Agnostic On Muslims hiding prophet's mistakes! Smile2Jannah And Visitor Speakers Corner

[@thesocialartsclub9095]

This guy was being so disingenuous. He came pretending he just wanted to learn about Islam....but later it was clear he was here to try and debunk Islam. He's actually a Christian in disguise

[@007issyable]

I was going to same the same but you beat me to it. May Allah guide everyone

[@journeywithmycoffee7967]

Totally agree!!

[@mariannevisser1777]

I agree with you! A christian in disguise! Probably working with Arun! Look how desperate the christians are! But it doesn’t work! Nobody can debunk islam! Al Hamdulilah for islam!

[@monkearmy2439]

COWARD cant be upfront like the MUSLIMS BROTHER, whether bad or good we call ourselves MUSLIMS who believe in ALLAH and the BELOVED MESSENGER Muhammad (SAW). lol has to hide his faith to ''debunk'' islam how sad and pathetic, wallahi the people of the book are seething in jealousy for the Muslims because they dont have what we have, TRUE guidance and IMAN from ALLAH. ALLAHUAKABAR!!! ALL PRAISE TO THE LORD OF ALL THE WORLDS.

[@teamcali9212]

Desperation to debunk Islam has them playing silly games.

[@sabi3052]

So trinity he understands, multiple god he understands, but Quran coming at different times he does not. This man is a true Christian!😂

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

holy cult Chapter: Regarding Intercourse With Captives Abu Sa’id Al Khudri said “The Apostle of Allaah(ﷺ) sent a military expedition to Awtas on the occasion of the battle of Hunain. They met their enemy and fought with them. They defeated them and took them captives. Some of the Companions of Apostle of Allaah (ﷺ) were reluctant to have relations with the female captives because of their pagan husbands. Grade: Sahih (Al-Albani) Reference : Sunan Abi Dawud 2155

[@faheemahmed5786]

​@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Cope!

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@faheemahmed5786 muslim: "We are not TERR_R_st!!!" "I have been made victorious with t*rr*r " Chapter 57 The Book Of Jihad Book Sahih Bukhari Hadith No 2977 Baab Jihad Ka Bayan Me: Sounds like T_RR_R_st

[@faheemahmed5786]

@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Cope! Those who reject God, are going to hellfire, an eternal terror.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@faheemahmed5786 good cult hehe It was narrated from 'Ikrimah: "Some people apostatized after accepting Islam, and 'Ali burned them with fire. Ibn 'Abbas said: 'If it had been me, I would not have burned them; the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: 'No one should be punished with the punishment of Allah.' If it had been me, I would have killed them; the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: 'Whoever changes his religion, kill him.'" Sunan an-Nasa'i 4060

[@paulbarrett6093]

You have so much patience , you knew the brother wasn't real , and you still spent your time with him 🙏🏾.

[@FRead-sz2kf]

🙏🏿 ?!

[@John-hl5bo]

Sometimes you need to be patient with those people because brainwashing is so hard to fix it because you need to destroy his worldview and offer him a new one and it’s up to him to except it or deny it

[@mushirakazi3398]

You can wake-up, who is slipping. But not those who are blinds.

[@ShoaibAhmedNZ]

He wants to jump to step 10 without establishing the premises. It was rather a pointless discussion.He's got his ideas and doesn't really want to follow a line of thought.

[@mushirakazi3398]

This guy doesn't want to understand anything, he just wants to argue stupidly.

[@mariannevisser1777]

I think hè is a christian in disguise! He is not sincere!

[@Murad_313]

Mashallah you have a lot of patience, I lost it many times throughout the video

[@pureevil4674]

The patients by Zeeshan is next level, I would have ended the conversation a long time ago when I realised his insincere

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

vision cult Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: Do not greet the Jews and the Christians before they greet you and when you meet any one of them on the roads force him to go to the narrowest part of it. Reference : Sahih Muslim 2167a In-book reference : Book 39, Hadith 16

[@HaseebK0]

@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLATno surprise, disbelievers going to hell.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@HaseebK0 shock cult hehe It was narrated from 'Ikrimah: "Some people apostatized after accepting Islam, and 'Ali burned them with fire. Ibn 'Abbas said: 'If it had been me, I would not have burned them; the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: 'No one should be punished with the punishment of Allah.' If it had been me, I would have killed them; the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: 'Whoever changes his religion, kill him.'" Sunan an-Nasa'i 4060

[@HaseebK0]

@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT again, I see no issues.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@HaseebK0 truthful cult hehe It was narrated that 'Aishah said: "The Messenger of Allah married me when I was six, and consummated the marriage with me when I was nine, and I used to play with dolls." Reference : Sunan an-Nasa'i 3378 In-book reference : Book 26, Hadith 183

[@Aj17.]

The thumbnail should be "is there a probability you could be a cookie monster?" "Yes" 😂😂😂

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

mission cult It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim. Reference : Sahih Muslim 1767a In-book reference : Book 32, Hadith 75

[@faheemahmed5786]

​@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Cope! Man worshippers and rejectors of prophets would go to hellfire.

[@MRSyonicBoom]

talking to the white guy with the black jacket would have been better lol he got all brother zeshans points ..... very patient zeshan was :) honestly love this guy for the sake of allah for comming to speakers coner and doing dawah keep it bro

[@halalpolice23]

26 minutes in to it and he look sincere may Allah SWT guide him to Islam

[@AbdulazizKider]

He dissapointed you right hehe?

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

it is halal to strike the neck of non muslim Abu Musa' reported that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: When it will be the Day of Resurrection Allah would deliver to every Muslim a Jew or a Christian and say: That is your rescue from Hell-Fire. Reference : Sahih Muslim 2767a In-book reference : Book 50, Hadith 57

[@faheemahmed5786]

​@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Man worshippers and rejectors of prophets would go to hellfire. There's nothing surprising about that.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@faheemahmed5786 brothel time Chapter: Regarding Intercourse With Captives Abu Sa’id Al Khudri said “The Apostle of Allaah(ﷺ) sent a military expedition to Awtas on the occasion of the battle of Hunain. They met their enemy and fought with them. They defeated them and took them captives. Some of the Companions of Apostle of Allaah (ﷺ) were reluctant to have relations with the female captives because of their pagan husbands. Grade: Sahih (Al-Albani) Reference : Sunan Abi Dawud 2155

[@iMANTlS]

@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT People are competing who to go to heaven, and who to go to hell. Just like an employer seeing all others who have the same specialty, are potential competitors. And if there is a spot for promotion, the one gets promoted technically took the place of others from the same speciality. That does not mean the employer fired the others or halal to kill them. But of course, you need to learn and be educated to understand text. If you go out trying to be smart while you don't even know how to read the text, you're no different than a terrorists.

[@wahyder]

Seriously br Zeeshan you have lots of patience God bless you 🙏 To tolerate and idiot who is biased and fool

[@mok3346]

i think his confusion is that he thinks the whole Quran was revealed at once, and then over 23 years the prophet chose which order to reveal it to the people, as the circumstances of society deemed appropriate in his eyes

[@kamarured7692]

This guy is not confused, he's disingenuous and trying to trip Zeeshan into describing God as having parts so he can Christianity is correct

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

breastfeeding adult is halal Sunan an-Nasa'i 3320 In-book reference: Book 26, Hadith 125 It was narrated that 'Aishah said: "Sahlah bint Suhail came to the Messenger of Allah and said: 'I see (displeasure) in the face of Abu Hudhaifah when Salim enters upon me.' The Messenger of Allah said: 'Breast-feed him.' She said: 'How can I breast-feed him when he is a grown man?' He said: 'Don't I know that he is a grown man?' Then she came after that and said: 'By the One Who sent you with the truth as a Prophet, I have never seen anything I dislike on the face of Abu Hudhaifah after that.'"

[@faheemahmed5786]

​@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Tell that to your mom.

[@4freeman313]

Wow.. muslim is really patient, absolutely dishonest opponent

[@Hshsbwba]

Confused chad: There's no God Smiling brother: Of course there is, what would made you to believe in Him? Confused Chad: I don't know and don't want to know, and don't want to say. Why are you putting me on the spot? You just want me to believe in God. Aghhhhhhh😡 Smiling Brother: You're Confused.

[@baer9650]

No way this dude is serious. This discussion is mind blowing in a negative way. I wonder which person of him is responsible for logic but that guy wasn’t attending this session 😂😂

[@vinhhuynh-b3t]

may Allah swt guide this brother ameen

[@sondrameyer2816]

You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it.......think. Smiling to Junah with extreme patient.

[@lionroar26]

'You just want me to agree with you' 'You just want me to convert' Waste of time.

[@DestinyAwaits19]

Then stop trying to convert non muslims.

[@josantai2691]

Assalammu'alaikum...1st in here....Allahu Akbar...❤

[@kamarured7692]

He's not trying to learn jack S***

[@freeman7983]

baraka ALLAHU fikoum

[@alexbenny6469]

If you answer all his questions, then he's gonna ask you to show him the color of wind, hes not agnostic he's a Christian, now a days its becoming a new trend to debate Muslims either through fake ex Muslim or agnostic because through Christianity they lose debate,and at the end when nothing works then they insult the beloved prophet that's the type of strategy they use with so much frustration

[@thedruggist83]

Yes.. i see the trend too! Most will come as ex-muslim but get exposed easily by Al Fatihah!

[@silat-dl9lh]

@samdawah if you guys could have a second mic for the questioner because a lot of what is being said from the other party can’t be heard. May Allah bless you in your efforts

[@Nakheel77]

The cute boy in the middle is laughing 😂, Love you dear.

[@hacene4110]

he is not intellectually sound..... That's it.

[@kbisal]

The mental gymnastics to fit in not understanding the concept of God...ya Allah! 😂

[@davidsalman8362]

He's so hung up on trying to Justify Multiple Gods i think he's a Christian in Disguise but won't mention it cause you'll use the Christian Kryptonite "The Bible" Against him, so he hides under Different things

[@ffkamil455]

You give them something as a gift as the Quran says And the Quran will be completely in English language. A Pakistani man in America who is giving the Quran like this. You can also give them Quran and some advice and tell them about Islam. The words will create more interest and they will feel satisfied.

[@kamarured7692]

This guy is a flipping joker, the more i watch the more i want swear, this guy really came acting but trying to trip up Zeeshan but when Zeeshan wasn't going toward the trap he wanted to lay he started getting more rude and more impatient, hes very nefarious

[@teamcali9212]

Im in amazement on how many excuses Christians come up with to disbelieve in Islam. Quite shooking actually but not surprising.

[@YusupWong]

Asalamualaikom Bro. What is this guy up to man ? He is going ALL OVER THE PLACES! Truthfulness belong to ALLAH SWT

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

peaceful cult Narrated Atiyyah al-Qurazi: I was among the captives of Banu Qurayzah. They (the Companions) examined us, and those who had begun to grow hair (pubes) were killed, and those who had not were not killed. I was among those who had not grown hair. Reference : Sunan Abi Dawud 4404 In-book reference : Book 40, Hadith 54

[@faheemahmed5786]

​@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLATCope! Rejectors of prophets would go to hellfire.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@faheemahmed5786 police be upon him hehe It was narrated that 'Aishah said: "The Messenger of Allah married me when I was six, and consummated the marriage with me when I was nine, and I used to play with dolls." Reference : Sunan an-Nasa'i 3378 In-book reference : Book 26, Hadith 183

[@anaskpalmalaki8804]

What happened if there are three Presidents in a country?

[@tanzidaify]

So arrogant and argumentative. He came to prove his pointlessness and proved being so unsmart.

[@X_x_kingfisher_x_X]

I thought arul is demoted to be a hackler 😅😅 but it’s satan (so you think it’s a promotion) 😅😅😅😅

[@basedmuslimbooks]

1:03:55 yeah but the difference is none of Gods attributes manifests themselves into creation. The issue with Christianity is that the trinity is not even attributes, theyre actual things with wills of their own But even if we grant that, shouldn't you be alarmed the christian God only has 3 "attributes" when even humans have at least 5 big trait characteristics? What's his angle?

[@indram5384]

How can the Quran be the word of God, when their prophet said God told him to married a little child Aisha whose only 9 years only!! Nonsense!! God is almighty caring merciful compassionate and many more!! Their prophet married a little 9 years ago child!! Married his adopted sons wife and married his cousin, how can he be a prophet? Disgusting.

[@Yourdad388]

Arul look like hindus but he present itself as a Christian may be he know if he say he is hindu then they will regret in every conversation 😂😂😂

[@sapieearshad9105]

James is trying to support the multiplicity of the Christian god using Islam n attributes of Allah. Trinity is 3 different persons in 1. He's not logical n reasonal, just assume. Very disingenious.

[@lionabbass]

You can't have more than 1 Absolute Master and you can have 1 Absolute decision and outcome always without conflicts except there is only 1 that is truly Absolute Master making the Absolute decision for consistent outcome eliminating conflicts, etc, truly indicating that there is always a single and only 1 Absolute Master where the others called Absolute Masters aren't in reality.

[@MohamedYataAwal]

السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته ... في مثل هاته الحالات يجب التركيز على مناهج الادراك و أساليب التفكير ... و على الخصوص ... - الايمان بالغيب أي الايمان بوجود غيبيات و مغيبات .... - منهج الشك المطلق كأسلوب تفكير عبثي مطلق...يجعل من الانسان كفرد فاقد للقوى العقلية.... - ثم المدارك اليقينية العقلية : البديهيات، ...الفطرة ,,, - و المحسوسات ...- و المتواترات ..- و التجريبيات...- و الاعتراف ... و لكم جزيل الشكر و العرفان .... و الله هو الموفق

[@sayedquadri1338]

I recommend this guy to have a turn with Hamza (Hamza’s Den)… All doubts i.e. BS will be cleared😂😂

[@kingkey1607]

just think of it like this "let's say there's 3 gods (astaghar Allah wa authu billah) the Muslims has a god, the Christians has a god and the jew has a god" if there's conflict between all 3 of us, think about how it is up there with the 3 gods! they will not wait till now to battle it out! the whole universe wouldn't exist nor us humans! which one of the Gods created Adam and from Adam all of us? if you really use your logic, then you'll know and understand there can't be more than one God! La ilaha ila Alalh wa Mohamad abdahu wa rasulahu.

[@PTaylor1087]

Is it safe to say that the revelation of the Quran, each part was revealed circumstantially and at the time it was needed? Ex. People wondering about protection and guidance ask Muhammad PBUH and Allah reveals Surah Al Kahf. May Allah forgive me if I get this incorrect as I’m Still learning. This is in reference to the questions about the order the Quran was revealed in

[@abdbag1544]

This guy does not want to blive one God but arguing for multi gods.

[@wahyder]

He is afraid of truth

[@Pollakrobba1]

1:22:30 this is the main reason why so many people dislike the muslims , The man was in the back nodding his head ( basically agreeing with the muslim ) then the Agnostic points him out , with ''you were nodding your head so u agree with him'' and then the man that was nodding behind the muslim didnt even have a clue what the conversation was about. i hate people like this , these are a perfect example of yesman that just stand there because they have nothing else to do in life and just want to stand there agree with everything the muslims say even tho they arent paying attention.

[@halalpolice23]

19:55 😂 that was funny. Have he seen only the book of bukhari how big it’s💀

[@andreasbouzis2446]

Who wrote the first Hadith if not Bukhari ??

[@soodaa2530]

Sahaba

[@007issyable]

What a crazy man. Ar Rahman is a perfect expample the chapter talks about and this is the perso. Who defines Allah words.

[@dawoodpatel8580]

People that think they and to intelligent cant use common sense thats why our profit ( pbup ) him said must have wisdom behind our thinking

[@albertskoope]

God is most kind, kindness is not god and not all that has kindness is god. Bottle is blue, but blue is not bottle, and not all that has blueness is bottle.

[@sameemmohammad666]

If it would be shamsi talking to this agnostic about chronological of Quran n why not allah do this or this....simply he would answer allah do what he wish n allah known Best...

[@samueldavids3704]

Zeeshan you slept at the start. There was a trigger at the very beginning where you lost this guy. You needed to correct it straight away. The guy thought that Allah made a mistake by not revealing in the correct order and that the sahabas wrote the order later. That isn’t true. Allah revealed the correct order and it always lived in the hearts. What was already revealed in the correct order was later compiled in a book so it wouldn’t be forgotten. This point needed to be hit harder for the message to be put forward.

[@andreasbouzis2446]

No one wants to talk to Arul because they can’t preach their TAQiYA!

[@moh5able]

What did Jesus say to Christian in The Bible ? John 8 :42-47 42 Jesus said to them, GOD SENT ME 43 Why is my language NOT CLEAR TO YOU 44 You belong to YOUR FATHER,THE DEVIL 45 Yet because I tell the truth, YOU DO NOT BELIEVE ME 46 Can any of you prove me guilty of sin? If I am telling the truth, WHY DON'T YOU BELIEVE ME 47 Whoever belongs to God hears what God says. The reason you do not hear, is that YOU DO NOT BELONG TO GOD. What will the Christian Say To Jesus ? Matthew 7: 22: ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name and in your name drive out demons and in your name perform many miracles? What did Jesus Reply To Christian ? 23 Then I will tell them plainly, ‘I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!’ WHO IS GOD ACCORDING TO JESUS ? There is only ONE TRUE GOD, the Father (John 17:3) WHO IS JESUS ACCORDING TO HIS DISCIPLE? Act2:22 Jesus of Nazareth, A MAN attested to you by GOD with mighty works and wonders and signs that GOD did through him in your midst, as you yourselves know.

[@MoorfHiden-wq2ou]

Wow you are a muslims always quote verse in bible out of context because you never read bible. Now when you quote this verses do you gone accept other verses or you accept only them you quote? You muslims are funny when you deal with bible. If i do the same to quran you cry.

[@AshfaQ9556]

Allah plans this world around our free will..cuz he is all powerfull.

[@SuperKauser]

The guy is just ignorant Zeeshan proud of you for your manners

[@albtoolm4794]

One moment in which the information is wrong is that the Arabs in the past circumambulated the Kaaba while they were naked. This is not true. Yes, the Arabs were cruel, but they also had customs, traditions and ethics in society, such as honoring the guest, solidarity of family members, obedience and respect for the elderly. As for the infanticide of girls, that is unfortunately for fear of shame because of an attack. The tribes are on each other, and they sanctify the Kaaba, and there is someone who is responsible for cleaning and building, and they did not allow anyone to go out naked from his house or circumambulate around the Kaaba while he was naked. Please make sure before talking about these matters. This is history and it must be mentioned correctly and not distorted

[@azferahseng3411]

May God extend his life enough until he finally find Islam as the truth. If his time is up before taking Shahada, well good luck enduring getting his skin burn by hell fire, and then it is replaced with new ones, and burn again by hell fire and replaced again with new ones, and burn again, and goes on forever😂😂

[@realtox4149]

Talking to some people i think is a waste of time but they with idea of not disagreeing so the will act like they don't understand wild they is true

[@charliepouridiots]

"Quran" in the transaction is " that what is recited" .... The First Muslims who believed in the prophet Muhammad ( Pbuh) didn't need to hear the complete Quran , what was revealed from the Quran was more than enough for them ! The Quran is a miracle for ALL generations past and future TILL the end of humanity !!! Even now the Quran contain signs our current generation can't understand fully , hence theses sign are for other generation to come !!!

[@MoorfHiden-wq2ou]

its no miracle of quran that is debunked the quran you have today is not even complete

[@Seeker-ec1dd]

Wasn't Quran revealed in 7 dialects. So which one was actually written down or all seven were written down. Where are these copies. Wasn't the Quran compiled years after the death of the Prophet. That is a little different from what the Speaker seems to suggest.

[@journeywithmycoffee7967]

7 dialect doesn't mean different version of Quran. Quran is still in Arabic language. 7 dialect was approved by prophet Muhammad pbuh during his life time & the sequence of the verses is all remain the same until now. It is just how the Texas dialect vs Australia dialect vs British accent. Basically they are all English language right?

[@Seeker-ec1dd]

@@journeywithmycoffee7967 That looks highly impractical to memorize, recite and write down the verse in 7 dialects.

[@sapieearshad9105]

​@@Seeker-ec1dd It's not seven dialects but seven ways of reciting it. Be a good seeker.

[@journeywithmycoffee7967]

@@sapieearshad9105 Ya.. correct, different way of reciting. Thanks.

[@MoorfHiden-wq2ou]

@@Seeker-ec1dd dialect? it was totally diffrent word and missing verses etc. Its no dialect just diffrent qurans. Its always exist many qurans thats why uthman went around try to burn as mutch he could.

[@a.m7805]

This guy is stubborn and pretty dishonest

[@Real_vanGogh]

Instead of giving someone the "Satan" label, you can also wish him strength in finding truth. Would the prophet Muhammed call another fellow human "Satan"? These thumbnails are getting more pathetic by the day.

[@davesingh6168]

SPGC DEY JOOTHAY CERTIFICATES ASYLUMS WASTEY SIMRAN MAAN NET KINEY CERTIFICATE DITAY AR KI CHARGE KITAY

[@borassinio]

Arul the Satan 😂

[@ahmedabdelazim7110]

More like Satan's pet.

[@khandakershahi]

🤣😂😅😆😄

[@rushankhan7]

where is he in this video? i think he was just in the thumbnail?

[@hamzanocap]

Saar do not redeem saar why did you redeem

[@ffkamil455]

Gift you a Quran which will be in full English language. People will be more likely to listen to you. An American person is giving such English language Quran to people.this chanel name is I AM THE WARNER

[@carlosillich787]

Don't think he explained the compilation in chronology very well. Needs to study more.

[@tassmann3481]

He proved to a Christian who looking for Islam weak point for him to challenge

[@goldenratio8838]

Pagan came acting calm...and got triggered...LOL!...got destroyed ma sha Allah!

[@tassmann3481]

I don't think he is interested maybe he just wants to know for his requirements.

[@soodaa2530]

12:27 br.Z i think you know where he come from 😉

[@scottholder4431]

Atheists have no problem admitting there is a designer........religious people just have a difficult time admitting that designer is natural processes.

[@samueldavids3704]

"Natural processes"? What does that even mean. Are you leaving it vague intentionally? Religious people have no problem in your version of events which leaves out a designer. The problem is your alternative concept isnt consistent and doesnt logically make sense. Also, it isn't clear from your perspective what these natural processes mean. My opinion is that if you non religious people decided to go into more depth and give more details...you will logically build further to arrive at the destination (at a bare minimum) that there is more likely to be a designer involved. As soon as you are pushed to go further, it's like you see the destination ahead, panic and then go off track because it scares you. Every single time in conversation with Atheists/Agnostics it comes to this. Its the same formula and pattern. They start off by saying they don't believe in anything and as soon as we press on that, it becomes clear that they do believe in something. You cant make this up.

[@scottholder4431]

@@samueldavids3704 Can you prove me wrong?

[@scottholder4431]

@@samueldavids3704 You got it brother. That designer is natural processes.........not supernatural processes. That's why religion is so stupid. They believe the creator is supernatural processes, but yet they have no evidence of their own beliefs. LMAO!

[@commandar88]

​@scottholder4431 who is the designer and why did the designer decide to create the world when the world did not have to exist?

[@scottholder4431]

@@commandar88 natural processes is the designer. It's stupid to assume the designer is a who.

[@tassmann3481]

Just ask him to read the Al-Quran

[@xanh350]

The answers are so vague and don't make sense most of the time, also some answers feels like the guy on the left are pulling out at random or also deflecting, example when asked why he didn't relieve them in the same order, he goes (because then there wont be doubt, or because then its like asking to god to reveal himself) then he try to justify these answers by saying absolute nonsense. I'm sure the guy on the right wasn't convinced by 80% of the answers. Here I gave just one example but there are many examples and I dont want to write an essay lol.

[@hamzanocap]

Because the guy on the left is a comedian who thinks he's qualified to have these debates. Two men without knowledge arguing in circles.

[@ajaytranter2655]

The guy in the right is just an argumentative steroid user .

[@YourSense114]

The Quran revealed for 23 yrs, in two different cities in many different circumstances For example, Chapter 5 verse 176 Before even the questions were posted to the Prophet (PBUH) The prophet will receive revelation that a some people will come and they will ask about inheritance and the prophet should say such and such In ISlam, Almighty didn’t appoint judgment for the inheritance or how should be divided but Almighty ruled IN ADVANCE THE LAW OF INHERITANCE AND IT SHOULD BE FOLLOWED AS ALMIGHTY REVEALED IN THE QURAN Some people were trying to exploit the weak people and Almighty put it it FULL STOP The Quran clearly warned people who do unjust when it comes to inheritance, when it comes to defaming chastised women, breaking promises, distracting mothers or abandoning your parents, roping orphans etc Almighty put it law for mankind to follow and sent messengers to convey , but imen who loved money, power and pleasures chose to concoct man made laws and because of that the world is IN CRISIS This thing called BELIEVING ALMIGHTY, is only at the hands of Allah and only Allah knows who deserves to be saved from hellfire Despite the culprits putting billions of dollars to counter attack the message of Islam, only genuine people who seeking the truths will be guided not by the people of the dawah but by the will of Almighty

[@MyKittiCats]

This guy is so lost so sad fo him ridiculous

[@umurizo3949]

This ma is trying to ruin someone intellectual. He's jumping here and there pointlessly. Arguing every angle of discussion seems he got point to debunk islam but actually he's not.

[@sulaymans.jawara1455]

This guy is just looking for fame in a foolish way.

[@thedruggist83]

He is so confused!!!!! Everything is “not really” when he’s given fact! He is pure christian! So confused

[@mukhar786]

I think he is Christian

[@thedruggist83]

Me too! He just disguise so that we cant use their kryptonite on them

[@zakidiffi1503]

definition of insincere

[@mohammedamranmiah1594]

Sounds is so bad all I can hear is wind

[@lionabbass]

This guy wants the Creator of all to be collage of Creators. We in Islam are radical absolute monotheists unlike the others that are only monotheists by names make Creator to be many and exhibit weakness so much a single person defeated Him. I say these class of monotheists are really similar to the Hindus, and, the other polytheists.

[@martmohamed1886]

This atheist wants to use his definitions and wants to point score. He isn't listening or learning. His mind is shut to logic, yet he wants to be logical

[@HPzFreelance]

9:45 he's arguing that it would be easier to remember if the revelation came in the order it was written. Dude, do you not realize the Quran is the ONLY book that is being memorised en mass? There are 7 yr olds today after 1400yrs + after the fact, know it (around 600 pages of Arabic text) by heart often when they themselves are not Arabic speakers. There are millions of such people around the world who have memorised the Quran cover to cover. Allah (SWT) the creator of the universe and beyond no doubt choose the best method and why argue about it rather investigate what it says and take heed before its too late. This guy is not logical and he admitting he could be spaghetti monster proves my point. Note to self.... Don't waste time watching/listening to this guy unless he changes his approach. If you have multiple Gods and they are INDEPENDENT then as soon as they agree to collaborate they loose their INDEPENDENCE. How hard is it to get that across your head ?

[@basedmuslimbooks]

1:03:25 How is a father a, son and a holy spirit, a quality / feature / attribute? Even if I tried it doesnt make sense. "Hey you should ask Ali about X because hes such a Son." "Yo hes got mad Father" "we should trust him he is the most holy spirit of us all" Disingenuous, and a snake.

[@b.simmons1011]

False, in Christianity the Trinity is one essence that consists of 3 persons existing externally. There is 1 will amongst the 3 co-eternal persons. Meaning there is no difference in will. John 5:19-23

[@ajaytranter2655]

I think the steroids are making him agitated and to much testosterone in him

[@lionroar26]

Fraud is a Trinitarian

[@jro6947]

This guy is really annoying, he's arguing about things he doesnt even understand ,he's disingenuous and not trying to understand,he came all calm saying he wanted to learn about Islam then started arguing and trying to debunk Islam which makes me think he's a secret Christian because he's definetly not trying to learn and understand but argue

[@markrobby7136]

It's so sad and blasphemous to really believe that the Holy God would be involved by send his angel as this Man, to reveal all that childish, random and in immorality of; children marriage, multiple wives, women as prostitutes, murders, racism, women as object of sexual assaults and all. Thank God it's not the same God as the God of Christian

[@khaledhussain6020]

He is definitely an under cover Christian. Why he won't come out and say it because he knows what he believes in makes no logical sense so if he can bring Islam on to his level then he can say we'll myn don't make sense neither does yours.

[@razakmanify]

He interrupts too much to have a decent conversation. Clearly Insincere

[@tassmann3481]

I mean this guy is a Christian the Muslim guy keep on saying Al-Ikhlas

[@ahmedabdelazim7110]

I believe this guy is trying hard to make himself believe that Allah is not one. He wants to be confused. Jesus, God, and the holy spirit all of disjoint aspects. Jesus needs sleep, God doesn't, God is all knowing, jesus isn't, Holy spirt has wings, jesus doesn't. This is not the same as Allah being mercival and powerful at the same time.

[@mithunkhan937]

he could be secret Chirstian or have broken brain..

[@andreasbouzis2446]

You believe Allah wrote the Quran before the creation of man , if there was no creation! To who Allah teach the Quran?? What the universe has to do with the Quran revelations ?? Allah reveal to much the Quran in 7 dialects! Bukhari 6936 ‘ It disproves the fact Muhammad was not prophet!!

[@tassmann3481]

Someone got to tell the Muslim not to entertain rubbish this guy way out trying to/or to condenm Islam he refuses to listen.

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

This are of the story of revelation of Quran to his Prophet Muhammad pbuh. ======= (16:98) Whenever you read the Qur'an seek refuge with Allah from Satan, the accursed.101 101. This does not mean that one should merely repeat the Arabic words: I seek Allah’s refuge against the accursed Satan. It means that one should have a sincere desire and do his utmost to guard against Satan’s evil suggestions when one is reciting the Holy Quran and should not allow wrong and irrelevant doubts and suspicions to enter his mind. One should try to see everything contained in the Quran in its true light, and refrain from mixing it up with his self invented theories or ideas foreign to the Quran so as to construe its meaning against the will of Allah. Moreover, one should feel that the most sinister and avowed design of Satan is that the reader should not obtain any guidance from the Quran. This is why Satan tries his utmost to delude the reader and pervert him from getting guidance from it, and mislead him into wrong ways of thinking. Therefore, the reader should be fully on his guard against Satan and seek Allah’s refuge for help so that Satan should not be able to deprive him of the benefits froth this source of guidance, for one who fails to get guidance from this source, will never be able to get guidance from anywhere else. Above all, the one who seeks to obtain deviation from this Book is so entangled in deviation that he can never get out of this vicious circle. The context in which this verse occurs here is to serve as an introduction to the answers to the questions which the mushriks of Makkah were raising against the Quran. They have been warned that they could appreciate the blessing of the Quran only if they would try to see it in its true light by seeking Allah’s protection against Satan’s misleading suggestions, and not by raising objections against it. Otherwise Satan does not let a man understand the Quran and its teachings. (16:99) Surely he has no power over those who have faith and who place their trust in their Lord. (16:100) He has power only over those who take him as their patron and who, under his influence, associate others with Allah in His Divinity. (16:101) Whenever We replace one verse by another verse - and Allah knows what He should reveal - they are wont to say: "You are nothing but a fabricator102 (who has invented the Qur'an)." The fact is that most of them are ignorant of the Truth. 102. This may also mean: To send down one commandment to elaborate upon the other, for the commandments were sent down piecemeal in the Quran. For instance, the commandments about prohibition and fornication were sent down gradually one after the other during several years. But We hesitate to accept this interpretation because An-Nahl is a Makki Surah and to the best of our information there is no instance to show that commandments were sent down piecemeal at Makkah. Therefore, we prefer the other interpretation. The Quran has added details of one theme and explained the same with different kinds of illustrations at different places. Likewise it has related a story in different words at different places and presented its different aspects and details at other places. It has put forward one argument at one place to prove a theme and another at another place to prove the same theme. It has related one theme concisely at one place and in detail at the other. That is what the disbelievers of Makkah put forward as proof that Muhammad (peace be upon him) forged the Quran himself. They argued like this: Had the Quran been the Word of Allah, it would have related one thing in full at one place, for Allah’s knowledge is not defective that He should have to think out gradually the details of a theme and to give different versions to explain the same thing. In contrast to this, the knowledge of a human being is defective. A man has to think out gradually as has been done in the case of the Quran which is a clear proof that you have forged it yourself. (16:102) Tell them: "It is the spirit of holiness that has brought it down, by stages,103 from your Lord so that it might bring firmness to those who believe,104 and guidance to the Right Way,105 and give glad tidings of felicity and success to those who submit to Allah."106 103. The Holy Spirit: Gibril. Instead of using the name of the angel who brought revelation, his title has been deliberately mentioned to warn the disbelievers that the Holy Spirit who brought revelation is free from human frailties. He is neither dishonest that he should add something to or take away something from the message he brought, nor is he a liar and forger that he should invent and state something in the name of Allah. Nor does he suffer from any human lust that he should practice a deceit. He is wholly pure and holy and conveys the Word of Allah intact. 104. That is, the fact that Allah sends down His message piecemeal does not mean that Allah’s knowledge and wisdom are defective as you consider because of your folly. Allah sends His revelations gradually because human intelligence and capacity to grasp are limited and defective which do not let him understand the whole theme at one and the same time and make it firm in his mind. Therefore, Allah in His wisdom conveyed His revelation piecemeal through the Holy Spirit. He sends a theme gradually and gives its details by and by and uses different methods and ways to make it plain to human beings so that they might grasp it according to their abilities and capabilities and become firm in their faith and knowledge. 105. The second practical wisdom of sending down the Quran piecemeal was that those believers who obediently followed it, should get necessary instructions for the propagation of Islam and the solution of other problems of life at the time when they were actually needed. It is obvious that if those instructions had been sent down before time and at one and the same time they would not have been useful. 106. The third practical wisdom of not sending down the Quran as a whole at one and the same time was to give good tidings and encouragement to the obedient servants who were suffering from persecution and encountering great obstacles because they needed it over and over again. That is why they were assured of ultimate success time and again to fill them with hope to carry on their mission. (16:103) Surely We know well that they say about you: "It is only a human being who teaches him,"107 (notwithstanding) that he whom they maliciously hint at is of foreign tongue, while this (Qur'an) is plain Arabic speech. 107. In this connection, traditions mention the names of several persons, one of whom is Jabar. According to the disbelievers of Makkah he taught the Prophet (peace be upon him). However, one thing particularly noteworthy about all these persons is that they were non Arab slaves. Whosoever he might be, the fact that he used to recite the Torah and the Gospel and had an acquaintance with the Prophet (peace be upon him). This gave an opportunity to the disbelievers for spreading this false report that it was the particular slave who was the real author of the Holy Quran, but Muhammad (peace be upon him) presented it as the Word of God. This not only shows that his opponents were very impudent in spreading false accusations against the Prophet (peace be upon him) but also that, in general, people are not just in judging the worth of their contemporaries. They were ill treating like this that great personality who has had no parallel in history. Nevertheless, these people who had become blind in their opposition, preferred to attribute the authorship of the matchless Arabic Quran to a non Arab slave who had a smattering of the Torah and the Gospel. Instead of accepting the claim of the Prophet (peace be upon him), who was an embodiment of truth, they attributed its authorship to an insignificant foreign slave. Continued on the replies on this comments.

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(16:104) Surely Allah will not enable those who do not believe in the signs of Allah to be directed to the Right Way, and a painful chastisement awaits them. (16:105) (It is not the Prophet who invents lies), it is rather those who do not believe in the signs of Allah who invent lies.108 They are liars. 108. This verse can also be rendered like this: A Prophet does not forge any false thing but those, who do not believe in the revelations of Allah, invent falsehoods. (16:106) Except for those who were forced to engage in infidelity to Allah after believing the while their hearts remained firmly convinced of their belief, the ones whose hearts willingly embraced disbelief shall incur Allah's wrath and a mighty chastisement lies in store for them.109 109. This verse deals with the case of those Muslims who were being persecuted with cruelty and were being subjected to unbearable torments to force them to give up their faith. They are being told that if at any time they are forced to utter words of disbelief to save their lives, when in fact in their hearts they are secure against disbelief, they will be pardoned. On the other hand, if they accepted unbelief from the core of their hearts, they shall not escape the torment of Allah even if they succeed in saving their lives. It does not, however, mean that one should utter words of disbelief to save his life. This is merely a permission but not the ideal thing for a believer. According to this permission if one utters such a thing, he shall not be taken to account. In fact, the ideal for a believer is to utter words of truth in any case whether his body is cut into pieces. There are instances which show that during the period of the Prophet (peace be upon him) some acted upon the ideal while others took advantage of the permission. There was Khabbab bin Art (may Allah be pleased with him) who was made to lie on embers of fire until the fire was extinguished by the melting of his fat, but he remained firm in his faith. Then there was Bilal Habashi who was made to put on an armor and stand in the scorching heat. Then he was dragged on the burning sand but he went on saying, Allah is one. There was another believer, Habib Gin Zaid bin Asim, whose limbs were cut one by one by the order of Musailimah, the Liar. Each time his limb was severed it was demanded of him that he should acknowledge the Liar as a prophet but each time he refused to bear witness to his claim of prophethood until he breathed his last. On the other hand, there was the instance of Ammar bin Yasir whose parents were mercilessly butchered before his eyes. After this he himself was put to such unbearable torture that, in order to save his life, he had to utter the same words of unbelief that were demanded of him. Afterwards when he came crying to the Prophet (peace be upon him), he said: O Messenger of Allah, they did not let me go until I spoke evil of you and praised their deities. The Prophet (peace be upon him) asked him: How do you feel about this, in your heart? He replied humbly: My heart is fully convinced of the faith. At this the Prophet (peace be upon him) replied: If they put you to the same torture again, you may utter the same words. May Allah be pleased with them all. (16:107) That is because they love the life of this world more than the Hereafter; and Allah does not guide those who are ungrateful to Allah for His favours. (16:108) They are the ones upon whose hearts and hearing and eyes Allah has set a seal. They are utterly steeped in heedlessness. (16:109) No doubt they shall be losers in the Hereafter.110 110. These words apply to those people who gave up their faith, when they felt that they could not bear hardships of the right way and so they again joined their unbelieving, mushrik people. (16:110) And surely your Lord will be Most Forgiving and Most Merciful towards those who left their homes after they were persecuted, and who thereafter struggled hard and remained constant.111 111. They were those believers who migrated to Habashah === === (26:192) Indeed this118 is a revelation from the Lord of the Universe;119 118. At the end of the historical account, the same theme, with which the Surah began, is resumed. For reference, see (verses 1-9). 119. That is, this lucid Book whose verses are being recited to you, and this admonition from which the people are turning away, is not the product of the whims of a man. It has not been written and compiled by Muhammad (peace be upon him) himself, but it consists of the revelations of the Lord of this universe. (26:193) which the truthful spirit120 has carried down 120. That is, Angel Gabriel, as mentioned in (Surah Al- Baqarah, Ayat 97): Say to them: Whosoever is the enemy to Gabriel, he should understand that he has, by Allah’s command, revealed to your heart the Quran. Here the object of using the title of the trustworthy Spirit for Gabriel implies that the Quran is not being sent down by Allah through some material agency, which is subject to change and vacillation; but through a pure Spirit, having no tinge of materialism, and who is perfectly trustworthy. This Spirit conveys the messages of Allah precisely in the same form and with the same content as they are entrusted to him. It is not possible for him to tamper with the messages, or to make his own additions to them in any way. (26:194) to your heart that you might become one of those who warn (others on behalf of Allah),

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(26:195) (a revelation) in clear Arabic language,121 121. This sentence may be related to “the trustworthy Spirit has come down” and also to: “who are (appointed by God) to warn.” In the first case, it will mean that the trustworthy Spirit has brought it down in plain Arabic language, and in the second case, it will mean that the Prophet (peace be upon him) is included among those Prophets who were appointed to warn the people in the Arabic language, i.e. Houd, Salih, Ishmael and Shuaib (peace be upon them all). In both cases the object is the same: the divine message has not been sent down in a dead or mysterious language, or in a language of riddles and enigmas, but in such clear and lucid Arabic, which can be understood easily by every Arab and every non Arab who has learned Arabic. As such, the people who are turning away from it, they cannot have the excuse that they could not understand the message of the Quran. The only reason of their denial and aversion is that they are afflicted with the same disease with which Pharaoh, the people of Abraham the people of Noah, the people of Lot, the Aad and the Thamud, and the people of Aiykah were afflicted. (26:196) (a revelation embodied) in the scriptures of the ancients.122 122. That is, this very admonition and divine message and teachings are contained in the former Scriptures also. The same message of submission to One God, the same belief in the Hereafter and the same invitation to follow the Prophets has been given in all those Books. All the Books sent down by God condemn shirk and the materialistic philosophy of life and invite people to accept the true and sound philosophy of life, which is based on the concept of man’s accountability before God, and demands that man should give up his independence in deference to divine commands brought and preached by the Prophets. None of these things is new, which the Quran may be presenting for the first time, and none can blame the Prophet (peace be upon him) of saying something which had never been said before by the former Prophets. Among other arguments this verse also is quoted in support of Imam Abu Hanifah’s early opinion that if a person recites the translation of the Quran in the prayer, his prayer will be in order and valid, whether he is able to recite the Quran in Arabic or not. According to Allama Abu Bakr al-Jassas, the basis of this argument is: Allah says that the Quran was contained in the former Scriptures also; obviously this could not be in Arabic words, As such, if translated and presented in another language, it will still be the Quran. (Ahkam-ul-Quran, Vol. III, p. 429). But the weakness of this argument is obvious. The Quran, or any other divine Book, was never revealed in a manner that Allah inspired to the Prophet with its meaning and then he presented it before the people in his own words. The fact is that every Book, in whatever language it came, was revealed in divine words and meanings together. As such, the teachings of the Quran were contained in the former Scriptures in divine words and not in human, and none of their translations could be considered as the divine Book or its representation. As regards the Quran, it has been stated over and over again that it was literally revealed in the Arabic language: We have sent it down as Quran in Arabic. (Surah Yusuf, Ayat 2). We have sent this command in Arabic to you. (Surah Ar-Raad, Ayat 37). An Arabic Quran without any crookedness. (Surah Az-Zumar, Ayat 28). Then just before this verse, it has been said that the trustworthy Spirit has brought it down in Arabic. Now how can it be said that the translation of the Quran made into another language will also be the Quran and its words will represent the words of Allah? It appears that later the Imam himself felt this weakness in the argument and, according to authentic traditions, gave up his earlier opinion, and adopted the opinion of Imams Abu Yusuf and Muhammad, who held that a person who could not recite Arabic words, could recite the translation of the Quran in his prayer till he was able to pronounce Arabic words. However, the prayer of a person, who was able to recite the Quran in Arabic, would not be valid if he recited its translation. The fact is that the two Imams had proposed this concession only for those non Arab converts who were not able to offer their prayer in Arabic immediately after embracing Islam. In this the basis of their argument was not that the translation of the Quran was the Quran itself, but that just as a person unable to perform Ruku and Sajdah was allowed to offer his prayer by making signs, so a person unable to pronounce Arabic words could recite the translation. Then just as the prayer of a person who offered it by making signs could not be valid as soon as the cause of inability was removed, so the prayer of a person who recited the translation would not be valid as soon as he became able to pronounce Arabic words. (For a detailed discussion, see Al-Mabsut by Sarkhasi,Vol. I, p. 37; Fath ul- Qadir and Sharh Inaya alal-Hedaya, Vol. I. pp. 190-201). (26:197) Is it not a Sign to them (to wit, the Makkans) that the learned men of the Children of Israel know that?123 123. That is, the learned men of the Israelites know that the teachings of the Quran are the same as of the former Scriptures. Though the people of Makkah themselves were un-initiated in the knowledge of the Book, there were many scholars among the Israelites living in the surrounding areas, who fully understood that the Quran did not bring a novel message, which was being presented by Muhammad bin Abdullah for the first time, but it was the same message which had been brought and preached by Prophets of Allah one after the other since thousands of years. Is it not then a convincing proof of the fact that the Quran has been sent down by the same Lord of the universe Who sent down the former Books. According to Ibn Hisham’s Life of the Holy Prophet, a little before the revelation of these verses a deputation of 20 men, who had been influenced by the preaching of Jaafar, came to Makkah from Habash. They met the Prophet (peace be upon him) in Masjid al-Haram and asked him in the presence of the unbelieving Quraish what his teachings were. In response, the Prophet (peace be upon him) recited a few verses of the Quran, whereupon tears came down from their eyes and they believed in him there and then to be a true Messenger of Allah. When they took leave of the Prophet (peace be upon him), Abu Jahl met them along with a few other men of the Quraish and rebuked them, saying: Never has a more stupid company come here before: O foolish men, you were sent here by your people with a view to inquiring about this man, but no sooner did you meet him than you gave up your own faith. Those gentle people did not like to have a dispute with Abu Jahl, so they left him, saying: We have no wish to enter an argument with you. You are responsible for your faith and we are for ours. We adopted something in which we saw some good for ourselves. (Vol II, p. 32). This same incident has been mentioned in Surah Al-Qasas, thus: Those to whom We had given the Book before this, believe in the Quran and when it is recited to them, they say: We have believed in it. This is the very truth from our Lord. We were even before this followers of Islam. And when they heard vain and meaningless talk, they refrained from entering an argument, saying: For us are our deeds and for you yours, peace be to you, we do not like the ways of the ignorant. (verse 52-55). (26:198) (But such is their adamance) that had We revealed it to one of the non-Arabs and even if he had recited(this clear Arabic discourse) to them (26:199) they would still not have believed in it.124 124. That is, now when a man from among themselves is reciting to them this divine revelation in lucid Arabic, they say that he himself has composed it, and therefore it cannot be from Allah. But if the same revelation in eloquent Arabic had been sent down by Allah to a non Arab as a miracle, and he had recited it before them in perfect Arabic accent, they would have invented some other excuse for not believing in him. They would have said that he is under the power and influence of a jinn, who speaks Arabic through a non Arab. As a matter of fact, a lover of the truth considers the thing presented before him coolly and forms an opinion about it after due thought. But an obdurate person who is unwilling to believe, pays no attention to it at all, but instead seeks all sorts of excuses to reject it, and will, in any case, invent an excuse for his denial. This obduracy of the unbelieving Quraish has been exposed over and over again in the Quran, and they have been clearly told that even if a miracle were shown to them, they would certainly have found an excuse to deny it because they are not inclined to believe: O Messenger, even if We had sent down to you a Book written on paper, and even if they had touched it with their own hands, the disbelievers would have said: This is nothing but manifest sorcery. (Surah Al-Anaam, Ayat 7). Even if We had opened a gate for them in heaven, and they had begun to ascend through it, they would have said: Our eyes have been dazzled; nay, we have been bewitched. (Surah Al-Hijr, Ayats 14-15). (26:200) Thus have We caused this (Admonition) to penetrate the hearts of the culprits (like a hot rod).125 125. That is, unlike the truth loving people to whom the Quran brings peace of the mind and heart, it passes like a hot iron rod through the hearts of the disbelievers, which sets them ill at ease, and they, instead of pondering over its themes, start looking for subterfuges to deny it. (26:201) They will not believe in it until they clearly see the grievous chastisement.126 126. This is the same kind of punishment which was mentioned by the nations mentioned above.

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(41:33) And who is fairer in speech than he who calls to Allah and acts righteously and says: “I am a Muslim”?36 36. After consoling and encouraging the believers, now they are being exhorted towards their real duty. In the preceding verse they were told: Being firm in the service to Allah and standing steadfast on this way after adopting it is by itself the basic good, which makes man a friend of the angels and worthy of Paradise. Now they are being told: The next thing which wins man the highest place of honor is that he should do good deeds himself and should invite others to the service of Allah, and even in the environment of severe antagonism where to proclaim Islam is tantamount to inviting hardships for oneself, one should firmly say that one is a Muslim. To understand the full significance of these words, one should keep in view the conditions in which they were said. The conditions were that anyone who proclaimed to be a Muslim would feel as if he had stepped into a jungle of beasts, where everyone was rushing at him to tear him into pieces. More than that, if anyone opened his mouth to preach Islam he would feel as if he had called on the beasts to come and devour him. Such were the conditions when it was said: A person’s believing in Allah as his Lord and adopting the right way and standing steadfast on it is indeed a great and fundamental good, but the greatest good is that man should boldly say that he is a Muslim and should invite others towards Allah’s service, fearless of the consequences, and while performing this duty should remain so pure and pious in conduct and character that no one should have a cause to find fault with Islam and with those who uphold it. (41:34) (O Prophet), good and evil are not equal. Repel (evil) with that which is good, and you will see that he, between whom and you there was enmity, shall become as if he were a bosom friend (of yours).37 37. To understand the full significance of these words, one should keep in view the conditions in which the Prophet (peace be upon him) and, through him, his followers were given this instruction. The conditions were that the invitation to the truth was being resisted and opposed with extreme stubbornness and severe antagonism, in which all bounds of morality, humanity and decency were being transgressed. Every sort of lie was being uttered against the Prophet (peace be upon him) and his companions. Every kind of evil device was being employed to defame him and to create suspicions against him in the minds of the people. Every kind of accusation was being leveled against him and a host of the propagandists were busy creating doubts against him in the hearts. In short, he and his companions were being persecuted in every possible way because of which a substantial number of the Muslims had been compelled to emigrate from the country. Then the program that had been prepared to stop him from preaching was that a hand of the mischievous people was set behind him, who would raise such a hue and cry that no one should be able to hear anything as soon as he opened his mouth to preach his message. In such discouraging conditions when apparently every way of extending invitation to Islam seemed to be blocked, the Prophet (peace be upon him) was taught this recipe for breaking the opposition. First, it was said that goodness and evil are not equal, as if to say: Although apparently your opponents might have raised a dreadful storm of mischief and evil, as against which goodness might seem absolutely helpless and powerless, yet evil in itself has a weakness which ultimately causes its own destruction. For as long as man is man, his nature cannot help hating evil. Not only the companions of evil, even its own upholders know in their hearts that they are liars and wicked people and are being stubborn for selfish motives. Not to speak of creating dignity and honor for them in the hearts of others. It lowers them in their own esteem, and causes their morale to be weakened and destroyed in the event of every conflict. As against this evil, the good which appears to be utterly helpless and powerless, goes on operating and working and it becomes dominant in the long run. For, in the first place, the good has a power of its own which wins the hearts and no man, however perverted and corrupted, can help esteeming it in his own heart. Then, when the good and evil are engaged in a face to face conflict and their nature and merits become apparent and known, after a long drawn out struggle, not many people would be left, who would not start hating the evil and admiring the good. Second, it was said that evil should be resisted not by the mere good but by a superior good, as if to say: If a person treats you unjustly and you forgive him, it is the mere good. The superior good is that you treat the one who ill-treats you which kindness and love. The result would be that your worst enemy would become your closest friend, for that is human nature itself. If you remain quiet in response to an abuse, it will be mere goodness but it will not silence the abuser. But if you express good wishes for him in response to his abuses, even the most shameless opponent will feel ashamed, and then would hardly ever be able to employ invectives against you. If a person doesn’t miss any opportunity to harm you, and you go on tolerating his excesses, it may well make him even bolder in his mischief. But if on an occasion he gets into trouble and you come to his rescue, he will fall down at your feet, for no mischief can hold out against goodness. However, it would be wrong to take this general principle in the meaning that every enemy will necessarily become a close friend when you have treated him with the superior good. There are such wicked people also in the world, whose inimical nature will never change for the better no matter how tolerantly you may overlook their excesses and how benevolently you may react and respond to every evil committed by them. But such devil-incarnates are as few in the world as the embodiments of goodness are. (41:35) But none attains to this except those who are steadfast;38 none attains to this except those endowed with mighty good fortune.39 38. Although a very efficacious recipe, it is not easy to use. It requires a great will power, resolution, courage, power of endurance and full control over one’s own self. A man may act benevolently in response to an evil done, on an impulse, and there is nothing extraordinary in it. But when a person has to fight for years and years, for the sake of the truth, those mischievous worshipers of falsehood, who do not feel any hesitation in violating any bond of morality, and are also intoxicated with power, it requires extraordinary grit to go on resisting the evil with good, and that too with the superior good, without ever showing any lack of restraint and self-control. Such a work can be accomplished only by him who has resolved with a cool mind to work for the cause of upholding the truth, who has subdued his self to intellect and sense and in whom good and righteousness have taken such deep roots that no malice and mischief of the opponents can succeed in deposing him from his high position. 39. This is a law of nature. Only a man of very high rank is characterized by these qualities; and the one who possesses these qualities cannot be prevented by any power of the world from attaining to his goal of success. It is in no way possible that the depraved people may defeat him with their mean machinations and shameless devices.

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(41:36) And if you are prompted by a provocation from Satan, seek refuge with Allah.40 He, and He alone, is All-Hearing, All- Knowing.41 40. Satan feels grieved when he sees that in the conflict between the truth and falsehood, meanness is being resisted with nobility and evil with goodness. He wants that he should somehow incite the fighters for the sake of the truth and their prominent men in particular, and especially their leaders, to commit such a mistake, even if once, on the basis of which he may tell the common people that evil is not being committed by one side only. If mean acts are being committed by one side, the people of the other side also are not morally any better, they too have committed such and such a shameless act. The common people do not have the capability that they may assess and counterbalance fairly the excesses being committed by one party by the reactions of the other. As long as they see that while the opponents are adopting every mean act yet these people do not swerve at all from the path of decency and nobility, goodness and righteousness, they continue to regard and esteem them highly. But if at some time they happen to commit an unworthy act, even if it is in retaliation against a grave injustice, both the sides become equal in their esteem, and the opponents also get an excuse to counter one blamable act with a thousand abuses. That is why it has been said: Be on your guard against the deceptions of Satan. He will incite you as a well wisher to take note of every abuse and every insult and attack and urge you to pay the opponent in the same coin, otherwise you would be regarded as a coward and weaken your image of strength. On every such occasion whenever you feel any undue provocation, you should take care that this is an incitement of Satan who is arousing you to anger and wants you to commit a mistake. And after having been warned, do not be involved in the misunderstanding that you have full control over yourself, and Satan cannot make you commit any mistake. This high opinion of one’s own power of judgment and will is another and more dangerous deception of Satan. Instead of it you should seek Allah’s refuge, for man can save himself from mistakes only if Allah helps and grants him protection. The best commentary of this subject is the event which Imam Ahmad has related in his Musnad on the authority of Abu Hurairah. He says that once a man started uttering invectives against Abu Bakr in the presence of the Prophet (peace be upon him). Abu Bakr kept on hearing the invectives quietly and the Prophet (peace be upon him) kept on smiling at it. At last, when Abu Bakr could restrain himself no longer, he also uttered a harsh word for the person in response. No sooner did he utter the word, the Prophet (peace be upon him) was seized by restraint, which appeared on his face, and he rose and left the place immediately. Abu Bakr also rose and went behind him. On the way he asked: How is it that as long as the person went on abusing me, you kept quiet and smiling, but when I also said a word in retaliation, you were annoyed. The Prophet (peace be upon him) replied: As long as you were quiet, an angel remained with you who went on replying to him on your behalf, but when you spoke out, Satan came in place of the angel. I could not sit with Satan. 41. After seeking Allah’s refuge against the storm of opposition, the thing that brings patience and peace and tranquility to the heart of the believer is this conviction, Allah is not unaware. He knows whatever we are doing as well as that which is being done against us. He is hearing whatever we and our opponents utter and watches the conduct of both of us. On the basis of this very conviction, the believer entrusts his own and the opponents of the truth’s affair to Allah and remains satisfied. This is the fifth place where the Prophet and, through him, the believers have been taught this wisdom of preaching and reforming the people. For the other four places, see (Surah Al-Aaraf, Ayats 199-204), (Surah An-Nahl, Ayats 125- 128), (Surah Al-Muminun, Ayats 96-98), (Surah Al-Ankabut, Ayats 46-47) and the E.Ns. (41:37) And42 of His Signs are the night and the day, and the sun and the moon.43 Do not prostrate yourselves before the sun, nor before the moon, but prostrate yourselves before Allah Who created them, if it is Him that you serve.44 42. Now the discourse turns to the common people and they are made to understand the truth in a few sentences. 43 That is, they are not the objects of divine power that you may start worshiping them, thinking that Allah is manifesting Himself in their form, but they are the signs of Allah by pondering over which you can understand the reality of the universe and its system, and can know that the doctrine of the Oneness of God which the Prophets are teaching is the actual reality. The mention of the night and day before the sun and moon has been made to give the warning that the hiding of the sun and appearing of the moon at night, and the hiding of the moon and appearing of the sun in the day clearly point to the fact that neither of them is God or object of divine power, but both are helpless and powerless objects, and are moving subject to the law of God. 44. This is an answer to the philosophy that the intelligent among the polytheists generally used to propound to prove that polytheism was rational. They said that they did not bow to these objects but bowed to God through them. An answer to this has been given, so as to say: If you really are Allah’s worshipers, there is no need of these intermediaries: why don’t you bow down to Him directly? (41:38) But if they wax proud45 (and persist in their attitude, it does not matter, for) the angels near-stationed to your Lord glorify Him night and day, and never grow weary.46 45. If they are arrogant: If they think it is below their dignity for them to listen to you, and still persist in the ignorance in which they are involved. 46. It means this: The system of this whole universe, whose agents are the angels, is running on the basis of Allah’s Oneness and His servitude. The angels who are its agents are testifying every moment that their Lord is pure and exalted far above that another should be His associate in His Divinity and worship. Now, if a few foolish persons do not believe even after admonition, and turn away from the way that is being followed by the whole universe and persist in following the way of shirk only, let them remain involved in their folly. The consensus is that it is obligatory to perform sajdah (prostration) here, but the jurists differ as to which of the two preceding verses requires the performance of sajdah. Ali and Abdullah bin Masud performed the sajdah at the end of (verse 37), while Ibn Abbas, Ibn Umar, Said bin Musayyab, Masruq, Qatadah, Hasan Basri, Abu Abdur Rahman as-Sulami, Ibn Sirin, Ibrahim Nakhai and several other prominent jurists have expressed the opinion that it should be performed at the end of verse 38. The same also is the opinion of Imam Abu Hanifah, and the Shafeites also have held the same view as preferable. (41:39) And of His Signs is that you see the earth withered, then We send down water upon it, and lo! it quivers and swells. Surely He Who gives life to the dead earth will also give life to the dead.47 Surely He has power over everything. 47. For explanation, see (Surah An-Nahl, Ayat 65); (Surah Al-Hijr, Ayats 5-7); (Surah Ar-Room, Ayat 19) and (E.N. 19 of Surah Al-Fatir). (41:40) Those48 who pervert Our Signs49 are not hidden from Us.50 Is he who will be cast into the Fire better, or he who comes secure on the Day of Resurrection? Do as you wish; He sees all what you do. 48. After telling the common people in a few sentences that the doctrine of Tauhid and the Hereafter to which Muhammad (peace be upon him) is inviting them, is rational and the signs of the universe testify to its being right and true, the discourse again turns to the opponents who were determined to oppose it stubbornly. 49. The word yulhidun in the original is derived from ilhad which means to deviate, to turn away from the right to the wrong path, to adopt crookedness. Thus, ilhad in the revelations of Allah would mean that instead of understanding them in their clear and straightforward meaning one should misconstrue them and go astray and also lead others astray. One of the devices being adopted by the disbelievers of Makkah to defeat the message of the Quran was that they would hear the verses of the Quran and then would isolate one verse from its context, tamper with another, misconstrue a word or a sentence and thus raise every sort of objection and would mislead the people, saying that the Prophet (peace be upon him) had said such and such a thing that day. 50. These words imply a severe threat. The All-Powerful Ruler’s saying that the acts of such and such a person are not hidden from Him by itself contains the meaning that he cannot escape their consequences. (41:41) These are the ones who rejected the Good Counsel when it came to them, although it is certainly a Mighty Book.51 51. A mighty Book: An unchanging Book, which cannot be defeated by tricks and cunning devices, which the worshipers of falsehood are employing against it. It has the force of the truth in it, the force of true knowledge, the force of argument and reason, the force of eloquence and style, the force of divinity of God who sent it, and the force of the personality of the Messenger who presented it. No one, therefore, can defeat it by falsehood and hollow propaganda.

[@Oa5e38a1hi5]

(41:42) Falsehood may not enter it from the front or from the rear.52 It is a revelation that has been sent down from the Most Wise, the Immensely Praiseworthy. 52 “Falsehood . . . . from before it” means that none can succeed in proving anything wrong or any teaching false in the Quran by making a frontal attack on it; “nor from behind it” means that nothing can be discovered till Resurrection which may be opposed to the truths and realities presented by the Quran; no new science, if it is really a science, can be propounded, which may contradict the knowledge contained in the Quran; no new experiment or observation can be made to prove that the guidance given to man by the Quran in respect of the beliefs, morality, law, civilization or culture, and economic, social and political life is wrong. That which this Book has declared as the truth can never be proven to be falsehood and that which it has declared as falsehood can never be proven to be the truth. Furthermore, it also means that whether falsehood makes a frontal attack, or makes a surprise attack by deception, it cannot defeat the message which the Quran has brought. In spite of all sorts of open and secret machinations of the opponents the message will spread and none shall be able to defeat and frustrate it. (41:43) (O Prophet), nothing is said to you but what was already said to the Messengers before you. Surely your Lord is the Lord of forgiveness53 and the Lord of grievous chastisement. 53. That is, it is all due to His clemency and forgiveness that although His Messengers were opposed, abused and persecuted yet He went on giving respite to their opponents for years and years on end. (41:44) Had We revealed this as a non-Arabic Qur'an they would have said: “Why were its verses not clearly expounded? How strange, a non-Arabic scripture and an Arab audience!”54 Tell them: “It is a guidance and a healing to the believers. But to those who do not believe, it serves as a plug in their ears and a covering over their eyes. It is as if they are being called from a place far away.55 54. This is the kind of the stubbornness that the Prophet (peace be upon him) was confronting. The disbelievers said: Muhammad (peace be upon him) is an Arab. Arabic is his mother tongue. How can one believe that the Arabic Quran that he presents has not been forged by himself but has been revealed to him by God? The Quran could be believed to be the revelation of God if he had started speaking fluently in a foreign language unknown to him, like Persian, Latin, or Greek. This argument of theirs has been refuted by Allah, saying: Now when the Quran has been sent down in their own tongue so that they may understand it, they raise the objection: Why has it been sent down to an Arab in Arabic? But if it had been sent down in a foreign tongue, these very people would have said: How strange! An Arab Messenger has been sent to the Arabs, but the revelations being sent to him are in a tongue which is neither understood by him nor by his people. 55. When a person is summoned from afar, he hears a voice but does not understand what is being said to him. This is a wonderful simile which fully depicts the psychology of the stubborn opponents. Naturally when you talk to a person who is free from prejudice, he will listen to you, will try to understand what you say, will accept it if it is reasonable, with an open mind. On the contrary, the person who is not only prejudiced against you but is also malicious and spiteful, will not at all listen to you however hard you may try to make him understand your viewpoint. In spite of hearing you all the time he will not understand at all what you had been saying.