aespa (에스파) - 도깨비불 + Girls ｜써클차트 뮤직 어워즈 2022 / CCMA2022

[@yasminchan7425]

I feel kinda silly but hearing them sing Illusion and Girls live, I had to hold back tears, it just makes me so happy to hear them sing live and see how they're actually having fun

[@Amandine___]

IKR I’m speechless right now

[@feli435]

Minjeong is crazy

[@바보Queen]

cringe

[@Amandine___]

@@바보Queen no one asked for your opinion :)

[@leaf5446]

sm don't let them sing live most of the time :( they seem so happier when they do

[@tantan91]

그냥 서서 노래 못 부르는 그룹들보다 이정도면 ㄹㅈㄷ임 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 요즘 앵콜 무대들만 보면 알겟지???? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@낮말은새가듣고]

???:겟사리 라떼 소리 미래쿠와 데쎄게 도나 소뤼

[@Kaisarzach]

Wow winter vocals is amazing, no wonder she got all those lines and high note in aespa

[@BP-tm6ye]

our main vocalist 😍😍😍

[@ZynthoAlgmiros]

​@@BP-tm6ye Lead

[@hyunjinskookiejar2041]

Wow. It’s the first time I’ve heard them actually sing with mics ON, without a loud backtrack or something. And they SLAYED. But this performance was Winter’s rule tho. She was insane!!!

[@winter-bw1ey]

Watch spicy week 2 promotions they sang live there to and their encores

[@poorviverma3125]

Bro this video is before spicy ​@@winter-bw1ey

[@ZynthoAlgmiros]

​@@poorviverma3125well not this comment

[@OliveWang-oq9lf]

Winter vocal power reminds me of Taeyeon , both have small body but their vocal are so powerful & stable

[@TheLastS209]

I've seen them both live and winter is no where near taeyeon's vocal. not to take away from winter, I think she is one of the best performers currently, but she cannot be compared vocally to taeyeon. She gave me goosebumps for the whole 2 hour concert.

[@Valeria-zp2pb]

@@TheLastS209 "Reminds me"

[@OpalStar76]

@@TheLastS209 clock it

[@diegococa8080]

​@@TheLastS209Winter is compared to Taeyeon even by Taeyeon herself, so, nobody gives a heck about yout opinion

[@TheLastS209]

@@diegococa8080 can you post the link for that? I want to see how taeyeon compares the two. Winter is my favorite 4th gen idol, but I mean taeyeon is just leagues ahead of her, you can compare even taeyeons vocals when she was much younger, it was so developed even then. Winter is a good idol and will be very popular with the new gen, who are not accustom to older gen powerhouse vocalists like taeyeon.

[@snoopyd.2309]

My girl Winter is a MONSTER

[@archany_louise]

You can hear the breathing in their mics. Wow. Thiis is what you called live. No loud background music. Winter's voice is powerful. I love the improvement in their stages.

[@vanessalima03]

Yess!!

[@jooxdene5509]

there is a back track but you would know when they are singing, karina and winter confident in singing

[@jesusavalosramos4489]

​@@jooxdene5509 bts and black pink not do backtrack do playback.

[@jesusavalosramos4489]

SM Entertaiment = live vocals.

[@notanameiii1446]

@Hiro Evangelista weakest? you praise Nmixx, how about them? they skipping the high notes part in dice

[@XtaviusOfficial]

Bruh, Winter's vocal stability is insane.

[@saneyuu]

im so shocked fr

[@manshop6283]

@@XtaviusOfficial i'm sorry, i got wrong comment section

[@lesfilledesir]

all of them are super stable

[@auroraocean-df9xc]

Also karina are we hearing her? Gosh her vocals

[@HoàngPhạm-c7f]

her technique improved as well the highnote is not as strained as before, she fully supported them now

[@leafleaf6575]

Winter sings most of the lines and yet she is so stable. She definitely have 4 lungs lol.her stamina is amazing. And love her clean and neat dance always. Slay my queen ❤

[@notyourmomma3409]

haters even called her LAZY 😅😅 How can you even call that lazy?

[@FULLTIMEMUSIC444]

​@@notyourmomma3409theyre too lazy( haters) thats why

[@shefali567]

Winter is such an ACE. but u need to pay attention to her to notice her dancing skills. They only call her lazy cus she doesn’t over do her expressions

[@먀-v7]

윈터 라이브 ㄹㅈㄷ다 진짜 개잘하네

[@bellmeisterful]

People don't realize how good Winter is. She's the most flawless live singer in K-POP from what I can tell.

[@newjeans1998]

I mean almost all of these comments are about winter

[@majesticsuicune3363]

@@newjeans1998 as she deserves, she's the 2nd member to get the most criticism probably after Giselle. A lot of people downplay her abilities

[@newjeans1998]

@@majesticsuicune3363 of course :) im just mentioning it lol

[@user-st1js6dw1z]

생라이브에 가까운 거 맞는듯 도깨비불 때 잘 안 들려서 뭐지 싶었는데 걸스 땐 다른걸 보니 읊조리는 노래라 그랬던 것 같음

[@suckerfortaeyeon2458]

Ning really deserves that main vocal position. Her notes are on point.

[@LOLA-yj9rr]

Right

[@majoo2605]

Mother winter ate fr

[@mate7763]

I came here to re-watch WINTER slay live vocals. I still haven't move on from circle chart WINTER.

[@mrrziith730]

So satisfying to hear Aespa live vocal

[@motkenhyoutube]

winter ate and left no crumbs

[@chickenddumplings]

winter is mad insane, my jaw dropped during the last chorus of girls woah she’s so cool !!

[@vim2339]

Winter is really a good everything her visual is so amazing ❤

[@aldisaputra7973]

oh my god, Winter's voice is so stable and beautiful

[@uchinaga_era]

I came here to clean my ears after listening to that lesserafim coachilla

[@yiliang9085]

3:28 5:33 5:55 8:11 윈터 라이브 실력 실화냐 원전 하드캐리네

[@swing_123]

그 미국투어 갔을때도 윈터만 살아남았잔슴..ㅋㅋ

[@에스파파야]

@@swing_123코첼라는 평소보다 못한게 맞지만 첫 라이브가 너무 큰 무대였어서..

[@Lemon-j3s]

윈터 라이브 파워풀하니 듣기 좋다 역시 윈터..

[@AllenChibi]

Winter is being savage to the mic.

[@Sarah-nu7dr]

Karina is a sub vocalist and she’s hitting high notes like it’s nothing her vocals are truly amazing for a sub vocalist also she’s rlly stable 💓😭

[@HereIStandbyU]

To me she's lead vocalist., not sub. Her vocals are so good.

[@majung28]

All that and being the main dancer and lead rapper is insane tbh

[@중지발가락-i8v]

윈터가 근데 진짜 잘하는 것 같음.... 성량도 미쳤구... 너무 시원한 라이브임

[@dychdyt]

근데 지젤은 마이크가 꺼졌나용??

[@bean-ny3ov]

@@희연-y8h ㅋ… 마이크 내려가서 중간중간 올릴때마다 목소리 잘만들리는데 무슨ㅋㅋ

[@melongbread1105]

@@dychdyt처음에 지젤부분 잘들어보세요 들림

[@melongbread1105]

@@희연-y8h잘들리기만한데

[@yji.n-o2o8]

@@희연-y8h 숨소리 잘만 들리는데…?

[@ELISEAlyssa18]

Winter ate all notes. Karina too. NN when she was walking from main stage to the second stage, it didnt sound like she was walking when she projected her voice. Giselle was mad that she was nearly shouting into the mike (they set it too low?). Wow, amazing vocals 👏. This is what we call "singing". Now, where are the haters. Normally they would be camping in Aespa's videos as if nothing could satisfy them

[@markleeismylee1511]

Winter and Karina are extremely stable, so it makes sense for them to be in Got The Beat with Seulgi-Wendy, Taeyeon-Hyo, Boa

[@와인파이캔]

윈터는 파워풀하게 부르는 것 같고 닝닝은 고음도 부드럽게 부르는 것 같다

[@쑤나-c6f]

맞아요 스파이시들어도 윈터는 고음이 파워풀하고 닝닝은 부드러움

[@Frgiadeffa]

Winter's voice is very Powerful. I can't take my eyes off Winter. Beautiful girl with Golden Voice❤️ Keep up the Spirit Aespa !!

[@markleeismylee1511]

WINTER IS OFFICIALLY THE MOST STABLE 4TH GEN KPOP VOCAL AND IS A LIVE-VOCAL QUEEN

[@xynickyor1223]

No but she is fine

[@TheLastS209]

Agreed. I am blown away

[@dbpx12]

@@xynickyor1223 get ready for your account to be deleted

[@xynickyor1223]

@@dbpx12 for why ? winter is a good vocalist but she's not the best, what's wrong? Are you going to cry about it?

[@melekbasri1575]

@@xynickyor1223 They might be just a little kid, ignore them XD

[@박연아-e4q]

Let's use earphone to hear winter angel voice..she's so stable omg

[@moonblue8928]

When Karina and Winter sing together they sound so powerful

[@lacielleonheart]

8:13 여기부터 윈터 라이브랑 개쩌는 눈빛이랑..걍 소름돋아서 몇번을 돌려봄

[@Bbk-sd6bn]

A R G H J R H J J Y 101/)

[@sidharthkhumanthem7948]

3:29 i can't handle winter's powerful vocal.....

[@9x9_Pali1]

이 날 라이브한 게 신의 한수였음..

[@raykim-sy9yn]

요즘 찐 라이브를 하도 안하니까 사람들이 ar 라이브에 익숙해져서 진짜 잘하는 라이브 구별을 못하네... 어려운 노래에 잘한건데;

[@milli9541]

I’m so glad the company allows them to show live vocals more frequently now. They're all great😍 Winter’s outfit and makeup just 🔥

[@Jasmine09]

omg, winter is so stable, i didnt hear any breathing, she has powerful stamina

[@thflrjatk]

와...도깨비불 무대보고 카리나한테 홀림..와..어떻게..사람이...사람이 아니라..여신이죠....? 아니...윈터 라이브 개미쳣다..너무잘하셔ㅠ

[@pearlyzzaignacio8594]

SM artist vocals are really on another level. among the performers in CCMA, aespa was one of the best and cleanest live performance. when people say SM artist eat their cd's maybe it is true, look at WInter she's slaying that live.

[@martinaci7670]

Winter always stabil when live perform 😭❤️ proud of you gangg

[@끼욧-p3i]

닝닝이랑 카리나도 진짜 열심히 잘함 카리나 근데 아팠나?? 마지막에 왤케 혼자 땀을 흘리지???..

[@noname-pd5nh]

ㅇㅇ 저날 아팟음

[@fivestarmichelin_]

The way they sang all the 'Hey's in Illusion. Bruh mad respect to them for singing even the adlibs of the songs. It's not new, but it’s definitely rare.

[@leok6959]

윈터가 노래 진짜 잘하네

[@divyanshprabhat5195]

winter and karina have well developed stamina both have insane stability .Technique wise ningning is best to control her projection and giselle is already good all she need is more experienced and she is getting

[@개쩌는타임라인]

와 레전드다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 성량 무슨 일 속이 뻥 뚫리네 걸스 댄브부터 엔딩까지 걍 벅차오름 7:24 닝닝 걸으면서도 안정적이고 7:44 윈터는 성량도 미쳤다 8:00 8:06 8:12 8:24 8:41 뭐야 진짜 ai인가 끝까지 라이브 빡 하는 거 넘 좋다

[@ISTJ_0723]

이제 에스파 라이브 못한다하면 귀에 문제있는 수준임 ㅋㅋ (밑댓 병먹금 합시당)

[@김태양-i8n]

암만봐도 윈터도 고음말고는 불안정한데 왜이리 억빠를 해대냐? 고집만 개 센 급식 빠순이들이라 그럼?

[@holyy3331]

@@김태양-i8n그 가수평가였나 봐보셈 ㅋㅋㅋ윈터가 4세대중 3위였나 4위였나 암튼 그럼 ㅋㅋ뒷감당 조심하고 냄새 오지게나니까 좀 닦고다녀 ㅎ

[@모아_마이]

@@김태양-i8n꼬우면 이 영상 엠알 제거 보고왕^!^

[@swing_123]

​@@김태양-i8n응 자소서 잘봣구연ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@정태영-b1x]

와... 에스파 엄청 성숙해 졌다.. 자기들 노래긴 하지만 느낌 정말 잘 살린다. 라이브도 탄탄하고.

[@forteleven]

winter really has the most stable live vocals, a secret weapon indeed 🤍

[@dultokki]

winter live vocal 🔥

[@Sarah-nu7dr]

Can we talk bout how stable winter and Karina are and they all hitting high notes like it’s nothing although that giselle had issues i think with her mic she slayed regardless also their sp they did amazing

[@irenerv2536]

AESPA THE REAL STANDARD OF 4TH GIRL GROUP

[@anwesamanna794]

Winter is truly a rookie monster!

[@wwexbae]

써클이 깔끔하게 라이브 엠알 티가 나오는 것 같기도 하고.. 뭔가 라이브 티가 잘나는 에스파 라이브 처음 봐서 좋다 다 본인 몫 잘하는데 윈터가 진짜 잘한당 마지막 윈터 고음에서 카리나 마무리까지 미쳤네 ㄹㅇ

[@user-zo7xg8wv1g]

걸스가 에스파 팬의 뽕을 차게하는 뭔가가 있음ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ도깨비불도 명곡이긴 하지만

[@iill4379]

명곡 수준ㅋㅋ

[@이예진-h1l]

ㅇㅈ 콘서트에서도 걸스 첫곡으로 한 거 진짜 잘한듯ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@pone1154]

그냥 노래로 듣는거말고 무대랑 같이보는게 ㄹㅇ전투력올라감

[@lotte_1111]

ㄹㅇ 도깨비불 타이틀 해야했었다 할때 걸스나오고 타이틀인덴 이유가 있다 했음

[@Sunset_for_rest]

가사 첫 줄도 “일어나라 그대여”

[@물고기자리-f5o]

잘하든 못하든 노래, 춤에 집중하면서 땀흘리며 무대하는 걸그룹 정말 오랜만에 본 것 같다👍 그러면서 앨범 낼때마다 성장하는거 보면 팬들도 뿌듯하고 레전드 무대에 몇번을 돌려보고 그랬는데.. 요즘은 춤만추고 립싱크하고 예쁜표정에 웃는표정으로 무대해서 재미도없고 보는 이유도 없어서 안챙겨보게됨 우리나라 아이돌들 실력파여서 해외에서도 뜬건데 다시 라이브하는 모습들 많이 봤으면 좋겠다

[@spaceships.s]

Varieties of head voice, chest, lower register, all while dancing. Aespa is a beast!

[@토끼부부-h2m]

8:00 윈터 표정 진짜 미쳤다

[@swing_123]

윈터 저 춤출때가 ㅈㄴ 머싯음..

[@dodoblah7090]

I'm in love with Karina. Winter's live vocals gave me goosebumps, Ning Ning too

[@zainabkhan6346]

At first it felt like they weren't as confident but by the time GIRLS came on they were singing much more loudly and it was amazing!

[@darabamiora869]

Who said they can't sing? come to apologize them now !! Right Now. Wow their vocal really give me goosebumps. So stable and amazing

[@Sv-fp3qu]

They off tune in few adbils

[@darabamiora869]

@@Sv-fp3qu yes ofc cuz they are human and they performed 2song with some dance break so it they might get some exhausted as human should

[@nodescription7286]

@@Sv-fp3qu seriously, who doesn't ?

[@alalani_r3i]

​@@nodescription7286 robots

[@el3166]

@@Sv-fp3qu I don't see ya big self on the stage though? its easy to critique people when you sitting on your twin sized bed at home, don't play with them.

[@clambloom4539]

Winter? What in the WORLD?!!! Those vocals... SHOOKETH!

[@Lalaaland_]

Excuse me??? What a voice! Their live vocals are so powerful!

[@ningthoujamsonia4632]

Omg winter ur vocal is sooo amazing

[@aeD4RK]

*AESPA SANG LIVE HERE, you can hear their breathing and no doubling for back track.* 👌 The fact their studio and live stage sound same; *BEST VOCAL LINEUP EVER!* 💫

[@butterfly4925]

Except Giselle

[@aeD4RK]

@@butterfly4925 Not sure. She can sing live pretty well so if she don't want to sing live, maybe she had some problem. But it seemed live to me.

[@vanessalima03]

Yess!!

[@vanessalima03]

​@@aeD4RK me too!! Giselle is perfect!!!

[@naonieu6665]

Don't know what happened but they look so serious to bring this performance. Their condition at the end tell how hard they perfoms, this is definetely improvement of Aespa. Hope they keep growing for next CB

[@sabinahasanah3671]

Minjeong vocal, rap, dance, sp💖💖

[@sourlivia]

winter live vocal is so good please

[@vananhnguyen6855]

Ning Ning really deserve her main vocal position. Hope that next time Giselle's mic will be closer to her mouth so that we can hear her voice louder

[@dystephiary]

True Ning's runs are on point and she hits them low notes effortlessly

[@gnds_4592]

But NN went through several parts. It's a shame that the dance is praised a lot but the quality of the live vocals is declining

[@auriels1451]

Yeah unfortunate what happened to Giselle - hope next time she can try adjusting her mic or something on stage. But also sounds like the live sound engineer was turning their mics up/down (normal in theater kind of things when using headset mics cuz theyre so finicky/avoid rustles and breathing stuff esp when dancing and theyure not singing) - sounds like they missed doing that a bit (I remember hearing it off when ningning sang a small part and also a few times for giselle F) - hope its a bit better next time - but glad it was live yay :)

[@JustMe-12345]

@@gnds_4592 its basically the first time they sang live… so not a lot to compare to. they all did great

[@muximushy]

@@auriels1451 I saw her adjusting on 1:42 but no more adjustments.... just a bit closer to her mouth will be better fr her sound quite soft in here

[@anonymoushuman1781]

WINTERR I LOVE YOUU

[@팔팔-y1s]

너무 멋지다ㅠㅠ 역시 라이브하는 무대에서 더욱 진정성이 느껴짐 눈에서 독기 보이는 짱스파 최고..

[@user-pb3ke3ds8y]

생라이브가 이럴 수 있다는 게 안믿김 진짜 레전드

[@6elll.525]

winter is the ace!!!!

[@animegurl23579]

Winter's projection & stability is insane

[@markleeismylee1511]

Karina is the most stable sub-vocalist.❤️❤️❤️❤️ And Giselle sounded so good in Illusion, it's unfortunate that her mic issues continue in a lot of their live performances.

[@nanjowan]

Winter and Ningning carried!!! aespa's mainvos devoured this performance♡

[@oktarians6505]

Wah gila! Winter you can ate all hightnote 😭😍😍😍 ini lipsing sama on mic gaada beda hya ya, gilak sih, bangga banget sama mereka 💜💜💜

[@aldisaputra7973]

winter kaya main vocal ya

[@gnds_4592]

Iyaa , tapi jangan deh nyebut winter kek main vocal . ngeri sama fansnya NN . Walaupun faktanya NN emg ngelewatin beberapa part dia nyanyi dan suaranya sering gak stabil . Tp fansnya gak terima sama hal itu dan malah nyerang winter

[@oktarians6505]

@@gnds_4592 ehiyayaaa 😭😭😭 duh maaf bukan gitu sebenernya maksutnya 😭 jadi takut kena hate nih 😭 kuhapus deh 😭🙏🙏

[@oktarians6505]

@@gnds_4592 makasih ya udah diingetin🙏🙏🙏😭😭😭

[@gyubami]

Winter is really good at her job

[@rndmbaeby]

But seriously aespa really improves so much in stage prescense and when they sang live ia really mind blowing how good they are

[@봄이-n8w]

이 영상 진짜 많은 사람들 보면 좋겠다.. 라이브 존라 잘 하는데ㅠㅠ

[@notyourmomma3409]

I was one of those people complaining why Winter got the most lines and highnotes compared to Ningning.. and now I can clearly say Winter deserves all her lines, her stability is pretty insane.

[@moonlightbbae]

samee

[@alexisantill5485]

Karina sounds sooo amazing ahh!! Love her voice sm. 😍

[@chulpowr]

에스파 살아있네!! 파이팅 오진다 짱짱짱!! ^^

[@poeing]

진짜 덕질 정체기에서 써클차트 영상보고 도파민 뿜었다.. 라이브 이렇게 잘하는데!!

[@J-ung]

ㅇㄱㄹㅇ임

[@crazyabout1327]

What a stage! So proud of the girls! Illusion is a really vocally challenging song and it's clear that they are way more comfortable with the range of Girls. Karina and Winter have great stamina. NingNing was a little unstable here, but she was brilliant in other performances, so maybe it was just not her day. Also WHO DID DIRTY my girl Giselle?! It was obv she shouted her lines, so she could be heard

[@Jake71531]

이걸 립싱크 라고 하시는 분들은 보청기를 적극적으로 추천 드리겠습니다!!!

[@라기-g8r]

ㅇㅈ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@junile7879]

라이브긴한데 다른아이돌보다 못하는게 문제죠

[@라기-g8r]

@@junile7879 보청기 갔다 드려유?

[@뭘봐-y2k]

@@junile7879 긍까 다른 아이돌 누구

[@라기-g8r]

@@zzxxzzxx1 기준이 너무 엄격한거 아님?? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@wish7935]

다들 왤케 이뻐..미쳤다ㅏ라이브 실력도 좋고 닝이 윈터 화음 좋다ㅏ

[@kennisme]

Winter literally ate the CD

[@EristiaRafranjaYanda]

Winter omg 😲

[@hannahalvarez48_]

Winter so stable ❤❤❤

[@Qqx41129]

라이브인거 팍팍 느껴져서 너무 좋은 영상 댄브부터 보컬, 랩까지 전부 마음에 든다

[@juli_ettoromeo]

8:11 WINTER I HEAR U

[@cutegurl2218]

winter ate this performance

[@minin4420]

Winter is soooo good

[@모아_마이]

7:43 지린다…

[@firstrunnerup1675]

thats why winter was a secret weapon i mean look at that.

[@jellylibby2527]

Winters like vocals man and people saying she has no stage presence watch this ❤

[@lovesteady]

리나 마지막 애드립 너무 잘해ㅠㅠ

[@mariarosedeldejose6148]

WINTER's vocals is TOP-TIER!

[@eighteenrubidiamond8966]

I honestly appreciate their performance with live vocals cus compared to just watching it, you get to listen to their live vocals which makes their performance much more realistic and actually entertaining especially for us who couldn’t watch the show in person and actually get to hear them sing. Hope they perform with live vocals a lot in the future.

[@jeon_ritu4750]

THE GIRLS ARE SINGING LIVE👀😌 my girls never disappointed uss