AESPA "can't sing" live || each member's vocal

[@hallyupedia4937]

Can you help me reach my first 30 subscribers? I will post more about Aespa. Thank you💛💛💛

[@portalofsoul8429]

I subbed

[@schuylersz]

no

[@yujimeoww3121]

You don't have to post anything ab aespa

[@inquisitvem6723]

There is no 4th gg that can sing live during a perpformance as good as STAYC…hands down the best kzbin.info/www/bejne/m4CoonSYiJZ4rs0

[@sefani5539]

Help help palalu help

[@sleepvore]

i don't understand why their mics are turned so low during their music show performances when they can sing so well. it's such a disservice to them and the fans. i hope they can have more fun with performing live in the future. :(

[@masakazuhiruko550]

But honestly whats the point of singing live without live audience?

[@sleepvore]

@@masakazuhiruko550 even before the p*ndemic happened, musicians have been streaming live performances with no live audience? it’s fun. they can do adlibs and play around. if they perform wonderfully, that’s great! but even if they mess up, it still brings something new and interesting to the table? if i wanted to hear the studio recording, i’d stream the song on spotify. 🤷🏻

[@juno1765]

@@masakazuhiruko550 I disagree, if you're an idol you should be able to sing live and dance at the same time cause that's your job. Lip syncing from debut to now isn't something I would like, like what's the point of doing the choreo and just lipsync... Just make it a live dance and don't even set the mics then. Having no audience isn't an excuse to not sing live. Another group does sing live every performance and without audience....

[@tytracker]

I think it's because they're still technically rookies in their first year. kind of a safety net for them. their encores were pretty good though!

[@nctpwark3379]

In my opinion, sm ler them do live a few times only bcs they're new and alrd getting lotsa hate. Therefore if they make a single mistake haters will come for them which will make it worse. To conclude, it's a protection. But their live performance was too good, although ning2 was a bit shaky by the end.

[@miahbrant6831]

Bro , they come from SM like even the rappers are good vocalists Sm has the most well prepared vocalists in the K- music Industry

[@ihatewatermelons]

I agree

[@Phirunkhunsekay]

Literally, and ppl have the audacity to say otherwise 💀

[@kwissycarat1668]

Yes💯

[@user-zb3np7xo1i]

And the audacity of those sm antis to discredit sm artists in singing is just beyond dumb. Their rappers and dancers may not be the best in terms of vocals but they have really great techniques and they don't sound bad.

[@hindmiley]

The rappers are originally great vocalists but sm make them rap

[@amURKei]

All sm artist can sing.. singing is the main foundation of talents by their artist..from low to high notes..as long as you can sing... Even if you already debuted thay still having a lessons.evaluations etc.. they were very hardworking artist.. the thing is they make exemptions when it comes creating your own musics etc. . .

[@randual123]

Blah blah blah, but why the heck it’s so hard to find them singing live on their own stage?? If you happen to find one please send a link. Much appreciated

[@imasaiko_]

@@randual123 cuz SM wants that stage performances looks and sounds good mostly focus on the dance and visuals and especially in the first days of promotions, they barely let them sing like like in the stage encore and that makes me kinda sad because is a fact that girls definitely can sing live

[@dbpx12]

prove it you cant

[@vitoxander4135]

no, not all of them can sing

[@fullsunstaner8581]

@@vitoxander4135 all of them can sing

[@juliavitoria9537]

Karina's voice blends so perfectly with jazz

[@maurogu_]

Same! I love her voice so much

[@maurogu_]

Same! I love her voice so much

[@HYBELABELSJANITOR]

Ningning: Powerful vocal, nice vibrato, has good control of her voice, and has good technique. Winter: Angelic voice, very high pitched vocal and has good control of her vocals too. Karina: Incredible low notes, phenomenal deep voice, unique vocals and an amazing vocalist too (an all rounder indeed!) Giselle: In terms of vocals, I would say she has a pretty good control of her voice and has a decent vocal capabilities too. But her main strength is her high pitched raps which is kinda new to me, and it's an amazing asset. Over all, they are all good vocalists. STAN TALENTS Y'ALL

[@mintykookieee]

Totally agree!

[@TreyCary1]

Excellent username😂

[@aranyamamaniolimpia7104]

Giselle is an alto

[@anatalias]

giselle in her dreams come true recording, that “im in twilight zone” BLOW ME her tone tho

[@ceekavin8971]

Your right but Giselle is alto 🥰

[@linapetrova7284]

Sm: Vocals and Visuals (also All rounders) Jyp: Leadership and Dance Yg: Rap and stage presence

[@yuqi_cottage333]

Hybe Cube All

[@JiPOPPIN]

which YG? because modern day YG has none of that.

[@pahrisintherain]

@toddy to be honest, I don't know where YG ENT direction right now. The last I check BlackPink is still their top artists. IKON seems to be on hiatus now, Treasure seems to focus on content making now, and I haven't heard the news with Winner. In terms of stage presence, example Blackpink, because I rarely see them perform, I don't get to see their stage presence often. Last time I remember was their Coachella performance, that was the moment I saw how strong their stage presence was. It's kind of unfortunate, we don't get to see them performing often.

[@treasure7262]

@@JiPOPPIN in rap they still have most of the best rappers in the industry. And stage presence they certainly do have. Just check treasure as a whole, Ikon and Bp

[@zdhv5]

@@JiPOPPIN toxic 💀

[@megs3953]

And they only debut a few months ago and their this good and confident and comfortable singing in front of everyone. So older groups still aren't comfortable song live or singing in front of people

[@markalterado88]

They’re*

[@niloo466]

ningning's vocals are so angelic

[@nineplustentwentyone26]

I am stanning such a talented and wonderful group :"))

[@Crystal_Sky_]

2:48 I swear the way Winter sings live is better than those lypsync that they are forced to do by sm. The way she sings so perfectly is everything.💜💜

[@burgerandmilk7133]

okay im now convinced that aespa is the vocal group of 4th gen

[@horus7416]

They are, even if Ningning isn't the best main vocalist of the generation. Winter is 100% the best lead vocal, and Karina and Giselle the best sub vocals of the 4th gen. People don't talk much about it but aespa is the most skilled group in SM in terms of vocal (on average if you count every member)

[@MrRdlv]

The mimers of 4th gen you mean?

[@aeri2771]

u surely havent checked stayc out,,, no hate to aespa they are good vocalists

[@soland1s]

@@aeri2771 nah

[@Vivian-ho1xu]

@@aeri2771 stayc is extremely stable singing live but I wouldn’t say they’re better than aespa yet, like SM is hard to pass in terms of vocals

[@PratyashaBaithalu]

Karina: Seductive voice Winter: Sweet Voice Ningning: High-pitched voice Giselle: Rapper voice Haters can go blah blah blah. But they would keep rocking as always 💅

[@husseinmanggis954]

winter is more high-pitched

[@Mariya_838]

@@husseinmanggis954 yes

[@rinrin4334]

​@@husseinmanggis954 i agree

[@cookielover9250]

Wow... Ning ning and Winter... like i´m sure all of them will have their own singles on day

[@perry7003]

winter and ningning have such powerful but sweet vocals

[@chiviny8512]

No one is saying aespa can’t sing 😭 we all know they’re vocally gifted.

[@noudidnt7376]

Theyre still hated for not singing live though😭 ppl say they cant sing like all the time

[@cowbearrie]

i just searched for aespa live vocals BECAUSE someone said they cant sing lmfao

[@chiviny8512]

@@cowbearrie now what fandom said that 😭 ??

[@cowbearrie]

@@chiviny8512 i didnt check what fandom they were in, but it was a thread of people saying aespa cant sing live

[@jijijasie]

Their songs are vocally demanding and the choreography is insane.

[@melvin91motorola]

miss A with their song breathe singing while jumping while aespa lipsync all their stage for entire promotion thats signs of lazy

[@luxxx23q]

@@melvin91motorola Well they can still ousting miss A

[@vampl0ver]

@@melvin91motorola that song is not vocally challenging lmfao

[@hagakure81]

@@melvin91motorola It isn't laziness, its simply the industry they are part of now. Live singing is pretty much a thing of the past.

[@melvin91motorola]

@@hagakure81 kepler, itzy and stayc can live sing while doing choreo...don't tell me aespa choreo is hard cuz that just bullshit, even gfriend having more difficult choreo than laesypa

[@angel-hj1rs]

Ningning has such a pretty voice

[@j6nrod]

ningning became my bias because of her voice. i watched their black mamba debut stage and i just fell in love with her voice and i said yup she’s gonna be my bias. i made the right choice.

[@MooNLight21400]

Samee

[@fridhahaw9696]

Winter's vocal is another level 🔥

[@idk-mb7eu]

You mean *On The Next Level*

[@alexia3552]

4:45 oh my god that was gorgeous, I hope they incorporate this into one of their songs or B-sides

[@재스민-s5d]

omg Karina and Giselle are rappers but their Vocal is perfect

[@Jiminjeong._]

Karina and Giselle best friends and Best Sub Vocalist of 4th gen too 😭💖

[@wintersdog2343]

winter's voice is so soothing

[@AURORAstuff]

I thought it's a live performance of a song called "can't sing" 😭 pls

[@moonlightyy.7886]

That's creative

[@akihasc7047]

🤣🤣🤣

[@mari-kv8uf]

omg I didn't knew you're a MY

[@wysse_beats]

I know Ningning is the best vocalist in the group, but I'm allowed to like Winter's voice more, when she sings I hear someone much more confident, in next level and savage she has so demanding parts. All of them are actually great vocalists, but when you are confident you have advantages. I hope our Maknae queen can find her confidence in the future performances

[@rosie5816]

She’s more confident than winter especially in the behind the scenes recording. But it’s not even about her being not confident in her voice it’s the fact that she’s aespa most bullied member , she literally got bullied for being Chinese and “ overweight “ . She’s not confident bc eveyone stripped her confidences away. But even with that being said Ningning literally always eats everyone up in these recording behind the scenes.

[@deadcells963]

@@rosie5816 nah all of them get hate , but the most bullied is 100% Karina. Yes , ningnings hate Is unfair but Karina gets more hate and she handles it

[@rosie5816]

@@deadcells963 no at all. The hate karina goes through is no where near ningnings. Cmon she’s been bullied since debut for literally breathing. Yes karina gets a lot of unescorted hate and so does all of aepsa , but what Ningning goes through just for being her nationality is so fucked up. She’s been fat shamed , had xenophobic comments thrown at her , and so much more.

[@alexia3552]

I view both Winter and Ningning as main vocal type singers, just with different vocal flavors. They're both given a lot of demanding parts and difficult high notes, and honestly seeing aespa for the first time all I could think was that each member seemed like an all-rounder solo/center type of level

[@mochees]

winter just has a unique tone that's why you think she's more confident

[@Pamcuup]

I love winter's voice so much.

[@Crystal_Sky_]

NingNing's singing is no joke. Her high notes are so beautiful, She sings it like it's so easy but she slays it,The queen.💜

[@mchellerel7374]

they CAN sing live, they just rarely do, and on reality TV shows like Knowing bros, it's most likely that autotunes are added so that it seems even more 'perfect'. of course it's not the girls' fault, it's just that the shows, SM, and the kpop industry in general is obsessed to make everything seem 'perfect' even though the girls are genuinely talented and sing amazingly live

[@lalitajain7690]

Winter's IU covers are the best ❤️

[@kelvinprince3031]

I'm in love with Winters vocals😭😭

[@vinnymadelynelamata6255]

I hope people know that Ningning is literally a competitive singer since she was a kid. Like, she literally joins actual singing competitions in china

[@aminafem8066]

Winters voice sounds amazing!!

[@msichhakchhuak6252]

i love karina's voice so much 💗

[@Phirunkhunsekay]

4:35 I can't get over this

[@Evilmeowmeow]

Winter,s voice is like a lulluby haha

[@AliceLee-ej5ds]

No one says they "can't sing". They just "don't sing"

[@jkgosolo]

winter's voice is my favorite

[@kabeom]

no one says they cant sing live. everyone knows aespa has vocals. most ppl r pointing out that aespa NEVER sings live n thats the problem

[@WallFlower08]

They do sing lives. Go check out their MR removed stages performance

[@aespa9149]

They sing live like 2 or 1 show

[@kabeom]

@@aespa9149 can u pls tell me which ones? r they actual stages w their song/choreo or just singing itself?

[@MrRdlv]

They never sing live

[@hyunlixxie2662]

@@kabeom there was a behind the scenes where ningning said they’re singing live, and people still continued to deny it

[@Rover_prv]

Karina is very tallented

[@11m.atheus]

I love so much Ningning!

[@haewon_yeji7370]

There is no doubt they can sing LIVE. However, I want them to sing LIVE while dancing. Dont get me wrong. I have been a fan since black mamba to Savage Era but, they lip sync majority of their music shows which makes me sad because there is NO SINGLE doubt they can sing live.

[@bennu547]

From what I hear it’s just trendy for k pop groups to not have live vocals. I don’t know why Aespa is being called out specifically when it’s just a fact across the board. Like I understand that not doing live vocals for a dance, especially if it’s a hard one, because it must be so exhausting. I get that. But it can be done and groups should do live vocals if they want to. Not lip sync because everyone else is doing it. I imagine lip singing in Korea isn’t a big deal seeing that this is the case

[@haewon_yeji7370]

@@bennu547 Right. However, they are the rookie of the year. I dont expect less, I expect more.

[@Moonlight_Shad0w]

@@haewon_yeji7370 Go and tell that SM. But they wont change that, probably for their vocal cord health.

[@mochees]

@@bennu547 do you understand how hard that is. it's so difficult to sing well while dancing with full effort.

[@syulaw6521]

@@mochees but they literally lipsync their forever performance and thats a ballad with minimal dancing

[@mai-is1ll]

winter tiene una voz tan dulce y cute, lloro AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[@anavictoria143]

Aespa is the group with the best vocals of the 4th generation, in my opinion

[@donutspeaking]

Love AESPA

[@PORTSKINZ]

They absolutely can. They just aren't allowed.

[@you-lf2uj]

Why is karina voice so seductive

[@basicallybored4962]

The problem isn't that they can't theoretically sing live, the problem is that they don't sing live during their stages and concerts... idek why they don't, they are clearly stable enough and their raw voices are so beautiful, to the point where it's their focal point.. I think if they focused on live vocals on stage (more than choreo) that would really emphasize their strengths

[@gugsu]

they have sung live a lot of times during this era

[@leeoso7295]

I love ningning so much!!!!! ❤

[@katenarnian6379]

No comment...I will just say one thing...Never doubt SM Idol....SM popular and respect with they high note and vocal....

[@redkei]

Definitely beautiful voices. Definitely being touched up post filming for TV. So talented either way.

[@surabishrestha8227]

Asepa look so happy when they sing live🥺🥺

[@sanuhh.]

I’ve been a kpop fan for years and I still don’t get fans’ obsession with wanting them to always sing live while dancing with very tough choreo LOL. It’s either the choreo is too boring for them or they’re doing pre record, nothing is enough. Personally for me, it’s never bothered me whether someone sings live or not especially kpop idols who work x10 harder, I’m just here for the music. No one gives a crap when Western artists lip synch.

[@donna.exists]

Same. I think SOME fans just want to TAKE PRIDE with the fact that their idols can sing live while dancing. So what if they don't? At least we know that they can.

[@brina9129]

Finally someone said this

[@user-ww7gq2vq9p]

Very trueeee

[@melvin91motorola]

sorry to break your lame reason for having an ok on idol not singing live on music shows but for me following kpop scene from 2nd gen until now it's a pretty big deal for me cuz this is the worst group to not even have one savage live performance except them doing encore stage and radio shows, why their great senior can sing live while doing hard choreo but when it's aespa is ok for them to lipsync? having train for years just to lipsync on stage? whats the point of debuting? f(x) and snsd sing live starting from debut and now aespa having their 3rd comeback still lipsync to their own song? what a joke

[@sanuhh.]

@@melvin91motorola yeah i've been following kpop since 2nd gen too you're not special.

[@VanVeenful]

I don't think people mad about they can't sing. It's just their raw vocal never shown on their performance. It's always their autotuned performance, encore with MR, so basically they never have chance to show their raw vocals for an entire song

[@notmyname3556]

aespa are good, people just being unnecessarily critical since sm produced the best idol vocalists like kyuhyun, luna, chen and wendy.

[@bluelemoonade]

Is quite funny that haters say "they can´t sing live" because is like sir they just don't do to live all the times but they can do it if sm let them and other groups are praised by just sat and sing a little bit live like it was a big thing. Aesap song has crazy high notes and they did it live too, they sounded the same with the cd

[@behappy.4530]

Lip singing is quite okay for me once i hear them sing live and have the knowledge that they can actually sing. People should stop treating idols like dolls lol they are HUMANS that canNnot always do everything perfectly or right

[@melvin91motorola]

what's the point of becoming singers if you can't even sing/lipsync your own song on stage

[@abdulhafidhhidayatulloh1305]

Aespa can sing live, but can't sing live while dancing their own song

[@Tzuhee_Bae]

Babe , they can .. but sm don't let them sing live ..

[@jess.c6612]

No one said they can't sing. I believe these girls are amazing vocalists and can do amazing things but all of their performances with the exception of their debut has been lipsync and honestly idc about being perfect I just want to hear them sing live and do what they are meant to do! they are singers and are dancing at the same time! NO ONE should be expected to be perfect while doing so much! SM needs to let these girls show off their artistry the correct way, not by lipsync!!!

[@jess.c6612]

honestly i just wish that they can show their amazing artistry bc these girls are amazing!

[@Thailandto1]

Ning Ning is incredible

[@darylleadriana]

stop sleeping on karina’s vocals!!! 😭😭😭🥵♥️

[@woomp2004]

SM let them sing live godamnit !!?!?

[@buffdaddddddddy]

no one actually says they can't sing. most are pissed that they're not allowed to sing live. you can be a stan all u want but some people actually want SM to let these girls use their talents live and grow and not waste it.

[@highfunctioningsociopath6454]

they all can sing live but the problem here is that SM won't let them 😃

[@codblueee]

as a second gen stan, aespa vocal is so powerful and amazing damn!

[@kikalcala]

No one ever said they are bad vocalists, on the contrary, what people say is their company should let them perform their own songs live once in a while, we all know they can't be constantly straining their voices, but we still haven't heard them live just once singing their own songs in any show, isn't it weird? Doesn't SM trust on them or what?

[@ice_bear_oaia3743]

i dont think this is what people mean when they say they "cant sing live".

[@drea2578]

I wish SM would let them perform on Killing Voice and It's live channel on youtube or in one of the radio shows. They don't have to dance so they can sing live comfortably. Or SM should just release a live version of their song

[@minkachii2962]

I really love karina's voice 😭💜🥰

[@wtvsfh20]

Ninning is starting to concentrate while standing , so now it's time to think about every "live" performance where they dance

[@marlee7763]

This is why I'm an SM stan.. I can flex that they can sing with their raw voices live.

[@oreoteez.]

how can they not do that?😭

[@dalayneejo]

just wanted to point out that all the clips from the variety show were autotuned vocals. you can hear the slight metallic/tingy tone to them. but aespa is seriously talented and i wish sm would actually do more with them.

[@noudidnt7376]

Yes thats true, but i dont get why they didnt put when they sang live during livestreams and their own videos + encores

[@dalayneejo]

@@noudidnt7376 exactly

[@megalakandayah9347]

Y saying they lip sync???their voices so amazing👍👍👍👍they should get more live performance so people will not think about lip sync

[@whereis.mon.]

i would die for them to make a killing voice medley

[@mai-is1ll]

HERMOSAS PRECIOSAS DIOSASSSSS LAS AMO

[@kaas2597]

Thank you for such a great compilation. Wish they were allowed to sing live on music shows.

[@avi_bhd]

They are amazing, they can sing fabulously but sm doesn't give them any chance of singing live and so many people hate them becuz of that which hurts so much

[@jhonalbertcuria4393]

Ningning's Love on Top is a masterpiece. Why did I just find it now? What's wrong with yt?😭

[@sooya-mc2wh]

It's not that that can't sing but it's that they didn't sing live in many performances-

[@annylumunoz761]

They way all the girls jumped when Ningning reached the higher note in marIAAAAAAAAAAA🥺🖤

[@lofiguy8136]

Okay, I'm just going to say, 'they're all so talented singers, rappers and dancers'! ❤Aespa❤

[@abby-jg6lr]

people in the comments are talking about how aespa never sing live, but can we also mention the fact that red velvet didn’t have a single queendom stage where they sang live?? it’s not their fault but it’s strange because they sung live in every other era. sm was just out to disappoint all of us this year

[@valleriestar2172]

agree there is something fishy with SM

[@cherrywashere6852]

I know and believe they all can sing. You really cannot doubt SM’s vocal bcs they have such high standard and very competitive training period. BUT it doesn’t mean much if they don’t sing live during performances. I respect mediocre but stable kpop lives more than full of high notes hardcore choreo but lipsync. The whole point that makes kpop unique and interesting is their live singing while dancing performances…

[@mai-is1ll]

NINGNING NINGÚNA COMO VOSSSS REINAAAAAAAA TE AMO NANANANA ESE VOCAL PORFAVOR PARTIME LA CARQ

[@hue719]

Not surprised they are from SM entertainment.

[@sakshi6282]

For the Good sake, let these girls sing live. Their voices are so adorable 💖

[@yikes9944]

i mean i already knew they could sing but that first clip of ningning had me shook

[@nzndana]

bro ningning's vocals 😩💗😩💗

[@kentgarcia6244]

Winter my bias🥰

[@williamribeiro1365]

Everyone knows they can really sing, they just don't sing live. It's better to accept that, no big deal.

[@sunnysunlight2497]

They can sing live but until now they still not perform live (live singing + dancing)

[@mai-is1ll]

ay winter sos tan linda estoy llorando ays aya aya ydjsbjaa

[@puuduuwuu]

and now they are confidently singing every song live while using handmics

[@oohindah7851]

this is why SM prefers idols from SM official auditions from various countries to form groups, rather than making groups from TV shows that have been set up like that. SM idols are of high quality, in terms of vocals, dance, and attitude..

[@mirukumiru3901]

here after coachella performance. best 4th gen vocal. queens

[@drwin1965]

ningning is my another favorite chinese kpop idol after ten

[@yennylorenza8765]

i personally love karina's voice the best.

[@kimchae2115]

GISELLE RAPS IS THE BEST

[@sunghoonshii]

I love karina 's voice the most

[@ravenhowlter6773]

their vocals are more stable than my life