aespa - NingNing | Line Evolution • JUL/22

[@terrydavis2887]

NingNing is the soul of Aespa. She doesn’t demand attention, her voice says it all. Ty for video.

[@myaespauniverse2495]

Neither do the rest of the girls-💀

[@jinsoulheadbang8584]

Ningning is not only a main vocalist, she's a wholeass rapper

[@Flopsix_tropican]

She Havent Rap On Any Of The Songs Tho

[@Teddyhaobin.]

@@Flopsix_tropican next level??????

[@helloworld-sl2lw]

​@Krew4life when does she rap in next level????😂😂😂😂

[@quannguyentien6301]

since when ning rap ?

[@tenleeenthusiast]

​@@quannguyentien6301on concerts, on her solo stage perf, and even giselle's rap lines in concerts when gigi is absent

[@CB-yl3mw]

1. Winter: 364,7 sec. 2. NingNing: 328,9 sec. 3. Karina: 278,9 sec. 4. Giselle: 234,3 sec.

[@ningningchinaqueen5160]

wow is winter the first but this is unfair main vocal ningning ningning should get more parts sm what is she going through

[@opinionisopinion]

This is cruel Wendy and Taeyeon or all main vocalist are too far from Lead Vocalist except for Jessica Ningning really injustice

[@assypeachmusic1006]

i think SM made winter the new main vocalist of aespa and didnt tell no one abt that😭

[@Binchanareangels]

NingNing can sing, rap, show her visual, dance, idk what else she can do but she is A group herself in

[@ayeshasamdani2979]

I am in love with this girl's voice...❤️❤️

[@Coaraisa]

so great see every aespa girls, have a good line distribution

[@proxigogo]

No hate but I trully want Yoo Young Jin to take a break and let other producers to work with aespa on the TT, like Kenzie, guy is too Winter's biased from vocals to rap, like he should't make it so obvious

[@tnlkb6115]

can I ask you a question? Which Aespa member lines always get viral? Is it Ningning? Giselle? Karina? It Winter right? So why wouldn't the producer give Winter more lines to bost the chance of another viral moment for the group? Winter and Ningning aren't to far away in terms of skills, but Winter got a little bit of edge against Ningning. 2NING strenght is the power on her voice, but Winter's is her vocal color, prononciation and live vocal/stability. Winter's voice is also more marketable and pleasing to the ear. And yes I said pleasing. I don't like how there is this narratif now that Winter voice is piercing or annoying to hear. Especially since their debut days, Winter always have been praised for her amazing voice. I just hope this narratif hasn't been created by the fandom to discredit Winter vocals. That would be pretty petty and mess up. And look, I also want Ningning voice (and Giselle) to get even more focus on Aespa songs. But I am also not naive enough not to understand how this game work. For the group to be successful, the compagny and producer need to go with the best option to secure the group popularity. Take for example Blackpink and BTS. In Blackpink, Jennie is obviously the better rapper, yet Lisa get more rap part because her flow is more popular. And in BTS, despite them starting as a hiphop group, their rapline get less and less lines as time pass on because the vocal line is more popular. You want Ningning to shine more? Make her trend. That it.

[@proxigogo]

@@tnlkb6115 What with the essay?? So pressed for nothing, go touch some grass akgae, the fact that what I said was focus on changing producers but you decided to change the narrative over virality, trend, competition and victimisation, no wonders W's stans have THE reputation.

[@Yumii6660]

@@tnlkb6115 Karina's line

[@rachellavarett1719]

​​​@@tnlkb6115out Lisa i think the only way for her to get lines is rap cuz she's a sub vocalist if they give Jennie more rap lines then Lisa would get nothing and she'll be below Jisoo in limes. They dislike Jisoo that much

[@kitkitlotino4509]

So pretty NingNing

[@kate_playlists4975]

Timestamps: Black Mamba: 0:03 Forever: 0:37 Next Level: 1:34 Savage: 2:12 Dreams Come True: 3:05 Life's Too Short: 4:10 Girls: 4:39

[@zothansangipachau1799]

I came her just to say that ur line distributions r great

[@amitkpoplds]

Thank you so much💕

[@kjline5378]

my bias😘😉

[@이런-아]

You know what I just realized aespa's main producer was winter's trainer that says alot

[@이런-아]

And I heard that voice strain in her high note in girls

[@proxigogo]

He is obviously Winter's biased, that's why most MYS want Kenzie to produce aespa's next song, she was in charge of Nayeon's POP solo song, SNSD genie and ITNW, aespa's Lucid dream

[@zothansangipachau1799]

Ur line distributions r great

[@davidprates3336]

Can you do more line evolutions please I really love them ❤

[@twonce4459]

Yes 🥰😍🥰 Yes

[@maafbangyt]

Can you do like this bp comeback this august , i like your layout/bar

[@amitkpoplds]

Yess

[@Titio_BangchanSKZ57]

Black Mamba: 34.2s Forever: 56.8s Next Level: 38.5s Savage: 52.9s Dreams Come True: 64.7s Life's Too Short: 29.0s Girls: 52.8s NingNing 닝닝 aespa 에스파

[@iluvjniniii]

💗

[@ningningchinaqueen5160]

Chinese main vocal power

[@Suoonl]

Why do all of her lines sound like entire songs

[@MuhammadArifinAKWI]

Please request line evolution of Joo A Hi-L MV: "Too Too" and "Hi-Way"

[@Kauã-Studios]

First

[@winnykpop]

Hi, amitkpop, can we collaborate with the latest itzy song later, I also invite my friends

[@amitkpoplds]

Yess, contact me in discord

[@winnykpop]

@@amitkpoplds I don't have discord:(

[@amitkpoplds]

@@winnykpop ohh, so with who are we gonna collab more, i was planing to make with susumie a collab on itzy, i was planing to make with them a how would

[@winnykpop]

@@amitkpoplds oh then next time

[@amitkpoplds]

@@winnykpop whyy, you can join us

[@toad9209]

Can I Have permission to use ur layout? Pleasd

[@ilianajohnson3936]

forever is a song for aespa lol

[@Eunwoo-zr1el]

Where illusion

[@c.lineofficial]

I think they're just doing m/v's.

[@danieltp35011]

Second