AC Black Flag vs AC Rogue | WHICH GAME IS BETTER?

[@fellowv1nceenjoyer786]

You can actually charge with your ship in black flag, you just need to sink all legendary ships first.

[@masterassassin791]

oh damn i didnt know that my b

[@fellowv1nceenjoyer786]

@@masterassassin791 nah its good, you probably just didn't play it enough to sink then all.

[@c1own.]

@@masterassassin791 if you ever need content, lore deep dives and just funny gameplay of any of the games, walk through, challenge etc. 🤷‍♂️

[@practicalpro2862]

Wdym by that?

[@practicalpro2862]

U can actually charge ships without destroying all the legendary ships like I haven’t finished all the legendary ships and I still charge ships

[@calvinmatthews1527]

To me Black Flag seems more like a full game while Rogue feels like an afterthought. Also, loved how you formatted this VS video. Hope to see another one like this soon.

[@TheDumbSauceGuy]

Is this a joke? I mean one character is named Hope.

[@Largentina.]

@Ay Bruh Chill What do you mean you're "ngl?" You're not going to lie about your opinion about the world and gameplay? Ok lol. Nobody expects you to. Or did you mean "ngl" as if you thought your subjective statement was an objective one?

[@danielyoungblood8525]

@Ay Bruh Chill Gameplay is the same.

[@geekyluna1909]

@Ay Bruh Chill damn you gonna let them shut you up like that ?

[@Messi-rw9ng]

It kind of *was* made as an afterthought since it was made and released at the same time as AC Unity, the next gen game at the time which had more resources and money being poured into. Rogue was kind of like a last little treat for last gen players.

[@scopekean_6850]

If rogue would have been the same length as black flag i think it would be one of the best in the series

[@MembersOfHistory]

i agree, shay is a good character

[@TheChocoboRacer]

So far they do seem to be the same length in ACTUAL content. A lot of my playtime on AC4 came from all the filler bullshit they added to pad out the game

[@soliduszor]

@@TheChocoboRacer I beat it without doing any of that except some assasins contracts and 5 upgrades to my ship

[@Kentuckyfrieddragons]

Love this opinion and in my opinion, since it’s already game of the original type third overall, it probably would’ve been my favorite game

[@teneesh3376]

Well no. That mindset just encourages devs to pad out the game with boring content. Ac2 and brotherhood had so much bloat that was just extremely boring. And rogue already has some missions that are not fun to play. Honestly it needed more polish. In concept, AC 4.5 isn't a bad idea. But dear God it kept all the bugs and glitches, and doesn't improve on elements. I mean just adding the notoriety system in ac3 would be a great improvement to the world

[@RahatTheKiller]

I'm probably in the minority of people who played Rogue before Black Flag. Absolutely fell in love with it and completed it 100% - I even asked, "Why bother with Black Flag?" When I got BF for free in the run-up to Origins, I ate my previous words. Sure, Rogue has a special place in my heart, but The Caribbean is more gorgeous and Edward's story is one of the best-written.

[@Basisreallycool]

I too, played Rogue fist and, I too, massively found black flag to be far superior when I got around to it. Rogue had a fast paced story sure, but that meant you were hurried from mission to mission, making the ending to an already short game come sooner. Black flag had a leisurely paces story with just enough urgency that you felt you could explore a little in between missions. Whilst you may argue that rogues gameplay was more refined, it means nothing if you don't feel inclined to truly test it. The whole plot of Rogue was a poor attempt to get audiences interested and the new, introduced, characters felt borderline bad. Take the dude in the cowboy hat for example, who the was he? I'm sure I knew at the time but he and the others lack the memorability of black flags characters. Its a testimont to how good black flag is when Edward sits down and sees his dead friends drinking and you feel his emotion. Shay feels too detached in comparison.

[@Largentina.]

I agree 100% Also, when it comes to little environmental details and and the way Edward reacts to the geometry of landscape is definitely superior. For example, you know how when you go up to the corner of a wall in AC games, and you walk towards it so the character leans on it on and tilts his head to look around the corner? Well, on BF and Unity the characters react to whatever is beneath their feet dynamically. So if there's a rock or curb underneath he shifts his body weight accordingly.

[@nmea0601]

Same opinion here

[@moongoalie2410]

Don’t forget that Rogue was very last minute and got less production time compared to black flag. Rogue could’ve been a good successor to Flag, but Ubisoft got greedy.

[@okuigokublack]

Yes, traversal is more fun in BF. The tropical backdrops with jungles really adds a unique feel. Rogue suffers from looking sameish due to the dull winter landscape most of the time.

[@ariesgaming4085]

I really like both the games..but i think in case of ac rouge the story is somewhat cool because it was the first game where a thought crossed my mind that the assassin's are not always nice and the templars might be right this time. Only if ac rouge's gameplay was a little longer it would have been so underrated....but got to say Edward kenway has a better personality..🙂

[@jasemsaeed5967]

The combat style in both games R Trash specially the graphics on both games

[@ariesgaming4085]

@@jasemsaeed5967 bro if you are looking for graphics then you wouldn't want to play either of the two, you would play unity

[@PastPositive]

@@jasemsaeed5967 The combat in both games is some of the best combat in any game, they have the same combat as 3. If you were looking for graphics you wouldn’t go to a game that came out in 2013, so I don’t think graphics are a problem here, in general the graphics for black flag and rogue are phenomenal considering they came out so long ago.

[@digivagrant]

@@PastPositive In terms of combat, AC3 is still superior. Cant best the cool animations of the Tomahawk-knife combat.

[@KingInfernagon]

@@PastPositive I love Black Flag but I have to disagree with the combat being praised. Its a FAR worse copy of AC 3's combat. Its janky, sometimes unresponsive and has audio syncing issues especially in the final kill being muted.

[@smoke1506]

Shays intro will always be iconic

[@jacktheripper6079]

Damn this is a close one personally I prefer rogue but they are both great games

[@stevenmoinian5511]

This might seem obvious, but for me, it's quite difficult. I love both the stories very much. Gameplay is exactly the same, so naturally I like both. As for open world, I like AC4 but Rogue's world is very interesting and unique too (except for NY, which was also in AC3)

[@korozom]

In rouge u can kill npc, and I love that

[@martifato6121]

@@korozom i know me too ☺

[@nmea0601]

@@korozom 😂😂😂

[@nerdtom4513]

@@korozom Also Shay: Too many innocents have been killed already🤷‍♂

[@VagueVAA]

Ngl the story of rogue had me at the edge of my seat more than black flag could ever. And with the short story that helped bc black flag didn’t need to be tht long. They could’ve shortened the sequences to atleast 10 the same goes for AC II

[@delreybaby]

the story of rogue has one of the strongest premises of the series, but it is VERY underwhelming. gameplay wise rogue is a carbon copy of black flag, so the outcome is pretty obvious with this one.

[@godzillazfriction]

so basically all assassin's creeds gameplay that are a carbon copys of their new and each software engine are considered and by your logic carbon copys.

[@Xeno574]

@@godzillazfriction Eh, Black Flag is still better regardless. Rogue suffers from the fact that it's way too short. Like by the time you get halfway through AC4, Rogue already starts playing it's credits.

[@godzillazfriction]

@@Xeno574 wowowowowoowiwiwiwiwiwiwiwwiwoowowowowwoiwwiiwiwiwiwiwowowwoowowowowowowowowowowwwowowowoowwowoowowowowowowowowowowowowowowwoowowowooeoeoeoeowowowwoowowowowowowowowowowwoowowowowowwoowowowowowowowowowowowoowowowowowowwowowwoowowowowowoowowowowowowwoowowowowowo2owo2o2o2o2o2o2owoowoowowwoowowowowowowowowowwowowoowowwowowow really?

[@Xeno574]

@@godzillazfriction Uhhh yes.

[@gametests]

Ac4 gameplay itself is graphite copy of ac3

[@williamhughes8598]

Another great video man. Appriciate you

[@nick15684]

I definitely prefer Black Flag as a whole. Both games are good in their own right, but I feel I got a lot more out of Black Flag. Rogue is a staggeringly short game, even for a game you expect to be short. Interestingly, Blak Flag is the last numbered Assassin's Creed game. After 4, they just stopped for some reason.

[@kibathefang6022]

Ugh, I really loved playing AC Rogue but just when it was getting good it ends. Just so short. If they delayed Unity and focused on making Rogue a full game with longer ans more complete story, then this would have been a good closer for the Kenway series.

[@CJPooz]

AC rogue to me is just more uniquely written man. Perspective was awesome man! Glad they kept it short and sweet

[@williamhughes8598]

Dude, I was wondering how old you were. The reason being that I am hoping to make a channel myself but I'm still at middle school and don't know if I will be good enough

[@slapbass8723]

Man age isn't a problem it comes down to opinions of others and if u r entertaining and fun to watch

[@masterassassin791]

I'm a young adult but with what slap bass said, age isn't as big a deal as you might think. As long as the quality and consistency is there people will watch. If you're thinking about trying to make a channel of your own I say go for it, you never know and it doesn't hurt to try. Just commit and stay dedicated to it and it will grow! Hope this helps, have a good rest of your day!

[@sergentoddball3617]

Check all the very professionnal youtuber, look at their very first video. Everyones videos are bad at first but then you get money to buy better gear and learn to edit better and better.

[@roviewer1376]

@@masterassassin791 you forgot a part of your quote, “Have a good rest of your days, Assassins!”

[@Hefferr]

Dunkey was truly right when he said assassin’s creed reverted to the the most boring and bare bones story telling

[@jbcatz5]

Black Flag’s theme of change is reflected not only in Edward’s development, but in the world he inhabits. The dream of piracy is becoming less and less of a reality as the British take more control, to the point that when Jenny at the end asks if they’ll see pirates Edward sadly says they’re all gone. He had to leave it behind so he could progress as a person and in his position.

[@R3tr0w1]

I have no opinion on which is better, but in my opinion black flag is better, those sea shanties go hard

[@swasthicool988]

YESSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! , Both of my favorite AC games I have played. I love both of these Games. I have been waiting for a video like this THANK YOU MasterAssassin. Can you also link your Discord in the description in your next video. PLSSSSS

[@Smortn]

I personally love AC Rogue more...

[@skylerwhite9869]

Assassin's Creed Rogue accomplished a lot by using pre-existing Assassin's Creed assets. Assassin's Creed : Liberation is another example but nobody talks about that as they executed it horribly.. It is slightly unfair to compare it to Black Flag, a fully fledged game with arguably many more new assets than Assassin's Creed III, although the gameplay of Assassin's Creed felt the same until Assassin's Creed Unity. I can give you a small last of some things Rogue took. -Naval combat system from Black Flag -The entire Davenport Homestead map (with some modifications) -The eagle compass from AC Multiplayer and the whispering noises from Multiplayer as well, I believe. -AnvilNext Engine from Black Flag, I believe. -Naval Fleet missions from Black Flag -British uniforms from Black Flag (slightly redone though) -Legendary ships (but some come with fleets now) -Man-o-war models, from Black flag (some man-o-war and legendary ship models were redone and used for Rogue) But Rogue fixed the small things we hated. -Introduced a faster and sleeker ship that felt arguably stronger than the Jackdaw. -A chance to see how the Homestead looked before the events of AC III (not much different) -Naval Fleet missions which you do not need wi-fi for (pirate gamers, arise!) -There was a glitch in Black Flag where you could dock the Jackdaw just before entering the legendary ship stage. You could then jump onto the ship, kill all the crew aboard, and destroy it with one shot. It was patched in Rogue. -Tailing missions were drastically reduced -Gave you the charge ability in the beginning of the game. and some other changes.

[@Tucher97]

Ah Rogue, the example of "if it works, dont fix it, adjust, slightly alter it."

[@deafmole9974]

I personally see Rogue just as black flag but with better and shorter story, + some extra neat gameplay features

[@jim_stas0911]

Damn perfect video as always even tho I'm barely in it but I already know

[@manavalien2907]

Ofcourse Ac Black Flag is the best game of this series 💖💖💖

[@Engille967]

No. Ac3 and rogue are better

[@ii-p996-go-brrrt-ii2]

Rogue is way better

[@Ambatukam3131]

@@ii-p996-go-brrrt-ii2 no ac black flag better rogue because graphically black flag is much better i was playing rogue on old pc it was nice but new pc really looks much better than ac black flag rogue i'm sure of that

[@Engille967]

In customization you mentioned the side content, there are similar native pillar puzzles in Rogue and you unlock a templar armor for templar relics

[@superkid801]

Another great Vs. I do say Black Flag for the story and journey we follow with Edward, although Rogue is also great for exploring the other side too. I do enjoy the soundtracks to these games as well. Great video mentor

[@benspooner7396]

Black flag also had stalkers in the jungle section with the natives when you reach the observatory

[@CdDaGod]

We need that Origins vs Knight vid ASAP my guy. Great Vid btw 👏🏽

[@jesusdelatorrereynoso6297]

I'm really glad that the deciding factors for the plot were the length of Rogue and Achilles' character because I hear valid reasons for why both plots should get the point there. Edward's journey is a dream really (at least for me) as a young guy, being the captain of a crew, going around partying and not having a care in the world in your forties like life finally smiling on him after working hard his whole life, it's really relatable to a guys goals in life as an underdog so you want him to rise up the ladder. And Shay's story is a great addition to the whole Templar-Assassin conflict, the theme that neither side is all good or bad, which is great for the fans out there looking for something more related to the series' premise as a whole even having a direct impact on the other games III and Unity. It's a tie, but yeah, the short story brought Rogue down just a bit.

[@sabashukvani]

Even though I prefer Black Flag over Rogue because of the open world and settings both games are still magnificent and they’re one of my favorite games from the whole series. The gameplay is really enjoyable in both games and naval combat is splendidly designed.

[@dragusz]

Indeed but in my opinion ac3 naval combat was more realistic than Rogue and black flag

[@coolpikachu17]

Black Flag was good due to Edward being a pirate and that makes him better but they should have extended Rouge's story.

[@Rhyfhm]

Can you do a review on the Assassin's Creed movie? Great video!

[@masterassassin791]

I actually did one quite a while ago as a 40K special if you'd like to check it out! Maybe I'll do a longer more proper review for it someday as well

[@Farfigschiter.]

Pros each game: fun as fuck with good story Cons each game: too many tailing missions in Black Flag and Rogue is too short

[@seabubbles225]

I do love both games, but I rly believe the timing of Rogue matters a lot. It is basically more of the same with tweaks and enhancements. If Rogue came first, it would probably be liked a little more, while Black Flag does have a more interesting setting

[@stereowired]

The Big Mouth cheat makes Rogue my preferred favorite. Also I love the French and Indian War setting, cause I’m a fan of that period of history.

[@jbcatz5]

It is worth looking around the Abstergo Entertainment building for memos and QR code sticky notes, getting files and information to flesh out the modern day setting and from the perspective of Abstergo to boot. Black Flag has a excerpt of the novelisation as one of these firewall minigame rewards. One memo in Rogue points out they’ve reused the Animus interface from the Edward Kenway project, and another mentions Arno from Unity. If you’ve read the books or played later games a lot more of these emails make sense.

[@jde7052]

I think Unity vs Revelations would be great for next one. Both lineage Assassins, both important love interests, both do something new and different with parkour, big contrasts still create an interesting discussion.

[@peculiar3529]

Personally I found the hook blade very irritating. It just made side ejects 10x more inconsistent

[@jde7052]

@@peculiar3529 I personally thought it was pretty fun but I have heard and understand that complaint. What I mostly enjoyed it for was it’s ability to help you stay in free run getting passed guards when they tried to block you with its kind of roll over them evasion kind of thing it was used for in game of tripping people with it and the throwing guards also for like a combat standpoint I think it added a bit of fun features as well.

[@felhasznalonev7424]

@@jde7052 It felt so weird to play any other AC game after Revelations because I was constantly pressing Shift while doing parkour lol

[@MrMgkman13]

Rogue is definitely more refined, and I love sailing around the Atlantic. But the fantasy of being a Pirate in the Caribbean is just better in my opinion

[@joshbailey4962]

As much as I want to say Black Flag is a better game, I had so much more fun playing as Shay, being a templar felt so similar but so different, it felt so unique and almost refreshing. Rogue to me feels like a polished Black Flag just shortened and with a very unique story. Not to mention that connection to at the end of the game with Arno was just so cool to me.

[@felhasznalonev7424]

I had the same experience. I love Rogue, it's just more interesting to me because I liked the North American setting MUCH more than the Caribbean. It was refreshing to play as a Templar. I remember when AC III came out I wanted a game with Haytham as a protagonist so bad.

[@wanharrazwantaufiak1395]

​@@felhasznalonev7424 😊

[@nicollasplate7479]

It is a polished Black Flag, and the fact it has less content makes it even better, Black Flag is a short good game with A LOT of bad side quests to make, Rogue also has these but they are less and quicker

[@ZandrickKrowe]

Black Flag is probably my favorite AC game but I was pleasantly surprised with Rogue. I neglected to play it when it came out and played it recently.

[@exoticbutters4212]

I think of rogue as the same thing that halo 3 ODST was to halo 3: a smaller, dlc sized game using the same assets and sharing similar gameplay to their predecessor, but with minor changes here and there and a different story

[@TyL3RAdAmZ]

Very good overview. Was thinking of buying one for the switch never played rogue but played blackflag but never 100% completed

[@michaeltaylor815]

It's really hard to pick due to the obvious similarities, and this might be my opinion but I would say Rogue just because the theme is underused with the Seven Years War, and I kinda like Shay's Templar outfit

[@GJMEDICO]

Rogue is way better for me... an improvement over black flag in every way except characters

[@MrAllen-cc6jh]

I would give it to Rogue if it had been longer. Shay remains one of my favorite main protagonists in the entire series, definitely better than Edward, Connor, and Arno. A major difference though is that Black Flag has a lot more and generally better side characters.

[@Jarsia]

Controversial opinion, I actually like Rogue's open world more. It loses some points for basically ripping a city from AC3 to an extent, though New York is still a cool location, but I actually enjoyed the river valley and North Atlantic for their variety. The icy waters could be quite stunning, and I love the close quarters of the river valley, and all the little villages and settlements were fun to explore. I don't dislike Black Flag's open world at all, but after a while it can seem very "one tone". Havana feels more developed than Kingston, sure, but beyond that one location feels much the same as the next. Rogue wins out for me purely on variety.

[@andrewpenhallurick3389]

Thank you for your videos they have really helped me with this game series.

[@kaycred3361]

U make a good point about Rogue not showing templars having a bad side.i didnt even think of that

[@icylow2893]

The only thing that motivated me to play rogue is to unlock all the outfits.... I really like the templar armor from black flag... And rogue has more variations of it

[@nicollasplate7479]

I'm kinda surprised, replaying all ACs in sequence made me notice AC Rogue is better in almost every aspect of the game.

[@NCRTrooper]

Personally I like rogue more I like how they switched it up and made you a Templar and it showed that the templars aren’t necessarily bad people of course most of them are…

[@Althar9809]

AC Rogue feels like Star Wars in many ways… you have a corrupted order from which a Rogue but powerful agent rises to join the opposite side while still questioning his morality. In the end, Shay’s goal was just to be a good man, just like Edward. I also love the relationship between Shay and Haytham but I wished it was more developed

[@rogangamer]

Disagree with World Design. The towns seem very barren and most of the towns look the same. More weather, Snow and Ice was a great touch. I understand there are limits in the tropics but still. Rouge had more dense towns plus the Lisbon level alone made Rogue more impressive.

[@perryquijano6749]

My favorite game is Black Flag, and I just recently bought Rogue so I can't wait to play it

[@Ruhann-Vanzyl]

Black flag was amazing in my opinion i couldn't stop playing, but ac rogue is simply a masterpiece.

[@Disaster0031]

I actually love the setting and theme for legendary ships in ac black flag You hear music and then just see a giant ship come out the dark fog while its thundering and raining plus its a bit terrifying just not knowing where he is and just come out of nowhere and seeing him from a distance

[@stereowired]

Rogue also had some pretty nuts legendary ship battles. The Storm Fortress is like the man o war version of the Morrigan, all modifications and that.

[@Disaster0031]

@@stereowired I don't have qc rogue but the legendary ships are pretty intimidating

[@abednego_1254]

"The boy has so much potentials. but so little discipline." - Hope Jensen, Assassin's Creed Rogue just exactly how i feel about AC Rogue. the game got so much potentials. but so little dedications the devs gave into it. oh well… but at least the main menu music is good

[@godzillazfriction]

it wasnt really little dedication the devs had for rogue, remember it was a ubisoft studio called ubisoft sofia that developed the game and given the exact same release time for both rogue and unity, the bigs of ubisoft obviously wanted to have rogue done quickly as possible.

[@stereowired]

It’s garbage. Worse than Valhalla.

[@gilian7412]

Why is this even a question? 100 % BLACK FLAG!!!!!!

[@legittrololo2163]

I personally prefer the modern day of ac rogue,it has a great ending which shows that not all the Templar are the good but don't show them as completely evil

[@testtickles8878]

Black flag just has too many shitty pointless islands with 1 collectible that does nothing, but its a chore to pull up the ship, swim to shore, climb a tree, and then grab to then slowly swim back

[@NoonMight]

I love these comparison videos

[@smiley6229]

You can salvage enemy ships for money in ac rogue

[@mrmimi807]

Ok, now we're talking, that was always my dream in AC black flag, but when we will be able to make them our ships and make an entire naval

[@هايالقناةفقطتجربة]

i know people don't like rogue but shay is like the definition of fear just look at his face in the cinematic trailers like when you stay at the main menu for too long rogue is such a waste of potential

[@FrostM04]

you deserve more subscribers bro love your content

[@arturstick]

the big difference for me is that AC4 is colorfull, and Rogue is more Darkness. This is a reflection of the protagonist and the places they lived. AC4 is on the caribe, is almost impossible to compete. Dark games make me dont wanna play it when the story ends.

[@hexerrune123]

Bro I love you and your my fav KZbinr and can you do the most humorous assassins

[@AjayKumar-mg3xc]

Bf was the first assassin creed game i played like 5 years ago it has a special place in my heart 💓

[@STSGuitar16]

I bought the Rebel Collection for Switch, which has BF, Freedom Cry, Aveline, and Rogue, and played through BF (92% completion because I just can't bring myself to sail to all of those tiny ass islands with chests on them lol) over the course of about a month. Planned on going straight to Rogue next and started it only to find out that it is literally the exact same game as BF, just set in the north Atlantic. After realizing that, I decided to move on and play Unity instead. Played Unity for a few days until I noticed that AC Origins was on sale for like $8 on ubisoft, so I went ahead and bought that one and started playing it on Nvidia cloud streaming using my Joy-cons on my iPad (which actually works extremely well and gives me even better graphics and fps than my Switch did, surprisingly). I absolutely hated it at first just because I had just come off of playing the Ezio games, AC3, and BF, which are obviously very different game experiences (I just got my Switch in May and have been playing all of these games for the very first time, which has been a great experience) from the newer games. I was initially extremely overwhelmed by it, and I kept getting killed nearly instantly in Origins for so long until I got the hang of the combat in the RPG AC games and leveled up, but now I am actually really enjoying it a lot. Like I said, I'm a relatively new gamer and totally fell in love with the gameplay of AC2-BF, so all of a sudden dropping into an RPG was a huge change for me, but now that I am used to it I'm no longer overwhelmed and feel like I have a pretty good grip on it. I know people love to hate the RPG games, but I honestly think it will be seen as a great move that the series made at that point in time, especially now that we are about to see a return to the classic formula with Mirage. That said, I do still prefer the classic AC formula over the RPG stuff, and I very much plan to play Rogue at some point since it is basically like an extension of BF, which I absolutely love. All in all, I'd say it's a good thing that we AC fans have so many options. I mean you gotta admit, doing something like making every game just a re-skin of previous games, like Rogue basically is, got stale. Absolutely still worth playing, and I do look forward to playing through it at some point, so it's a good feeling knowing that I have another great classic AC game waiting for me when I am ready. Idk why I wrote all of this, I guess I just had some AC thoughts I wanted to get out lol. But yeah, Black Flag kicks ass, and by extension, Rogue also kicks ass too. It's a good thing that we have options in this series and that everything isn't all just the same game in a different setting.

[@simonlee3370]

Why do I feel quite different on running animation between these 2 games? Rogue is a bit sluggish and not as fluent as Black flag

[@nickparker3569]

You are top tier dude! Ubisoft needs to hire you to advertise for them lol

[@rehunk3134]

Love the videos dude they keep me wanting more. Could you do a which game is better on Evil with 1 vs Evil within 2 or red dead redemption 1 vs 2

[@ItsNight.]

I wish they made another book more realistic pirate game

[@EmpireZzzz]

I'm playing rogue right now

[@zombiewarrior225]

Part of me wishes that Ubi postponed Unity for a year to iron out all the bugs and put a bit more work into Rogue. If they didn't release both games at the same time and was smart about things, Rogue might've been a way more memorable and better game. It seems like one of the forgotten AC games

[@alexmurillo9996]

You should make who is the stealthiest Assassin.

[@omardiaz3557]

My answer is "the rebel collection"

[@babyyoda5409]

i love this series, your explanations are great and can you please also do the Chronicles series

[@stereowired]

Personally I enjoyed Rogue more than Black Flag, probably because I think of it as not just a BF clone, but a mix of BF and AC3. It has that Frontier and City exploration of AC3 and the ship combat and seafaring experience of BF. There’s also the Big Mouth Cheat and that’s extra points.

[@pavlekostic5340]

I played both games, black flag is so unique game and in rogue we got things from bf and grqphics and so many details from other ubisoft game like far cry 4, if you played far cry you will see that thay copied water, they copied islands and so many other things. Just to finish Ubisoft made Bf to be best game on market, but rogue is made with low budget, in the shadow of unity

[@hjrmedia9062]

Always Love your Content Bro❤.

[@ericgropuis]

I agree with everything you said in this video. I love Rogue it’s probably my favorite game and Shay is my favorite protag but the game was messed up with having to borrow so much from Black Flag which had the time out into it to make that game good, and yeah it’s a good game engine which lets Rogue play well but I do enjoy the small differences in the gameplay which lets us be a Templar with flipping the assassination target missions which are very repetitive and I get bored rather quickly of them but now having to hunt the assassin instead. I enjoy the differences with the navel combat with the plucker gun, trail of fire and fire shots instead of the other gun, fire battles and chain shots. I enjoy traveling through both games but with the different environments you have to handle the ship more in the tighter space as well as you now being able to be boarded. I enjoy the small differences but does it make it the better game, I don’t think so. If they took the time to develop the game instead of working on both Unity and Rogue at the same time both games could have been better

[@garrywilliams8730]

I recently played Origins and what have they done to the combat?They might as well call it Fighters Creed now.These 2 games wipe the floor with the new ones in my opinion

[@Ishub]

I myself like to call it "RPG's greed".

[@garrywilliams8730]

@@Ishub the difference between AC 1 and what it is now is as vast as space

[@garrywilliams8730]

@N7Andy good point ,I'm just so used to playing the older games

[@garrywilliams8730]

@N7Andy I wonder what Rift and Infinity are going to he like.I really hope they go back to their roots

[@garrywilliams8730]

@N7Andy I don't know much about their histories but I'd like to see it about Mayan or Incan empires

[@Mr3-j4m]

I liked playing AC Black Flag more on my Switch Lite than AC Rogue. Buy both combo collection at $14 only. So good

[@Hepheat75]

Great video, I enjoyed it.

[@sarinz439]

in terms of outfits, I'll go with rogue, Shay outfits are so cool, especially templar enforcer, templar 11th, and assassins killer.

[@erkoconqueror3603]

Great video as usual wp bro

[@GrimTheDestroyer]

I love Rogue more but Black Flag is better

[@inquespot9368]

100%agree with everyone of your choices. Had Rogue been left in the over for another year and been a few hrs longer, we would still be talking about it as one of the best AC games. But its time to raise the blackflag and sing "Yo ho yo ho a pirates life for me".

[@eval_is_evil]

I dont know, i really prefered the north. The BF's jungles all blended in, just wasnt great. Rogue was really well done but short. You could explore a lot though, the maps were nice, you just didnt get much markers for those activities. Very interesting with stalkers, it was great.

[@SatchelChannel]

I think AC Rouge is just an improved version of blackflag. Played both, but i felt rogue to be somewhat better

[@wolphdrake3714]

I knew black flag was going to mop to the floor with rogue even before watching the video😆 I still whated it though...nice take!👍

[@LiamsTheMan22]

Hey Master Assassin, I’ve been recently playing AC Unity again and noticed that the online services are pretty much completely broken now in 2022 and have been all year and I’m very disappointed because it makes getting all the trophies and experiencing all the content pretty much impossible :( maybe you could make a video talking about it since it seems Ubisoft has known about the issue all year and arent doing anything about it and I think it’s very important considering the main selling point of Unity is the coop. Also I love you videos man I’ve been watching a alot of them recently since getting back into AC Unity and you make me want to go replay all of my favourite games again since its been so many years :)

[@Aryan-zs5zj]

Black Flag was the first ac game I played and rogue being the second because I liked ac blackflag so much and I wanted a similar experience

[@Opie1912]

You do a video about the best assassinations in the series

[@darkassassin9106]

nice video

[@_apolart_9927]

I find it funny that in the Brazilian dub of Rogue, the voice actor is the same as Adam Sandler's Brazilian voice actor

[@thanawutchaibandit6950]

Great vid man

[@segplayz4519]

im a bit disappointed you didn't mention george monro, as he was probably my favorite character from rogue

[@charliecharalambous9276]

I love both of them but man is black flag good

[@DJknight8963]

I think another good thing rogue did that was better than black flag was the economy system which not only gave you incentive to raid and get resources but also helps you upgrade your ship and get better gear faster. I will say that black flag did make up for this by putting more emphasis on fleet missions since you can get really good money from those. Other than that I agree with everything you said

[@Teo_Takeover]

I actually prefer Rogues story a lot more than Black Flags, it was just so stupid like Ubisoft couldn't stop themselves from making the same "rebels building a cause to take out an oppressive government" plot they make for every game and I'm glad it changes from that pretty quickly but at the beginning when they're talking about getting pirate followers to join their cause I couldn't stop rolling my eyes with how nonsensical that was. All the characters except Adawale, Thatch, and Hornigold were extremely underdeveloped Including Edward. At the end when he wants to join the Assassin's they make a big deal out of him repenting for all the terror he's caused as a pirate, but from our POV all he ever sunk were Spanish and British warships and actively did what the Assassin's were doing anyways, also he should have been the ancestor who could kill civilians not Shay. character would appear then die and the devs really wanted us to care but I just couldn't like Vane for mission when you have to kill him I was confused half the time and thought he was Hornigold because I didn't remember who Vane was because he was In like 2 cutscenes before that, it was similar with Mary and that other guy who I literally can't remember the name of, but you find him dead. Thatch was a better written but the dying on the day of his retirement was pretty corny.

[@pablochiarelli7818]

U should do a video of which is the best equiped/geared assassin, ranking the gadgets and items of the protagonists