aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속)' The Performance Stage (Romantic Street Ver.)

aespa's new single "Forever" is out!
Listen and download on your favorite platform: smarturl.it/aespa_Forever
❄'Forever (약속)' MV: • aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속...
Subscribe to aespa Official KZbin Channel!
kzbin.info?sub_con...
aespa official
/ aespa
/ aespa_official
/ aespa_official
/ aespa_official
/ aespa.official
weibo.com/aespa
#aespa #Forever #Performance #약속 #에스파 #æspa

[@gya5833]

Is it just me or the performance stages looked more luxurious than the actual music video? The outfits obviously played a big role.

[@clara6979]

They changed their stylist skskskkssk JK

[@iloey4u786]

@@clara6979 their style look better now than before

[@clara6979]

@@iloey4u786 ik

[@aerimsong]

thank god they didn't use the outfits on their mv and teaser pics cause those weren't good. these casual outfits fit the concept more imo

[@dmndmnans1441]

@@clara6979 they are?

[@user-xc4el9tx1o]

But the fact that each one of them has varying voice tone provides them with so much potential in terms of pulling of any concept.

[@floraison_amethyst]

Say to Giselle that stop Seducing and flirting Jeno,Fyi Jeno is for Lia only! But that Giselle is so desperate just to get Jeno and trying to break Lia and Jeno's Relationship

[@aespakarinaisakillervisual2572]

@@floraison_amethyst brain is something no?

[@jakerobin6599]

@@floraison_amethyst excuse me, this is KZbin and not Wattpad.

[@dandanie._.]

@@floraison_amethyst tf are you high on? that shit's real.

[@nuriznisakinah4189]

@@jakerobin6599 hahaha i just laugh at her stupid comment and u just making this more funnier i love that XD

[@user-ry7du2gr7x]

유지민 음색 진짜 미친거아니야...? 못하는게 없어 ... 불공평하다 불공평해

[@user-vu5dc8hs2v]

하나님이 졸다가 지민언니한테 완벽함을 너무 많이 쏟았대요 내가 물어봤어요

[@user-bd6vh8rq1q]

근데 난 스엠소속 가수팬은 아니지만 스엠 겨울노래 너무 좋음 .. 뭔가 2008-2009년도의 크리스마스같아 눈오고 반짝거리고 따뜻한 겨울날..

[@cantspell8007]

Yes sm has a good Christmas songs , especially Taeyeon Christmas song for me🤗✨⛄🎄

[@taeilstrony]

NO but Ningning black hair with that hairstyle just hits different I'm falling deeper inlove with my queens

[@fengying4898]

ningning's vocal killing beautiful!

[@kimdungchu6581]

I agree. She is a princess

[@gilaradi6337]

She's so gorgeous

[@fadlilaendyra8330]

Sm made them not using the backtrack anymore so that people would notice they're singing live. But they're so stable until people once again doubting when it's already clear this is live.

[@michaeltambunan4264]

Yes this is so righttt, I almost think this is pre recorded

[@khanhhuynh3145]

yes they live so stable that I doubt whether it is pre-recorded or not haha

[@SemajP514]

Not trying to be disrespectful to other groups but there is no weak group member in aespa. Each individual is all around talented.

[@aespacuresmyanxiety2273]

I'm a multifandom kpop stan and I agree to this.

[@sugrsweet2753]

this is straight up a fact

[@cantspell8007]

You don't need to defend yourself but yeah there's always who oppose the fact. I am so lucky to be MY

[@cantspell8007]

💗💗💗💗

[@markitandD.O.it1]

Fact!!!

[@dlovev]

애들 진짜 개이뿌다 왜 다 인형같냐 어디서 저런 보석을 찾은거야 스엠능력 칭찬해

[@eyebrowstj]

Another episode of SM artists slaying vocals, visuals, choreography, and stage presence!

[@vc5831]

*aespa untalented ugly flops, ITZY better than aesflop, aespa can't sing*

[@dairynehyun2122]

@@vc5831 what hahahahaha

[@CK_AlyXa]

@@vc5831 uno reverse u, now ur the one

[@juyeonlover405]

@@vc5831 i smell some jealousy -dy

[@devonpierre3551]

Aespa being the first ever KPOP group ambassadors for givenchy is sexy.

[@stannct1dwdw626]

@@sabirarahman9360 stay pressed fvck

[@user-xu5df5br7f]

*Kpop group

[@yeonnayaaa_]

@@sabirarahman9360 they the first loll in kpop 🔥❤

[@dmnsngie]

Kpop group*

[@kudoukaito613]

Yesss their power

[@user-pw3iz4tr4d]

닝닝 실생활에서는 한국말 아직 서툰데 노래부를때는 발음 정확해서 깜짝깜짝 놀람... 연습 진짜 많이 한거라는 증거...

[@DH-yh8eb]

그것도 그런데 원래 음악적 재능 있는 사람이 언어를 잘따라함. 소리에 민감하고 자기가 듣는 소리를 잘 캐치해서 잘 따라하는 능력이 있어서 노래만 잘하는게 아니라 언어도 잘따라함. 말자체가 서툰거랑은 별개로 발음은 찰떡같이 잘하는 사람들 있는데 그런사람들이 소리쪽에 재능이 있는거임

[@KimLeon2]

전 머글일 때 외국인 있는 줄도 몰렀어요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-hy9jo5cr3c]

@@KimLeon2 아아 저두요.... 다들 한국어 너무 잘해서 감동 ㅠ

[@melody_32]

@@DH-yh8eb 우˗ˋˏ 와 ˎˊ˗ ,...

[@user-nk1qu1vv6b]

@@DH-yh8eb 올..똑똑하네요

[@user-zs5fb9ln3j]

바다 목소리가 그리워서인가 닝닝 찾다가 이 영상 봤는데 보컬 닝닝 진짜 탄탄하다... 듣기 너무 좋음

[@jjkzenin08]

Every version of this song never disappoints because of their visuals and vocals

[@vc5831]

*ITZY better than aesflop*

[@sieunlvrs615]

@@vc5831 k it's your opinion, both itzy and aespa are great so stfu

[@kairimontefalcosmith654]

Their voices in each performance version is different. So yeah , they're singing live.

[@ndyndy7442]

Yes this time i hear a different version of karina at the last part.. they are singing live..

[@azraaiishsyal4767]

Yes even Ningning do a change little bit

[@PuhLiz]

Cause this time it's totally live I guess the previous ones are pre recorded . This one actually sounded really different and I could hear little bit of vocal mistakes here and there , I'm so happy they sang it live for the first time , it's so good to hear the rawness in vocal .

[@Lamborghini_Huracan]

비현실적인 비주얼과 무결점의 노래실력으로 이렇게 따뜻한 노래까지 잘하다니 진짜 대박이네

[@user-wm7nf5lo1s]

심돌에서 주레버 듣고 왔는데 원래 이런곡이군요...노래 완전 좋네요 음색들이 어우..다들🤭

[@jaehyunnae_kkeoya228]

Congratulations to Aespa for being the first ever kpop artist selected as Givenchy Ambassador💗💗

[@wintoreos]

When are they gonna be used in ads

[@chaeroii]

@Evelyn Violet I think they will be global. Because Givenchy provided an exclusive 2021 collection when the espa were on the red carpet in 2020. Givenchy has big plans with Aespa.

[@ISTANKPOP]

If you wanna know about Givenchy ambassadors The four members of aespa have been appointed the brand ambassadors for Givenchy! On February 10, SM Entertainment shared that aespa was selected as the 2021 brand ambassador of French luxury brand Givenchy. They will feature in collections and key lines by Matthew M. Williams, the creative director of Givenchy. aespa is the first K-pop artist to be a brand ambassador for Givenchy. It is also unusual in the fashion world for a group, and not an individual member, to become the face of a brand. This proves the influence of global super rookie aespa. Matthew M. Williams said, “When I first saw aespa, I was overwhelmed by the energy each member had. I felt that as a group and individually, Karina, Giselle, Winter, and Ningning have strong individuality and style that naturally fit with Givenchy. aespa’s fashion is having their own color.” aespa commented, “We’re extremely happy to work with Matthew, the new creative director of Givenchy. Since we are joining Givenchy’s new chapter, we will try to show various aspects and activities.”

[@czennieteumeahgaseblink__1073]

How's the brand name pronounced?

[@theiwatobiicepick7673]

@@czennieteumeahgaseblink__1073 Google says it's pronounced like "zhee·vaan·shee"

[@czennieteumeahgaseblink__1073]

@@theiwatobiicepick7673 oh okay. Ty.

[@j-annabonado3228]

Well deserved...no doubt about their fashion.. They are so fashionista and beautiful... Way to go aespa😍❤️

[@iamsnowiee]

Oh I didn’t know that Thanks for the helpful information

[@S1LVERCLOUD]

Aespa is the only group in which when the rap line starts singing they sings too good that can be main vocalist with ease.

[@user-gw7xf4co1m]

헐 다들 너무 청순하잖아 ㅠㅠ 지금은 엄청 매력적이라면 여기선 너무 애기애기함 ㅠㅠ 특히 닝닝이 흑발에 중단발 넘넘 이쁘다 ㅠㅠ 다들 왜 이렇게 이뻐.. 노래도 넘넘 이쁘고...

[@allyssanicoleg.manejero8451]

A group where the rappers can pass as vocalists. Worth to stan!

[@kristeldawnalcera583]

They can pass as vocalist 'cause both of them are choirs, too. AH, MY HEART.❤

[@Kygmii]

Fallen in ningning's vocal and still i can't get over it

[@cherry-wz7vy]

a disney princess!!!

[@fengying4898]

@@cherry-wz7vy i think so 2

[@user-zu5bw7qx6b]

eargasm

[@katexo-lsong8796]

the fact that they all can sing and have beautiful voices makes me so proud to be a predebut fan

[@izzie17girl]

winter's high pitch is always be my favorite part, im addicted to her voice

[@baekgu4639]

Winter's visual is another level The voice is so sweet

[@floraison_amethyst]

Winter should thanks to plastic surgery

[@uhuyyyeee3413]

@@floraison_amethyst butthurt midzy :(

[@puanmaharani5606]

@@floraison_amethyst its okey skip

[@isabellevingno3743]

The talent + looks, they're going to dominate 4th generation of K-Pop.

[@floraison_amethyst]

Aespa would dominate the world if the members are Herin,Hina,Lami,Koeun,Yiyang and Jeongyeon,so stfu and accept the fact that your aespa members did plastic surgery

[@myyczen4015]

@@floraison_amethyst wtf

[@myyczen4015]

@@floraison_amethyst Ur also a shipper so stfu

[@sapik9030]

@@floraison_amethyst HEYY PLZZ DONT MENTION JEONGYEON AND OTHER SMs TRAINEES TO THIS, SO EMBARASSING

[@meme-ye2ki]

Winter has royalty written all over her face and gestures. A real princess.🌈

[@user-st8wd4im8d]

닝닝이 포에버 할 때 순간 ses바다 인 줄 알고 소름돋음

[@no-vg8nr]

좀 닮기도 한것같음

[@user-fq9qd3gx1j]

ㄹㅇ.. 이번 savage때도 계속 바다 생각남

[@Anne-xj4vv]

헐 저도 같은 생각!

[@erosaphrodite8113]

Off topic, but Congratulations to aespa for being the first ever kpop artist as a group selected as Givenchy Ambassador. Imagine the power they are holding rn.

[@lunalouve1674]

Wow that's great! I'm sure they will get bigger and bigger like their seniors~

[@user-te3xm1lw3o]

I mean, our queens deserve it

[@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300]

All 4?

[@andikadzikry]

@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 yeaaa

[@treasureeffectyoonjaehyuke2013]

@@blink-oncefeat.multistan1300 yes

[@nadienadhirah]

THE POWER OF GLOBAL ROOKIES🔥 being the first ever kpop artist to chosen be the givenchy ambassador ✨

[@user-mq7yn7pf6y]

엑소 겨울 앨범 느낌난다...ㅠㅠ 에스파 리메이크 짱... 역시 스엠... 눈물날 것 같음ㅜㅠㅠㅜㅠ

[@coups_hannie]

근데 진짜 실제로 원래 엑소 곡인데 발매하지 못하고 에스파 곡으로 나온 거라는 추측이 있어요,,,! 정말 추측이긴 한데 2019 SM STATION 겨울 특집(?) 트레일러에 forever가 조금 실렸었는데 그게 백현 목소리인 것 같았고, 결국 이 곡만 그 사건으로 인해 발매되지 못해서 그런 추측이 있더라구요,,

[@esther3683]

Their vocals are heavenly, as if they were angels. Every time I listen to this song, their vocals make me feel at ease.

[@valeriaortizsuarez7535]

They're so beautiful and their vocals are seriously no joke so proud them being ambassador of givenchy.

[@sohailahcandayo7322]

Sm doesn't need music shows because they have their own stage

[@ericjaygragsin]

For sure SM needs music shows on their official comeback tho.

[@floraison_amethyst]

Sm home of Plastic Visuals Biggest Examples are Taeyong,Jaehyun,Jaemin,Winter,Irene,and etc.

[@asdfghjklasffghjkl4862]

@@floraison_amethyst You reek of insecurities, camping under sm vids. how sad:(((

[@sohailahcandayo7322]

No one in nct have plastic surgery duh!

[@Lajririrkt]

@@ericjaygragsin may be it is just joke 😁😁

[@sarahghic2754]

Im falling love with winter's voice😰😭🌹

[@hchoi8482]

실력 외모 스타성 뭐하나 빠지는게없다..

[@nicholaslouie7590]

Calling aespa rookies is truly an understatement. Just look how stable there vocals are, and don’t forget about them visuals.

[@onealpanes4200]

@@Marstatoy toxic

[@yurihansdetorres3560]

@@Marstatoy you're not a real once

[@hhjaehoon2100]

@@Marstatoy are you the real twice fan? Because the real twice fan know their limit because of twice vocals. You know what I mean ? 😂😂😂

[@alhizamdisoma2755]

@@Marstatoy coming from a Twice fan who always uses LipSinc. Maybe you hear too much lipsinc that you dont know its difference with live vocals

[@Sean-ts1qr]

@@alhizamdisoma2755 guys I love aespa but be realist they do playback at 100% just open ur hears....

[@itzyamelia4605]

Fun fact: Most of the comments here are congratulating Aespa being chosen as Givenchy ambassador WELL DONE AESPA, FOREVER~❄️❤️

[@user-ch9gl6dr9f]

I know right 😂

[@nelacyntia9255]

yassss!!! our super rookie!!

[@vc5831]

*SM paid them for that, aespa ugly untalented flops can't do that by themselves, while ITZY no promotion but better than aesflop*

[@woorella6614]

@@vc5831 Okey, its your opinion not our opinion

[@harula8273]

@@vc5831 imagine hating on a group rather than supporting your personal fave hahahahaaaa

[@jinzerdrixbuya2112]

STAN AESPA, THE ONLY ARTISTS THAT HAVE A BALLAD SONG WITH A DANCE BREAK!!!

[@user-lf1os3sh5c]

They remind of SNSD... The quality of their performances is amazing. They are so likable. I'm very excited to see what they have in store for us.

[@riazerimar7759]

Ning ning's high note is obviously live and sounds sweet and powerful coz its her raw vocal while singing live.

[@violetgomez4521]

Ning Ning please

[@levyconnors9435]

She definitely reminds me of Jonghyun!!! I think his spirits are still reaching out to support her vocals.

[@user-ch9gl6dr9f]

@@levyconnors9435 same 🤧

[@vi.santxs]

winter is my beautiful queen aespa the best new group of SM intertement

[@IM_A_PATRIC]

주레버 듣고 원곡 들으러 왔습니다,,,,,

[@AfterschoolNaNa]

진짜 이번 겨울에 역주행 하자ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 노래 너무 좋다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@aznharlumabao6417]

Winter has this honey like voice, it's very soothing. I can listen to her voice on repeat.

[@floraison_amethyst]

Lmao but you still can't change the fact that Winter is always seducing and flirting Winwin she wants to steal Winwin from Karina,I'm glad that Bastard already have sasaeng and i hope that sasaeng will kidnap her

[@aznharlumabao6417]

@@floraison_amethyst so what's your point??? Because as you can see what you're saying is not even related to what I've said???

[@abbigailisit442]

@@floraison_amethyst gago

[@aya-qx1po]

A 3 MONTH OLD ROOKIE BECOME GIVENCHY AMBASSADOR THE POWER THAT THEY HOLD

[@nicm.p.431]

Ikr! That’s what you call monster rookies 👑

[@floraison_amethyst]

Itzy is still a monster rookie

[@johnlyndonbeniabon1227]

@@floraison_amethyst don't drag itzy here, your creating a fanwar over mys and midzy, I'm both Midzy and My so pls stop this kind of behavior, both group are talented and unique in their own way.

[@linhtaekook4314]

@@floraison_amethyst Please don't mention another group here!

[@dreamdiary97]

@@floraison_amethyst please Don’t mention other group, for this era 4th generation aespa is monster rookie

[@user-uq6sj5qn2n]

와 닝닝 목소리는 바다에 흑발하니까 조이느낌도있네 .. ㅜㅜ 에스파넷다진짜 존예에 이런무난한(?)컨셉 개조타 ㅜㅜ 넥스트레벨로 할미...입덕직전이다정말...

[@hanatake2353]

1 year ago today, aespa released their second digital single “Forever (약속)”!!💥 It became their 2nd ever entry on the World Digital Song Sales, as well as their 2nd Top 15 hit on the chart. It also became their 2nd hit on the Worldwide iTunes chart, debuting at #26.

[@raeeyo_]

Am I the only one who is still crying because of the beautiful lyrics, that sing by the 4 prettiest girls ? :’)

[@baekyhun5681]

THIS ISN'T EVEN A COMEBACK YET BUT THE WAY THEY SHOWCASE EACH MEMBER'S VOCALS, THE STAGE, THE OUTFITS, THE STYLING, THE HAIR IS GIVING ME LIFE!

[@S1LVERCLOUD]

Not just Aespa has amazing visuals but also so much Talented. There’s nothing aespa members are not ACE at. They’re all rounder!

[@jendictive]

their vocals are on the *next level*

[@russelljuderodriguez3086]

SM: How many performance versions do you want? Aespa: YES

[@wannabessa9531]

HAHAHAHAHAHHA

[@mrmaclipstick5183]

I think this is the last one

[@spectre2278]

HAHAHAHHAA

[@04_alifbariqananta42]

lhayo piro, kok malah yes i pye to karep e

[@stannctjungwoo4221]

I'm addicted with Karina's voice again and again She is definitely of perfection Karina you deserves for all compliments after the hatred you received *KARINA QUEEN*

[@karinaace7965]

Karina Queen!

[@imapotato6627]

same i love her soo much

[@hori3044]

KARINA ACE

[@aspdrmleelvr]

me too! winter's voice too. i love both of their voices 🤍🤍 winter & karina

[@stannctjungwoo4221]

@@aspdrmleelvr me too all aespa member is main vocal🔥🔥🔥

[@mgkang6067]

왠지 시간이 흘러 한국걸그룹역사에 넘사벽 레전드를 찍을것 같다.

[@trillion9698]

라이브 레전드 진짜 뭐하나 빠지없는 에스파는 신이에요

[@sonemyzen7382]

Congratulations for being the first kpop group (yes all 4 of them) to be chosen as Givenchy Ambassadors!!!!

[@hannahlyssa8120]

Yoo Youngjin's daughter, Winter. One of the best vocals in SM.

[@praveenw.4393]

I'm obsessed with Karina's voice. Hope she gets more vocal lines to improve her singing skill more

[@fadlisyaharudin4094]

samee

[@anbevolution1617]

Ahhh winter such lovely voice, karina is so charismatic she touched my heart, ningning is so cute and her voice is soothing to my ears, just see her laugh is so theraputic, giselle is so beatiful and lovely also.

[@l1652]

Gonna spend VALENTINE'S DAY with this Girls😭♥️

[@asdkjgf]

This is the last performance live stage. Thank you SM and the stage director for giving all these beautiful stages for aespa. I look forward to their next comeback with their original song 🥰

[@StevensQueue]

Imagine a group who can perform strong and fierce tracks such as Black Mamba and Savage, can soften themselves and our hearts with such a magical ballad! Proud MY here!

[@baldtansupermacy]

The most iconic aespa perfomance.

[@aereluvshon3023]

This kind of song really fits with Karina's visual, acting, voice and character. A soft, sweet and warm music.

[@sashavhiryths9263]

+best center and leaderrr

[@elishaedenatencio4704]

Agree.

[@aespamx725]

Yess

[@karina8580]

@@sashavhiryths9263 agreeeee!!

[@nadiahalim8650]

Winter is just so pretty wow

[@karenched]

not an SM stan but one thing i cant deny with their company is the vocals of their artists wow

[@jhoannamariecueto8385]

Aespa, mahal ko kayo sm kahit may dance break yung ballad song n'yo!

[@user-mb5hd6bu9s]

SMtown's artists are all best in every aspect. The visual, choreograph, rapping and especially the vocals,they have it all. All talented artists debut in SM and seeing aespa debut under SM. Well I can't think of any words. I'm just proud to be an SM stan❣️ Ps. Stan the artists not the company itself by the way😉😅

[@khanhhuynh3145]

true, SM artists and songs are really special, and can't find in any other agency. I am a SM stan too, from TVXQ to aespa.

[@leesooah_]

me too, a stan since 2007 ^^

[@btsismyoxyjin6577]

Yeah..... Aespa is the first SM group I have stan 😍😍

[@aesyoojijiyoo]

Karina and Ningning powerful voices! I'm crying. Winter and Giselle's soft voices! I'm still crying.

[@rossanascarati2720]

Ning Ning and Winter beautiful high voices, giselle Karina a bit deep voice

[@khristinejoyceclaveria4321]

Imoa whaha i justvloge the song .karina give me the vibe look she' smiling to m

[@mevlus4443]

에스파가 이런것도 만들수있구나...

[@originalnamjesus]

Istg as someone who’s into kdramas alot, Giselle’s voice is the type you can usually hear in any kdrama ost. It was the first thing that came through my mind when she started singing here. Let the girl sing an OST soon pls.

[@sidney4814]

yessss!!

[@bad_kmj2467]

I don’t think she will sing an ost because she is the main rapper.i think ningning or winter can be the one who songs the ost because they’re the vocalist line.

[@bad_kmj2467]

@qυιηтεssεηтιαl qυεεη yeah.but i think sm will focus on theri vocals line first

[@ainaaridzuan7010]

@@bad_kmj2467 yeah but considering that giselle's singing background (been in a choir b4)... I think it also depends on the kinda tone thatis suitable for the OST,,, if u get what I mean hohoho

[@bad_kmj2467]

@@ainaaridzuan7010 yeah i get it.but i dont think she will be the first one to sing the ost considering she’s not the vocal line

[@042andipangeranmaulanaibra4]

MV : winter era Cozy Winter Cabin Ver : karina era Glitter Snowball Ver : ningning era Romantic Street Ver : giselle era BUT OVERALL ALL THE MEMBERS IS THE MASTERPIECE AND TALENTED

[@AlvinaEkaDamayanti-]

True

[@ceryysloves]

this!!

[@floraison_amethyst]

You mean? A masterpiece of Plastic Surgery,Can't dance and rap?

[@spa8089]

@@floraison_amethyst this animal

[@ceryysloves]

@@floraison_amethyst so what if someone did plastic surgery? cant u see that it means they're really determined to be an idol? so that they can pass the beauty standards of their country? and biss yes they're full of talents unlike you who can't do anything but spread negative and hate comments towards our girls just bcs you're jealous of their success. just support your faves instead of wasting your time here.

[@ratasupasueb4230]

SM is so lucky having them…🧎🏻‍♀️

[@nicm.p.431]

I know they are from SM so they have to have bomb vocals but HOLY CRAP if you told me Karina and Giselle were rappers I’d think you were lying 😂😂

[@vc5831]

*Karina is a bully like irene, she is stiff dancer and KAI from EXO said he hates her because she was rude to her seniors*

[@vc5831]

*and Giselle is a criminal in her pre debut*

[@mshinyee8294]

@@vc5831 what in the world are you saying

[@rtharn5876]

@@vc5831 HATERS THANKS FOR THE VIEWS. GO AWAY PLEASE

[@anabuulku786]

@@vc5831 thanks for your views, now back to your place

[@lesliecampos7465]

This goes to prove that not all songs need to have a rap to be good

[@vishalpatil3592]

And not all songs need to be upbeat and hiphop

[@obsessed2754]

Ballad is an SM thing. No wonder these girls can sing.

[@sailorkamatis5603]

This song is also really old too, older songs don't typically have a rap.

[@obsessed2754]

@@human7491 this is not even a title track is just an Sm thing making a version of a songs coming from legendary artists. Look at their black mamba, it was a hit. But I disagree that having a beat drop is the reason why a song is successful..Hmmm old classic songs dont have beat drop but still loved up to this days. A clear example of which is Girls Generations' INTO THE NEW WORLD. Bigbang's HARUHARU, Super Junior's NO OTHER and so much more. Nowadays songs are full of beats and drop that yes its fun when its new but it gets boring as time goes by. We still love a song with a meaning and someone is singing in the chorus than just beatdrops. The reason why Ariana Grande, Justin Bieber, Beyonce and other famous artist still does classics 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@Lady_JUNSU]

This can happen because they have good vocals. It'd be such a waste if SM didnt give them a chance to show more of their vocals like this

[@vincentlegaspi4373]

WINTER VOICE IS PURE EARGASM. THIS GIRLS VOICE IS BLESSED!

[@koro_free]

겨울에 꼭 들어야하는 명곡

[@bubblegum2169]

AESPA THE BEST

[@birfancik8763]

You are 3rd congrats

[@th.d]

they look so fine with their outfits

[@user-co8hc6xu2k]

에스파 노래중에 이게 제일 좋음

[@purplejuri]

Their vocals are CRAZY!!! 4th generation’s it girlgroup

[@alleonamarie3628]

MY FAVOURITE GIVENCHY AMBASSADORS

[@floraison_amethyst]

Nobody asked

[@itzyamelia4605]

@@floraison_amethyst Nobody asked for your existence and btw succs to have lots of hate on ur channel ):

[@user-pe5nh7fq7l]

@@floraison_amethyst aw jealousy 🥰

[@mukundakrishnan2678]

@@floraison_amethyst jealous. Nobody asked you to come here.

[@agassetiamulya5358]

@@floraison_amethyst aw why so pressed ew

[@user-eh7zv4ph5w]

뮤비보다 이게 멤버들 더 이뻐보인다 외모 미쳤다 정말

[@mikajoyorua6182]

can't wait to hear their voice as an OST in the near future K-drama. SM Vocals still the best.

[@noriahnoh320]

My bias winter. She so pretty and cute. I Love you so much winter. The sound of winter is soft

[@MINETURNNOWRblxGaming]

Popular opinion: Everyone agrees that æspa is the main vocalist.

[@kathymitty_]

Yep, I agree

[@floraison_amethyst]

I'm not

[@viclusiv]

IKR.

[@junkyupedia7348]

lmao when will people stop figthing over here on replies

[@viclusiv]

@@floraison_amethyst means you are deaf

[@kpoprmec365]

Aespa babies the new generation of Kpop. Lets go Aespa, rule this world.

[@wintoreos]

Hi, if you don't mind, can you please drop votes for giselle on whosfan app. She's third position but the number one position gets online global news so please :)

[@vc5831]

*they will never surpass ITZY, at least ITZY are talented and pretty unlike Aespa the untalented ugly flops*

[@wintoreos]

@@vc5831 can you plz take your hate somewhere else. Atleast aespa are going to slap you with their vocals. As if you're artists are talented then them. What if I say itzy are ugly they barely win votings

[@PuhLiz]

V c how come itzy is best ? vocals ? Let's not even insult itzy by putting them In that category . Dance ? Yeah jyp is known for having best dancers but but Karina and winter are really good too and Giselle and Ning Ning are far better from lia while all of them not being from dance line. Also rap ? Giselle's synk rap could dominate any rap ryujin did so far. She have never rapped that strong till now . And lastly visuals ...we all know the answer but I'm not gonna judge visuals as talent cause it's not really a talent but something that you're born with and have no control over and it's subjective but still if you consider k beauty standards aespa is far more compatible with that ...also I don't see your point of hating a 3 months old rookie group while comparing them with a 2 year old group who eventually paid for getting a bonsaeng award . So sad😢.

[@wintoreos]

@@PuhLiz this hater, I see him everywhere. Itzy are also not that big.

[@damiarahman1025]

내 지금 처럼..by winter is so beautifulll and soothinggg🥺🥺😭😭

[@giabaonguyen6366]

Can’t joke with Winter charisma ⭐️ Being better and better day by day! Love her so ❤️

[@nicoleibardolaza6340]

visual, dance skills and voice they got everything♥️ Aespa is a overall package group Proud to be MY ♥️♥️

[@34dollarze]

I already have a feeling about those Givenchy outfits that they wore in kbs gayo 2020. Go get it Givenchy Bæbies! ✨

[@artsistic_2273]

Karina's vocal kinda strong. I bet she's a belter and can hit high notes.

[@Gemstones1000]

Indeed.

[@moondust7027]

your words became true bestie 😭

[@ivyevelyn2761]

Her vocal is underappreciated tbh. She got her high notes in savage but it's not enough for me, I want moreee

[@-gowon3072]

This stage is so beautiful the girls did so well and the outfits are so cute🤍🤍🤍

[@mooniee_8938]

ive stan them months before the debut and now being one of the most powerful rookie groups like can you believe being an ambassadors of a luxury brand like ugh if i stanned them late i wont even believe that giselle is a main rapper a FCKIN MAIN RAPPER all of them are MAIN VOCALIST already no need of the main, lead and sub vocal positions already

[@Rain-kp2nf]

Okay but they just debuted and they are already Givenchy ambassadors? Like all of them? The power this rookie group holds is OUTSTANDING 🔥

[@ssimonesays]

woaaah really i didnt know :o thats so big!!

[@floraison_amethyst]

Stay pressed! Itzy will be forever The best Rookie group ever

[@hiii1608]

@@floraison_amethyst oh okay.

[@moonlightbae7015]

@@floraison_amethyst but you are the one who pressed here...

[@enolaholmes5709]

@@floraison_amethyst you stay stupid, both groups are best

[@user-pl7sm8gl1b]

내 느낌만 그런지몰라도.. 이 노래 st 진짜 예전 스타일 느낌나서 너무좋다..2000년 초반에 팝송느낌...뒤에 반주도 그렇고..ㅜㅜㅜ좋아요좋아

[@j_honey_0506]

너무아련해서 보면 너무좋으면서 왤케 슬프지..

[@callista8859]

Did u notice Giselle? Even though she is main rapper she's like main vocalist.They all are so talented!

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

her voice is so nice and angelic, there’s no weak vocalist in this group😭

[@geolliboo6956]

she's a choir when predebut

[@callista8859]

@@user-ib1is7ny7r Yesss! That's why I like Asepa so much.❤️

[@callista8859]

@@geolliboo6956 Woww Really? That's why her vocal skill was great.

[@vivekgogate3068]

Who is Giselle?

[@christy8586]

SM: How many versions of Forever do you want? aespa: yes.

[@floraison_amethyst]

So what?! Aespa members will be forever Herin,Hina,Lami,Koeun,Yiyang,and Jeongyeon

[@christy8586]

@@floraison_amethyst I really loved the SM Rookie Girls and still do but they're not in aespa and aren't even in SM anymore so please don't spread hate on any of the girls. aespa is Karina, Giselle, Winter, and NingNing and noone can change that fact.