstrual cycle while breastfeeding. She’s still breastfeeding her daughter. Yep, she isn’t being truthful about the pregnancy at ALL😂!! I got a feeling the breastfeeding will stop after this post!!!😂

[@marahardok3845]

@@terriholley1298ela está gravida e sim, mulheres amamentando também engravidam e acontece com muitas porque pensam assim.

[@L-km9ww]

@@terriholley1298 Your comment makes 0 sense. At least learn about the way a woman's body works before trying to defame someone or be a troll

[@jodeesmith1685]

​@@terriholley1298😂😂😂😂😂😂 tell that to all the women who got pregnant while breastfeeding. That is sòòooooo not the way it is. Joke will be on you when you breastfeeding and get pregnant. That egg drops at 4 weeks YES YOU CAN GET PREGNANT Joke was on me. I believed my old aunt. She said what you said.

[@lara_lora_]

@@terriholley1298 Часто женщины беременеют во время кормления грудью.Меня это обошло,но моих некоторых родственников -нет.

[@lara_lora_]

Считаю,что специально простужают Марьям,чтобы вызвать у подписчиков жалость У Марьям уже хриплый голос..У них сердец нет,одни деньги.Поселиться под вышкой.Всё собрала.

[@sabihamerdanovic8798]

Nemojte zalit Ludu zenu sama je to htjela. Prevedi engleski.

[@L-km9ww]

No one is that sick to do that. By writing these things, you just make yourself look inconsiderate

[@jackietaylor-wv4ft]

How can you be given a cold on purpose 😅

[@L-km9ww]

@@jackietaylor-wv4ft Right? These viewers don't think

[@lara_lora_]

@@jackietaylor-wv4ft Ребёнок с хриплым голосом должен быть в тепле,а не в палатке,босиком.

[@user-kk5dv6rr1s]

Зиба ищет приключений!

[@user-ku6px4fz9w]

Добрый вечер Зиба дорогая что ты делаешь ты с ума сошла от такого ветра ребёнка застудишь и ветер всё твои вещи унесёт вернись к маме пока не поздно там вместе с матерью тебе будет легче будите помогать друг другу

[@marijakasperska5207]

You should have taken the child from such a mother a long time ago and not even asked her how she can abuse the child like that? She could hang out wherever she wanted, but torturing a child 😱 This no longer a mother. 👎😭❤️

[@CVGFanClub]

This is almost impossible to watch. Maryann does not deserve this. She is tormented by what her mother has her in. Her father is a worthless human being, to push her and his daughter to this, and SHE IS PREGANT BY HIM, doing all of this!!!!!! She cannot possibly say there. Does she not make enough from these videos to get a one room something, somewhere in a city? I am going to stop viewing this story, as it is hurtful to see that beautiful child suffer under those conditions. She loves being in a house like environment. Stop this Ziba and do this another way. I will keep watching if you change this!

[@meymabautista8326]

You tube need to check on this bec of the chikd !!!

[@letjoanin]

Report it to KZbin--there's a tab called "Report".

[@L-km9ww]

Just think outside the box, clearly this is the truth, otherwise no mother would do this. Have some compassion and think from her perspective

[@user-pr9id8xw7p]

Annesi var abileri var ne isi var orda evide. Vardı saçma o yerde olması olan çoçuğa oluyor hiç acımıyor çocuğuna ufak mufak bir ev alsaydınız zibaya daha iyi olurdu kendi mont giymiş cocuk yine ince giysilerle gitsin kocasinın yanına

[@Youlooktothemirror]

Good afternoon dear ZIBAH. PLEASE GO to some Village and ask help. Don’t stay in this place , it’s dangerous for you and Miriam. Please dear. ❤

[@ElenDeLeon-qk2pt]

Baya a vivir con su madre ella es una madre ejemplar muy linda doña Fátima está para todos sus hijos por favor la niña corre peligro alli

[@user-bc1kg9cn7g]

В этом месте ужасный ветер. Нужно найти другое место.

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

Duh, one not close to the road..... since you left to hide where no one, especially Ali, can find you. You sure didn't think when you and Ali wrote the script!!

[@user-gf7eh1pz3r]

У них в деревне много семей снимаются в ролях, кому, вы верите, у них у всех свои добротный дома, а это они так деньги зарабатывают, я тоже верила ...по началу, а сейчас все не логично, эти видео на лошар, есть такие кто начинает жалеть, писать, чем больше коментов, у них больше денег, в день обычный блогер зарабатывает до 20000руб, сам один рассказывал, это они считают мало, я понимаю смотреть видео о их естественной жизни о их быть, но они ж начинают придумывать мыльные оперы, противно и смешно, жаль только детей.

[@laurievelardo570]

I think she picked this place because her brothers stayed there before. Mirza lived here and Saifullah lived above there in a cave. Maybe she thought they would eventually fine her there.

[@annedavies2611]

Her poor little feet will be frozen. And she won’t understand why she’s not at home 😢

[@macreato911]

I hear people in the background…who are they?

[@alextrofimof]

Убежала от мужа сказка ребенка немучай что твой муж твой канал несмотрит вся страна на тебя смотрит она от мужа убежала если правда ты убежала тогда почему видио снимаешт обманывать некрасиво

[@sandral.8693]

My thoughts exactly 😂😂😂

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

And why if she ran away and hiding would she camp so close to a road for everyone to see her and Maryam!!!$

[@ivoneteteodoro2447]

​@@carolyndoolittle2970, 12:23 pq ela é sem noção. Pense que o povo e burro. Pra mim chega não quero mais vê essa mentira horrível, usando uma criança. Merece perder a guarda da menina para o estado.

[@jodeesmith1685]

IT IS A FILM OF what if.

[@L-km9ww]

She didn't film the road she took to get there. Therefore, by simply seeing the place he can't know where she is. Moreover Ali seems to be ignorant, maybe he doesn't prefer to watch the videos anyway. He doesn't look like someone who watches KZbin to me

[@user-yq6qj1gc5t]

Бледный ребёнок, она её мучает, очень жалко девочку. Смотрю только из-за Марьям. ОПЕРАТОР ПОЖАЛУЙСТА СКАЖИТЕ Зибе чтобы пошла жить к маме или к Сейфуле.

[@dacianapalconi-fm7oc]

😅O tâmpită 😅

[@carolyndoolittle2970]

She and Ali think we,?the viewers are the fools

[@user-bh2ev5ks7f]

Baby beatiful Myryam i thought i didnt you again Im so happy s To see you again smart & beautiful little girl

[@user-kt3go7gp8u]

Как в песне поется, ".... Накрыла стол горой, нарисовалола бровь, ну чтож ты не идешь, моя любовь.

[@user-mb7vu8gn8g]

This woman is unbelievable shocking to say the least on the side of a road😮 baby sick freezing cold and she cud have gone to her mum

[@kirandeepgill2602]

Plz back home

[@honeysosweet637]

👐🏻👶🏻❤️🧕🏻👈🏼😘💬I Do Feel For Ziba And Little Maryam But This Is A Foolish Mistake. The Place She Chosen Is NOT SUITABLE For Her And The Baby! As A Pregnant Woman, Ziba Needs Her Family MORE THAN EVER! Can’t Someone Like Mirza, Hassan, Suifallah Or Khosrow Come And Convince Ziba To Live With Hassan Since He Has A Gigantic Castle 🏰 With Much Room For Them To Live In? We Viewers All Want Ziba To Be With Her Family For Her Well-being. Ziba Has Too Much Stress And She’s Not Thinking Logically!

[@user-lv9zd3oi2s]

Me da una pena por la niña tan hermosa y amorosa tener que sufrir esa criatura..😢

[@user-yw1mf4fu6r]

Ее скоро ветром сдует с горы. Да и нашла же она место? Ужас один.

[@user-lv9zd3oi2s]

No soporto que esa niña sufra me cala mu corazón

[@agustinaenriquez9861]

😢ay Ziba está es la peor drsicion k as tomado llevar ala niña a un lugar no seguro y exponiéndola al peligro tu hija está enferma , deja el orgullo tonto y recapacita , le estás dando más la razón a Ali de quitarte la niña por tus malas desiciones ,por k no ir a denunciarlo por maltrato y amenazas contra tu vida tienes el vídeo donde te amenazó , con tu familia está segura , con Mirza , sayfula o con tu madre pero deja de ser cabeza dura , nada más piensas en ti , no puedes con el cuidado de Maryan tu quieres una vida de comodidades y como no se te dio con Ali por si adicción y TODABIA quedas embarazada otra vez , no tienes dignidad , y si es por ganar dinero exponiendo ala niña a esta tempestad estás mal mujer ,se puede tener 20 años pero ya no es tu vida , es la de tus hijos , nesesitas ayuda psicológica , esto no se como lo permite KZbin , sr. De la cámara digaselo por favor k regrese con su familia ala villa. Por favor no exponga ala niña😢😢😢😢

[@user-sh2hx6pg3e]

БОЛЬНОГО РЕБЕНКА ДЕРЖИТ НА ХОЛОДЕ , ПРИШИБЛЕННАЯ , БОЛЬШЕ НЕТ СЛОВ.

[@faizaali911]

Zeba is not good woman 😡

[@cassiagoncalves6118]

Não ser uma boa mulher ainda vai né gente ? Mas, não ser uma boa mãe não é aceitável.

[@faizaali911]

English translation

[@ranneizam]

If she doesn't take action and report to the police she will be constantly harrassed and under threat all her life for as long as the crazy guy is still alive.