Aberdeen Pig Farm Revisited and Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2)

[@Cartmanhater]

The fact that Arthur was supposed to die after tasting the stew/ drinking the liquor but didn’t just proves once again how much of a menace he is

[@internetcutie]

it's gonna take more than that to take down Black Lung Morgan

[@Wp2oo2owsnxmx]

​@@internetcutieblack lung? As in r/okbuddyblacklung?

[@rmi12]

@@Wp2oo2owsnxmxit’s what micah calls him

[@Ghosty09]

@@Wp2oo2owsnxmxbro is online way too much 💀

[@Wp2oo2owsnxmx]

​@@Ghosty09 sis*. I am a girl, as unreal as that sounds And yes, r/okbuddyblacklumg my beloved

[@Khon_kha]

That fade away long shot of Morgan hacking that prick to death is gruesome I love it

[@AirGoddess1087]

Omg I know! It was like something out of a horror movie! Freakin awesome 😊😁

[@professorwinston]

they really messed up poisoning Arthur

[@QuantumGamingYT]

If u kill the brother and hogtie the sister without killer her and keep her inside their house...If u visit the house after atleast 1 day, the sister will disappear from the house along with the bother's dead body.. But the most interesting part is that if you enter the room where u found a family picture of brother sister and parents, when the quest started, that picture will also disappear... This implies that when the sister fled the house, she took along with her the brothers dead body and the family picture... Insane amount of details by Rockstar

[@rawkerboi]

Dam!!

[@Nataly-qc2jq]

Does she do the same thing if you keep her hogtied in the grave without killing her?

[@SongsForSorrows]

I theorize that this also happens when you hogtie the sister and leave her on the grave w/ dead bodies. I assume that she did escape and ended up bringing her brother's body (and perhaps later bury it) and the picture with her.

[@QuantumGamingYT]

@@SongsForSorrows yes very much possible logically

[@mikebannerman72]

@@rawkerboidamn*

[@Strada62]

There's 2 things that cracked me up, the look on Arthur's face when he realizes the two are incestuous siblings, and the other was the time when he walks into the saloon in Valentine, meet's up with Javier and Charles at the bar with a couple workin girls, and Auther says, "I didn't know i was talkin to a lady!" His facial expression and the way he said it, Priceless!

[@kevinmora5662]

9:03 Arthur’s eyes moving back and forth once he realized. He was like “HOLD TF UP” 😂😂😂

[@gerardwayseyelash]

He said 👀

[@Gunpaw1958]

So, i always thought they were cannibals and the stew they fed Arthur was human victims. He even comments that it taste different, but I never hear anyone talk about it, except you. Thanks!

[@chrishilton3626]

I think your right 🤮

[@bonehead2641]

Apprently though human meat tastes like pig or lamb.

[@chrishilton3626]

@@bonehead2641 I don’t care what it tastes like eating human flesh is one of the worst sins to commit

[@bonehead2641]

@@chrishilton3626 im saying it has a possibility of not tasting off or too different.

[@chrishilton3626]

@@bonehead2641 well they call it long pork for a reason

[@warriorley]

You also forgot the fact that if you loot their food in Aberdeen Pig Farm, they called you out to stop it. When you're not listening and still loot it for third time, they demand you to leave the house. But if you're still not leaving, they'll turn hostile and attack you lol. Robbing them before they rob you is always a good plan. 😅

[@sculptureofsound2]

15:26 you can see her throw the poison in last minute just before she starts stirring and offers a taste to arthur.

[@SouthernRex-1994]

22:22, can't fool me with that angle mister.

[@M3TA763AR5071D]

The noise it makes 😂😂😂

[@angelmonarrez5280]

They look so good lol

[@QueSeraSeraaaa]

"Arthur, my eyes are up here." "I made my choice."

[@QueSeraSeraaaa]

"Yeah, i could use a drink." Is the most relatable reaction ever.

[@kennethkerrigan8140]

where is the house?

[@elverdugo826]

Inside the house, there is a loose wood plank on the second floor, when you turn right at the top of the stairs. It gets open and there is a lot of jewelry box inside the floor. But for some reason, you can't pick it up. Those boxes has some letters on it too.

[@internetkurator9256]

JEEZ really??

[@buff_old_man]

​​@@internetkurator9256 yeah, I just loaded the save, found that plank but there was no option to open it. Turns out you just need to step on it. I guess, it was supposed to be another stash, but they forgot to add the option to open it and loot it (or they forgot to remove it completely)

[@Diggz24]

Dude that's been known about for 5 years!! Lmfaoo! 🤦

[@Diggz24]

​@@buff_old_man he's being sarcastic because it's so widely known and has been for years! That's why Strangeman didn't include it in this vid.

[@buff_old_man]

@@Diggz24 oh bruh , then I'm sorry that guy and I made him spend his precious time reading smth he already knew. Didn't sense the sarcasm since I never heard about it, tho

[@jayb9310]

Incredibly well made encounter yet so easy to miss, love how genuinely well written these creeps are.

[@skxlter5747]

Wait until rdr 3 comes out it'll take up to 100

[@rawkerboi]

@@skxlter5747 we all be dead when RDR 3 Teaser drops! Lets enjoy RDR 2 only

[@JGFurgie]

The Pig farm is supposedly the best way to get money between Arthur and John. Story-wise, Arthur can remember that place, figure it'd be good for some last-minute cash either for himself or for the others to get them out, chalks up the loss to his consumption (old name for TB), but in the madness of the last days never has a chance to really get back. John reads about it in Arthur's journal and once he gets free-roaming, figures "hey at best I can get some money back, at worse I can at least avenge that mess and clear out some dangerous folk". Also it makes sense that there's rumors they were rich; for a family to be able to sit and have not one, but two portraits, and a photo at their own farm possibly takes some serious cash. The portraits mean time to sit, multiple days in a row, which on a farm that's not usually an option. I doubt the portraits are photo-based, as upscaling photos wasn't really an option until sometime after film became more widespread around the 1920s if I remember correctly? Otherwise, most photos were anything from a little smaller than a driver's license or around the same size (a little wider) than most modern smartphones. So yeah, family was rich till kiddos decided to get a little too handsy with each other, got told off, murdered family, probably either murdered or sent away any servants, fed the pigs, ate the pigs, now they lure in people, steal their money to pay bills and what not, possibly eat them, and get as handsy as they like. I imagine a lot of their money goes towards supplies to eat and drink well, with some maybe going towards local law enforcement to keep them from asking too many questions.

[@loodymaster]

what the fuck?

[@ozzycortes6518]

“Don’t be shy partner” I kill them when he said that 😂😂

[@marcmarc3980]

Yeah Me too After you are the miss exist the house with à knife

[@Diggz24]

When you deliver that death blow to her and how you edited in that red screen and ringing flatline sound was phenomenal!! Its almost like what she see's and hears!! Damn that was so good!! Strangeman you are an Artist Sir!! 🎩

[@JubeiKibagamiFez]

Also, before you confront them inside the house after the mass grave, you can enter a previously locked door on the outside of the house that is a Shine Shack. They have a little extra money in a lock box.

[@eston830]

If you finish them off and then come back during the epilogue, the house is a wreck. The furniture's all gone, house dilapidated, etc.

[@professorpyne]

Even if you don’t finish them off, someone else probably does. They don’t run away, if they did they’d take all the money they stole with them. Not only will Arthur be able to retrieve his money from the regular hiding place (if they robbed him), but there is also some (irretrievable) gold bars hidden under the floorboards on the upper level.

[@MackHarrisonofficial]

Bray looks like a fat Tom Cruise and I can’t unsee it. Also you can use the robbery aspect as a time capsule to save money for John.

[@pyr1412]

That’s what I did for my John lmao. I waited until the second to last mission to go visit them as Arthur and I just let them rob me since I learned that John starts out broke.

[@mikebannerman72]

What is it you do Mack?

[@bradwhite5884]

​@@pyr1412 Is there a special dialogue if you return as John after them robbing Arthur?

[@HitsuTwistedTalong]

I always love Arthur's interactions with the couple. I really love how he stares at them during dinner. hahahha perfect super good!

[@QueSeraSeraaaa]

I bursted in laughter, he had the best expressions during that scene."

[@cvolante8032]

"Well... when a brother and sister who are also each other's aunt, uncle, niece nephew, and cousin love each other way too much....."

[@internetkurator9256]

That is the house of Habsburg

[@cvolante8032]

@@internetkurator9256 Technically, that's every monarchy ever. The Brits. The Saudis. The Lannisters

[@deadmentellnotails114]

Sweet home Alabama 😂

[@QueSeraSeraaaa]

"Thank you and have a good night!"

[@fayyazzaman139]

​@@cvolante8032Brits are the ones with Inbreeding because they used to marry relatives too close . The others may marry within family, but at least 3rd or 4th cousin will be the closest.

[@TimberWolfer63]

Nice to see you come back to this. I naturally was like, "What the actual hell" when they said they were siblings. Frankly I took care of both them swift and easily

[@DKSON1337]

22:20 Those are some great camera skills Strange Man lmao

[@JubeiKibagamiFez]

9:05 I know this is more ominous at night, but if you do it during the day, you can see Arthur's look of confusion and then utter disgust.

[@Dutch_from_tahiti]

I see u doing that youtube thing now trewlany

[@MadaraUchiha-rennigan]

😂

[@actualartist3082]

This makes no sense? different character.

[@I_HAVE_LUMBAGO]

Trelawny is a different character

[@kingcharlesparody]

@@actualartist3082It’s called a joke you noob

[@Dutch_from_tahiti]

@@actualartist3082 ik this is the strange man u fellers can't take a joke

[@duskdominator-dd]

Soundtrack at 17:09 is from GTA 5 Mission "Nervous Ron"

[@thebarnineffect]

got a brown dog, scratching at the back door? I'm using that in the future

[@jaymac7203]

I've never heard Bray writing his memoirs before? Lol, I can't believe I'm still coming across new things 🤠

[@rowan9047]

I'm stuck at home recovering from surgery and I've been binge watching your RDR videos all afternoon, they're amazing! Each one is like a little in world documentary. Spectacular use of editing to create atmosphere in a game I thought I knew like the back of my hand after hundreds and hundreds of hours. Such awesome creepy content! Keep it up!

[@Aussie_Jesus_Christ]

when i found that camper i was immediately found by bounty hunters. I managed to shoot them all, but the camper was caught in the crossfire and man i feel bad about it

[@ichangedmyusernamebecausei2551]

Guess he wasn’t quick with his gun after all.

[@rawkerboi]

@@ichangedmyusernamebecausei2551 lmao

[@dafaadhamrizqi8028]

I think you miss the part where you can use them as a stash house. If you did their quest right before the mission Red Dead Redemption you can use them as a place to stash all of arthurs money. So that when you can finally freely roam as john in the epiloge you can go back to the farm and get all of arthurs money back. Now i already forget do you need to kill them or not, so its best to have a separate save file for this trick just incase.

[@ThatOneChick420]

Amazing how many different versions there are, of the Aberdeens and more.. One of the reasons I enjoy it so much, every time I play it, I discover something new.. This was a nice revisit SM. Thanks for another awesome watch! 😊

[@puarterquonder]

Can you explain the mystery why the gunsmith in Tumbleweed (middle of the desert) rent boats?

[@deeem2628]

Water enthusiast

[@SeaguIISoup]

manifesting

[@jdbatx]

Tumbleweed is close enough to lake don julio or the San Luis river, so that’s probably where the boats go

[@christopherbako]

A brown dog scratching at the back door. 😊I'll remember that

[@loxng6801]

I've got a good memory 🤠

[@M3TA763AR5071D]

8:50 damn, homie chipped a tooth 😂😂

[@amberkinney6118]

I think it was actually a piece of human bone fragment left in the stew. My ex used to shoot hares and make soup and there was always at least one little bone 🤮

[@charlesoakland7599]

Awesome you mentioned motel hell!!! I love that movie. I'm glad some people still know about it.

[@sircory9377]

22:47 I know I’m late, but another implication that they may be cannibals is that when Bray first starts speaking about how the place used to be a pig farm, he pulls something out of his mouth, too small to see from Arthur’s POV. This could imply he pulled out a tooth or other remain from whatever poor soul that was in that stew.

[@Cosmic_407]

Remember: pigs eat human bodies.

[@professorpyne]

Something about this “couple” that will always intrigue me but I’ll never get an answer to. Tammy Aberdeen seemed genuinely sad at the mention of her parents’ deaths. Bray Aberdeen’s sadness was also apparent, but maybe less so. Why is that, I wonder? Funny to think that somebody like that could feel regret of any sort. You’d think it would be well past that point!

[@franceseagustin4422]

The man made me remember to the yellow King from true detective

[@mediarare2386]

One of those encounters where you know that everything about this is bad but you go through it anyway. To get some loot and ready to shoot.

[@buff_old_man]

But you never know if the game will let you do somethind after that ugly mf from the swamps

[@Jam_Axo]

the pig farm was my first ever encounter on red dead 2, i was lost, confused, and then two friendly pig farmers gave me a nice warm drink and put me somewhere nice.

[@Night_Terror_]

17:33 that whole scene was awesome

[@bk_bro11]

I'd heard of this channel before but I was not expecting this high quality of a video! Kept me interested the whole time!

[@chaoticboy626]

17:52 “tremors of impact shook my arm. Warm blood splashed on my face. Whatever’s left of Arthur Morgan died that night” IYKYK

[@simpled5755]

Theory: Brad is the forgotten offspring of the Aberdeens. Comes from the descendents of the Aberdeen family, whether it be an unknown 3rd relative or smth

[@patricklevesque6784]

Thank you for the time you take to make these videos. I am always in anticipation waiting for the next one to come out. I can't get over the detail you go into for these videos. This channel is amazing. Keep up the amazing work!

[@Break.]

"a brown dog scratching at the back door" is great lmao

[@tdegrddeehjgd]

The woman has always reminded me of Jennifer Jason Leigh.

[@billybamboom]

17:19 the canonical way arthur would handle this, for sure. i’m set that this happened.

[@JubeiKibagamiFez]

16:49 This happens if you don't get robbed by them, also. If you never drink the drink or eat the stew during a revisit, Bill will still have this dialogue.

[@mullemeck5015]

Wish you’d cover the hidden floorboard upstair

[@truthhurts3524]

Was curious if that was gonna pop up. Have always wondered what those things were/were for.

[@raideveloper]

He probably didn't mention because you can't interact with them at all so probably a cutted collectible, not part of the narrative. Also because brey is an obese npc and that was cut too they were probably developed and scripted quite early. Which explain the forgotten cutted collectible there

[@lewisjohnston7077]

How John Marston can inherit Arthur Morgan money aswell.

[@iambirb6985]

Do you mean the debts?

[@haveabossday]

He doesnt

[@iambirb6985]

​@@haveabossdayOHHHHH, mb

[@lewisjohnston7077]

@iambirb6985 after the mission my lost son and when Eagle Flies dies. Last mission you can do as Arthur if you don't want him to die. Go Aberdeen Pig Farm for dinner. Get drunk. Pass out. Let the couple Rob you. Can go back and shoot Bray and Tammy and then leave the money behind the painting. Come back as John and he can inherit and collect it as early as the epilogue chapter 1.

[@iambirb6985]

@@lewisjohnston7077 i never knew that, thanks

[@summerdreams7949]

I love the cinematic movie clips you do!!❤

[@AngryDadGaming]

Jesus, Arthur went HAM on those pig farmers… _Pun intended…_

[@ThePunkLoserAlcoholic6]

Can’t wait for all your GTA 6 content

[@SamThesillyStuka-bo4qu]

Bro this is one of the best rdr2 vids ever I wish they put the sounds and visuals in it like you did

[@professorpyne]

4:52 This is an interesting saying I’ve only ever heard once… here. “Brown dog scratching at the back door.” Bray evidently thinks Arthur has some “business” to attend to when he enters the bathroom. 💩

[@billarqam]

Amazing effort you put on this Respect 💯

[@gus_dabus]

17:43 emptied a whole round on him

[@354Entertainment]

This is one of the best side quest ever!

[@pajalasunrise]

First time I found them, I was so confused, second time around, something in my brain started to go off everything felt weird and couldn’t figure out why, then I realised all I could think about was the pickton farm and motel hell! I think they took a lot of inspiration from those two. Great video btw😅

[@Fabiokht]

I live in Iran. You are one of the best KZbin users. Watching your work is one of my best pleasures. Good luck, brother.

[@barbarathorndyke8417]

Great video, although I'm surprised you didn't include the stuff under the floorboard upstairs which you can find using Eagle Eye mode. I think it spawns after you've killed the couple and return to the farm after 1-2 days. I believe it's connected to their story, but remains unclear.

[@hipstersheep22]

This guy's the Magma Musen of RDR2 content

[@RealTalkC800]

"got a brown dog scratching at the back door". lol I'm using that, AND I'm gonna say it in a southern accent from now on.

[@Jestnarr]

9:03 Arthurs head: its just a burning memory.

[@edwardcui7535]

If you don’t recover your money with arthur, john can go in the epilogue and recover all of arthur’s savings

[@thenessbi]

i so hope that gta6 story will be as good and detailed as rdr2. Like interactions with npcs, quests ... It's so good

[@Willisintt]

That edit went hard when you went back to the pig farm to finish the job

[@vongsokmony9881]

Holly molly; the Viking axing part is so gooooddd!

[@ElKorzenios]

17:30 - 18:03 - Directed by Quentin Tarantino

[@PatWalsh-l8y]

If you wait to go there until just before Arthur’s last mission and allow yourself to get robbed but don’t go back. Then go back in the epilogue as John. Arthur’s money will still be there. This is a good way to transfer Arthur’s money to John instead of losing it when Arthur dies. I built up a bunch of items which don’t get robbed to bring to the fence so Arthur can have some money for things until he dies

[@mugengamerorsomethingidk4190]

I got to Aberdeen when i was in epilouge, so i blindly just took them as crazy people and not just money hogs, once i got the cutscene with the drinks i took it down but tasted the stew, then i quickly ran to the house hogtieing the both of them and burning the house down with them.

[@ayahnnaharrell1066]

Great vid, but that window scene of you butchering Bray was borderline cinematic! 🔥🔥🔥

[@madisonsosa21]

I can watch your videos everyday and still be intrigue. Very fascinating

[@pickatenney]

Your editing is insane. 🤘🏼❤️

[@end-bat45]

There is a hidden room that you can only access from the outside by shooting out the windows of the room, there some really good loot there

[@victorgonzalez3704]

There is a floorboard on the second floor that you can shoot, It has stuff inside you can't pick. Is that a developers secret?

[@SFAused2Bcookiecat]

In Strange Man's first video about the Aberdeen siblings it was mentioned, that if we let them rob Arthur, we can come back as John to collect his money.

[@Chief81]

One of the coolest encounters in RDR2. I love how Rockstar made the game/world have a creepy/dark side/vibe to it, which imo only made it better.

[@Low-tier-jack-marston6482]

9:03 arthurs facial expression is just him saying "what the"

[@socialbaker4014]

You are made of amazing! I look forward to all your videos, keep up the good work 😀

[@djartyom924]

the coffin of Andy and Leyley but its 1899

[@officialconch]

Is there an explanation for why the brother consistently tosses the food out of his mouth?

[@nagomo8794]

when i did this, I came back for revenge and the game crashed just there by the door. I was so scared to lose almost 10k, when i logged back I went for a biblical massacre in that house (found the money too *sigh*)

[@CHOPPASLUGBM]

I am at 92% completion on my first and only playthrough of RDR2. I debate starting a new story but I just feel like there is so much I accomplished and don't want to do it all again lol.

[@williammurray7453]

Brought her to the pit first playthrough loved how she reacted to it. Great game

[@Uptownculture]

Ur videos the best🤝 Big Love Homie

[@ArcticVXR1]

Also, after a short while... few days maybe, after the events and killing them. If you go back to the house, it will be ransacked and looted.

[@crabifyouwanna]

The music is so unsettling

[@findaxelfoley8106]

Strangeman for the win!!! This is how its done!!

[@Addison8175]

Amazing work!

[@gonzalocastillo6489]

Very very great video grettings from Chilee

[@babyelephantemperor8852]

Great video

[@eversage999]

i discovered this is how john can get all of arthers money in the second half of the game you let them rob you and you come back as john

[@FroggBoy1]

awe man i missed out on so much. i killed them, didn't think to loot the bodies and walked off without thinking much of it. i hate how easy it is to miss out on stuff like this in rdr2

[@Warrior___]

There is as well a prisoner requesting your help and at the end says to you , that you should rob this farm ..

[@SeaguIISoup]

damn the cinematography is on point

[@nastrognola7613]

Best place to save Arthur money for John use..😀👍

[@rhameparralax8006]

"ya pasty streak a piss" 😂

[@Fabuliciouzs]

I love the manhunt music by the way ❤