aespa(에스파) - Girls @인기가요 inkigayo 20220724

[@HeY-0_0]

Winter looks so cute here when she did her 'yaww' part. Sadly, today is the last stage performance for aespa. We, MYs really enjoyed all the 'Girls' stage performances and till we meet them again for the next comeback..

[@nazimbenseghir4319]

WHAT ???

[@isveclioglusum]

last??

[@rara1138]

@@isveclioglusum the first comment means for music shows because they have to prepare for SK fan meeting on 30th- 31st July.

[@HeY-0_0]

@@rara1138 Thanks for the explanation.

[@tesalonikaruoh8688]

need more stage

[@성이름-n1p5p]

아니 뭔 음방을 한 번씩만 출연하냐고.. 몇 주는 해야 되는 거 아니냐고요.. 컴백하자마자 바로 출연시켜 음방 영상 많이 보고싶은데 하

[@호롤로-k7i]

성적이 생각보다 안나와서?

[@증말루]

@@호롤로-k7i ㅂㅅ 에스엠 원래 음방 별로 안 돎 그리고 초동 여돌 최초로 100만장 넘겼는데

[@aespa_nct_love]

@@호롤로-k7i 넥레때부터 발매 2주차에 두개 3주차에 두개 이렇게만 돌았었는데요

[@justtanaka4326]

I think what makes Aespa different successful is that the four them have different charisma and sound. An unusual blend and combination. Their cultural difference, visuals and sound in one pot is insane.

[@melodies_memoryofexy1006]

Agree

[@altaviadagger8889]

I like your comment, because you compliment all member

[@ningwang9678]

what's an unusual about their blending? It's perfect

[@baeeunho3096]

Yess, since I became MY their voice it's easy to recognize at very first listening! And their voices blending so well together!

[@nisha6785]

Ikr i always thought of this because their difference is very distinct. i think that what makes people gets to know them and easily differentiate each member

[@sushi672]

I’m in love with winter’s vocals, stage presence, rap, and beauty!! she really is an ace

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

her hairs are too short to be the ace.

[@sushi672]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY her hair has nothing to do with her talent lol? and she looks gorgeous with short hair, yes she can be an ace

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@sushi672 unless winter makes herself more beautiful, she's unqualified to be an ace for now. her hairs aren't suitable for her which is why she cannot demonstrate beauty

[@sushi672]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY if YOU don’t think she’s beautiful, that’s your problem. millions of people, including myself, disagree. she’s beautiful, stunning, pretty, you name it. she’ an ace and that’s it!

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@sushi672 it's not about a vote. l don't care how many people is obsessed to Winter. she can never achieve Karina 's beauty level. the only video when Winter was incredibly beautiful is Studio Choom

[@justtanaka4326]

I’m in love Giselle rap, Ningning’s vocal, Winter’s visual, Karina’s dance 😍

[@buluketekdoraemon230]

Me too 😭

[@andreigil8186]

Pero que dice este de winter visual que no viste los vocales de WINTER?

[@Mylyfesmsrbl]

@@andreigil8186 i don't exactly understand what u said but the main vocalist is ningning

[@hyunlixxie2662]

y’all only talk about winter’s visuals, when will u guys start appreciating the fact she improved her sp & expression? her dancing skill? her vocals?????

[@hyunlixxie2662]

@@Mylyfesmsrbl they’re basically saying why they only mention winter’s visuals (it’s not a talent or a skill)

[@lidiabidia105]

I love all the makeup looks on this stage!! But especially Giselle and Winter’s

[@jacoblee5202]

cover up the lack of talent

[@mxmcelestine6210]

i love how gisselle's makeup and hair was styled in this stage, she looks so good!

[@I-DLEneververSVTcaratULTkpoppy]

ikrr me toooo

[@frametastic]

Finally.

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

too ugly

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@Olivia Araújo winter is severely lack of beauty

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY I hope you get better. If your struggling with your own looks. Stop dumping it on the members.

[@giseIIes]

winter’s facial expressions have been soooo good lately🫶

[@rara1138]

WINTER'S STAGE PRESENCE, VOCAL, AND DANCE IS OUT OF THIS WORLD! SHE IS TRULY AN ACE

[@chaeyoungabadbitch9743]

I agree but she needs to work on stage presence

[@rara1138]

@@chaeyoungabadbitch9743 she improved

[@chaeyoungabadbitch9743]

@@rara1138 she did but that doesn’t make it amazing

[@rara1138]

@@chaeyoungabadbitch9743 it’s amazing that she improved, she is improving day by day.

[@exowerone.]

@@rara1138 facts.

[@itsmeilinda]

Ningning's outfit this time was so pretty, it made her look cool and cute. I hope SM will highlight her as the main vocal in the next songs 👍

[@Exhuberant]

Giselle's charisma is overflowing here! Omg, girl she's the definition of hardwork and improvement. She *owned* this stage..!!

[@-zaeq.8869]

No

[@clerith]

yess she gave her best at their last promotion and im really proud of her

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

forget ugliest giselle! do l make themselves clear?

[@fatmad3592]

@@-zaeq.8869 hater much 🙄

[@kkxebsong]

la amo cada día mas y más ♥♥

[@totheworld_NCTot25]

WINTER SMILING!! I'm dead. Ningning so beautiful, it's like she owned this comeback

[@katehyacinth7174]

I just love how Winter change her part of the choreo every stage!

[@warrenrepecio7072]

Which part?

[@memook100]

@@warrenrepecio7072 1:48

[@rhudinaormasa1962]

Ningning and Giselle's aura in this performance is on another level!!

[@jacoblee5202]

aura of being terrible

[@RaissaAlmeida.]

@@jacoblee5202 terrível ?? Faz melhor que ela

[@RaissaAlmeida.]

@@jacoblee5202 ela canta, dança, faz rap,compõe e você fala que ela foi terrível ?? kkkkkk

[@nicotorres12]

Karina - improved her popping Winter - improved her 'energy' and her facial expression Giselle - improved her footwork Ningning - slaying like she normally does Aespa gets a good amount of hate but they will just keep improving. Stanning them is fun because they are hardworking and very humble.

[@sarangfied]

so you’re just saying the other members didn’t used to slay

[@chaeyoungabadbitch9743]

@@sarangfied girl that was such a reach

[@nicotorres12]

@@sarangfied They do, but they are not perfect. And seeing them improve in different aspects is fun too. Tbh Ningning is the best performer but I'm sure she also improved something, sorry for not noticing it though. I hope someone can comment it later.

[@sarangfied]

@@nicotorres12 ok i get it

[@ningwang9678]

@@nicotorres12 it's hard to see Ningning's shortcomings because even haters use Ningning to talk trash to the other members

[@blablabla633]

Ningning's Charisma, stage presence and facial expression are all on point! she's so captivating

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

ningning doesn't possess any charm or beauty. let her retire.

[@vim2339]

Nining stage presence and her beauty is amazing

[@sheesshhhh178]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY lmao what?

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@sheesshhhh178 ningning is too ugly to satisfy audiences.

[@mm-hl2nr]

I think Winter's diction is what makes her voice special. It attracts the listeners👏👏

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

winter got a good voice and a less beautiful appearance.

[@zadreyshants8727]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY shut up!

[@xgalphaz]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY I'm sorry what

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY Toxic Fan alert. Please go back to playing your Tekka 7 game or whatever it is.

[@DeoxysDNA]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY Her visual is strong lol

[@FF-zz6yc]

Ningning is really consistent and she never disappoints 👏🔥🔥

[@user-rl4bp2to9r]

Ningning is such a performer and so professional. Her stage presence is always so fierce

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

she's lack of beauty.

[@L_O_V_E_1574]

*I can't ninigning she so beauty* 😭💞💞

[@neslisah1860]

Ningning is really main slayer. Not just in aespa. Her attitude in stages are all amazing. By far, she has the best stage presence, energy and facial expressions.

[@바보Queen]

spelled winter and karina wrong

[@fritzgerraldmiral6472]

@@바보Queen shut up 🤐

[@AllenChibi]

Ikr!!! Love Ningning so much. She is born to be a star indeed.

[@soph9014]

@@바보Queen this comment is about ningning… and karina and winter barely have any stage presence

[@crystalcastle660]

Ningning is the best ❤️

[@angelinaa.5260]

Winter looks so happy and it's nice to see

[@nicotorres12]

I do believe Girls' is Karina's era, but Winter totally got my attention this stage. She went hard for this performance

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

However, winter 's beauty amount isn't enough to achieve Karina 's

[@iamayanakuzunoha430]

You have zero appreciation for true beauty that is Winter. You should have your eyes check ok dude with long-ass name...

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@iamayanakuzunoha430 l'm not your dude, l'm your commentator. why do l have to appreciate an idol who's not beautiful enough to satisfy my aesthetic? my black eyes work very well.

[@freakittyfreak]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY okay so then why don't you comment about how Karina is the most beautiful and caught your eyes everytime, if you haven't already

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@freakittyfreak Karina 's appearance is very unstable. sometimes, she lost her beauty by wrongful hairstyle and costumes. especially ponytail or double ponytail or she tied her hairs to any kind of shape.

[@hyunlixxie2662]

Winter improved her sp & her expressions so much this comeback, proud of all the girlies

[@delightedfred4626]

The screams when Giselle is going to start her rap, yaahhh we're addicted to her rap 😩

[@jacoblee5202]

screams of pain.

[@SirChick]

@@jacoblee5202 she can rap really well. I don't know what got into your mind.

[@jacoblee5202]

@@SirChick Yeah her rap sounds good to deaf people, I know.

[@SirChick]

@@jacoblee5202 I really hope someone gives you a brain (or functioning ears) Giselle can rap really REALLY well.

[@jacoblee5202]

@@SirChick Someone with a brain wouldn’t be managing a youtube account dedicated to creating kpop clips, so please use insults that wouldn’t be applicable to you as well.

[@tenlee1325]

Wow, Ningning is so beautiful, that styling really suits her

[@violetta7438]

i don't know how aespa everyday make themselves performances better and better,BUT ITS REALLY AMAZING,I LOVE THIS GIRLS😭😭

[@baeeunho3096]

Their learned so much, so proud of them!

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

they 're doing exactly the same thing repeatedly

[@malalaliyah]

I have been so proud of Giselle this era. She's just been so energetic and charismatic and her improvement has been obvious from start to finish, no matter what antis have to say. I'm so proud of and I adore her so much.

[@mxmcelestine6210]

OMG THEIR MAKEUP AND HAIRSTYLE IN THIS STAGE IS ICONIC

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

they're not beautiful at all. Karina destroyed her hairs once again.

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY SHUT-

[@ashercabrera1577]

aespa fighting!!

[@Ximena-wp3zh]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY y este😹

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@Ximena-wp3zh only Karina and Winter showed themselves in the end, which means other 2 foreigners are unworthy to be seen

[@manggutv2748]

태어나주셔서 감사합니다.^^

[@Password9141]

Barbie NingNing who always slayed in every stage. Golden maknae indeed...u can see how experienced she is..

[@MadeJk]

I’m a My, I love all of the members but golden maknae is a title that belongs to someone else, so let’s say that Ningning is an amazing maknae 💖

[@Password9141]

@@MadeJkdon’t be afraid, there’s no copyright about that title. Actually im not care what that fandom think

[@lindavaleriaparischinchill2279]

@@MadeJk she is the fairy maknae then she looks like a fairytale herself

[@rkive1790]

i'm stan from ningning but she's not golden maknae, pls free ningning 😭

[@Password9141]

@@MadeJk nope, that fan made. Even the OG golden maknae is not him, is Taemin

[@kimrubyjane8987]

winter thumbnail is so cute

[@anshikasingh867]

Winter has definitely improved her aenergy so much💙💙⭐⭐

[@pannybunny1510]

I really love Winter’s make up today. She’s soooo pretty like a barbie doll. Bule colour really suits her.

[@Prette_Lu]

Ningning at 1: 27 is too precious. She deserves so much love along with her members 💗

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

ningning is way too ugly to be loved

[@vim2339]

Nining is my biased

[@琦-n1f]

1:27

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@琦-n1f only Karina and Winter showed themselves in the end, which means other 2 foreigners are unworthy to be seen

[@琦-n1f]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY 你没事吧？

[@jlhhp]

Giselle😭 so powerful, beautiful and charismatic. She improves a lot💕💗

[@mxmcelestine6210]

ning ning looks like a frost/snow princess, she looks so good omg

[@_dionne]

WOW.. Inkigayo is learning the camerawork.. This was the best stage out of all they had for this era.. aespa has really grown.. they look so comfortable now.. glad SM exposed them to bigger crowds in the west and not just sticking to music shows..

[@jeremy.iral13]

I really love the choreo of winter at 2:53. So smooth and beautiful 🥹 I’m glad she did it for their last stage.

[@priyankarao9812]

This performance AESPA slayed, Everything was awesome, love that we can see their confidence growing. Love these queens. Winter sweet smile and expressions are back. Best style and looks

[@eheadso3o7o9]

this stage is different and superior to the rest of their live perfs. they levelled up their stage presence here. 💜 fighting, aespa!

[@archany_louise]

I think it is becoz they just enjoyed their perf here and it came out better than their other stages.

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

even the 2 stages from official aespa channel are much better than this one

[@ashercabrera1577]

Fighting Aespa!!!

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY sorry to be rude but can you not? like just shut pls-

[@winingaerina]

as you guys see , aespa actually have their own power,stability,presences on stage . ppl said aespa dont have stage presence . this video is proof that aespa have stage presence like their own . they dont make expressions like other famous group ( like wink, or something) they just wink as well but yo can see their own wink . and one more thing, in dancing , aespa also good as other dancer . they just not show off their skill at all music stage . singing, ppl or fans ofcourse will see their singing skill as fast as you see them do their performances bcs they are really good at singing even in any genre of music. and what are real power of aespa is the all rounder of them.

[@zunairajabeen2694]

Winter smile is too sweet and attractive 💜💜 Her voice,rap,dance, visual is too perfect and attractive ❤️❤️❤️ Her high note is too perfect and powerful 💜💜❤️❤️

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

because her hairs are too short to shine

[@byeolbitooo9567]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY you are absolutely everywhere dragging winter down

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@byeolbitooo9567 that's what l do!

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY that's what you do??!? GET A LIFE. IF YOUR INSECURE ABOUT YOURSELF THEN SO BE IT BUT DON'T U DARE DRAG OTHERS INTO YOUR OWN PROBLEMS. GET OUT AND TOUCH GRASS.

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@bealncetwnc8001 Karina seems much more beautiful than other 3 members

[@aleksa.mikaela]

I have to say, Winter is improving with her stage presence. I'm proud of her, I think she slayed this era.

[@winterarmamentuer4504]

Omg Winter on the thumbnail!! She neve fails makes my heart going flutter!!

[@BenchCarreon]

I know that it’s been said so many times in every performance videos… but seriously, Ningning’s stage presence is insane. Also, how pretty everyone is! Wow. Kudos to their stylists.

[@jytfvkods1910]

winter也太美了，每次回归她的美貌都会逐渐增加。实力也在一点点变好，真的是个很棒的孩子

[@descryelegance772]

Karina be delivering the best dance, the elegant visual, amazing vocals, cool raps, and never absent strong stage presence. She nailed every performance this era making each more interesting to watch. Easily the ace of the group. And AESPA girls.. Well done :)

[@amaryllisflick7813]

Love how energetic Winter looks in this stage. And loved the way she changed some stuff in the choreo. Thank you so much Aespa for giving us a wonderful performance! In your last promotions, you really went all out

[@m1334y]

Winter so pretty

[@sabrinas4355]

They improved so much especially winter, I can actually see more expression on her face. Ningning is always awesome, she never lacks and she's always consistent.

[@fairyheartfillia3855]

Winter's facial expression really improves. We know she can't act fierce if she's this cute, but she looks cute and cool at the same time! 😍

[@nfnfnfnfn3984]

2:53 OMG!!! Finally we can get to see Winter doing the original choreography again. It really give the big impact.

[@sogoonarong3182]

because she is wearing pants today. It gonna be really awkward and controversial if she has to do it with miniskirt

[@hessaa1712]

As long she don't wear skirts! it nice to see it

[@Iris-xb1hd]

Winter's voice is my favorite omg😍

[@rara1138]

WINTER dance moves are more on being smooth, sharp, and clean. She does not overpower her dancing that is why she is so satisfying to watch. Keep coming back to watch all her fancams, she's born to be a star

[@sinzyxx]

RIGHT!!

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@sinzyxx winter 's hairs and body height are both too short to be a star.

[@sinzyxx]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY what do u mean by that?

[@sinzyxx]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY I wasn't aware that there are hair length and body height requirements to be a star 🧐

[@sinzyxx]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY stop talking nonsense and just get the f out of here. we're not asking for your opinion anw

[@sinzyxx]

minjeong really know how to play with her facial expressions. she knows what and when to use it. stop attacking her by saying she's like a robot who have no expression. you guys probably don't know what u're talking about. do u even know what their concept is 🤣

[@dhitadestriani5284]

their stage is everything but can we appreciate the cameraman? they did a great jobb👍🏻

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

Nobody appreciates useless staffs. we only care about performers

[@Lyf4rMusic]

IKR ! It was exquisite work from them.

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

@@Lyf4rMusic half members are beautiful, other half are ugly. song is boring, dance is cool.

[@ashercabrera1577]

@@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY get. a. life.

[@misora2310]

Winter as the thumbnail, so cute😭♥️

[@aaj_]

Okay giselle is clearly dance so hard, you did such a good job our pretty giselle🥰💜💙

[@Lyf4rMusic]

Absolutely loved the sharpness in the camerawork for this stage ! The girls looked stunning with Karina's styling being my favourite here

[@vidimufti2716]

Winter's face on thumbnail is just too cuteee, too much cuteness to handle

[@fatmad3592]

Gisselle’s charisma is overflowing here and I’m so glad she’s back to being her old self on stage with a little extra stage presence. You can tell she really tried with her expressions and dance work. I’m so proud of her 🥹 NINI slayed as always being the queen of stage presence in Aespa.

[@mayyaah4964]

Winter thumbnail so cuteee

[@lalalili7154]

In love with Ningning's voice.

[@heraaaa8578]

Ohmyg! Giselle, you're so beautiful

[@nidata2698]

Me actually loving Girls, I love winters style here

[@jungjiho]

this is my favorite performance of aespa thus far! you can really see their improvements especially in the sp department! i also noticed that winter's expression isn't very stiff anymore!

[@Aaron-wo1mx]

Winter❤️

[@rara1138]

Winter is perfect. another level of visual, dance and vocal. She's literally an all rounder.

[@Serenity0526]

NINGNING SERVING!!!

[@jyubie]

This stage was definitely live. You can hear some parts which are not the same as the official track. GO GIRLS!!!

[@chaeyoungabadbitch9743]

it wasn’t, it’s prerecorded and they are lipsyncing

[@gulsnismaylova1716]

Giselle' s rap and vocal is very good

[@gunduzmenmedov8723]

Yeah, thats great!

[@M.leman7]

Giselle is my bias😍

[@gulsnismaylova1716]

@@M.leman7 my bias is NingNing but I love Giselle:)

[@jacoblee5202]

good in hell for torture

[@sully3131]

It's lovely to see Winter smile at a performance

[@aeD4RK]

AESPA GIRLS FACTS: They slayed the mamba with Girls,the haters with Life's Too Short and our hearts with Illusion. Those unmatched VISUAL,DANCE,RAP AND SINGING SKILL are the reason we are MYs. Proud of you GALs. Let's see each other in next come back. WE THEM GIRLS!

[@marwanmurad22]

What these is there last performance

[@aeD4RK]

@@marwanmurad22 for this era,yes.

[@BLACKINFINITYETERNITY]

nobody gives a damn to your nonsense. they are too weak to slay a python

[@martinapaing8566]

Winter improved a lot. Btw Winter another legend thumbnail 😍

[@greenteabbi]

4:09 Karina's visual is stunning and so unreal, Karina is god

[@lattelyd]

winter is talented, but today she stands out bc she had more energy than in other stages

[@rara1138]

Our Winter is such a talented person!! She is so beautiful, I am really looking forward for her legendary career!! All the members too.

[@DW-qy9rr]

NingNings outfit is the best.

[@oyooo3395]

I'm so proud of winter.. cause her stage presence are improve a lots

[@earIgrav]

ningselle particularly slayed here omg

[@S1LVERCLOUD]

OMG GISELLE IS SLAYING THE RED HAIR ❤ SHE LOOKS UNREAL !!

[@Gozyugerblue]

I love aespa lightsitck so much I wish I could get one

[@rara1138]

WINTER on the thumbnail is everything.

[@SleepingBabyOW]

인기가요가 썸네일 장인이긴 하네

[@retrievezz]

맞음. 안들어올수가 없음ㅋㅋ

[@typagirl1115]

NingNing is literally wrecking my bias this comeback , she is literally go good in everything and her stage presence is om next level ♥️👑✨ Also karina's dancing skills , vocals , rap and vocals , everything is just so good . Ace indeed ♥️💅 and my bias too 💕

[@iamayanakuzunoha430]

Winter's beauty is just extraordinary. The beauty you'll never get tired of seeing, like a flower, always blooming...

[@kalz9639]

Winterrrrr

[@LadyPisces96]

Blonde NingNing hits different every time 😍

[@rara1138]

0:53 Her smile really shines bright like a diamond. I fell for her.

[@ts01421]

Giselle has improved so much! Her makeup was amazing today and the energy?! Oh damnn Gigi ate and left no crumbs. Sm please give her more lines.

[@etherealmh2988]

Winter nailed this stage

[@feby1428]

The best performance, outfit and camerawork for this era.

[@memescrayfish9632]

I love how Winter’s voice is always louder than the backtrack, proves that they are really singing live

[@chaeyoungabadbitch9743]

they literally aren’t they are lip syncing

[@mar7534]

This is lip sync as always

[@memescrayfish9632]

You can literally hear her voice at 1:10🤨

[@memescrayfish9632]

And also Giselle’s rap at 1:30

[@mar7534]

@@memescrayfish9632 I only hear the backtrack. Also, their lip syncing is bad, they barely open their mouths. They never sang live on korean music shows and today is no exception.

[@gomdori720]

winter thumbnail so prettyyyy

[@YM_M27]

Karina so eye catching ❤️

[@vim2339]

Nining and winter really Stan out in this area they look so beautiful and angelic their voices. 😭💗🫰🏼.

[@orangebutblue]

Inkigayo really take some notes on aespa's camera works for Girls. I can see it

[@Ash.e__Mayy]

i love how winter looks today! she looks especially happy and that thumbnail is so cute T.T

[@loveanddalso887]

Winter stage presence is cool