aespa sang live 'Savage' | radio, showcase, mmtg...

[@Max-my6rk]

see ning ning still has no problem delivering her high notes even when she is sitting there.

[@brooklynmusings]

Her note is supported and that's a really big deal for any K-Pop idol! She's a real singer among idols, just like the other SM vocalists.

[@n1y4th38]

its easier when sitting

[@queenb3730]

@@brooklynmusings what does it mean when a note is supported

[@rizkypepew]

But the key is different.. :(

[@김태연-b5u]

@@n1y4th38 it’s actually harder to support while sitting so no

[@crislockhart8188]

Please, SM, give us an official live version!! We need to enjoy those vocals

[@nameisNICK.F]

Ikr, I've been waiting for weeks for them to appear on radio live

[@zyler578]

like the ones nct releases after every comeback, the UNCUT ones

[@babyai2461]

IKR i dont understand why SM didn't let them singing Live That's annoying when I read hate comment bout them keep lipsync, SM let Aespa singing Live.

[@juno1765]

SM is really wasting the Ningning, Karina and Winter's years of training and Giselle's 11 months of training

[@loveyloveydovey]

@@juno1765 maybe bc giselle barely trained and is irrelevant

[@boorave]

The fact that all of them are good Vocals 😭✨

[@zebrasbean2385]

Just sm things

[@lowspects8027]

Innit

[@yuqi_cottage333]

It's sm thing bro

[@aaliyahetc.6687]

sm training

[@boorave]

SM training and SM water that tastes like water? (joking)

[@ac9901]

KARINA'S CHORUS YES

[@remsangixix740]

It was soo addicting ✨😩

[@Itsjudd_]

People saying they sound different, don't u see sm artists recording their songs?? There's a lot of videos and u can clearly see they repeat every verse until the producer like it. They will try a lot of tones and voices so even if they sound a lil bit different it doesn't mean sm put autotune or effects on their voices.... They know how to sing and sound effects are cool (it doesn't mean they can't sing)

[@Itsjudd_]

@greatgatzzzby exactly!! people can't expect them to sound exactly the same everytime 🙂🤧

[@alvionita5240]

@greatgatzzzby even with one month, RV reached 3.8 million views for that recording video. I mean, maybee the other group stan want to know how RV managed it and then they saw it ehehehe

[@Sake_Ikura_Don]

They sound different, because they sing a couple of octaves lower than the recording. And of course the producers add autotune. No one in their right mind will release a raw track, without corrections, even if Beyoncé is singing.

[@vinnymadelynelamata6255]

@@Sake_Ikura_Don AMEN!

[@moonlace1560]

They’re also singing in a different key than the actual song when doing it casually so ofc it sounds different

[@pixelrina]

karina's "oooh" is to die for

[@a_maze_in_kwangya]

Karina's voice tone always my favorite (btw, go stream NCT 127 new song fellow grass). It's so unique to my ears

[@ianjylz7651]

It's like her voice is always on autotune but its not, it has a unique vibe on it! When listening to every aespa song, the first voice I distinguish is Karina!

[@nazma4537]

Fellow grass 💀

[@eynanonano7405]

grass-

[@Leoonbinn]

FELLOW GRASS I- 😭😭

[@jayvlv3800]

Same. Her vocal tone is my fave along with ning

[@arlescenes]

They sing with a lot of energy and also they do it like all prepared and in a recording studio so it’s a bit different

[@highhighhighhi7158]

1:25 wow they sound so good together

[@balakajan151]

Karina you are a talented woman!!! I could see in your eyes that something is holding you back.

[@sarydell1878]

ningning your voice is next level🦋

[@jasperidolog3219]

Gee! Ningning the queen of gen 4 main vocal, Winter the queen lead vocal they just did those highnotes effortlessly😍🤗💖

[@atmo85]

No one's talking about how well Giselle sang Winter's part ❤️

[@rap6451]

ningning never fails to amaze me

[@yongtae3981]

If aespa were this good, why aren’t they singing live 😭. Why won’t SM Ent. allow it? I always hear pre-recorded.

[@bluequeen8022]

Maybe SM doesn't think is worth making the effort since there's no public? Idk

[@Taco6876]

Because the dance is too hard and if they sing live they might damage their vocals

[@ccsbm208]

@@Taco6876 if they damage their voice it’s either cause their technique’s off or their overworking their vocal chords not dance. Dancing would affect stamina and voice projection.

[@silly_hue-wheat]

@@Taco6876 literally there's no correlation..

[@purpleeyebrows19]

@@Taco6876 literally not how any of that works. An artist only risk damaging their vocals if they use an unhealthy technique not by singing live whilst dancing lmao. According to you Aespa would damage their vocals by doing their jobs lol

[@Lizzie2708]

Winter is amazing, just listen to her voice

[@hilaholo6822]

Just like I said before, Aespa members are more than capable to sing in live stage. Why SM doesn't allow them to song live? Their live vocals are good too

[@everythingsfinett3903]

SM doesn’t let any of Its artists sing live recently. Not even Tae and Red Velvet which are known for their godly vocals. If seniors can’t do anything about It what makes you think Aespa can go against SM's decision

[@hilaholo6822]

@@everythingsfinett3903 lmfao I didn't expect AESPA to go rebel against SM's decision. I questioning SM motives. SHINee still had some live performances in don't call me era tho it's a pity that SM made them lip syncing too in most of them

[@remsangixix740]

They honestly slayed this comeback vocals pn point and Giselle’s rap😩✨✨

[@alex.7937]

All of them are rlly vocally amazing but I rlly like Karina vocal tone

[@ma-yi9ye]

NINGNING. GIRLLL.

[@ac9901]

Give us a LIVE!!!!! this is so good WTF is sm doing???????

[@alisha1.2.7.]

I LOVE IT WHEN THEY SING HIGH NOTES ACAPELLA

[@james24222]

I love Karina’s voice 🥰

[@kangsobin1069]

Aespa is good at singing, they are anti lipsing I really like it!

[@nmixx.changeupletsgo]

huh? they are great vocalists but they literally lip sync almost all of their performances…

[@donaldliden4545]

@@nmixx.changeupletsgo I agree... Its not possible to dance like they do and sing good enough at the same time,you just try jump around and keep a steady tone😀if u want to check the vocal talents of any idol i think only time its not tempered with is in livestudio at radiostations.They sit still and really cant hide if they struggle with the singing or if it comes easy and in right tone

[@caramelatte5477]

Girl they literally lip sync in all their performances lol They are great vocalists (proved in their songs) but they are the complete opposite of "anti lipsync"

[@justcutiecats2733]

They're literally lip sync all the time, not because they can't sing. I think it's because SM or the Tv won't let them singing live.

[@juno1765]

@@justcutiecats2733 yep which is sad, wasting the girls' potential

[@user-gr7sg8ne3h]

NINGNING THIS VOCAL😩❤❤❤❤❤

[@chinyamamoto9753]

I really want aespa to do sing their songs in the radio

[@olallacrs7854]

aespa has really good vocals. Even rappers can sing so good. Aespa shouldn't have any problems with singing live but why SM won't let the girls sing live? They are fully capable. SM should let the girls sing and not lipsync pre-recorded songs. It's giving them a bad reputation and I don't want the girls to have a bad rep :((

[@poppyorange5061]

0:15 Dont mind me just making this timestamp cause definitely not addicted to karinas voice👀😅

[@bambi9429]

how many proof do y'all want to prove that aespa can sing 100% raw vocals?????? Edit: I see many people are coming at me... First of all, I am referring to their raw vocals, that they can / knows how to sing without the help of the autotune. Second, I didn't mention "live performance" above 🐱 this video PROVES that aespa can sing 100% raw vocal by singing different songs. Lastly, I'm pointing out their RAW VOCALS, and not their performance. I never hated aespa. I'm a stan before they debut. It's correct, blame SM Entertainment not the girls. 😐🥲

[@wyattajero337]

who said they can't sing live?

[@wyattajero337]

it's just that they're not singing live while performing, they never did

[@bambi9429]

@@wyattajero337 wdym

[@purpleeyebrows19]

@@bambi9429 they never sing live

[@bambi9429]

@@purpleeyebrows19 how did you know? 😅

[@preetipandey5473]

Winter's 'savige' is savage 😝

[@leleticiaa]

sm needs to let these girls sing live

[@donutspeaking]

Love NINGNING

[@Skyblue-oz7rp]

Aespa are the vocal queens

[@fluffbxi_7828]

they are all so stable omgg

[@4N70N10HDZ]

That Karina's Aaoooohhh!! ✨✨✨

[@sabrinaleedance]

I always see ppl talking about how they don't sing live, etc, but they clearly are amazing singers. I can understand not wanting to strain their voices since they hit so many high notes !

[@arafadhwang4119]

karina sounds the best here

[@canismajoris513]

0:56 “IMMAa KiTtlAAa”

[@hannah_opal]

its sad that sm wont let them sing live

[@emmablanky-5090]

karina is a rapper yet her vocals is like a lead or even main singer

[@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062]

Lead Vocalist, she's already one for my standards

[@cosman3248]

I'm a Blink but Karina would probably be a main vocalist in Blackpink.

[@nairalovesyou9550]

i think SM don't use their original voice in the mv or they put some effect on their voice, thats its feels different to me while they singing it live

[@brooklynmusings]

They're singing in a lower pitch when they're on radio shows. It's probably better so that they can preserve their voices for the more intense live shows. Also, nearly all musicians on earth use some kind of autotune in their mics, so unless you are lucky enough to hear them sing acapella live with no mic (like Beyoncé does), you'll rarely know what any artist's voice sounds like.

[@yuyaulzzang4845]

yes i think so too Thats why there is no encore from aespa,,, sm edit aespa voice at recording... Thats why sm didnt let them singing live... Because it different...

[@sasandap]

@@yuyaulzzang4845 yo shutup stop commenting the same thing, try to be more creative pls

[@geezusson8710]

They are just singing in a lower key that’s why it sounds different.

[@sapphirecruz4644]

@@yuyaulzzang4845 hi the encore stage is up now just so you can be informed. they sang very well

[@francescacassano1984]

ALL ROUNDER QUEENS ✨

[@hiraizoe5898]

These girls are great

[@luneaa3294]

All of them are good in singing

[@aj4852]

0:19 this part is difficult even though it’s not high note

[@Cha-lee02]

They can sing live why sm can't give them to perform with microphone on

[@randomstuff0.18]

Today I learned how much music does to a song

[@snehasaha0854]

They really are the best vocalist in 4 gen girls

[@rayane_.i602]

They’re so talented

[@farahhanisnabilasepuansuri6511]

1:18 sorry but I almost can't see where is Ningning 😅😭😂😂😂

[@BELLA-t9b1p]

Ning Ning 😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💞💞💞

[@vyeagra420]

they can clearly sing , why don't they sing live??

[@cakku667]

The voice of Karina is so deep

[@nathilla7034]

To the whole Kpop Industry LET MY IDOLS SING AGAIN BITCHES, WE WANT RAW VOCALS, NO PRE-RECORDED LIP-SYNC

[@ninaswan4193]

They all seem nervous and not confident.

[@ninaswan4193]

It seems like SM and their expectators put a lot of pressure on them. I'm an EXO-L and I can see that they are very much alike to EXO when they were rookies. Hayss. I hate SM.

[@UGee1997]

@@ninaswan4193 Maybe, right now, aespa is the center of attention from general public and kpop fans in general

[@angge_0509]

I think they need more confidence to sing live. They are a bit self conscious in my opinion seen by how soft they do it and how they always look up and down as if seeing if the people listening there has a good reaction. If SM let them perform with live vocals then they will slowly build confidence. People just have to realize it won't be as crisp seeing as they will dance at the same time and vocal effects placed in the studio version won't be there. Clearly they can sing well.

[@naurrrr6719]

KARINAAA

[@lesliefellone6085]

I don't know why there are still people who criticize aespa's vocals, why don't they just accept that they can sing live/not and they are incredibly amazing! Watch this video for some fact and their other song!

[@leslnava]

Queens😍

[@aribaariba8609]

Its funny when kpop community is shocked that some idols can actually sing 😂😂

[@LadyPisces96]

This should have been a viewable episode 😭 I hope they comeback to Wendy's Youngstreet this comeback! I'm sure Wendy would like it, too. SM just has to make it happen.

[@BELLA-t9b1p]

Ilovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeee youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu aespa

[@رُؤَئَ-م9س]

😭😭😭😭 اش جابك هون 😭😭 لهالدرجة نحن مايز اصليين من شوف كل فيديوهات ايسبا

[@BELLA-t9b1p]

@@رُؤَئَ-م9س يي

[@uszifatydindaalfhatika4155]

but it definitely on a different key-- I--

[@antaradas4960]

I got goose bumps 😄

[@secret6038]

0:21 i’m the only one who hears “i’m a sandwich”? 😭😭

[@dreepaulmico971]

😂😂😂😂

[@leliselily7112]

Still don't understand why sm don't let them sing live

[@ningning5561]

Karina ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@wenbc5000]

gentle voices, very beautiful and completely natural. THAT is what i like to see sm, not the autotuned fake ass voices they pre-record every time they have a performance, it makes the song sound so artificial and impossible to sing properly.

[@belulugaga]

Just wanna throw this into the face of people who say that aespa can't sing live.... I agree they lipsync for stage performances but yes you can't deny the fact that they are really stable with their voice.... This is not an excuse but just wanted to say maybe sm want that perfect image of aespa to be the same like no voice cracks just perfect but I hope they have a comeback soon and sm finally let them sing live....... ✨ 😭❤️

[@oliviaenthusiast2009]

i feel like their voices in the recording is pitched up??

[@ucantran9743]

It’s just that they’re singing in a lower tone.

[@oliviaenthusiast2009]

@@ucantran9743 okay

[@skytimely]

Usually when recording for the song, hey have multiple takes, and pick the best. It’s not pitched up, but sometimes it’s hard for the singers to actually reach those vocals without practicing for a little bit. So on the spot they go with the lower tone so there are no voice cracks! :)

[@Max-my6rk]

for winter and Giselle definitely... ning ning not much difference.

[@simpayshenaides]

@@oliviaenthusiast2009 you cant use a plain voice in making a full song, Of course ur voice will be different in mic especially amplifying it with effect and its not that bad

[@xdinaryvillain9662]

singing it in all in a slightly lower tone that the original is so much more different than y'all think, i mean a lot of people can sing the notes they did here acapella but struggle to do the tone in the original. I mean even ning ning had to put her hand in her ear and everything just to do a lower version than the original guys imagine if she had to sing the original tone?? honestly i know y'all are gunna come at me, but istg im only saying this for the delulu fans and not to hate on aespa whatsoever, peace.

[@anushkabhatia1358]

They sounded quite good but I think the only member who struggles or isn't confident to sing live is winter

[@부채-i8h]

@@anushkabhatia1358 the only good vocalist here is winter lol.

[@anushkabhatia1358]

@@부채-i8h no I didnt said that she sounded bad she was just nervous and not so confident actually all thE members bit they sounds good

[@khjaune]

0:56 MISS MAAM???

[@visrose2894]

They are just singing in a lower key

[@chrissycupcakes2448]

All of them sang at a lower register because the higher one would be way to hard and damn near impossible

[@sooyaasaelim_]

They sang the original note at their encore

[@jisoosnonallergiccat5119]

Omg giselle!!

[@sakuraweather6078]

i think i understand why sm doesn't let aespa singing live, because once they failed reach highnote or vocal cracking, people will always remember that they can't singing. just like twice and blackpink during ddu3x era. having one or many mistake when singing are pretty normal, but people these days demand perfect performance.

[@meghaalvarez1060]

SM is globally popular entertainment group who gets millions of trainees for auditions...so they wouldn't have chosen members of aespa if they didn't know how to sing. So y'all stop bothering about them using voice effects of not.

[@Emily_fanai]

Funny thing I see in comment sections & Twitter:Aespa doesn't sound like the mv when they sing live..SM is using too much autotune Broo...Those are not autotunes,SM artists don't need autotunes,that's why they're famous,they got the TALENT...Those are called compressions(everyone use it) and effects(to make it sound cooler than raw vocals)...If you haven't seen how SM artists do their recordings,go watch them...They're very passionate about how they sound so they keep on trying in different tones(even if the producer already like it,they ask if they can try it again until they really feel the vibe)and fyi..no one can sound just like a studio recorded audio in live...

[@rabbit5163]

0:15

[@happyasalways421]

Lower than their mv's

[@yuyaulzzang4845]

Thats why there is no encore from aespa,,, sm edit aespa voice at recording... Thats why sm didnt let them singing live... Because it different...

[@chandraguzly7788]

@@yuyaulzzang4845 so, i thought they didn't let aespa for singing live is because of they want to shock MY for their actual singing live in encore stage

[@mariafernandarodriguezboni2205]

Are you out of your mind? 😂

[@alygalera2112]

@@yuyaulzzang4845 their encore is now up for music core

[@yuyaulzzang4845]

@@alygalera2112 ive seen it… just like i thought… now i surely know why SM didnt let them Sing theyre song live…

[@sweethome52]

I Hope Giselle Rap line is also Included the Deep fake and Everybody look at me are So Addicting.

[@amilapindanimwale6837]

They amazing jus don't understand why SM doesnt want them to sing live

[@jiyagohil1527]

Ning ning's high note was okish as per me. I was personally not the biggest fan of it, cuz how many ever times I listen to it, it kinda sounds like a scream in the start

[@colared2217]

Plz the first ningning's part can i have the link of full ep with wendy

[@kimberlychu441]

It's key is lower than the original

[@BELLA-t9b1p]

Karina 😭😭😭😭😭💞💞💞💞💞💞💞😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@رُؤَئَ-م9س]

😭😭

[@wenreneisreal6668]

anyone has link of the first part she sings in this clip🥺

[@wenreneisreal6668]

tks I've just found it kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKOlip6XnsegbMU 32:35

[@amarantaquiles2569]

Why are they singing in a lower key?

[@madamursula321]

SM thingz 💅🏻✨

[@apearl888]

ning ning şaşırtmıyor

[@parinishigupta968]

SM is seriously sleeping on their vocals. GIVE US LIVE VOCALS BRO THEY'RE SO PREFECT

[@dahlia9494]

if they can hit these hard notes rn why cant they let the girls sing live

[@0_base1]

❤️❤️

[@armymoo6967]

some people really think singing and dancing the shit out of you at the same time is easy?? those who think its easy should try to do both at the same time, concentrate so you don't do ANY mistakes, sing perfect and look perfect at the same time, maybe also struggling with revealing outfits. our girls and all the other artists who lip sync are good vocalists, if they weren't, they wouldn't even be an idol. I accept that they lip sync.

[@purpleeyebrows19]

The problem is aespa 99% of the time lipsyncs if it was just the occasional performance fair enough but they heavily rely on it at this point and considering they come from a company revered for having the best vocalists in the K-pop industry that’s not a good look for them. It’s literally their jobs to be able to perform and if they can’t even sing live most of the time then that’s clearly something both sm and aespa have to work on. However it’s not just an aespa issue it’s a wider issue with most K-pop artists nowadays most of them barely sing live anymore and it shouldn’t be normalised. singing whilst dancing isn’t easy in the slightest but it isn’t impossible that’s what the trainee period is there for…

[@a40109]

Savige 🙂🙂

[@golly123123]

Where on earth is the original video? 😢

[@cookingdouyin1376]

Nốt cao của ningning hát live thấp hơn trong mv

[@neoreulboyeojwo1496]

Hạ tông xuống đó bạn với né khúc lên tông lần cuối

[@АльбинаАбайкызы-л8ш]

Вокал Ниннин😍🥹

[@happyasalways421]

Ningning singing in lower note i guess

[@willowmilogypsy]

why are they all in different keys..?