A spontaneous trip ends in years of horror (Part 1/2)

[@grrman]

This is actually beyond unsettling. The absolute disgusting things that some people do is sheer lunacy.

[@lakid9749]

If this is a message to everyone, that voice inside - always listen to you’re intuition.

[@Meanwhile-]

It's not often I find Casefile's content to be too much, but I think I'll be skimming the wikipedia article and phoning this one in. Thanks for the work.

[@rachelcappello9767]

I agree. It’s so cathartic! His narration in so detailed that what she was subjected to feels tangible. This is proof that monsters are real!

[@mariaquiet6211]

I've heard this case before and I couldn't relive it. It was so bad.

[@CaramelSunflowers]

I couldn't finish this episode, utterly horrific 😢

[@rhondamcewananderson3968]

I was a teenager, living in southern California, in the 70's. We would hitchhike to the beach, often. This case is really upsetting to me.💔

[@zezethuqutu2577]

Same. I really can't handle it.

[@readdeeply9278]

If your loved one ever goes missing, you must absolutely launch your own investigation. Lamentations will only make you feel miserable and useless. Police do not find missing people which is why the US has 600,000 of them. I help run a local missing persons page and learned as I went. What questions to ask the family, how to hold their hand while at the same time gain valuable information, how to retrace a persons steps and locations. Cell phones have made things much easier than they used to be. If they are found, or return, acting disinterested in what happened to them is not only unhelpful, it is cruel. And dangerous. I can't even imagine what that must have looked like. Ask questions, for God's sake. You can do it tactfully. But pretending it didn't happen is the worst thing you can do to a person. Hit me up if anyone needs help. That said, I'm diving in! thanks for all your hard work and for sharing this story.

[@alabrrmrbmmr]

All you have to do is pray to God!

[@siddhesvara]

Man, what a horrible ordeal. Amazing delivery and production as always. Casefile is hands down my favorite true crime podcast.

[@311girl]

The wife isn't upset he's r*ping someone; she's upset because he's cheating. What a couple of nuts.

[@FoxExcess]

She's abused and brainwashed...

[@bethwood9377]

When I was 19 my good friend went missing, walking home from work. The weeks until they found her body were agonizing. I can't even imagine what it was like for this family to wait for years. I'm thankful for faith.

[@twelvesmylimit]

I recognised this case from the beginning but you added details I had never heard before. Horrifying case but, as usual, so well done, Casefile. 👍

[@TheBlueappy]

What a story... Colleen you are one tough lady. I'm sure I couldnt have endured so much for so long. Such a horrible horrible story..

[@andrewrobertson3894]

This story is absolutely insane.

[@coreencasey5109]

There are some evil monsters in this world that dont deserve to be breathing the same air. A woman who goes along with a man like that is just as bad. 😢Colleen is a machine to survive.

[@FoxExcess]

A brainwashed abuse victim is "just as bad"? Give your head a shake.

[@candyrain09able]

​@@FoxExcessI was about to respond to that comment the same way, however I hope they must be referring to Janet, his wife as the person that's "just as bad".

[@usefulusinguser]

I know exactly where red bluff is. That part of the country/California is specifically known for its atrocious levels of missing persons cases. I personally know someone that started to live a more “free spirited life” which led to spiraling downward into serious mental health issues induced by drugs and the wrong people. Choosing to be homeless and trusting random individuals with 0 thought out into it. Haven’t heard from her in years and these specific types of stories always terrify me for her because she’s more of a “perfect target” than Colleen was. Haven’t hear or seen her in years and same goes for my other friends who knew her. Really wish she is okay.

[@maureenhawes1598]

Portland Oregon USA here and always looking forward to Casefile.

[@Yes_Anastasia]

Hey there. Oregon City, Oregon here!

[@MiMiiViVi]

So scary. Getting into cars with strangers is so unsafe and luckily hitchhiking isn't popular anymore, but there are still many other dangers people take that are preventable. Thank you Casefile Presents 👍

[@Gospel_weekly]

Thanks case fill, this is my Saturday night that I now look forward too, getting old not waiting to go out but waiting a podcast to drop, it’s 11pm here in Sydney, who else waiting for this week’s video tonight and what city you in ?

[@KenyanBunnie]

Listening at 7AM in NJ, USA. Goodnight!

[@Gospel_weekly]

@@KenyanBunniewow my brother lives in New Jersey., small world, thanks for shouting out where you listening from

[@johnoneill7947]

Maitland, NSW, Australia.

[@lindagordon51]

Melbourne Victoria, Australia 🇦🇺

[@natalieh4354]

10pm North Qls,same plans as you 😊

[@MeghanBean]

This is the most horrific I’ve maybe heard

[@KyleMccabe-ki3qf]

It really is

[@steven6570]

Used to listen to these on Saturday nights in Japan, now I’m living in London again, I’m listening to these videos 12 hours later than usual in my bed in England.

[@GwynnyBly8256]

I have watched/ listened to this horrific case before. The beginning of this case had me confused. It sounded familiar but different. I did realise that I knew Colleen’s experience when her POV started. Thankyou for a thoughtful presentation of not just Colleen’s experience, but also her family’s. The difference for me was the families experience at the beginning. The rest was very similar to the other presentations I have heard of this case. This may link more to my choice to listen to/watch other YT presentations that express a focus on the victim, not the perpetrator. Thankyou again for such a personal representation of such a horrific experience from not just Colleen but also her family ❤

[@missyd5016]

This has to be the most in depth documentary ive ever watched/heard I've ever seen about Colleen Stan. Absolutely brilliant.

[@AB-un4io]

How I’ve not been recommended to this channel until now is beyond me. Subscribed. Thanks, Casefile, for bringing these extraordinarily hideous cases to the light. They’re hard to hear but that’s exactly why people need to hear them. And not “gentled up” in delivery. The reason certain words make folk’s skin crawl is because those words are meant to describe horrific acts that SHOULD make one’s skin crawl. Ignorance IS NOT okay in these cases even if it ensures “bliss” for those who cannot handle the truth. My heart goes out to these victims and their families. Only if we arm ourselves with “unsavory” knowledge can we begin to hope to use discernment in dealing with people who seem “off” or possibly dangerous, making note of the person, behavior, and things hinted at…spoken…but left mostly unsaid, can we hope to save their intended victims. It’s hard to consider that there are people out there intent on destroying other people but the truth is hard. Nothing good comes easily. How many folks could be saved agony if only-for instance, “stalking” was considered as the very dangerous crime that it is and that stalking is generally just the beginning for some very depraved individuals out in this world. It’s scary. But knowledge is power. Stay safe, all. 🙏🏼🕊

[@TonyScarborough-y2u]

'Gg/,,,,,,,,,,

[@TheCakeIsNotaVlog]

It must be said. Mike is damn lucky that wasn’t my kid

[@veronicaellen4634]

Casefile. If I've never told you, this is my most absolute favourite true crime channel. Sure, I float around youtube and watch other creators. I really like some of them too. But nobody will ever compare to the masterpiece that is Casefile.

[@fairysnuff-000]

You put so much work into your uploads …. The research is obvious, there is so much detail

[@anitaholst7671]

Just think about it: had she not hitchhiked this horrendous story wouldnt have been her fate. Moral: the only risk worth taking is when the infinitesimal odds are IN YOUR FAVOR. Buy a lottery ticket? YES. Hitch a ride with a total stranger? NO. You never know when those infinitesimal odds are gonna be cashed in. FIND A DIFFERENT SOLUTION!

[@runkeral901]

The only way to make sure you won't ever be in such horrifying situation is simply to never trust anyone, especially strangers. Certain behaviours can cause certain unpleasant outcomes, and this has nothing to do with blaming the victim, it's just cause and effect. She clearly didn't deserve to be tortured for years by that psychopath, no one does, she just wanted to go to a friend's birthday party, but the way she wanted to get there was risky and reckless. 😢 Once I was offered a ride by a stranger and refused instantly, because of stories like this. I stay away from people I don't know and don't go anywhere with them. I don't care if I am too cautious, these days you need to be to stay alive and well. You might never experience anything bad all your life, but one scary and horrible thing is enough to scarr you for life. And I am being scarred enough by now as it is, by being bullied at school and outside school. People with fragile psyche like me wouldn't take anything worse.

[@user-mt4ku7jw1y]

Theres some truly twisted monsters out there alright

[@missdee153]

Please please please..... to all the content creators who release stories that require multiple videos.... will y'all please consider keeping titles the same or using the name as the first words in the title? Numbering episode numbers with a name on thumbnails are good but difficult to read bc they're small. This channel used to add the number as the first part of the title. I appreciate the part 2 of 2 in the description for this particular story. I dont start stories with multiple videos until they've all been posted so I have stopped watching a few channels all together bc they were posting 3-5 part stories but changing the titles completely and not disclosing that the vid they post is only part 1 of more. I like being able to listen to the videos consecutively that are parts of multi-part series

[@khaightlynn]

Agreed. I also miss the numbering Casefile used in their titles. It was much easier to find my place, or to skip ones I've already heard when organized by number and/or name. I do appreciate the part 1 of 2 heads up in the title, I also don't like to listen to multi part episodes until all parts have been released, I'm the same way with some TV shows/series. Makes listening/watching better at my own pace

[@seaweed1068]

but....why did her family let her go with that guy? Even if he was totally fine, wouldn't they be more suspicious or even call the police to investigate him?

[@ShanaMoe]

I've seen other videos on this case, but it never really dawned on me how long and torturous her captivity was. There was no humanity in this case. the "nice" things he did were just a manipulation technique

[@kimberlybrymer6849]

THAT WAS TERRIBLE......AND THEN A MYSTERIOUS MAN APPROACHED........TO BE CONTINUED........LOL THAT IS A REALLY GREAT PLACE TO LEAVE US WONDERING AND IMAGINING WHO THIS MAN IS ! GREAT JOB!

[@roberthouse7903]

This is the most horrific story I’ve ever heard

[@dougholmes8468]

That was such a GREAT episode!!!! I REALLY appreciate all your content and delivery of each episode. Can’t wait for part 2!! How long will we have to wait…..

[@rydz656]

Kind of a sick thing to post given the content.

[@dougholmes8468]

@@rydz656 it was meant to mean that it was a very well done, as noted in first sentence. And I was anxious to hear the ending. I appreciate your deep analysis of my comment 👌

[@myselfme767]

You can literally google it and not leave comments like this!

[@dougholmes8468]

@@myselfme767 thanks Gerry! Sure appreciate your help there. You are very kind to let me know.

[@myselfme767]

@@dougholmes8468 you're welcome!

[@abandonedmuse]

This was one of the scariest stories i have ever heard.

[@robinplante9560]

This is one episode that I couldn’t finish listening to. Instead, I looked up her name and read a short summary of what happened.

[@charliekezza]

The toybox killer liked his contracts too, must mess the victims up that they had to sign it

[@Maligroot]

Thanks Matey 👍

[@moxie-ik7kz]

This is probably the second most disturbing casefile ive heard. But there was one that a kidnapper cut off the girls arms and pushed her off a bridge

[@ldg1414]

One of the most unsettling true crime cases I've ever heard, right up there with the toy box murders.

[@SpicyTexan64]

"Legally binding" slave contract? That's just silly.

[@Timjblackley13]

"The Company" knows how to get through those legal loopholes

[@Time_Is_Left]

Have you heard of the McDonald’s strip case?

[@chesspiece81]

Good Saturday morning Casefile

[@buk390]

Is part 2 out?

[@Fastingthefataway]

Is this story true?

[@Jlanta81]

Yes

[@billesommer4636]

Will be waiting for your narration ❤❤

[@SlimSlashie]

In almost every case I've listened to of yours, the single thread that ties ALL of them together is the thought that, "If that victim had a handgun and TRAINED with it, this most likely would never happen." Evil exists, you are forewarned. If you watch this channel you already know that. People like this man and woman are REAL, you interact with them on a daily basis. If you have the ability to defend yourself, please, by all means, train and become proficient with a firearm. It may save you, someone you love, or dozens of future victims from something worse than death. This story is terrifying.

[@onceminutosgirl]

Wow I live 25 mins away from SF and never heard of this :/ so unsettling. My bf is from Sac and he never heard of it either. So insane.

[@claudiadornelles5742]

Super scary!

[@Timjblackley13]

Absolutely insane story. I subbed to the patreon just to hear the rest of it. Wow

[@RhythmAndStyle]

Why in the world who u let a love one go off again after they have been missing for yrs, this family should have done everything to stop her from leaving

[@jimin-with-luv1306]

1:04:00.... so thats why jane said the police would be no use

[@deebooga7188]

Chris Delia sent me.

[@danrobinson572]

Awesome 👏 podcast 😊

[@exilefox939]

We should know in january if he should be released or not by the way. The case will take 3 weeks if they dont prolong it again.

[@PetroicaRodinogaster264]

oh, I accidentally started listening to part two, when I hadn’t listened to this part one first. But it made no difference, because I got the story, and I’m glad in a way that I didn’t listen to the first part, because the second part was so harrowing I don’t think I’ll ever forget it. I didn’t know the movie. The girl in the box was about this girl it’s just an absolutely horrid horrid horror movie story

[@brokens1097]

There's content on KZbin that some people feel needs a warning?

[@garethadams9610]

Imagine if Bonn Scott had not died and had been the AC/DC vocalist throughout the 1980s.

[@danrobinson572]

I thought 💭 that of that before.

[@garethadams9610]

@@danrobinson572 👍😁

[@SpicyTexan64]

Imagine if you spelled Bon Scott's name correctly. 🤔🙈

[@MonarchMKUltra]

Hot take, Brian Johnson is the better singer.

[@garethadams9610]

@@MonarchMKUltra I disagree, but I do like Brian very much :)

[@jatilq]

I think these killers were mentioned in an episode of Paranormal Activity. Episode "The Apartment", did mention the vocal cords being cut. Think its time to watch "Girl in a Box". Also reminds me of the found footage film 'The Poughkeepsie Tapes'.

[@SG-pu3rx]

It was in Criminal Minds and many other tv shows as well

[@sdafc888]

Can’t wait til next week

[@jjoe7078]

This is the worst case I have ever heard about. Jesus Christ.

[@lestereo]

Most disturbing

[@MsHburnett]

Horror story

[@danrobinson572]

Wow he will be paroled soon and the wife testified against him and living in anonymity and has two daughters.

[@WouldntULikeToKnow.]

I hope he doesn't get to live to see his first day outside.

[@danrobinson572]

@@WouldntULikeToKnow. I agree ☝️

[@yeetnama9094]

SOMEONE needs to be waiting for him

[@danrobinson572]

@@yeetnama9094 yes 👍

[@barbaradobner6050]

Sooo....when exactly next week will we hear the second part?

[@loredanadincu4300]

He posts on Saturdays only

[@barbaradobner6050]

@@loredanadincu4300 thank you 🤗

[@Primesuspect13]

❤❤❤

[@jotun.616]

Sounds like patty hearsts story. The sla or whatever being about as real as "the company"

[@Crustyrat58]

I listen to this when I sleep🤤🤤

[@yeetnama9094]

Pornography should be banned forever

[@AngelXO96]

It should

[@MissVanHelsing]

Watching at 2am in Australia! ❤ What's the biggest thing everyone's overcome in their own lives, and what did you learn?

[@KulturKampf777]

Disgusting case and people

[@SassySlater]

21:40

[@NemFX]

Or you just don't answer the door.

[@ThugShakers4Christ]

Coleen shouldn't have been greedy and gone with the trucker. Every hitchhiker knows the rules of the road: ass, gas, or cash, no one rides for free

[@MiMiiViVi]

Not back in the day. Hitchhiking was common in rural areas to get to town and usually locals would pick up locals. Later it became popular way for teens and young people without cars to get around, and even travel the country. It wasn't until weirdos with stupid fantasies started using it as a way to prey on victims did it become unsafe. Shame, our society should have more decency than that.

[@lucianofortes1367]

Her family let her go n she had chances he a Warrior a dumb 1

[@MonarchMKUltra]

To be fair, the sister was willing to stand in the way to prevent her from leaving.

[@exactlywhatineeded]

Honestly you spent a little too much time describing the things that happened to her in way too much detail. Very unnecessary. The only video that I genuinely had to turn off, not cause I can’t listen to it but if someone hears me listening to this, it’ll be extremely weird

[@Ida-Adriana]

Why do you intonate every word (almost) identically?!? It’s very distracting, no offence. I would love to listen to this podcast, everything else is great but sadly it’s impossible for me. I think it’s up speak like kim kardashian. You keep going up unnecessarily on most words. It sounds robotic like a text-to-speech thingy. I have autism, btw and sensory processing disorder but a lot of people do these days.

[@yeetnama9094]

so what?

[@13donstalos]

So you think you're better?

[@SpiritGirlSF]

No photos related to the case and robo voice. No thanks.

[@FreebornLivingWoman]

If ever you are forced to sign a contract, always put v.c at the.end ad this is an indication that you were coerced into it ie not of your free will

[@jom9494]

For all those unbelievers out there. As Colleen said she was looking into the eyes of the devil ! The sixth sense she had at the gas station was the spirit. Beware!

[@WouldntULikeToKnow.]

Still an "unbeliever". Yes, there are awful people and, yes, humans can have a good gut instinct about bad situations but this isn't proof of the supernatural.

[@Missright-m8d]

I love how everyone warned her and she didn’t listen and the universe served her right ❤

[@Noodlepunk]

Janice totally got away with the kidnapping.🫠