aespa - GISELLE | Line Evolution • 12/20

[@lovicious9812]

1. Karina: 198.3 sec 2. Giselle: 175.8 sec 3. ??? 4. ???

[@BEACHSHINE5_1]

🌷-Giselle just needs a few lines! 😿

[@julesfoury9240]

She's so close

[@cleitonjunior5874]

@@BEACHSHINE5_1 she already has good lines!

[@BonaRude]

@@cleitonjunior5874 nah

[@aldrinbatalla1691]

@@BonaRude she does! in black mamba Giselle almost sing all chorus in the black mamba

[@aerieves]

Giselle's "I'm in twilight zone" is so heavenly

[@user-by3l33]

YAAAAAAS

[@llama5990]

Although Giselle doesn’t get the most lines, she sings some of the most memorable parts of their songs.

[@roodamaxamud3103]

Actually she has beautiful voice she can rap and sing and even can hit high notes

[@andjelad9433]

In my opinion, she have better vocals than rap, but her rap is still great considering past female rappers in SM

[@user-by3l33]

Giselle CAN BE VOCAL, CAN BE RAPPER AND ALSO IS VISUAL

[@joseantoniomontejomoreno2438]

She have beautiful voice,

[@hincmarcarax4640]

has

[@Lia-e5i9i]

@@hincmarcarax4640 is a brazilian, it's ok to make a mistake.

[@hincmarcarax4640]

@@Lia-e5i9i I never said otherwise, I'm just correcting it

[@bigepicmanthatlovesfunands4477]

And she has a great wattpad story

[@dieeinzigwahredilara]

her vocal tone is so pretty

[@s.p.i.c.a2452]

Her vocal in DCT is so angelic ✨✨✨

[@thanhthao7663]

The peak of Giselle's beauty is Savage

[@lvn_ncl]

Uchinaga Aeri (Giselle) Savage - 44.7 Forever - 40.8 Next Level - 39.3 Dreams Come True - 37.7 Black Mamba - 13.3

[@sammy__summers]

Giselle looks fabulous with red and blonde hair 🌹❤️🔥🔥🔥

[@darktr9419]

I noticed it would be better if jisoo has lines like Giselle although Giselle is last she have lines like a lead vocalist

[@RaavaPeace]

What do u mean? Are u talking about blackpink jisoo? Didnt she get "vocal" part like a lead vocalist also?

[@darktr9419]

@@RaavaPeace well what I mean is when you watch jisoo line distribution here her lines only range from 20 sec. to 35 sec. unlike Giselle she had 13 sec. for black mamba but then get at least 40 sec. In the other comebacks , that's what I mean

[@sylwia2943]

@@darktr9419i think that it may happend because in aespa's choruses they are usually singing too (in every song but not black mamba) while in blackpink its usually just instrumental + song title ykyk so aespa in general just have more singing/rapping parts in songs in blackpink

[@darktr9419]

@@sylwia2943 Well yeah you're right , but from the start it's just an opinion but yeah what you said is definitely true

[@RaavaPeace]

@@darktr9419 ooh i just noticed that, the duration is more varied for giselle

[@juliaysg]

Karina Giselle Winter Ningning

[@dudasantos902]

Vozes mais bonitas 1°- GISELLE 2°- WINTER 3°- NINGNING 4°- KARINA

[@Fanny-.]

Na minha opinião ficaria assim 1 Winter 2 Giselle 3 Ningning 4 Karina

[@capyhx]

Na minha opinião ficaria assim: 1°- Ningning 2°- Karina 3°- Winter 4°- Giselle

[@isabellefranca9633]

1° WINTER 👑🥇 2° NINGNING 🥈 3° KARINA 🥉 4°GISELLE ✨

[@gatho12]

1 winter 2 ningning 3 Giselle 4 Karina

[@MariaFernanda-xc8yo]

Minha opinião: 1° Giselle 1° Karina 1° Ningning 1° Winter

[@raccoonsalamander4646]

the alien rap in dreams come true is so iconic

[@itreasurr]

as a giselle biased since black mamba i'm happy that she got to show her vocals in forever and dreams come true

[@aparecidamelopereiramelo314]

Eu amo a voz dela!

[@kimsihyeon845]

Voz Linda

[@macedoo2127]

her vocal is so fine

[@Vichum]

She is soo pretty😍

[@ttyy12322]

She apologised ages ago, yall so funny complaining about her when you have better things to deal with😍

[@Vichum]

@@ttyy12322 oh no i love giselle

[@ttyy12322]

@@Vichum wha i my mind just died, I thought u said skrtskrt

[@riii4444]

@@ttyy12322 they edited their comment, probably they did say skrr skrr

[@ttyy12322]

@@riii4444 oh yeah

[@BEACHSHINE5_1]

🌷-I love it to see!

[@saerenity]

2:38 love it

[@franperdomo858]

For more vocal parts for Giselle in 2022 and self written raps credicts

[@kuroroo420]

EARLY AND I LOVE UR VIDSS

[@lovicious9812]

thank u so much!!!🤗

[@juliyum]

she was done so dirty on BM i never even realized

[@aree9146]

She and karina didn’t have that much lines in BM because it was Vocal centered and the song itself didn’t have that much lines

[@ayame._.]

@@aree9146 lol look at her in forever

[@aree9146]

@@ayame._. forever is 5minutes song with alot of line, BM’s line is less, like winter’s line in forever is above one minute (the 1st in forever) and ningning’ lines in BM is ~33sec (the 1st in BM)

[@primarinegaming6761]

She wasn’t lol the “ma ma mamba” chorus vocals were lead by her.

[@aree9146]

@Des getting to sing one more line than giselle ain’t a lot

[@jhiaka9888]

She actually has more line in black mamba she did A LOT of the adlibs

[@AraAraMe]

I feel so bad that giselle is receiving a lot of hate, she deserves so much and people are really trying to cancel and tear her down 🥺

[@xhstan]

Bro she looked for the hate. She could've stopped all of this if she never said the n-word in the first place + if she wrote a sincere apology not that forced looking fake apology which didn't specify to who she even was apologizing to.

[@danielnising]

I‘m happy to see that people still have appreciation for her after that accidential slip and all the cancel culture going on nowadays.

[@Moonylvsyp]

♡

[@wikizakrzewska3509]

dreams come true is a song of s,e,s

[@mommysaranghae1281]

They remade it. 4/5 of their title tracks are remakes lol

[@wikizakrzewska3509]

@@mommysaranghae1281 XD

[@taburelli]

@@mommysaranghae1281 and?

[@mommysaranghae1281]

@@taburelli and what?

[@mommysaranghae1281]

@@taburelli i’m not complaining

[@kpopgirlseditions6760]

Please can u do red velvet line evolution?

[@Bella73275]

How that 12/20?? Cómo que 12/20?

[@Vichum]

No entiendo es un comeback o remake?

[@josuereyesarcos5575]

Remake, aunque visualmente parece un comeback ahhhh. Siento que es más que nada un single independiente como Forever.

[@Vichum]

@@josuereyesarcos5575 Ahh entiendo, gracias!❤

[@lujanrojas4565]

es parte de proyecto sm express, de remarestizacion, o sea, van a haber muchos remakes por parte de sus grupos. Dreams come true es original de S.E.S, un tema de 1995

[@josuereyesarcos5575]

@@Vichum ya investigue un poquis y al parecer su disquera siempre hace eso, son como proyectos para fans. No son singles porque no tendrán promoción :3

[@mommysaranghae1281]

Most of their songs are remakes

[@saerenity]

I hate how she only got 13sec in black mamba.

[@Nolol314]

The most memorable line from her is n-

[@4jongseob]

Skrt skrt on

[@gumballmail81]

Idk why you even bother clicking on video related to her if you just want to hate her. Get a life or something 🗿

[@GiselleOutsold]

*naevis*

[@mommysaranghae1281]

I agree

[@primarinegaming6761]

Your only video on your channel features two groups with an idol that has accusations of saying the n word…(one is confirmed btw)if your gonna comment this on all Giselle vids then at least hold your favs accountable too

[@inyochayacha548]

@@GiselleOutsold sorry, I'm a new Aespa fan and I want to know what does "Naevis" mean??