aespa - Savage @ Coachella 2022 4K FANCAM

[@EricAndBrad]

Please share with everyone!! People deserve to hear how they ACTUALLY sounded live at Coachella. After filming this fancam in the front row and then going online after, I was shocked that people were commenting that the audience was dead and that they couldn't hear aespa's live singing over the back track. It must have been the livestream!! But in person the girls were GIVING!! (and so were the fans) This fancam is proof!!

[@user-us9im1bt4k]

thank you very much 🤍😭

[@Moonairr]

THANKK YOUUUU!!!!

[@miso3230]

Omg!! Thank you for this!! And thanks for appreciating Aespa's performance ❤️❤️

[@evelyn.sy19]

Naevis lovs u ❤

[@gigihot]

Thank you for sharing this fancam❤️✨

[@Haura-i5g]

And the fact this was their first performance with REAL AUDIENCES after covid... Rookie aespa relly deserved y'all apologies

[@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715]

Yes that year was the Coachella comeback after 2 year Hiatus, that time Aespa was too young but they did a great performance, the real issue that time was the audience, Coachella 2022 was dead maybe because of the covid event, but now if Aespa get invited again, they will gonna Rock the Stage for Real

[@ander8908]

​@@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715 el problema fué que no se había anunciado que las invitadas eran aespa hasta muy tarde, los fans no pudieron ir a apoyar al grupo y por eso la mayoría de personas en el evento era gente que no las conocía

[@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715]

​@@ander8908 true .. I think they performed because they listed in the Line up of 88rising Future same as 2ne1

[@kforhonor986]

I just came back from listening to LE SSERAFIM's first and second week performance. I'm a huge fan of LE SSERAFIM and I am not afraid to say that Aespa did extremely well!

[@wastelifetakenotes]

@@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715i wasnt present on this coachella specifically but i think most people who havent gone doesnt realize that aespa was only invited as a “guest” (by 88rising) for the 2nd week, so they werent even on the main/established poster lineup.. they were rookies + they didn’t really get a chance to pull existing fans (apart from people who’re already attending) to be part of the audience. this was a feat that people seriously underappreciated 😭

[@ambybibi]

I AM SO SHOCKED. I knew they could sing live but this is better than what I expected. Winter sounds amazing ! She is so stable damn

[@junejune1990]

Yes, i am shock too😂she so stable

[@carree645]

actullay nining was the most stable others did good too also Giselle rap was on fire

[@recreatingcontents5795]

Yes Winter did Amazing just mesmerizing

[@kwamicake]

@@carree645 I didn't find ningning stable this performance

[@moamoaoz]

@@carree645 I love Ningning but her voice was shaking like an esrthquake

[@awkwardlyshypotato6848]

I've never hated their performance. Aespa deserved a proper apology from everyone who trashed them.

[@alifiyahnora859]

FR

[@masakazuhiruko550]

After that atrocious vocals from thar group damn. The so called opera singer cant sing for her damn life. She could probably go toe to toe with tone deaf idols

[@Bellaa-ws2bj]

FR

[@Kiyomi_aesthetic]

Actually fr

[@Votefor17]

I remember them being so hated in 2022 . Like be fr. A SM group , can't sing? What a joke

[@SangNguyen-sq2ph]

I need aespa bring Drama to Coachella

[@tess3554]

YEEEES

[@wooziteknik]

FR

[@seerdaf7246]

Omggg yessss

[@m0u7rn]

PLZ

[@neogotmybackpain1817]

Yesssss

[@beckmendes3684]

omg this fancam quality is so good even better than the official shooting which put on such a loud original music literally covered their live singing…thx for sharing this anyways!!!!

[@tanjieting1]

Where can I find the official shooting video?

[@fa-tz8bh]

FR!!!!

[@idlekarma]

@@tanjieting1 coachella live

[@winda_are_indah]

I agree

[@tanjieting1]

@@idlekarmaThank you

[@Rosieee65]

My girls deserve apology from anyone that spoke trash bout their vocals not a MY but like be fr they slayed

[@Kiyomi_aesthetic]

Fr

[@hunniesanr]

FR‼️

[@tttvvvxxxq]

the vocals give me chills omg they're too good

[@elsa5717]

Just compare their dance. Different choreography and le sserafim has hard Choreo. It makes them lose voice and stamina. Aespa only move hand so they can focus on singing.

[@nahhh-c5s]

well thats the point, kpop is about singing songs. Hybe shouldnt make their artists have hard dances, they couldve just been dancers then.@@elsa5717

[@xKayNee]

@@elsa5717 Well usually in a group live performance, the one actually singing will focus less on the choreo to focus more on their vocals. Despite everything, even in Le Sserafim's first performance, the vocals was just not good enough. Still a fan though, but they should not have been at Coachella. It might even lower their confidence even more now.

[@kapankapan331]

@@elsa5717 buset belain grup sampe semua komen dibales satu persatu, mbak

[@itzelayala7323]

​@@elsa5717Coreografia difícil para vocales medi

[@mybmyacc]

Winter's vocals is so stable and clean that I doubt if she's actually singing live or if it's back track, she's amazing! I listen like 10-15 times when her vocals are so heavenly and sounds like studio version and then as I listen closely, it's actually live, she's really really stable

[@veeday9822]

It's always happened to her when people confused with her singing. The power of special trainee secret weapon YYJ's daughter

[@inyochayacha548]

Can I ask something?? At the end of the song, the highnotes of Ningning and Winter, they really sang them or they were a back vocals??

[@mybmyacc]

@@inyochayacha548 The backtrack is playing, but the backtrack's volume is very low in fancams, those highnotes are their live voices. They sound like studio version, but they really sang them, it's live. I listened to it again and again and even watched other fancams, they sound so much like the studio version, so I also doubted if they actually sang it live, and they really sang it live, I get amazed everytime, even though I repeated it for like 15 times, I still get impressed!

[@inyochayacha548]

@@mybmyacc Thank u!! 🥰

[@lidiavasconcelos]

SO TRUE

[@lophiki]

It’s literally their first time performing in front of a big crowd and it’s their first ever live show in the us! After 1 year of performing only infront of cameramans i’m sure this wasn’t easy for them. And they killed it

[@tearofgod]

I mean, they did perform at the Macy's Parade last year

[@arcim2018]

Big crowd???

[@aysathulrameela9947]

@@arcim2018 yah if u see their Instragram pics it Was a big crowd

[@lophiki]

@@arcim2018 you can assume it was small if it makes you feel better☺️

[@sims2lovealot]

@@tearofgod It was a pretty small performance though and they barely had any time to actually show their stuff, especially on such a tiny float.

[@t_yonglin5129]

people need to see this fancam.. they are so talented..

[@EricAndBrad]

After filming this fancam in the front row and then going online, I was shocked that people were commenting that the audience was dead and that they couldn't hear their live singing over the back track. It must have been the livestream, but in person the girls were GIVING!! (and so were the fans) This fancam is proof.

[@priyankarao9812]

@@EricAndBrad Thank you for uploading this we wanted to see this, Hope you enjoyed a lot too.

[@trishpacs7173]

@@EricAndBrad ikr, myriads of thanks to these fancams ❤️ I’m sooooo proud of them 😭

[@lilidaili6283]

@@EricAndBrad can you comment again and pin your cmt ( the cmt you reply) what you just said out of this commend to LET EVERYBODY KNOW please

[@vavent_]

@@EricAndBrad SOOO high quality fancam, perfect video quality and sound great, thanks!

[@kpopviralz8362]

Coachella should invite Aespa again seriously!😢😌

[@justt_joy]

Fr 😢 they’re improving so much

[@STCKMN_]

FR!!!

[@Kiyomi_aesthetic]

Fr

[@4neonct]

drama in rock ver 😢

[@JkLover01]

SERIOUSLY FR!!!

[@istantoomanygroupshelp3249]

SORRY BUT ive to say that THESE GURLS ARE MONSTER VOICES LIKE WTF....this is what i call live vocals damn

[@my2411]

Yassshhh ... four queen.🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@weavtj1097]

Lmaooo I thought you were mentioning IVE for a second 😭😭😭

[@istantoomanygroupshelp3249]

@@weavtj1097 hehe really 😂😂😭💀

[@noransom2765]

I think just winter

[@gigigotmelikeohh1302]

@@noransom2765 have you heard the others???

[@MegaLuckyLeafy]

Giselles confidence really got them all hyped since the beginning yes girl be that sun and everyone was glowing with happiness :D and them vocals LIVE!!!! No autotune no loud backing here just their vocals. Love it.

[@Jjx589]

Giselle can’t even follow the lyric….. she sang with her own beat and it’s really suck and terrible

[@black-sm5gv]

Hyped??

[@MegaLuckyLeafy]

@@black-sm5gv pumped up you know.. having the time of your life just excitement.

[@Ryukimmm]

But the others why are they still stiff

[@lunarialoonatic]

@@Ryukimmm winter was the only stiff one imo. Ningning was nervous af

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

winter is mega stable! ningning was a beast during the entire performance she’s crazy!! def stood out the most. Karina and Giselle were awesome too, nobody missed a bit

[@부채-i8h]

Ningning is out of tune, that's why you think she stands out lol

[@liamdollete1645]

@@부채-i8h Ningning stood out because of her stage presence. Winter stood out with stability in vocals

[@pauline3499]

@@부채-i8h ningning is shaky but never out of tune.

[@paledangels]

@@부채-i8h not once did she get out of tune here

[@nhunguyen0203]

@@부채-i8h wtf who is out of tune? Wow TIL that sometimes hate can make people deaf.

[@b2thegoodness]

결국 진짜는 드러나기 마련... 진짜로 라이브하는 가수들은 인정받을수밖에 없다.

[@김주하-f6t]

❤❤ 진짜 인정하는바

[@ChanChan-ns9te]

aespa’s vocals are no joke. And to think, they dont even sound breathless, and their voices are full despite the choreo. Biggest slap to the haters out there. They are probably playing blind rn sksksks

[@shaistakhan3655]

Actually this is thsir fie3st time they are singing live

[@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062]

@@shaistakhan3655 I wouldn't say its their first time, the encores exists

[@ryujinae1227]

@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 yeah but even the encore has a really loud backtrack. its not the girls’ fault tho, its SM bc its clear they CAN sing live

[@lethrubs787]

@@shaistakhan3655 yes! but they do it great, in a PERFOMANCE !! with varius songs! tha's makes AMZING!

[@vanshika2135]

@@ryujinae1227 the inkigayo literally has no backtrack but okay

[@taeyongscheeks]

Actually the confidence Giselle had there is AMAZING. The HIGH NOTES were GREAT and Karinas and Giselles notes that were there WERE AMAZING and the OUTFITS JUST LOOK AT THEM.

[@happinessisyou9859]

Witch one is Giselle?

[@kingaeri7722]

@@happinessisyou9859 the one with braids and most covered of them all (japanese idol inspired outfit)

[@YuliAna-ds7fs]

Sorry, but for me Giselle screamed, instead of singing or rapping..

[@AB-yk2pq]

@@YuliAna-ds7fs Giselle was rapping and singing like everyone else, the only difference is that she was louder because she was trying to give preformance with good energy. It's festival, many people are there. You can't tell me she was "screaming" during Life's too short. People are never happy

[@m_mamba11]

@@YuliAna-ds7fs I agree with. She was literally screaming there...

[@arcelapuz5867]

Who's coming back here for a fresh breath of air and LOUD, CLEAR, and LIVE VOCALS?! AESPA 🥹💕

[@JaeminLee-nf8zx]

Yes baby 😂

[@garen577]

lol they aint lip singing most of the time. maybe slight a bit better lesarrafim but still bad.

[@JaeminLee-nf8zx]

@@garen577 lol blindly defend ur faves it must be very hard to accept the harsh reality of your faves, aespa is soooooo muchhhhhh better in terms of vocals lol ur faves performance in the recent big stage is so 😂🤣🤣🤣🤣 comedy our school performance is better

[@softpotatocutie]

aespa also lip synch most of their tv broadcast performances, but when they're called to perform live, they deliver and slay, they can actually sing with stability while dancing and all lol while your fave lip syncs cos they can't do it live properly ​@@garen577

[@itzelayala7323]

​@@garen577Chico literal no desafinaron casi nada y eso que ellas SI tocan notas altas no como tus favoritos que solo se fueron a humill@_r 😂

[@StacyJohn-yc6kl]

Coming back to this and just realised that they slayed that day and the hate they got was just forced

[@nicozgd1574]

IKR!!!

[@acesaurus2537]

You’re right!

[@acesaurus2537]

The only reason they probably hating was because “the crowd was dead” as they said, which I find funny because it’s normal since they still rookies. But they slayed the live singing ey

[@acesaurus2537]

Also, for a rookie like them, it’s okay that the crowd were not loud since many did not know them yet at that time. I think the important thing there is that a lot of the crowd did not leave and actually pay attention to their performance and vibing to their song even if they did not know Aespa. No need for the locals to go crazy shouting. It’s actually kind of nice that there are less shouting because it’s kind of irritating since you cannot hear them properly. Anyway, bless and cleanse your ears to Aespa’s live vocals mwah. Haters gotta hate the talented ones😘

[@STCKMN_]

YOU ARE SOOOOO RIGHT!!!

[@beyaset6395]

GIGI SLAYED THAT RAP, WINTER’s VERY STABLE, NINGNING AND KARINA’s STAGE PRESENCE MY BABIES Y’ALL DID GREAT

[@wiktorrogala4975]

Disappointed GiGi didn’t hit us with an “n” word lyric 😫 she’s an icon for that!

[@TristanLoh4200]

wait giselle is called gigi now?

[@starcore0w0]

@@TristanLoh4200 I guess??

[@TristanLoh4200]

@@wiktorrogala4975 which song did she sing the n-word in?

[@jungwons_wife_but_he_dont_503]

@@wiktorrogala4975 wasn't that a year ago bro she apologized to and no hate but I think y'all forgot hwasa said it to in a cover but actually said it

[@nguyenchau1330]

Guys , I have watched this performance this year. And I still feel shocked and surprised because they performed too great. At that time, when the group on this stage was very sad because there were toxic and unorthyted comments about the group. And now I tried to watch it and really I am extremely proud of the girls. aepsa fighting

[@jessy5791]

Vocalnya aespa is the best

[@soobinsdolphin]

this actually made me tear up lol... after so much criticism of not singing live, having no stage presence, being untalented and only debuting for their visuals, these girls just PROVED EVERYONE WRONG. their first time singing properly live, first time live in the US, first show in front of a big crowd, only the third kpop gg to perform at coachella, they must have been so nervous, but look at them!!! absolutely killing it, and i couldn't be more proud

[@diaz._.]

I KNOWWW I'm so proud of them!

[@shelly6115]

Same, I was looking for a comment like this 🤧

[@user-tp8dd1vs5m]

IKR THEYRE BEING ATTACKED SO MUCH 😭

[@inyochayacha548]

Can I ask something?? At the end of the song, the highnotes of Ningning and Winter, they really sang them or they were a back vocals??

[@serenagreen.909]

@@inyochayacha548 they sang them

[@AnnaTunG]

no music arrangement, no dancers and this is the first stage they interacted with people (due to the covid-19) aespa really did great and i love u!!!!

[@ann203]

This is why we stan idols from SM!

[@blink_____jenniequeen6670]

THEY DESERVE THE BIGGEST APOLOGY 🥲 they did so good🔥🔥🔥🔥like the rap skills and vocal skills is just ✨

[@bocilbocilndeso5303]

totally agree!!!

[@yoursasianbestie786]

Coachella really needs to invite AESPA again😤 They were so damn ready by talent back then but now they’re so damn more experienced and could eat the entire stage atp. The live vocals r literally crazyy

[@funketwins]

drama would go craaaaaaaaazy

[@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715]

They too early to get invited in 2022 same as Le sserafim this year, but they improved a lot and ready for a Coachella comeback

[@stefft.6966]

But crowd didn't know them

[@cecenaristia1462]

They can sing better thn le serafim though.... Sorry just the truth

[@stefft.6966]

@@cecenaristia1462 but nobody cared

[@eya7861]

This is the best fancam I've seen and I hope people would find this. The girls are giving a lot, thank you for uploading this🤧🥕🥬

[@ajh_8]

same 😭😭

[@ayiadnwtaa]

Bruhh, just realized why you put the carrot emojis 😭💀-

[@ulizchang]

I agree but what's with that emojis t____t

[@ayiadnwtaa]

@@ulizchang Its bcs since æspa doesn't have an official lightstick, karina told MY to use carrots or whatever the other emoji is as a lightstick 😭

[@ulizchang]

@@ayiadnwtaa i know, thanks 😭 but it's still funny to me 😭

[@thaonguyen-ww8sz]

2:06 THISSSSSS. Karina and Winter are such vocal beasts

[@Toomuchcigar]

I’m convinced that karina is actually lead vocal, whereas winter and ning ning is the main. Karina’s stability and technique is top notch

[@sims2lovealot]

@@Toomuchcigar Karina was actually meant to be the main/lead vocal and that's what she initially trained for. But she ended up being such a good dancer and they discovered Winter so she got moved to main dancer.

[@masakazuhiruko550]

Karina's standard is already on some main vocals of 4th gen thougj

[@alicewinter8716]

preach lol this group is a strong vocal group no doubt

[@my_review15]

they are so stable and burn the whole stage🔥 Love WinRina

[@s4ltyysenp4ii39]

How can Winter be so tiny but so stable???? She ate all those highnotes! She sounded exactly the same as their studio version.

[@JH-bb8in]

She’s the real main vocal. NingNing has that title to sell albums in Chija

[@s4ltyysenp4ii39]

@@JH-bb8in ningning's a good singer too. 😊 but winter slayed all her high notes.

[@kaarissm]

@@JH-bb8in but Ningning has more volume in her highnotes, also she always keep her vibra

[@JH-bb8in]

@@kaarissm she's unstable, period

[@eulalia3468]

@@JH-bb8in nope ningning has a better technique and wider range she's the main vocalist

[@pauline3499]

Make this fancam trending everyone! Their vocals and the cheers here are so clear, every aespa listener deserves to hear this.

[@multistan8162]

Not only they showed to the world they can SING live but also Winter (also NingNing) has denied all those who claim that she has no stage presence. I was there and Wintee SLAYED. Everyone was so shocked she literally blowed us away with her facial expressions and charisma. She looked like she was having much fun

[@ranme3798]

I think NO ONE said ningning has lacks stage presence. She has the BEST stage presence since debut. Some might argue karina has the best but imo ningning's stage presence is superior

[@multistan8162]

@@ranme3798 I honestly don’t know what y’all are talking about. Yes I’m a my and I won’t be biased I admit they are not the strongest in stage presence but that’s for all the members not just 2/4 or 3/4. I see so many people saying NingNing has a very solid stage presence when there is literally no difference between the members, what does NingNing do more than the others? smile 2 or three times more?. That’s what makes me angry y’all do not hate aespa but y’all want to bring down Winter and Karina because they are the most popular members or the most talented, aces or whatever. I accept criticism but I can’t accept the Winter or Karina hate thing, just say Aespa in general aren’t the strongest performers + do not tell me NingNing has a really great stage presence because I dare y’all to watch a Winter and NingNing fancam and tell me the difference. Each and every aespa member has flaws and things they are good at, Giselle is a good rapper, Karina a good dancer and fotg, Winter is a good vocalist dancer and “center” and NingNing a really good vocalist. they have time to improve the stage presence. Sorry for the long answer and I’m not talking directly to you ☺️

[@slayer-dj3dc]

@@multistan8162 winter is so bad

[@seenjeans]

@@multistan8162 agree I don’t rlly see the difference in stage presence between NingNing and Winter/Giselle. They make the same exact facial expression (meaning they don’t make expressions) I guess NingNing just has a naturally more intimidating or more charismatic face? Idk I don’t see it.

[@treatpeoplewithkindness2955]

@@multistan8162 For me Ning Ning is by far the one with better stage presence of the group and Karina is good too. Idk but is something about the face, for me Winter every time make the same blank face that in a way is very related with their concept but make her seen like she is bored. Also sometimes I feel lack of energy with Giselle and Winter. In general I perceived more energy from Ning Ning (specially in Dreams Come True and Savage era) this is not a hate comment towards Winter or Giselle but I would like them to try something new (for example I really like how Giselle was smiling the whole time in this presentation)

[@ninikimlove]

Even though aespa was still a rookie group during coachella still they performed like experts. People who hated on them before should apologize to them fr. Their live vocals,dancing,stage presence was phenomenon but SM could have given them good set designs to captivate more audience. Before i thought they weren't ready for coachella but after seeing Le sserafim's performance aespa was surely ready..

[@rianekafauziah7825]

Mind you it was aespa's first performance in front of a huge audience considering they debuted during pandemic era and no concerts, no nothing. Straight up Coachella 😭 if they were given another chance they'd slay more

[@ninikimlove]

@@rianekafauziah7825 ikr

[@lyhee6201]

일주일전에 캐스팅됨

[@ng.6180]

Aespa needs to be back at Coachella! Hopefully, in 2025, I would love to see them bring the DRAMA!

[@chakiyyy147]

Hopefully, we'll seeeee

[@biylah]

THISS!!!❤

[@Creemor]

Ya serious? Did you watch the video? Singing is great but dancing is lifeless!!!!

[@prettymcmxx]

​@@Creemor they're literally still a rookie when they performed at Coachella. haven't you seen their recent performances? lol.

[@alexiamountain]

@@CreemorMusic is not for dance last time I checked. Music is for the EARS!

[@mittens2207]

Comments here just showed how fluid the hate train is. 1 year ago, so many people criticised and hated Aespa for "bad" performance, and suddenly right now, they are awesome.

[@jacobong2257]

because now they found someone to replaced them... it's sad either way =.=

[@herseykcameron7013]

They had vocal even then but the stage presence were bad no lie but now lsfm had no vocal but stage presence which didn’t save them like how vocal didn’t save asepa then

[@summer-plumeria]

Because they were and have always been awesome. It just took a trash ass performance from LSFM for dummies to see the light

[@pristified53]

THIS!!

[@sabrinaseftiani]

Cause they're compared with BP back then

[@vavent_]

Really high quality FanCam Coachella should find your FanCam and put on their YT channel as official😃 It's 10x times better than Coachella's

[@liudmilakorovina4495]

agreed

[@dean4712]

coachella did dirty to aespa putting loud bg music and make it look like lip syncing

[@satanissima]

I'm not a stan but I will always respect them for this. Imagine debuting mid pandemic, you're a 1.5 y.o group that have always performed without an audience and never been allowed to sing live. And now you're in a foreign country, main stage, a huge crowd of people expecting to see what this kpop thing is all about, and your mic is on. And they delivered like seasoned pros. I'm BEYOND impressed. This was no small feat they pulled.

[@patobebe460]

I'm not even part of aespa´s fandom but I'm very happy for them, not only were they invited to one of the most important music festivals in the world, but they were also able to show everyone that they can sing live and have stage presence. Good job aespa!.

[@logical1117]

giselle's charisma is out of the world i'm really impressed with her confidence on stage!!! and ningning's vocals??? THIS GIRL IS INSANE

[@luvchoihsan]

she said the n word as well!! so insane!!

[@kenziearlvernon6668]

@@luvchoihsan shut tf up what does this have to do with the video

[@FluffyPhoenix991]

@@luvchoihsan pathetic, don't act like you never used it you angel

[@kakyyao]

@@luvchoihsan namjoon said it aswell, and guess what ? no one gave a damn. unfair, just because bts is more popular doesnt change the fact he said it too. i am no way defending her, but bringing down her talents isnt okay. this comment is about her charisma, but you come in "she said the n wor-" girl stfu we are talking about TALENTS. not what she did wrong

[@them00nremix87]

@@kakyyaolouder please!!!!!

[@noriichan3504]

Ningning and Winter vocals are so clear!!! Giselle is so cute hyping up the crowd and throwing her own color into the song!! Karina the ethereal leader

[@JH-bb8in]

I’m sorry but Winter >>> NingNong.

[@powbobs]

@@JH-bb8in Racist

[@minaesthetically]

@@JH-bb8in no room for racists here, get a life

[@JH-bb8in]

@Lola .f ningFing is there to sell albums in China but her facy reminds me of stinky tofu

[@them00nremix87]

@@JH-bb8in ummm korea not china😂😂😂😂... learn the whole asia geography please... you want to throw hate but dumb at the same time😂😂 Hahha

[@qwertyuiopasdfghjkl4607]

What an ear cleanse honestly

[@jun1291-s9]

Yesss Everyone went to see blackpink and aespa performance again

[@queenwonyoungtheitgirl]

​@@jun1291-s9 blackpink is the standard, aespa was boring

[@cookie.arcelia5328]

⁠@@queenwonyoungtheitgirlfell off

[@arcelapuz5867]

​@@queenwonyoungtheitgirl 2NE1 is the standard of YG before Blackpink. Fact Check ✅

[@nazimsellali8202]

​@@queenwonyoungtheitgirlwe need Aespa and keep crying

[@navaejaeger]

WINTER ATE THE CD, NINGNING SLAYED, GISELLE STAGE’S PRESENCE ATE, KARINA ATE EVERYTHING.

[@jojo-mp5bt]

It feels like watching a whole new aespa version. Their energy, vocal and stage presence is just wow. They look more happy and aespa's live performance hits different.They are freaking shining .

[@m1r__]

fellas you know why you're here.

[@seasonsoflove9507]

you caught me

[@kewl_]

Omg i’ve been caught. Hahahahaha

[@ng.6180]

Yes, we do! 😏

[@kztvfx]

LOL le sserafim

[@Cherie-u6f]

😂😂😂

[@heysungie1642]

the most stable voice winter even all high notes she was able to hit all.

[@notamulti7451]

did ningning skip the last high note? I think she did bc she was tired not really sure

[@jlvv_1]

@@notamulti7451 yes I guess so

[@notamulti7451]

@@jlvv_1 it was pretty understandable. they performed 5 songs straight and they sang with higher pitch than the original

[@jellyen-]

@@notamulti7451 3:48 no

[@carol127v]

@@notamulti7451 she didn't! and she did it perfectly too, they're all so good omg

[@thundercloudss]

SM should let them sing live in some of their music shows. Don't try to perfectly polished your idols. Let them sing live, so their charisma can reach the roofs. Even if it's not perfect, that's okay, because that makes a performance more genuine.

[@jywvxz7302]

i think sm will let aespa sing live now in music shows, since music shows already allowed audience and they can already cheer to their faves.

[@navaejaeger]

@@jywvxz7302 same.

[@bagushernananda7879]

SM really not put an investmen on music show nowaday, they dont really care for their artist to perform there and only sent them for 1 week, well i think there's positive and negative about it, the positive is the artist wont overwork and SM can save their budget for other things that more profitable than music shows

[@lolita960]

@@bagushernananda7879 honestly!! At this point SM artists don’t have shit to prove vocally! The music shows are there to promote the songs and compete with other groups, who cares about singing live ? NCT is WORKING working of course they’re gonna save their vocals these people are not robots

[@haechanie2208]

so proud of them! they debuted in the start of the pandemic,,, had little experience in performing with a live audience and now they're doing coachella!!

[@irmanhardiansyah]

This is the fairest fancam to show their quality. Winter pitch control, power n stability was insane, she's the engine to serve Ning2 giving the magical touch. Giselle with her enemous energy. Lastly, Karina as a leader having iron nerf to start the whole songs and brought the confidence to the whole team. Aespa is the future of KPOP

[@user-ae-winter]

U r right.

[@cosmicsnow6388]

woah, winter is so stable while hitting those high notes and dance moves

[@sofiagreen4100]

Winter's live is so stable, every time she sings I listen more closely because she sounds exactly like the studio ver.

[@aubrey5935]

giselle really knows how to hype the crowd, the way she changed the flow and slightly screaming gave me goosebumps. she’s a performer.

[@sihablospanol4662]

Omg yes!! She really is a performer!

[@happyNot96]

I'm here because I miss them so much. That's how live singing should be, so stable

[@z_hange]

Wow. Winter's incredible. She's so stable and even in their other songs when she's singing with her head voice, her voice sounds like it's been edited and effects had been added but it's actually her singing live. People have called her a walking studio recording booth in the past especially when they hear her sing in fansigns and that's so true. OMG

[@paulv514]

Wait why does Winter sound so perfect live? She’s really a crazy talented

[@Nana-ch5jm]

Ikr. She sounds just like the official audio

[@zzzonline]

Winter omg- she sounds literally like the studio version, so stable

[@mutevoice873]

@@Ubbe_lito me too

[@jichhuu]

they all do

[@charcharancharan2901]

mind u this was aespa first public performance as rookies

[@lumeire3519]

OH MY GOD! Miss Winter Kim how could you have that voice so stable and consistent while still having so much power even when you're only supporting?!?! It's unreal. 😭

[@lowkeyfunnyaf9643]

I was super excited for Aespa to perform at Coachella & they didn’t disappoint. They were working very hard. U can see Gisselle’s smile 😆 She looks so happy

[@quinyhayhay]

Ikr I knew Giselle was excited

[@levierdragon]

They definitely have more stage presence and energy when they sing live.

[@thethreesistersthreesister120]

nope😁

[@starsofdreams3947]

@@thethreesistersthreesister120 YES YES

[@ahs_sxxlgx]

Yup

[@kenpochi4524]

@@thethreesistersthreesister120 get a life.

[@aysathulrameela9947]

@@thethreesistersthreesister120 life is to short to hate

[@lalaland6936]

I've been a kpop fan since the 2nd gen, because they're (aespa) just a rookie I didn't expect them to sing Black Mamba, Next Level and 'Savage' in a row and without a break. Their songs has a high notes so I was very impressed because their voices are very stable. I've seen a lot of idols who are also from well-known companies and have been in the kpop industry for so long but their voices are not that stable. Let me remind you, STAGE PRESENCE is easy to learn, you don't need to hire some professional or expert just to have it, as long as you have experience to perform in front of people, as long as you enjoy the music, you will learn it. But the stability of your voice, you can't easily adopt it by experience.

[@s4ltyysenp4ii39]

ÆMEN!!

[@cocolemon8942]

LOUDER!

[@luwisey2386]

Yaasssss

[@ok-jl5ww]

@@s4ltyysenp4ii39 LMFAO

[@ohmykimchaewon]

we all can have stage presence even tho we can't dance or sing, Aespa didn't lack something here, but the stage itself, Stage lightings, and no bands? (bands can literally hype the song up). But damn, i was worried at the last part coz Ningning still dance the dancebreak with hype and It's so tiring and the reason why it makes me worried bc she will hit highnotes after dancebrreak but goddamn she still slayed that highnote

[@lookatrobbbbertaaa_]

IT’S SO SATISFYING EARING THEM SINGING LIVE, THEIR VOCALS ARE SO POWERFUL I’M SO PROUD OF THEM!!

[@sunnygirl7669]

The winter fangirls lmfaooo, Karina and giselle’s energy was literally next level and winter and Ningning sang those high notes like there’s no tommorow, stan aespa y’all

[@AnfrersAyyLmao]

I'm shocked at Winter the most, she's by far the most stable of them.

[@fullmoon8453]

This is what the "stable vocal" means

[@yanisellreyes1717]

I really love how stable Winter’s voice sounded.

[@CosmicWin]

WINTER'S HIGH NOTE WAS SO STABLE!

[@_my_insomnia_blink562]

They were unbelievable!!!!! Ningning and Giselle's stage presence ain't no joke! Karina and Winter were on point too! I'm so proud of them, iconic 🤧🥬💕

[@rinahartoyo8563]

My proud to aespa...

[@MC-ko2mx]

As a casual listener, I felt Giselle really ramped up her stage presence. She was able to let loose a little, and looked like she was really feeling the performance, IYKWIM.

[@danissegomez7953]

Ningning and Giselle who gets less appreciated in the past cuz they aren't Korean are now slaying! Glad people appreciate them more!!

[@rinahartoyo8563]

@@danissegomez7953 yess ningning & giselle voice really good...

[@user-ub2vv4do3w]

@@danissegomez7953 To be honest, ningning miss the tune a lot... lol

[@m1r__]

looking back SM did them so dirty omg just sent them like that no special stage nothing 😂 and they still slayed imagine a Drama stage at Coachella

[@rickay4549]

And only two weeks notice😭

[@Be.my.chill.kill.127]

fr we need them to go back to coachella again

[@andref-ds8dt]

and the fact that coachella is their first big stage where there’s a lot of real ppl watching them. since they debut during pandemic they did not used to seeing/interact with real ppl. like SM really set them up😭 thank god after the hiatus the girls and SM actually improve so muchh, now SM giving them new remix on every stage they perform, they also giving them thousands of backdancer, and great dance break

[@erwuw08408]

They didn’t have much time to prepare for it

[@sammiecchana]

Giselle’s confidence is on another level!! Finally they can sing their hearts out!!

[@felixslettuuce7153]

Winter is such a war machine packed in such a tiny body, she's so good

[@nguyenhaphuong7713]

GISELLE DID SUCH A GOOD JOB!! SHE LITERALLY SLAYED, LOVE HER RAPPING SO MUCH OMG

[@asmaa9787]

ikr 😭 Giselle's rap sounds even better here especially the last high pitched rap and her stage presence is so good

[@nguyenhaphuong7713]

@@asmaa9787 yes like her rapping was so powerful and badass, reminds me of the same vibe as Jennie in Coachella RAP QUEENS 💖

[@nguyenhaphuong7713]

@Kate Park yes she was so stable in rapping and also gets the crowd to involve! her abroad experience really helped her to be comfortable with foreigners i bet!

[@nymeriam715]

I don’t get why Aespa Coachella was known to be boring. It’s so good!

[@billliealim]

Prolly bc it didn’t have any heavy performance production but hey at least we know they can actually sing

[@Sarah-uj4hv]

aespa has the skills and talent. unfortunately i just think they lack a big presence in the west

[@jacobong2257]

@@Sarah-uj4hv please! if i know i would performance at this kind of stage i dont think i can do it at all....

[@michelleh1464]

@@billliealim they sing much better than le serafirm at coachella

[@jelienafendi7810]

winter is very VERY STABLE. her high note also her stage presence always amaze me!!! she's is a slayer!!!!! GOOD JOB WINTER! GOOD JOB AESPA!! 🥰

[@씨발-j4c]

Winter sounds like the studio version wow. Clear and stable vocals

[@namelessfan8795]

With this stage. They've performed a song or two before this yet they're so fucking stable. I'm just convinced that they may have been singing live all along, since debut. Like, listen to this! They sang this after a song or two! While dancing! Yet they're stable as fuck! Especially Winter! Like, you've gotta be kidding me, this is too great to be fucking real...

[@rara1138]

WINTER didn’t eat CD, she is CD .

[@rara1138]

@@Ubbe_lito yesyes

[@thinkabouteta]

now aespa has become a big group and can perform at the Tokyo Dome in two days and all tickets are sold out.

[@janrowebacaltos8585]

WINTER’S VOCAL IS SO DAMN STABLEEEE!!!

[@user-qr2fz6ih3n]

How did tiny Winter has such a powerhouse voice O.O?????

[@aoisoraa2]

it shows the biggest difference between singing and just shouting

[@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715]

Don't hate and compare the girls , just appreciate both of their performances. They really deserved to be Love not to hate

[@JaeminLee-nf8zx]

😂 fr

[@magnoliazambranarevollo2160]

LS HAHAHAHAA

[@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715]

​@@magnoliazambranarevollo2160 😂 Lol , don't hate other groups

[@Arf700]

@@jhomsubiaga-cabaro5715tell me you're not the one bullied aespa here right?

[@aldehcastro3438]

WAY TO GOOOO GISELLE!!!!!!!!! cannot be any prouder for you my aespaaaaa!!!! Thank you so much for the HQ vids!!!! ❤️❤️❤️

[@xanna8664]

they reallyare monster rookies! their live vocals is so stable, they have a great stage presence wowowoworejdosos

[@jewellanaletticia]

The fact that they had to sing higher than their songs due to huge crowd, yet they still slayed and sang flawlessly. Aespa we're so proud of you! Let those monkeys act like deaf for saying your crowd was dead while you were performing that's how the dogs bark when no one feed them😭💅

[@mangamama9881]

These haters wouldn't be saying that had I been there because I tend to be overdramatic when I like music 😂 but the crowd was happy like idk what they're on about

[@SkyBlueRose15]

Winter and NingNing’s vocals are so stable!!! Giselle is having such an amazing time and hyping up the crowd!!! And Karina’s stage presence is amazing!!! Aespa absolutely slayed this Coachella performance I love them!!! ❤️

[@ourlove9159]

Goosebumps. This performance is a big slap to antis who said they can't sing live. Who said they can't hype the crowd? The crowd even sing together with them. Knowing the fact that Aespa doesn't have much experience singing in front of crowd as they debuted during pandemic, their vocals alone here just hold our attention, which is good enough for a rookie group.

[@bb.yani1]

Y'all kpop fans make me laugh so hard 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. You call this a performance? Please, stay in Japan.

[@sonesavvy]

this is the first time I put fancams on loop because their vocals are just soooooo good. I was annoyed by the fact that the back track in the livestream is louder than their actual voices. Their voices were so damn stable! aespa deserve all the hype!

[@danissegomez7953]

True!! You can always trust fancams more than the official live stream sometimes.

[@taylors5981]

THOSE HIGH NOTES! LIVE! WOW. THEY KILLED IT. Absolutely killed it. People still going to say they were lil syncing, which is ridiculous, but idc because obviously they are WRONG

[@tayloristhemusicindustry3283]

karina really is the ALL ROUNDER and ACE of aespa, she is a lead rapper and still hit those runs and stable af !!! plus her dance and visuals are insane, I LOVE YOU KARINA

[@yesoryes2436]

Winter is main vocal material They perform for like 5 songs, but she is always singing so stable, i am waiting for her solo debut or maybe just singing an ost for drama would be my pleasure

[@Nana-ch5jm]

Winter and Ningning sang an ost from our blues drama. It should be released next week.

[@전봉준-l4v]

fact = Winter stable vocal better than ning ning. Winter >>> ning ning

[@yesoryes2436]

@@Nana-ch5jm really? I just know, thank u for the information

[@JH-bb8in]

She’s the real main vocal. NingNing is there to sell CDs in china

[@alexanderyang4620]

@@전봉준-l4v 小西八 ningning >>>> your mom and dad + whole family tree combined

[@asdkjgf]

Winter is stable as hell. Her high notes too is insane

[@giaeriblue]

Watching aespa's performance after watching LE SSERAFIM's disastrous Coachella performance is a relief to my ears and mind.

[@tasnimafauzia1795]

I didn't know what's going on a year ago about aespa's stage like I thought everything's just fine cause they're doing so fine and that well😭 Now that I realise the hate they had, people should be ashamed for hating this performance

[@totorrrrooroo8238]

에스파 이제 대중적인 곡 많이 냈으니까 제발 가서 제대로 찢었으면 좋겠다. 저때는 너무 광야노래만 낸 상태기도 했고 거의 첫 라이브 무대였는데 이제는 진짜 무조건 잘할 것 같다는 믿음이 생김

[@YasengGoranih]

ㄹㅇㄹㅇ

[@v4mpyss]

they sang live and they slayed! other companies should learn from this and let their artists sing live

[@Lemon65975]

Ofc they slayed! But most of the artists sing live...

[@ceebae8255]

Who lipsync's more than SM

[@Lemon65975]

@@ceebae8255 truth

[@zephyrcasa3913]

Sm need to trust their artist more

[@Lemon-x-]

I think you mean that SM should let them sing live more often lol. There's plenty of groups from other companies that sing live on music shows etc. it's just that SM for whatever reason doesn't let their artists sing live often, which sucks because SM groups have really good vocals

[@Error-qt4lu]

Giselle killed it , she had more stage presence then everyone else! U can tell she was really enjoying the stage

[@Daedroh]

Winter always stable! Hope she gets some well deserved rest and recovers back up to 100%

[@natchapuengwan8065]

Winter's vocal is not kidding.

[@aengdujelly4698]

Right! Her voice is amazing 🤘🤘

[@블랙맘마-y6j]

2:17 3:42 WINTER high note amazing winter live vocals omg🔥

[@aengdujelly4698]

She eating CDs 👏👏

[@dannarosedegracia2460]

All of them carried for me! Karina is a rapper but can pass up as vocalist to be honest, she’s good and her dance of course is the best among the 4. Winter was so good in keeping herself the most stable and her high notes are perfect, her dance is not 100% energy due to high notes but 100% smooth and precise. Ningning slayed this performance of course, she has high notes as well and 100% energy almost unbelievable! And Giselle our girl, very confident and looking a total performer with her rap, adlibs and hyping the crowd. I won’t get tired rewatching this.

[@chrisermaeydigdigan3409]

Winter is so stable. Giselle ang ningning rock the stage. Karina is so satisfying to watch.