A Thirty-Minute Roast of Lost Judgment

  Рет қаралды 8,431

GC Vazquez

GC Vazquez

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 118
@TheExFatal
@TheExFatal Жыл бұрын
6:26-6:36 Honest question, have you ever been to school? Even the game itself explains it that they turn a blind eye on bullying to keep its prestigious status, and expelling students would hurt its reputation. That's the in-game explanation, and that's how it works here on planet Earth too
@Arcananine77
@Arcananine77 Жыл бұрын
12:37 - 13:02 I think this complaint can be explained by the fact that "Yakuza: Like a Dragon" and "Lost Judgment" approach the same subject in different ways. Said subject being the idea of "gray areas", legal or moral. Where the former portrays them favorably to the point of idealization; the latter basically argues that gray areas can be very dangerous in their own ways, and that excusing or looking away from shady practices in service of a nebulous "greater good" or "status quo" can have devastating consequences, whether it's at a school or in society at large. That was my takeaway from the game at least. Not simply "bullying is bad"; but rather "be careful of embracing what you deem a lesser evil".
@machiiiiiiiiii
@machiiiiiiiiii Жыл бұрын
I really disagree with your assessment on Kuwana. I think he's the best antagonist in the series and especially an upgrade from Judge Eyes' antagonist who was just a killer without much motivation or exploration of his corruption. Kuwana being very similar to Yagami but disagreeing on correcting the justice system is what makes him a perfect antagonist for me. Them debating their ideals with each other is much more than what you usually get with this series and their ideals are backed up with their actions, since Kuwana kills people and blackmails his former students and Yagami tries as hard as he can without doing any of that and being a good guy. It makes Yagami's struggle throughout both games and your journey as a player feel meaningful, as he of course wins at the end and makes the world a better place because of it. It's downright inspiring as someone who has often felt that Kuwana's method was the only way to make a difference despite becoming a problem of it's own.
@pigmuffin3581
@pigmuffin3581 9 ай бұрын
the issue with Kuwana is that he's sorta fake deep. He falls into the classic RGG trope of "this bad guy is actually....... GOOD?" near the end of his arc and most people (myself included) were just suuuuuuuuuuuper tired of it by the point this game came out. If he was one of like 2-3 antagonists in the series it would be been completely fine but it's just an eyeroll at this point. The reason people like Kuriowa so much is because he's super out of character just insane for the studio, no turnaround or redemption etc just a cold blooded menacing lunatic. so much so Sega had to tell them to chill out with the violence for the sequel (when LJ was being developed)
@matteoguala7267
@matteoguala7267 4 ай бұрын
A killer doesn't have a true motivation to do it, he's just a psycho who doesn't feel pity, Kuroiwa was one of them. To me it's refreshing to see a main villain in a yakuza game that doesn't get justified, it's not like you always have to understand a villain.
@dvader518
@dvader518 Жыл бұрын
Can we talk about how The Kaito Files is the only RGG story with a final boss that isn't antagonistic towards the main character? It's simply two dudes fighting to prove who is worthy of the woman they love.
@ronwisegamgee
@ronwisegamgee Жыл бұрын
Yeesh! This was scathing! What made this game a more enjoyable experience for me was the fact that I could change the text to Spanish and the voice-acting to English. This allowed me to make playing Lost Judgment into an activity I can do with my mom, who is a native Spanish speaker but has a decent grasp at English. We both enjoyed the melodrama and, while I abhorred the first-person portions where I had to look for clues to progress, I got a huge kick out of the OST of this game. Your criticisms of this game are understandable, though, GC. Thanks for the video.
@tendeezbutnot5277
@tendeezbutnot5277 Жыл бұрын
Honestly surprised at the lack of mention of Mikiko, It's truly refreshing to see a woman in a RGG game like her
@TheExFatal
@TheExFatal Жыл бұрын
the guy played the entire game on a stream, you think he paid attention to much of anything?
@ToroTor0
@ToroTor0 Жыл бұрын
@@TheExFatalhe was too busy reddit raging over minor story moments to actually bother with the rest of his poorly made review
@pyrobowser158
@pyrobowser158 Жыл бұрын
@@TheExFatal Yes and he has a much better take than most people I've seen on this game. It's fine to say LJ's story is kinda... bad, but the side content and gameplay are stellar.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Thanks for watching!
@MilkJugA_
@MilkJugA_ Жыл бұрын
I kinda wish you didn't make a spoilerfree review when critiquing the story. There needs to be more concrete examples to give context to your points.
@marleonka.
@marleonka. Жыл бұрын
I wonder whats it gonna be since imo Lost Judgement has some of the most interesting approach to its story the series has had in a long while. It is very different but also very promising and I think they nailed a lot of the core aspects, exploring them in new different ways, to me its the second best in the series so I cant wait to hear why its trash and worse than Dead Souls
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I'm pretty hard on it in this video! A little less in the second half though.
@emperorznb
@emperorznb Жыл бұрын
As someone who walked away baffled by the main plot of Lost Judgment when I played it at launch, and who just played the Kaito Files this month and absolutely loved it, you couldn't be more on point with this video
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Thank you!
@doonishsan
@doonishsan Жыл бұрын
5:24 this one, I always thought how strange the cutscenes look in LJ. It's probably because it was made during the pandemic and whatnot. Idk
@moister3727
@moister3727 7 ай бұрын
Pretty sure RGG nails simple yet heartful narratives rather than complex ones, those get out of hand easily.
@Sperium3000
@Sperium3000 Жыл бұрын
Are... You ok?
@roblifting
@roblifting Жыл бұрын
I loved Lost Judgment! The main story was a mess but the substory plot was really fun.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I loved the school stories!
@MadDogSolo
@MadDogSolo Жыл бұрын
I agree with you on a lot of things, I don’t think you’ll like Gaiden or 8’s stories though because Tsuyoshi Furuta is involved in those (8 for sure, idk about Gaiden but I’m pretty sure)
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Furuta might be involved with 8, but he's got Yokoyama and another writer curbing him on that one I think. Still you never know!
@MadDogSolo
@MadDogSolo Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez Yokoyama is involved in everything but yeah I did see there was another writer.
@Arcananine77
@Arcananine77 Жыл бұрын
As someone who really enjoys both Lost Judgment and your videos on this franchise I'm looking forward to this. I wonder if you'll have something to say about how the narrative handled Sawa.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I didn't go too deep into this in the video, but I felt like it was nonsense how SPOILER: Yagami absolutely dragged her into it and then acted like it wasn't his fault
@Arcananine77
@Arcananine77 Жыл бұрын
​@@GCVazquezI agree, and what also didn't sit right with me was SPOILERS that Yagami basically became a crusader on her behalf after she got fridged. Going "Sawa this" and "Sawa that" every other cutscene.
@Ashyson780
@Ashyson780 Жыл бұрын
​​​@@Arcananine77 Thats the point tho, Kuwana did everything for Mitsuru's Justice, Mitsuru this Mitsuru that to justify his actions. Sawa's death proves that Kuwana's justice is flawed. Tbh hearing Yagami say "What about Sawa" is cathartic and satisfying because it exposes Kuwana's hypocrisy.
@victoriastanton576
@victoriastanton576 Жыл бұрын
'Now I'm not expecting him to suck me silly from the back' is a phrase that will get me through dark times, I know it.
@mceehammer4185
@mceehammer4185 6 ай бұрын
Is it really flop? i dont think so, if its a flop there will be no sequel. maybe i am just easy to please. but in terms of the story and gameplay i love it sm. its very different form the franchise. cause ofcs its a spin off duh.
@ImranAhmad-rz5oz
@ImranAhmad-rz5oz Жыл бұрын
A large number of media covering bullying in Japanese schools tend to portray teachers doing nothing to stop bullying. Probably because it's more reflective of their circumstances. I get that the solutions to bullying in this game is rather cartoonish but your assessment of bullying sounds like a equally shallow western take unfamiliar of cultural variance.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Even though one of Yagami's central issues with Kuwana is that he didn't step in when he should have? I'm all for understanding cultural variance, but this is about the narrative of this game being inconsistent.
@oklemonss
@oklemonss Жыл бұрын
That's a nice argument, however... Have you considered Sawa-Sensei?
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
HOW COULD I HAVE FORGOTTEN SAWA SENSEI
@oldwaterbottle2872
@oldwaterbottle2872 Жыл бұрын
I adore the Judgment games, I honestly prefer them to the mainline Yakuza games, but this video perfectly captures why I was really letdown by this game’s narrative especially considering how much I loved the story of the first game. Combat is easily the best it’s ever been and that alone puts it in at least top 3 RGG titles.
@GrooseyGroose
@GrooseyGroose Жыл бұрын
Although I agree with several main points brought up in this video, such as the main cast being incredibly underutilized and the bullying investigation being asinine, I think this video is overly harsh on Lost Judgment for failing to do things it wasn't intending to do in the first place as well as holding it to standards that every other game in the series also fails to meet. I love the series but it seems unfair to single out LJ for exposition dumps, static dialogue scenes, and repeating of information when the main series and Kaito Files both had multiple scenes where the main character literally sits down for several minutes with a dedicated exposition dump character to have the plot explained to them. I'm also surprised that you had such high praise for Kaito Files, which I strongly disliked for its treatment of Mikiko as a character and its glossing over of how despicable Shirakaba's behavior towards Mikiko was to the extent of framing him as honorable. Mikiko fell into the classic RGG trap of being introduced as a strong-willed female character but taking away her agency by having her fail at everything she set out to do and ending up a damsel in distress (a la Sayama). I found the scene of Kenmochi pretending to have sexually assaulted Mikiko in order to provoke Kaito one of the most distasteful in the entire series and incredibly disrespectful to her character. I also agree that the dynamic between Yagami, Sawa, and Kuwana is mediocre, but in my opinion, Kuwana's character becomes fantastic when you view him in isolation from Yagami. His relationship with Kusumoto is one of the best written in the series, with his undying loyalty born out of such horrendous guilt that he breaks down sobbing when Kusumoto tries to release him from his burden in the epilogue.
@ryno_8848
@ryno_8848 Жыл бұрын
The mini games were fun, and I like how they included Sega master system, games, and sonic the fighters
@rickythemaddragonxiong8757
@rickythemaddragonxiong8757 Жыл бұрын
I say that Judgment had a better story & Lost Judgment is kinda weak but good gameplay, better than 1st game. Kaito Files is probably better than main story and hoped they plan on doing more with the other Detective members like Higashi & Sugiura but Ishin Kiwami has already been released this year so it won't until a potential Judgment 3 (with or without Takuya Kimura despite already on PC). Say, have u heard that youtuber YongYea has been officially casted as Kiryu's new English VA for Gaiden & 8? What do u think of that or do u only play Japanese only & English sometimes?
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I've heard! I don't really have a huge opinion on it since I haven't heard it in-game, but I'm interested in finding out how the performance turns out! Shame about not getting the original actor though. Oh well!
@rickythemaddragonxiong8757
@rickythemaddragonxiong8757 Жыл бұрын
@GCVazquez Darryl Kurylo himself actually approves Yong. This is what he said in response on Twitter. "I am very happy and honored to have portrayed a wonderfully written and iconic character as Kiryu. I am just as happy to have discovered that the role will be portrayed by a dedicated actor who more closely matches Kiryu's culture. I strongly approve."
@15awesomehighfive
@15awesomehighfive Жыл бұрын
@@rickythemaddragonxiong8757 What else was he going to say? Anyway, as we all know, playing these games in anything but the japanese original VO is heresy so... ;)
@TheLlamaFarmer3
@TheLlamaFarmer3 Жыл бұрын
I tried to keep an open mind but still came out disagreeing with almost everything you said lol Still, good video, sorry to hear the game didn't hit the right notes for you
@ReFriedNoodles
@ReFriedNoodles Жыл бұрын
I'll admit I was pretty forgiving to the first Judgment game but I'd still be willing go back and replay it over its sequel. Lost Judgment earned its title. I'm all for lowering the stakes to tell a story, but then they up the ante very quickly and very considerably. A simple case about bullying then leads to a giant government conspiracy that is ultimately unresolved and a bad guy being judged but not receiving Judgement. "Cognitive dissonance" is what I'm feeling with these characters and this narrative. (Not sure if I'm using the term correctly.)
@Titanxzero1
@Titanxzero1 Жыл бұрын
Idk I can't get with most of this. I still enjoyed the game regardless of some of the flaws. So I'm sorry but no I'm not at all skipping the main story cutscenes, because I like them too.
@ararebeast
@ararebeast Жыл бұрын
Nin-Nin! Ryan Acosta fans unite! This may be the last time I get to cheer for everyone's favorite weeb on a GC video, I hope you'll permit me this one final offense. You make a good point that people feel less like characters. When the principal turns towards the camera and gives a dissertation off-the-cuff on statistics and bullying and why people bully and what-have-you, it's so unrealistic. It would be LESS unbelievable if he pulled out a folder with a bunch of statistics and said aloud he had been looking into it because he was concerned. But instead you get plot dumps that really show the writer's hand that they do not actually understand what they're talking about and they did precious little research into it. It has the energy of an after-school PSA where the characters summarize the message for you and give the moral explicitly, but the moral itself is confused here. Bless the Kaito Files though, the vibes were immaculate and it just felt so good and consistent all the way through. But I have to dock a couple points because Kaito did not use the forbidden Warp Kick technique to delete a high school student from reality.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
If Kaito could warp kick the world would be in danger
@Ashyson780
@Ashyson780 Жыл бұрын
Tbh the only part of the vid i agreed with was the biker mini game. Lost Judgment is my fav RGG story, and imo the best one. My two gripes are the biker mini game and the fact that Yagami is not as fun to play as Kiryu.
@kacklina
@kacklina Жыл бұрын
ok, the intro and the "scientific" explanation of bullying, hitting highschoolers, the victimizing of women, and the bad writing with things like the microphone in the classroom, all were bad, buuuuuut I feel Yagami has more of a personality of his own in this in this one, also I feel the story was actually a story, not a pasting of side stories to fill all the holes shown as the main story of the game, like Judment, also I found so ridiculous the "saving the world plot" because all the story was around a cure for Alzheimer, I rally appreciate they focused in a case in this game. I also like the new characters, I would have loved more Higashi in the game thought. With the Kaito files, I felt like, yes, he could be the new protagonist no problem, he could work better than Yagami in my opinion. Loved the mini games, I hated the robot one.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I can agree with all of that!
@kacklina
@kacklina Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez I feel like we all want Kaito as the main protagonist xD
@ToroTor0
@ToroTor0 Жыл бұрын
Reminder that this dude deletes comments he doesn’t like. Do not listen to him.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
KZbin has an automod system. But it's true, I delete comments when I feel like it. If that's too much for you, find a different space that will harbor you. I don't even know why you're still here if that bothers you enough to mention it.
@ultrapyrusbrawler
@ultrapyrusbrawler Жыл бұрын
Welp, unfortunate that you did not like Lost Judgment all that much better than Judgment. While I did enjoy the story of LJ, I completely understand you're criticisms of it. I think something that makes Furuta's writing make more sense in its structure when you take into account that players could spend tens of hours between main story scenes doing side stuff. Taking that in mind, it makes the repetition of information more logical and palatable to the player. However, I am not saying this is an excuse for it, merely that this may be a possible reason for why it is written the way it is. Given that other games in the franchise have handles this sort of thing much better, I completely get you're disdain for it. At least you enjoyed the Kaito Files. I hope for whatever the next judgment game ends up being that they manage to utilize their cast as well as it did. (Seriously, why was Mafuyu even in this game? She had, like, only two lines.)
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
A lot of the side characters are underutilized in Lost Judgment I feel! I would love another one despite my disdain for Lost Judgment.
@dvader518
@dvader518 Жыл бұрын
Will The Kaito Files get its own video?
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Kaito Files is in here!
@dvader518
@dvader518 Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez So all that's left before you get caught up on Western releases is Ishin.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
And I'm editing that video as we speak! :D
@scottangus6684
@scottangus6684 Жыл бұрын
Completed lost judgment for a second time recently. I loved the first one but the pacing in lost judgment is so off. The story fails to keep my full attention unlike the first. This game honestly should of cut back on cutscenes and had more combat encounters especially with the new fun combat they added. There was only like 2 chapters where you got to fight lots of thugs to have fun with the combat! That being said I do like the villains and boss themes and fights.
@Titanxzero1
@Titanxzero1 Ай бұрын
Yeah, I'm not taking this advice thanks...
@hyperXknees
@hyperXknees Жыл бұрын
Mainly with the Kaito files, the ending with Shirakaba rubbed me the wrong way. I know it was supposed to be kinda silly, but I just think the writers didn't really address his creepy actions and behavior properly and even trying to make the audience find him cool for "manning up". All of it came across as tacky. Otherwise I agree and would prefer tighter packages like it in the series. As for Lost judgment. It's a ridiculous story, but I enjoyed Kuwana well enough to make me forgive some of the earlier absurdity. Though I'll admit I do just have a general bias towards this series and seem to enjoy most entries by default. Nice work on the review.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Thanks!
@kacklina
@kacklina Жыл бұрын
I forgot about that, I loved the Kaito files, but yes, I remember now, he was so creepy.
@420HBKHHHDX8
@420HBKHHHDX8 Жыл бұрын
I have to say that i never played any RyoGoKu for the plot. The Judgment games make no difference. The side stories is were it is. Masterful crafted and fascinating. The only game that broke that cycle was Ishin. A truely fun game on every level. I do hope the series improves. But so far, I can live with the quests alone.
@Titanxzero1
@Titanxzero1 Жыл бұрын
Wow, I thought most of the stories were pretty good.
@SwearSpark
@SwearSpark Жыл бұрын
My god these thumbnails are stellar!
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
And this one I did all by myself!
@zacharywong483
@zacharywong483 Жыл бұрын
Very nice vid, GC Vazquez!
@culIen
@culIen Жыл бұрын
Wowza, as an unbiased party I love commenting on GC Vazquez videos for no reason. Algorithm? What's that.
@gamewrit0058
@gamewrit0058 Жыл бұрын
"Like a firetruck on the back of a seaturtle." 😆👍
@kacklina
@kacklina Жыл бұрын
As problematic as it could be I did like Lost Judgment more than Judgment xD, but as always I want to know your opinion.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I didn't completely dislike it, but fair warning I am NOT kind to it for the first 15 minutes of this video.
@JosephJoeseph
@JosephJoeseph Жыл бұрын
I'm starting to think the sheer volume of side content is starting to hurt the main story of these games. Like you said, the direction of the dialogue scenes is just nonexistent, and I feel like if more of the budget went towards more pre-rendered cutscenes, which actually have detailed animation and engaging camerawork, and towards the dialogue scenes to make them have at least a bit more animation and more interesting direction, even if that wouldn't've fixed the bloated writing it could have made it more palpable. The worst example of this are 'cut-out' scenes where you have a cut-out of Yagami on one side and another character on the other with a blurred background. It's not even shot-reverse shot, it's somehow even more uninteresting than that! And I loved the school stories but I can't help but think there could have been half as much content to them and they still would have worked perfectly. Why do I have to race 3 wankers who contribute nothing to the story before getting to the Made In Heaven leaders, the actual characters? Stuff like this could have been cut down a lot and allowed for more budget to go into the actual main story.
@DavidRamirez-se2yt
@DavidRamirez-se2yt Жыл бұрын
I'm honestly looking forward to playing the shorter games, more focused.
@hoovyaj
@hoovyaj Жыл бұрын
As much as i love Lost Judgment, i have to agree with your points even though the game borrows alot of its story elements from its predecessor on why Yagami is still a flawed detective, even though i like the story of Judgment, Kaito Files, and the Keihin Gang and The professor side storyline. Im still dissapointed that Yagami still couldnt right his wrongs, im not saying that writing game stories and detective work should be easy but not once i saw the main antagonist facing defeat but they either usually die or flee the scene and hide from the public and Yagami actually succeed on his cases other than Soma getting arrested. If theres a 3rd Judgment game i hope he does become more experienced and some old mechanics from Judgment return and this time Yagami actually succeeds and brings justice. I still do like Lost Judgment's story though since i felt touched by the bullying parts on the story since i used to be a victim before but at some parts its confusing and dont make sense at all but overall, this game is still a S or A tier game. But im glad even though some story aspects are borrowed from Judgment but with different events. The main supporting characters from Judgment dont even appear that much on LJ for some reason like Mafuyu, Genda, Ayabe etc. i do hope some characters from Judgment do return in the main story as much if a 3rd game is possible.
@1kvkk
@1kvkk Жыл бұрын
Man ❤❤❤❤
@catsfootironclaw
@catsfootironclaw Жыл бұрын
YYAAAAY BABE WAKE UP NEW GC VAZQUEZ VIDEO
@shizuwolf
@shizuwolf Жыл бұрын
A guy pushing 40 dating girls in their 20’s….sounds like Dane Cook. But seriously, an RGG style game in a high school setting would be interesting. Something like that old show “Fillmore” but with more violence.
@DavidRamirez-se2yt
@DavidRamirez-se2yt Жыл бұрын
Same, remember bully?
@shizuwolf
@shizuwolf Жыл бұрын
@@DavidRamirez-se2yt heard about it, but never played it
@DavidRamirez-se2yt
@DavidRamirez-se2yt Жыл бұрын
@@shizuwolf its basically Yakuza
@shizuwolf
@shizuwolf Жыл бұрын
@@DavidRamirez-se2yt it’s probably more comparable to GTA since it’s from the same company.
@pyrobowser158
@pyrobowser158 Жыл бұрын
Glad to see I wasn't the only one who really didn't care a lot for LJ's story. First Judgement is a top 25 game for me, and I think RGG's best story other than Y0, but LJ was... eh very ambitious but a little rubbish. I was genuinely surprised how much better written the side content was tho, this game might have the best side content since Y0 for me. School stories all in all might as well be their own game.
@wtfthisisntminecraft3501
@wtfthisisntminecraft3501 Жыл бұрын
I loved Judgment but really thought Lost Judgment fell short on surpassing its predecessor. It felt less like a detective crime drama and more like... whatever the fuck it ended up being. The RK gang as the primary antagonistic organization definitely made me feel like the developers would've rather made a Yakuza-themed game instead. Which, oddly enough, is a feeling I didn't get from The Kaito Files, where the protagonist is a literal Ex-Yakuza literally using two of Kiryu's fighting styles. Kuwana was alright, I just felt like the community overhyped him. I still think Kuroiwa was the better antagonist: The twist that the supposedly goody two shoes cop was the villain whereas the dirty cop was the more righteous one felt consistent with what was presented in previous RGG titles, mirroring Yakuza 4's dynamic between Tanimura and Munakata. I don't even know why Yagami and Kuwana had their final fight. It sure wasn't to make sure Kuwana doesn't go through with his plan, since he throws away his phone in the beginning. Kuroiwa however was a villain that actively needed to be stopped, and Yagami did just that by defeating him.
@suhanhwang9988
@suhanhwang9988 Жыл бұрын
I... have bad news. Like a Dragon Infinite Wealth is being written by Tsuyoshi Furuta. Make of that what you will.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I hear it's got three writers on it, so I have hope they'll rein him in!
@suhanhwang9988
@suhanhwang9988 Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez Fingers crossed.
@malty776
@malty776 Жыл бұрын
Every fucking thing in lost judgment is in that school that game made me hate school more then i already hated
@ayeyotrel928
@ayeyotrel928 11 ай бұрын
It got to the point in the story I didn’t even want to fight Kuwana lmao
@CNight-zr5ek
@CNight-zr5ek 8 ай бұрын
I enjoy your content, and awaited this video with much excitement after finally getting around to finishing LJ and feeling a very similar sense of disappointment. You do make a lot of GOOD points which I also agree with, however, you muddle those points with a lot of exaggeration and times where you are borderline get things wrong that make your viewpoint come off as much more disagreeable than it really is to the average viewer. Cinemasins-esque nitpicking doesn't contribute to your criticism. Things which other commenters have pointed out like the fact you didn't pay attention to the fact that the principal says vocally in dialogue twice that he doesn't want to expel students, he want to cover up the bullying and prevent it anonymously which is likened to real life institutions. A lot of schools don't even take that second step, which is why the joke of "You're the one punished for hitting the bully back" is so commonplace in modern society. Because it's true, and the game depicts that well. I very much agree that the story is confused. It lacks footwork, and is lost in what it tries to do. It ends up doing justice to none of the morals it tries to present because they don't really go anywhere, and it ends up feeling flanderized in almost every aspect. Rather than Yagami pushing his views in any stronger way (Kuwana being called a serial killer is laughed off, which I found embarassing from a writing perspective.) he just clings onto muh sawa, muh sawa, muh sawa, muh sawa. It's not endearing, and it makes Kuwana look like he's in the right, which he shouldn't be. He doesn't achieve anything by hunting down and murdering PAST bullies. All he achieves is some form of minor catharsis for the victims, but it doesn't achieve anything in the slightest. The fact the characters cross their arms and go "Hmmmmm, this guy has a point." Is actually infuriating, and I could not find myself stomaching a large part of the plot past the first five chapters. It's as you said. Empty characters spouting trivia and moral debates for the sake of trying to emulate the feeling of an actual story where things happen, when in reality you're backtracking the same info, coming to the same conclusions and nothing is truly happening until you're giving a payoff with no build up, that feels unsatisfying. While Judgment at least tried to be a new idea, Lost Judgment is just a Yakuza game dressed up as a detective simulator, but it falls prey to the same mistakes of overcomplicated conspiracies, mixed messaging which is afraid to commit to a single stance without coming off extreme and charismatic characters misused by the authors.
@ZeroCoolIsGod
@ZeroCoolIsGod Жыл бұрын
I struggled to give a shit about the plot in this one. And yeah, “40 year old dude beats up teenagers and is the coolest,” got old quick. They should have scraped Yagami, and let you play as Kyoko Amasawa. They could leave the plot mostly the same but it’s the MRC investigating the bullying and murder. Maybe let Kaito be the clubs NPC mentor. Better game imho.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Even if they did the thing they always do and not want a woman fighter, they could have had some high school punk be the main character or something. But then it wouldn't really be a Judgment game if Yagami isn't the star, right? I dunno- I think the premise was kind of in the way from the start.
@ZeroCoolIsGod
@ZeroCoolIsGod Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez I agree, that would be be too different to still be a Judgement game. I think I just want them to take their combat engine, side story format and mini games, and put them in a game with a story worth paying attention to. Or just skip the main story and give me 40 hours of voiced, episodic, short story quests. Premium Adventure Judgement is a hell of a good time.
@DavidRamirez-se2yt
@DavidRamirez-se2yt Жыл бұрын
​@@ZeroCoolIsGodI completely agree
@CyricZ
@CyricZ Жыл бұрын
Look at you all caught up. Well almost. You've still got Assassin's Creed 3 to play.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
working on the Ishin video right now >:D
@15awesomehighfive
@15awesomehighfive Жыл бұрын
Well... only Yokoyama is writing LAD Gaiden, so alongisde the smaller scope there's still hope it's one of the greats.
@winters_revolt
@winters_revolt Жыл бұрын
Honestly, unlike Judgement where I was going back and forth with paying attention to wondering what the hell is goinf on. I was able to follow the plot of Lost Judgement pretty well. I would leave this game for a while due to being busy with school work, and though sometimes, I would have to look up some things, I would still be able to follow it. I also found myself more invested in this story than Judgement. I could not tell you whu. I just did. I found myself invested in Kuwana as a villain and his dynamic with Yagami. But that might have to do with my own personal experiences and views on justice. That said, I do understand your points, and I think it just comes down to the fact that we have our own views of storytelling. That being said, I still consider Furuta the worst writer of RGG studios. He feels more like he is trying to turn his college essays into a story, and that can get old really fast. So, my investments with Lost Judgement feel like an accident and I am not sure if I would hold the same view if I played it again. That being said, the Kaito Files, I actually loved. It actually made me realize how smart Kaito was and it had a balance of being silly and serious and it rolled with it. It felt like an Ace Attorney case, which is on purpose as it has one of the writers from the recent AA games. I did not like the final boss as a character of Kaito Files as I felt he was a bit too creepy, but we got to kick his ass so I am willing to overlook, plus the Kaito Files had the sense to realize how silly the final boss is. So, yeah, those are my thoughts.
@live_kaito_reaction
@live_kaito_reaction Жыл бұрын
Lost judgment feeling like it was written based on 80s PSAs about bullying was so disappointing after coming from the marketing. At least we got kaito files out of it.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
It just falls so flat
@alexvydra2534
@alexvydra2534 Жыл бұрын
This is the only video I watched before finishing the game. I bought it few months ago on a sale for 1 € but can't force my self to continue past chapter 5 becouse of the plot. Also I don't know if this is only mi problem but Yagamis combat feels reali bloated. You have 4 fighting stiles and 6 combat skill "trees" all with at least 50 upgrades from witch some have almost same input but one is a heet action.The only reason why i want to finish the main game is so i can beat the only Amon mising.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
I really enjoyed the combat of Lost Judgment, but I can absolutely see it feeling bloated for some players!
@alexvydra2534
@alexvydra2534 Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez Also, one thing that pisses me off is that they waisted the school setting on Yagami insted of Saejima solo game. Like can you imagine a game where Daigo uses his influence to fulfill Saejimas dreem and make him a teacher that would be the best thing ever.
@azrafahmad5635
@azrafahmad5635 Жыл бұрын
okay, one final thought, the music in this game is some of the best yet in the series. shame its wasted on this game
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
It had some jams!
@Titanxzero1
@Titanxzero1 Жыл бұрын
Jeez game wasn't that bad
@jack0slack
@jack0slack Жыл бұрын
I don’t disagree with any of this, but I have to emphasise the part that just broke me. Broke me from the introduction. Couldn’t get past it. I’m a 38 year old man. Beating up children. It’s just a shock. Right off the bat, first time. I kept waiting for how this would resolve without a fight. He scares them off. He gets them to trip into objects and hurt themselves without ever hitting them. He shames them into backing off. Nope, he just slugs them. 38 year old man. Hitting minors. In late teens, fine, but still children. That for me was the whole ball of wax. No matter how good any of the rest of it was, that was so profoundly uncomfortable that it would never get past it. I found it morally repugnant.
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
Honestly I thought it was kind of funny! I just also wish the game leaned more into that sort of non-combat way to deal with the kids. Especially since you never fight a mix of kids and adults at the same time, it would've been cool to get forced into a fighting style unique to dealing with the kids, right?
@jack0slack
@jack0slack Жыл бұрын
@@GCVazquez Maybe where it disables attacks, dodges and blocks build heat, and environmental heat attacks are you dodging so the kids slam into walls or fall into bins, etc? Maybe.
@jack0slack
@jack0slack Жыл бұрын
Oh, I can't *wait* for this. (I _really_ hated Lost Judgment. Detested it.)
@GCVazquez
@GCVazquez Жыл бұрын
you'll enjoy this!
Judgment Retrospective - Blinded From The Truth
1:10:58
Riku
Рет қаралды 14 М.
I Need Some Help
28:29
GC Vazquez
Рет қаралды 2 М.
How to treat Acne💉
00:31
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
To Brawl AND BEYOND!
00:51
Brawl Stars
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
黑天使被操控了#short #angel #clown
00:40
Super Beauty team
Рет қаралды 55 МЛН
Quando eu quero Sushi (sem desperdiçar) 🍣
00:26
Los Wagners
Рет қаралды 13 МЛН
METAL GEAR SOLID | COMPLETE RECAP OF ENTIRE FRANCHISE! ⁴ᴷ
3:20:32
OnlyGoodSHHH
Рет қаралды 689 М.
Lost Judgment | A Complete History and Retrospective
1:40:07
YourFavoriteSon
Рет қаралды 69 М.
Deus Ex: Human Revolution is FINE, And Here's Why
3:33:34
hbomberguy
Рет қаралды 16 МЛН
Is Judgment the BEST Yakuza Game?
23:10
SnowiestAngeman
Рет қаралды 135 М.
The Complete, Unabridged Timeline of Devil May Cry
2:46:56
EruptionFang
Рет қаралды 3,9 МЛН
Kasuga Ichiban Is Like A Dragon's Greatest Hero
39:39
GC Vazquez
Рет қаралды 36 М.
Lost Judgment Discussion & Thoughts (Spoilers)
47:58
devilleon7
Рет қаралды 16 М.
Vagrant Story Retrospective | An Extremely Comprehensive Critique and History
3:07:34
I Finished A Video Game
Рет қаралды 1,7 МЛН
Judgment | A Complete History and Retrospective
1:25:23
YourFavoriteSon
Рет қаралды 92 М.
The Most (Turn) BASED Yakuza Game
21:23
SnowiestAngeman
Рет қаралды 131 М.
How to treat Acne💉
00:31
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН