अग्निरथ की हरित-धुलाई : Indian Railways Greenwashing by 100% electrification argument favor against

[@TheMrunalPatel]

Vocabulary: This vanity project is a sordid saga of the humongous wasting of costly assets and profligacy unmatched in the annals of railways anywhere in the world.

[@Mayanksagar-i2e]

Kya shabit Krna chata ho ap sir itna hard vocabulary use krka 😂😂😂

[@harshvardhan5893]

By Shashi Tharoor

[@sentinelindia]

Are Tharoor sir big fan❤❤

[@adityapratapsingh3624]

Ye English likh denge to negative marking kar dega check karne wala hai......""jada hoshiyari ye le""

[@cgtim3230]

Wah Kya Jute piece hai... 3% ho ya 10%.. Railway ko isse kitne running cost mei saving hai woh kyun nahi bataya? Aur wohi Liebus log jo pollution ke naam par 😭 karte hai woh Modi ne usse rokne ko kuch kiya toh pollution no problem chalega... Aur Bharat ka renewable energy produce abt 215GW pohach gaya hai, yane 40% of total consumption.... Wah kya Liebu Sieckuvon ki doglepan ki bhi misal nahi... Agar Modi oxygen acha hai bol toh kal Saas mat lena vid nikal denge... 😂

[@Nisha-ol4nq]

Sir google se dekha h 😅😅 Vanity - घमंडी Sordid -घिनौना Humongous- बहुत बड़ा Profligacy फिजूलखर्ची Annals -वर्षक्रमिक इतिहास

[@Nehayadav-gj3kf]

Thanks

[@ketunky3056]

Anals ka matlab?

[@nikhilrajpoot7051]

Sir but there is a thing ki india m abhi mana ki chalo coal se most of the bijli banti h pr ab gov rapidly renewable aur nuclear sources par shift ho rhi h aur at certain point of time india ka major electricity renewable hoga to future ke hisab se its a great step ❤

[@RAJP.]

00:16 ravish & dhruv

[@sahil712]

😂😂

[@Vivekvishwakarma11]

😂 duggal saab

[@Conceptsin15minutes]

But sir. I have some points - 1. Electricity generated in power plant is much more efficient, a power plant is approximately 55-56% efficient where as a diesel engine is on 28-30% efficient. ( Carnot cylcle due to use of several accessories in power plant which is not possible in diesel engine ) 2. My second point is that just like how we have to sell our 2nd hand phone before it dies completely , then you will get some money atleast. 3 . Engines who’ve a life of 15 years according to our standards. Just like I use a mobile phone(3yrs now) which was discarded by some ameerzaada on Olx thinking it’s outdated. But it’s still useful for me and I am still happy that I got such a good deal. (This will bring some kind of soft power to India too). If we deliver it in good quality and shape.goodwill cannot be measured in money.

[@AnkitKumar-AK47]

That's ok bro but then why did the govt say 100% green energy 😊

[@gurjotsingh8934]

Bulls’s hit

[@navan1087]

Another big point is Indian railway is aiming to become power source agnostic by going electric.Means you are not dependent on imported diesel, since line can be charged by any source like solar,hydal,coal power etc.The aim to become 100 % green is not there any time soon.

[@islamsuck1]

very beautiful andhbhakth

[@asmodeus3084]

Also geo-politics in play. When say 100% green you get some loans and shit from world bank for infra projects. This guy doesn't know anything, he's just analysing with very narrow mind, he needs to get out of well and look outside India for its benefits.

[@raviXYz5122]

Translation ---यह दिखावटी परियोजना महंगी परिसंपत्तियों की भारी बर्बादी और अपव्यय की एक घिनौनी गाथा है, जिसका विश्व में रेलवे के इतिहास में कोई उदाहरण नहीं है।

[@sanjaykumarsinha3837]

डीज़ल इंजिन की हरित धुलाई पर्यावरण को बचाने की एक कोशिश है । अचानक थोड़े ही सभी इंजन बिक जाएंगे , अतः उतना सशंकित नहीं होइए । जहां तक कोयले से बिजली बनाने का प्रश्न है,तो धीरे धीरे क्लीन एनर्जी की दिशा में भारत अग्रसर हो रहा है । समय लगेगा । ये फैसला एक अच्छे दिशा की ओर ले जा रहा है ।

[@Ramiz422]

तो पहले बंधू ये पैसे सीधे हरित बिजली बनाने में ही खर्च किया जाए ना प्रदूषण का प्रमुख कारण ही कोयले वाले पावर प्लांट है बाकी किसी भी स्रोत से इतना प्रदूषण नहीं होता जितना कोयले के पावर प्लांट से होता है और जो इंजन बेचे जा रहे हैं वो तो अफ्रीका में जाकर थोड़ी आक्सीजन छोड़ने लग जाएंगे

[@ravikantsharma3600]

Superb video with superb editing sir

[@Upscaspiranthobby]

Thank you sir🎉

[@TheMrunalPatel]

Most welcome!🥉Here is your Bronze medal for being the third person to comment on this video!

[@jayprakashkumar4711]

00:14 Sir Apne bna diya yehi kaffi h 😂 😂

[@madhudhaka4570]

Authentic roast by Mrunal sir

[@Cricketingtrends]

Excellent explanation sir

[@pranavmishra244]

Thank you sir. You explained in such simple and easy way.

[@CivilsPlant]

Mrunal Sir is Hero

[@deepakmalik2241]

Mai railway me loco pilot hu aur jo jo point aapne point out kiye mai bhi same soch rha tha... Sb point 100% right hai..

[@RahulPatel-ht3kv]

Sab baate hi Sir...inhone bola tha..ayodhya ke liye 1000 train cahalayenge..Delhi se ayodhya tak..4..5 train he chalte hi...Ye sab jumla hi....kuch nahi hoga...usko bech kar..paisa sab jeb me rakh lenge

[@MrKhabbu]

Pehle wali sarkar ne kya Shankar kam kiya tha . Lekin public plagal hey

[@MrKhabbu]

Good initiative by GOI.

[@youtubechnl129]

Excellent video

[@IrisBeam123]

सर सबसे अधिक डीजल नौसेना पोत प्रयोग करते है

[@thorengamer13]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGLGoKmnqLKWotUsi=LdzN47HS9pwFeqp1

[@alizaidi2083]

Thnku sir for explanation

[@SaikatSarkar-z8r]

Good evening Sir🎉❤

[@TheMrunalPatel]

Good evening to you as well! 🎉!🥈 Here is your Silver medal for being the second person to comment on this video!

[@bhawaniscrown490]

APKI CLASS KE LIYE MENE KISIKO RECOMMEND KIA LEKIN APKI VIDEO DEK KAR USNE MANA KAR DIA

[@user-su1te6gv5p]

😂😂 Right decision

[@ramudriver7584]

❤ Nali ke gas se 😢😮😅😊😂

[@fvcdtrk]

I have seen dumb people but never as dumb as educators of upsc coaching. Your propaganda against right wing is so fkin evident is embarrassing😂 1. With EV push we Already going for electrification in vehicle

[@Dp5536-l3s]

Mrunal sir

[@chandrashekharsharma4243]

SECURITY THREAT, If we stop diesel engines then there can be security threats for country.😢😢😢😢, How,, If during attack the enemies are able to destroy or halt electric network then all trains running on that route will be useless as none of train can move on that track. But with diesel engine that won't be the case.

[@RavinaTANWAR-pv3cg]

Cancel karo bhai isko cancel❌ karo 😂😂... Sir aap great ho ❤😊

[@parimalpandya9645]

All the equation get completed to add the kickback factors included simply

[@Abhisheknagar750]

😂😂😂 🙌 bhut achcha video

[@vetset3085]

India nxt byjus. = unacademy 😅

[@AyushTiwari-fe9ox]

Nhi bhai jb tk mrunal sir jaise teacher g ❤🙏🙏🙏

[@BPSCOne]

Jali n jli n😂😂😂

[@utkarshndaaspirant28]

Unacademy best hai trust me Mai iit foundation ki preparation kay hu 2020- 2022 tak

[@krishnabhardwaj3549]

Mostly Byjus teachers joined unacademy 🤣

[@rkentertainment2633]

Electricity efficiently work krti hai...jishe Carbon emission kafi kum hota ..... Appko uda Net zero kais😂

[@hb-cuo]

First we need to focus on the railway track of India Railway System. Many accident took place frequently in recent years and delay in train timming are the major concern or challenges for the Indian Railways.

[@indianbhaai]

Thank u sooo much mrunal sir 🙏❤️ This is very knowledgeable video please continue this type of lecture series

[@thorengamer13]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGLGoKmnqLKWotUsi=LdzN47HS9pwFeqp1

[@Gautam_Sharma19]

Thank you sir

[@islamkikhubsurti8057]

डीजल आधारित ट्रेने अधिक प्रदूषण उत्पन्न करती है? या एक विद्युत आधारित ट्रेन के चलने पर जो विद्युत खपत होती है, उस खपत हुई विद्युत के उत्पादन पर कोयला अधिक प्रदूषण उत्पन्न करता है? दूसरा विद्युत आधारित ट्रेने लागत को बढ़ाती है या डीजल आधारित ट्रेने लागत को बढ़ाती है?

[@YuvrajSingh-mh3ef]

Sir, is there any interview guidance program for CAPF candidates

[@jagdishkamble7916]

क्या अजिब बात है ना😉 रविश कुमार और राठी ने video नहीं बनाई उन्हे पहले तुमने बनाई😂😂😂.... Congratulations 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@RaushanKumar-yy7ns]

It's called BJP Hypocrisy

[@qwerty9889]

Abdul mixer hai tu ,,

[@poojadhankdhank3151]

Good evening sir

[@TheMrunalPatel]

good evening!

[@islamkikhubsurti8057]

अफ्रीका के‌ सभी देशों में क्या केप गेज पटरी है क्या? दूसरा यदि‌आधी कीमत पर मालवाहक, यात्रीवाहक ट्रेने मिल रही है तो कौन सा देश नही लेना चाहेगा? यदि हमें ट्रेनों निचले ढांचे को केप गेज के अनुसार बदलना पड़ेगा‌ तो जो बदलाव से स्पेयर पार्टस निकलेंगे क्या वा किसी अन्‍य ब्रोड गेज ट्रेनों के लिए उपलब्ध नहीं हो जाएगा?

[@_imsyadav]

Sir , I have one doubt kya me circle officer ka obc upsc ke liye use kar sakta hu ??

[@Qwerty-m1k]

Yes

[@TheMrunalPatel]

it has to be in the format prescribed by upsc in the notification see this pdf for more. upsconline.nic.in/daf/daf1_csm_2023/Instructions.pdf

[@subhakantasahoo6807]

Ye bhi sahi he. But nuclear aur solar power plant dhire dhire badh rahi he aur age yahi chalega. Coal power plant dhire dhire band hoga.

[@sidheart7447]

😂😂😂 Aapka padane ka style bilkul alag hai Vande matram 🙏🏻

[@aguyfromkota3204]

Sir aapka woh example yaad aa gaya ki ''maine seedhe haath se khilaya aur ncert aise ghumakar" yahi kar rahi hai govt.😅😅

[@adityasingh3507]

एब्नार्मलिटी में ये डीजल इंजन ही काम आते है। सब हटा देंगे , एक्सीडेंट के समय समझ में आएगा😆

[@India-dz4gb]

😅ये सब लोग अभी पैदा हुए है?? कांग्रेस ने कितना देश बर्बाद किया वो वीडियो कितना बनाया था

[@Ajay_qd3dz]

Modi government to purani dhongi h..😂😂

[@NikhilPramanik-zw1me]

Bihar me bahut jagah nhi h bhai electric railway lines

[@Hamster-guru.8958]

Sir please make one video for defining minorities in India after 1970 to 2024 What solution for article 29 and 30

[@bhanusingh4412]

Sir eco ke teacher hai polity ke nahi

[@SOLDGERBOY420]

Electric cars 😂 Electric truck 😂 Ye khatam fule ki khapat😂😂😂

[@TheMrunalPatel]

Timestamps 00:00 Intro 00:30 government reasoning 01:09 Broad Gauge vs Cape Gauge 02:09 Use of coal power 02:40 Railways income sources 03:16 Russian and Chinese models 03:45 Strategic reasons 04:24 Tharoor Vocabulary

[@junedkhan-w7h]

हा तो अदानी बैठा है न सब कुछ कर ने को

[@man1ch0u]

Why don't you go back to coal fired steam engines! A diesal locomotive is also internally an electric engine running on diesan generator that causes and spreads much more pollution compared to large power plants. Electric equipments/machines and sustainable power generation is the future.

[@DipakPandya-y7i]

डिजल इनजीन बंद नहीं करना चाहिऐ यह इनजीन भारत के लिए ऐक मजबूत इनजीन है, यह इंजन Kbhi भी काम आ सकता हैं भविस्य मै

[@ajeetY]

Ab mota bhai Hydrogen se chalenge 😂😂

[@thorengamer13]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGLGoKmnqLKWotUsi=LdzN47HS9pwFeqp1

[@yogeshkashyap-y1m]

Africa me engin chalega to pollution nahe karega

[@S1236-x6u]

बीजेपी का स्मार्ट इनविजिबल भ्रष्टाचार, मित्रो को प्रोजेक्ट दो, मिल बाट कर खाओ। जनता लुटती है तो लुटे।

[@ajeetY]

Mrunal sir aapke ghar ki bijali solar energy per work krta

[@advvaibhav]

ध्रुव राठी और रवीश के लिए अब कुछ बचा नहीं वीडियो बनाने के लिए

[@abhisheksingh247]

White t shirt looks so much better than that black one😂😂

[@यादव-संदीप.1]

1:47 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@himanshumaharana1108]

European union, western nation ko khus karana he........Environmental commitment kar diye hange

[@dsanrame268]

BJP ke politician ko commission bhi to lena hai New Electric locomotive se...

[@amritchatterjee3160]

So u r Agree that we don't have any nuclear electricity generation plant in future. Academy? Is one I did 4 Govt critic.No no vision for future needs

[@vikaskapasiya5495]

ट्विटर देखने के बाद आया हूं,कौन कौन है जो ट्विटर पोस्ट के बाद आए है

[@Moviescene.5ugt]

Main to bs sir ka meme dekhne aata hu..

[@virenderpratapsingh2594]

Sath m ashvani ko bhi bhej do yha accident km ho jae😂❤

[@Ram_Laxkar]

Accident ke liye 99% ☪️ancer community jimmedar hai

[@atishsinhaa]

Dhruv rathee ko bina sabun dhoya

[@GAMMING_ADA]

Phir bolenge electricity mehengi hogayi issilye kiraya increase karna pd gya

[@RahulPatel-ht3kv]

Inse nahi chal rhaa hi desh ..Bech kyu nahi dete...😂😂😂😂

[@Chhotu-z5p]

रवीश कुमार से बेहतर स्टूडेंट के लिए

[@MrKhabbu]

Bhai tumahara kam sirf inform karna hey ki government kya karegi. Achha hey ya bura hey yeh comment karna apka kam nahi hey especially is Academy platform per. Yahan sirf aur sirf fact ko samne rakhna hey .

[@vetset3085]

अनअकैडमी बी प्रोफेशनल है😂😂😂😂

[@Sahil_51155]

Y

[@BrijeshYadav-d3q]

Hello sir

[@Dk-Pandit]

Modi sarkaar ko lagta hai , bharat america ki tarah dikhe , lekin hr desh ki apni el vlue hota hai

[@madhudhaka4570]

🤭👍🏻

[@kamlasingh6273]

मूर्ख को सत्ता देने पर यही होता है 😌😌

[@ramrawat5225]

Isiliye india tarakki nhi kar rha hai Sarkar kuch naya karna chahti h Kuch to naya hoga bhai

[@nirmaljha3703]

Tab to bekar ka railway track ka electrification Kiya Gaya. Jis visay par jyada Gyan na ho us par jyada mat bolo.

[@harshrathore9407]

Cancel bhai cancel ❌

[@cgtim3230]

Wah Kya Jute piece hai... 3% ho ya 10%.. Railway ko isse kitne running cost mei saving hai woh kyun nahi bataya? Aur wohi Liebus log jo pollution ke naam par 😭 karte hai woh Modi ne usse rokne ko kuch kiya toh pollution no problem chalega... Aur Bharat ka renewable energy produce abt 215GW pohach gaya hai, yane 40% of total consumption.... Wah kya Liebu Sieckuvon ki doglepan ki bhi misal nahi... Agar Modi oxygen acha hai bol toh kal Saas mat lena vid nikal denge... 😂

[@Youhavetobesmarttounderstandme]

Modi kewal bare bare baat karte hai😮 Middle class par Tax ke upar ses fir GST ka Tax laga kar Choose rahe hai

[@saniyaashraf6577]

Medal de do sir

[@nikkikashyap2958]

Good evening sir g 🎉

[@TheMrunalPatel]

Same to you!🥇 Here is your Gold medal for being the first person to comment on this video!

[@nikkikashyap2958]

​@@TheMrunalPatel Very very Thank you sir g 😊🇮🇳🙏

[@amritchatterjee3160]

Very. Sad for u

[@AarifSayyed-d1w]

ESE KAHETEY HAY KHATRE ME HAY

[@ironpurush]

Medal milega??😅

[@VikaskumarMeena-k9n]

है

[@Niggesh2029]

Modi vishvguru

[@SPKumar54]

Andheri nagari mangu raja

[@dhruv6019]

Maulana Modi ko prize chahihe western countries se.. Ise bhi environment ka kida laga hai Trudeau jaisa

[@Szoraion]

" Maulana modi " ya kuch naya tha 😅

[@lalitkoli2687]

Kul mila ke modi ki dalali hi ho rahi hai iss video me 😂😂😂

[@Ram_Laxkar]

Sir pehle aap khud smj lo.....phir video bnao..puri video me kya kehna chah rhe ho smja hi nhi pa rhe ho...jesa America or Russia kr rhe hai vese hum bhi kr rhe hai

[@greatgaurav]

Bhai tum 3 bar vedio ko dekho fir samjho aur comment kro

[@TheMrunalPatel]

1.🗣 Join Unacademy Interview guidance program: unacademy.com/content/upsc/the-last-mile/ 2.🔠 Prelims & Mains coaching: unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil-services-examination-ias-preparation/KSCGY/subscribe?plan_type=plus&referral_code=mrunal.org

[@paradox_2]

Scam hai green energy, jab electricity coal se banega, solor bhi 25 saal baad e waste Banega, Bijli sirf Adani dega, sara profit adani ka hoga

[@Sangeeta23468ajay]

Ama yar train chlegi bizli aur bizli mota bhai banata hai .

[@rajkaushik5812]

1 obc pm desh nahi challa saktta😂😂😂nehru banne ke chakar mai 2 gujrati elon musk se ab kese ladenge😂😂😂delhngee

[@rohitdas589]

😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 जोर से बोलो जय श्री राम 😅😅😅😅

[@indian3199]

😅 नहीं होगा क्यू की डिझेल ओर इलेक्ट्रिक एंजिन मे Bhot फर्क है

[@thorengamer13]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bGLGoKmnqLKWotUsi=LdzN47HS9pwFeqp1

[@OggMarndi]

To diesel mein kaun sa oxygen nikalta hai Ishwar ki aulad se mera sawal poochh le