A young ex-Muslim called in

[@SaikatBasak]

Doubt is the best thing we can have as humans. You definitely have been able to inject doubt on somebody's mind.

[@mangeshshirali7954]

good way to compel the mind to reason and question the reason. but only concern might be, that in this quest one would either be happier than ever (as I am) or feel distraught (as I used to)... but in anycase... clarity of confusion shall prove more empathetic than clarity of thought. just sharing...

[@warrior_of_liberation]

This was sweet call... and i am glad to see people from Muslim background being positive about it in comments.😀

[@AazamPossum]

Yeah. I feel better seeing other exmuslims turning up. It's a positive change

[@makekikkeli2699]

Love your name and pic, it fits so well to the theme

[@warrior_of_liberation]

@@makekikkeli2699 Thanks ✌🏼😁

[@beRationalByShekhar]

"Roadmap is what you had till now. Right now what you have is freedom" Brilliant! I'm gonna use that.

[@Ranak_141]

yeah, most people just follow religion without thinking that much, My family is also Muslim but not that religious so I used to call myself Muslim, Also I grew up with secular thoughts because of my family and my secular school, and with fascination with science. So when I came across some more religious things, I found that hard to believe, I made excuses to stay religious then I just accepted I was an atheist, and Vimoh you helped a lot, these videos helped me to shape my points, and positions better. Thanks

[@Sreetam89]

Same story but with Hinduism

[@sadiqakhan277]

As a mother i am so happy, when youngsters like her doubt, criticize and leave islam. Atheist men are accepted in our community but females no way. An old Vimoh fan,💜 you made more sense than the ex muslims.

[@kannadafactstar]

Atheist man ?? How are they accepted?? Lmao

[@sadiqakhan277]

@@kannadafactstar i meant tolerated, a man who never prays fasts and jokes abt god is ok but a woman dare not she will be scolded even threatened to mend her ways.

[@Heisenberger2005]

​@@sadiqakhan277 here mam you dropped you rationality crown 👑

[@sadiqakhan277]

@@Heisenberger2005 muslimahs never wear any crown, its all abt your taqwa n belief.

[@sameerhussain444]

Agreed

[@sufyankhan6089]

What amazes me is his ability to stay calm when she said he was the one who made her doubt her religion. I become so happy in a "gotcha" kind of sense when i debate with any religious friend of mine and they concede even a minor point. Really amazing that he stayed calm and collected and not even a smile on his face.

[@SKEPTICsss]

This video felt so good this hour in the morning 😭

[@customerservice8320]

I am an ex-muslim atheist. It feels great to be able to get out of such dogmatic thinking and mindset. My journey began with mufassil islam( Bangladeshi British ex-muslim), Vimoh (indian atheist), apostate prophet(turkish ex-muslim), galib kamal and haris sultan(Pakistani atheist and reading richard dawkins and many others

[@CVR-qt8dn]

I don't know about other people. I love Vimoh but hate Apostate prophet. I mean Apostate has literally made a duo with a christian preacher just to attack islam. 😂

[@customerservice8320]

@@CVR-qt8dn yeah... I have seen so many colors in people since i became atheist. Today i find most of them are dogmatic in different ways, like some of them are extremely narcissist. Some are arrogant, some uses other blind religious people and rig money from them like Indian ex Muslim sahil is to afraid to talk about other religion's dogma which is not a problem to me, but which makes me wonder is he promotes hinduism yet he always announce Himself godless agnostic person. It's their life, they can do whatever they want to do. I just feel sorry to see how religious people become so stupid and let other to rig them off.

[@kishiding]

​@@CVR-qt8dn But ap don't agree on every with david wood. The main thing is no matter what is doing, Is his acquisitions in Quran are correct?

[@CVR-qt8dn]

@@kishiding Absolutely not. I don't take david wood seriously. His videos are only based on his hatred of Islam. I mean , He laughed at the prophet's splitting of moon and commented that scientifically it isn't possible, but then he is told a similar story in the bible and his laughter disappears in a second. And he was trying to give apologetic justifications. He is nothing but a hypocrite 😂

[@Junaid-dr9oj]

@@CVR-qt8dn Can Vimoh debate on evolution or any other similar topic(which challenges Islamic ideology)with Mohammad Hijab or Suboor Ahmed

[@Zia_Ali.]

Wish this lovely caller all the best in life and hope that she is able to find purpose and meaning outside of religious boundaries!! Your content and work is excellent Vimoh and its moments like these that also reveal just how impactful it is - keep on keeping on!! ♥

[@gauravdom]

I want to cry a little with happiness and joy. Her voice, the tone, the innocence, the education, and clarity. It's so wonderful to have experienced this. Kudos to your courage, of course. In an ideal world, this video should be widely watched and enjoyed.

[@as00r60]

This man doing for youths what Richard Dawkins did to me growing up. Kudos ❤

[@AazamPossum]

Same bruh

[@akash2017]

I'm an atheist from a Hindu family and I have tried so many times to have a logical discussion with my family with respect to religion and its fallacies. The caller is so self-aware and honest, it's tough to get something like this in my family.

[@mokka_commentry]

How do you cope up with them? Are you singled out? Or they're understanding enough to agree with disagreements?

[@Skeptic_arun]

​@@mokka_commentry I stopped discussions. Once in a while I do. They pray to god to give me some "buddhi". But seriously I can't see my mother's pain just because of her religious practices. Half of the days she's fasting. And other things...

[@ramakrishnagodugunur195]

I find it much more relieving when a woman/girl steps out of the religious fold. I would offer a warm welcome to the world of free people and rational living. Great content on your channel! Thank you!

[@nishantagarwala4493]

Heartwarming. Thank you. Good to see what you're upto!

[@farjanajamal8802]

This is so much positive not because she is an ex-muslim but bro we are discussing things logically. Wow, we humans, need to listen to stories people have with zero judgements.

[@erick.j8508]

Even u left islam sister ?

[@flamma2870]

she is in early stage of mental freedom. when i understood the concept of atheism or world without god then some type of exposition happens in my mind. suddenly everything makes sense and i realise concept of god and religion is stupid. just like big bang after mental explosion my mind is now in super calm state and i appreciate life and nature more and more.

[@Lunarplex]

This is so encouraging and so admirable.

[@Heisenberger2005]

You are really a rational person sir Doubting religion even after being bought in a Brahmin family Its hard if we see

[@lokendrasingh6760]

Good to see people are questioning their beliefs and figure out what is rational. Good work Vimoh 👍

[@farukh_rationalist]

Hey Vimoh, I was in a very similar situation when I was in Class 11-12th. I was born in a Muslim family, but they are not like conservative Muslims. If I talk about myself, I was never inclined towards religion since childhood. I always had a rational mindset, and this led me to leave religion completely. It's been past two years since I moved towards more rationalistic approach, and I never frame my judgement based on others skin colour, gender, religion, caste, etc. Lastly, I'm loving this phase, this approach to life being an Agnostic-atheist and rationalist. Your videos helped me a lot in thinking with a more humanistic approach. Take care, Vimoh. I will talk to you someday during the live stream.

[@starlordgg]

I left Islam when I was around her age. I am 35 now and despite trying to find some truth in Islam, I fail to see anything convincingly divine about it. I have also helped many people come to this realization.

[@user-zb3ih3vh4n]

I was an atheist now i accept Islam please come back

[@danish4888]

Brother don't listen to these theists you've made sense full decision in you life

[@Ashl_eykit]

​@@user-zb3ih3vh4nwhy can't you guys just let people decide what they want for themselves, i don't get it.

[@dazaiosamu7316]

​@@nityarai7172....i have....now watch rationality rules...and graham oppy

[@concerned_parent]

Whether it is (ex)muslims, (ex)mormons or other people expressing their doubts I am always struck by how well-intended and genuine they are. Irrespective of the exact beliefs: I always feel the doubts display the striving for good in people. Very humbling and very human.

[@chelseaboy2396]

Great to see a Muslim challenging her beliefs. Honestly saying it so difficult to make a muslim an atheist or agnost but this is such a positive change. Would love to see more such people around in our society which can make our country more rational. Your work is paying off Vimoh. Kudos! And props to the girl for getting into a rational mindset.

[@rajvaibhavtripathi84]

Many people say that going to the temple makes them feel relieved and peaceful. I think it needs some sort of psychoanalysis to understand that it's not going to the temple which makes them feel peaceful but the their belief on this idea that going to the temple will make them feel peace is the real game here. They are so much subconsciously convinced of it that they truly devote themselves to it.

[@rajivlochan862]

Are u an atheist?

[@mokka_commentry]

Or otherwise like how some defend temples, God is formless and have deities for focus or concentration. Once achieved that threshold, they need no longer. These are just false fallacies.

[@rohitk8797]

It’s called having a sense of belongingness and being part of a herd with common objective… we are social animals.

[@humanbeing4076]

My journey towards Atheism begin when I read a quote by European scholar "Never believe in anything if you have even a single scope of doubt". I'm mad at myself till date that I can't remember his name who changed my life forever but my Guess is that he was "Rene Descartes" I was in 7th, 8th or 9th class (can't remember that too😔). I had this chapter on European scholar's in history textbook, Maharashtra State Board !

[@aamirsheikh6798]

Kudos to him for ending up here with Vimoh. Unlike many other ex-Muslims, most of whom align with the alt-right wing and propagate specific ideologies in a clever manner knowing how to attract audiences from particular groups Vimoh remains distinct. While many of these individuals are critical of Islam, their competence in rationalism and critical thinking often falls short. Our goal is to foster a society that upholds secular values and prioritizes rationalism, working towards a future where these principles prevail

[@shiroyasha_007]

I think it was a her.

[@abhi3710]

It's because most radical islamists align with Left liberals.

[@boring.101]

Hope she finds her way.

[@unstoppableub]

We atheists are the most oppressed community.

[@yashwanthchoudary8302]

I don’t think so. At least not in India.

[@eee9034]

​@@LOGICALGUY-jm5fuare you on drugs? Mao,stalin, etc, do you even know what is oppression ? You are just a naive Indian, who are termed 'useful idiots' by your foreign commie masters

[@starlordgg]

Atheistophobia is real folks

[@Aakashputtur]

​@@yashwanthchoudary8302but difinately in muslim community

[@unstoppableub]

@@LOGICALGUY-jm5fu communism is a bigoted ideology. Where communists come to power first thing they do is that they destroy democracy. Ex. China, Cuba, Vietnam, former USSR.

[@scarystory-b3u]

Such a sweet talk ❤👏

[@saquibkhan2103]

That’s a sweet call we all liked it 🥰😍😍

[@usazar]

So much love for this young person 💕! Relax my friend and welcome to the side of disbelief. Yes, when the delusion falls it falls hard. It gets much easier and better.

[@meghac23]

I completely relate to her state of mind. Different people invest in different things physically, emotionally, and even spiritually. And when the foundation of something you believe in so much is shaken, it takes a while to find your bearings. For me, this happens with people I have met in life and not religion.

[@shiroyasha_007]

Beautiful call.

[@vishwakumar2864]

There was (and kinda still is) this damning existential crisis which I got during the time I started to doubt the religion, doubting what if there is nothing after death, and what if all these are probably made up answers by humans just to comfort themselves and by some to exploit the gullible. That was so fascinating and downpushing at the same time 😄. And at that time, there was no internet with me and I never thought there will be many people who must have thought like this. Felt so lonely back then. When you believed theres an answer about existence with certainty and then start doubting it, it hits so differently. And I think I kinda learnt to cope with it. After all it is not like there is "nothing" after my death, atleast there will be people who know me and might talk about me, and probably I might change some paths in the world, hopefully in a progressive way.

[@zaidazam2592]

i dosent matter how x number of ppl are leaving islam coz all these ppl are never serious muslims or they followed their will . or they only followed the so called molvis not the modern scholers like enginner ali mirza or javed gamdi these two are real gem who made me understand the critical thinking in islam how are we have to see prospectives of diffrent rules & regulations .

[@dear_imran]

Obviously a brainwashed Muslim will hardly thinks of his own

[@mayursawant111]

This is a correct explanation of how a theist turn into a atheist. 👍

[@Silversubs29078]

Much support to her, hope she's doing well

[@Mayank-Pawar]

Wow, This was a pretty good conversation and so much to learn.

[@makekikkeli2699]

Huge respect from North-Europe

[@shortinformation6073]

Women who want to leave religion in indian society its only way is be financially independent. There is no other way.

[@mokka_commentry]

What're you saying? Financial independence is the key to Apostasy or other way around?

[@happyguy650]

i can relate to this as an xmuslim. When i started doubting in my teens i used to have panic attacks and would get lost in thoughts for a very long time. But as you said i now have found that freedom.

[@ahmadalimd]

Congratulations to both of you

[@rajesharma]

hi Vimoh, can you suggest any good book on atheism or agnostic atheism in Hindi, I want my granny, mother to read, as they are super religious, and reason is they watched there parents super religious, so followed everything without reasoning. Just them to think little bit differently, and why I am atheist

[@vimoh]

ghulamgiri. by rahul sankrityayan. very short book

[@rajesharma]

thank you ❤

[@rohitk8797]

@@vimohthanks, I’ll buy it for my mom.

[@basantyadav7487]

Critical thinking and open-mindedness is the key. Question everything.

[@rakeshteaches5218]

This makes me so happy.

[@jellybeancandy9080]

one qs - why isnt vimoh bigger, why are we sleeping on this man ... i wish more brainwashed youngsters stumble across you and start thinking for themselves,,, props to you man , cool content... love your debates

[@Manoj_0000]

Jai ho🌈

[@saquibkhan2103]

Bro your smile 😊 👍

[@MrJekyllDrHyde1]

Sister, you need to join the stream of ex-muslims Sahil & Adam Seeker.

[@VerditerClaude]

Brother, you need to see Abuzar Responses and Zaid Patel.

[@eee9034]

​@@VerditerClaudetell your masters zaid and abuzar , to challenge sahil & adam in their channel

[@VerditerClaude]

@@eee9034 they did 😂

[@eee9034]

@@VerditerClaude kon hara kon jeeta, link bhejo

[@LoveYourself-my9nz]

Actually not really, unka content kafi toxic h.

[@xzx255]

It is obvious that majority's threat on religious minorities always leads to more dependence on religion.

[@InosukeHashibira-h8q]

wholesome❤❤❤

[@WhatsInAName222]

All power to her.

[@Noend69]

I can understand him i can relate with him on each spectrum. If there's god its not from any religion . As muslim Shes open about it that not all but most moderate muslim in india don't care about religion much 5:01

[@unstoppableub]

Vimoh, do you think that we should discuss about circumcision of male children?. I think it's a grave human right violation and we should be vocal about it.

[@vimoh]

yes. absolutely

[@doitwithnick501]

love from goa

[@childhoodindoctrination9661]

2:54 *Point*

[@miguelsramon4702]

awesome

[@kookiecuter]

Can someone pls share the link abt the short she mentioned?

[@rolex-r8s]

would have loved to hear more about 'oppression against muslims'. Also do you think the comparison of current environment with portugese actions is fair?

[@vimoh]

yes

[@rolex-r8s]

I don't think so. current govt isn't stopping any minority from practicing its faith. Anyway, thanks for replying.

[@vimoh]

it is.

[@rolex-r8s]

tell me which laws/actions of the govt are preventing minorities from practicing their faith

[@vimoh]

bulldozer justice. saffron hate speeches that go unpunished. FIRs against muslims for doing namaz. multiple ruling party members saying things like india belongs to hindus. hate mongers getting not arrested or getting early bail. the list is endless.

[@ghulamrasoolsheikh2118]

I hear the voice and I got that person is girl, and you call her Ahmed by name, but non muslim call girl with Ahmed name because Ahmed name used for boys only, why I feel that this is only made up story as ex-muslim

[@Zia_Ali.]

Or maybe - just maybe, she's using a fake account or/and a fake name for OBVIOUS REASONS! 🤦🏻‍♂

[@vimoh]

The name was Emmet

[@ghulamrasoolsheikh2118]

​@@vimoh right upper side there is CC , turn it ON and play the video at 2.52 to 2.59 you will see and hear that you call her Ahmed

[@vimoh]

I call her Emmet.

[@AnarchistDoc]

Being an Atheist from Muslim family I don't like this term called Ex Muslim

[@vimoh]

why?

[@sadiqakhan277]

True i also don't like the term ex muslim as no matter what we will always be connected with our roots.

[@eee9034]

@@sadiqakhan277 "ex-muslim" word is best of this, it will keep muslims reminding there is problem in islam and people are leaving it

[@sadiqakhan277]

@@eee9034 infact we are blamed for being obsessed with islam even after leaving it.

[@eee9034]

@@sadiqakhan277 i understand, what you wanna say, but let me remind you , There is surah in quran that tell to ki!! people who left islam , i think you know that, . , its muslims who is obsesed with ex-muslim, even that pdfile warlord muhammad was obsessed with ex-muslim, Ex-muslims are not obsessed with islam, So don't get demoralized by those people who justify the r@ pe of their great grear grand mothers by arabs and turks

[@AbhishekChaturvedi7]

If "there is a designer for everything that exists" then there must be a designer for God as well , right ? So who created God ?

[@Wonderedalien]

That's why we call him" God ' he is the alpha and Omega

[@suga667]

👌

[@kanny8742]

I hope all blind followers take note

[@supreetsahu1964]

❤

[@thanveermohammed1997]

I think this girl needs to look for some Muslim Philosophers who can change her mind to get attached to Islam. Let her watch sheikh Usman , Hamza Tzortis etc .

[@aakibmansoori1476]

the girl is perfectly fine she should enjoy her life rather than waste her time in Islamic cult

[@user-zb3ih3vh4n]

True I was an atheist now i accept Islam I think she takes decisions based on whims

[@tpb1006]

@@user-zb3ih3vh4n so she should believe that the earth is flat?

[@TheVolleyGeek96]

There's answer to everything if you know where to look. Reading or memorizing Qur'an isn't sufficient. I'm not against personal choice of the caller but I'd rather find answers in the books than asking someone about something or watching something on KZbin 😅 that's all. 'It's her choice' though 🙂

[@vimoh]

I'm definitely in agreement about books being more vital than youtubers like me. But there is more actual knowledge on youtube in general compared to all the religious texts in the world.

[@TheVolleyGeek96]

@@vimoh Perspective!

[@vimoh]

No. Provable. The range of topics covered on KZbin alone are enough.

[@TheVolleyGeek96]

@@vimoh I'm not arguing about the quantity or quality. I said about the questions she has at this point, The answers are there in the books you just need to have some patience and determination to find it. Because I'm telling this from a personal experience. Once i was also struggling with similar dilemma it took me more than 2 years to find answers for all my questions. I learned it the hard way. KZbin was never been in my sources. Yeah, I'm on agreement with your point about content being so rich, But that's THE issue because often people get more confused than before after consuming so much algorithm fed content. I hope you're getting my point.

[@Zia_Ali.]

@@TheVolleyGeek96 After seeking your answers - did you coincidentally start believing even strongly in the same religion that you were born in and were raised in from your childhood? Or did you find some other "answers" ?

[@abhichoori4632]

Do we really need someone to tell u that there is no god?

[@nithyaatmeshwaran4518]

Tell her parents that the Muslims aren't being persecuted - look at the whole picture and you will realise who is persecuting whom

[@vimoh]

We're not gonna do that here on this channel thank you very much. Denial of reality will get you banned.

[@ahnafazizict7684]

either side is true. in india, hindus oppress muslims, but then again muslims oppress ex muslims. however, in india's case muslims being oppressed is more severe. in bangladesh however, atheists are oppressed extremely horribly. killed literally. people should stop doing that. everyone, hindus, muslims, atheists etc. should engage in constructive debates instead of threatening and persecuting each other.

[@MrVikas07]

इस्लाम से बाहर आकर बहुत अच्छा किया। इंसान बनो, इंसान की मदद करो। जय श्री राम

[@vimoh]

ummeed hai kisi din tum bhi apne dharm ko chhodne kii himmat juta paoge

[@spuriusscapula4829]

@@vimoh Are aapko pata nahi tanatan drum atheism allow karta hai

[@SENPAI_12]

Rest was ok end mai hagg diya bhai

[@vimoh]

you mean last mein kuchh aisa bola jo tumhare agenda ko suit nahi karta.

[@SENPAI_12]

@@vimoh yes congratulating someone for becoming atheist and ending it with a religious slogan is pretty hypocritical to me..

[@parulgarg4502]

Mothoon is a good movie recommendation for her

[@rajmukhekar7468]

Can we have a conversation about God? I am not an Hindu atheist and neither a Hindu theist. But I want to learn about ideologies of an atheist, because I want to view both sides before I have my opinion. I had conversation with allot of thiests but never met an atheist before... We can have this conversation anywhere you wish like zoom meet or I can also give you my number if give me a reply to do so

[@vimoh]

come on my live stream. link on main page. Saturday at 8 pm.

[@anandmukhekar4598]

​​@@vimoh ( I am the same guy with different account ) I dont know if I would be satisfied with that but i am very happy and excited right now because I got your attention and we are going to have a conversation soon... Thank you ❤