aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Black Mamba to Armageddon]

[@Stantwiceforabetterlife]

NingNing and Winter in the new album⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️

[@argxoxo7326]

now those chinese stan can stfu but if cbar dont buy after international links is open then next comeback she is done

[@jisongprak882]

​@@argxoxo7326 oh she made u mad af lmaooo

[@antoncutie]

@@argxoxo7326 nobody is done except your hating a$$

[@antoncutie]

@@argxoxo7326 nobody is done except yourself

[@GazaAriana]

@@argxoxo7326why you mad?

[@justamultifanperson]

In the end, Ningning got first place also started it at 1st place. Giselle deserves more lines.

[@anisaafsar4528]

As the rapper in a vocal based group. The worst dancer, least popular member etc.? Sure

[@kennyxgn5167]

@@anisaafsar4528u act like as if she even gets all the rap lines lmao and being a dancer dont affect your lines. she and karina's vocal are almost the same, let's not try to justify her mistreatment.

[@ricocarpenter2189]

​@anisaafsar4528 She's an excellent vocalist. Both her and Karina are pretty much on the same level vocally. And despite being a "vocal" based group Aespa still has a significant amount of rap parts that Giselle doesn't get.

[@anisaafsar4528]

@k8lemonade shes always had basically the same lines, in terms of rap no but overall lines and dance centre, it's just yall refuse to acknowledge because it isn't specifically her singing. Girls. Fine. It's a vocal song anyway for the last half. But spicy, drama, armageddon etc. Have plenty of parts compared to their first comebacks where all members are singing and Giselle is being put in the centre for the dance. E.g: all drama choruses, spicy post choruses and pre chorus, armageddon last chorus, spicy last chorus etc.

[@ratubarsah-jp9kl]

She gets 20%, 1/5 portion of lines from 4 members group. She is a subvocalist and a rapper in a mostly vocal based group, she is treated better than most girl group members in her position.

[@ABCslurpthatD]

The way Giselle's only song where she ranked first is also their most streamed bside after Illusion. Her power!

[@twicatcher]

winter and giselle have the same number of lines in im unhappy so if you want you can consider her first

[@malinislowero.2022]

What song

[@twicatcher]

@@malinislowero.2022 lucid dream and im unhappy

[@d_3_ty]

The song being popular doesn't depends who's first in line distribution

[@philip0w0hoang]

Average Line Distribution per song Ningning: 40.2 | 28.1% Winter: 39.8 | 27.9% Karina: 33.7 | 23.6% Giselle: 29.2 | 20.4% Variation: 14.8% Color of Zone: Green

[@jrchx]

GS and KR: "alright we just gone sit here and watch the show" WT and NN: * literally fighting over first place *

[@ionut9277]

Way worse for Giselle lmao

[@MEERAM_legend]

im just sad of giselle because she does not got many line in any song yeah she the main rapper but its okay because she got the first place line distribution in lucid dream song by aespa...love so much giselle 🥰😍

[@tree9273]

She barely even gets rap parts anymore

[@Cryforme-]

I really manifested that Giselle would have another song in this album where she will get most lines but well...Fck SM 💀😭

[@ARBUZIK.dudkin]

#justice for Gisselle. Btw I noticed that in the 4 years that aespa exist most of their song came out in 2023 and after. Armageddon helps with that a lot considering it’s 10 songs

[@ARMYONCE1812]

Finally, Ningning got 1st in aespa's overall songs for almost 3 years! This video reminds me of how Lia beats Yeji from being 1st place in ITZY's line distributions back in 2021.

[@queen_yulia]

LIA and NINGNING are both my biases 😭 It feels good ngl

[@lalisamanoban-q2f]

yep karina and winter get so much line, and mingling is the main vocalist😢

[@Lewis-hl9qw]

I’ve never been so satisfied to see someone’s bar reach the top. NingNing was painfully close for so long.

[@tulio3476]

Yes,she desserve so much more moments in the first place

[@_linlin_]

I agree. I hope SM also gives more lines to Giselle, she deserve to do more than 95% of the heavenly adlibs.

[@tulio3476]

@@_linlin_ i completely agree

[@porcelain03]

wdym Ning and Winter have a pretty even split, the only unsatisfactory one is Giselle with 1 and heavily underused in songs

[@abjolute]

Yall ningning fans need to calm down

[@vixen8990]

let's stream Giselle's synk out rap and show company that we want more lines for her

[@ionut9277]

It's already the most streamed and viewed out of all 4 members. SM doesn't give a flying shit

[@vixen8990]

@@ionut9277 then we really can't do anything 😔

[@jungkookking1812]

​@@ionut9277exactly 😠she literally got most attention during pre debut but now

[@hihi_0906]

6:15 that's actually concerning

[@ionut9277]

FR

[@jungkookking1812]

Exactly 😢

[@aina____]

no it isn't? there are only 4 members, someone has to be last, at least giselle gets over 20 seconds most of the time.

[@immhaaa3858]

​@@aina____atleast?! So we should just be glad that she atleast gets lines? There shouldn't be such a huge gap 2-27, just because someone has to be last doesn't mean they should get least lines every single time

[@aina____]

@@immhaaa3858 well go join aespa and be the one to have the least lines so that y'all would stop yapping.

[@karinaa_bluu]

YAYYYY NINGNING IS FINALLY FIRST! but poor giselle :( the gap between karina and giselle is 200s 😞

[@porcelain03]

finally? she started first she ended first and has a good split between her and winter

[@koreanfannews8458]

​@@porcelain03 why ning fans want to playing that they're got mistreatment? I remember during spicy 😢 ning fans attack winter with a lot of hatred comments because she have a bit little line 😅

[@porcelain03]

@@koreanfannews8458 I fully agree with you. Winter got so much unnecessary hate. You see how Ning is at the top for Supernova and Armageddon and I haven't seen Winter fans wishing pure hate on Ning. I'm Winter biased and I'm out here happy when every member shines, it's bizarre to hate someone from the same gg you claim to love. The girls are friends and each has different strengths. Wish the toxic fans would mature. The only one that is actually mistreated in Aespa is Giselle, sadly. Gigi isn't my bias or wrecker (that's Karina) and I'm very active asking SM to give her more parts. I love Ning, she's PHENOMENAL but you don't have to hate on a member to make your fave rise. It's so weird.

[@typicallymeee]

shes been first multiple times, wdym finally 😭

[@HienNguyen-kh6nv]

I really hate some Ningning akgae fans because they always complains about the line distribution for her since she usually got 1st in most aespa's song

[@IStanItzy0212]

Giselle deserves more lines

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

I honestly thought after full album it should be more fair for Giselle but...... It ended up being more unfair😅.

[@blackandwgite7431]

Ningning es la principal vocalista ❤🔥

[@typicallymeee]

times theyve been 1st in line distribution karina - 6 giselle - 1 winter - 19 ningning - 20 so instead of saying “finally nn gets her well deserved lines” , she HAS been and thats great!! i think all this talk of nn being mistreated w lines is a waste and should be more directed to giselle if im being honest. ningning and winter are the top two singers of the group so it makes sense if they have a lot especially if they’re very close in how many times theyve gotten first. but i feel the rap parts being distributed to the vocal line is unnecessary sometimes and should be given to giselle

[@YESHIROFOREVER]

Yeah NINGNING, but they have to do something about Giselles lines

[@rjiejlk]

Ningning finallyyy

[@imyourjoy842]

finally ningning first as it should

[@m_aslo]

My ningning is finally the first, after so many years

[@zyotagram]

YESS, im so happy

[@porcelain03]

wdym drama trick or treat better things don't blink are last year

[@mioann]

​@@porcelain03 they mean total songs distribution

[@adoreanydesiree]

wdym finally.. ningning has had the most lines and giselle is the one who always had the least out of the entire group

[@m_aslo]

​@@adoreanydesireeYes, it's sad, but at least the main vocalist is the first

[@illuminated.by.ourwishes]

Being a Giselle stan is rough y'all. 4 years of mistreated and people still acting like nothing happened. I bet you if it's was someone else y'all would be loud af, but lucky for y'all it's always Giselle...

[@khahoo5027]

Fr me too as a giselle Stan every comeback i get disappointed

[@Kiran_B]

Same Giselle deserves a lot more lines than she has in Aespa she should prove the company that she is actually good which she is

[@oliviakirch]

wish giselle got more lines :/ she’s so extremely talented yet barely gets any time to shine besides a few songs. all members are amazing of course, though next comeback i would love to see her get more attention

[@opinionisopinion]

Omg my prayers this year got answers ❤ Liz and Ningning rank 1 in their group songs line distribution 🎉 waiting and hoping 0.0001% in twice Jihyo would rank 1 again but i guess even Jesus can't save Jihyo and Jeongyeon anyway back to aespa I'm so happy for Ningning but Giselle should third rank

[@Kep1er_OT8]

Nayeon has 400 seconds more than jihyo its impossible 💀

[@opinionisopinion]

@@Kep1er_OT8 that's why my hope for twice is 0.0001% even Jesus can't save God Jihyo 😭

[@Nayeonmy178]

Giselle deserves second place and Ningning first place both are queens

[@opinionisopinion]

@@Nayeonmy178 actually yes because she is Main Rapper and Vocalist, Giselle the only main rapper and strong vocalist who being rank last in kpop history

[@Nayeonmy178]

@@opinionisopinion Yes she is mistreated so badly

[@sparticle3750]

LOVE THE VID! Did you mean to put most viewed aespa music video at the top btw 😂

[@k-stat]

Ohh no that’s a mistake 😅

[@Kyanandrhea612]

Giselle deserved more lines in the new album

[@newvouz]

Armageddon is the type of song that totally fits her voice but sm really didn't care

[@sushi672]

Why are so many people surprised ning is first here when they literally alternate 😭 next cb will probably be winter again, and ningning again after that, that’s how it works my goodness

[@Lewis-hl9qw]

They clearly don’t alternate overall, Winter stays at the top for most of the video.

[@mimi_imfat]

They did not alternate at all until this cb. Ning was only first overall in debut song and after this cb. With the second song they ever released (forever) winter has been at the top until this cb

[@summernight2752]

They never really alternate tbh. Ningning overall just got more lines than Winter in album only started since Drama mini and this is the 2nd time it happens while Winter leading the first 3 mini albums

[@jungkookking1812]

Ningning is definitely not mistreated but come on you don't have to lie it's definitely not alternate 💀

[@GazaAriana]

@@Lewis-hl9qwcheck it again drama album had ningning and this album again ningning it ain’t even that serious yall do overreact they both the vocals of the group

[@gingerlovesgaeul]

#treatgisellebetter #giselledeservesbetter

[@KYTISKE]

Aespa in 3 years of career has more songs than Blackpink in 7 years of career 🗿.

[@hrinluv]

Every girl group have more songs than blackpink at this time .....🗿

[@Seulgi_bff]

@@user-ml9zs5fg1f🤦🏻

[@soobsocool]

remember when people used to say Aespa had really little songs💀💀

[@Cryforme-]

Coz YG has a beef with them & his girl groups 😭 Blackpink deserved soo much better they're rlly talented

[@Cryforme-]

​@@soobsocool Prob coz that Time SM used to give them cbs after 9-10 months but now since Drama the gap is like only 6-7 months

[@jhaneyx]

As giselle stans, i guess we just have to wait for our girl to release a solo song or album to hear her more Like i dont expect much now for four years she's treated like that. Come to think of it, why she kind of lost her passion to music it must be one of the reasons :/

[@m_6nus]

Ningning on top where she belongs

[@luxnova2467]

Ningning in first where she belongs ❤

[@enixcheen5192]

Ningning deserved that top spot. Giselle deserves more lines. Her vocal tone is my most favorite.

[@lilin2155]

Karining❤

[@camilletexidor3730]

the overall line distribution is quite fair. In a better world, everyone would have 25% but nobody is below 20%

[@mimi_imfat]

I don’t think expecting them to be all around 25% is realistic. Cause the rappers are always gonna have less lines even if they have one solid rap verse in every song cause the vocalists sing the choruses, verses and have long high note

[@camilletexidor3730]

@mimi_imfat exactly. A perfect linz distribution is impossible, so this, is actually a great ld

[@rinakyun]

@@mimi_imfat giselle is also a vocalist not only a rapper

[@hazelsweenz]

NINGNING DESERVED

[@avrilynicolas3247]

Me and Those who were sure that Gigi will outstand in this album finally: 🤡

[@migu8328]

That was me during savage, she appeared so many times but with short lines and thought she'll get a lot of lines

[@sushi672]

We should celebrate all four girls and how much work they’ve put in to make such fantastic music for us. Thank you Aespa ❤️

[@unknowngirl2675]

GISELLE DESERVE MORE RAP ❤

[@mounaazouz5163]

winter fit in every song always first for me

[@jungkookking1812]

So you mean other members don't fit?

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Right

[@argxoxo7326]

@@jungkookking1812 yes

[@Riya_imnida]

Ningning main vocal Winter lead vocal maybe center Karina Main dancer,lead rapper center Giselle Main rapper

[@newvouz]

Giselle is 1st!!🎉.........in the most 4th places....

[@bxnnyzen]

oh giselle... im so sorry that shit company treats you like this..

[@aespaXElsa]

You missed one song "Get goin" aespaXFragile rock

[@kateorin]

what about their "get goin'" song for fraggle rock ??

[@latamfantasy]

pobre gigi

[@Lummieplays]

i thought karina was the one with the most lines lolz i didnt expect this btw i love aespa❤

[@cristhian4012]

Ok people theres a few things we all need to understand. Havent you tought that maybe Gigi doesnt want to rap that much? What if she wants to sing more these days? Yes, maybe SM its not encouraging her that much about her rap skills and practice. We dont know whats happening inside her mind and feelings, and of course we dont know what that messy company its doing 💀👀 But we all know 1 thing: Gigi deserves more lines, thats for sure! Doesnt matter if its singing or rapping. But she deserves it too!

[@summernight2752]

The thing they can give Ningning and Winter rap lines but that couldn’t said the same with Giselle getting vocal lines. Especially for some reason SM always forget her exists after the 2nd chorus (like Drama and Armageddon). aespa is the group who have one of the most balanced talent when it comes to vocal and rap so the gap shouldn’t be this drastic

[@nokimekamipikachu8905]

I wish Ningning will be having more lines than Winter

[@shivabehvandi]

I love aespa❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@saaahell]

I'm glad ningning got 1st place in this album spicy traumatized me so much

[@tulio3476]

Same feeling bro

[@queen_yulia]

Yess

[@Lovewinter19]

yes mhm ningning getting 2nd in that album and having 2 first places meanwhile giselle= yep so traumatic💀

[@SimplyReaverASMR]

Hello second!

[@lamchileung172]

Winter’s voice is very attractive ❤

[@sooji_thesnow雪]

No!!! Winter!!!!

[@jeirartyt9010]

Armageddon is her Best album for sure!!

[@jeonghayeon_triples]

Hope Winter will have more lines in another comeback Title track Giselle should get full Rap

[@ϾϾe]

Winter has enough lines-

[@АлёнаУс-с6ь]

Compare to another groups it's pretty fair I think. Sometimes last one has 3, 4, 5 times less seconds than first one...

[@imNanhha]

lmao finally our main vocal ningning got the first place ❤

[@bestminijeongss]

I think karina and giselle deserves more lines(especially giselle) for bsides bcuz they can sing pretty well even tho they are rappers also the gap between members shouldn be more than 200+ seconds all members can sing i hope in future giselle becomes 1st in more songs and has a high note cuz she never had a high note

[@chase_free]

I really thought Karina will have the most! Everybody have 1000+ seconds so it's a great distribution

[@ThePrincessmaria]

Can you do for enhypen popularity

[@ummuilham3119]

"Good" topic for solo-stan-fans war inside fandom. 😅.

[@ThePrincessmaria]

@@ummuilham3119 no one asked you for your opinion

[@tomoovehk]

​@@ummuilham3119 lmao it's usually the fans of the most popular member that request this kind of ranking video then they can say "XXX main slayer, most popular as expected" and then bring down the other members LOLL

[@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα]

The main vocalist is FINALLY back!!

[@Gold-GamesSK]

Armageddon era mingmingz fighting for 1st kinda reminded me of PewDiePie Vs t-series thing 😂

[@MYDIVESTAY]

Poor giselle

[@benbirinsanım0103]

oh çay kahve kahve çay çay çay çay çay çay çay kahve cay kahve😊😊

[@moonlightsunshine6]

Should Winter Stans now cry about our main vocal being second like the other Stans did in a past? I don't see any comments about "oh no main vocal is second😭", or I guess if it's Winter MYs are only happy is she would be last

[@MYænter]

Maknae line has the most line 😅

[@maryta2976]

But SM give Winter most of the killing parts.. And about gisele!! -_- SM , I HATE YOU In fact, it is SM habit to discriminate for all their group

[@Winteo111]

i see everyone in this comment section hate Winter that much 👍

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Yes thats why i hate this fandom Winter deserves way better

[@hazelsweenz]

​@@dareenabuhmeidan2286she's the second most popular member, the fuck yall talking about 😭

[@hazelsweenz]

being happy because 2ning FINALLY got the first place in overall line distribution is not hating on winter. ningning is the main vocalist and she deserves it

[@Winteo111]

@@hazelsweenz i said "in this comment section" not "around the world" everyone knows Winter is the 2nd most popular member 😐

[@Winteo111]

@@hazelsweenz and i'm not talking about you. i'm talking about some of toxic fans in the comments section who're expressing how much they hate Winter because of unfair line distribution. what's wrong with you really 🙄

[@karismafadilah2730]

giselle...

[@HWSLyt]

Next can you make nct dream line distribution all songs (from chewing gum to smoothie pls)

[@BS-rr6uv]

I mean Winter is a main vocalist and so is Ning, I don’t see why it matters which one is first.

[@Zhewxs]

you write most viewed mv instead all song ld

[@rockylee5647]

Can you do nct127 all songs line distribution

[@alicjanizio7051]

Why don t have a get goin song ?

[@Jennielrc]

A lead vocalist having almost the same amount of lines as a main vocalist , SM favouritism will never end

[@aaliyahalade]

Winter is no longer lead. She’s also a main vocalist Also it’s not uncommon for a lead vocalist to have the same amount of lines as the main vocalist. Best example is Nayeon and Jihyo

[@Jennielrc]

@@aaliyahalade then why give positions of they ain't going to respect them ?? Ain't no need for that

[@hirano5725]

​@user-dc1ry5xk5h respect what exactly? It's not like it's the damn end of the world if the best singer doesn't get ALL the lines all the time.

[@aaliyahalade]

@@Jennielrc main vocal ≠ most lines. They usually get the most vocally difficult part but ultimately line distribution is based on who suits the part the best. Thats why some songs a sub vocalist may get the most lines because its suits them the best or in rap focused songs, the rappers get the most lines

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Winter is also a main vocalist so cry at somewhere else kid Also she deserves her lines in my opinion winter's vocals bring some flavor to aespa's songs

[@hrinluv]

NINGNING PASS WINTER, AGAIN, NINGNING PASS WINTERRR

[@Winteo111]

so? 🤨

[@jungkookking1812]

Chill😂

[@Lovewinter19]

happy now? acting as if shes never been first yet has the most 1 places💀get help

[@hyeekafiiez]

I don't know why MYs get so excited because ning surpassed win

[@My_jihua]

What name app's 🥺

[@viorangealgo]

Flourish Studio

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Winter deserves her lines 🙌 i dont care about yall opinion

[@My_name_is_DexeEyix]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@T4pink]

Two main vocalist fighting each other 😂😂😂. The lead vocal and lead rapper staying steady third and main rapper steady last😂😂😂 . While those two fight it out😂😂. Frankly whether aespa fans hate it or not aespa has one of the decent line distribution in sm

[@kauehenry4448]

2ning and summer:💥💥💣💣💣🤼🤼⚔️⚔️🥷 karen:😀💆 Cuntselle:💀💀💀💀

[@arxxdy9465]

my main vocal winter🔥😻

[@iiSummerXx]

Ningning is 3rd in Next Level

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

No she's last. Random k is little bit wrong

[@Lovewinter19]

cry harder😂

[@marjlyn]

can ningning stans finally leave winter alone now

[@My_name_is_DexeEyix]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Lovewinter19]

Positions Karina - Center, Face of the group, Main rapper, lead vocalist, Main Dancer NingNing - Main Vocalist, Lead rapper, Maknae Winter - Main Vocalist, Lead dancer, Lead rapper Giselle - Lead/sub rapper, Sub Vocalist, Main Aliber

[@argxoxo7326]

now those chinese stan can stfu but if cbar dont buy after international links is open then next comeback she is done

[@jisongprak882]

nah, don't need to worry internationally and now koreans are starting to warm up to her, praising her more bc of her visuals and live vocals. she's gonna be fine lol continue being mad tho

[@argxoxo7326]

@@jisongprak882 hahaha gp don't buy album 😂 😂

[@mariqilieva6650]

Giselle and Winter deserve more!😢❤

[@luxnova2467]

Girl Winter does not… 😂

[@Lewis-hl9qw]

Winter deserves less. Take a 100scs from her and give them to Giselle, then the distribution feel’s automatically a lot better than it is for her currently.

[@rianrony515]

​@@Lewis-hl9qwshe is main vocal, Gigi can't replace her, let's hope for Gigi full rap verse

[@jeonghayeon_triples]

​@@Lewis-hl9qwWhy are you being toxic ? Winter deserve lines

[@Celestial-c8z]

⁠@@rianrony515 gigi could have replaced the rap she got in bahama set the tone in this album and savage/girls and replaced NingNing raps in set the tone and drama as well. They could have had set the tone be the gigi song and have her like 50+ seconds in it albeit WinNing aren’t to be blamed and its sms fault

[@patrickyu6732]

Actually Winter first in Poroglue and live My life.

[@mypearlb5208]

Nope, Ningning is first in Prologue and Karina in Live My Life. This distribution is correct, they have the same as wavemoonk.

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Waiting for winter to be first again🙏💙

[@jotambor6360]

You forget get goin 🥲